Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T21:16:29.066Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Body–Mind Challenge: Theology and phenomenology in Bengal-Vaishnavisms

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 July 2018

SUKANYA SARBADHIKARY
SUKANYA SARBADHIKARY*
Affiliation:
Presidency University Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Recent studies of Asian religious traditions have critiqued Western philosophical understandings of mind–body dualism and furthered the productive notion of mind–body continuum. Based on intensive fieldwork among two kinds of devotional groups of Bengal—claimants to an orthodox Vaishnavism, who focus on participating in the erotic sports of the Hindu deity-consort Radha-Krishna in imagination and a quasi-tantric group, which claims to physically apprehend Radha-Krishna's erotic pleasures through direct sexual experience—I demonstrate that, although these devotional groups stress on combating theologies, with emphases respectively on the ‘mind’ and the ‘body’, in their narrations of religious experiences, however, both groups allude to rarefied phenomenological states of cognition and embodiment. So, while influenced by ideas of (mental) ‘purity’ and (bodily) ‘actuality’, respectively, practices of both groups rely on similar states of mind–body continuum. So I argue that the mind–body complex has intensely nuanced articulations in the discursive and experiential domains of these non-Western religious contexts. Through my analyses of the texts and embodiments of these opposed devotional groups, I show that theology gets both organically entangled with as well as challenged by phenomenological experiences. I further argue that explorations in the tenor of religious studies sharply enrich the anthropology of religiosities. Also, such engagements between theology and anthropology have been relatively lacking and need more emphasis in studies of contemporary South Asian religions.

Type
Research Article
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 52 , Issue 6 , November 2018 , pp. 2080 - 2108
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*I thank Nirmalya Guha for teaching me some ways of understanding Indian philosophical thought; my students, for their discussions in the course on ‘Sociology of the Body’, which I teach at Presidency University; and faculty and students of CSSS, JNU, especially Harish Naraindas and V. Sujatha, for their comments during a presentation of an earlier draft of the article. I thank the three reviewers and editorial team of Modern Asian Studies for their most sincere comments and criticisms. Upal Chakrabarti has provided valuable insight about the organization of the arguments. Sandipan Mitra has helped in the final stages of editorial work. This article is an attempt at ‘thinking across traditions’, and I am grateful to Prathama Banerjee and Sudipta Kaviraj for their deliberations, and our engaging discussions about such prospects and philosophies.

References

Basu, M. M. 1932. Sahajiya Sahitya (The Literature of the Sahajiyas). Calcutta: Calcutta University Press.Google Scholar
Beckerlegge, G. 2006. Swami Vivekananda's Legacy of Service: A Study of the Ramakrishna Math and Mission. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Beuke, C. J., Garry, M., Sharman, S. J.. 2004. ‘Imagination or Exposure Causes Imagination’ The American Journal of Psychology, vol. 117, pp. 157–168.Google Scholar
Bhatta, G. 1911. Haribhakti Vilasa. Calcutta: Kolikata Rajdhanyam.Google Scholar
Bose, M. M. 1986. The Post-Chaitanya Sahajiya Cult of Bengal. Delhi: Gian.Google Scholar
Bottero, A. 1991. ‘Consumption by Semen Loss in India and Elsewhere’ Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry, vol. 15, pp. 303–320.Google Scholar
Brahmachari, M. 1994. Vaisnava Vedanta. Calcutta: Sri Mahanambrata Cultural and Welfare Trust.Google Scholar
Caro, R. V. 1995. ‘An Ignatian Meditation: “Carrion Comfort”’ Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review, vol. 84, pp. 152–159.Google Scholar
Casey, E. S. 2000. Imagining: A Phenomenological Study. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Chakrabarti, R. 1996. Bonge Vaishnava Dharma: Ekti Aitihashik ebong Samajtattvik Adhyayan (Vaishnavism in Bengal: A Historical and Sociological Exercise). Kolkata: Ananda.Google Scholar
Chakrabarty, A. 2009. ‘Is This a Dream? Analytical Reflections on Objecthood and Externality’ Journal of Indian Council of Philosophical Research, vol. 26, pp. 29–44.Google Scholar
Collins, S. 1997. ‘The Body in Theravada Buddhist Monasticism’. In Coakley, S. (ed.) Religion and the Body. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 185–204.Google Scholar
Cook, J. C. 2010. Meditation in Modern Buddhism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Csordas, T. J. 1993. ‘Somatic Modes of Attention’ Cultural Anthropology, vol. 8, pp. 135–156.Google Scholar
Csordas, T. J. 1994. The Sacred Self: A Cultural Phenomenology of Charismatic Healing. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Csordas, T. J. 2002. Body/Meaning/Healing. Hampshire, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Das, P. 1988. Sahajiya Cult of Bengal and Pancha Sakha Cult of Orissa. Calcutta: Firma KLM.Google Scholar
Dasgupta, S. 1976. Obscure Religious Cults as Background of Bengali Literature. Calcutta: Calcutta University Press.Google Scholar
De, S. K. 1986 (1961). Early History of the Vaisnava Faith and Movement in Bengal. Calcutta: Firma KLM.Google Scholar
Dimock, E. C. Jr. 1963. ‘Doctrine and Practice among the Vaisnavas of Bengal’ History of Religions, vol. 3, pp. 106–127.Google Scholar
Dimock, E. C. Jr. 1966. The Place of the Hidden Moon: Erotic Mysticism in the Vaisnava-Sahajiya Cult of Bengal. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.Google Scholar
Flood, G. 2006. The Tantric Body: The Secret Tradition of Hindu Religion. London, New York: I. B. Tauris.Google Scholar
Gell, A. 1995. ‘The Language of the Forest: Landscape and Phenomenological Iconism in Umeda’. In Hirsch, E. and O'Hanlon, Michael (eds) The Anthropology of Landscape: Perspectives on Place and Space. Oxford: Clarendon Press, pp. 232–254.Google Scholar
Goswami, N. 2008. Manober Muldhon (Man's Essence). Navadvip: Sri Nitai Gour Seva Ashram.Google Scholar
Gupta, R. 2007. The Caitanya Vaisnava Vedanta of Jiva Goswami: When Knowledge Meets Devotion. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Haberman, D. L. 1988. Acting as a Way of Salvation: A Study of Raganuga Bhakti Sadhana. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Haberman, D. L. 1992. ‘Krsna-lila as Perceived in Meditation and Pilgrimage’. In Rosen, S. J. (ed) Vaisnavism: Contemporary Scholars Discuss the Gaudiya Tradition. New York: Folk Books, pp. 305–326.Google Scholar
Haberman, D. L. 2003. The Bhaktirasāmrtasindhu of Rūpa Gosvāmin. Delhi: Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts and Motilal Banarsidass.Google Scholar
Halliburton, M. 2002. ‘Rethinking Anthropological Studies of the Body: Manas and Bodham in Kerala’ American Anthropologist (N. S.), vol. 104, pp. 1123–1134.Google Scholar
Hardy, F. E. 1983. Viraha-Bhakti: The Early History of Krsna Devotion in South India. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Hayes, G. 1995. ‘The Vaishnava Sahajiya Traditions of Medieval Bengal’. In Lopez, D. S. Jr (ed) Religions of India in Practice. Princeton: University Press, pp. 333–351.Google Scholar
Hayes, G. 1999. ‘The Churning of Controversy: Vaisnava-Sahajiya Appropriations of Gaudiya Vaisnavism’ Journal of Vaisnava Studies, vol. 8, pp. 77–90.Google Scholar
Hayes, G. 2000. ‘The Necklace of Immortality: A Seventeeth-Century Vaisnava Sahajiya Text’. In White, D. G. (ed.) Tantra in Practice. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press, pp. 308–325.Google Scholar
Hayes, G. 2005. ‘Contemporary Metaphor Theory and Alternative Views of Krishna and Radha in Vaishnava Sahajiya Tantric Traditions’. In Beck, G. L. (ed.) Alternative Krishnas: Regional and Vernacular Variations on a Hindu Deity. Albany: State University of New York Press, pp. 19–32.Google Scholar
Hayes, G. 2012. ‘Conceptual Blending Theory, ‘Reverse Amnesia’, and the Study of Tantra’ The Journal of Hindu Studies, vol. 5, pp. 1–17.Google Scholar
Hayes, G. 2014. ‘Possible Selves, Body Schemas, and Sādhana: Using Cognitive Science and Neuroscience in the Study of Medieval Vaisnava Sahajiyā Hindu Tantric Texts’ Religions, vol. 5, pp. 684–699.Google Scholar
Holdrege, B. A. 2015. Bhakti and Embodiment: Fashioning Divine Bodies and Devotional Bodies in Krsna Bhakti. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Ingold, T. 2000. The Perception of the Environment: Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Jordt, I. 2006. ‘Defining a True Buddhist: Meditation and Knowledge Formation in Burma’ Ethnology, vol. 45, pp. 193–207.Google Scholar
Kearns, C. M. 2005. ‘Irigaray's Between East and West: Breath, Pranayama, and the Phenomenology of Prayer’. In Benson, B. E. and Wirzba, N. (eds) The Phenomenology of Prayer. New York: Fordham University Press, pp. 103–118.Google Scholar
Khandelwal, M. 2001. ‘Sexual Fluids, Emotions, Morality: Notes on the Gendering of Brahmacharya’. In Sobo, E. J. and Bell, S. (eds) Celibacy, Culture, and Society: The Anthropology of Sexual Abstinence. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, pp. 157–179.Google Scholar
Lakoff, G. and Johnson, M.. 1999. Philosophy in the Flesh: The Embodied Mind and its Challenge to Western Thought. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Leavitt, J. 1996. ‘Meaning and Feeling in the Anthropology of Emotions’ American Ethnologist, vol. 23, pp. 514–539.Google Scholar
Levy, R. I. 1984. ‘Emotion, Knowing, and Culture’. In Shweder, R. A. and LeVine, R. A. (eds) Culture Theory: Essays on Mind, Self and Emotion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 214–237.Google Scholar
Lewis, T. T. 1995. ‘The Power of a Mantra: A Story of Five Protectors’. In Lopez, D. S. Jr (ed) Religions of India in Practice. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 227–243.Google Scholar
Low, S. M. 1994. ‘Embodied Metaphors: Nerves as Lived Experience’. In Csordas, T. J (ed.) Embodiment and Experience: The Existential Ground of Culture and Self. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 139–162.Google Scholar
Lutz, C. and White, Geoffrey M.. 1986. ‘The Anthropology of Emotions’ Annual Review of Anthropology, vol. 15, pp. 405–436.Google Scholar
Lyons, J. D. 2006. ‘Meditation and the Inner Voice’ New Literary History, vol. 37, pp. 525–540.Google Scholar
McDaniel, J. 1995. ‘Emotion in Bengali Religious Thought: Substance and Metaphor’. In Marks, J. and Ames, R. (eds) Emotions in Asian Thought: A Dialogue in Comparative Philosophy. New York: State University of New York Press, pp. 39–63.Google Scholar
Mitchell, J. P. 1997. ‘A Moment with Christ: The Importance of Feelings in the Analysis of Belief’ Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, vol. 3, pp. 79–94.Google Scholar
Morley, J. 2001. ‘Inspiration and Expiration: Yoga Practice through Merleau-Ponty's Phenomenology of the Body’ Philosophy East and West, vol. 51, pp. 73–82.Google Scholar
O'Connell, J. T. 1989. ‘Were Chaitanya's Vaisnavas Really Sahajiyas? The Case of Ramananda Raya’. In Stewart, T. K. (ed.) Shaping Bengali Worlds, Public and Private. East Lansing: Asian Studies Center, Michigan State University, pp. 11–22.Google Scholar
Ondracka, L. 2015. ‘Divine Body and Other Bodies in the Natha-Siddha Sanskrit Texts’ The Journal of Hindu Studies, vol. 8, pp. 210–232.Google Scholar
Openshaw, J. 2002. Seeking Bāuls of Bengal. Cambridge: University Press.Google Scholar
Openshaw, J. 2010. Writing the Self: The life and philosophy of a dissenting Baul Guru. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Persson, A. 2007. ‘Intimate Immensity: Phenomenology of Place and Space in an Australian Yoga Community’ American Ethnologist, vol. 34, pp. 44–56.Google Scholar
Salomon, C. 1994. ‘The Cosmogonic Riddles of Lalan Fakir’. In Appadurai, A., Korom, F. J. and Willis, M. A. (eds) Gender, Genre and Power in South Asian Expressive Traditions. New Delhi: Motilal Banarssidas Publishers Pvt. Ltd, pp. 267–304.Google Scholar
Salomon, C. 1995. ‘Baul Songs’. In Lopez, D. S. Jr (ed.) Religions of India in Practice. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 187–208.Google Scholar
Sarbadhikary, S. 2015. The Place of Devotion: Siting and Experiencing Divinity in Bengal-Vaishnavism. California: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Sarukkai, S. 2001. ‘Translation and Science’ Meta, vol. XLVI, pp. 646–663.Google Scholar
Slingerland, E. 2008. What Science Offers the Humanities: Integrating Body and Culture. Cambridge: University Press.Google Scholar
Stewart, T. K. (ed.). 1999. Caitanya Caritamrta of Krsnadasa Kaviraja: A Translation and Commentary. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Stewart, T. K. (ed.). 2010. The Final Word: The Caitanya Caritamrta and the Grammar of Religious Tradition. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Tilley, C. 2008. Body and Image: Explorations in Landscape Phenomenology 2. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.Google Scholar
Urban, H. B. 2003. ‘The Power of Impure: Transgression, Violence and Secrecy in Bengal Sakta Tantra and Modern Western Magic’ Numen, vol. 50, pp. 269–308.Google Scholar
Urban, H. B. 2010. The Power of Tantra: Religion, Sexuality and Politics of South Asian Studies. London and New York: I. B. Tauris.Google Scholar
White, D. G. 2009. Sinister Yogis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Williams, P. 1997. ‘Some Mahayana Buddhist Perspectives on the Body’. In Coakley, S. (ed.) Religion and the Body. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 205–230.Google Scholar
Willis, R. J. 1979. ‘Meditation to Fit the Person: Psychology and the Meditative Way’ Journal of Religion and Health, vol. 18, pp. 93–119.Google Scholar
Wulff, D. M. 1984. Drama as a Mode of Religious Realization: The Vidagdhamadhava of Rupa Gosvami. Chicago: Scholars Press.Google Scholar