Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-ndw9j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T06:50:04.373Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Tale of Two Regions: Diffusion of the Israeli “50 Percent Rule” from the Galilee to the Occupied West Bank

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Geremy Forman
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The “50 percent rule” is an Israeli judicial doctrine that has played a pivotal role since the early 1960s in deciding disputes between the Israeli government and Palestinian landholders under Article 78 of the Ottoman Land Code. It was first institutionalized during a government land‐claiming campaign aimed at providing state land for settlement‐based Judaization of Israel's predominantly Palestinian Galilee region. Two decades later, during a similar state land‐claiming campaign, the doctrine diffused into the occupied West Bank. Drawing on spatial components of social science diffusion literature and work in the field of legal geography, this article offers a legal‐historical‐geographical analysis of the evolution and diffusion of the 50 percent rule. Its conclusions suggest a new spatialized approach to the study of legal transfers and transplants that conceptualizes law's movement across international borders as one component of a broader process of legal diffusion, in which internal diffusion also plays an important role.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 34 , Issue 3 , Summer 2009 , pp. 671 - 711
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2009 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References

Agnew, John. 1979. Instrumentalism, Realism, and the Diffusion of Innovation. Professional Geographer 31 (4): 364–70.Google Scholar
Albeck, Plia. 1983. State Lands in Judea and Samaria. Press Bulletin of the State of Israel, September 14, Jerusalem. In author's possession.Google Scholar
Allon, Yigal. 1976. Israel: The Case for Defensible Borders. Foreign Affairs 55:38–53.Google Scholar
Bar‐Yaacov, Nissim. 1990. The Applicability of the Laws of War to Judea and Samaria (the West Bank) and to the Gaza Strip. Israel Law Review 24:485–506 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Ben, Aluf. 2004. Settlements Have an Element of Temporariness. Haaretz, April 2 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Benvenisti, Eyal. 1990. Legal Dualism: The Absorption of the Occupied Territories into Israel. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Benvenisti, Eyal. 1993. The International Law of Occupation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Benvenisti, Meron, and Khayat, Shlomo. 1988. The West Bank and Gaza Atlas. Jerusalem: West Bank Data Project and the Jerusalem Post.Google Scholar
Bitzor, Yehoshua. 1978. Weizman: I Will Expropriate neither Vineyards nor Olive Orchards Belonging to West Bank Inhabitants. Maariv, May 25 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Blaut, James. 1977. Two Views of Diffusion. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 67 (3): 343–49.Google Scholar
Blaut, James. 1987. Diffusionism: A Uniformitarian Critique. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 77 (1): 30–47.Google Scholar
Blomley, Nicholas. 1989. Text and Context: Rethinking the Law‐Space Nexus. Progress in Human Geography 13:517–18.Google Scholar
Braverman, Irus. 2008. “The Tree Is the Enemy Soldier”: A Sociolegal Making of War Landscapes in the Occupied West Bank. Law and Society Review 42 (3): 449–82.Google Scholar
Burman, Sandra, and Harrell‐Bond, Barbara. 1979. The Imposition of Law. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Clasborne, William. 1979. Israel Ends Its Ban of Buying Land in Gaza, West Bank. Jerusalem Post, September 18.Google Scholar
Eldar, Akiva. 2006a. The Black List of the Valley. Haaretz, March 14 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Eldar, Akiva. 2006b. Peretz's Office Confirms: Palestinians Were Not Permitted to Return to the Valley Out of Concern They Would Claim Their Lands. Haaretz, July 12 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Eshet, Gideon. 1978. Secret Plan to Establish Company to Purchase Land from Arabs in the West Bank. Yediot Aharonot, April 19 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Michael, Fischbach. 1994. The Implications of Jordanian Land Policy for the West Bank. Middle East Journal 48 (3): 492–509.Google Scholar
Fisher, Stanley, ed. 1919. Ottoman Land Laws. London: H. Milford.Google Scholar
Forman, Geremy. 2002. Settlement of Title in Northern Israel in Light of Sir Ernest Dowson's Colonial Guiding Principles. Israel Studies 7 (3): 61–83.Google Scholar
Forman, Geremy. 2005. Israeli Settlement of Title in Arab Areas. PhD diss. Department of Land of Israel Studies, University of Haifa, Israel.Google Scholar
Forman, Geremy. 2006. Law and the Historical Geography of the Galilee: Israel's Litigatory Advantages during the Special Operation of Land Settlement. Journal of Historical Geography 32:796–817.Google Scholar
Forman, Geremy. Forthcoming. Liberal Reform in an Illiberal Land Regime: The Land Settlement Ordinance of 1960 and the History of Formative Land Legislation. Israel Studies.Google Scholar
Gorenberg, Gershom. 2006. The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967–1977. New York: Times Books.Google Scholar
Graziadei, Michele. 2006. Comparative Law as the Study of Transplants and Receptions. In The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law, ed. Zimmermann, Reinhard and Reimann, Matthias, 441–75. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Gross, Aeyal. 2006. The Construction of a Wall between The Hague and Jerusalem: The Enforcement and Limits of Humanitarian Law and the Structure of Occupation. Leiden Journal of International Law 19:393–440.Google Scholar
Harris, William Wilson. 1980. Taking Root: Israeli Settlement in the West Bank, the Golan and Gaza‐Sinai, 1967–1980. Chichester, UK: Research Studies Press.Google Scholar
Holzman‐Gazit, Yifat. 2007. Land Expropriation in Israel: Law, Culture and Society. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.Google Scholar
IDF Military Advocate General. 1990. Land in the Judea and Samaria Region—Appeal Board Rulings. Israel: IDF Military Advocate General.Google Scholar
Israel Law Review. 2005. Special Double Issue: Domestic and International Judicial Review of the Construction of the Separation Barrier. Israel Law Review 38: 1–2 (6‐417).Google Scholar
Israel Ministry of Defense. 1971. Four Years of Military Government, 1967–1971. Israel: Ministry of Defense [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Israel State Comptroller. 2005. Annual Report of the State Comptroller 56a , [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Kedar, Alexandre. 2001. The Legal Transformation of Ethnic Geography: Israeli Law and the Palestinian Landholder. New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 33 (4): 923–1000.Google Scholar
Kharif, Yosef. 1979. Legal Expert Plia Albeck's Study of State of Land in Judea and Samaria Prevented the Crisis Everyone Expected. Maariv, October 15 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Kretzmer, David. 2002. The Occupation of Justice: The Supreme Court of Israel and the Occupied Territories. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.Google Scholar
Langer, Maximo. 2004. From Legal Transplants to Legal Translations: The Globalization of Plea Bargaining and the Americanization Thesis in Criminal Procedure. Harvard International Law Journal 45 (1): 1–64.Google Scholar
Legrande, Pierre. 2001. What Legal Transplants? In Adapting Legal Cultures, ed. Nelken, David and Feest, Johannes, 55–70. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
Lein, Yiheskel, and Weitzman, Eyal. 2002. Land Grab: Israel's Settlement Policy in the West Bank. Israel: B'tselem [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Levitsky, Naomi. 2001. Your Honor. Israel: Keter [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Litani, Yehuda. 1978. Settlement Weitzman Style. Haaretz, March 13 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Lustick, Ian S. 1980-1981. Saving Camp David: Kill the Autonomy Talks. Foreign Policy 41:21–43.Google Scholar
Lustick, Ian S. 1981. Israel and the West Bank after Elon Moreh: The Mechanics of De‐Facto Annexation. Middle East Journal 35 (4): 557–77.Google Scholar
Morrill, Richard, Gaile, Gary, and Thrall, Grant Ian. 1988. Spatial Diffusion. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Nelken, David. 2001. Towards a Sociology of Legal Adaptation. In Adapting Legal Cultures, ed. Nelken, David and Feest, Johannes, 7–54. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
Nelken, David, and Feest, Johannes, eds. 2001. Adapting Legal Cultures. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
Rapoport, Meron. 2008. Papers Detail Settlers’ West Bank Land Grab. Haaretz. http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/objects/pages/PrintArticleEn.jhtml?itemNo=964797 (accessed March 19, 2009).Google Scholar
Report of the Commission on First Land Registration in the Judea and Samaria Region. 2005 [Hebrew]. In author's possession.Google Scholar
Rogers, Everett. 2003. Diffusion of Innovations, 5th ed. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
The Rule of Law in the Areas Administered by Israel. 1981. Tel‐Aviv: Israel National Section of the International Commission of Jurists.Google Scholar
Sandberg, Haim. 2000. Land Title Settlement in Eretz‐Israel and in the State of Israel. Jerusalem: Harry Sacher Institute for Legislative Research and Comparative Law [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Sandberg, Haim. 2007. The Lands of Israel: Zionism and Post‐Zionism. Jerusalem: Harry Sacher Institute for Legislative Research and Comparative Law [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Segev, Shmuel. 1979. A Vocal Argument at the Autonomy Talks. Maariv, September 27 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Shragai, Nadav. 2009. Settlement Gets Green Light for Massive Expansion. Haaretz. http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/objects/pages/PrintArticleEn.jhtml?itemNo=1064419 (accessed March 18, 2009)Google Scholar
Suchovolsky, Avraham, Cohen, Eliyahu, and Erlich, Avi. 1986. Land Law in Judea and Samaria. Tel Aviv: Dekel.Google Scholar
Shahak, Israel. 1992. Israeli Land Seizures in the Occupied Territories. Middle East Policy 1 (2): 96–106.Google Scholar
Shamir, Ronen. 1990. “Landmark Cases” and the Reproduction of Legitimacy: the Case of Israel's High Court of Justice. Law & Society Review 24 (3): 781–806.Google Scholar
Shehadeh, Raja. 1982. The Land Law of Palestine: An Analysis of the Definition of State Land. Journal of Palestine Studies 11 (2): 82–99.Google Scholar
Shehadeh, Raja. 1985. Occupier's Law: Israel and the West Bank. Washington, DC: Institute for Palestine Studies.Google Scholar
Tedeschi, Guido (Gad). 1966. On Reception and on the Legislative Policy in Israel. Scripta Hierosolymitana, Vol 16. Studies in Israeli Legislative Problems. Jerusalem: Magnes Press.Google Scholar
Tessler, Mark. 1986. The Political Right in Israel: Its Origins, Growth, and Prospects. Journal of Palestine Studies 15 (2): 25–26.Google Scholar
Tirosh, Avraham, and Bitzor, Yehoshua. 1978. Due to Disagreements, Yadin and Rubinstein Ask Barak for Information about the Expropriations. Maariv, May 25 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Twining, William. 2004. Diffusion of Law: A Global Perspective. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 49:1–45.Google Scholar
Twining, William. 2005. Social Science and Diffusion of Law. Journal of Law and Society 32 (2): 203–40.Google Scholar
Tzimuki, Arieh. 1979. Weizman and Dayan Oppose Discussion of Land Expropriation. Yediot Aharonot, August 22 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Watson, Alan. 1993. Legal Transplants: An Approach to Comparative Law, 5th ed. Athens: University of Georgia Press.Google Scholar
Waxman, Yosef. 1978a. Delay of Approval of Sharon Plan for 25,000 Residential Units in Judea and Samaria. Maariv, January 6 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Waxman, Yosef. 1978b. Sources in the Prime Minster's Office: Hostile Elements Spread News about the Expropriations. Maariv, May 24 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Zamir, Eyal. 1985. State Land in Judea and Samaria: The Legal Status. Jerusalem: Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Zamir, Eyal, and Benvenisti, Eyal. 1993. The Legal Status of Lands Acquired by Israelis before 1948 in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem. Jerusalem: Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Zertal, Idith, and Eldar, Akiva. 2004. Lords of the Land: The Settlers and the State of Israel, 1967–2004. Kinerret: Zmora Bitan, Dvir. [Hebrew]Google Scholar

Israel State Archives, Jerusalem, Israel

Report of the Interdepartmental Committee on Land Settlement (Appendix E), September 9, 1964, ISA (74) 5741‐gimel/15 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Courtroom Minutes in State of Israel v. Badaran, Bi‘na/109, August 26, 1959, Haifa District Court, ISA (30) 3957‐bet/482 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Letter from Aharon Barak to Uzi Gadur, February 13, 1978, ISA (30) 321/78 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Affidavit of General Orly, Tamimi v. Defense Minister, HCJ 321/78 (unpublished), July 6, 1978, ISA (30) 321/78 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Affidavit of Aziz Shehadeh in Al‐Nazir et al. v. Commander of Judea and Samaria, HCJ 285/81, n.d., ISA (30) 13642‐bet/285 [Hebrew.Google Scholar

Israel Defense Forces Archive, Tel Hashomer, Israel

Internal Statistics of the Appeal Board Commissioner's Office for 1987–1988, IDFA 1990/1903‐4; 1990/1903‐5; 1990/350‐17; 1990/350‐18; 1990/350‐19.Google Scholar

Cases Cited Legend

ABCO: Appeal Board Commissioner's OfficeGoogle Scholar
DK: Office of Daniel KramerGoogle Scholar
HDC: Haifa District CourtGoogle Scholar
IDFAB: IDF Appeal BoardGoogle Scholar
SOHN: Settlement Officer of the Haifa and Northern DistrictsGoogle Scholar
SGP: Supervisor of Government PropertyGoogle Scholar

Cases Cited

Abu ‘Awad et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 12/86, April 12, 1987, IDFAB, DK.Google Scholar
Abu Kabita et al. v. SGP[Hebrew], Appeal 126/87, December 27, 1989, IDFAB, ABCO.Google Scholar
al‐Aghrayb v. Appeal Boards[Hebrew], HCJ 277/84, 40(2) P.D. 57, March 24, 1986.Google Scholar
al‐Aghrayb v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 14/80 and 3/82, April 8, 1984, IDFAB (Sukhovolsky, Cohen, and Erlich 1986, 284–97).Google Scholar
al‐Badata et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 39/86, November 2, 1986, IDFAB, DK.Google Scholar
al‐Khatib v. State of Israel[Hebrew], CA 314/61, 16 P.D. 837–840, April 2, 1962.Google Scholar
al‐Nazir et al. v. Commander of Judea and Samaria[Hebrew], HCJ 285/81, 36(1) P.D. 701. February 7, 1982.Google Scholar
al‐‘Umar et al. v. State of Israel[Hebrew], CA 423/61, 15 P.D. 2552. December 25, 1961.Google Scholar
‘Awida et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 7/04, July 10, 2006, IDFAB. In author's possession.Google Scholar
Awkhish et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 12, 13, 22/81, October 10, 1982, IDFAB (IDF Military Advocate General 1990, 53–65).Google Scholar
‘Ayyash et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 27/83, June 4, 1986, IDFAB (IDF Military Advocate General 1990, 129–34).Google Scholar
Badran v. State of Israel[Hebrew], CA 482/59, 15 P.D. 906–912. April 13, 1961.Google Scholar
Commander of IDF Forces in Judea and Samaria v. Military Appeal Board (initial hearing scheduled for May 2009).Google Scholar
Diyab v. State of Israel[Hebrew], CA 505/63, 18(2) P.D. 29. February 5, 1964.Google Scholar
Dwaikat et al. v. Government of Israel, CA 390/79, 34 P.D. October 22, 1979.Google Scholar
Habiby v. Government of Palestine, CA 65/40, 7 P.L.R. 290. June 7, 1940.Google Scholar
Hakeren l'yad Midreshet Eretz Israel v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 22, 23/06, May 22, 2008, IDFAB, DK.Google Scholar
Haluma et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 17 and 31/81, March 31, 1982, IDFAB (IDF Military Advocate General 1990, 66–70).Google Scholar
Matar et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 42/85, November 8, 1992, IDFAB, ABCO.Google Scholar
Nasir v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 75/91, n.d., IDFAB, ABCO.Google Scholar
Rajbi v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew]. Appeal 4/05, June 15, 2008, IDFAB. In author's possession.Google Scholar
Rajub et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 18/82, January 31, 1985, IDFAB, ABCO.Google Scholar
Residents of Kafr ‘Aqab v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 15/82, April 8, 1984, IDFAB (IDF Military Advocate General 1990, 96–106).Google Scholar
Salawin et al. v Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 58/91, July 12, 1998, IDFAB, DK.Google Scholar
Selek v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 14/81, June 24, 1982, IDFAB, DK.Google Scholar
Sharita et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 31/83, October 27, 1985, IDFAB, ABCO.Google Scholar
Shibli et al. v. State of Israel[Hebrew], CA 65/64, 18(4) P.D. 766. November 30, 1964.Google Scholar
State of Israel v. al‐‘Umar et al.[Hebrew], Deir Hanna/391, May 14, 1961, HDC, ISA (30) 4525‐bet/423.Google Scholar
State of Israel v. ‘Arnum I [Hebrew], Bi‘na/14, November 4, 1959, SOHN, ISA (33) 20527‐bet/14.Google Scholar
State of Israel v. ‘Arnum II [Hebrew], Bi‘na/12, November 4, 1959, SOHN, ISA (33) 20527‐bet/12.Google Scholar
State of Israel v. Khatib and Da‘ash[Hebrew], Deir Hanna/48, October 11, 1960, HDC, ISA (33) 20586‐bet/48.Google Scholar
State of Israel v. Sa‘id Muhammad Ahmad Salih[Hebrew], Kabul/8, March 5, 1962, HDC, ISA (30) 4564‐bet/148.Google Scholar
State of Israel v. Salih[Hebrew], CA 148/62, 16 P.D. 1446, June 20, 1962.Google Scholar
Sulayman et al. v. State of Israel and ‘Asila v. State of Israel[Hebrew], CA 504/62 and CA 145/64 (united), 18(4) P.D. 617. December 21, 1964.Google Scholar
Sulayman et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 15/80, May 12, 1982, IDFAB, DK.Google Scholar
Tamimi v. Defense Minister, HCJ 321/78, July 6, 1978, ISA (30) 321/78 (unpublished), ISA (30) 321/78 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Unspecified Appellant v. Supervisor of Government Property‐I [Hebrew], Appeal 15/83, n.d., IDFAB, DK.Google Scholar
Unspecified Appellants v. Supervisor of Government Property‐II [Hebrew], Appeal 54/86, November 3, 1992, IDFAB, ABCO.Google Scholar
Yahya et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 117/81, March 4, 1982, IDFAB (IDF Military Advocate General 1990, 71–79).Google Scholar
Yusuf et al. v. Supervisor of Government Property[Hebrew], Appeal 75, 76, 77/86, January 27, 1991, IDFAB, ABCO.Google Scholar

Statutes Cited

Geneva Regulations. Convention (IV) Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, 1949. http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/geneva07.asp (accessed November 5, 2008).Google Scholar
Hague Regulations. Laws and Customs of War on Land (Hague IV), 1907. http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hague04.asp (accessed November 5, 2008).Google Scholar
Land (Settlement of Title) Ordinance Amendment, 1960, Laws of Israel 302 (February 25, 1960) 13–16 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Military Order 58, Concerning Abandoned Private Property (July 23, 1967). Orders and Appointments of the Military Government 15 (November 1967) 158–162 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Military Order 59, Concerning Government Property (July 31, 1967). Orders and Appointments of the Military Government 15 (November 1967) 162–65 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Military Order 172, Concerning Appeal Boards (Judea and Samaria), 1967 (Updated Version) [Hebrew]. IDFA 2001/1585‐18.Google Scholar
Military Order 291, Concerning Land and Water Settlement (Judea and Samaria) (December 19, 1968). Orders and Appointments of the Military Government 16 (December 1968) 591–93 [Hebrew.Google Scholar
Ottoman Land Code (1858). See Fisher (1919).Google Scholar
Regulations as to Title Deeds. See Fisher (1919).Google Scholar
Statute of Limitations, 1958, Laws of Israel 251 (April 6, 1958) 112–115 [Hebrew.Google Scholar