Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T08:15:25.025Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The China Question in Italian Foreign Policy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 December 2016

CARLA MENEGUZZI ROSTAGNI
CARLA MENEGUZZI ROSTAGNI*
Affiliation:
Department of Political Science, Law, and International Studies, University of Padova, Italy Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Relying on evidence from the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and on the private archives of both Aldo Moro and Pietro Nenni, this article shows that from the mid-1950s onwards, important politicians—Socialist Pietro Nenni, Christian Democrat Giovanni Gronchi and Liberal Gaetano Martino—worked to encourage economic exchanges between Italy and China, and were linked with the concurrent initiatives of economic actors like Dino Gentili and Enrico Mattei. It also reveals that this gradual but steady process placed the China question firmly on the agenda of Italian parliamentary debates and government programmes as early as 1964. Finally, it shows that, while American diplomacy was still dominated by the Vietnam War and opposed any initiative towards Chinese recognition, in 1969–1970 the long process of rapprochement between Rome and Beijing came to an end. Thanks to Nenni's and Moro's diplomatic action, Italy recognized the People's Republic of China (PRC) before the Americans decided to inaugurate triangular diplomacy and reach out to China.

Type
Research Article
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 51 , Special Issue 1: Circumventing the Cold War: The parallel diplomacy of economic and cultural exchanges between Western Europe and Socialist China in the 1950s and 1960s , January 2017 , pp. 107 - 132
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Samarani, G. (2009). ‘Repubblica popolare cinese e Taiwan nel secondo dopoguerra’, in Scarpari, M. and Samarani, G. (eds). La Cina Verso la modernità, Einaudi, Torino, pp. 259–275 Google Scholar; Westad, O.A. (2007). The global cold war: third world interventions and the making of our times, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Google Scholar; Jian, Chen, (2001). Mao's China and the cold war, University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill; London Google Scholar; Hershberg, J.G. (1995). ‘The cold war in Asia’, Cold War International History Project Bulletin, no. 6–7, Woodrow Wilson Centre for Scholars, Washington, DC Google Scholar; Joyaux, F. (1994). La tentation impériale Politique extérieure de la Chine depuis 1949, Imprimerie nationale, Paris, pp. 59–61 Google Scholar; Bergère, M.C. (1994). La Cina dal 1949 ai giorni nostri, Il Mulino, Bologna Google Scholar; Twitchett, D. and Fairbank, J.K. (eds) (1987). Cambridge history of China. Vol. XIV: The People's Republic 1949–1965, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Google Scholar.

2 Pini, M. F. (2011). Italia e Cina 60 anni tra passato e futuro, L’ asino d'oro edizioni, Roma, pp. 63–67 Google Scholar.

3 Samarani, G. and De Giorgi, L. (2011). Lontane, vicine. Le relazioni fra Cina e Italia nel Novecento, Carocci, Roma, pp. 107–108 Google Scholar.

4 Nenni, P. (1981). Tempo di guerra fredda Diari 1943–1956, Sugarco, Milano, p. 538 Google Scholar.

5 Capisani, L.M. (2013). ‘Dino Gentili, la Comet e il dialogo commerciale fra Italia e Cina (1952–1958)’, Studi storici, no. 2 (April–June), pp. 419–447 Google Scholar; Luti, G. (1994). Tra politica e impresa: vita di Dino Gentili, Passigli, Firenze Google Scholar; Varsori, A. (1982). Gli alleati e l'emigrazione democratica antifascista 1940–1943, Sansoni, Firenze, pp. 211–239 Google Scholar.

6 Petrini, F. (2005). Il liberismo a una dimensione La Confindustria e l'integrazione europea 1947–1957, Franco Angeli, Milano, pp. 46–48 Google Scholar.

7 Gentili said in an interview of 1978: ‘The PCI at the beginning of this development of the work helped me by suggesting Spartaco Muratori as my delegate in Beijing’; see Luti, Tra politica e impresa, p. 282. See also Pini, Italia e Cina 60 anni tra passato e futuro, p. 86.

8 This is the name of the lower branch of the Italian parliament, the other being the Senate.

9 Nenni, Tempo di guerra fredda, p. 622; Luti, Tra politica e impresa, p. 281.

10 ‘Record of conversation between Comrade J.V. Stalin and chairman of the central people's government of the People's Republic of China Mao Zedong on 16 December 1949’, ‘Sino-Soviet Relations’ collection, in digitalarchive.wilsoncenter.org/document/111240, [accessed 29 May 2016]. Luthi, M. (2010). The Sino-Soviet split: cold war in the communist world, Princeton University Press, Princeton and Oxford, pp. 31–41 Google Scholar; Chen Jian, Mao's China and the cold war, pp. 50–53; Westad, O.A. (ed.) (1998). Brother in arms: the rise and fall of the Sino-Soviet alliance, 1945–1963, Stanford University Press, Stanford, pp. 52–74 and 314–329 Google Scholar.

11 Luti, Tra politica e impresa, p. 200.

12 ‘Comet . . . bought fertilizer from the Italian company Marine Trading (its subsidiary in London) resold the cargo from Italy to its Hong Kong subsidiary . . . this cargo, once in Hong Kong, was sent on to Canton. The fertilizer was for agriculture and as such was never stopped by the Italian or by the American government.’ From an interview with Virgilio Dagnino, who collaborated with Dino Gentili in the creation of Comet, quoted in Luti, Tra politica e impresa, p. 101.

13 Gentili to Nenni, 8 September 1953, Archivio Centrale dello Stato (ACS)—Fondazione Nenni, paper series 1944/1979, envelope 26, bundle 1395. As member of NATO, Italy was involved in the trade embargo on China. See Cain, J.F. (1995). ‘The US-led trade embargo on China: the origins of Chincom, 1947–52’, Journal of Strategic Studies, vol. 18, no. 4, pp. 33–38 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Nenni, Tempo di guerra fredda, pp. 43–56.

15 He continued: ‘In the last four-year period 1950–1953 the volume on Italian exports to China increased from 844 million to about 3,000 million lira, surpassing the prewar level’; see Gaetano Martino to the Chamber of Deputies, 19 October 1954, in Discorsi parlamentari di Gaetano Martino pubblicati per deliberazione della Camera dei deputati (2 vols) (1977), Grafica editrice romana, Rome, vol. I, p. 445. About Gaetano Martino, see Saija, M. and Villani, A. (2011). Gaetano Martino, 1900–1967, Rubbettino, Soveria Mannelli, pp. 221–283 Google Scholar; Villani, A. (2008). Un liberale sulla scena internazionale. Gaetano Martino e la politica estera italiana 1954–1967, Trisform, Messina, pp. 75–77 Google Scholar.

16 Capisani, ‘Dino Gentili, la Comet’, pp. 427–428.

17 Ortona, E. (1986). Anni d'America: la diplomazia 1953–1961, Il Mulino, Bologna, p.64 Google Scholar.

18 Ibid., pp. 23–24.

19 Ibid., p. 56.

20 Ibid., p. 58; specifically for Clare Boothe Luce, see pp. 16–19 and 55–67.

21 Nenni to G. Martino, 5 September 1955, ACS—Fondazione Nenni, paper series 1944/1979, envelope 32, bundle 1580.

22 Nenni, Tempo di guerra fredda, pp. 682 and 684.

23 Nenni sent Martino two letters on 14 and 15 September 1955, ACS—Fondazione Nenni, paper series 1944/1979, envelope 32, bundle 1580.

24 Martino replied on 15 September, ibid.

25 Martino to the Chamber of Deputies, 27 September 1955, in Discorsi parlamentari, vol. II, pp. 574–575; Martino to the Senate, 11 October 1955, ibid., pp. 601–602.

26 Martino to the Chamber, 27 September 1955, ibid., pp. 574–575.

27 Brosio, M. (2008). Diari di Washington, 1955–1961, Il Mulino, Bologna, p. 111 Google Scholar.

28 Nenni, Tempo di guerra fredda, p. 694.

29 Ibid., p. 703.

30 Ibid., p. 711.

31 Di Nolfo, E. (1999). ‘La mancata ammissione dell’ Italia all’ ONU nel 1945–47’, in Tosi, L. (ed.). L’ Italia e le organizzazioni internazionali, Diplomazia multilaterale nel Novecento, Cedam, Padova, pp. 181–188 Google Scholar; and Pastorelli, P. (1999). ‘L’ ammissione dell’ Italia all’ ONU’, ibid., pp. 189–200. See also Ortona, Anni d'America: la diplomazia, pp. 142–144.

32 Dino Gentili in an interview in Il Mondo in 1978, in Luti, Tra politica e impresa, p. 263. Vittorio Valletta, chief executive officer of Fiat, had negotiated and continued to negotiate with the Americans on contracts between Fiat and North American Aviation. See Ortona, Anni d'America: la diplomazia, p. 76.

33 Imperato, F. (2011). Aldo Moro e la pace nella sicurezza, la politica estera del centro-sinistra. 1963–68, Progedit, Bari, p. 121 Google Scholar.

34 Archivio storico del ministero degli Affari esteri (ASMAE), Affari politici (1950–1957), b. 33, Washington Embassy, telegrammi Martino to Roma, 5 and 6 April 1956, Cattani from Rome, 17 March, 16 April, Brosio from Washington, 17, 18 March and 8, 12, 15, 17 April 1956.

35 ASMAE, Affari politici (1950–1957), b. 1544, Cina-Francia, cables from Paris, 15, 24 March 1956 and from Hong Kong, 24 January and 1, 20 March 1956.

36 Bernkopf Tucker, N. (ed.) (2001). China confidential: American diplomats and Sino-American relations 1945–1996, Columbia University Press, New York, pp. 147–151 Google Scholar.

37 ASMAE, Affari politici (1950–1957), Italia-Cina, telegramma segreto by Brosio from Washington, 15 July 1957; Telegrammi segreti 1958; Washington Embassy, telegrammi Ortona, 1, 2, 4, 6, 10 September 1958. See also Kissinger, H. A. (2011). Cina, Mondadori, Milano, pp. 160–163 Google Scholar.

38 Samarani, G. (2007). ‘Enrico Mattei e la Cina’, in Guarneri, D. (ed.). Enrico Mattei. Il comandante partigiano, l'uomo politico, il manager di stato, BFS, Pisa, pp. 92–96 Google Scholar; Bagnato, B. (2004). Petrolio e politica. Mattei in Marocco, Polistampa, Firenze, pp. 201–202 Google Scholar; Perrone, N. (2001). Enrico Mattei, Il Mulino, Bologna, 2001 Google Scholar; Pietra, I. (1987). Mattei, la pecora nera, Sugarco, Milano Google Scholar.

39 Samarani, ‘Enrico Mattei e la Cina’, p. 94.

40 Capisani, ‘Dino Gentili, la Comet’, pp. 444–445.

41 ASMAE, Telegrammi ordinari Gran Bretagna e colonie arrivi e partenze, 1962, from Hong Kong to Rome, 12 July 1962.

42 ASMAE, Gran Bretagna consolati, telegrammi ordinari, 1963, Cattani from Rome, 7 May 1963.

43 Telegramma Saverio Santaniello, Hong Kong, 18 June 1963, ACS, Carte Moro (CM), series 3, bundle 59.

44 Brosio, M. (2009). Diari di Parigi, 1961–1964, Il Mulino, Bologna, pp. 432–435 Google Scholar, 437.

45 Nenni, P. (1982). Gli anni del Centro Sinistra, Diari 1957–1966, Sugarco, Milano, pp. 329–330 Google Scholar.

46 Saragat, 10 December 1964 in 3a Commissione Affari esteri, IV Legislatura—902-A—Res. V

47 Telegramma segretissimo by Saverio Santaniello, Hong Kong, 23 June 1964, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61, f. 117; news on meeting of Vittorelli, Santaniello with Mao Zedong, also in ASMAE, 1964, telegrammi ordinari Gran Bretagna e consolati.

48 Reply of Foreign Minister Giuseppe Saragat, Senato della Repubblica, Atti parlamentari, IV Legislatura, 14 February 1964, p. 217.

49 Telegramma segretissimo Saverio Santaniello, 23 June 1964.

50 Discussion between Ambassador Cattani and the Assistant Secretary of State, William Tyler, 30 June 1964, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61.

51 Telegramma segretissimo by Saragat from Ottawa, 9 November 1964, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61.

52 Reply of the President of the Council Aldo Moro, Camera dei Deputati, Atti parlamentari, IV legislatura, 6 August 1964, p. 957.

53 Intervention of the foreign minister in the discussion of the budget of the Foreign Ministry, to the Chamber of Deputies to the Commission of 75, 3 December 1964, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61; on the Chinese nuclear explosion, see ASMAE, Gran Bretagna e colonie, telegrammi ordinari, 1964, telegrammi by Bolla from Hong Kong, 17, 21, 22, 23 October 1964; Jing Zhang (2009). ‘In quest of mushroom clouds: perspectives from the Chinese side’, CSSEO Working Paper, no. 148.

54 Memorandum and news of agencies, 3 December 1964, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61.

55 ASMAE,1961, telegrammi segreti, ambasciata Washington, telegrammi by Brosio, 9 January, 8 April 1961; Yafeng Xia (2006). Negotiating with the enemy: US-China talks during the cold war, 1949–1972, Indiana University Press, Bloomington; Kissinger, Cina, p. 188.

56 Memorandum Cottafavi, 21 November 1964, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61. In 1961, in the attempt to render useless the annual demands from the Asian states on the admission of China, the United States, together with Australia, Colombia, Japan, and Italy, had proposed a procedural motion that declared a decision on making the Chinese seat an ‘important question’ and so to be dealt with by a qualified majority of two-thirds of members present and voting. Vinci to Moro on the Chinese ‘seat’, 2 November 1965, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61.

57 Information sent by Moro to Fanfani, telegramma, 26 September 1965, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61.

58 The President of the Council, Senato della Repubblica, Atti parlamentari, IV legislatura, 18 February 1965.

59 Sica, M. (2011). ‘La Pira e la pace nel Vietnam’, Nuova Antologia, pp. 136–162 Google Scholar; Sica, M. (1991). Marigold non fiorì. Il contributo italiano alla pace in Vietnam, Ponte alle Grazie, Firenze, pp. 34–42 Google Scholar.

60 Fenoaltea to Fanfani, 12 April 1965; Fanfani to Moro, 25 September 1965; Moro to Fanfani, 26 September 1965; Fanfani-Rusk discussion, 26 September 1965; from Washington to Fenoaltea, 10 October 1965 and 15 October 1965, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61; intervention of Moro in Senato della Repubblica, Atti parlamentari, IV legislatura, seduta del 19 novembre 1965, pp. 1078–1080.

61 Moro to Fanfani, 7 November 1965, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61.

62 Navi cinesi, 24 August 1967, ACS, CM, series 3, bundle 61, f. 3; Samarani and De Giorgi, Lontane, vicine, pp. 128–129.

63 Nenni, P. (1983). I conti con la storia. Diari 1967–1971, Sugarco, Milano, pp. 251–254 Google Scholar; Di Nolfo, E. (2010). ‘La normalizzazione delle relazioni diplomatiche tra la Repubblica Italiana e la Repubblica Popolare cinese’, in Di Nolfo, E. (ed.). La normalizzazione delle relazioni diplomatiche tra la Repubblica italiana e la Repubblica Popolare cinese, Atti e documenti, Rubbettino, Soveria Mannelli, pp. 14–21 Google Scholar and 25–47; Olla Brundu, P. (2004). ‘Pietro Nenni, Aldo Moro e il riconoscimento della Cina comunista’, Le carte e la storia, vol. X, no. 2, p. 32 Google Scholar.

64 Ortona, E. (1989). Anni d'America: la cooperazione 1967–1975, Il Mulino, Bologna, pp. 299–300 Google Scholar and 326–327.

65 Nenni, I conti con la storia, pp. 291 and 309.

66 Moro, A. ‘Programma per una “pace integrale”’, Il Popolo, 9 ottobre 1969.

67 Telegrammi Meeting of the Minister with President Nixon, 9 October 1969, ACS, CM, series 5, bundle 138; conversation of the Minister with the US Secretary of State, 10 October 1969, ibid.; in the same sense, see also the telegram Moro, Meeting Nixon, 30 September 1970, ibid. See also Ortona, Anni d'America: la cooperazione, pp. 198–201.

68 Di Nolfo, E. (2012). ‘Le reazioni americane al riconoscimento italiano della Cina’, Eunomia, no. 1, pp. 9–32 Google Scholar.