Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-ndw9j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T12:45:00.273Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Flipping the “New Penology” Script: Police Misconduct Insurance, Grassroots Activism, and Risk Management–Based Reform

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 December 2021

Abstract

Through a multi-method qualitative case study, I examine the failed 2016 ballot campaign of the Committee for Professional Policing (CfPP), a police accountability group in Minneapolis, Minnesota. In attempting to make Minneapolis the first city nationwide to require police to carry professional liability insurance, the CfPP turned the logic of Malcolm M. Feeley and Jonathan Simon’s “new penology” paradigm onto police. Their thesis argues that a contemporary penal shift occurred away from rehabilitation toward managing aggregates of dangerous criminal categories through risk management approaches. I extend their thesis in a new direction by examining how—in the emerging age of “algorithmic risk governance”—social movement organizations, like the CfPP, are starting to invert the new penology onto criminal justice personnel. In flipping the script, the CfPP called for a new private insurance market using mandatory police misconduct insurance to manage aggregates of dangerous police officers. After highlighting how the CfPP developed new penological objectives, discourses, and technologies, I discuss the implications of grassroots groups adopting and redefining traditional penal logics and propose future research avenues.

Type
Articles
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the American Bar Foundation

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

This study received funding support from the University of Minnesota’s Interdisciplinary Doctoral Fellowship and Doctoral Dissertation Fellowship programs and received initial Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval on December 29, 2015 and subsequent annual IRB renewal. I thank Malcolm M. Feeley, Edward G. Goetz, Philip Goodman, Veronica Horowitz, Ethan Johnson, Stephen Rushin, Christopher W. Schmidt, Joanna C. Schwartz, Jonathan Simon, Christopher Uggen, and Robert Werth for their supportive and helpful feedback and Stacy Belden, Andrew Martineau, Breck Radulovic, Willa Sachs, and Scott Uhl for editing and research assistance.

References

REFERENCES

Archbold, Carol A. 2004. Police Accountability, Risk Management, and Legal Advising. New York: LFB Scholarly Publishing.Google Scholar
Archbold, Carol A. 2005. “Managing the Bottom Line: Risk Management in Policing.Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management 28, no. 1: 3048.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Armacost, Barbara E. 2004. “Organizational Culture and Police Misconduct.George Washington Law Review 72, no. 3: 453546.Google Scholar
Aviram, Hadar. 2010. “Humonetarianism: The New Correctional Discourse of Scarcity.Hastings Race and Poverty Law Journal 7, no. 1: 152.Google Scholar
Aviram, Hadar 2015. Cheap on Crime: Recession-Era Politics and the Transformation of American Punishment. Oakland: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aviram, Hadar, and Ryan, Newby. 2013. “Death Row Economics: The Rise of Fiscally Prudent Anti-Death Penalty Activism.Criminal Justice 28, no. 1: 3340.Google Scholar
Baker, Tom, and Jonathan, Simon. 2002. “Embracing Risk.” In Embracing Risk: The Changing Culture of Insurance and Responsibility, edited by Baker, Tom and Simon, Jonathan, 125. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Balko, Radley. 2016. “How the Insurance Industry Could Reform American Policing.” Washington Post, March 1. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2016/03/01/how-the-insurance-industry-could-reform-american-policing/.Google Scholar
Barlyn, Suzanne, and Alwyn, Scott. 2020. “Insurers Exploring ‘New World’ of Police Officer Professional Liability.” Insurance Journal, July 24. https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2020/07/24/576789.htm?fbclid=IwAR2VvT-To17pK2pdhIWS_8sb_Xk0KBVKFdNzIZx9G9h6hKgcjSLvd8PVtkY.Google Scholar
BBC News. 2021. “Breonna Taylor: Inquiry Launched into Louisville Police Department.” April 26. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-56894831.Google Scholar
Berman, Russell. 2020. “The State Where Protests Have Already Forced Major Police Reform.” The Atlantic, July 17. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/07/police-reform-law-colorado/614269/.Google Scholar
Bogel-Burroughs, Nicholas, and John, Eligon. 2021. “George Floyd’s Family Settles Suit against Minneapolis for $27 Million.” New York Times, March 12 [updated March 30]. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/12/us/george-floyd-minneapolis-settlement.html.Google Scholar
Bronson, Caitlin. 2016. “Can Mandatory Insurance Solve the Problem of Police Violence?” Insurance Business Magazine, June 28. https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/breaking-news/can-mandatory-insurance-solve-the-problem-of-police-violence-34030.aspx.Google Scholar
Brown, Wendy. 2015. Undoing the Demos: Neoliberalism’s Stealth Revolution. New York: Zone Books.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2013a. “CfPP Advisory Board Convening.” September 12 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2013b. “CfPP 6-10-13 Flyer Double Sided Half Sheet.” June 10 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2013c. “Position on Requiring Police Officer Professional Liability Coverage.” August 5. https://cfppmpls.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/position-paper-on-police-professional-liability-insurance.pdf.Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2014. “Charter Amendment for Police Liability Coverage Petition.” April 12 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016a. “CfPP Legal Thoughts on 8-19-16 Reply Brief.” August 19 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016b. “CfPP Media Session Agenda.” May 20 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016c. “History-Making Police Insurance Amendment Petition to Be Submitted.” May 31 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016d. “Letter to City Council.” July 26 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016e. “MN Supreme Court Gets It Dead Wrong!” August 31 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016f. “Office of the State Auditor Complaint.” August 5 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016g. “PIA City Council Presentation.” August 3 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016h. “PIA PCOC Presentation.” June 14 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016i. “Police Insurance Amendment Proponents Dispute Ruling, Plan Appeal.” August 22 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016j. “Press Conference: Court Hearing on Lawsuit to Get Police Insurance Amendment on the Ballot.” August 11 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016k. “Press Conference: Proponents of Police Insurance Amendment File Lawsuit to Get on the Ballot.” August 4 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016l. “Segal Legal Opinion on Police Insurance Amendment Is Absolutely Wrong.” July 29 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016m. “Support the PIA Half Sheet.” July 21 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2016n. “Volunteer Recruitment Flyer Corrected.” April 16 (on file with author).Google Scholar
CfPP (Committee for Professional Policing). 2018. “Home.” Accessed February 23. https://cfppmpls.wordpress.com/.Google Scholar
Cheh, Mary M. 1996. “Are Lawsuits an Answer to Police Brutality?” In Police Violence: Understanding and Controlling Police Abuse of Force, edited by William, A. Geller and Toch, Hans, 247–72. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Cheliotis, Leonidas K. 2006. “How Iron Is the Iron Cage of New Penology? The Role of Human Agency in the Implementation of Criminal Justice Policy.Punishment & Society 8, no. 3: 313–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clear, Todd R., and Natasha, A. Frost. 2015. The Punishment Imperative: The Rise and Failure of Mass Incarceration in America. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Coleman, Aaron Ross. 2020. “Police Reform, Defunding, and Abolition, Explained.” Vox, July 16. https://www.vox.com/21312191/police-reform-defunding-abolition-black-lives-matter-protests.Google Scholar
Coleman, Roy, and Joe, Sim. 2005. “Contemporary Statecraft and the ‘Punitive Obsession’: A Critique of the New Penology.” In The New Punitiveness: Trends, Theories, Perspectives, edited by Pratt, John, Brown, David, Brown, Mark, Hallsworth, Simon, and Morrison, Wayne, 101–18. Devon, UK: Willan Publishing.Google Scholar
CRA (Civilian Review Authority). 2002. “Guiding Principles for Police Oversight Reform.” March (on file with author).Google Scholar
CUAPB (Communities United against Police Brutality). 2021. “Who We Are.” Accessed October 5. http://www.cuapb.org/who_we_are.Google Scholar
Dagan, David, and Teles, Steven M.. 2016. Prison Break: Why Conservatives Turned against Mass Incarceration. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Du, Susan. 2016. “Group Wants Minneapolis Police to Carry Liability Insurance.” City Pages, April 7. http://web.archive.org/web/20160408222554/http://www.citypages.com/news/group-wants-minneapolis-police-to-carry-liability-insurance-8182566.Google Scholar
Dukmasova, Maya. 2018. “Should Chicago Cops Have to Pay for Their Own Misconduct Insurance?” Chicago Reader, June 29. https://chicagoreader.com/blogs/should-chicago-cops-have-to-pay-for-their-own-misconduct-insurance/.Google Scholar
Elinson, Zusha, and Dan, Frosch. 2015. “Cost of Police-Misconduct Cases Soars in Big U.S. Cities.” Wall Street Journal, July 15. https://www.wsj.com/articles/cost-of-police-misconduct-cases-soars-in-big-u-s-cities-1437013834.Google Scholar
Elliott, Michael W. 2017. “Big Data Analytics: Changing the Calculus of Insurance.” National Association of Insurance Commissioners, November. https://www.naic.org/cipr_newsletter_archive/vol23_big_data.pdf?96.Google Scholar
Epp, Charles R. 2009. Making Rights Real: Activists, Bureaucrats, and the Creation of the Legalistic State. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ericson, Richard V., Aaron, Doyle, and Dean, Barry. 2003. Insurance as Governance. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Ericson, Richard V., and Haggerty, Kevin D.. 1997. Policing the Risk Society. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Federal Mediation Now. 2003. “Federal Mediation Demands.” January 3 (on file with author).Google Scholar
Feeley, Malcolm M., and Simon, Jonathan. 1992. “The New Penology: Notes on the Emerging Strategy of Corrections and Its Implications.Criminology 30, no. 4: 449–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feeley, Malcolm M., and Simon, Jonathan 1994. “Actuarial Justice: The Emerging New Criminal Law.” In The Futures of Criminology, edited by Nelken, David, 173201. London: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
Forliti, Amy, and Mohamed, Imbrahim. 2020. “Minneapolis Police Reform Plan Would Require Insurance for Officers.” Associated Press, June 8. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/minneapolis-police-reform-plan-would-require-insurance-for-officers.Google Scholar
Foucault, Michel. 1977. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. Trans. Sheridan, Alan, New York: Second Vintage Books/Random House.Google Scholar
Goodman, Philip, Joshua, Page, and Michelle, Phelps. 2017. Breaking the Pendulum: The Long Struggle over Criminal Justice. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodwin, Alyxandra, Whitney, Shepard, and Carrie, Sloan. 2018. “Police Brutality Bonds: How Wall Street Profits from Police Violence.” Action Center on Race and the Economy, June. http://nathancummings.org/wp-content/uploads/PoliceBrutalityBonds-Jun2018-1.pdf.Google Scholar
Goodwin, Alyxandra, Whitney, Shepard, and Carrie, Sloan 2020. “Police Brutality Bonds: How Wall Street Profits from Police Violence.” Action Center on Race and the Economy, June. https://acrecampaigns.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/ACRE_PBB_2020_2.pdf.Google Scholar
Hannah-Moffat, Kelly. 2019. “Algorithmic Risk Governance: Big Data Analytics, Race and Information Activism in Criminal Justice Debates.Theoretical Criminology 23, no. 4: 453–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harris, Alexes. 2016. A Pound of Flesh: Monetary Sanctions as Punishment for the Poor. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Harris, Christopher J. 2010. Pathways of Police Misconduct: Problem Behavior Patterns and Trajectories from Two Cohorts. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.Google Scholar
Jackson, Darrell D. 2017. “Profiling the Police: Flipping 20 Years of Whren on Its Head,” University of Missouri Kansas City Law Review 85, no. 3: 671–96.Google Scholar
Kappeler, Victor E. 2006. Critical Issues in Police Civil Liability. 4th ed. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press.Google Scholar
Kaste, Martin. 2016. “To Change Police Practices, A Push for Liability Insurance in Minneapolis.” NPR: All Things Considered, June 27. http://www.npr.org/2016/06/27/483420607/to-stop-police-lawsuits-reformers-want-officers-to-get-insurance.Google Scholar
Levenson, Laurie L. 1993. “The Future of State and Federal Civil Rights Prosecutions: The Lessons of the Rodney King Trial.University of California Los Angeles Law Review 41, no. 3: 509608.Google Scholar
Lynch, Mona. 1998. “Waste Managers? The New Penology, Crime Fighting, and Parole Agent Identity.Law and Society Review 32, no. 4: 839–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mac Donald, Heather. 2016. The War on Cops: How the New Attack on Law and Order Makes Everyone Less Safe. New York: Encounter Books.Google Scholar
Mastrofski, Stephen D., and Willis, James J.. 2010. “Police Organization Continuity and Change: into the Twenty-First Century.Crime and Justice 39, no. 1: 55144.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maurutto, Paula, and Kelly, Hannah-Moffat. 2006. “Assembling Risk and the Restructuring of Penal Control.British Journal of Criminology 46, no. 3: 438–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McCoy, Candace. 2010. “How Civil Rights Lawsuits Improve American Policing.” In Holding Police Accountable, edited by McCoy, Candace, 111–60. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.Google Scholar
Michels, James P. 2016. “RE: Proposed Charter Amendment for Police Liability Insurance.” Rice, Michels & Walther LLP, June 10 (on file with author).Google Scholar
Morin, Rich, Kim, Parker, Renee, Stepler, and Andrew, Merer. 2017. “Behind the Badge: Amid Protests and Calls for Reform, How Police View Their Jobs, Key Issues and Recent Fatal Encounters between Blacks and Police.” Pew Research Center, January. https://assets.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2017/01/06171402/Police-Report_FINAL_web.pdf.Google Scholar
Muhammad, Raychelle. 2018 “Alton Sterling May Only Get Justice by Way of a Financial Settlement Like Every Other Black Family.” Inquisitr, March 31. https://web.archive.org/web/20180331235836/https://www.inquisitr.com/opinion/4848810/alton-sterling-may-only-get-justice-by-way-of-a-financial-settlement-like-every-other-black-family/.Google Scholar
Murphy, Carla. 2016. “A Push to Make Cops Carry Liability Insurance in Minneapolis.” Chicago Reader, June 27. http://chicagoreporter.com/a-push-to-make-cops-buy-liability-insurance-in-minneapolis/.Google Scholar
Neily, Clark. 2018. “Make Cops Carry Liability Insurance: The Private Sector Knows How to Spread Risks, and Costs.” New York Daily News, March 29. https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/cops-carry-liability-insurance-article-1.3901990.Google Scholar
Newman, Jonah. 2016. “Police Liability Insurance Ordinance Introduced to Chicago City Council.” Chicago Reporter, September 20. http://www.chicagoreporter.com/police-liability-insurance-ordinance-introduced-to-chicago-city-council/.Google Scholar
Norwood, Candice, and Daniel, Bush. 2020. “What a Biden Administration Could Mean for Criminal Justice Reform.” PBS NewsHour, December 14. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/what-a-biden-administration-could-mean-for-criminal-justice-reform.Google Scholar
Novak, Kenneth J., Smith, Brad W., and James, Frank. 2003. “Strange Bedfellows: Civil Liability and Aggressive Policing.Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management 26, no. 2: 352–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
O’Malley, Pat. 2008. “Experiments in Risk and Criminal Justice.Theoretical Criminology 12, no. 4: 451–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Otu, Noel. 2006. “The Police Service and Liability Insurance: Responsible Policing.International Journal of Police Science and Management 8, no. 4: 294315.Google Scholar
Page, Joshua. 2013. “Punishment and the Penal Field.” In The Sage Handbook of Punishment and Society, edited by Simon, Jonathan and Sparks, Richard, 152–66. London: Sage Publications.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Patton, Alison L. 1993. “The Endless Cycle of Abuse: Why 42 U.S.C. 1983 Is Ineffective in Deterring Police Brutality.Hastings Law Journal 44, no. 3: 753808.Google Scholar
Police Conduct Oversight Commission. 2021. “About.” Accessed October 6. https://lims.minneapolismn.gov/boards/PCOC.Google Scholar
President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. 2015. “Final Report of the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing.” Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services. https://cops.usdoj.gov/pdf/taskforce/taskforce_finalreport.pdf.Google Scholar
Ramirez, Deborah, Marcus, Wraight, Lauren, Kilmister, and Carly, Perkins. 2019. “Policing the Police: Could Mandatory Professional Liability Insurance for Officers Provide a New Accountability Model.American Journal of Criminal Law 45, no. 2: 407–60.Google Scholar
Ramirez, Mark D. 2013. “Americans’ Changing Views on Crime and Punishment.Public Opinion Quarterly 77, no. 4: 1006–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rappaport, John. 2016. “An Insurance-Based Typology of Police Misconduct.University of Chicago Legal Forum 2016: 369405.Google Scholar
Rappaport, John 2017. “How Private Insurers Regulate Public Police.Harvard Law Review 130, no. 6: 15391614.Google Scholar
Ross, Darrell L., and Bodapati, Madhava R.. 2006. “A Risk Management Analysis of the Claims, Litigation, and Losses of Michigan Law Enforcement Agencies: 1985–1999.Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management 29, no. 1: 3857.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rothschild-Elyassi, Gil, Johann, Koehler, and Jonathan, Simon. 2019. “Actuarial Justice.” In The Handbook of Social Control, edited by Deflem, Mathieu, 194206. Oxford: John Wiley & Sons.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rozema, Kyle, and Max, Schanzenbach. 2019. “Good Cop, Bad Cop: Using Civilian Allegations to Predict Police Misconduct.American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 11, no. 2: 225–68.Google Scholar
Rushin, Stephen. 2017a. Federal Intervention in American Police Departments. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rushin, Stephen 2017b. “Police Union Contracts.Duke Law Journal 66, no. 6: 11911266.Google Scholar
Schwartz, Joanna C. 2014. “Police Indemnification.New York University Law Review 89, no. 3: 8851005.Google Scholar
Schwartz, Joanna C. 2016. “How Governments Pay: Lawsuits, Budgets, and Police Reform.University of California Los Angeles Law Review 63, no. 5: 11441299.Google Scholar
Segal, Susan L., Susan, Trammell, Trina, Chernos, and Burt, Osborne. 2016. “Charter Amendment Petition Regarding Police Liability Insurance Requirement.” Office of the Minneapolis City Attorney, July 28. https://kstp.com/kstpImages/repository/cs/files/Police%20Liability%20Insurance%20Opinion%207_28_16.pdf.Google Scholar
Simon, Jonathan, and Feeley, Malcolm M.. 2003. “The Form and Limits of the New Penology.” In Punishment and Social Control, edited by Thomas, G. Blomberg and Cohen, Stanley, 75116. 2nd ed. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Stephens, Darrel W. 2011. Police Discipline: A Case for Change. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice. https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/234052.pdf.Google Scholar
Stone, Deborah. 2002. “Beyond Moral Hazard: Insurance as Moral Opportunity.” In Embracing Risk: The Changing Culture of Insurance and Responsibility, edited by Baker, Tom and Simon, Jonathan, 5279. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
US DOJ (US Department of Justice). 2015. “Investigation of the Ferguson Police Department.” Washington, DC: US Department of Justice Civil Rights Division. https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/opa/press-releases/attachments/2015/03/04/ferguson_police_department_report.pdf.Google Scholar
Wacquant, Loïc. 2009. Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Walker, Samuel, and Archbold, Carol A.. 2019. The New World of Police Accountability. 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
Weitzer, Ronald. 2015. “American Policing under Fire: Misconduct and Reform.Society 52, no. 5: 475–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Worden, Robert E., Christopher, Harris, and McLean, Sarah J.. 2014. “Risk Assessment and Risk Management in Policing.Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management 37, no. 2: 239–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar