Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dlnhk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T22:34:16.646Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Trying Something Old: The Impact of Shame Sanctioning on Drunk Driving and Alcohol-Related Traffic Safety

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Lauren C. Porter
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Largely absent from US criminal sentencing since the early 1800s, shame penalties have been staging a comeback. This revival has been met by a number of debates among legal scholars, one of which centers on the potential for such penalties to reduce crime. This study addresses this debate by investigating the impact of formal shaming on drunk driving and alcohol-related traffic safety in Ohio. In accordance with the Traffic Law Reform Act of 2004, judges have since been mandated to issue “restricted plates” to certain first-time and all repeat DUI offenders with limited driving privileges. Results indicate a curvilinear association between punishment levels and drunk driving. Increases in the certainty and visibility of plates are associated with decreases in suspension rates, but there is a point at which increasing the punishment level no longer retains its intended impact. In addition, levels of punishment are unrelated to alcohol-related traffic safety.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 38 , Issue 4 , Fall 2013 , pp. 863 - 891
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References

Allison, Paul D. 2002. Missing Data. Sage University Paper Series: Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, 07‐136 . Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Allison, Paul D. 2006. Fixed Effects Regression Methods in SAS. Paper 184‐31. SAS Institute Inc.Google Scholar
Anselin, L. 2001. Spatial Econometrics. In A Companion to Theoretical Econometrics, ed. Baltagi, B. H. Malden, MA: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Anselin, L., and Bera, A. K. 1998. Spatial Dependence in Linear Regression Models with an Introduction to Spatial Econometrics. In Handbook of Applied Economic Statistics, eds. Ullah, A. and Giles, D. A., 237–289. New York: Marcel Dekker.Google Scholar
Baum, Christopher F. 2006. An Introduction to Modern EconometricsUusing Stata. College Station, TX: Stata Press.Google Scholar
Beccaria, Cesare. [1764] 1995. On Crimes and Punishments. In Beccaria: “On Crimes and Punishments” and Other Writings, ed. Bellamy, Richard, trans. Richard Davies. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Becker, Gary S. 1963. Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach. Journal of Political Economy 76:169–217.Google Scholar
Beckett, Katherine, and Herbert, Steve. 2010. Banished: The New Social Control in Urban America. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Bentham, Jeremy. 1781. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Berger, Dale E., and Marelich, William D. 1997. Legal and Social Control of Alcohol‐Impaired Driving in California: 1983–1994. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 58:518–523.Google Scholar
Bhattarai, Abha. 2011. Is Posting Mug Shots on Facebook a Good Idea? Post User Polls, Washington Post, January 18, 2011. http://views.washingtonpost.com/post‐user‐polls/2011/01/is‐posting‐dui‐mug‐shots‐on‐facebook‐a‐good‐idea.html?hpid=talkbox1 (accessed January 29, 2011).Google Scholar
Book, Aaron. 1999. Shame on You: An Analysis of Modern Shame Punishment as an Alternative to Incarceration. William and Mary Law Review 40:653–686.Google Scholar
Braithwaite, John. 1989. Crime, Shame, and Reintegration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Breusch, Trevor S., and Pagan, Adrian R., 1979. Simple Test for Heteroscedasticity and Random Coefficient Variation. Econometrica, 47:1287–1294.Google Scholar
Chapin, Bradley. 1983. Criminal Justice in Colonial America, 1606–1660. Athens: University of Georgia Press.Google Scholar
Cook, Philip. 1980. Punishment and Crime: A Critique of Current Findings Concerning the Preventative Effects of Punishment. In The Economics of Crime, eds. Andreano, Ralph and Siegfried, John J. New York: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
Crowder, Kyle, and South, Scott J. 2008. Spatial Dynamics of White Flight: The Effects of Local and Extralocal Racial Conditions on Neighborhood Out‐Migration. American Sociological Review 73:792–812.Google Scholar
Dau‐Schmidt, Kenneth G. 1990. An Economic Analysis of the Criminal Law as a Preference‐Shaping Policy. Duke Law Journal 1:1–38.Google Scholar
Deane, Glenn, Messner, Steven F., Stucky, Thomas D., McGeever, Kelly, and Kurbrin, Charis E. 2008. Not “Islands, Entire of Themselves”: Exploring the Spatial Context of City‐Level Robbery Rates. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 24:363–380.Google Scholar
Diroll, David. 2005. Traffic Law Primer Under S.B. 123, H.B. 52, & H.B. 163. Columbus, OH: Ohio Criminal Sentencing Commission, Columbus OH. http://www.hamilton‐co.org/municipalcourt/Outlines/Traffic_Primer_SB123_010105.pdf (accessed May 12, 2009).Google Scholar
Downey, Liam. 2006. Using Geographic Information Systems to Reconceptualize Spatial Relationships and Ecological Context. American Journal of Sociology 112:567–612.Google Scholar
Drukker, David M. 2003. Testing for Serial Correlation in Panel‐Data Models. Stata Journal 3:168–177.Google Scholar
Dyer, Bob. 2009. DUI Plates Are Another Ohio Flop. Beacon Journal, June 19.Google Scholar
Feehan, Jennifer. 2004. DUI “Shame Plates” Used as Scarlet Letters on Offenders’ Bumpers. Toledo Times, November 7. http://www.toledoblade.com/frontpage/2004/11/07/DUI‐shame‐plates‐used‐as‐scarlet‐letters‐on‐offenders‐bumpers.html (accessed February 10, 2012).Google Scholar
Finkel, Steven E. 1995. Causal Analysis with Panel Data. Sage University Paper Series on Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, 07‐015 . Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Gehm, Theodor L., and Scherer, Klaus R. 1988. Relating Situation Evaluation to Emotion Differentiation: Non‐Metric Analysis of Cross‐Cultural Questionnaire Data. In Facets of Emotion: Recent Research, ed. Scherer, Klaus R. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Gibbs, Jack P., and Firebaugh, Glenn. 1990. The Artifact Issue in Deterrence Research. Criminology 28:347–364.Google Scholar
Gogoi, Pallavi. 2007. Shame and Shoplifting at Wal‐Mart: Alabama Judge's Unusual Punishment Highlights “Shrinkage” Problem. Bloomberg Businessweek on msnbc.com. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/19957110/ns/business‐bloomberg_businessweek/ (accessed December 1, 2010).Google Scholar
Grasmick, Harold G., and Bursik, Robert J. 1990. Conscience, Significant Others, and Rational Choice: Extending the Deterrence Model. Law & Society Review 24:837–861.Google Scholar
Grasmick, Harold G., Bursik, Robert J. Jr., and Arneklev, Bruce J. 1993. Reduction in Drunk Driving as a Response to Increased Threats of Shame, Embarrassment, and Legal Sanctions. Criminology 31:41–67.Google Scholar
Grasmick, Harold G., and Kobayashi, Emiko. 2002. Workplace Deviance in Japan: Applying an Extended Model of Deterrence. Deviant Behavior 23:21–43.Google Scholar
Hansen, Lars P. 1982. Large Sample Properties of Generalized Method of Moments Estimators. Econometrica 50:1029–1054.Google Scholar
Harel, Alon, and Klement, Alon. 2007. The Economics of Stigma: Why More Detection of Crime May Result in Less Stigmatization. Journal of Legal Studies 36:355–377.Google Scholar
Harvard Law Review. 2003. Note: Shame, Stigma, and Crime: Evaluating the Efficacy of Shaming Sanctions in Criminal Law. Harvard Law Review 16:2186–2207.Google Scholar
Hausman, Jerry A. 1978. Specification Tests in Econometrics. Econometrica 46:1251–1271.Google Scholar
Homel, Ross. 1988. Policing and Punishing the Drinking Driver: A Study of General and Specific Deterrence. Springer‐Verlag.Google Scholar
Huschka, Ryan J. 2006. A Critical Analysis of the Constitutionality of Contemporary Shame Punishments. Kansas Law Review 54:803–836.Google Scholar
Kahan, Dan M. 1996. What Do Alternative Sanctions Mean? University of Chicago Law Review 63:591–653.Google Scholar
Kahan, Dan M. 2000. Gentle Nudges vs. Hard Shoves: Solving the Sticky Norms Problem. University of Chicago Law Review 67:607–645.Google Scholar
Kahan, Dan M. 2005. What's Really Wrong with Shaming Sanctions. Texas Law Review 84:2075–2095.Google Scholar
Kahan, Dan M., and Posner, Eric A. 1999. Shaming White‐Collar Criminals: A Proposal for Reform of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines. Journal of Law and Economics 42:365–392.Google Scholar
Kenkel, Donald S. 1993. Drinking, Driving, and Deterrence: The Effectiveness and Social Costs of Alternative Policies. Journal of Law and Economics 36:877–913.Google Scholar
Kmet, Leanne, and Macarthur, Colin. 2006. Urban‐Rural Differences in Motor Vehicle Crash Fatality and Hospitalization Rates Among Children and Youth. Accident Analysis & Prevention 38:122–127.Google Scholar
Leuven, Edwin, and Sianesi, Barbara. 2003. PSMATCH2: Stata Module to Perform Full Mahalanobis and Propensity Score Matching, Common Support Graphing, and Covariate Imbalance Testing. Boston, MA: Boston College Department of Economics, Statistical Software Components. http://ideas.repec.org/c/boc/bocode/s432001.html (accessed June 10, 2011).Google Scholar
Logan, Charles H. 1982. Problems in Ratio Correlation: The Case of Deterrence Research. Social Forces 60:791–810.Google Scholar
Markowitz, Fred E., Bellair, Paul E., and Liska, Allen E. 2001. Extending Social Disorganization Theory: Modeling the Relationships between Cohesion, Disorder, and Fear. Criminology 39:293–320.Google Scholar
Marvell, Thomas A., and Moody, Carlisle E. 1996. Specification Problems, Police Levels, and Crime Rates. Criminology 34:609–646.Google Scholar
Massaro, Toni M. 1997. The Meanings of Shame: Implications for Legal Reform. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 3:645–704.Google Scholar
Moran, P. A. P. 1950. Notes on Continuous Stochastic Phenomena. Biometrika 37:17–23.Google Scholar
Muelleman, Robert, and Mueller, Keith. 1996. “Fatal Motor Vehicle Crashes: Variations of Crash Characteristics Within Rural Regions of Different Population Densities.” Journal of Trauma‐Injury Infection & Critical Care 41:315–320.Google Scholar
Murray, Michael P. 2006. Avoiding Invalid Instruments and Coping with Weak Instruments. Journal of Economic Perspectives 20:111–132.Google Scholar
Nagin, Daniel S. 1998. Criminal Deterrence Research at the Outset of the Twenty‐First Century. In Crime and Justice: A Review of Research, ed. Tonry, Michael, vol. 23. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Nagin, Daniel S., and Pogarsky, Greg. 2001. Integrating Celerity, Impulsivity, and Extralegal Sanction Threats into a Model of General Deterrence: Theory and Evidence. Criminology 39:865–891.Google Scholar
National Commission Against Drunk Driving. 1985. A Progress Report on the Implementation of Recommendations by the Presidential Commission on Drunk Driving (Grant No. DOT HS‐806‐885) . Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.Google Scholar
O'Brien, Soledad, and O'Brien, Miles. 2006. Deadly Texas Wildfires; Bush's Approval Ratings Dips; Judge Considers Mistrial in Moussaoui Case [television transcript]. CNN News: American Morning, March 14. http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0603/14/ltm.07.html (accessed May 12, 2009).Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Alcohol and Drug Addiction Services. 2002–2007. Unique Clients by County of Residence, 2002–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Alcohol and Drug Addiction Services.Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Commerce: Division of Liquor Control. 2003–2007. Bottles of Liquor Sold by County, 2003–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Commerce: Division of Liquor Control.Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Public Safety. 2002–2007a. Active License Suspensions by County, 2002–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Public Safety.Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Public Safety. 2002–2007b. Age and Sex Distributions for Licensed Drivers, 2002–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Public Safety.Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Public Safety. 2002–2007c. Alcohol‐Related Crashes by County, 2002–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Public Safety.Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Public Safety. 2002–2007d. DUI Profile by County, 2002–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Public Safety.Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Public Safety. 2002–2007e. Special Plate Report: ORG Code Monthly Sales by County. ORG Code: 993—Family Plates, 2002–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Public Safety.Google Scholar
Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections. 2003–2007. Columbus, OH: Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections.Google Scholar
O'Rourke, Patricia. 2004. Ohio Driving Under the Influence Special License Plates. Research Report 2004‐R‐0115 . Hartford, CT: Office of Legislative Research, Connecticut General Assembly.Google Scholar
Peters, Victoria J., Oetting, E. R., and Edwards, Ruth W. 1992. Drug Use in Rural Communities: An Epidemiology. In Drug Use in Rural American Communities, ed. Edwards, Ruth W. New York: Haworth Press.Google Scholar
Posner, Eric A. 2002. Law and Social Norms. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Pratt, Travis C., Cullen, Francis T., Blevins, Kristie R., Daigle, Leah E., and Madensen, Tamara D. 2008 The Empirical Status of Deterrence Theory: A Meta‐Analysis. In Taking Stock: The Status of Criminological Theory, eds. Cullen, Francis T., Wright, John P., and Blevins, Kristie R., 367–395. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar
Reschovsky, Clara. 2004. Journey to Work: 2000. Washington, DC: US Bureau of the Census.Google Scholar
Schur, Edwin M. 1971. Labeling Deviant Behavior. Englewood‐Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
Smith, Richard H., Webster, Matthew, Parrot, W. Gerrod, and Eyre, Heidi L. 2002. The Role of Public Exposure in Moral and Nonmoral Shame and Guilt. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83:138–159.Google Scholar
Sullivan, Lucas. 2008. DUI Plates Seldom Used on Drunk Drivers. Dayton Daily News, October 1, A1 Google Scholar
Taxman, Faye S., and Piquero, Alex. 1998. On Preventing Drunk Driving Recidivism: An Examination of Rehabilitation and Punishment Approaches. Journal of Criminal Justice 26:129–143.Google Scholar
US Bureau of the Census. 2000. Census of Population and Housing. Table 1: Annual Estimates of the Resident Population for Counties of Ohio: April 1, 2000 to July 1, 2008 (CO‐EST2008‐01‐39) . Washington, DC: US Bureau of the Census.Google Scholar
US Department of Justice. 2001–2006. Uniform Crime Reports: County Level Arrest and Offense Data. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation.Google Scholar
Watkins, Thomas. 2011. City Considers Posting DUI Mug Shots on Facebook. Associated Press, January 18. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/01/18/dui‐mug‐shots‐facebook_n_810180.html (accessed January 29, 2011).Google Scholar
Weisheit, Ralph A., and Donnermeyer, Joseph. 2000. Change and Continuity in Crime in Rural America. Criminal Justice 1:309–357.Google Scholar
Weisheit, Ralph A., Wells, L. Edward, and Falcone, David N. 1995. Crime and Policing in Rural and Small Town America: An Overview of Issues. NIJ Research Report Series . Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.Google Scholar
Whitman, James Q. 1998. What Is Wrong with Inflicting Shame Sanctions? Yale Law Journal 107:1055–1092.Google Scholar
Whitman, James Q. 2003. Harsh Justice: Criminal Punishment and the Widening Divide Between America and Europe. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Williams, Kirk R., and Hawkins, Richard. 1989. The Meaning of Wife Assault. Criminology 27:163–181.Google Scholar
Wooldridge, Jeffrey M. 2002. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Zimmerman, Gregory M. 2008. Beyond Legal Sanctions: The Correlates of Self‐Imposed and Socially Imposed Extralegal Risk Perceptions. Deviant Behavior 29:157–190.Google Scholar

Cases Cited

Paul v. Davis , 424 US 693 (1976).Google Scholar

Statutes Cited

Traffic Law Reform Act of 2004, Ohio Revised Code: 4503.231, Sec. A.Google Scholar