Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-hvd4g Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-23T06:26:59.809Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Juror Perceptions of the Legitimacy of Legal Authorities and Decision Making in Criminal Cases

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Amy Farrell ,
Liana Pennington  and
Shea Cronin
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Literature on trust in legal authorities and institutions demonstrates that trust affects individual behavior, yet there is little research on whether attitudes toward legal authorities such as the police or courts influence juror behavior as a third party assessing evidence and determining legal outcomes for others. Additionally, the literature on juror decision making confirms that juror race is an important predictor of juror decisions, but explanations for differences among racial groups are not clear. Since minority groups hold less favorable attitudes toward legal authorities generally, legitimacy theory may help explain racial differences in decision making among jurors. Using data from nearly 2,000 jurors in felony trials, this research utilizes multilevel modeling techniques to find that jurors' trust in legal authorities is related to juror outcomes, though the effect of juror trust and confidence in the police is opposite that of juror trust and confidence in the courts. Additionally, juror race conditions the effect of trust in police and courts. Trust is a stronger predictor of both perceptions of evidence and voting for black jurors than it is for white jurors.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 38 , Issue 4 , Fall 2013 , pp. 773 - 802
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Banesh, Sara C., and Howell, Susan E. 2001. Confidence in the Courts: A Comparison of Users and Non‐users. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 19:199–214.Google Scholar
Barnett, Arnold. 1985. Some Disturbing Patterns for the Georgia Death Sentence. University of California Davis Law Review 18:1327–1374.Google Scholar
Bennett, Lance, and Feldman, Martha. 1981. Reconstructing Reality in the Courtroom. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Bernard, J. L. 1979. Interaction between the Race of the Defendant and that of Jurors in Determining Verdicts. Law & Psychology Review 5:103–111.Google Scholar
Bonazzoli, Juliet. 1998. Jury Selection and Bias: Debunking Invidious Stereotypes Through Science. Quinnipiac Law Review 18:247–305.Google Scholar
Bowers, William J., Sandys, Marla, and Steiner, Benjamin. 1998. Foreclosed Impartiality in Capital Sentencing: Jurors' Predispositions, Guilt‐Trial Experience, and Premature Decision‐Making. Cornell Law Review 15:163–184.Google Scholar
Bradford, Ben, Jackson, Jonathan, and Stanko, Elizabeth A. 2009. Contact and Confidence: Revisiting the Impact of Public Encounters with the Police. Policing and Society 19:20–46.Google Scholar
Bray, Robert M., and Noble, Audrey M. 1978. Authoritarianism and Decisions of Mock Juries: Evidence of Jury Bias and Group Polarization. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 36:1424–1430.Google Scholar
Butler, Paul. 1995. Racially Based Jury Nullification: Black Power in the Criminal Justice System. Yale Law Journal 105:677–725.Google Scholar
Cao, Liqun, Frank, James, and Cullen, Francis T. 1996. Race, Community Context and Confidence in the Police. American Journal of Police 15:3–22.Google Scholar
Casper, Jonathan D., Benedict, Kenneth, and Perry, Jo L. 1989. Juror Decision‐Making, Attitudes, and the Hindsight Bias. Law and Human Behavior 13:291–310.Google Scholar
De la Garza, Rodolfo O., and DeSipio, Louis. 2001. A Satisfied Clientele Seeking More Diverse Services: Latinos and the Courts. Behavior Sciences and the Law 19:237–248.Google Scholar
Devine, Dennis J., Buddenbaum, Jennifer, Houp, Stephanie, Studebaker, Nathan, and Stolle, Dennis P. 2009. Extra‐Evidentiary Influence and the Liberation Hypothesis: Data from the Field. Law and Human Behavior 33:136–148.Google Scholar
Devine, Dennis J., Clayton, Laura, Dunford, Benjamin, Seying, Rasmey, and Pryce, Jennifer. 2000. Jury Decision‐Making: 45 Years of Empirical Research on Deliberating Groups. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 7:622–727.Google Scholar
Easton, David. 1965. A Systems Analysis of Political Life. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Eisenstein, James, Flemming, Roy B., and F. Nardulli, Peter. 1988. The Contours of Justice: Communities and Their Courts. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.Google Scholar
Eith, Christine, and Durose, Matthew. 2011. Contacts Between the Police and Public, 2008. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.Google Scholar
Ewick, Patricia, and Silbey, Susan S. 1998. The Common Place of Law: Stories from Everyday Life. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Fagan, Jeffrey. 2008. Legitimacy and Criminal Justice. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 6:123–140.Google Scholar
Feeley, Malcolm. 1979. The Process Is the Punishment. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Fitzgerald, Robert, and Ellsworth, Phoebe. 1984. Due Process vs. Crime Control: Death Qualification and Jury Attitudes. Law and Human Behavior 8:31–51.Google Scholar
Franke, Derrick, Bierie, David, and MacKenzie, Doris Layton. 2010. Legitimacy in Corrections: A Randomized Experiment Comparing a Boot Camp with a Prison. Criminology & Public Policy 9:89–134.Google Scholar
Garvey, Stephen, Hannaford‐Agor, Paula, Hans, Valerie, Mott, Nicole, Munsterman, Thomas, and Wells, Martin. 2004. Juror First Votes in Criminal Trials. Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 1:371–398.Google Scholar
Gau, Jacinta, and Brunson, Rod. 2010. Procedural Justice and Order Maintenance Policing: A Study of Inner City Young Men's Perceptions of Police Legitimacy. Justice Quarterly 27:255–279.Google Scholar
Gibson, James. 1989. Understandings of Justice: Institutional Legitimacy, Procedural Justice, and Political Tolerance. Law & Society Review 23:469–496.Google Scholar
Gibson, James, and Caldeira, Gregory. 1992. Blacks and the United States Supreme Court: Models of Diffuse Support. Journal of Politics 54:1120–1145.Google Scholar
Gottfredson, Denise, Kearley, Brook, Najaka, Stacy, and Rocha, Carlos. 2007. How Drug Treatment Works: An Analysis of Mediators. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 44:3–35.Google Scholar
Greene, Edith. 1988. Judge's Instructions on Eyewitness Testimony: Evaluation and Revision. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 18:252–276.Google Scholar
Hannaford‐Agor, Paula, and Hans, Valerie P. 2003. Nullification at Work? A Glimpse from the National Center for State Court Study of Hung Juries. Chicago‐Kent Law Review 78:1249–1277.Google Scholar
Hannaford‐Agor, Paula L., Hans, Valerie P., Mott, Nicole L., and Munsterman, G. Thomas. 2002. Are Hung Juries a Problem? Final Report. NCJ 201096. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice.Google Scholar
Harris, David A. 1999. The Stories, the Statistics, and the Law: Why “Driving While Black” Matters. Minnesota Law Review 84:265–326.Google Scholar
Hastie, Reid, Penrod, Steven D., and Pennington, Nancy. 1983. Inside the Jury. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Hedeker, Donald. 2007. Multilevel Models for Ordinal and Nominal Variables. In Handbook of Multilevel Analysis. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
Hepburn, John R. 1980. The Objective Reality of Evidence and the Utility of Systematic Jury Selection. Law and Human Behavior 4:89–101.Google Scholar
Horowitz, Irwin. 1988. Jury Nullification: The Impact of Judicial Instructions, Arguments and Challenges on Jury Decision Making. Law and Human Behavior 12:439–453.Google Scholar
Horowitz, Irwin, Kerr, Norbert, and Neidermeier, Keith. 2001. Jury Nullification: Legal and Psychological Perspectives. Brooklyn Law Review 66:1207–1249.Google Scholar
Hox, J. J. 1995. Applied Multilevel Analysis. Amsterdam: TT Publikaties.Google Scholar
Huang, W. S., and Vaughn, Michael. 1996. Support and Confidence: Public Attitudes Toward the Police. In Americans View Crime and Justice: A National Public Opinion Survey, eds. Flanagan, Timothy and Longmire, Dennis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Johnson, Sheri Lynn. 1984. Cross‐Racial Identification Errors in Criminal Cases. Cornell Law Review, 69:934–987.Google Scholar
Kalven, Harry, and Zeisel, Hans. 1966. The American Jury . Boston, MA: Little Brown.Google Scholar
Kenny, David, Mannetti, Lucia, Pierro, Antonio, Livi, Stefano, and Kashy, Deborah A. 2003. The Statistical Analysis of Data from Small Groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83:126–137.Google Scholar
King, Nancy. 1993. Postconviction Review of Jury Discrimination: Measuring the Effects of Juror Race on Jury Decisions. Michigan Law Review 92:63–130.Google Scholar
Kitzmann, Katherine M., and Emery, Robert E. 1993. Procedural Justice and Parents' Satisfaction in a Field Study of Child Custody Dispute Resolution. Law and Human Behavior 17:553–567.Google Scholar
Lasley, James. 1994. The Impact of the Rodney King Incident on Citizen Attitudes Toward the Police. Policing and Society 3:245–255.Google Scholar
Lind, E. Allan, and Tyler, Tom R. 1988. The Social Psychology of Procedural Justice. New York: Plenum Press.Google Scholar
Maas, Cora J. M., and Hox, Joop J. 2005. Sufficient Sample Sizes for Multilevel Modeling. Methodology 1:86–92.Google Scholar
MacCoun, Robert J. 2005. Voice, Control, and Belonging: The Double‐Edged Sword of Procedural Fairness. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 1:171–201.Google Scholar
MacCoun, Robert J., and Kerr, Norbert L. 1988. Asymmetric Influence in Mock Jury Deliberation: Jurors' Bias for Leniency. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54:21–33.Google Scholar
MacCoun, Robert J., and Tyler, Tom R. 1988. The Basis of Citizens' Perceptions of the Criminal Jury. Law and Human Behavior 12:333–352.Google Scholar
Meares, Tracey L. 1997. Charting Race and Class Differences in Attitudes Toward Drug Legalization and Law Enforcement: Lessons for Federal Criminal Law. Buffalo Criminal Law Review 1:137–174.Google Scholar
Menjivar, Cecila, and Bejarano, Cynthia. 2004. Latino Immigrants' Perceptions of Crime and Police Authorities in the United States: A Case Study. Ethnic and Racial Studies 27:120–148.Google Scholar
Merry, Sally Engle. 1990. Getting Justice and Getting Even: Legal Consciousness Among Working‐Class Americans. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Moore, Mark. 1997. Legitimizing Criminal Justice Policies and Practices. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin October:14–21.Google Scholar
Murphy, Kristina, Hinds, Lyn, and Fleming, Jenny. 2008. Encouraging Public Cooperation and Support for Police. Policing and Society 18:136–155.Google Scholar
Myers, Martha. 1979. Offended Parties and Official Reactions: Victims and the Sentencing of Criminal Defendants Sociological Quarterly 20:529–540.Google Scholar
Nielsen, Laura Beth. 2004. License to Harass: Law, Hierarchy, and Offensive Public Speech. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Overby, L. Marvin, Brown, Robert D., Bruce, John M., Smith, Charles E. Jr., and Winkle, John W. III. 2005. Race, Political Empowerment and Minority Perceptions of Judicial Fairness. Social Science Quarterly 86:444–462.Google Scholar
Pabst, William, Munsterman, G. Thomas, and Mount, Chester. 1976. The Myth of the Unwilling Juror. Juridcature 60:164–171.Google Scholar
Packer, Herbert L. 1968. The Limits of the Criminal Sanction. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Paternoster, Raymond, Brame, Robert, Bachman, Ronet, and Sherman, Lawrence W. 1997. Do Fair Procedures Matter? The Effects of Procedural Justice on Spouse Assault. Law & Society Review 31:163–203.Google Scholar
Pennington, Nancy, and Hastie, Reid. 1990. Practical Implications of Psychological Research on Juror and Jury Decisionmaking. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 16:90–105.Google Scholar
Perez, Dolores, Hosch, Harmon, Ponder, Bruce, and Trejo, Gloria Chanez. 1993. Ethnicity of Defendants and Jurors as Influences on Jury Decisions. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 23:1249–1262.Google Scholar
Raudenbush, Stephen W., and Bryk, Anthony S. 2002. Hierarchical Linear Models: Applications and Data Analysis Methods, 2nd ed. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Reisig, Michael D. 2007. Procedural Justice and Community Policing—What Shapes Residents' Willingness to Participate in Crime Prevention Programs. Policing 1:356–369.Google Scholar
Reisig, Michael D., and Giacomazzi, Andrew. 1998. Citizen Perceptions of Community Policing: Are Attitudes Toward Police Important? International Journal of Police Strategies and Management 21:547–561.Google Scholar
Roach, Kent. 1999. Four Models of the Criminal Process. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 89:671–716.Google Scholar
Rose, Mary R., Ellison, Christopher, and Seidman Diamond, Shari. 2008. Preferences for Juries Over Judges Across Racial and Ethnic Groups. Social Science Quarterly 89:372–391.Google Scholar
Rottman, David B., and Hansen, Randall M. 2001. How Recent Users View the State Courts: Perceptions of Whites, African‐Americans, and Latinos. Washington, DC: National Center for State Courts.Google Scholar
Sealy, A. Phillip. 1981. Another Look at Social Psychological Aspects of Juror Bias. Law and Human Behavior 5:187–200.Google Scholar
Shaffer, Donald R., and Case, Thomas T. 1982. On the Decision to Testify on One's Own Behalf: Effects of Withheld Evidence, Defendant's Sexual Preferences, and Juror Dogmatism on Juridic Decisions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 42:335–346.Google Scholar
Shaffer, David R., Plummer, Diane, and Hammock, Georgina. 1986. Hath He Suffered Enough? Effects of Jury Dogmatism, Defendant Similarity, and Defendant's Pretrial Suffering on Juridic Decisions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 50:1059–1067.Google Scholar
Sherman, Lawrence W. 2002. Trust and Confidence in Criminal Justice. National Institute of Justice Journal 248:22–31.Google Scholar
Shuman, Daniel, and Hamilton, Jean. 1992–1993. Jury Service—It May Change Your Mind: Perceptions of Fairness of Jurors and Nonjurors. Southern Methodist University Law Review 46:449–479.Google Scholar
Skolnick, Paul, and Shaw, Jerry. 1997. The O. J. Simpson Criminal Trial Verdict: Racism or Status Shield? Journal of Social Issues 53:503–516.Google Scholar
Sommers, Samuel. 2006. On Racial Diversity and Group Decision‐Making: Identifying Multiple Effects of Racial Composition on Jury Deliberations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90:597–612.Google Scholar
Sommers, Samuel. 2007. Race and the Decision Making of Juries. Legal and Criminological Psychology 12:171–187.Google Scholar
Sommers, Samuel, and Ellsworth, Phoebe. 2003. How Much Do We Really Know About Race and Juries—A Review of Social Science Theory and Research. Chicago‐Kent Law Review 78:997–1031.Google Scholar
Sunshine, Jason, and Tyler, Tom R. 2003. The Role of Procedural Justice and Legitimacy in Shaping Public Support for Policing. Law and Society Review 37:513–548.Google Scholar
Taylor, Tanya, and Hosch, Harmon. 2004. An Examination of Jury Verdicts for Evidence of a Similarity‐Leniency Effect, an Out‐Group Punitiveness Effect or a Black Sheep Effect. Law and Human Behavior 10:587–598.Google Scholar
Thibaut, John W., and Walker, Laurens. 1975. Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Thompson, William C., Cowan, Claudia L., Ellsworth, Phoebe, and Harrington, Joan. 1984. Death Penalty Attitudes and Conviction Proneness: The Translation of Attitudes into Verdicts. Law and Human Behavior 8:85–113.Google Scholar
Tonry, Michael. 1996. Malign Neglect: Race, Crime, and Punishment in America. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1984. The Role of Perceived Injustice in Defendants' Evaluations of Their Courtroom Experience. Law & Society Review 18:51–74.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1990. Why People Obey the Law. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1998. Public Mistrust of the Law: A Political Perspective. University of Cincinnati Law Review 66:847–875.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 2001. Public Trust and Confidence in Legal Authorities: What Do Majority and Minority Group Members Want from the Law and Legal Institutions? Behavioral Sciences and the Law 19:215–235.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 2003. Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and the Effective Rule of Law. Crime & Justice 30:283–357.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 2005. Policing in Black and White: Ethnic Group Differences in Trust and Confidence in the Police. Police Quarterly 8:322–342.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 2006. Psychological Perspectives on Legitimacy and Legitimation. Annual Review of Psychology 57:375–400.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., Boeckmann, Robert, Smith, Heather, and Huo, Yuen J. 1997. Social Justice in a Diverse Society. New York: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., and Fagan, Jeffrey. 2008. Legitimacy and Cooperation: Why Do People Help the Police Fight Crime in Their Communities? Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 6:231–275.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., and Huo, Yuen J. 2002. Trust in the Law: Encouraging Public Cooperation with the Police and Courts. New York: Russell‐Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., Sherman, Lawrence, Strang, Heather, Barnes, Geoffrey C., and Woods, Daniel. 2007. Reintegrative Shaming, Procedural Justice, and Recidivism: The Engagement of Offenders' Psychological Mechanisms in the Canberra RISE Drinking‐and‐Driving Experiment. Law & Society Review 41:553–585.Google Scholar
Ugwuegbu, Denis Chimaeze. 1979. Racial and Evidential Factors in Juror Attribution of Legal Responsibility. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 15:133–146.Google Scholar
U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics. 2009. Sourcebook of Criminal Justice Statistics. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.Google Scholar
Visher, Christy. 1987. Juror Decision‐Making the Importance of Evidence. Law and Human Behavior 11:1–17.Google Scholar
Walker, Samuel. 1980. Popular Justice: History of American Criminal Justice. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Waters, Nicole L., and Hans, Valerie. 2009. A Jury of One: Opinion Formation, Conformity, and Dissent on Juries. Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 6:513–540.Google Scholar
Weitzer, Ronald, and Tuch, Steven A. 2005. Racially Biased Policing: Determinants of Citizen Perception. Social Forces 83:1009–1030.Google Scholar
Weitzer, Ronald, and Tuch, Steven A. 2006. Race and Policing in America: Conflict and Reform. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Werner, Carol, Strube, Michael, Cole, Allen, and Kagehiro, Dorothy. 1985. The Impact of Case Characteristics and Prior Jury Experience on Jury Verdicts. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 15:409–427.Google Scholar
Williams, Joyce, and Holmes, Karen. 1981. The Second Assault: Rape and Public Attitudes. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar