Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T02:26:13.408Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Forked River Runs Through Law School: Toward Understanding Race, Gender, Age, and Related Gaps in Law School Performance and Bar Passage

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Timothy T. Clydesdale
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Analyses of the National Longitudinal Bar Passage Study (N = 27,478), demonstrate that law schools enlarge entering academic differences across race, age, disability, and socioeconomic origins rather than reduce them, and that academic differences in turn impact bar passage. Such differences cannot be reduced to (1) academic preparation, effort, or distractions; (2) instructional or law school-type characteristics; (3) social class; or (4) acceptance of an elitist legal ethos. Rather, results suggest that (1) women, minorities, and other atypical law students confront stigmatization throughout legal education;(2) for women (entering law school in 1991), this stigmatization is new, rejected, and consequently unassociated with law school outcomes; (3) for minorities, this stigmatization is continuous with prior socialization, making resistance difficult and consequent impact sizable; and (4) for other atypical law students, this stigmatization varies with visibility of difference, as do resistance and impact. Implications for social stigma theory and legal education are discussed.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 29 , Issue 4 , Autumn 2004 , pp. 711 - 769
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2004 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ABA Commission on Racial and Ethnic Diversity in the Profession. 2000. Miles to Go 2000: Progress of Minorities in the Legal Profession. Chicago: American Bar Association.Google Scholar
Banks, Lovell Taunya. 1988. Gender Bias in the Classroom. Journal of Legal Education 38(1–2): 137–46.Google Scholar
Becker, Howard S. 1963. Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Beh, Helen C. 1994. Gender Rivalry and Attitudes Toward Sex Roles: Changes Over a Fifteen-Year Period. Psychological Reports 74 (1): 188–90.Google Scholar
Bell, Derrick. 1994. Confronting Authority: Reflections of an Ardent Protester. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
Bell, Myrtle P., David Harrison, A., and Mary, E. McLaughlin. 1997. Asian American Attitudes toward Affirmative Action in Employment: Implications for the Model Minority Myth. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 33 (3): 356–77.Google Scholar
Benjamin, Andrew H. G., Alfred, Kaszniak, Bruce, Sales, Stephen, Shanfield B. 1986. The Role of Legal Education in Producing Psychological Stress among Law Students and Lawyers. American Bar Foundation Research Journal 2: 225–52.Google Scholar
Bentley, Bedford T. 1998. Blacks and the Bar Examination. Bar Examiner 67 (4): 7–8.Google Scholar
Berk, Richard A. 1983. An Introduction to Sample Selection Bias in Sociological Data. American Sociological Review 48: 386–98.Google Scholar
Bok, Derek C. 1983. A Flawed System of Law Practice and Training. Journal of Legal Education 33: 570–85.Google Scholar
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1984 Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste, trans. Richard, Nice. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
1988. Homo Academicus, trans Peter, Collier. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Bowen, William G., and Derek, Bok. 1998. The Shape of the River: Long-Term Consequences of Considering Race in College and University Admissions. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Bowers, Allison L. 2000. Women at the University of Texas School of Law: A Call for Action. Texas Journal of Women and the Law 9: 117–65.Google Scholar
Carnoy, Martin. 1994. Faded Dreams: The Politics and Economics of Race in America. Cambridge, U. K.: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Chambers, David L. 1990. Educational Debts and the Worsening Position of Small-Firm, Government, and Legal-Services Lawyers. Journal of Legal Education 39: 709–24.Google Scholar
Costello, Yang Carrie. 1998. Identity Dissonance: Gender, Identity and Professional Socialization at Law School. Proceedings of the American Sociological Association Annual Meeting. Washington, D.C.: American Sociological Association.Google Scholar
Crocker, J., Major, B., and Steele, C. 1998. Social Stigma. In Handbook of Social Psychology, ed. Gilbert, D. T., Fiske, S. T., and Lindzey, G., 4th ed., vol. 2, 504–53. Boston: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Cross, Theodore, and Bruce Slater, Robert. 1997. Why the End of Affirmative Action Would Exclude All But a Very Few Blacks From America'a Leading Universities and Graduate Schools. Journal of Blacks in Higher Education, Autumn, 8–17.Google Scholar
Curcio, Andrea A. 2002. A Better Bar: Why and How the Existing Bar Exam Should Change. Nebraska Law Review 81: 363–423.Google Scholar
DiMaggio, Paul. 1982. Cultural Capital and School Success: The Impact of Status Culture Participation on the Grades of U.S. High School Students. American Sociological Review 47: 189–201.Google Scholar
Dowd, Nancy E. 2003. Diversity Matters: Race, Gender, and Ethnicity in Legal Education. Florida Journal of Law and Public Policy 15: 11–56.Google Scholar
Duffy, Jennifer R., and Peter, J. Pashley. 2003. Analysis of Differential Prediction of Law School Performance Based on 1999–2001 Entering Law School Classes. Newtown, Penn.: Law School Admission Council.Google Scholar
Erlanger, H., and Klegnon, D. 1978. Socialization Effects of Professional School: The Law School Experience and Student Orientations to Public Interest Careers. Law and Society Review 13 11–35.Google Scholar
Erlanger, Howard S., Charles Epp, R., Mia, Cahill, and Kathleen, M. Haines. 1996. Law Student Idealism and Job Choice: Some New Data on an Old Question. Law and Society Review 30 851–64.Google Scholar
Ewing, Kimberly M., Tina Richardson, Q., James-Myers, Linda, and Richard, K. Russell. 1996. The Relationship Between Racial Identity Attitudes, Worldview, and African American Graduate Students'Experience of the Imposter Phenomenon. Journal of Black Psychology 22:53–66.Google Scholar
Foster, James C. 1981. The Cooling Out of Law Students. Law and Policy Quarterly 3: 243–56.Google Scholar
Gaber, Paula. 1998. Just Trying To Be Human in This Place: The Legal Education of Twenty Women. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism 10: 165–275.Google Scholar
Gibson, Margaret. 1997. Ethnicity and School Performance: Complicating the Immigrant/Involuntary Minority Typology. Special Issue: Anthropology and Education Quarterly 28(3).Google Scholar
Glen, Booth Kristin. 2002. When and Where We Enter: Rethinking Admission to the Legal Profession. Columbia Law Review 102: 1696–740.Google Scholar
Goffman, Erving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Gonzales, Patricia M., Hart, Blanton, and Kevin, J. Williams. 2002. The Effects of Stereotype Threat and Double-Minority Status on the Test Performance of Latino Women. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 28: 659–70.Google Scholar
Granfield, Robert. 1986. Legal Education as Corporate Ideology: Student Adjustment to the Law School Experience. Sociological Forum 1: 514–23.Google Scholar
1992. Making Elite Lawyers: Visions of Law at Harvard and Beyond. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
1994. Contextualizing the Different Voice: Women, Occupational Goals, and Legal Education. Law and Policy 16: 1–26.Google Scholar
Granneld, Robert, and Thomas, Koenig. 1990. From Activism to Pro Bono: The Redirection of Working Class Altruism at Harvard Law School. Critical Sociology 17: 57–80.Google Scholar
1992. Pathways into Elite Law Firms: Professional Stratification and Social Networks. Research in Politics and Society 4: 325–51.Google Scholar
Grillo, Trina, and Stephanie, M. Wildman. 1996. Obscuring the Importance of Race: The Implication of Making Comparisons between Racism and Sexism (or Other Isms). In Wildman 1996, 85–102. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Guinier, Lani, Michelle, Fine, and Jane, Balin. 1994. Becoming Gentlemen: Women'n Experiences at One Ivy League Law School. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 143: 1–110.Google Scholar
Gulati, Mitu, Richard, Sander, and Robert, Sockloskie. 2001. The Happy Charade: An Empirical Examination of the Third Year of Law School. Journal of Legal Education 51: 235–66.Google Scholar
Halaby, Andrew F., and Stephen, R. McAllister. 1997. An Analysis of the Supreme Court't Reliance on Racial “Stigma” as a Constitutional Concept in Affirmative Action Cases. Michigan Journal of Race and Law 2: 235–82.Google Scholar
Heatherton, Todd F., Robert Kleck, E., Michelle Hebl, R., Jay Hull, G., eds. 2000. The Social Psychology of Stigma. New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
Heckman, James. 1979. Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error. Econometrica 45: 153–61.Google Scholar
Howarth, Joan. 1997. Teaching in the Shadow of the Bar. University of San Francisco Law Review 31: 927–40.Google Scholar
Hunt, , Cecil, J. II. 1996. Guests in Another'r House: An Analysis of Racially Disparate Bar Performance. Florida State University Law Review 23: 721–93.Google Scholar
Jensen, Larry, and Robert, Christiansen. 1994. Finding Agreement among Women on Gender Issues. Psychological Reports 75(1, pt. 1): 35–44.Google Scholar
Jones, E. E., Farina, A., Hastorf, A. H., Miller, D. T., and Scott, R. A. 1984. Social Stigma: The Psychology of Marked Relationships. New York: Freeman.Google Scholar
Juan, Karin. 1994. The State of Asian Americans: Activism and Resistance in the 1990s. Boston: South End Press.Google Scholar
Kennedy, Duncan. 1970. How the Law School Fails: A Polemic. Yale Review of Law and Social Action 71: 1–21.Google Scholar
1983. Legal Education and the Reproduction of Hierarchy: A Polemic Against the Storm. Cambridge, Mass.: AFAR Press.Google Scholar
Kidder, William C. 2001. Comment: Does the LSAT Mirror or Magnify Racial and Ethnic Differences in Educational Attainment? A Study of Equally Achieving “Elite” College Students. California Law Review 89: 1055–124.Google Scholar
2003. The Struggle for Access from Sweatt to Grutter: A History of African American, Latino, and American Indian Law School Admissions, 1950–2000. Harvard Blackletter Law Journal 19: 1–42.Google Scholar
Kissam, Phillip C. 2003. The Discipline of Law Schools: The Making of Modern Lawyers. Durham, N.C.: Carolina Academic Press.Google Scholar
Klein, Stephen P. 1989. Bar Examinations: Ignoring the Thermometer Does Not Change the Temperature. New York State Bar Journal, October, 28–33.Google Scholar
1991. Disparities in Bar Exam Passing Rates among Racial/Ethnic Groups: Their Size, Source, and Implications. Thurgood Marshall Law Review 16: 517–29.Google Scholar
Klein, Stephen P., and Roger, Bolus. 1997. The Size and Source of Differences in Bar Exam Passing Rates among Racial and Ethnic Groups. Bar Examiner 66 (4): 8–16.Google Scholar
Komaromy, Miriam, Kevin, Grumbach, Michael, Drake, Karen, Vranizan, Nicole, Lurie, Dennis, Keane, and Andrew, Bindman. 1996. The Role of Black and Hispanic Physicians in Providing Health Care for Underserved Populations. New England Journal of Medicine 334: 1305–10.Google Scholar
Krauskopf, Joan M. 1994. Touching the Elephant: Perceptions of Gender Issues in Nine Law Schools. Journal of Legal Education 44: 311–40.Google Scholar
Kubey, Craig. 1976. Three Years of Adjustment: Where Your Ideals Go. Juris Doctor 6 (11): 34–39.Google Scholar
Law, Sylvia A. 1999. White Privilege and Affirmative Action. Akron Law Review 32: 603–27.Google Scholar
Lee, Stacey. 1994. Behind the Model-Minority Stereotype: Voices of High- and Low-Achieving Asian American Students. Anthropology and Education Quarterly 25: 413–29.Google Scholar
Lee, Yongsook. 1991. Koreans in Japan and the United States. In Minority Status and Schooling: A Comparative Study of Immigrant and Involuntary Minorities, ed. Margaret, Gibson and John, Ogbu, 131–67. New York: Garland Publishing.Google Scholar
Lemann, Nicholas. 1999. The Big Test: The Secret History of the American Meritocracy. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.Google Scholar
Lempert, Richard O., David Chambers, L., and Terry, K. Adams. 2000. Michigan'n Minority Graduates in Practice: The River Runs Through Law School. Law & Social Inquiry. 25: 395–505.Google Scholar
Lopez-Garza, Marta, and David, Diaz R., eds. 2001. Asian and Latino Immigrants in a Restructuring Economy. Palo Alto, Calif.: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Low, Victor. 1982. The Unimpressible Race: A Century of Educational Struggle by the Chinese in San Francisco. San Francisco: East-West Publishing.Google Scholar
Markus, Hazel Rose, Claude, Steele M., and Dorothy, M. Steele. 2000. Colorblindness as a Barrier to Inclusion: Assimilation and Nonimmigrant Minorities. Daedelus (Fall): 233–59.Google Scholar
Merritt, Deborah J., Lowell Hargens, L., and Barbara, F. Reskin. 2001. Raising the Bar: A Social Science Critique of Recent Increases to Passing Scores on the Bar Exam. University of Cincinnati Law Review 69: 929–68.Google Scholar
Merritt, Deborah J., and Barbara, F. Reskin. 1997. Sex, Race, and Credentials: The Truth about Affirmative Action in Law Faculty Hiring. Columbia Law Review 97: 199–300.Google Scholar
Mertz, Elizabeth, Wamucii, Njogu, and Susan, Gooding. 1998. What Difference Does Difference Make? The Challenge for Legal Education. Journal of Legal Education 48 (1): 1–87.Google Scholar
Min, Pyong. 1995. Asian Americans: Contemporary Trends and Issnes. Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
Moffatt, Michael. 1989. Coming of Age in New Jersey: College and American Culture. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Ogbu, John U. 1983. Minority Status and Schooling in Plural Societies. Comparative Education Review 27 (2): 168–90.Google Scholar
1987. Variability in Minority School Performance: A Problem in Search of an Explanation. Anthropology and Education Quarterly 18: 312–34.Google Scholar
Ogbu, John U., and Herbert, D. Simons. 1998. Voluntary and Involuntary Minorities: A Cultural-Ecological Theory of School Performance with Some Implications for Education. Anthropohgy and Education Quarterly 29 (2): 155–88.Google Scholar
Orneld, Gary, and Dean, Whitla. 2001. Diversity and Legal Education: Student Experiences in Leading Law Schools. In Diversity Challenged: Evidence on the Impact of Affirmative Action, ed. Gary, Orfield with Michal, Kurlaender. Cambridge, Mass.: Civil Rights Project, Harvard University, Harvard Education Publishing Group.Google Scholar
Pipkin, Ron. 1976. Legal Education: The Consumer'r Perspective. American Bar Foundation Research Journal 4: 11–61.Google Scholar
Ramsey, , Henry, Jr. 1998. Historical introduction to LSAC National Longitudinal Bar Passage Study, by Linda, F. Wightman, iii–vii. Newtown, Penn.: Law School Admission Council.Google Scholar
Raack, David W. 1991. Law School and the Erosion of Student Idealism. Journal of Legal Education 41: 121–43.Google Scholar
Ridley, Ellen S. 1998. Comments on the LSAC Bar Passage Study. Bar Emminer 67 (4): 11–12.Google Scholar
Saha, Sara Taggart H. Somnath, Miriam, Komaromy, and Andrew, B. Bindman. 2000. Do Patients Choose Physicians of Their Own Race? To Provide the Kind of Care Consumers Want, Medical Schools Might Be Able to Justify Using Race as an Admissions Criterion. Health Affairs 19 (4): 76–84.Google Scholar
Schuman, Howard, Charlotte, Steeh, Lawrence, Bobo, and Maria, Krysan. 1997. Racial Attitudes in America: Trends and Interpretations. Rev. ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Sherman, Paul J., and Janet, T. Spence. 1997. A Comparison of Two Cohorts of College Students in Responses to the Male-Female Relations Questionnaire. Psychology of Women Quarterly 21(2): 265–78.Google Scholar
Shih, Nalini Ambady Margaret, Jennifer, Richeson A., Kentara, Fujita, and Heather, M. Gray. 2002. Stereotype Performance Boosts: The Impact of Self-Relevance and the Manner of Stereotype Activation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83 (3): 638–47.Google Scholar
Soloranzo, David, Allen, Walter R., and Grace, Carroll. 2002. Keeping Race in Place: Racial Microaggressions and Campus Racial Climate at the University of California–Berkeley. Chicago-Latino Law Review 23: 15–111.Google Scholar
Spangler, Gordon M. Eve, and Ron, Pipkin. 1978. Token Women: An Empirical Test of Kanter'r Hypothesis. American Journal of Sociology 84: 160–70.Google Scholar
Stata Corp. 2001. Stata Statistical Software: Release 7.0. College Station, Texas: Stata Corporation.Google Scholar
Steele, Claude M. 1997. A Threat in the Air: How Stereotypes Shape Intellectual Identity and Performance. American Psychologist 52(June): 613–29.Google Scholar
1992. Race and the Schooling of Black Americans. Atlantic Monthly, April.Google Scholar
1999. Expert Report: The Compelling Need for Diversity in Higher Education. Michigan Journal of Race and Law 5: 241–59.Google Scholar
Steele, Claude M., and Joshua, Aronson. 1995. Stereotype Vulnerability and the Intellectual Test Performance of African Americans. Journal of Personality and Social Psychobgy 69: 797–811.Google Scholar
Stolzenberg, Ross M., and Daniel, A. Relles. 1997. Tools for Intuition About Sample Selection Bias and its Correction. American Sociological Review 62: 494–507.Google Scholar
Stover, Robert. 1989. Making It and Breaking It: The Fate of Public Interest Commitment During Law School. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Sturm, Susan, and Lani, Guinier. 1996. The Future of Affirmative Action: Reclaiming the Innovative Ideal. California Law Review 84: 953–1036.Google Scholar
Suzuki, Lisa A., Tamiko, Mogami, and Ellen, S. Kim. 2002. Interpreting Cultural Variations in Cognitive Profiles. In Asian American Mental Health: Assessment Theories and Methods, ed. Karen, Kurasaki S. and Sumie, Okazaki, 159–71. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.Google Scholar
Takaki, Ronald. 1989. Strangers From a Different Shore. New York: Little, Brown.Google Scholar
Thernstrom, Stephan. 1998. Diversity and Meritocracy in Legal Education: A Critical Evaluation of Linda F. Wightman'n “The Threat to Diversity in Legal Education. Constitutional Commentary 15(Spring): 11–43.Google Scholar
Thernstrom, Stephan, and Abigail, Thernstrom. 1997. America in Black and White: One Nation, Indivisible. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
Twenge, Jean M. 1997. Attitudes Toward Women, 1970–1995. Psychology of Women Quarterly 21(1): 35–51.Google Scholar
Valencia, Richard, ed. 1991. Chicano School Failure and Success: Research and Policy Agendas for the 1990s. London: Falmer Press.Google Scholar
Vaughns, Katherine L. 1998. LSACs National Study Findings on Bar Passage Rates: Do They Augur the End of Old Debates and Controversies about Discrepancies in Bar Passage Rates Among Ethnic Groups Bar Examiner 67 (4): 19–21.Google Scholar
Whitla, Dean, Gary, Orneld, William, Silen, Carole, Teperow, Carolyn, Howard, Joan, Reede. 2003. Educational Beneflts of Diversity in Medical School: A Survey of Students. Academic Medicine 78 (5): 460–66.Google Scholar
Wightman, Linda F. 1995. Legal Education at the Close of the Twentieth Century: Descriptions and Analyses of Students, Financing, and Professional Expectations and Attitudes. Newtown, Pa.: Law School Admission Council.Google Scholar
1996. Women in Legal Education: A Comparison of the Law School Performance and Law School Experiences of Women and Men. Newtown, Pa.: Law School Admission Council.Google Scholar
1997. The Threat to Diversity in Legal Education: An Empirical Analysis of the Consequences of Abandoning Race as a Factor in Law School Admission Decisions. New York University Law Review 72 (1): 1–53.Google Scholar
1998a. Are Other Things Essentially Equal: An Empirical Investigation of the Consequences of Including Race as a Factor in Law School Admission. Southwestern University Law Review 28 (1): 1–43.Google Scholar
1998b. LSAC National Longitudinal Bar Passage Study. Newtown, Pa.: Law School Admission Council.Google Scholar
1998c. Through a Difference Lens: A Reply to Stephan Thernstrom. Constitutional Commentary 15 (Spring): 45–56.Google Scholar
1999. User'r Guide: LSAC National Longitudinal Date File, Newtown, Pa.: Law School Admission Council.Google Scholar
2003. The Consequences of Race-Blindness: Revisiting Prediction Models with Current Law School Data. Journal of Legal Education 53: 229–53.Google Scholar
Wilder, Gita. 2002. Personal correspondence with the author, Aug. 29, 2002.Google Scholar
Wildman, Stephanie Armstrong, Margalynne, Adrienne, Davis D., and Trina, Grillo. 1996. Privilege Revealed: How lnvisible Preference Undermines America. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Wilkins, David B. 2000. Rollin on che River: Race, Elite Schools, and the Equality Paradox. Law &Social Inquiry 25: 527–56.Google Scholar
Wilkins, David B., and Mitu Gulati, G. 1996. Why Are There So Few Black Lawyers in Corporate Law Firms? An Institutional Analysis. California Law Reinew 84: 493–618.Google Scholar
Williams, Patricia J. 1991. The Alchemy of Race and Rights. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Wong, Paul, Faith Lai, Chieping, Richard, Nagasawa, and Tieming, Lin. 1998. Asian Americans as a Model Minority: Self-Perceptions and Perceptions by Other Racial Groups. Sociological Perspecnties 41 (1): 95–118.Google Scholar
Yu, Frederick Y. 1998. One Minority'y Reaction. Bar Examiner 67 (4): 22–23.Google Scholar
Zweigenhaft, Richard L., and William Domhoff, G. 1998. Diversity in the Power Elite: Have Women and Minorities Reached the Top? New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Zwick, Rebecca. 2002. Fair Game? The Use of Standardized Admissions Tests in Higher Education. New York: Routledge Falmer.Google Scholar