Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T20:30:41.794Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Reconstruction of Nineteenth-Century Politics in Spanish America: A Case for the History of Ideas

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 October 2022

Charles A. Hale
Charles A. Hale*
Affiliation:
University of Iowa
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The historiography of the nineteenth-century political process in latin America is in trouble. With the burgeoning of Latin American history as a professional activity, historians are increasingly “moving beyond” past politics to study social and economic themes. The traditional treatments of the nineteenth century, dedicated to glorifying or debunking heroic leaders, to perpetuating old partisan and ideological struggles, or even to presenting in a more detached way a minutely-detailed political narrative, have lost their allure. It is true, to the obvious consternation of the editors of the Handbook of Latin American Studies, that items in the traditional mold still abound. In Mexico, for example, the celebration of the centennial and sesquicentennial of the two heroic ages of liberalism, the Revolution for Independence and the Reforma, gave great impetus to political writing. Analogous historiographical stimulants can be found in other countries, sometimes where the heroism of the anniversaries is less clear. Yet the value of even the best of such work is increasingly called into question by professional historians.

Type
Topical Review
Information
Latin American Research Review , Volume 8 , Issue 2 , Summer 1973 , pp. 53 - 73
Copyright
Copyright © 1973 by the University of Texas Press

Footnotes

*

This article is a substantially revised version of a paper first given at the 1970 meeting of the Southern Historical Association, in Louisville. I am grateful to several colleagues for their helpful criticisms, especially Charles Gibson, Peter H. Smith, and Alan B. Spitzer.

References

Alberdi, Juan B. 1886 Fragmento preliminar al estudio del derecho. Obras completas 1. Buenos Aires (1st ed. 1837).Google Scholar
Amunategui Solar, Domingo 1946 La democracia en Chile. Teatro político (1810-1910). Santiago.Google Scholar
Anderson, Charles W. 1963 Bankers as Revolutionaries. In: The Political Economy of Mexico: Two Studies by William P. Glade, Jr., and Charles W. Anderson. Madison.Google Scholar
Ashcraft, Richard 1972 Marx and Weber on Liberalism as Bourgois Ideology. Comparative Studies in Society and History (CSSH). 14: 130–168.Google Scholar
Baechler, Jean 1972 De l'ideologie. Annales. 27: 641–664.Google Scholar
Barager, Joseph R. 1959 The Historiography of the Río de la Plata Area since 1830. Hispanic American Historical Review (HAHR). 39: 588–642.Google Scholar
Barros Arana, Diego 1902 Historia jeneral de Chile. 16. Santiago.Google Scholar
Bauer, Arnold J. 1971 The Church and Spanish American Agrarian Structure: 1765-1865. The Americas. 28: 78–98.Google Scholar
Bergman, Gustav 1951 Ideology. Ethics. 61: 205–218.Google Scholar
Berkhofer, Robert F. Jr. 1969 A Behavioral Approach to Historical Analysis. New York.Google Scholar
Bilbao, Francisco 1897 El evanjelio americano. Obras completas. 1. Santiago (1st ed. 1864).Google Scholar
Birnbaum, Norman 1960 The Sociological Study of Ideology (1940-60): A Trend Report and Bibliography. Current Sociology. 9: 91–172.Google Scholar
Bourricaud, François 1972 The Adventures of Ariel. Daedalus. 101: 109–136.Google Scholar
Chevalier, François 1965 Conservateurs et liberaux au Mexique. In: La intervención francesa y el imperio de Maximiliano. México.Google Scholar
Cockcroft, James D. 1968 Intellectual Precursors of the Mexican Revolution, 1900-1913. Austin.Google Scholar
Collier, Simon 1967 Ideas and Politics of Chilean Independence, 1808-1833. Cambridge, England. Cosio Villegas, Daniel et al. 1955-1972 Historia moderna de México. 9 vols. México.Google Scholar
Dealy, Glen 1968 Prolegomena on the Spanish American Political Tradition. HAHR. 48: 37–58.Google Scholar
Donoso, Ricardo 1946 Las ideas políticas en Chile. México.Google Scholar
Dore, R. P. 1964 Latin America and Japan Compared. In: Continuity and Change in Latin America. J. J. Johnson ed. Stanford.Google Scholar
Echeverria, Esteban 1940 Dogma socialista. Buenos Aires (1st ed. 1839).Google Scholar
Edwards Vives, Alberto 1966 La fronda aristocrática. Santiago (1st ed. 1928).Google Scholar
Eyzaguirre, Jaime 1965 Fisonomía histórica de Chile. Santiago (1st ed. 1948).Google Scholar
Fuenzalida Grandon, Alejandro 1893 Lastarria i su tiempo. Santiago.Google Scholar
Gibson, Charles 1963 Colonial Institutions and Contemporary Latin America: Social and Cultural Life. HAHR. 43: 380–389.Google Scholar
Gillispie, Charles C. 1950 The Work of Elie Halévy: A Critical Appreciation. Journal of Modern History. 22: 232–249.Google Scholar
Glade, William P. Jr. 1969 The Latin American Economies. New York.Google Scholar
Grew, Raymond 1969 On Reading Six Books in Search of Another. CSSH. 11: 355–364.Google Scholar
Hale, Charles A. 1967 Review. HAHR. 47: 419–420.Google Scholar
Hale, Charles A. 1968 Mexican Liberalism in the Age of Mora, 1821-1853. New Haven and London.Google Scholar
Hale, Charles A. 1971 The History of Ideas: Substantive and Methodological Aspects of the Thought of Leopoldo Zea. Journal of Latin American Studies (JLAS). 3: 59–70.Google Scholar
Halevy, Elie 1928 The Growth of Philosophic Radicalism. London (1st ed. 1901-04).Google Scholar
Halevy, Elie 1965 Saint-Simonian Economic Doctrine. In: The Era of Tyrannies. E. Halévy. 1965 (1st ed. 1907).Google Scholar
Halperin, Donghi Tulio 1969 Historia contemporánea de América Latina. Madrid.Google Scholar
Halpern, Ben 1961 “Myth” and “Ideology” in Modern Usage. History and Theory. 1: 129–149.Google Scholar
Hartz, Louis 1955 The Liberal Tradition in America. New York.Google Scholar
Higham, John 1951 The Rise of American Intellectual History. American Historical Review. 56: 453–471.Google Scholar
Hirschman, A. O. 1961 Ideologies of Economic Development in Latin America. In: Latin American Issues: Essays and Comments. A. O. Hirschman ed. New York.Google Scholar
Jobet, Julio Cesar 1955 Ensayo crítico del desarrollo económico-social de Chile. Santiago.Google Scholar
Larson, Margali Sarfatti 1972 Notes on Technocracy: Some Problems of Theory, Ideology and Power. Berkeley Journal of Sociology. 17: 1–34.Google Scholar
Lastarria, Jose Victorino 1909 Investigaciones sobre la influencia social de la conquista i del sistema de los españoles en Chile. Obras completas. 7. Santiago (1st ed. 1844).Google Scholar
Lerminier, Jean-Louis-Eugene 1833 De l'influence de la philosophie du xviiie siècle sur la législation et la sociabilité du xixe. Paris.Google Scholar
Lichtheim, George 1967 The Concept of Ideology and Other Essays. New York.Google Scholar
Lovejoy, A. O. 1936 The Great Chain of Being. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Lockhart, James 1969 Encomienda and Hacienda: The Evolution of the Great Estate in the Spanish Indies. HAHR. 49: 413–429.Google Scholar
Lockhart, James 1972 The Social History of Colonial Spanish America: Evolution and Potential. LARR. 7: 6–45.Google Scholar
Lynch, John 1972 Review of Stein and Stein (1970). JLAS. 4: 319–320.Google Scholar
McAlister, Lyle N. 1963 Social Structure and Social Change in New Spain. HAHR. 43: 349–370.Google Scholar
Mannheim, Karl 1936 Ideology and Utopia. London.Google Scholar
Manuel, Frank E. 1956 The New World of Henri Saint Simon. Cambridge.Google Scholar
Matossian, Mary 1958 Ideologies of Delayed Industrialization. Some Tensions and Ambiguities. Economic Development and Cultural Change. 6: 217–228.Google Scholar
Merton, Robert K. 1949 The Sociology of Knowledge. In: Social Theory and Social Structure. R. K. Merton, ed. New York.Google Scholar
Meyer, Jean 1971 Review of S. Collier (1967). Revue Historique. 246: 231–234.Google Scholar
Meyers, Marvin 1963 Louis Hartz, The Liberal Tradition in America: An Appraisal. CSSH. 5: 261–268.Google Scholar
Moore, Barrington Jr. 1966 Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Boston.Google Scholar
Morse, Richard M. 1964 The Heritage of Latin America. In: The Founding of New Societies. L. Hartz ed. New York.Google Scholar
Newton, Ronald N. 1970 On “Functional Groups,” “Fragmentation,” and “Pluralism” in Spanish American Political Society. HAHR. 50: 1–29.Google Scholar
Phelan, John L. 1968 Pan-Latinism, French Intervention in Mexico (1861-1867) and the Genesis of the Idea of Latin America. In: Conciencia y autenticidad históricas. Mexico.Google Scholar
Quesada, Ernesto V. 1950 La epoca de Rosas. Buenos Aires (1st ed. 1898).Google Scholar
Raat, William D. 1967 Positivism in Diaz Mexico. Salt Lake City (Unpublished dissertation, University of Utah).Google Scholar
Romero, José Luis 1963 A History of Argentine Political Thought. Tr. and intro. by T. F. McGann. (1st Spanish language ed. 1946).Google Scholar
Safford, Frank 1972 Social Aspects of Politics in Nineteenth-Century Spanish America: New Granada, 1825-1850. Journal of Social History. 5: 344–370.Google Scholar
Sarmiento, Domingo F. 1961 Facundo. Buenos Aires (1st ed. 1845).Google Scholar
Silvert, Kalman H. 1963 The Cost of Anti-Nationalism: Argentina. In: Expectant Peoples: Nationalism and Development. K. H. Silvert ed. New York.Google Scholar
Silvert, Kalman H. 1966 Leadership Formation and Modernization in Latin America. Journal of International Affairs. 20: 318–331.Google Scholar
Sinkin, Richard N. 1973 The Mexican Constitutional Congress, 1856-1857: A Statistical Analysis. HAHR. 53: 1–22.Google Scholar
Smith, Peter H. 1970 Political Elites in Mexico: Social Mobility and Revolutionary Change (unpublished Research Report).Google Scholar
Smith, Peter H. 1972 The Making of the Mexican Constitution. Conference on the Use of Quantiative Methods in the Study of the History of Legislative Behavior. Iowa City. (Proceedings to be published.)Google Scholar
Spengler, Oswald 1928 The Decline of the West. 2. New York.Google Scholar
Stein, Stanley J. 1970 The Colonial Heritage of Latin America. New York.Google Scholar
Stein, Stanley J. and Barbara, H. 1964 Latin American Historiography: Status and Opportunities. In: Social Science Research on Latin America. C. Wagley ed. New York.Google Scholar
Veliz, Claudio J. 1967 The Politics of Conformity in Latin America. New York.Google Scholar
Veliz, Claudio J. 1968 Centralism and Nationalism in Latin America. Foreign Affairs. 47: 68–83.Google Scholar
Womack, John Jr. 1971 Mexican Political Historiography, 1959-1969. In: Investigaciones contemporáneas sobre historia de México. México.Google Scholar
Zea, Leopoldo 1963 The Latin American Mind. Norman (1st ed. 1949).Google Scholar
Zea, Leopoldo 1968 El positivismo en México. Mexico (1st ed. 1943).Google Scholar