Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-m6dg7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T02:43:31.627Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Liability Related to Diagnosis and Transmission of AIDS

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 April 2021

Donald H.J. Hermann
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Given the pain, incapacity, and death that afflict persons with AIDS, it is not surprising that those exposed to HIV or those who have developed AIDS may sometimes feel themselves wronged and entitled to legal damages. There are two main areas of potential AIDS-related litigation: liability related to medical malpractice and liability related to transmission, whether via contaminated blood or blood products, needle-sharing, childbirth, or sexual intercourse.

This article will examine the precedents, arguments, and possible defenses in these areas and in relationship to a variety of potential defendants.

A cause of action for medical malpractice in AIDS-related diagnosis may arise in several ways: failure to diagnose, failure to inform a patient of a diagnosis, failure to provide proper counseling and treatment when patients test positive for HIV antibodies, and failure to report AIDS diagnoses to health authorities or at-risk sexual partners.

Type
Article
Information
Law, Medicine and Healthcare , Volume 15 , Issue 1-2 , Summer 1987 , pp. 36 - 45
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 1987

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

See, e.g., Trapp v. Metz, 28 N.Y.2d 913, 323 N.Y.S.2d 166, 271 N.E.2d 697 (1971) (admitted negligent diagnosis caused two-year delay in surgery for cancer); Chester v. United States, 403 F. Supp. 458 (W.D. Pa. 1975), aff'd 546 F.2d 415 (3d Cir. 1976) (physician's negligence in failure to order cancer tests permitted metastasis and death).Google Scholar
Roberts, , Treatment of opportunistic infections in patients with acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), in Ma, P, Armstrong, D, eds., The acquired immune deficiency syndrome and infections of homosexual men, 1984: Note 26 at 314–15.Google Scholar
DeVita, V, Hellman, S, Rosenberg, S, AIDS: Etiology, diagnosis, treatment and prevention, 1985: Note 8 at 78–79.Google Scholar
See, e.g., Van Vleet, V. Pfeifle, 289 N.W.2d 781 (N.D. 1980) (negligence of physician in failing to diagnose cancerous condition, thereby hastening and prematurely causing death, is basis for malpractice action, notwithstanding evidence that cancer would eventually have resulted in decedent's death even if cancer had been discovered sooner); Chappel v. Master, 255 So.2d 546 (Fla. 1972) (failure to communicate to prospective adopting parents that child was affected with fatal hydrocephalus held actionable).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Kaplan v. Haines, 96 N.J. Super. 242, 232 A.2d 840 (1967) (alleged erroneous diagnosis of spinal problem as herniated disc resulted in unnecessary operation); Willard v. Huston, 234 Ore. 148, 378 P.2d 966 (1963) (misdiagnosis caused erroneous treatment of child known to be suffering from hemophilia).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Price v. Neyland, 320 F.2d 674 (D.C. Cir. 1983) (malpractice liability for error in diagnosis and treatment of child born of parents with Rh factor blood incompatibility); Iverson v. Lancaster, 158 N.W.2d 507 (N.D. 1969) (alleged unnecessary hysterectomy caused by erroneous diagnosis of cause of high blood pressure is actionable); Lauro v. Travelers Insurance Co., 261 So.2d 261 (La. 1972) (unnecessary removal of breast resulting from misdiagnosis of cancer is actionable).Google Scholar
See Kraus v. Spielbcrg, 37 Misc.2d 29, 236 N.Y.S.2d 143 (1962).Google Scholar
See generally, AIDS anxiety in the “worried well” in Nichols S, Ostrow D, Psychiatric implication of acquired immune deficiency syndrome, 1984: 49–60.Google Scholar
Beadling v. Sirona, 176 A.2d 546 (N.J. 1961).Google Scholar
See generally, Petricciani, , Licensee tests for antibody to human T-lymphotropic virus type III: Sensitivity and specificity, Annals of Internal Medicine 1985, 103: 726–29.Google Scholar
See, e.g., Dowling, V. Mutual Life Insurance Co., 168 So.2d 687 (La. App. 1964) (liability for failure to notify plaintiff that he had tuberculosis); Hoover v. Williamson, 236 Md. 250, 203 A.2d 861 (1964) (failure to notify patient that he had silicosis).Google Scholar
James v. United States, 483 F. Supp. 581 (Cal. 1980).Google Scholar
Illinois AIDS Interdisciplinary Advisory Council, Preliminary report: The challenge of AIDS: The Illinois response, April 16, 1986 (reporting that positive tests have led to depression and suicide in Illinois).Google Scholar
See e.g., Hart v. Warren, 266 S.E.2d 53 (N.C. 1980) (cause of action for wrongful death allowed where evidence showed that the physician examined decedent for only four minutes, injected pain reliever, thus masking symptoms of patient's illness, and failed to make indicated test of serum amylase to detect pancreatitis from which patient ultimately died).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Ala. Code §22-11-4 (1981).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Davis v. Rodman, 227 S.W. 612 (Ark. 1921); Jones v. Stanko, 100 N.E. 456 (Ohio 1928).Google Scholar
Derrick v. Ontario Communiry Hospital, 120 Cal. Rptr. 566 (4th Dist. Ct. of Appeals 1975).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Golai, V. Greater New York Health Insurance Plan, 166 N.Y.S.2d 889 (N.Y. 1957).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Simonsen v. Swenson, 177 N.W. 831 (Neb. 1920).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Pennison v. Provident Life Insurance Co., 154 So.2d 617 (La. 1963); Curry v. Corn, 277 N.Y.2d 470 (N.Y. 1966).Google Scholar
See generally, Miller, et al., Potential liability for transfusion—Association AIDS, Journal of the American Medical Association 1985, 253' 3419.Google Scholar
See, U.C.C. §2–314 (1977).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Del. Code Ann. tit. 6, §2–316 (5) (defining blood and blood plasma as “medical service” and not “commodities or good subject to sale,” thus precluding a claim based on implied warranties that attach to sales).Google Scholar
See, Russell, V. Community Blood Bank, Inc., 185 So.2d 749 (Fla. App. 1967), aff'd and modified, Community Blood Bank, Inc. v. Russell, 196 So.2d 115 (Fla. 1967). See also, Jackson v. Muhlenburg, 53 N.J. 138, 249 A.2d 65 (1969) But see, Brody v. Overlook Hospital, 296 A.2d 392 (N.J. App. 1974), aff'd, 332 A.2d 596 (N.J. 1975) (limiting liability to cases where there is a known test to ascertain presence of blood contaminant).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Belle Bonifils Memorial Blood Bank v. Hanson, 579 P.2d 1158 (Col. 1978); Community Blood Bank, Inc. v. Russell, 196 So.2d 115 (Fla. 1967); Reilly v. King Century Blood Bank, Inc., 6 Wash. App. 172, 492 P.2d 246 (1971).Google Scholar
Cunningham v. MacNeal Memonal Hospital, 47 Ill.2d 443, 266 N.E.2d 987 (1970).Google Scholar
Restatement (Second) of Torts, §402 A comment K (1965).Google Scholar
266 N.E.2d 987 (Ill. 1970).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Brody v. Overlook Hospital, 317 A.2d 392 (N.J. App. 1974). aff'd. 332 A.2d 596 (N.J. 1975).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Hoder v. Sayet, 196 So.2d 205 (Fla. App. 1967); Jackson v. Muhlenberg Hospital, 53 N.J. 138, 249 A.2d 65 (1965); Samuels v. Health & Hospital Corp., 432 F. Supp. 1283 (S.D.N.Y. 1977); Villanea v. Santa Rosa Medical Center, 433 S.W.2d 622 (Tex. Civ. App. 1969).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Martin v. Southern Baptist Hospital, 352 So.2d 357, 354 (2d App. 1977).Google Scholar
Keeton, W, Prosser and Keeton on tons, 1984: 164–65.Google Scholar
Office of Biologics, National Center for Drugs and Biologics, Food and Drug Administration, Recommendations to decrease the risk of transmitting acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) from plasma donors, March 24, 1983.Google Scholar
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (henceforth “MMWR”), March 4, 1982, at 104.Google Scholar
Renslow v. Mennonite Hospital, 67 Ill.2d 348, 367 N.E.2d 1250 (1977).Google Scholar
MMWR, Sept. 27, 1985, at 575.36a. MMWR, May 22, 1987.Google Scholar
See, e.g., Cal. Health & Safety Code §1603 5 (1979); Ga. Code Ann. §85–5501a (1979 & Cum. Supp. 1986); Ill. Rev. Stat. Ch. 111 1/2.Google Scholar
See, e.g., Sloneker v. St. Joseph's Hospital, 233 F. Supp. 105 (D. Cal. 1964); Fischer v. Wilmington General Hospital, 51 Del. 554, 149 A.2d 749 (1959).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Conduit v. Hewitt, 369 P.2d 278 (Wyo. 1962); Tetteus v. Frost, 145 Okla. 273, 292 P. 356 (1930).Google Scholar
Restatement (Second) of Torts, §60 (1965).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Hart v. Geysel, 159 Wash. 632, 294 P. 570 (1930); Dixon v. Samartino 163 S.W. 739 (Tex. Civ. App. 1942).Google Scholar
See, Keeton, , supra note 32, at 123.Google Scholar
McCue v. Klein, 60 Tex. 168, 48 Am. Rep. 260 (1883).Google Scholar
Restatement (Second) of Torts §18, Comment c. See, e.g., Thomas v. Dunne, 131 Col. 20, 279 P.2d 427 (1955) (seating plaintiff on an electrified bench).Google Scholar
Mink v. University of Chicago, 460 F. Supp 713 (N.D. Ill. 1978).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Ware v. Garvey, 139 F. Supp. 71 (D.C. Mass, 1956).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Renslow v. Mennonite Hospital, 67 Ill.2d 348, 10 Ill. Dec. 484, 367 N.E.2d 1250 (1977) (child allowed recovery where child's mother at thirteen was negligently transfused with Rh-positive and subsequently conceived child who suffered prenatal brain damage).Google Scholar
MMWR, Dec. 6, 1985, at 721.Google Scholar
See, e.g., McKelvey v. McKelvey, 111 Tenn. 388, 77 S.W. 664 (1903); Hastings v. Hastings, 33 N.J. 247, 163 A.2d 147 (1961).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Goller v. White, 20 Wis.2d 402, 122 N.W. 193 (1963); Hebel v. Hebel, 435 P.2d 8 (Alaska, 1967); Williams v. Williams, 369 A.2d 669 (Del. 1976). See also, Conn. Gen. Stat. §2–572c (1977); N.C. Gen. Stats. §1–539.21 (1983).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Grodin v. Grodin, 102 Mich. App. 396. 301 N.W.2d 869(1981) (liability on pan of mother taking prescription drugs during pregnancy causing child's teeth to turn brown where mother was not reasonable under all the facts).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Bergrresser v. Mitchell, 577 F.2d 22 (8th Cir. Mo. 1978) (child alleged that as a result of negligence of physician and hospital in performing Caesarean section upon the child's mother several years prior to his birth, his mother suffered a rupture of the uterus, which necessitated his own premature emergency Caesarean delivery, during which he sustained brain damage as a result of oxygen deficiency).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Albala v. City of New York, 78 A.D. 2d 389, 434 N.Y.S.2d 400, aff'd 54 N.Y.2d 269,445 N.Y.S.2d 106, 429 N.E.2d 786 (1981) (prior abortion of mother resulted in perforation of the uterus, subsequently causing brain damage in fetus; nonetheless, unborn child cannot maintain action for negligence occurring prior to infant's conception).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Frankovitch v. Burton, 185 Conn. 14, 20, 440 A.2d 254, 259 (1981) (test of duty found in foreseeability); Brennen v. City of Eugene, 285 Ore. 401, 406, 591 P.2d 719, 722 (1979) (general rule that scope of the duty owed is governed by the concept of foreseeability).Google Scholar
Kathleen, K. v. Robert, B., 150 Cal. App. 3d 992, 997, 198 Cal. Rptr. 273, 276 (1984).Google Scholar
State v. Lankford, 29 Del. (6 Boyce) 594, 102 A. 63 (1917).Google Scholar
29 Del. (6 Boyce) at 594, 102 A. at 64.Google Scholar
See Restatement (Second) of Torts, §525 (1977).Google Scholar
Barbara, A. v. John, G., 145 Cal. App. 3d 369, 193 Cal. Rptr. 422 (1st Dist. 1983).Google Scholar
145 Cal. App. at 378–79, 193 Cal. Rptr. at 429.Google Scholar
See, e.g., Cal. Civ. Code §1710 (West 1973) (providing that deceit is the suppression of a fact by one who is bound to disclose it).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Ala. Code §22-16-17 (1977) (misdemeanor); Col. Rev. Stat. §§25-4-401(2)-407 (1982) (misdemeanor); Del. Code Ann., tit. 16 §§384.01, 03 (1973) (misdemeanor); Idaho Code §39–601, 607 (1977) (misdemeanor); Nev. Rev. Stat §441.290 (1981) (misdemeanor); N.Y. Pub. Health Law §2307 (McKinny 1977) (misdemeanor); Okla. Stat. Ann. tit. 63, §1–519 (1984) (felony); Utah Code Ann. §26-6-5 (Supp. 1983) (misdemeanor). See also, e.g., Reynolds v. State, 49 Okla. Crim. 215, 292 P. 1046 (1920) (affirming a conviction of a man who infected a woman with gonorrhea with a statute making communication of a venereal disease a felony punishable by up to five years in prison).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Panther v. McKnight, 125 Okla. 134, 256 P. 916 (1926) (court recognized private right of action for money damages for conduct in violation of criminal statute proscribing transmission of venereal disease).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Azure v. City of Billings, 182 Mont. 234, 240, 596 P.2d 460, 464 (1979): Bayne v. Todd Shipyards Corp., 88 Wash.2d 917, 918, 568 P.2d 771. 772 (1977).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Gill v. Whiteside—Hemby Drug Co., 197 Ark. 425, 431, 122 S.W.2d 597, 601 (1938) (violation of state law merely evidence of negligence).Google Scholar
See, e.g., HBN 1187 (Georgia) (1-13-86) (includes AIDS in enumeration of venereal diseases); HBN 653 (Idaho) (2-19-86) (provides that AIDS shall be classified as a venereal disease).Google Scholar
See, e.g., N.Y. Pub. Health Law §2311 (McKinney Supp. 1983) (Comm'r of Health); Ore. Rev. Stat. §434.005(3) (1981) (Health Div. of State Dept. of Human Resources); Vt. Stat. Ann. tit. 18, §1091 (1982) (Dept. of Health).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Nev. Rev. Stat. §441.050(1981) (“or any other disease which can be sexually transmitted”); Tenn. Code Ann. §68-10-101 (1983) (“other venereal diseases”); Okla Stat. Ann. tit. 63, §1–517 (West 1984) (“any other disease which may be transmitted from any person to another by sexual intercourse and found and declared by medical science or accredited school of medicine to be infectious or contagious”).Google Scholar
Kathleen, K. v. Robert, B., 150 Cal. App. 3d 992, 997, note 3, 198 Cal. App. 273, 276, note 3 (Cal. App. 2d Dist. 1984).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Cal. Health & Safety Code, §3353 (West 1979).Google Scholar
See, e.g., HB 1685 (Hawaii) (1-16-86) (includes AIDS among infectious and communicable diseases); SBN 825 (Maine) (2-28-86) (classifies AIDS as a dangerous communicable disease); HBN 1922 (Washington) (1-24-86) (classifies AIDS as a communicable or contagious disease).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Cal. Health & Safety Code, §3353 (West 1979) (“any person afflicted with any contagious, infectious or communicable disease who willfully exposes himself … is guilty of a misdemeanor”).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Iowa Code Ann. §139.31.32 (West 1972) (“any person who knowingly exposes another to infection from any communicable disease [is] guilty of a misdemeanor”).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Conn. Gen. Stat. Ann. §466–26 (West Supp. 1984); Fla. Stat. Ann §741.051 (West Supp. 1984); N.J. Stat. Ann. §37.1–9 (West Supp. 1984); N.Y. Dom. Rel. Law §13-a (McKinney Supp. 1983). See also, Note, Pre-marital tests for venereal disease, Harvard Law Review 1931, 53: 309–10 (purpose of premarital venereal test laws to prevent transmission of venereal disease to future spouse and to prospective children).Google Scholar
Restatement (Second) of Torts, §895F at 287–89 (App. 1982).Google Scholar
Restatement (Second) of Torts, §895F (1979).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Windauer v. O'Connor, 107 Ariz. 267, 268, 485 P.2d 1157, 1158 (1971); Apitz v. Darner, 205 Ore. 242, 287 P.2d 585 (1955); Bounds v. Caudle, 560 S.W.2d 925 (Tex. 1977).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Windauer v. O'Connor, 107 Ari. 267, 485 P.2d 1157 (1971); Stoker v. Stoker, §616 P.2d 590 (Utah 1980).Google Scholar
See, e.g., O'Grady v. Potts, 193 Kan. 644, 396 P.2d 285 (1964); Hamilton v. Fulkerson, 285 S.W.2d 642 (Mo. 1955); Pearce v. Boberg, 89 Nev. 266, 510 P.2d 1358 (1973).Google Scholar
See, e.g., N.C. Gen. Stat. §12. 1-20-08 (1976); R.I. Gen. laws §11-6-3 (1956); S.C. Code Ann. §16-15-60 (Law Co-Op 1977); Wisc. Stat. §9214.15 (1981).Google Scholar
See, e.g., N.D. Cent. Code. Code §2. 1-20-12 (1976); Okla. Stat. tit. 21. §886 (1981).Google Scholar
See, e.g., N.Y. Penal Law §255.17 (McKinney 1980); N.C. Gen. Stat. §14–184 (1981); N.D. Cent. Code §12. 1–2009 (1976); Okla. Stat. tit. 21. §872 (1981): R.I. Gen. Law §11-6-2 (1956); S.C. Code Ann. §16-15-60 (Law Co-Op. 1977); Wisc. Stat. §944.15 (1981).Google Scholar
Barbara A. v. John G., 145 Cal. App. 3d 369, 193 Cal. Rptr. 422 (1983); Kathleen K. v. Robert B., 150 Cal. App. 3d 922, 198 Cal. Rptr. 273 (1984).Google Scholar
See, Eisenstadt v. Baird, 405 U.S. 438, 453–55 (1972) (ban on distribution of contraceptives to unmarried persons is unwarranted governmental intrusion into individual's right to privacy); Stanley v. Georgia, 394 U.S. 557, 564 (1969) (law regulating private possession of pornography held unconstitutional; individual has right “to be free, except in very limited circumstances, from unwanted governmental intrusions into privacy”); Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479, 485–86 (1965) (state law prohibiting use of contraceptives by married couples unconstitutionally intrudes on right of marital privacy).Google Scholar
State v. Bateman, 113 Ariz. 107, 547 P.2d 6 (1976) (en banc) offering in part and revising in part, 25 citing Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965) and Eisenstadt v. Baird, 405 U.S. 438 (1972).Google Scholar
Kathleen K. v. Robert B., 150 Cal. App. 3d 992, 198 Cal. Rptr. 273 (2d Dist. 1984).Google Scholar
Cal. Cir. Proc. Code §340 (Deering's 1973).Google Scholar
Cal. Cir. Proc. Code §343 (Deering's 1973).Google Scholar
Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 83 §15 (1966).Google Scholar
Duke v. Housen, 589 P.2d. 334, 339 (Wyo. 1979), reh'g den'd, 590 P.2d 1340 (Wyo. 1979).Google Scholar
See, e.g., Sanchez v. Wade, 514 S.W.2d 812 (Tax Ct. App. 1974); Christian v. Daniel Battey Manufacturing Co., Inc., 279 So.2d 214 (La. Ct. App. 1973); Rankin v. Sowinksi, 119 N.J. Super. 393, 291 A.2d 849 (1972); Matthieu v. Piedmont Natural Jar Co., 269 N.C. 212, 152 S.E.2d 336 (1967).Google Scholar