Article contents
‘Communities at the Polls’: Electoral Politics and the Mobilization of Communal Groups in Travancore
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 November 2008
Extract
Modern Kerala presents us with a paradox: the state, best known to the outside world for its association with communism, is also where communalism has, arguably, found its most complex political expression. This raises tantalizing questions about the part considerations of class and community have played in the evolution of state politics. The aim of this paper is shed light on a little explored aspect of the background to the Kerala conundrum—the way in which politicians before independence mobilized communal support in elections.
- Type
- Articles
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1993
References
1 Baker, Christopher John, ‘The Congress at the 1937 Elections in Madras’, Modern Asian Studies 10, 4 (1976), pp. 557–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
2 Talbot, Ian, ‘Muslim Political Mobilization in Rural Punjab 1937–46’, in Robb, Peter (ed.), Rural India. Land, Power and Society under British Rule (Delhi, 1986).Google Scholar
3 The Malayalam-speaking state of Kerala, created on 1 November 1956 as a result of the linguistic reorganization of the states, included all but the four southern most Tamil-speaking taluks of Travancore; six of its present fourteen districts were part of erstwhile Travancore.Google Scholar
4 Gould, Harold A., ‘The Emergence of Modern Indian Politics: Political Development in Faizabad. Part I: 1884–1935’, The Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 12, 1 (1974), pp. 20–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
5 Francis Robinson, ‘Nation Formation: The Brass Thesis and Muslim Separatism’, ibid., 15.3 (1977), p. 216.
6 Paul Brass, ‘A Reply to Francis Robinson’, ibid., p. 234. For an elaboration of this theme see my ‘“Democracy” under the Raj: Separate Representation and Elections in British India’ The Journal of Commonwealth and Comparative Politics, 30, I (1992), pp. 39–64.
7 Dumont, Louis, Homo Hierarchicus: An Essay on the Caste System, translated by Sainsbury, Mark (Chicago, 1970).Google Scholar
8 Jeffrey, Robin, The Decline of Nayar Dominance, Society and Politics in Travancore, 1847–1908 (London, 1976), p. 265.Google Scholar
9 Bayly, Susan, Saints, Goddesses and Kings. Muslims and Christians in South Indian Society 1700–1900 (Cambridge, 1989), p. 459.Google Scholar
10 In the November 1989 Lok Sabha elections 79.33 percent of the electorate voted and in the March 1987 state assembly poll the turnout was 80.50 percent. These statistics are derived from returns published in the Cochin edition of the Indian Express and the Coimbatore edition of The Hindu.Google Scholar
11 Census of India, 1901, vol. 26, pt 1, p. 13;Google Scholar and Census of India, 1941, vol. 25, pt 1, p. 11.Google Scholar
12 Census of India, 1901, vol. 26, pt 1, p. 204;Google Scholar and Census of India, 1941, vol. 25, pt 1, p. 155.Google Scholar
13 Jeffrey, , Decline of Nayar Dominance; M. S. A. Rao, Social Movements and Social Transformation: A Study of Two Backward Classes Movements in India (Madras, 1979);Google ScholarNossiter, Tom, Communism in Kerala. A Study in Political Adaptation (Delhi, 1982).Google Scholar
14 Travancore Administrative Report (hereafter TAR), 1905–1906, p. 71;Google Scholar and TAR, 1913–1914, p. 2.Google Scholar
15 TAR, 1906–1907, p. iii;Google Scholar and TAR, 1909–1910, p. ii.Google Scholar
16 Sri Mulam Popular Assembly Proceedings (hereafter SMPAP), 28 (1932), p. 2.Google Scholar
17 SMPAP, 14 (1918), App. B, pp. x–xvii.Google Scholar
18 In the politically eventful 1920–1924 period Nair lawyers actually outnumbered Nair landlords.Google Scholar
19 Many of the associations that came into being in this period were of an ephemeral character but among the more important and sustained were the Travancore and Cochin Christian Association (fd. 1898), the Ezhava' Sri Narayana Dharma Paripalna Yogam (fd. 1903), the Keraliya Nair Samajam (fd. 1905), the Nambudiri Yogakshema Sabha (fd. c1906), the Pulaya' Sadhu Jana Paripalna Sangham (fd. 1913), the Nair Service Society (fd. 1914), the Lejnathul Mohamadiya Sangham (fd. 1915) and the Malabar Catholic Congress (fd. 1918). For a discussion of the emergence and subsequent development of these associations see my Ph. D. thesis, ‘Social Change and the Development of “Modern” Politics in Travancore: From the Late Nineteenth Century to 1938”, University of London, 1985, chs 2 and 3.Google Scholar
20 Padmanabhan, Mannathu, Ente Jeevitta Smaranangal (Changanacherry, 1964), pp. 30–4.Google Scholar
21 Madras Mail, 12 June 1918.Google Scholar
22 List of Political, Quasi–Political and Religious Societies, Sabhas and Anjumans for the year ending 30 June 1919, Dewan to Resident, 31 July 1920, Political File no. 46/1920, Travancore Government Records (hereafter TGR), Kerala Government Secretariat, Trivandrum.Google Scholar
23 Travancore Civic Rights League, Caste and Citizenship in Travancore No. 2 (Kotayam, 1919), p. 4.Google Scholar
24 One Quilon weekly (Kerala Chandrika, 16 September 1919) commented: ‘When British India runs, Travancore crawls’.Google Scholar
25 TAR, 1921–1922, pp. xi–xii.Google Scholar
26 The 1919 Government of India Act provoded for at least 70 percent of the members of the provincial legislatures to be elected and for two or three elected councillors to be appointed ministers with control over ‘transferred subjects’ such as local self government, education and health. Report of the Indian Statutory Commission, vol. 1 (London, 1930), pp. 133, 151–2.Google Scholar
27 ‘Government of India Act. Draft Rules for Elections to the Provincial Legislative Councils (as approved by the Joint Select Committee)’, Cmd. 812, G. B. Parliamentary Papers 1920, vol. 25, pp. 28–9.Google Scholar
28 TAR, 1921–1922, p. 40;Google ScholarTAR, 1924–1925, p. 34;Google Scholar‘Return Showing the Results of Elections in India, 1923’, Cmd. 2154, G. B. Parliamentary Papers 1924, vol. 18.Google Scholar
29 TAR, 1936–1937, p. 98.Google Scholar
30 Madras Mail, 5 March 1921.Google Scholar
31 Important Papers connected with the Students Strike, August–September 1921 (bound volume), Kerala State Archives, Trivandrum.Google Scholar
32 Police Commissioner to Chief Secretary, 3 Sept. 1921, quoted in Mohan, T. K. Vijaya, Genesis of Students' Unrest in Kerala (Trivandrum, 1980), p. 47.Google Scholar
33 Madras Mail, 29 April 1922 and 21 Jan. 1925.Google Scholar
34 TAR, 1921–1922, p. 40.Google Scholar
35 Membership list, Travancore Legislative Council Proceedings (hereafter TLCP), vol. 1.Google Scholar
36 Report of the Election Commissioners on the election petition presented by K. I. Joseph, Legislative Section File no. 83/1923, TGR; and Travancore Law Journal 24 (1934), pp. 31–2.Google Scholar
37 Travancore Almanac and Directory (hereafter TAD), 1923, pp. 84–92.Google Scholar
38 Ibid.
39 Ibid.
40 Baker, Christopher John, The Politics of South India 1920–1937 (Cambridge, 1976), ch. 2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
41 Ibid., p. 154.
42 Madras Mail, 27 May 1925.Google Scholar
43 Police Report on Mathunni, M., 3 July 1931, Judicial File no. 2417/1931, TGR.Google Scholar
44 Madras Mail, 3 June 1928.Google Scholar
45 Madras Mail, 11 Sept. 1925;Google Scholar and Aiyar, S. Ramanath, Progressive Travancore (Trivandrum, 1923), pp. 41–2.Google Scholar
46 Madras Mail, 18 Oct. 1925.Google Scholar
47 Madras Mail, 22 Aug. and 15 Sept. 1926.Google Scholar
48 Speech by the Dewan, , Watts, Maurice, SMPAP, 24 (1928), pp. 138–9.Google Scholar
49 TLCP, vol. 13, pp. 440–3.Google Scholar
50 Madras Mail, 6 Aug 1928.Google Scholar
51 TAR, 1932–1933, pp. 16–17, 93–4.Google Scholar
52 The Regulations and Proclamations of Travancore, vol. 7 (Trivandrum, 1934), p. 136.Google Scholar
53 See statement by Chacko, I. C., a leader of the Travancore State Catholic Congress, in the Dasan, 26 Nov. 1932.Google Scholar Quoted by Kusuman, K. K., The Abstention Movement (Trivandrum, 1976), p. 28.Google Scholar
54 Almost two-thirds of the increase in the ellectorate between 1928 and 1931 was accounted for by Nairs. TAR, 1927–1928, pps. 80–1;Google Scholar and TAR, 1930–1931, pp. 86–7.Google Scholar
55 The Christian Political Conference, the State Catholic Congress, the Latin Mahajana Sabha, the South Travancore Christian Association, the Kerala Christian Service League, the SNDP Yogam, the Muslim Service League, the Lejnathul Mohamadiya Sabha and the Hidayathul Islamia Sabha. All-Travancore Joint Political Congress Executive Committee, Travancore: The Present Political Problem (Calicut, 1934), Appendix V, p. 70.Google Scholar
56 Ibid., Appendix X, p. 114.
57 Ibid., pp. 59–62.
58 Weekly Secret Bulletin (hereafter WSB), vol. 2, para. 201 (17 August 1935), Kerala State Archives, Trivandrum.Google Scholar
59 An extraordinary general meeting of the Yogam at Changanacherry did so by 1491 votes to 9. JPC, The Present Political Problem, pp. 240–1.Google Scholar
60 Census of India, 1941, vol. 25, pt 1, p. 131: and List of Societies, Dewan to the Agent to the Governor General, 10 July 1936, Confidential Section File no. 1092/1936, TGR.Google Scholar
61 JPC, The Present Political Problem, pp. 61–2.Google Scholar
62 Ibid., Appendix XXX, pp. 242–4.
63 Madras Mail, 27 June 1933.Google Scholar
64 Membership lists, Sri Mulam Assembly Proceedings, vol. 1, and Sri Chithra State Council Proceedings, vol. 1.Google Scholar
65 TAR, 1935–1936, pp. 100–1.Google Scholar
66 Ibid.
67 WSB, vol. 3, paras 254 and 267 (12 and 24 Oct. 1936).Google Scholar
68 A deputation from a Nair Vigilance Committee submitted a memorandum expressing these fears to the Dewan, Sir Aiyar, C. P. Ramaswami. Madras Mail, 8 Nov. 1936.Google Scholar
69 WSB, vol. 3, para. 273 (2 Nov. 1936).Google Scholar
70 Malayala Rajyam, 24 March 1937.Google Scholar
71 In one central Travancorean constituency, Karunagapalli-Kartikapalli, three Nair candidates contested the two seats thus aiding a JPC candidate to win one. Madras Mail, 9 April 1937 and 1 May 1937.Google Scholar
72 TAD, 1938, pp. 294–7;Google Scholar and TAR, 1936–1937, pp. 98–9.Google Scholar
73 WSB, vol. 4, paras 88(3 April 1937), 108 (24 April 1937) and 111 (1 May 1937); Confidential Section File no. 1475/1937, TGR.Google Scholar
74 TAD, 1938, pp. 294–7.Google Scholar
75 TAR, 1936–1937, pp. 98–9.Google Scholar
76 Chiriyankandath, ‘Development of “Modern” Politics in Travancore’, pp. 286–7.Google Scholar
77 Jeffrey, Robin, ‘A Sanctified Label—“Congress” in Travancore Politics, 1938–1948’, in Low, D. A. (ed.), Congress and the Raj. Facets of the Indian Strrggle 1917–1947 (London, 1977), pp. 457–8.Google Scholar
78 Pillai, K. Raman, ‘The Significance of the 1987 Elections’, The Indian Journal of Political Science 50, 3 (1989), pp. 293–306.Google Scholar
79 A definition encompassing the descendants of both post-Sixteenth century Catholic, and nineteenth and twentieth century Protestant converts.Google Scholar
80 Between 1893–94 and 1941 total circulation in increased from 4150 to 128,000 (i.e. from one in a thousand to one in fifty Travancoreans). This does not take into account multiple readship. TAR, 1893–1894, p. 157;Google Scholar and Census of India, 1941, vol. 25, pt 1, pp. 165–6.Google Scholar
81 The Travancore Labour Association was initiated in 1922 and the Quilon Labour Association in 1928. Chiriyankandath, ‘Development of “Modern” Politics in Travancore’, pp. 115–21.Google Scholar
82 Ibid., pp. 97–9.
83 Ibid., pp. 199–203.
84 This pre-post-independence continuum forms the focus the my current research.Google Scholar
- 17
- Cited by