Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-tn8tq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-30T21:38:42.909Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Unfamiliarity and Procedural Justice: Litigants' Attitudes Toward Civil Justice in Southern China

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Xin He  and
Jing Feng
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

While procedural justice has been regarded as a distinct and essential factor shaping litigants' views on civil justice, few studies have focused on China, a country with a unique legal tradition and frequent legal reforms. Drawing on surveys and interviews with litigants in a basic-level court in Southern China, this study examines attitudes toward the civil justice system. Echoing several existing studies from China, our mixed methods analysis confirms that their views are dominated by outcomes—litigants with favorable outcomes are more likely to be satisfied, while those with unfavorable outcomes are more likely to be dissatisfied. Their unfamiliarity with the operation of the system constitutes a major reason for the dominance of substantive outcomes in their evaluations of the system. Many cannot distinguish between process and outcomes, nor do they feel control over the process. Moreover, they are dissatisfied with the process because it fails to meet their often-erroneous expectations. Our results do not necessarily challenge the importance of procedural justice, but they do suggest that China may be different. Litigants' perceptions of justice and fairness are situated and shaped by specific contexts.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 55 , Issue 1 , March 2021 , pp. 104 - 138
Copyright
© 2021 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The editor and anonymous reviewers of the review provided invaluable suggestions for improvement. We also benefited from comments from Fen Lin, Kwai Hang Ng, and Jianhua Zhu. Lastly, we are grateful for the court officials who helped arrange and the litigants who kindly accepted our interviews.

References

References

Benesh, Sara C. and Howell, Susan E. 2001. “Confidence in the Courts: A Comparison of Users and Non-users.” Behavioral Sciences & the Law 19: 199-214.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berrey, Ellen, Hoffman, Steve G., and Nielsen, Laura Beth. 2012. “Situated Justice: A Contextual Analysis of Fairness and Inequality in Employment Discrimination Litigation.” Law & Society Rev. 46: 1-36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bodde, Derk and Morris, Clarence. 1967. Law in Imperial China: Exemplified by 190 Ch'ing Dynasty Cases: With Historical, Social, and Juridical Commentaries. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Boittin, Margaret L. 2013. “New Perspectives from the Oldest Profession: Abuse and the Legal Consciousness of Sex Workers in China.” Law & Society Rev. 47: 245-78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Casper, Jonathan D., Tyler, Tom, and Fisher, Bonnie. 1988. “Procedural Justice in Felony Cases.” Law & Society Rev. 22: 484-507.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ch'ü, T'ung-tsu. 1961. Law and Society in Traditional China. Paris: Mouton.Google Scholar
Cohen, Jacob, Cohen, Patricia, West, Stephen G., and Aiken, Leona S. 2003. Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.Google Scholar
Creutzfeldt, Naomi and Bradford, Ben. 2016. “Dispute Resolution Outside of Courts: Procedural Justice and Decision Acceptance Among Users of Ombuds Services in the UK.” Law & Society Rev. 50: 985-1016.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Easton, David. 1965. A Systems Analysis of Political Life. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Engel, David and Engel, Jaruwan. 2010. Tort, Custom, and Karma: Globalization and Legal Consciousness in Thailand. Stanford: Stanford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Ewick, Patricia and Silbey, Susan S. 1998. The Common Place of Law: Stories from Everyday Life. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feng, Yuqing and Cao, Qing. 2014. “Popularized Judiciary in Rural China: Paternalistic Approaches and Enchanted Legal Consciousness.” Hong Kong Law J. 44: 651-77.Google Scholar
Friedman, Lawrence M. 2016. Impact. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fu, Hualing and Cullen, Richard. 2011. “From Mediatory to Adjudicatory Justice: The Limits of Civil Justice Reform in China.” In Chinese Justice: Civil Dispute Resolution in Contemporary China, edited by Woo, Margaret Y. K. and Gallagher, Mary E. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Galanter, Marc. 1974. “Why the Haves Come out Ahead: Speculations on the Limits of Legal Change.” Law & Society Rev. 9: 95-160.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallagher, Mary E. 2006. “Mobilizing the Law in China: ‘Informed Disenchantment’ and the Development of Legal Consciousness.” Law & Society Rev. 40: 783-816.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallagher, Mary E. 2017. Authoritarian Legality in China: Law, Workers, and the State. Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallagher, Mary E. and Wang, Yuhua. 2011. “Users and Non-Users: Legal Experience and its Effect on Legal Consciousness.” In Chinese Justice: Civil Dispute Resolution in Contemporary China, edited by Woo, Margaret Y. K. and Gallagher, Mary E. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Garoupa, Nuno and Ginsburg, Tom. 2015. Judicial Reputation: A Comparative Theory. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ginsburg, Tom and Moustafa, Tamir, eds. 2008. Rule by Law: The Politics of Courts in Authoritarian Regimes. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin. 2005. “Why Do They Not Comply with the Law? Illegality and Semi-Legality among Rural-Urban Migrant Entrepreneurs in Beijing.” Law & Society Rev. 39: 527-62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin 2009. “Routinization of Divorce Law Practice in China: Institutional Constraints' Influence on Judicial Behavior.” 23 International J. of Law, Policy and Family 83-109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin 2021. Divorce in China: Institutional Constraints and Gendered Outcomes. New York: NYU Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin and Lin, Fen. 2017. “The Losing Media? An Empirical Study of Defamation Litigation in China.” China Quarterly 230: 371-98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin and Ng, Kwai Hang. 2013. “Inquisitorial Adjudication and Institutional Constraints in Chinese Civil Justice.” Law & Policy 35: 290-318.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin and Ng, Kwai Hang 2017. “‘It Must Be Rock Strong!’ Guanxi's Impact on Judicial Decision Making in China.” American J. of Comparative Law 65: 341-71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin, Wang, Lungang, and Yang, Su. 2013. “Above the Roof, Beneath the Law: Perceived Justice behind Disruptive Tactics of Migrant Wage Claimants in China.” Law & Society Rev. 47: 703-38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin and Xiao, Huina. 2019. “A Typology of Tax Compliance in Developing Economies: Empirical Evidence from China's Shoe Industry.” Law & Policy 41: 242-66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
He, Xin and Yang, Su. 2013. “Do the “Haves” Come Out Ahead in Shanghai Court?” J. of Empirical Legal Studies 10: 120-45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heinz, Anne M. 1985. “Procedure v. Consequences.” In Courts and Criminal Justice, edited by Talarico, S., 13-34.Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
Hu, Li-tze and Bentler, Peter. 1999. “Cutoff Criteria for Fit Indexes in Covariance Structure Analysis: Conventional Criteria Versus New Alternatives.” Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary J. 6: 1-55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huang, Philip C. C. 1996. Civil Justice in China: Representation and Practice in the Qing. Stanford: Stanford Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jenness, Valerie and Calavita, Kitty. 2018. “‘It Depends on the Outcome’: Prisoners, Grievances, and Perceptions of Justice.” Law & Society Rev. 52: 41-72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnson, Devon, Maguire, Edward R., and Kuhns, Joseph B. 2014. “Public Perceptions of the Legitimacy of the Law and Legal Authorities: Evidence from the Caribbean.” Law & Society Rev. 48: 947-78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jonathan-Zamir, Tal, Hasisi, Badi, and Margalioth, Yoram. 2016. “Is It the What or the How? The Roles of High-Policing Tactics and Procedural Justice in Predicting Perceptions of Hostile Treatment: The Case of Security Checks at Ben-Gurion Airport, Israel.” Law & Society Rev. 50: 608-35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kahn, Joseph. 2005. “Deep Flaws, and Little Justice, in China's Court System,” The New York Times, September 21, A1.Google Scholar
Kline, Rex B. 2011. Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling. New York: The Guilford Press.Google Scholar
Kritzer, Herbert M. and Voelker, John. 1998. “Familiarity Breeds Respect: How Wisconsin Citizens View Their Courts.” Judicature 82: 59-65.Google Scholar
Lee, Ching Kwan. 2007. Against the Law: Labor Protests in China's Rustbelt and Sunbelt. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leventhal, Gerald S. 1980. “What Should Be Done with Equity Theory? New Approaches to the Study of Fairness in Social Relationships.” In Social Exchange: Advances in Theory and Research, edited by Gergen, K., Greenberg, M., and Willis, R. New York: Plenum Press.Google Scholar
Li, Ling. 2012. “The “Production” of Corruption in China's Courts: Judicial Politics and Decision Making in a One-Party State.” Law & Social Inquiry 37: 848-77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Li, Yuwen. 2014. The Judicial System and Reform in Post-Mao China: Stumbling Towards Justice. Surrey, UK: Ashgate Publishing.Google Scholar
Li, Yedan, Kocken, Joris, and van Rooij, Benjamin. 2018. “Understanding China's Court Mediation Surge: Insights from a Local Court.” Law & Social Inquiry 43: 58-81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lind, E. Allan, MacCoun, Robert J., Ebener, Patricia A., Felstiner, William L. F., Hensler, Deborah R., Resnik, Judith, and Tyler, Tom R. 1989. The Perception of Justice: Tort Litigants' Views of Trial, Court-Annexed Arbitration, and Judicial Settlement Conferences. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation.Google Scholar
Lind, E. Allan, MacCoun, Robert J., Ebener, Patricia A., Felstiner, William L. F., Hensler, Deborah R., Resnik, Judith, and Tyler, Tom R. 1990. “In the Eye of the Beholder: Tort Litigants' Evaluations of their Experiences in the Civil Justice System.” Law & Society Rev. 24: 953-96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lind, E. Allan and Tyler, Tom R. 1988. The Social Psychology of Procedural Justice. New York: Plenum Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacCoun, Robert J. 2005. “Voice, Control, and Belonging: The Double-Edged Sword of Procedural Fairness.” Annual Rev. of Law and Social Science 171-201.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merry, Sally Engle. 1990. Getting Justice and Getting Even. Chicago, IL: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Michelson, Ethan. 2019. “Decoupling: Marital Violence and the Struggle to Divorce in China.” American J. of Sociology 125: 325-81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Michelson, Ethan and Read, Benjamin L. 2011. “Public Attitudes toward Official Justice in Beijing and Rural China.” In Chinese Justice: Civil Dispute Resolution in Contemporary China, edited by Woo, Margaret Y. K. and Gallagher, Mary E. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
New York Times. 2015. “China's Broken Justice System,” New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/18/.../chinas-broken-justice-system.html (accessed on November 7, 2016).Google Scholar
Ng, Kwai Hang and He, Xin. 2014. “Internal Contradictions in China's Judicial Mediation.” Law & Social Inquiry 39: 282-312.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ng, Kwai Hang and He, Xin 2017. Embedded Courts: Judicial Decision-Making in China. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nielson, Laura Beth. 2000. “Situating Legal Consciousness: Experiences and Attitudes of Ordinary Citizens about Law and Street Harassment.” Law and Society Rev. 34: 1055-90.Google Scholar
O'Barr, William M. and Conley, John M. 1988. “Lay Expectations of the Civil Justice System.” Law & Society Rev. 22: 137-61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ohbuchi, Ken-ichi, Teshigahara, Kazuhiko, Sugawara, Ikuo, and Imazai, Kei-ichiro. 2005. “Procedural Justice and the Assessment of Civil Justice in Japan.” Law & Society Rev. 39: 875-92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Paternoster, Raymond, Brame, Robert, Bachman, Ronet, and Sherman, Lawrence W. 1997. “Do Fair Procedures Matter? The Effect of Procedural Justice on Spouse Assault.” Law & Society Rev. 31: 163-204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Philips, Susan U. 1990. “The Judge as Third Party in American Trial-Court Conflict Talk.” Conflict Talk 197-211.Google Scholar
Pia, Andrea E. 2016. “We Follow Reason, Not the Law: Disavowing the Law in Rural China.” Political and Legal Anthropology Rev. 39: 276-93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rottman, David B. 2015. “Who Trusts the Trial Courts, To What Extent, and Why?” In Motivating Cooperation and Compliance with Authority, edited by Bornstein, Brian H. and Tomkins, Alan J., 117-44.Springer.Google Scholar
Sarat, Austin. 1990. “The Law Is All Over: Power, Resistance, and the Legal Consciousness of the Welfare Poor.” Yale J. of Law and the Humanities 2: 343-79.Google Scholar
Su, Yang and He, Xin. 2010. “Street as Courtroom: State Accommodation of Labor Protest in South China.” Law & Society Rev. 44: 157-84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sunshine, Jason and Tyler, Tom R. 2003. “The Role of Procedural Justice and Legitimacy in Shaping Public Support for Policing.” Law & Society Rev. 37: 513-47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tatlow, Didi. 2016. “Chinese Woman's Mundane Query Turns into Surreal Court Scuffle,” Sinosphere, The New York Times, May 5.Google Scholar
The Supreme People's Court (SPC). 1998. “Several Stipulations on the Adjudicative Proceedings of Civil and Economic Cases,” July 11.Google Scholar
The Supreme People's Court (SPC)(2008. “Notice of the Supreme People's Court on Applying the Provisions on Time Limit for Producing Evidence of the Some Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedures,” December 11.Google Scholar
The Supreme People's Court (SPC)(2019. “The Fifth Five Year Reform Measures.”Google Scholar
Thibaut, John, Friedland, Nehemia, and Walker, Laurens. 1974. “Compliance with Rules: Some Social Determinants.” J. of Personality and Social Psychology 30: 792-801.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thibaut, John and Walker, Laurens. 1975. Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Thompson, Bruce. 2004. Exploratory and Confirmatory Factor Analysis: Understanding Concepts and Applications. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1984. “The Role of Perceived Injustice in Defendants' Evaluations of Their Courtroom Experience.” Law & Society Rev. 18: 51-74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1988. “What Is Procedural Justice? Criteria Used by Citizens to Assess the Fairness of Legal Procedure.” Law & Society Rev. 22: 103-35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1990. Why People Obey the Law. New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 2007. “Procedural Justice and the Courts.” Court Rev. 44: 26-31.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. and Allan Lind, E. 1992. “A Relational Model of Authority in Groups.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 25: 115-91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., Boeckmann, Robert J., Smith, Heather J., and Huo, Yuen J. 1997. Social Justice in a Diverse Society. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., Callahan, Patrick E., and Frost, Jeffrey. 2007. “Armed, and Dangerous? Motivating Rule Adherence among Agents of Social Control.” Law & Society Rev. 41: 457-91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. and Huo, Yuen J. 2002. Trust in the Law, Encouraging Public Cooperation with the Police and Courts. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
van den Bos, Kees, Vermunt, Riel, and Wilke, Henk. 1997. “Procedural and Distributive Justice: What Is Fair Depends More on What Comes First Than on What Comes Next.” J. of Personality and Social Psychology 72: 95-104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker, Laurens, Thibaut, John, and Andreoli, Virginia. 1972. “Order of Presentation at Trial.” Yale Law J. 82: 216-26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wenweipo [文汇报]. 2016. “Beijing Changping Judge Ma Caiyun Killed on Duty [北京昌平法官馬彩雲遭槍擊殉職], ” Wenweipao [文汇报], February 26, 2016.Google Scholar
Woo, Margaret and Wang, Yaxin. 2005. “Civil Justice in China: An Empirical Study of Courts in Three Provinces.” American J. of Comparative Law 53: 911-40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zhang, Mo and Zwier, Paul J. 2002–2003. “Burden of Proof: Developments in Modern Chinese Evidence Rules.” Tulsa J. of Comparative & International Law 10: 419-71.Google Scholar
Zhong, Jianhua and Yu, Guanghua. 2004. “Establishing the Truth on Facts: Has the Chinese Civil Process Achieved This Goal?” J. of Transnational Law and Policy 13: 393-443.Google Scholar

Statutes Cited

The Civil Procedural Law of the PRC, Effective Since 1982, Amended in 1991, 2012.Google Scholar
The State Council. 2006. “The Measures for Taking Litigation Fees,” Issued on December 19, 2006, Implemented on April 1, 2007.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

He and Feng supplementary material
Download undefined(File)
File 23 KB