Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-f46jp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-10T01:58:14.624Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

An Experimental Investigation of the Effect of Supreme Court Justices’ Public Rhetoric on Perceptions of Judicial Legitimacy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 December 2020

Logan Strother Open the ORCID record for Logan Strother [Opens in a new window]  and
Colin Glennon
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Public support for the US Supreme Court has been trending downward for more than a decade. High-profile decisions and hotly contested nominations have drawn the Court into our polarized politics. Recently, some justices have spent considerable time and energy giving interviews, speeches, and the like, assuring the public that the Court is an apolitical, neutral arbiter of disputes, distinct from the “political” branches. In this context, we turn to an understudied potential source of judicial legitimacy: the off-bench public rhetoric of Supreme Court justices. In this article, we present evidence from three original survey experiments to argue that Supreme Court justices’ off-bench rhetoric can powerfully influence public perceptions of the Court’s institutional legitimacy. Furthermore, these studies show that performance approval is key to changes in legitimacy: respondents who disapprove of a Court decision were immune to the effects of justices’ rhetoric.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 46 , Issue 2 , May 2021 , pp. 435 - 454
Copyright
© 2020 American Bar Foundation

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The authors thank Brandon Bartels, Sara Benesh, Chris Krewson, and the anonymous referees for helpful comments on previous drafts. The studies presented here were approved by the Institutional Review Boards at Princeton University (Studies 1 and 2) and Purdue University (Study 3).

References

REFERENCES

Associated Press. 2018. “Chief Justices Notes Kavanaugh Case, Cites Dangers of ‘Political Pressure.’” CBS News, October 17. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/john-roberts-chief-justice-stresses-independence-minnesota-speech/.Google Scholar
Barabas, Jason, and Jerit, Jennifer. 2010. “Are Survey Experiments Externally Valid?” American Political Science Review 104, no. 2: 226–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barnes, Roberts. 2016. “The Supreme Court and the Political World Are More Entangled Than Either Acknowledges.” Washington Post, July 17.Google Scholar
Bartels, Brandon L., and Johnston, Christopher D.. 2013. “On the Ideological Foundations of Supreme Court Legitimacy in the American Public.” American Journal of Political Science 57, no. 1: 184–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bass, Leeann. 2018. “The Supreme Court’s Politicized News Coverage.” Paper presented at the 2018 Annual Meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago, IL.Google Scholar
Braman, Eileen. 2016. “Exploring Citizen Assessments of Unilateral Executive Authority.” Law & Society Review 50, no. 1: 189–223.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Braman, Eileen, and Easter, Beth. 2014. “Normative Legitimacy: Rules of Appropriateness in Citizens’ Assessments of Individual Judicial Decisions.” Justice System Journal 35, no. 3: 239–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bullock, John G. 2011. “Elite Influence on Public Opinion in an Informed Electorate.” American Political Science Review 105, no. 3: 496–515.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bybee, Keith J. 2010. All Judges Are Political, Except When They Are Not: Acceptable Hypocrisies and the Rule of Law. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Carlson, Taylor N. 2019. “Through the Grapevine: Informational Consequences of Interpersonal Political Communication.” American Political Science Review 113, no. 2: 325–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Christenson, Dino P., and Glick, David M.. 2015. “Chief Justice Roberts’s Health Care Decision Disrobed: The Microfoundations of the Supreme Court’s Legitimacy.” American Journal of Political Science 59, no. 2: 403–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clark, Tom S. 2009. “The Separation of Powers, Court Curbing, and Judicial Legitimacy.” American Journal of Political Science 53, no. 4: 971–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Easton, David. 1965. A Systems Analysis of Political Life. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Engel, Stephen M. 2011. American Politicians Confront the Court: Opposition Politics and Changing Responses to Judicial Power. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fallon, Richard H. 2018. Law and Legitimacy in the Supreme Court. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L. 2007. “The Legitimacy of the U.S. Supreme Court in a Polarized Polity.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 4, no. 3: 507–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L., and Caldeira, Gregory A.. 2009. Citizens, Courts, and Confirmations: Positivity Theory and the Judgments of the American People. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L., Caldeira, Gregory A., and Kenyatta Spence, Lester. 2003. “The Supreme Court and the US Presidential Election of 2000: Wounds, Self-Inflicted or Otherwise?” British Journal of Political Science 33, no. 4: 535–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L., and Nelson, Michael J.. 2014. “The Legitimacy of the US Supreme Court: Conventional Wisdoms and Recent Challenges Thereto.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science 10: 201–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L., and Nelson, Michael J.. 2015. “Is the U.S. Supreme Court’s Legitimacy Grounded in Performance Satisfaction and Ideology?” American Journal of Political Science 59, no. 1: 162–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L., and Nelson, Michael J.. 2016. “Change in Institutional Support for the US Supreme Court: Is the Court’s Legitimacy Imperiled by the Decisions It Makes?” Public Opinion Quarterly 80, no. 3: 622–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glennon, Colin, and Strother, Logan. 2019. “The Maintenance of Institutional Legitimacy in Supreme Court Justices’ Public Rhetoric.” Journal of Law and Courts 7, no. 2: 241–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grossman, Joel B. 1984. “Judicial Legitimacy and the Role of Courts: Shapiro’s Courts.” Law & Social Inquiry 9, no. 1: 214–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Matthew E. K. 2014. “The Semiconstrained Court: Public Opinion, the Separation of Powers, and the U.S. Supreme Court’s Fear of Nonimplementation.” American Journal of Political Science 58, no. 2: 352–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hasen, Richard L. 2015. “Celebrity Justice: Supreme Court Edition.” UC Irvine School of Law Research Paper no. 2015-61.Google Scholar
Hitt, Matthew P., and Searles, Kathleen. 2018. “Media Coverage and Public Approval of the U.S. Supreme Court.” Political Communication 35, no. 4: 566–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ben, Johnson, and Strother, Logan. Forthcoming. “The Supreme Court’s (Surprising?) Indifference to Public Opinion.” Political Research Quarterly. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F1065912920958080.Google Scholar
Keck, Thomas M., and Strother, Logan. 2016. “Judicial Impact.” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press. http://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.103.Google Scholar
Krewson, Christopher N. 2019. “Save this Honorable Court: Shaping Public Perceptions of the Supreme Court Off the Bench.” Political Research Quarterly 72, no. 3: 686–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Linos, Katerina, and Twist, Kimberly. 2016. “The Supreme Court, the Media, and Public Opinion: Comparing Experimental and Observational Methods.” Journal of Legal Studies 45, no. 2: 223–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mack, Kathy, and Roach Anleu, Sharyn. 2010. “Performing Impartiality: Judicial Demeanor and Legitimacy.” Law & Social Inquiry 35, no. 1: 137–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicholson, Stephen P., and Hansford, Thomas G.. 2014. “Partisans in Robes: Party Cues and Public Acceptance of Supreme Court Decisions.” American Journal of Political Science 58, no. 3: 620–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicholson, Stephen P., and Howard, Robert M.. 2003. “Framing Support for the Supreme Court in the Aftermath of ‘Bush v. Gore.’” Journal of Politics 65, no. 3: 676–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nownes, Anthony J., and Glennon, Colin. 2016. “An Experimental Investigation of How Judicial Elections Affect Public Faith in the Judicial System.” Law & Social Inquiry 41, no. 1: 37–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scheb, II, John, M., and Lyons, William. 2000. “The Myth of Legality and Public Evaluation of the Supreme Court.” Social Science Quarterly 81, no. 4: 928–40.Google Scholar
Shapiro, Ari. 2018. “Chief Justice Roberts Delivers Civics Lesson on Role of Supreme Court.” All Things Considered, October 17.Google Scholar
Simon, Dan, and Scurich, Nicholas. 2011. “Lay Judgments of Judicial Decision Making.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 8, no. 4: 709–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simon, Dan, and Scurich, Nicholas. 2013. “The Effect of Legal Expert Commentary on Lay Judgments of Judicial Decision Marking.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 10, no. 4: 797–814.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Solberg, Rorie S., and Waltenburg, Eric N.. 2015. The Media, the Court, and the Misrepresentation. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Schmidt, Christopher W. 2013. “Beyond the Opinion: Supreme Court Justices and Extrajudicial Speech.” Chicago-Kent Law Review 88: 487–526.Google Scholar
Strother, Logan. 2016. “Beyond Kelo: An Experimental Study of Public Opposition to Eminent Domain.” Journal of Law and Courts 4, no. 2: 339–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strother, Logan. 2017. “How Expected Political and Legal Impact Drive Media Coverage of Supreme Court Cases.” Political Communication 34, no. 4: 571–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strother, Logan. 2019. “Case Salience and the Influence of External Constraints on the Supreme Court.” Journal of Law and Courts 7, no. 1: 129–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strother, Logan, and Gadarian, Shana. 2019. “The Supreme Court in a Polarized Era: Is Legitimacy at Risk?” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Southern Political Science Association. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3426819.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1990. Why People Obey the Law: Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and Compliance. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., and Rasinski, Kenneth A.. 1991. “Procedural Justice, Institutional Legitimacy, and the Acceptance of Unpopular U.S. Supreme Court Decisions: A Reply to Gibson.” Law & Society Review 25, no. 3: 621–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zilis, Michael A. 2015. The Limits of Legitimacy: Dissenting Opinions, Media Coverage, and Public Responses to Supreme Court Decisions. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zink, James R., Spriggs, James F. II, and Scott, John T.. 2009. “Courting the Public: The Influence of Decision Attributes on Individuals’ Views of Court Opinions.” Journal of Politics 71, no. 3: 909–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Strother and Glennon supplementary material

Strother and Glennon supplementary material

Download Strother and Glennon supplementary material(File)
File 47.5 KB