Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T04:16:52.817Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Failure of Feminism? Rape Law Reform in the Republic of Ireland, 1980–2017

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 November 2018

Ciara Molloy
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Based on Carol Smart's observation that rape law reform as lobbied for by the feminist movement during the 1970s and 1980s failed to achieve any meaningful change, this article seeks to examine the nature and implications of rape law reform in the Republic of Ireland from the 1980s to the present day. During the 1980s the conceptualization of rape changed from a proprietorial crime to a violation of individual bodily integrity due to feminist lobbying efforts and the emergence of a victim-centered approach in the criminal justice system. Though this changing conceptualisation has led to significant attitudinal change, particularly surrounding the issues of acquaintance and marital rape, procedural change has failed to secure higher conviction rates. In particular, this article demonstrates that the legal reforms achieved in the 1980s potentially resulted in a 2% decrease in rape conviction rates by 2007. When compared to England/Wales, conviction rates as distinctive from prosecution rates in Ireland remain chronically low. This indicates that any legal reforms must take account of the institutional bias ingrained the Irish criminal justice system against female rape complainants, which has continuing relevance for Irish legislation pertaining to sexual violence such as the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act, 2017. Overall this article suggests that rape is an exceptional crime and needs to be reassessed as such.

Type
Original Article
Information
Law and History Review , Volume 36 , Issue 4 , November 2018 , pp. 689 - 712
Copyright
Copyright © the American Society for Legal History, Inc. 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

She thanks Professor Richard McMahon of Mary Immaculate College, University of Limerick, for generously offering his time and expertise in refining the article's key arguments. She also thanks the two anonymous peer reviewers who engaged in a critical reading of this article and provided invaluable suggestions that greatly enhanced the overall manuscript. Finally, she also extends thanks to the Department of History in Trinity College Dublin where the initial research for this paper was carried out.

References

1. Smart, Carol, Feminism and the Power of Law (London: Routledge, 1989), 5Google Scholar.

2. Ibid.

3. See for example Henderson, Lynne, “Law's Patriarchy,” Law and Society Review 25 (1991): 411–44, at 431, 435CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4. Although adult male rape victims remain one of Ireland's hidden histories and tend to be relegated to a mere “dismissive footnote,” suggesting that this problem could be far more widespread than current statistics indicate, the majority of rape victims do appear to be female; Bourke, Joanna, Rape: A History from 1860 to the Present (London: Virago Press, 2007), 247Google Scholar. This article will, therefore, focus primarily on the experiences of female rape victims.

5. Anderson, Melisa, “Lawful Wife, Unlawful Sex—Examining the Effect of the Criminalization of Marital Rape in England and the Republic of Ireland,” Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law 27 (1998): 139–66, at 141Google Scholar.

6. O'Malley, Thomas, Sexual Offences: Law, Policy and Punishment (Dublin: Round Hall Sweet & Maxwell, 1996), 3Google Scholar; and Christina Ryan, “Judicial Attitudes in Rape and Sexual Assault Cases in the Republic of Ireland: Sentencing in the Appellate Courts” (MPhil diss., Trinity College Dublin, 1998), 23.

7. Hederman, Mary, “Irish Women and Irish Law,” The Crane Bag 4 (1980): 55–59, at 56Google Scholar; and Family Law Act, 1981, No. 22.

8. Mitra, Charlotte, “…For She Has No Right or Power to Refuse her Consent,” The Criminal Law Review 9 (1979): 558–65, at 559Google Scholar; and LeGrand, Camille, “Rape and Rape Laws: Sexism in Society and Law,” California Law Review 61 (1973): 919–41, at 925CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9. Ryan, Judicial Attitudes, 23.

10. Kelly, James, “‘A Most Inhuman and Barbarous Piece of Villainy’: An Exploration of the Crime of Rape in Eighteenth-Century Ireland,” Eighteenth-Century Ireland 10 (1995): 78–107, at 81Google Scholar.

11. O'Malley, Sexual Offences, 4.

12. Offences Against the Person Act, 1861 (24 & 25 Vict c 100).

13. Gorham, Deborah, “The ‘Maiden Tribute of Modern Babylon’ Re-examined: Child Prostitution and the Idea of Childhood in Late-Victorian England,” Victorian Studies 21 (1978): 353–79, at 353–54Google Scholar; and Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1885 (48 & 49 Vict. c 69).

14. Kennedy, Finola, “The Suppression of the Carrigan Report: A Historical Perspective on Child Abuse,” Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review 89 (2000): 354–63, at 358Google Scholar; and Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1935, No. 6.

15. Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, First Report (Dublin: Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, 1979), 7Google Scholar.

16. Archard, David, “The Wrong of Rape,” The Philosophical Quarterly 57 (2007): 374–33, at 378–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17. Giacopassi, David and Wilkinson, Karen, “Rape and the Devalued Victim,” Law and Human Behaviour 9 (1985): 367–83, at 368CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18. Anderson, Michelle J., “Marital Rape Laws Globally: Rationales and Snapshots Around the World,” in Marital Rape: Consent, Marriage and Social Change in Global Context, ed. Yllö, Kersti and Torres, M. Gabriela (New York: Oxford University Press, 2016), 177–86, at 178CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19. Married Women's Status Act, 1957, No. 5.

20. Murray, Thomas, Contesting Economic and Social Rights in Ireland: Constitution, State and Society, 1848–2016 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016), 283CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21. Gallagher, Michael, “The Changing Constitution,” in Politics in the Republic of Ireland, 5th ed., ed. Coakley, John and Gallagher, Michael (Abingdon: Taylor and Francis, 2010), 72–108, at 86Google Scholar; and Macmillan, Gretchen, “The Referendum, the Courts and Representative Democracy in Ireland,” Political Studies 40 (1992): 67–78, at 70–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22. O'Malley, Sexual Offences, 26.

23. Breen, Richard and Rottman, David B., Crime Victimisation in the Republic of Ireland (Dublin: Economic and Social Research Institute, 1985)Google Scholar; Kilcommins, Shane and Moffett, Luke, “The Inclusion and Juridification of Victims on the Island of Ireland,” in The Routledge Handbook of Irish Criminology, ed. Healy, Deirdre, Hamilton, Claire, Daly, Yvonne, and Butler, Michelle (Abingdon and New York: Routledge, 2016), 379–98, at 382Google Scholar; and Irish Independent, April 12, 1985.

24. O'Connor, Pat, Emerging Voices: Women in Contemporary Irish Society (Dublin: Institute of Public Administration, 1998), 76Google Scholar.

25. Galligan, Yvonne, Women and Politics in Contemporary Ireland: From the Margins to the Mainstream (London: A&C Black, 1998), 115Google Scholar.

26. Limerick Rape Crisis Centre, Limerick Rape Crisis Centre: Mid–West Region 1980–1995 (Limerick: Rape Crisis Centre, n.d.). Archives of Rape Crisis Midwest, uncatalogued; McKay, Susan, Without Fear: 25 Years of the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre (Dublin: New Island, 2005), 111Google Scholar; Irish Press, March 9, 1983; Irish Independent, September 20, 1986; and Irish Examiner, February 26, 1986.

27. Limerick Rape Crisis Centre, Aims of the Limerick Rape Crisis Centre for 1986/87 (Limerick: Rape Crisis Centre, n.d.). Archives of Rape Crisis Midwest, uncatalogued.

28. Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act, 1990, No. 32.

29. Lawrence, Robert R., “Checking the Allure of Increased Conviction Rates: The Admissibility of Expert Testimony on Rape Trauma Syndrome in Criminal Proceedings,” Virginia Law Review 70 (1984): 1657–705, at 1704Google Scholar.

30. Ferriter, Diarmaid, Occasions of Sin: Sex and Society in Modern Ireland, 2nd ed. (London: Profile Books, 2012), 112, 289Google Scholar.

31. Albrecht, Peter-Alexis, “The Functionalization of the Victim in the Criminal Justice System,” Buffalo Criminal Law Review 3 (1999): 91–107, at 95CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32. Bailey, Kimberly D., “Lost in Translation: Domestic Violence, ‘The Personal is Political,’ and the Criminal Justice System,” The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 100 (2010): 1255–300, at 1259–60Google Scholar.

33. Irish Independent, April 14, 1988.

34. Irish Examiner, May 14, 1988.

35. DPP v Tiernan (1988) IR 250.

36. Ibid.

37. Brownmiller, Susan, Against Our Will: Men, Women and Rape (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1975), 14–15Google Scholar; and Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, First Report, 3.

38. DPP v Tiernan (1988) IR 250.

39. Fennell, Caroline, “Criminal Law and the Criminal Justice System: Woman as Victim,” in Gender and the Law in Ireland, ed. Connelly, Alpha (Dublin: Oak Tree Press, 1993), 151–70, at 159Google Scholar.

40. Ibid., 166; Temkin, Jennifer, and Krahé, Barbara, Sexual Assault and the Justice Gap: A Question of Attitude (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2008), 31–32Google Scholar; and Hanly, Conor, Healy, Deirdre, and Scriver, Stacey, Rape and Justice in Ireland: A National Study of Survivor, Prosecutor and Court Responses to Rape (Dublin: The Liffey Press, 2009), 28Google Scholar.

41. Groth, Nicholas, Men Who Rape: The Psychology of the Offender (New York: Basic Books, 1979), 8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42. Fennell, “Criminal Law,” 166.

43. Criminal Justice Act, 1993, No.6, Section 2 and Section 5.

44. McCormack, Micheline, ‘Little Girl’: The Lavinia Kerwick Story (Dublin: McCormack Books, 1997), 57, 73Google Scholar.

45. Ibid., 78, 90.

46. Rob Jerrard, “Marital Rape,” The Police Journal October (1992): 340–43, at 340.

47. McMullan, Sinead, “Marital Rape in Irish Law,” Irish Student Law Review 3 (1993): 85–95, at 86Google Scholar.

48. Ryder, Sandra L. and Kuzmenka, Sheryl A., “Legal Rape: The Marital Exemption,” The John Marshall Law Review 24 (1991): 393–421, at 395Google Scholar.

49. Anderson, “Lawful Wife,” 151–154; McMullan, “Marital Rape,” 86; and O'Malley, Sexual Offences, 48.

50. Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act, 1990, No. 32.

51. Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, First Report, 4; and Irish Press, June  29, 1982.

52. Irish Independent, September 5, 1986.

53. Russell, Diana, Rape in Marriage (Bloomington and Indianapolis, IN: Indiana University Press, 1982), 87Google Scholar.

54. Ferriter, Diarmaid, Ambiguous Republic: Ireland in the 1970s (London: Profile Books, 2012), 356Google Scholar.

55. Jung, Patricia Beattie, “Sexual Pleasure: A Roman Catholic Perspective on Women's Delight,” Theology and Sexuality 12 (2000): 26–47, at 27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

56. Ferriter, Occasions of Sin, 439.

57. Sunday Independent, December 12, 1993.

58. Irish Press, December 13, 1993; Irish Independent, January 31, 2006; Irish Examiner, July 26, 2016; and Irish Independent, December 21, 2016.

59. Irish Times, May 23, 2016.

60. Ministry of Justice, Home Office and the Office for National Statistics, An Overview of Sexual Offending in England and Wales (London: The Stationery Office, 2013), 44Google Scholar.

61. Temkin and Krahé, Sexual Assault, 25.

62. Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act, 1990, No. 32; Bacik, Ivana, Maunsell, Catherine, and Gogan, Susan, The Legal Process and Victims of Rape: A Comparative Analysis of the Laws and Legal Procedures Relating to Rape, and their Impact upon Victims of Rape, in the Fifteen Member States of the European Union (Dublin: Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, 1998), 40Google Scholar.

63. Ibid., 248.

64. Hayden, Jackie, In Their Own Words: Coping with Rape and Sexual Abuse (Dublin: Hot Press Books, 2003), 72Google Scholar.

65. Evening Herald, January 5, 1977.

66. Flowe, Heather D., Ebbeson, Ebbe B., and Putcha-Bhagavatula, Anila, “Rape Shield Laws and Sexual Behaviour Evidence: Effects of Consent Level and Women's Sexual History on Rape Allegations,” Law and Human Behaviour 31 (2007): 159–75, at 172CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; and Hanly, Healy, and Scriver, Rape and Justice in Ireland, xxix.

67. Rape Crisis Network of Ireland, Rape and Justice in Ireland: An Introduction and Executive Summary, 2009. http://www.rcni.ie/wp-content/uploads/Exec-Summary.pdf (May 29, 2018).

68. Fennell, “Criminal Law,” 168.

69. Walby, Sylvia, Theorizing Patriarchy (Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 1990), 142Google Scholar.

70. O'Donnell, Ian and O'Sullivan, Eoin, “The Politics of Intolerance—Irish Style,” British Journal of Criminology 43 (2003): 41–62, at 45CrossRefGoogle Scholar; O'Donnell, Ian, “Sex Crime in Ireland: Extent and Trends,” Judicial Studies Institute Journal 3 (2003): 89–106, at 98Google Scholar; and Office for National Statistics, Crime in England and Wales: Year ending September 2015. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/bulletins/crimeinenglandandwales/yearendingseptember2015 (February 26, 2017).

71. McGee, Hannah, Garavan, Rebecca, de Barra, Mairéad, Byrne, Joanne, and Conroy, Ronán, Sexual Abuse and Violence in Ireland Report (Dublin: Liffey Press, 2002), 128Google Scholar.

72. Rape Crisis Network of Ireland, National Rape Crisis Statistics, 2015, 21. https://www.rcni.ie/wp-content/uploads/RCNI-RCC-StatsAR-2015-1.pdf (May 30, 2018).

73. Leahy, Susan, “Reform of Irish Rape Law: The Need for a Legislative Definition of Consent,” Common Law World Review 43 (2014): 231–63, at 238CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

74. Ferriter, Occasions of Sin, 444.

75. O'Donnell, “Sex Crime,” 95.

76. Ibid.

77. Bacik, Maunsell, and Gogan, The Legal Process, 265.

78. Sara Parsons, “Crime Trends,” in The Routledge Handbook of Irish Criminology, 15–48, at 17.

79. Bacik, Maunsell, and Gogan, The Legal Process, 293.

80. Leahy, Susan, “Bad Laws or Bad Attitudes? Assessing the Impact of Societal Attitudes upon the Conviction Rate for Rape in Ireland,” Irish Journal of Applied Social Studies 14 (2014): 18–29Google Scholar.

81. Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act, 2017, No. 2.

82. Law Reform Commission, Rape and Allied Offences (Dublin: The Stationery Office, 1988), 9Google Scholar.

83. The author is indebted to the anonymous peer reviewer who drew attention to this issue.

84. Wängerud, Lena, “Women in Parliaments: Descriptive and Substantive Representation,” Annual Review of Political Science 12 (2009): 51–69, at 51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

85. Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act, 2017, No. 2.

86. Elaine Loughlin and Joyce Fegan, “Sexual Consent to Be Defined in Law,” Irish Examiner Online, January 25, 2017. http://www.irishexaminer.com/ireland/sexual-consent-to-be-defined-in-law-440644.html (December 8, 2017).

87. Kilcommins, Shane, “Crime Control, the Security State and Constitutional Justice in Ireland: Discounting Liberal Legalism and Deontological Principles,” The International Journal of Evidence and Proof 20 (2016): 326–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

88. Robin, Gerald, “Forcible Rape: Institutionalized Sexism in the Criminal Justice System,” Crime and Delinquency 23 (1977): 136–53, at 136CrossRefGoogle Scholar, emphasis added.

89. Sunday Independent, January 1, 2017.

90. Central Statistics Office, Review of the Quality of Crime Statistics 2016 (Dublin: The Stationery Office, 2016), 4Google Scholar.

91. Amir, Menachem, Patterns in Forcible Rape (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1971), 259, 266Google Scholar.

92. Burt, Martha, “Cultural Myths and Supports for Rape,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 38 (1980): 217–30CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Payne, Diana, Lonsway, Kimberly, and Fitzgerald, Louise, “Rape Myth Acceptance: Exploration of Its Structure and Its Measurement Using the Illinois Rape Myth Acceptance Scale,” Journal of Research in Personality 33 (1999): 27–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Grubb, Amy and Turner, Emily, “Attribution of Blame in Rape Cases: A Review of the Impact of Rape Myth Acceptance, Gender Role Conformity and Substance Use on Victim Blaming,” Aggression and Violent Behaviour 17 (2012): 443–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

93. Bryden, David and Lengnick, Sonja, “Rape in the Criminal Justice System,” The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 87 (1997): 1194–384, at 1262CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

94. Wolfgang, Martin, “Victim Precipitated Criminal Homicide,” The Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science 48 (1957): 1–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

95. Hanly, Healy, and Scriver, Rape and Justice; Rape Crisis Network of Ireland, National Rape Crisis Statistics, 2013, 22–23. http://www.rcni.ie/wp-content/uploads/RCNI-National-Statistics-2013.pdf (January 8, 2017).

96. Fennell, Criminal Law, 167–68.

97. Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act, 1990, No. 32.

98. Dáil Éireann Debate, November 13, 1990, Vol. 402 No. 5 (1292–1293).

99. Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, First Report, 3.

100. Dáil Éireann Debate, November 13, 1990, Vol. 402 No. 5 (1289).