Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dlnhk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T21:42:09.144Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Waiting for the Forest Law: Resource-Led Development and Environmental Politics in Chile

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 October 2022

Roger Alex Clapp
Roger Alex Clapp*
Affiliation:
University of Toronto
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Chile has gained a reputation as the Latin American economic success story of the 1990s. Domestic savings rates are high, foreign investment continues to expand, inflation remains single-digit, and economic growth has averaged 6 percent annually from 1984 to 1995. In the seven years of democratic government since 1989, the poor have begun to share some of the benefits of this growth. From 1989 to 1993, unemployment fell from 12.2 percent to 4.9 percent, and social expenditures increased by a third in real terms (Hojman 1995). But Chile's impressive recent record of sustained economic development coupled with improvements in social justice has incurred significant environmental costs that raise doubts about the ecological sustainability of the Chilean model (Meller, O'Ryan, and Solimano 1996).

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Research Review , Volume 33 , Issue 2 , 1998 , pp. 3 - 36
Copyright
Copyright © 1998 by the University of Texas Press

Footnotes

∗

I am grateful to Carolyn Crook, Joe McBride, Jim Parsons, Dick Walker, and Michael Watts for their helpful comments. I also thank three anonymous LARR referees, whose careful reading and suggestions have substantially improved this study. Remaining errors of fact and interpretation are my responsibility. This article draws on dissertation research funded by the Inter-American Foundation and the Institute for the Study of World Politics, whose support is gratefully acknowledged.

References

Adams, W. M. 1995 “Sustainable Development?” In Geographies of Global Change, edited by R. J. Johnston, P. Taylor, and Watts, M., 354–73. Cambridge, Mass.: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Altamirano, Gregorio 1995 Perspectivas para la exportación de productos forestales prevenientes del bosque nativo chileno. Chile Forestal Documento Técnico no. 89.Google Scholar
Angell, Alan, and Pollack, Benny 1995 “The Chilean Elections of 1993: From Polarisation to Consensus.” Bulletin of Latin American Research 14, no. 2:105–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
BaÑAdos, Angelica 1991a “A paso acelerado avanza Forestal Anchile.” Chile Forestal, no. 180.Google Scholar
BaÑAdos, Angelica 1991b “Un complejo forestal con miras al futuro.” Chile Forestal, no. 181.Google Scholar
Cabello, Antonio 1991 “Consorcio francés invierte en bosque nativo.” Chile Forestal, no. 182.Google Scholar
Cardoso, Fernando, and Faletto, Enzo 1979 Dependency and Development in Latin America. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press (first published in Spanish in 1971).Google Scholar
Cavieres, A., Martner, G., Molina, R., and Paeile, V. 1986 “Especialización productiva, medio ambiente y migraciones: El caso del sector forestal chileno.” Agricultura y Sociedad 4:31–95.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1990a Chile Forestal, no. 149.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1990b Chile Forestal, no. 171.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1990c Chile Forestal, no. 172.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1990d Chile Forestal, no. 175.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1990e Chile Forestal, no. 176.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1991a Chile Forestal, no. 184.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1991b Chile Forestal, no. 186.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1992 Chile Forestal, no. 193.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1994a “La silvicultura no es un costo.” Chile Forestal, no. 215:32–34.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1994b “Un labrador de ciudad.” Chile Forestal, no. 216:20–23.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1994c “El año del despegue.” Chile Forestal, no. 223:14–17.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1995b “El sector desde una óptica diferente.” Chile Forestal, no. 226:20–23.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1995c “Aprobada con distinción.” Chile Forestal, no. 227:22–25.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1995d “Volumen exportado principales clientes.” Chile Forestal, no. 229:43.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1995e “Vigorosa marcha.” Chile Forestal, no. 233:8–11.Google Scholar
CHILE FORESTAL 1995f “Un ejercicio perfectible.” Chile Forestal, no. 234:8–10.Google Scholar
Clapp, Roger Alex 1993 “The Forest at the End of the World: The Transition from Old Growth to Plantation Forestry in Chile.” Ph.D. diss., University of California, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Clapp, Roger Alex 1995a “Creating Competitive Advantage: Forest Policy as Industrial Policy in Chile.” Economic Geography 71, no. 3:273–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clapp, Roger Alex 1995b “The Unnatural History of the Monterey Pine.” Geographical Review 85, no. 1:1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clapp, Roger Alex n.d. “Do Replacement Forests Leave Any Originals Behind? Tree Farming and Forest Conservation in Chile.” Manuscript.Google Scholar
CODEFF (COMITE DE DEFENSA DE LA FLORA Y FAUNA) 1990 “Posición de CODEFF sobre el Proyecto Forestal Corral de la empresa Terranova (CAP/MARUBENI).” CODEFF in-house document, Santiago.Google Scholar
Contreras, Rodolfo 1989 Más allá del bosque. Santiago: Amerinda.Google Scholar
CORMA (CORPORACION DE MADERA) 1991 Chile, país forestal. Santiago: CORMA and the Departamento del Bosque Nativo.Google Scholar
Cruz, Maria Elena, and Rivera, Rigoberto 1983 La realidad forestal chilena. Santiago: Grupo de Investigaciones Agrarias (GIA).Google Scholar
Darwin, Charles 1988 Beagle Diary, edited by Keynes, Richard. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Diaz-Vaz, Juan, Devlieger, Francis, Poblete, Hernan, and Juacida, Roberto 1989 Maderas comerciales de Chile. Valdivia: Marisa Cuneo.Google Scholar
Donoso, Claudio 1983 “Modificaciones del paisaje chileno a lo largo de la historia.” In Simposio Desarrollo y Perspectivas de las Disciplinas Forestales, 365–438. Valdivia: Universidad Austral de Chile.Google Scholar
Donoso, Claudio 1989 “Antecedentes básicos para la silvicultura del tipo forestal siempreverde.” Bosque 10, no. 1:37–53.Google Scholar
Donoso, P., Monfil, T., Otero, L., and Barrales, L. 1993 “Estudio de crecimiento de plantaciones y renovales manejados de especies nativas en el área andina de las provincias de Cautín y Valdivia.” Ciencia e Investigación Forestal 7, no. 2:253–88.Google Scholar
FAO (UNITED NATIONS FOOD AND AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION) 1991 Chile: Análisis de la contribución forestal al desarrollo nacional. Santiago: FAO.Google Scholar
FEMAT (FOREST ECOSYSTEM MANAGEMENT ASSESSMENT TEAM) 1993 Forest Ecosystem Management: An Ecological, Economic, and Social Assessment. Portland, Ore.: U.S. Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Gallardo, Enrique 1989 “Legislación sobre protección de la flora arborea y arbustiva nativa de Chile.” In Libro rojo de la flora terrestre de Chile, edited by Ivan Benoit. Santiago: Corporación Nacional Forestal (CONAF).Google Scholar
Grosse, Hans 1989 “Renovales de raulí, roble, coigüe y tepa.” Ciencia e Investigación Forestal 3, no. 6: 37–71.Google Scholar
Grosse, Hans 1993 “Tranformación de bosques nativos degradados en Chile.” Ciencia e Investigación Forestal 7, no. 1:135–58.Google Scholar
GÜEll, Guillermo 1990 “Políticas forestales: Una visión del sector privado.” Santiago: Corporación de Madera.Google Scholar
Gwynne, Robert 1993 “Non-Traditional Export Growth and Economic Development: The Chilean Forestry Sector since 1974.” Bulletin of Latin American Research 12, no. 2:147–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haig, Irving, and Teesdale, L. V. 1946 Forest Resources of Chile as a Basis for Industrial Expansion. Santiago: Corporación de Fomento (CORFO).Google Scholar
Harding, Lee 1994 “Threats to Diversity of Forest Ecosystems in British Columbia.” In Biodiversity in British Columbia, edited by Harding, Lee and Mccullum, Emily, 245–77. Victoria, B.C.: Environment Canada.Google Scholar
Hartmann, Lars 1956 “La industria forestal y sus posibilidades de desarrollo en la explotación de los bosques chilenos.” Santiago: FAO, Ministerio de Tierras y Colonizaciones, Dirección de Bosques.Google Scholar
Hartwig, Fernando 1990 “The Natural Forest Economy of Chile.” Plant Research and Development, no. 31.Google Scholar
Hartwig, Fernando 1991 Chile: Desarrollo forestal sustentable. Santiago: Los Andes.Google Scholar
Hoffmann, Adriana 1991 Flora silvestre de Chile: Zona araucana. Santiago: Fundación Claudio Gay.Google Scholar
Hojman, David 1995 “Chile under Frei (Again): The First Latin American Tiger—or Just Another Cat?” Bulletin of Latin American Research 14, no. 2:127–42.Google Scholar
Hueck, Kurt 1978 Los bosques de Sudamérica, Spanish translation from the German. Munich: German Society for Technical Cooperation.Google Scholar
Hunter, L. A. J. 1987 The Chilean Forestry Sector. Information Paper no. 2. Wellington: New Zealand Forestry Council.Google Scholar
INFOR (INSTITUTO FORESTAL) 1986 El consumo industrial de leña, 1983. Santiago: INFOR.Google Scholar
INFOR (INSTITUTO FORESTAL) 1993 Estadísticas Forestales 1993. Boletín Estadístico, no. 17. Santiago: INFOR.Google Scholar
INFOR (INSTITUTO FORESTAL) 1994 Estadísticas Forestales 1994. Boletín Estadístico, no. 18. Santiago: INFOR.Google Scholar
Johnson, Ronald, and Libecap, Gary 1980 “Efficient Markets and Great Lakes Timber: A Conservation Issue Re-examined.” Explorations in Economic History 17:372–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laarman, J., and Sedjo, R. 1992 Global Forests: Issues for Six Billion People. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Lara, Antonio 1985 “Los ecosistemas forestales en el desarrollo de Chile.” Ambiente y Desarrollo 1, no. 3.Google Scholar
Lara, Antonio, Araya, Leonardo, Capella, Juan, Fierro, Mauricio, and Cavieres, Aaron 1989 “Evaluación de la destrucción y disponibilidad de los recursos forestales nativos en la VII y VIII region.” Chile Piensa a Chile: Tercero Encuentro Científico sobre el Medio Ambiente, vol. 1. Concepción: CEPAL.Google Scholar
Lara, Antonio, and Cavieres, Aaron 1983 “La destrucción del bosque nativo para efectuar plantaciones de pineo insigne, en la cuenca del Río Cañicura, Comuna de Quilleco, Prov. de Biobio, VIII Región.” CODEFF in-house document, Santiago.Google Scholar
Lara, Antonio, and Veblen, Thomas 1993 “Forest Plantations in Chile: A Successful Model?” In Afforestation: Policies, Planning, and Progress, edited by Mather, Alexander, 118–39. Boca Raton, Fla.: Belhaven.Google Scholar
Lele, Sharachandra 1991 “Sustainable Development: A Critical Review.” World Development 19, no. 6:607–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leslie, Andrew 1987a “A Second Look at the Economics of Natural Management Systems in Tropical Mixed Forests.” Unasylva 39, no. 155:46–58.Google Scholar
Leslie, Andrew 1987b “International Logic of a High-Value Policy.” In Prospects for Australian Hardwood Forests, edited by Dargavel, J. and Sheldon, G. Canberra: Center for Resource and Environmental Studies.Google Scholar
Lindenmayer, David, and Norton, Tony 1994 “The Conservation of Leadbeater's Possum in Southeastern Australia and the Northern Spotted Owl in the Pacific North-West of the USA: Management Issues, Strategies, and Lessons.” Pacific Conservation Biology, no. 1:13–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marchar, Patricia 1995 Logging the Globe. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.Google Scholar
Meller, Patricio, O'Ryan, Raul, and Solimano, Andres 1996 “Growth, Equity, and the Environment in Chile: Issues and Evidence.” World Development 24, no. 2:255–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merino, Ricardo 1994 “Recuperación de Bosque Nativo: Un imperativo ético y técnico.” Chile Forestal, no. 220:14–15.Google Scholar
Montaldo, Patricio, and Medel, Fernando 1986 “Características agroclimáticas del sector Malleco a Llanquihue, Chile.” Agro Sur 14, no. 2:114–26.Google Scholar
Morales, Jorge 1989 La industria forestal en Concepción. Santiago: Grupo de Estudios Agrarias (GEA).Google Scholar
Norton, Tony, and Mitchell, Neil 1994 “Toward the Sustainable Management of Southern Temperate Forest Ecosystems: Lessons from Australia and New Zealand.” Pacific Conservation Biology 1:293-300.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oberdorfer, Erich 1960 “Pflanzensoziologische Studien in Chile: Ein Vergleich mit Europa.” Flora et Vegetatio Mundi, no. 2:1–208.Google Scholar
Panayotou, Theodore, and Ashton, Peter 1992 Not by Timber Alone: Economics and Ecology for Sustaining Tropical Forests. Washington, D.C.: Island.Google Scholar
Penna, Ian 1992 Japan's Paper Industry: An Overview of Its Structure and Market Trends. Tokyo: Chikyu no Tomo and Friends of the Earth Japan, Asia-Pacific Conservation Project.Google Scholar
Perez Rosales, Vicente 1882 Recuerdos del pasado. Santiago: Diario La Epoca (reprinted in 1970 by Francisco de Aguirre in Buenos Aires).Google Scholar
Quintanilla, Victor 1983 Geografía de Chile: Biogeografía. Santiago: Instituto Geográfico Militar.Google Scholar
Ramirez, Carlos 1987 “El género Nothofagus y su importancia en Chile.” Bosque 8, no. 2:71–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ramirez, Carlos, and Figueroa, Heriberto 1987 “Fitosociología de los Nothofagus de la zona higromórfica chilena.” Bosque 8, no. 2:127–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raven, Peter, and Axelrod, Daniel 1975 “History of the Flora and Fauna of Latin America.” American Scientist, no. 63:420–29.Google Scholar
Rivadeneira, Roberto 1995 “Diputado Jaime Naranjo: ‘Debe prevalecer la sensatez.‘” Chile Forestal, no. 230:20–23.Google Scholar
Roche, Michael 1990 History of Forestry. Wellington: New Zealand Forestry Corporation.Google Scholar
Rosales, Diego 1878 Historia general del Reyno de Chile. Santiago: El Mercurio.Google Scholar
Salas, Raul 1991 “El alerzal de la Cordillera de Saraos.” Paper presented to the II Congreso Internacional sobre Recursos Naturales, Valdivia.Google Scholar
Schmidt, Harald 1989 “El papel de la silvicultura en el desarrollo sustentable de los bosques naturales productores de madera.” Ambiente y Desarrollo 5, no. 3.Google Scholar
Schmidt, Harald, and Lara, Antonio 1985 “Descripción y potencialidad de los bosques nativos de Chile.” Ambiente y Desarrollo 1, no. 2:91–108.Google Scholar
SchmithÜSen, Josef 1960 “Die Nadelhülzer in den Waldgesellschaften der südlichen Anden.” Vegetatio 9 (published in The Hague).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stier, Jeffrey 1990 “The World Eucpulp Industry and Its Impact on the Northern U.S. Pulp and Paper Industry.” Northern Journal of Applied Forestry 7, no. 4:158–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stolzenbach, Carlos 1979 “Reafforestation with Indigenous Tree Species of a Chilean State Forest in the Southern Andes.” Plant Research and Development 10.Google Scholar
TERRANOVA 1990 Minuta técnica: Descripción general del Proyecto Forestal Corral. Valdivia: Terranova Departamento de Estudios.Google Scholar
Troncoso, Paula 1995 “Subsidio estatal recuperara al bosque nativo.” Chile Forestal, no. 224:21–23.Google Scholar
Veblen, Thomas 1980 “Structure and Dynamics of Old-Growth Nothofagus Forests in the Valdivian Andes, Chile.” Journal of Ecology 68, no. 1:1–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Veblen, Thomas 1982a “Natural Hazards and Forest Resources in the Andes of South-Central Chile.” Geojournal 6, no. 2:141–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Veblen, Thomas 1982b “Regeneration Patterns in Araucaria araucana Forests in Chile.” Journal of Biogeography 9:11–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Veblen, Thomas, and Ashton, D. H. 1982 “The Regeneration Status of Fitzroya cupressoides in the Cordillera Pelada, Chile.” Biological Conservation 23, no. 2:141–61.Google Scholar
Veblen, Thomas, Donoso, Claudio, Kitzberger, Thomas, and Rebertus, Alan 1996 “Ecology of Southern Chilean and Argentinean Nothofagus Forests.” In The Ecology and Biogeography of Nothofagus Forests, edited by Thomas Veblen, Robert Hill, and Read, Jennifer, 293-353. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Veblen, Thomas, Donoso, Claudio, Schlegel, Federico, and Escobar, Bernardo 1981 “Forest Dynamics in South-Central Chile.” Journal of Biogeography 8:211–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Veblen, Thomas, and Schlegel, Federico 1982 “Reseña ecológica de los bosques del sur de Chile.” Bosque 4, no. 2:73–115.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Villarreal, Rene 1990 “The Latin American Strategy of Import Substitution: Failure of Paradigm for the Region?” In Manufacturing Miracles, edited by Gereffi, Gary and Wyman, Donald, 292-332. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Vincent, Jeffrey, and Binkley, Clark 1992 “Forest-based Industrialization: A Dynamic Perspective.” In Managing the World's Forests, edited by Narendra Sharma, 93–137. Dubuque, Iowa: Kendall-Hunt.Google Scholar
Von Buch, Max 1990 “The Influence of Volcanic Eruptions and Quakes on Soils of South Chile.” Plant Research and Development 31.Google Scholar
Whitehead, Laurence 1986 “Whatever Became of the Southern Cone Model?” In Chile after 1973: Elements for the Analysis of Military Rule, edited by Hojman, David, 9–30. Liverpool, Engl.: Center for Latin American Studies, University of Liverpool.Google Scholar
Wisecarver, Daniel, and Tardones, Sergio 1989 “El sector forestal chileno: Políticas, desarrollo del recurso y exportaciones.” Ciencia e Investigación Forestal 3, no. 6:1–22.Google Scholar
Yudelevich, Moises, Brown, Charles, Elgueta, Hernan, and Calderon, Sergio 1967 Clasificación preliminar del bosque nativo de Chile. INFOR Informe Técnico no. 27. Santiago: Instituto Forestal.Google Scholar
Zeitlin, Maurice 1984 The Civil Wars in Chile. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar