Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T10:08:08.299Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Recruiting Agents in Industry and Trade—Lifting the Veil on Early People's Republic of China Operational Work*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 November 2011

MICHAEL SCHOENHALS
MICHAEL SCHOENHALS*
Affiliation:
Centre for Languages and Literature, Lund University, Box 201, SE-221 00 Lund, Sweden Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper is concerned with the operational activities of the public security organs of the People's Republic of China during the immediate post-1949 period of regime consolidation. The main part of the paper is a case-study of a 1950 pilot scheme to recruit agents in critical sectors of industry and trade in the city of Yingkou in Northeast China, a scheme in due course subsumed under a nationwide programme with a similar focus. In the years to follow, the operational recruitment of agents would become one of China's arguably most important operational responses to the twin Cold War threats of economic espionage and—above all—sabotage. This paper's findings suggest, with respect to operational activities, that in order to represent and explain more fully, in Leopold von Ranke's words, ‘how things really were’, social and political historians may well want to shift their focus away from successive highly public Maoist ‘mass movements’ and look instead to what transpired out of the public eye in the interregnum of ordinary times that such movements punctuated. If and when they do, they will discover significant yet hitherto largely unexplored similarities between the work of the early People's Republic of China public security organs and their counterparts in the Soviet Union and other (former) socialist states.

Type
Research Article
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 46 , Issue 5 , September 2012 , pp. 1345 - 1369
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Jianguang, Lü, ‘“Fengqiao jingyan” de chansheng guocheng (How the “Fengqiao Experience” Came About)’, in Chunlin, Zhu (ed.), Lishi shunjian I (Moments in History I) (Beijing: Qunzhong chubanshe, 1999) p. 61Google Scholar.

2 Barnett, A. Doak, ‘Social Controls in Communist China’, Far Eastern Survey, 22 (5) (22 April 1953) p. 48CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Domes, Jürgen, Die Ära Mao Tse-tung: Innenpolitik in der Volksrepublik China (Stuttgart: Verlag W. Kohlhammer, 1971) p. 55Google Scholar.

4 KGB Lexicon: The Soviet Intelligence Officer's Handbook, edited and introduced by Vasiliy Mitrokhin with a foreword by Peter Hennessy (London: Frank Cass, 2002) pp. 178–79, 358–59.

5 Aldrich, Richard J., The Hidden Hand: Britain, America and Cold War Secret Intelligence (London: John Murray, 2001) p. 5Google Scholar.

6 Zhongguo renmin gongan shigao (Draft History of the Chinese People's Public Security) (Beijing: Jingguan jiaoyu chubanshe, 1997).

7 Jobs, Sebastian and Lüdtke, Alf (eds), Unsettling History: Archiving and Narrating in Historiography (Frankfurt: Campus Verlag, 2010) p. 16Google Scholar.

8 On the challenges confronting historians working from official and other sources on subjects that, like operational work, are shrouded in extraordinary secrecy, see Hughes, R. Gerald, Jackson, Peter, and Scott, Len (eds), Exploring Intelligence Archives: Enquiries into the Secret State (London: Routledge, 2008)Google Scholar.

9 ‘Cable, Mao Zedong to Stalin, 30 December 1948’, Cold War International History Project Bulletin, 16 (Fall 2007/Winter 2008) p. 123.

10 Renmin ribao (People's Daily), 2 October 1949.

11 Brown, Jeremy, ‘From Resisting Communists to Resisting America: Civil War and Korean War in Southwest China, 1950–1951’, in Brown, Jeremy and Pickowicz, Paul G. (eds), Dilemmas of Victory: The Early Years of the People's Republic of China (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2007) p. 114CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Renmin ribao, 9 July 1950.

13 Tiedaobu, ‘Guanyu zhixing Zhengwuyuan guanyu zai guojia caizheng jingji bumen zhong jianli baowei gongzuo de jueding de zhishi (Instruction Implementing the Government Administration Council's Decision to Launch Protection Work in State Financial and Economic Departments)’, Tielu gongan tongxun (Railway Public Security Bulletin), No. 3 (15 December 1950) p. 3.

14 weiyuanhui, Zhongguo renmin jiefangjun lishi ziliao congshu bianshen (ed.), Gongan budui: zongshu dashiji biaoce (Public Security Forces: General Account, Chronology and Tables) (Beijing: Jiefangjun chubanshe, 1997) p. 57Google Scholar.

15 Elizabeth J. Perry, ‘Masters of the Country? Shanghai Workers in the Early People's Republic’, in Brown and Pickowicz, Dilemas of Victory, pp. 70–72.

16 Jianguo yilai gongan gongzuo dashi yaolan (Vital Survey of Major Events in Public Security Work Since the Founding of the Nation) (Beijing: Qunzhong chubanshe, 2003) p. 33.

17 ‘Cong dite qingbao moulüe gongzuo kan qi yinmou dongtai (Schemes and Activities of Adversary Operatives as Revealed by Adversary Intelligence Strategies)’, Baowei gongzuo jianshe (Protection Work Construction), No. 7 (15 January 1951) pp. 28–31.

18 See Dongbei renmin zhengfu gonganbu, ‘Guanyu gongan jiguan de lingdao zuofeng wenti (On the Leadership Work-Style of Public Security Organs)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo (Public Security and Protection Work), Vol. 20 (25 November 1950) p. 55.

19 Feng Jiping, ‘Zai Beijing shi di yi jie jingji baowei huiyi shang zhi kaimuci (Opening Words at the 1st Beijing Municipal Economic Protection Conference)’, Renmin gongan zengkan (People's Public Security Extra Issues), No. 20 (25 December 1950) p. 10.

20 Zhengwuyuan, ‘Guanyu zai guojia caizheng jingji bumen zhong jianli baowei gongzuo de jueding (Decision to Launch Protection Work in State Financial and Economic Departments)’, Tielu gongan tongxun, No. 3: 1.

21 yanjiushi, Zhonggong zhongyang wenxian (ed), Chen Yun nianpu 1905–1995 (Chronology of the Life of Chen Yun 1905–1995), 3 vols. (Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, 2000): Vol. 1, 117Google Scholar.

22 Zhongcaiwei and Zhongyang renmin zhengfu gonganbu, ‘Guanyu guojia caizheng jingji bumen zhong baowei jiguan zuzhi yu gongzuo de guiding (caoan) (Draft Regulations Governing the Organization and Work of Protection Organs in State Financial and Economic Sectors)’, Renmin gongan zengkan, No. 20: 3–6.

23 Zhongcaiwei and Zhongyang renmin zhengfu gonganbu, ‘Guanyu guojia caizheng jingji bumen zhong baowei jiguan zuzhi yu gongzuo de guiding (Regulations Governing the Organization and Work of Protection Organs in the State Financial and Economic Sector)’, Tielu gongan tongxun, No. 3: 2.

24 Ibid.

25 Luo Ruiqing, ‘Zai quanguo jingji baowei gongzuo huiyi shang de zongjie baogao (Summing-Up Report at the National Economic Protection Work Conference)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo, Vol. 18 (1 June 1950) pp. 13–14.

26 yanjiushi, Zhonggong zhongyang wenxian (ed.), Jianguo yilai Mao Zedong wengao (Mao Zedong's Manuscripts Since the Founding of the Nation), 13 vols. (Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, 1987–1998): Vol. 1: 535 (original emphasis)Google Scholar.

27 Wang Lin, ‘Zai huiyi shang de zongjie baogao’ (Summing-Up Report at the Conference), Renmin gongan zengkan, No. 20: 30 (my emphasis).

28 Luo, ‘Zai quanguo jingji baowei gongzuo huiyi shang de zongjie baogao’, p. 22.

29 I am grateful to Dr Daniel Leese at the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität Munich for providing me with this estimate, based on data from an official Yingkou municipal government source.

30 Wang Jinxiang, ‘Zai dongbei zhengzhi jingji baowei chuzhang yewu gongzuo huiyi shang de baogao (Report at a Vocational Work Meeting of Political and Economic Protection Section Chiefs from the Northeast)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo, Vol. 19 (15 September 1950) p. 24 (my emphasis).

31 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie (Summary of Work at Developing Agents in Factories and Enterprises in Yingkou Municipality during July and August)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo, Vol. 20: 41.

32 Ibid., p. 42.

33 ‘Zhongyang gonganbu pishi (Central Ministry of Public Security Comment and Instruction)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo, Vol. 19: 18.

34 Eddy, U, Disorganizing China: Counter-Bureaucracy and the Decline of Socialism (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2007) p. 107Google Scholar.

35 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, p. 42.

36 Ibid., p. 43.

37 Dongbei renmin zhengfu gonganbu zhengzhi baoweichu, ‘Dui qingli he guanjiao liuyong zhi fandong dangtuan renyuan de jidian yijian (Some Opinions Concerning the Disposal, Management and Education of Retained Members of Reactionary Parties and Organizations),’ Renmin gongan zengkan, No. 20: 45.

38 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, p. 45.

39 Shenyang shi gonganju, ‘Guanyu jianli teqing gongzuo de fangfa (Methods for Developing Agents)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo, Vol. 20: 32.

40 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, p. 43.

41 Dongbei renmin zhengfu gonganbu, ‘Gei Liaodong shengting de xin (Letter to the Liaodong Provincial Bureau)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo, Vol. 19: 55–56.

42 On the recruitment and utilization of ‘common informants’, see ‘Social Intelligence Work in 1951: A Report from the Public Security Office of the Tianjin Railway Management Bureau’, translated in Contemporary Chinese Thought, 38(3) (Spring 2007): 38–53.

43 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, p. 43.

44 Ibid., pp. 43, 47.

45 On Lüda in and around 1950, see Christian A. Hess, ‘Big Brother is Watching: Local Sino-Soviet Relations and the Building of New Dalian, 1945–1955’, in Brown & Pickowicz, Dilemmas of Victory, pp. 160–183.

46 Zhao Qing, ‘Cong zhengzhishang peiyang gongzuo guanxi (Foster Work Connections Politically)’, Renmin gongan zengkan, No. 9 (25 June 1950) p. 87.

47 Shenyang shi gonganju, ‘Guanyu jianli teqing gongzuo de fangfa’, p. 38.

48 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, p. 44.

49 Shenyang shi gonganju, ‘Guanyu jianli teqing gongzuo de fangfa’, p. 38.

50 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, p. 44.

51 Ibid.

52 Dongbei renmin zhengfu gonganbu zhengzhi baoweichu, ‘Guanyu muqian teqing renyuan de dongtai yu women shiyong duice (On Current Trends among Agents and Our Utilization Counter-Measures)’, Gongan baowei gongzuo, Vol. 20: 25–29.

53 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, pp. 44–45.

54 Ibid., p. 47.

55 Ibid., pp. 46–47.

56 Ibid., p. 46.

57 Ibid., p. 47.

58 Ibid.

59 Shenyang shi gonganju, ‘Guanyu jianli teqing gongzuo de fangfa’, p. 36.

60 Yingkou shi gonganju, ‘Yingkou shi qi ba yue kaizhan gongchang qiye teqing gongzuo zongjie’, p. 48.

61 Ibid., p. 41.

62 Ye Xiangzhi, ‘“Xingdong youji gongzuo de jiantao yu gaijin fangxiang” (“Self-Critical Views on Operations and Guerilla Work and the Direction of Improvement”)’, Gongan qingbao (Public Security Intelligence), No. 17 (19 March 1962) pp. 2–3.

63 Zhongfang, Wang, ‘Luo Ruiqing de gushi’ (The Story of Luo Ruiqing), in Mingshan, Sun (ed.), Lishi shunjian III (Moments in History III) (Beijing: Qunzhong chubanshe, 2004) p. 312Google Scholar.

64 Jianguo yilai gongan gongzuo dashi yaolan, pp. 32–33.

65 ‘Zhonggong zhongyang pizhuan zhongyang gonganbu liuyue zhi jiuyuefen gongzuo buzhi baogao (CCP Centre Circulates CMPS Work Plan for June–September)’, Tielu gongan tongxun, No. 11 (12 August 1952) p. 3.

66 Quoted in ‘Dongbei tielu gonganju zhaokai gongan chuzhang lianxi huiyi qingkuang zongjie baogao (Summing-Up Report Concerning the Joint Conference of Public Security Officers Called by the Northeast Railway Bureau of Public Security)’, Tielu gongan tongxun, No. 11: 10.

67 ‘Di san ci quanguo jingji baowei gongzuo huiyi jueyi (Resolution of the 3rd National Conference on Economic Protection Work)’, Tielu gongan tongxun, No. 13 (8 December 1952) p. 7 (my emphasis).

68 Ibid., p. 5.

69 yanjiushi, Zhonggong zhongyang wenxian & dang'anguan, Zhongyang (eds), Jianguo yilai Liu Shaoqi wengao (Liu Shaoqi's Manuscripts Since the Founding of the Nation), 7 vols. (Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, 2005–2008): Vol. 4, 324–27Google Scholar.

70 Wang Jinxiang, ‘Xin xingshi xia de jingji baowei gongzuo: zai di jiu ci quanguo gongan huiyi shang de fayan (Economic Protection Work under New Circumstances: Statement at the 9th National Public Security Conference)’, Jingji baowei gongzuo (Economic Security Work), No. 23 (15 February 1959) p. 9.

71 Dadao litong waiguode fangeming xiuzhengzhuyi fenzi Wang Jian (Down with Wang Jian, the Counter-Revolutionary Revisionist Element Who Maintains Illicit Contacts with Foreign Countries) (Shanghai: Shanghai shi gonganju bangongshi zhengzhibu nongbaochu geming zaofandui, 1967) pp. 8–13.

72 Jianguo yilai gongan gongzuo dashi yaolan, p. 319.

73 Chao, Compare Cheng and Haoben, Wei (eds), Zhejiang ‘wenge’ jishi (Factual Record of the ‘Cultural Revolution’ in Zhejiang) (Hangzhou: Zhejiang fangzhi bianjibu, 1989) pp. 117–118Google Scholar.

74 Chunli, Guo, Jizhong, Song, and Menggui, Xiong (eds), Meitan gongan baowei shiliao ji (Collected Historical Documentation on Public Security and Protection in the Coal Sector) (Beijing: Meitan gongye chubanshe, 1996) pp. 446, 437, 574Google Scholar. note: quotation marks in original.