Introduction
Tourmaline is the dominant host for boron in most rocks of the Earth's crust. It occurs in granites and granitic pegmatites, and also in sedimentary and in low-grade to ultrahigh-pressure metamorphic rocks and as detrital grains in sandstones and conglomerates (Ertl et al., Reference Ertl, Marschall, Giester, Henry, Schertl, Ntaflos, Luvizotto, Nasdala and Tillmanns2010; van Hinsberg et al., Reference van Hinsberg, Henry and Dutrow2011a, Reference van Hinsberg, Henry and Marschall2011b; Dutrow and Henry, Reference Dutrow and Henry2018; Henry and Dutrow, Reference Henry and Dutrow2018). Tourmaline-supergroup minerals are complex borosilicates with a significant compositional variability containing both light and heavy elements, from H to Pb, and across multiple valence states. This variability results in a wide range of distinct mineral species. The general structural formula of the tourmaline-supergroup minerals is XY3Z6T6O18(BO3)3V3W, where X = Na, K, Ca, Pb and □ (□ = vacancy); Y = Al, Fe3+, Mn3+, Cr, V, Mg, Fe2+, Mn2+, Li and Ti; Z = Al, Fe, Cr, V, Mg and Fe2+; T = Si, Al and B; B = B3+; V = (OH) and O; and W = (OH), F and O (Henry et al., Reference Henry, Novák, Hawthorne, Ertl, Dutrow, Uher and Pezzotta2011). The non-italicised letters X, Y, Z, T and B represent groups of cations accommodated at the [9]X, [6]Y, [6]Z, [4]T and [3]B crystallographic sites (italicised letters). The letters V and W represent groups of anions accommodated at the [3]O(3) and [3]O(1) crystallographic sites, respectively. The H atoms occupy the H(3) and H(1) sites, which are related to O(3) and O(1), respectively.
According to the dominance of specific ions at one or more sites of the crystal structure, the tourmaline-supergroup minerals can be classified in three primary groups on the basis of the X-site occupancy: X-site vacant, alkali and calcic (Henry et al., Reference Henry, Novák, Hawthorne, Ertl, Dutrow, Uher and Pezzotta2011). A further level of classification into subgroups is based on charge arrangements at the Y and Z sites. Tourmalines are also distinguished by the dominant W anion into hydroxy-, fluor- and oxy-species (Henry et al., Reference Henry, Novák, Hawthorne, Ertl, Dutrow, Uher and Pezzotta2011). In particular, occupancy of the X and Y-site is useful to reconstruct the chemical history of the fluids involved in tourmaline crystallisation (van Hinsberg et al., Reference van Hinsberg, Henry and Dutrow2011a, Reference van Hinsberg, Henry and Marschall2011b; Dutrow and Henry, Reference Dutrow and Henry2018; Bosi et al., Reference Bosi, Pezzotta, Altieri, Andreozzi, Ballirano, Tempesta, Cempírek, Škoda, Filip, Čopjacová, Novák, Kampf, Scribner, Groat and Evans2022; Altieri et al., Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Skogby, Hålenius and Bosi2022; Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Skogby, Hålenius and Bosi2023a, Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Andreozzi, Skogby and Bosi2023b).
Tourmaline is well known to be an efficient geological tool for investigating P–T–X conditions in all crustal settings within the Earth given its ability to register and preserve the composition and the redox conditions of the environment from which it crystallised (Dutrow and Henry, Reference Dutrow and Henry2011). Colour-zoning in tourmaline generally highlights internal variations in composition, reflecting evolution in the physico-chemical characteristics of the pegmatitic fluid during crystallisation (e.g. Dutrow and Henry, Reference Dutrow and Henry2018; Altieri et al., Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Skogby, Hålenius and Bosi2022; Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Skogby, Hålenius and Bosi2023a, Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Andreozzi, Skogby and Bosi2023b).
The Mavuco tourmaline gem deposit, located in the Alto Ligoña pegmatite district (NE Mozambique), is internationally known to be the source of a quantity of very valuable Cu-bearing gem tourmalines also known as ‘Paraiba’ variety (Laurs et al., Reference Laurs, Zwaan, Breeding, Simmons, Beaton, Rijsdijk, Befi and Falster2008; Ertl et al., Reference Ertl, Giester, Schüssler, Brätz, Okrusch, Tillmanns and Bank2013; Okrusch et al., Reference Okrusch, Ertl, Schüssler, Tillmanns, Brätz and Bank2016). Nevertheless, as the deposit is of secondary origin, very little is known about the original primary deposit in which the tourmalines formed. To investigate the nature of the primary deposit and eventual changes in the crystallisation environment, and consequently, reconstruct the tourmaline growth history, a tourmaline sample comprising a large fragment of a multicolour crystal has been chosen that gives the best representation of the variety of colours occurring in the deposit. This multicoloured sample has been subject to an in-depth analysis using a multi-analytical approach, including electron microprobe analysis, optical absorption and Mössbauer spectroscopic investigations.
Sample occurrence
The mining area of Mavuco consists of a secondary deposit of over 12 km2 located in the Alto Ligoña pegmatite district, in NE Mozambique (Fig. 1a). In this secondary deposit, tourmalines occur as fragments, ranging usually from 1 g to over 100 g with sub-angular to sub-rounded morphology, within a residual soil level mostly composed of quartz fragments and associated occasionally with fragments of gem beryl and spessartine. This layer is called kamada by local miners, with a thickness ranging from a few cm up to 1 m, and occurs on top of the altered bedrock, which is, in general, composed of amphibolitic paragneiss, and more rarely of marble lenses, and aplitic and pegmatitic veins. On top of the kamada is a layer named locally as kororo, a reddish-brownish soil unit with a thickness from 1 m up to exceptionally over 10 m. This layer is bauxitic with variable quantities of iron hydroxide nodules and sparse small quartz grains. Tourmaline or other gemstones are not present in this layer.
Figure 1. (a) The occurrence area of the tourmaline sample investigated is marked in the eastern portion of the Pegmatitic District of Alto Ligoña, NE Mozambique; and (b) a cross-section of the soil of the secondary deposit of Mavuco. Tourmalines are found in a light reddish-brown quartz-rich gravel layer (locally called kamada) on top of a light tan weathered bedrock, and underneath a layer of red–brown clayey-bauxitic soil (locally called kororo). Photo by F. Pezzotta.
This secondary gem deposit was interpreted by Laurs et al. (Reference Laurs, Zwaan, Breeding, Simmons, Beaton, Rijsdijk, Befi and Falster2008) (Fig. 1b) as of alluvial origin, with the primary pegmatitic tourmaline deposits eroded and transported by the seasonal streams through spasmodic flash floods downhill to the Mavuco area where they were deposited (Laurs et al., Reference Laurs, Zwaan, Breeding, Simmons, Beaton, Rijsdijk, Befi and Falster2008). Nevertheless, systematic observations made by one of the authors (Pezzotta) of the soil sections exposed during the mechanised excavations for the mining of gem tourmalines, performed by the Mozambique Gems company, show that the distribution and the thickness of the kamada are not related to the morphology and hydrology of the land, and indeed the kamada represents a very persistent unit in the soil, occurring at various depths from place to place, though always at the top of the altered bedrock. Moreover, the occurrence in the kamada of quartz and tourmaline clasts, and occasionally beryl and spessartine clasts, which still preserve quite well-defined crystal faces, together with clasts which are partially rounded to very rounded, and the local increase of the kamada thickness at the intersection and in the surrounding areas of altered quartz and pegmatitic veins still observable in the altered bedrock, are elements in favour of an eluvial, and locally colluvial, origin of such a soil unit. Thus, the minerals found as fragments in the kamada are the result of an in situ erosion of a primary deposit, composed, very probably, of a series of pegmatitic veins, which, at least in part, still exist at depth. Further studies are in progress by Pezzotta to define better this genetic model.
Materials and methods
Sample
A sample (labelled ‘MAV 6’) consisting of a large fragment (2.5 cm diameter, 12.75 g weight) of a multicoloured tourmaline crystal collected from the secondary deposit of Mavuco, roughly representative of a core-to-rim section perpendicular to the c axis, was chosen for the present study (Fig. 2, left). The sample is sub-rounded and results from the natural breakage and erosion of an original prismatic crystal, characterised by a black core, an intermediate polychromatic zone (yellow, pale blue–green, purple) and a dark-coloured rim.
Figure 2. The polychromatic tourmaline sample investigated in this work (image to the left) and the corresponding thin (500 μm) section (image to the right). Sample size: 2.5 cm. Sample weight: 12.75 gr. Scale bar = 1 cm. The analysed traverse (A–B) is represented by a solid red line. On the basis of colour and composition, the different coloured zones are labelled as: C1, C2 = core zones; I1= yellow intermediate zone, I2 = pale blue–green intermediate zone (note that the real colour of the crystal in the figure appears faded due to the backlighting) and I3 = pink–red intermediate zone; R = prismatic overgrowth.
On the basis of the compositional and colour inhomogeneity, the sample was divided in different zones. The area corresponding to the core zone, the intermediate polychromatic zone and the dark-green prismatic rim were labelled ‘C’, ‘I’ and ‘R’, respectively. The ‘I’ and ‘C’ zones were further subdivided, on the basis of changes in composition or colour, by adding a progressive numerical suffix starting from the core of the crystal.
Sample preparation
The tourmaline sample was glued to a glass slide using epoxy resin. Then, a crystal slice was cut and subsequently ground and polished to produce a flat surface with a uniform thickness of 500 μm for compositional microanalysis (Fig. 2, right).
For optical absorption spectroscopy analysis, crystal slices cut from the different coloured zones were glued to a glass slide using a thermoplastic resin. Before analysis, each coloured slice was further thinned to appropriate thickness (yellow intermediate zone: 280 μm; pale blue–green intermediate zone: 838 μm; purple intermediate zone: 843 μm; dark-green rim: 424 μm) and doubly polished.
Electron microprobe analysis (EMPA)
Compositional data for the tourmaline sample were collected along a straight line traverse from the black core to the dark-green rim with an average step size of 500 μm, using a CAMECA SX50 electron-microprobe at the Istituto di Geologia Ambientale e Geoingegneria (CNR of Rome, Italy). Forty four spot analyses were obtained. Electron microprobe analyses were obtained in wavelength-dispersion spectroscopy mode with an accelerating potential of 15 kV, a sample current of 15 nA and a beam diameter of 10 μm. Minerals and synthetic compounds used as reference materials were: wollastonite (Si, Ca), magnetite (Fe), rutile (Ti), corundum (Al), karelianite (V), fluorophlogopite (F), periclase (Mg), jadeite (Na), orthoclase (K), rhodonite (Mn) and metallic Cr, Cu and Zn. The PAP correction procedure for quantitative electron microprobe analysis was applied (Pouchou and Pichoir, Reference Pouchou, Pichoir, Heinrich and Newbury1991). Relative error for these data was <1% and detection limits <0.03 wt.%.
Mössbauer spectroscopy (MS)
57Fe Mössbauer spectra of the Fe-rich coloured zones of the tourmaline sample were collected using a conventional spectrometer system equipped with a 50 mCi source and operated in constant acceleration mode. The absorbers were prepared from 60 to 135 mg ground sample material that was mixed with an acrylic resin and pressed to 12 mm diameter discs under mild heating (<150°C). Data were collected at room temperature over the velocity range ± 4.2 mm/s and recorded in a multichannel analyser with 1024 channels. The velocity was calibrated with an α-Fe foil. The spectra were fitted using unconstrained Lorentzian doublets with the aid of the software MossA (Prescher et al., Reference Prescher, McCammon and Dubrowinsky2012).
Optical absorption spectroscopy (OAS)
Unpolarised, room-temperature optical absorption spectra of the polychromatic core zone and the dark-green rim, in the range of 30500–11000 cm–1, were obtained at a spectral resolution of 1 nm on doubly polished sections, using an AVASPEC-ULS2048 × 16 spectrometer attached via a 400 μm ultraviolet (UV) optical fibre cable to a Zeiss Axiotron UV-microscope. A 75 W Xenon arc lamp was used as light source and Zeiss Ultrafluar 10× lenses served as objective and condenser. Data in the NIR region (11000–5000 cm–1) were measured using a Bruker Vertex 70 spectrometer attached to a Hyperion 2000 microscope and equipped with a halogen lamp source, a CaF2 beamsplitter and an InSb detector at resolution of 4 cm–1.
Determination of atomic fractions
The wt.% of element oxides determined by EMPA (Table 1) was used to calculate the atomic fractions (atoms per formula unit, apfu). The B content was assumed to be stoichiometric (B = 3.00 apfu). Lithium was calculated in accord with Pesquera et al. (Reference Pesquera, Gil-Crespo, Torres-Ruiz, Torres-Ruiz and Roda-Robles2016). Iron oxidation state in the Fe-rich coloured zones was determined by MS (Table 2). The (OH) content was calculated by charge balance with the assumption of (T + Y + Z) = 15.00 apfu and 31 anions. The site populations and the empirical formulae (Table 3) of the different coloured zones of the tourmaline sample analysed were calculated following the site allocation of ions recommended by Henry et al. (Reference Henry, Novák, Hawthorne, Ertl, Dutrow, Uher and Pezzotta2011).
Table 1. Average compositions from EMPA and atoms per formula unit (apfu) for the different coloured zones of the tourmaline sample from the Mavuco area, Alto Ligoña pegmatite district, NE Mozambique.
a Calculated by stoichiometry (see text)
b Estimated with the procedure of Pesquera et al. (Reference Pesquera, Gil-Crespo, Torres-Ruiz, Torres-Ruiz and Roda-Robles2016)
c Calculated by Mössbauer analysis; for C1 and R, FeOEMPA = 4.99(20) wt.% and FeOEMPA = 1.39(26) wt.%, respectively
d Determined by OAS
Errors for oxides and fluorine are standard deviations (in brackets); ‘–’ is below detection limit
Table 2. Room temperature 57Fe Mössbauer parameters for the FeO-rich coloured zones of the tourmaline investigated in this study.*
* Centroid shift (δ) in mm/s relative to α-Fe foil; errors are estimated no less than ±0.02 mm/s for δ, quadrupole splitting (ΔEQ), and peak width (Γ), and no less than ±3% for doublets areas.
Table 3. Empirical formulae for the different coloured zones of the tourmaline sample investigated.
Results
Composition
Electron microprobe analyses of the sample revealed a wide variation in Fe- and Mn- concentrations, reflected in marked changes in colour from the black core, to yellow, pale blue–green, purple in the intermediate zone, and to dark green at the prismatic overgrowth, representing the rim. Calcium, Ti, Cu and F are also characterised by some variation along the traverse. Vanadium, Cr and Zn were below detection limits.
The determined concentrations of selected elements (as wt.% oxides) along the chosen traverse are shown Fig. 3, and average compositions for each coloured zone summarised in Table 1.
Figure 3. Results from EMPA of the tourmaline sample (only selected oxides are reported). See Table 1 for complete composition.
The black core of the sample (C1 and C2) is characterised by enrichment in Fe and Mn (FeO ≈ 5 wt.% and MnO ≈ 4 wt.%), which remains quite constant throughout the section (Fig. 3). Within the intermediate polychromatic zone, the yellow zone (I1), there is a sharp increase in MnO, reaching up to 7 wt.%, coupled with a simultaneous drop in FeO to less than 1 wt.% (Fig. 3). A decrease in the MnO content occurs in the pale blue–green zone (I2), with a progressive decrease to below 1 wt.% approaching the termination of the purple zone (I3), similarly for FeO, which falls to values below the detection limits in the I3 zone (Fig. 3). The dark-green prismatic rim (R) is characterised by a sharp increase in FeO and a moderate increase in MnO concentration, reaching up to 1.4 and 1.2 wt.%, respectively (Fig. 3).
In addition to FeO and MnO, the concentrations of CuO, TiO2 and CaO, show significant changes within the crystal. CuO concentration is above detection only in the yellow I1 zone, the pale blue–green I2 zone and the purple I3 zone, with values up to 0.15 wt.% (Fig. 3). Titanium is concentrated mostly in the C1, C2 and I1 zones, with values of TiO2 ranging from 0.45 to 0.65 wt.%, though it is below 0.05 wt.% in the I2 and I3 zones and the dark-green prismatic overgrowth (Table 1). A peculiar behaviour is seen for CaO content, which though generally low across all the zones of the crystal, displays an abrupt increase in the R zone, reaching ⁓4 wt.% (Fig. 3).
Mössbauer spectroscopy data and iron speciation
Portions of the black core (C1, C2), the yellow intermediate zone (I1) and the dark-green prismatic overgrowth (R), characterised by significant Fe contents, were subjected to MS analysis to evaluate the Fe oxidation states. The hyperfine parameters of the MS doublets and the relative Fe oxidation state and site assignment for each sample analysed are summarised in Table 2. The spectrum of the black core zone was fitted with four doublets. The first three doublets are compatible with Fe2+ occurring at the Y site (Andreozzi et al., Reference Andreozzi, Bosi and Longo2008). However, a unique Fe site-distribution cannot be achieved due to the limited resolution of the absorption doublets. A fourth weak doublet (3.2%) was interpreted as Fe2.5+ due to electron delocalisation. These data resulted in a Fe3+/ΣFetot-ratio of 0.02 (with Fe2.5+ distributed equally on Fe2+ and Fe3+), suggesting that Fe2+ strongly dominates the black core zone (Fig. 4a). The spectrum of the yellow intermediate zone was fitted with only Fe2+ doublets compatible with Y-site occupancy, without any indication of Fe3+ (Fig. 4b). For the dark-green overgrowth, a model with four absorption doublets was adopted. The first three doublets were interpreted as Fe2+ at the Y site (Y1, Y2 and Y3), whereas the fourth doublet is consistent with Fe3+ (4% of Fetot) (Fig. 4c).
Figure 4. Room-temperature 57Fe Mössbauer spectra for the black core (C1, C2), the yellow intermediate zone (I1) and the dark-green prismatic rim (R). For all the coloured zones (a, b, c), the experimental spectrum is represented by dots, and the calculated spectrum by a thick red curve. Lorentzian absorption doublets assigned to [6]Fe2+ are represented by dark-green, light-blue and light-green coloured areas. The neon-green coloured area refers to the assignment of [6]Fe2.5+ and [6]Fe3+.
Optical spectra
As stated above, the tourmaline sample is characterised by a marked polychroism. The different coloured zones were subjected to optical absorption spectroscopy analysis in the UV-Vis region with the spectra of the yellow, pale blue–green and purple intermediate zones and the dark-green prismatic overgrowth reported in Fig. 5.
Figure 5. Optical absorption spectra for the different coloured zones of the tourmaline sample analysed. Sample thickness: yellow intermediate zone = 280 μm; pale blue-green intermediate zone = 838 μm; purple intermediate zone = 843 μm; dark-green overgrowth = 424 μm. The main absorption bands are indicated.
The spectrum of the yellow intermediate zone (I1) has a very strong absorption band in the near UV-region at ⁓30700 cm−1 and a sharp and very weak absorption band at ⁓24000 cm−1. The spectrum recorded in the pale blue–green intermediate zone (I2) reveals only the presence of a very weak broad band at ⁓14000 cm−1 and an intense broad band at ⁓11000 cm−1 in the near-infrared range (NIR). The recorded optical absorption spectrum of the purple intermediate zone (I3) is characterised by weak and broad absorption bands at ⁓25200 cm−1, ⁓22000 cm−1 and ⁓14000 cm−1, and a stronger broad band at ⁓19000 cm−1. The spectrum of dark-green prismatic overgrowth displays two broad absorption bands centred at 13800 cm−1 and 9200 cm−1, and a set of weak and relatively sharp bands between ⁓25000−24000 cm−1.
The set of sharp bands, in the NIR region of spectra between 6700–7200 cm–1, are due to overtones of the fundamental (OH)-stretching modes. These bands are obscured in the spectrum of the dark-green overgrowth by the strong absorption band at ⁓9000 cm–1, and barely visible in the spectrum of the yellow intermediate zone (I1) due to the reduced thickness.
Classification of tourmaline species in the multicoloured crystal from the gem deposit of Mavuco, Alto Ligoña pegmatite district, Mozambique
The empirical formulae (Table 3) show that the composition of the black core zone (C1), as well as the yellow (I1), the pale blue-green (I2) and the purple (I3) intermediate zones, are consistent with a tourmaline belonging to the alkali-group, subgroup 2 (Henry et al., Reference Henry, Novák, Hawthorne, Ertl, Dutrow, Uher and Pezzotta2011): they are Na-dominant at the X position of the tourmaline general formula and fluor-dominant at W with (OH+F)− > O2− and F >> (OH). In addition, they are ZAl- and Y(Al1.5Li1.5)-dominant. Thus, the black core zone (C1), the yellow (I1), the pale blue–green (I2) and the purple (I3) intermediate zones can be classified as fluor-elbaite, ideally Na(Li1.5Al1.5)Al6Si6O18(BO3)3(OH)3F.
The outer part of the black core (C2) can be classified as a tourmaline belonging to the alkali-group, subgroup 4 (Henry et al., Reference Henry, Novák, Hawthorne, Ertl, Dutrow, Uher and Pezzotta2011): it is Na-dominant at the X position of the tourmaline general formula and oxy-dominant at W with O2− > F−. Because it is ZAl- and Y(Al2Li)-dominant, its composition can be described as darrellhenryite, ideally Na(Al2Li)Al6(Si6O18)(BO3)3(OH)3O.
In contrast, the dark-green prismatic rim (R) can be classified as a tourmaline belonging to the calcic-group, subgroup 2 (Henry et al., Reference Henry, Novák, Hawthorne, Ertl, Dutrow, Uher and Pezzotta2011): it is Ca-dominant at the X position and fluor-dominant at W with (OH+F)− > O2− and F >> (OH). Because it is ZAl- and Y(Li2Al)-dominant, its composition is considered to be fluor-liddicoatite, ideally Ca(Li2Al)Al6(Si6O18)(BO3)3(OH)3F.
Discussion
Causes of colour
Colours in tourmaline are essentially related to the transition elements (Ti, V, Cr, Fe, Mn and Cu), acting as colour-causing agents through several mechanisms at structural levels, with the most common ones being crystal field transitions (CFT), intervalence charge transfer (IVCT) interactions, and colour centres (Fritsch and Rossman, Reference Fritsch and Rossman1987; Pezzotta and Laurs, Reference Pezzotta and Laurs2011; Rossman, Reference Rossman, Henderson, Neuville and Downs2014). Since compositional analyses of the different coloured zones did not reveal V2O3 and Cr2O3 (levels below the detection limit ≤0.03 wt.%), the main transition metals that could contribute to the colour of the tourmaline investigated are Fe, Mn, Ti and Cu.
The black colour characterising the core zone (C1, C2) hindered the recording of an optical absorption spectrum. Nevertheless, we can assess that such a colour is caused mainly by the highly absorbing Fe2+ transitions because of the abundance of this element in the inner core zone (FeO > 4 wt.%).
The spectrum of the yellow intermediate zone (I1) has a very strong absorption band in the near UV-region at ⁓30700 cm−1 and a sharp and very weak absorption band at ⁓24000 cm−1, which can be assigned to Mn2+–Ti4+ IVCT and Mn2+ spin-forbidden transitions, respectively (Rossman and Mattson, Reference Rossman and Mattson1986; da Fonseca-Zang et al., Reference da Fonseca-Zang, Zang and Hofmeister2008) (Fig. 5). This assignment is consistent with the enrichment in MnO and TiO2 observed from compositional data (Table 4). Because the yellow coloration is mainly caused by an intervalence charge transfer Mn2+–Ti4+ interaction and to a minor extent by Mn2+ spin-forbidden transition, the I1 zone corresponds to the ‘canary’ tourmaline gemmological variety described in Laurs et al. (Reference Laurs, Simmons, Rossman, Fritz, Koivula, Anckar and Falster2007).
Table 4. Interpretation of OAS results for selected spot analyses on different coloured zones in the tourmaline sample investigated.
The spectrum recorded in the pale blue–green intermediate zone (I2) reveals only the presence of a very weak broad band at ⁓14000 cm−1 and an intense broad band at ⁓11000 cm−1 in the near-infrared-range, both ascribed to Cu2+ spin-allowed d-d transitions (Rossman et al., Reference Rossman, Fritsch and Shigley1991; Mashkovtsev et al., Reference Mashkovtsev, Smirnov and Shigley2006) (Fig. 5). Results from EPMA confirmed the enrichment in Cu in this part of the crystal, with an amount up to double than that of the yellow zone (Fig. 3). This fits well with the different intensity of the absorption bands relative to Cu observed in the blue and the yellow zones. The relatively low MnO concentration (< 2 wt.%) does not contribute to the colour through Mn2+ spin-forbidden electronic transitions, as Mn2+ is a weak absorber (Rossman, Reference Rossman, Henderson, Neuville and Downs2014). In addition, a lack of TiO2, prevents Mn–Ti interaction and consequently prevents the occurrence of a stronger Mn2+–Ti4+ IVCT absorption band. Thus, in the absence of Fe (Table 4), Cu is the only colour-causing agent for the pale blue–green colouration of the I2 zone. Moreover, on the basis of overall results, the pale blue–green intermediate zone (I2) can be classified as the ‘Paraiba’ tourmaline variety (Laurs et al., Reference Laurs, Zwaan, Breeding, Simmons, Beaton, Rijsdijk, Befi and Falster2008).
The optical absorption spectrum of the purple intermediate zone (I3) is characterised by a weak and broad absorption band at ⁓22000 cm−1 and a stronger broad band at ⁓19000 cm−1, both ascribable to Mn3+ d–d transitions (Reinitz and Rossman, Reference Reinitz and Rossman1988; Taran et al., Reference Taran, Lebedev and Platonov1993; Ertl et al., Reference Ertl, Rossman, Hughes, Prowatke and Ludwig2005; Bosi et al., Reference Bosi, Cámara, Ciriotti, Hålenius, Reznitskii and Stagno2017, Reference Bosi, Celata, Skogby, Hålenius, Tempesta, Ciriotti, Bittarello and Marengo2021) (Fig. 5 and Table 4). These assignments agree with the purple colour of this part of the crystal, which can be ascribed to the presence of Mn3+ as a colour-causing agent. On the basis of the intensity of the band at ~19000 cm–1 and using the molar extinction coefficient suggested by Reinitz and Rossman (Reference Reinitz and Rossman1988), the Mn2O3 content was estimated to be 0.56 wt.% (Table 1) in the I3 zone. The origin of the broad and weak absorption bands at ⁓25200 cm−1 and ⁓14000 cm−1 is less obvious. The very low Fe and Ti content recorded by EMPA in this zone, rules out Fe2+–Ti4+ IVCT as well as spin-allowed Fe2+ origins of these bands (Table 4). Other transition metals, such as Ni, can be taken into account (Taran et al., Reference Taran, Lebedev and Platonov1993), although the absence of Ni in this sample rules out this possibility. Thus, the origin of these two absorption bands remains unclear. According to these data, the purple coloration of the I3 zone is dominated by the presence of Mn in the oxidised trivalent state. Nevertheless, the relatively significant content of Cu could add a minor bluish hue to the colour. Hence, this variety of Cu-bearing rubellite might correspond to the gemmological variety cuprian-rubellite (Fritsch et al., Reference Fritsch, Shigley, Rossman, Mercer, Muhlmeister and Moon1990).
The spectrum of the dark-green prismatic overgrowth of the crystal displays two broad absorption bands centred at 13800 cm−1 and 9200 cm−1, and a weak broad band at 24000 cm−1, all attributable to the presence of relatively high levels of Fe (FeO up to 1.4 wt.%) (Fig. 5). Mössbauer analysis also shows, in addition to Fe3+, the presence of Fe2+. Thus, the two strong bands at 13800 cm−1 and 9200 cm−1 could be caused by electronic exchange interactions between the Fe2+/Fe3+ pair at adjacent Y sites in the tourmaline structure (Taran and Rossman, Reference Taran and Rossman2002) (Table 4). The set of weak and relatively sharp bands between ⁓25000−24000 cm−1 can instead be assigned to spin-forbidden Fe2+ and/or Fe3+ bands (Mattson and Rossman, Reference Mattson and Rossman1987) (Table 4). In accord with these assignments, the dark-green colouration of the overgrowth is controlled mainly by Fe2+/Fe3+ interactions.
Growth history
The tourmaline sample analysed is composed of a relatively large detrital fragment, representing (from core-to-rim) all the growth sectors of an original crystal. Although there is no direct information regarding the primary deposit in which the original crystal formed, the changes of the composition observed in the sample allows some significant inferences concerning the original growth stages, as well as the characteristics and the evolution of the crystallisation fluids.
The secondary Mavuco tourmaline deposit, from which the sample was collected, is located in the Alto Ligoña pegmatitic district characterised by a crystalline basement of amphibolitic facies with migmatitic domes, into which a number of gem-bearing LCT pegmatites of the upper Neoproterozoic age have been intruded (Pinna et al., Reference Pinna, Jourde, Calvez, Mroz and Marques1993; Bettencourt Dias and Wilson, Reference Bettencourt Dias and Wilson2000; Lächelt, Reference Lächelt2004). The main features of the sample investigated, in addition to the minerals associated with tourmaline as residual grains in the secondary Mavuco deposit, clearly indicate a pegmatitic origin for the primary deposit. Thus, it represents, from core-to-rim, the stages of growth of an original tourmaline crystal of pegmatitic origin. Moreover, the relatively high gemmological quality and geochemical evolution of this tourmaline indicates that the original crystal formed in the core zone of a pegmatitic vein, very probably, in a miarolitic cavity.
The black inner core of the crystal exhibits a significant enrichment in Fe and Mn (FeO > 5 wt.% and MnO > 4 wt.%). This enrichment is related to the amount of these elements available in the pegmatitic system during the early crystallisation of tourmaline. The subsequent progressive decrease in Fe, with FeO contents decreasing to below the detection limit in the outermost part of the core zone, and remaining close to zero in the intermediate zone, is the result of Fe-depletion in the system, due mostly to tourmaline crystallisation. Indeed, MnO, shows an increase up to over 6 wt.% in the intermediate zone, then falling in the outermost intermediate zone to very low values (< 0.5 wt.%). The increased incorporation of Mn that characterises the yellow intermediate zone (I1) could be promoted by the depletion of Fe in the pegmatitic melt. In fact, the MnO content in the tourmaline crystal rises when the FeO content starts to decrease (Fig. 3), and this profile could be related to the behaviour of Mn during pegmatite crystallisation. Manganese is incompatible in typical magmatic primitive tourmaline (schorl–foitite), whereas Fe is very compatible, and thus the progressive increase in the Mn/Fe ratio of melt is driven by the crystallisation of tourmaline (London et al., Reference London, Evensen, Fritz, Icenhower, Morgan and Wolf2001; Maner et al., Reference Maner IV, London and Icenhower2019).
However, during the latest stages of growth of the crystal, a sharp, new increase in Fe and Mn occurred, as documented by the dark-coloured prismatic overgrowth. A similar phenomenon has been described in the tourmaline crystals from Elba Island (Italy). These crystals are typically characterised by a sudden late-stage Fe and/or Mn enrichment, which results in dark-coloured overgrowths, mostly evident at the termination of the crystals (Pezzotta, Reference Pezzotta2021; Altieri, Reference Altieri2023; Altieri et al., Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Skogby, Hålenius and Bosi2022, Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Skogby, Hålenius and Bosi2023a, Reference Altieri, Pezzotta, Andreozzi, Skogby and Bosi2023b). As has been argued for the Elba Island tourmalines petrogenetic model, a pocket rupture event related to brittle deformations occurring during the latest stages of crystallisation of the cavities in the pegmatitic rock, was responsible for a partial opening of the geochemical system. According to this model, the highly reactive late-stage cavity fluids were able to penetrate the fractures in the pegmatitic rock around the cavity. Consequently, this led to the hydrothermal alteration of the early-crystallised Fe- and Mn-rich minerals, such as Fe-rich micas and almandine–spessartine garnet. The release of Fe and Mn in the system caused a dramatic change in the composition of the pocket environment with the subsequent formation of the dark-coloured overgrowth. The observed significant increase in Ca in the dark-coloured tourmaline overgrowth might be related to two potential factors. Firstly, it could be linked to the destabilisation of early crystallised plagioclase crystals in the pegmatitic rock. Alternatively, it could be the result of fluid contamination originating from the metamorphic crystalline rocks into which the pegmatite was emplaced.
The CuO content is always low, with the highest values (~0.15 wt.%) in the I2 and the I3 zones. It is noteworthy that the highest values correspond to geochemically evolved growth sectors (Fig. 3). The occurrence of Cu in pegmatitic systems is interpreted as a contamination of the pegmatitic liquids/fluids, which could have occurred at the source or even at the emplacement level (e.g. Beurlen et al., Reference Beurlen, De Moura, Soares, Da Silva and Rhede2011; Beckett-Brown et al., Reference Beckett-Brown, McDonald and McClenaghan2023). However, the profile of the abundance of Cu in tourmaline crystals growth is still poorly documented.
The presence of Mn3+ in the I3 zone, which results in the pink–red colouration, could suggest a change towards oxidising conditions in the environment. This contrasts with the very low oxidising conditions in which the tourmaline crystallised. In fact, Mössbauer data show an Fe3+/Fetot ratio of 0.02 in the core zone, the presence of only Fe2+ in the yellow intermediate zone (I1), and a Fe3+/Fetot ratio of 0.04 that characterises the dark-green prismatic overgrowth. In this particular scenario, it proves challenging to elucidate the sudden and temporary transition to oxidised conditions in the environment during crystallisation of the observed pink–red I3 zone. The possibility of a geochemical system opening at this stage can be ruled out because no sudden changes in the composition can be observed in the I3 zone. A possible explanation for the occurrence of Mn3+ in the I3 zone can be ascribed to the presence of a low amount of Mn3+ in the original melt. It has been reported that the Mn partition coefficient is anomalously low for Mn3+ and Mn uptake by tourmaline is dominated by Mn2+ (van Hinsberg, Reference van Hinsberg2011). Thus, the Mn3+/Mn2+ ratio increased as consequence of the preferential incorporation of Mn2+ by tourmaline and the incorporation of Mn3+ occurred once Mn2+ had been completely depleted. Another explanation to account for the change in the redox state which occurred in the pink–red I3 zone, where Mn3+ prevails, is to assume that tourmaline, after crystallisation, encountered a natural radiation source, thereby inducing the Mn2+ oxidation and consequently leaving an overprint in the composition. However, the oxidising effects of any radiation source only become evident in the I3 zone, characterised by the lowest Mn content and absence of Fe. We suggest that, in addition to other phenomena, the Mn2+ and Ti4+ IVCT interaction might offer a stabilising effect against the oxidation of Mn. According to this, the initial part of the crystal, up to the yellow intermediate zone (I1), is enriched in TiO2 (> 0.4 wt.%) and MnO (> 1.5 wt.%), whereas TiO2 is undetectable in the pink–red I3 zone. To the best of our knowledge, this explanation has not been proposed previously in the literature. It introduces a new concept that has the potential to open up a new area of research.
Conclusions
This work investigated a fragment of a multicoloured tourmaline from the secondary deposit of Mavuco (Alto Ligoña, Mozambique), which represents the growth history from core-to-rim of the original crystal. By combining data obtained by compositional and spectroscopic investigations, it was possible to determine the colour-causing agents that characterise the different coloured zones of the crystal.
The polychromatic feature of this tourmaline fragment highlights the petrogenetic potential of tourmaline as a powerful tool to register physicochemical variation in the crystallisation environment. However, the presence of a change in the redox state of Mn within a limited zone, probably occurred after the tourmaline crystallisation, and might represent evidence of post-crystallisation alteration of the compositional signature of the tourmaline crystal.
Acknowledgements
Sample preparation for compositional and spectroscopic analyses was carried out with the support of Dr. D. Mannetta to whom the authors express their gratitude. The authors sincerely thank M. Serracino for his assistance during chemical analyses. The company Mozambique Mining is acknowledged for providing the studied sample. The authors sincerely thank the reviewers Peter Bačik and Andreas Ertl for their constructive comments that helped to improve the manuscript. This research received funding by Sapienza University of Rome (Prog. Università 2023 to F.B.)
Author contributions
F.P. and F.B. conceived the project. F.B. created the working group. F.P. selected the research material and collected the field information. A.A. and F.B. provided EMPA data. H.S. and U.H. provided MS and OAS data. A.A. analysed the data and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. F.P. contributed to the discussion section. All the authors reviewed the final version of the manuscript.
Competing interests
The authors declare none.
Open access
