Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-hvd4g Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-09T20:22:21.800Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Professionalization and Probity in a Patrimonial State: Labor Inspectors in the Dominican Republic

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

Andrew Schrank
Andrew Schrank*
Affiliation:
University of New Mexico. [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Are international labor rights campaigns making a difference in Latin America? This article reveals that Dominican policymakers and bureaucrats are responding to foreign pressure by redoubling their commitment to a distinctively Franco-Iberian model of labor law enforcement, in which skilled labor inspectors use their discretion to balance society's demand for protection with the economy's need for efficiency. In so doing, they provide an alternative to traditional collective bargaining practices—which at least partly decouples both the intensity of the enforcement effort and the degree of worker protection from the level of unionization—and an example for the rest of the region. The article therefore concludes by reconsidering the Central American experience in light of the Dominican findings and discussing their joint implications for our understanding of administrative reform, industrial relations, and globalization, not only in the so-called CAFTA countries but in Latin America more generally.

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 51 , Issue 2 , Autumn 2009 , pp. 91 - 115
Copyright
Copyright © University of Miami 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abrahamson, Peter. 2007. Free Trade and Social Citizenship: Prospects and Possibilities of the Central American Free Trade Agreement (Cafta-Dr). Global Social Policy 7, 3: 339–57.Google Scholar
Agencia Latinoamericana de Expertos en Planificación H., S.A. (ALEPH). 2002. Evaluación de sistemas de servicio civil. Santo Domingo : BID. August.Google Scholar
Albracht, Gerd. 2005. Integrated Labour Inspection Systems: the Strategy of the Ilo. Labour Education 3–4, 140–41: 67–73.Google Scholar
Alburquerque, Rafael. 1984 [1992]. Administración del salario minimo. In Estudios de derecho del trabajo, ed. Alburquerque, . Santo Domingo : Taller. 330–44.Google Scholar
Alburquerque, Rafael. 1998. El control de las normas del trabajo. In Procedimiento penal laboral, ed. Alburquerque, . Santo Domingo : FINJUS. 9–22.Google Scholar
Alburquerque, Rafael. 2003. Derecho del trabajo. Tomo I: Introducción: los sujetos del derecho del trabajo. Santo Domingo : EJTP.Google Scholar
Alburquerque, Rafael. 2005. La supervision administrativa de las normas de trabajo. Paper presented at workshop on Work Inspection and Labor Market Regulation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, January 21.Google Scholar
Amengual, Matthew. 2007. Dividing Labor Regulation. Paper presented at the 27th Congress of the Latin American Studies Association, Montréal, September 5–7.Google Scholar
American Federation of Labor–Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO). 2005. The Real Record on Workers' Rights in Central America. Washington, DC : AFL-CIO.Google Scholar
Anner, Mark. 2008. Meeting the Challenges of Industrial Restructuring: Labor Reform and Enforcement in Latin America. Latin American Politics and Society 50, 2 (Summer): 33–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aries, Paul. 1996. Inspection du travail et inspection ouvrière dans le discourse de la Cgt de la genèse de l'institution à l'entre deux guerres. Droit et Société 33: 389–404.Google Scholar
Auvergnon, Philipe. 2006. Some Lessons Drawn from a Comparative Approach to the Issue of the Effectiveness of Labour Law. Managerial Law 48, 3: 288–302.Google Scholar
Banco Central de la República Dominicana. 2003. Tasas de cambio promedio para compra y venta de divisas, 1991. June.Google Scholar
Beltré, Yanet. 2007. Una mafia. El Caribe, March 7.Google Scholar
Bensusán, Graciela. 2007. La efectividad de la legislación laboral en América Latina. Geneva : International Institute for Labour Studies.Google Scholar
Betcherman, Gordon, Luinstra, Amy, and Ogawa, Makoto. 2001. Labor Market Regulation: International Experience in Promoting Employment and Social Protection. Washington, DC : World Bank.Google Scholar
Bhagwati, Jagdish. 2007. Why Multinationals Help Reduce Poverty. World Economy 30, 2: 211–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bonoli, Giuliano. 2003. Social Policy through Labor Markets: Understanding National Differences in the Provision of Economic Security to Wage Earners. Comparative Political Studies 36, 9: 1007–30.Google Scholar
Braibanti, Ralph. 1976. The American Experience in Diffusing Administrative Technology. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 428 (November): 65–76.Google Scholar
Braithwaite, John. 2006. Responsive Regulation and Developing Economies. World Development 34, 5: 884–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pereira, Bresser, Carlos, Luis 1997. Managerial Public Administration: Strategy and Structure for a New State. Journal of Post-Keynesian Economics 20, 1: 7–23.Google Scholar
Pereira, Bresser, Carlos, Luis, and Spink, Peter. 1999. Reforming the State: Managerial Public Administration in Latin America. Boulder : Lynne Rienner.Google Scholar
Brown, Drusilla. 2007. Globalization and Employment Conditions Study. Social Protection Discussion Paper No. 0708. Washington : World Bank.Google Scholar
Castillo, Anina del. 2007. Asume el reto de promover el trabajo decente. Paper presented at the 15th Conferencia Interamericana de Ministros de Trabajo. Port of Spain, September 11–13.Google Scholar
Cepeda, Denisse. 2008a. Al trabajador hay que darle empleos dignos. Listín Diario (Santo Domingo), June 23.Google Scholar
Cepeda, Denisse. 2008b. Donde ir si tiene conflicto laboral. Listín Diario, April 14.Google Scholar
Clark, Linda. 1996. Review of Les voltigeurs de la république: l'inspection du travail en France jusqu'en 1914, by Vincent Viet. Journal of Social History 29, 4: 1010–13.Google Scholar
Cook, María Lorena. 2007. The Politics of Labor Reform in Latin America: Between Flexibility and Rights. University Park : Penn State Press.Google Scholar
Coolidge, Jacqueline. 2006. Reforming Inspections. Viewpoint Note no. 308. Washington, DC : World Bank. June.Google Scholar
Córdova, Efrén. 1975. Prospects for Harmonising Latin American Labour Law. International Labour Review 112, 4: 291–307.Google Scholar
Costa Rica. Ministerio de Trabajo y Seguridad Social (MTSS). 2005. Evaluación: Plan de Transformación de la Inspección de Trabajo: 2000–2005. San José : MTSS.Google Scholar
Daza, José Luis. 2005. Labour Inspection and the Informal Economy. Labour Education 3–4, 140–41: 15–21.Google Scholar
Dore, Ronald. 1975. The Prestige Factor in International Affairs. International Affairs 51, 2: 190–207.Google Scholar
Drumbl, Mark. 2007. Atrocity, Punishment, and International Law. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Elkin, Stephen. 1986. Regulation and Regime: a Comparative Analysis. Journal of Public Policy 6, 1: 49–71.Google Scholar
Espina, Alvaro. 2007. Modernización y estado de bienestar en España. Madrid : Fundación Carolina.Google Scholar
Estlund, Cynthia. 2006. The Death of Labor Law? Annual Review of Law and Social Science 2: 105–23.Google Scholar
Evans, Peter. 2005. Harnessing the State: Rebalancing Strategies for Monitoring and Motivation. In States and Development: Historical Antecedents of Stagnation and Advance, ed. Lange, Matthew and Rueschemeyer, Dietrich. London : Palgrave. 26–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fadul, José Ramón. 2006. Presentación. In Estadísticas laborales: Boletín No. 8. Santo Domingo : Secretaría de Estado de Trabajo. 7.Google Scholar
Farrell, Diana. 2006. Tackling the Informal Economy. Business Week, May 10: 3.Google Scholar
Fenwick, Colin, Howe, John, Marshall, Shelley, and Landau, Ingrid. 2007. Labour and Labour-Related Laws in Micro- and Small Enterprises: Innovative Regulatory Approaches. SEED Working Paper no. 81. Geneva : ILO.Google Scholar
Fox, John. 1953. Problems of Labour Administration in Latin America. International Labour Review 73: 225–40.Google Scholar
Frundt, Henry. 1998. Trade Conditions and Labor Rights: U.S. Initiatives, Dominican and Central American Responses. Gainesville : University Press of Florida.Google Scholar
Frundt, Henry. 2002. Central American Unions in the Era of Globalization. Latin American Research Review 37, 3: 7–53.Google Scholar
Fuentes, Alberto. 2007. A Light in the Dark: Labor Reform in Guatemala during the Frg Administration, 2000–2004. Unpublished thesis. Cambridge : Department of Urban Studies and Planning, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.Google Scholar
Fundación para la Paz y la Democracia (FUNPADEM). 2006a. En República Dominicana: importante avance en unificación de criterios para inspección laboral. Gacetilla No. 149. San José : FUNPADEM.Google Scholar
Fundación para la Paz y la Democracia (FUNPADEM). 2006b. República Dominicana colabora con inspecciones de trabajo de Nicaragua y El Salvador. Gacetilla No. 166. San José : FUNPADEM.Google Scholar
Fundación para la Paz y la Democracia (FUNPADEM). 2006c. República Dominicana: los derechos laborales marcan la diferencia. Cumplir para ganar. Boletín no. 1. March.Google Scholar
General Accounting Office (GAO). 1998. Worker Rights: Progress Made, But Enforcement Issues Remain. Washington, DC : GAO.Google Scholar
Gerth, Hans, and Wright Mills, C. 1946. From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. New York : Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Glenn, David. 2002. A Free Trader Today: Jagdish Bhagwati Reflects on a Combative Career. Chronicle of Higher Education 48, 29 (March 29): A14.Google Scholar
Goetz, Anne Marie, and Jenkins, Rob. 2002. Voice, Accountability, and Human Development: The Emergence of a New Agenda. Background Paper. New York : United Nations Development Programme, Human Development Report Office.Google Scholar
Golub, Stephen. 1997. Are International Labor Standards Needed to Prevent Social Dumping? Finance and Development, December: 20–23.Google Scholar
Gopalakrishnan, Ramapriya. 2007. Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining in Export Processing Zones: Role of the ILO Supervisory Mechanisms. International Labour Standards Department Working Paper no. 1. Geneva : ILO.Google Scholar
Grindle, Merilee. 2002. Review of Bresser Pereira and Spink 1999. Journal of Latin American Studies 34, 1: 179–81.Google Scholar
Henderson, Jeffrey, Hulme, David, Jalilian, Hossein, and Phillips, Richard. 2007. Bureaucratic Effects: “Weberian” State Agencies and Poverty Reduction. Sociology 41, 3: 515–32.Google Scholar
Heredia, Blanca, and Ross Schneider, Ben 2003. The Political Economy of Administrative Reform in Developing Countries. In Reinventing Leviathan: The Politics of Administrative Reform in Developing Countries, ed. Schneider, and Heredia, . Coral Gables : North-South Center Press. 1–29.Google Scholar
Hernández Rueda, Lupo. 1983. La situación laboral en la República Dominicana. In La situación laboral en la República Dominicana, ed. Moya Pons, Frank. Santo Domingo : FORUM. 11–16.Google Scholar
Hoekman, Bernard, and Özden, Çaglar. 2005. Trade Preferences and Differential Treatment of Developing Countries: A Selective Survey. Policy Research Working Paper 2566. Washington, DC : World Bank.Google Scholar
Hoferlin, Isabelle. 2005. Hard times for Labour Inspection. Labour Education 3–4, 140–41: 22–28.Google Scholar
Iacoviello, Mercedes, and Rodríguez-Gustá, Ana. 2006. Síntesis de diagnóstico: caso República Dominicana. In Informe de la situación del servicio civil en América Latina, ed. Echebarría, K.. Washington, DC : BID. 447–72.Google Scholar
International Labour Office. 1947. Labour Inspection Convention. Convention 81. Geneva : ILO.Google Scholar
International Labour Office. 2006. Labour Inspection. Report III, Part 1B. International Labour Conference, 95th Session. Geneva : ILO.Google Scholar
International Labour Office (OIT). 2008a. Informe de verificación de la implementación de las recomendaciones del libro blanco, período: agosto 2007–enero 2008. San José : OIT.Google Scholar
International Labour Office (OIT). 2008b. Verification Report on Implementation of White Paper Recommendations Is Published in Nicaragua. Information Sheet. April 30. San José : ILO.Google Scholar
International Labor Rights Fund (ILRF). 2004. A Report on Fundamental Labor Rights in the Export Processing Zones and Sugar Sector of the Dominican Republic. Washington, DC : ILRF.Google Scholar
Itzigsohn, José. 2000. Developing Poverty: The State, Labor Market Deregulation, and the Informal Economy in Costa Rica and the Dominican Republic. University Park : Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
Jatobá, Vera. 2002. Labour Inspection Within a Modernized Labour Administration. Lima : ILO.Google Scholar
Knack, Stephen. 2002. Social Capital and the Quality of Government: Evidence from the States. American Journal of Political Science 46, 4: 772–85.Google Scholar
Latinobarómetro, . 2005. Latinobarómetro 2005. Santiago : Latinobarómetro.Google Scholar
Lipsky, Michael. 1980. Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Lynn, Laurence. 2007. Public Management: A Concise History of the Field. In The Oxford Handbook of Public Management, ed. Ferlie, E. et al. New York : Oxford University Press. 27–51.Google Scholar
Marshall, Ray. 1990. Trade-Linked Labor Standards. Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science 37, 4: 67–78.Google Scholar
Montero, Gregorio. 2003. El servicio civil de carrera en Centroamérica y el Caribe: caso República Dominicana. 8 Congreso Internacional del CLAD sobre la Reforma del Estado y de la Administración Pública. Panama City, Panama, October 28–31.Google Scholar
Murillo, M. Victoria, and Schrank, Andrew. 2005. With a Little Help from My Friends: Partisan Politics, Transnational Alliances, and Labor Rights in Latin America. Comparative Political Studies 38, 8: 971–99.Google Scholar
Olivares, Iván, and Arróliga, Lourdes. 2007. Ministra Chávez define prioridades de Mitrab: “Derechos laborales en zonas francas. Confidencial, January 28–February 3.Google Scholar
Oficina Nacional de Planificación (ONAPLAN). 2002. Política social del gobierno dominicana. Vol. 1. Santo Domingo : ONAPLAN.Google Scholar
ONAP Informa (Santo Domingo). 2004. Avances en la reforma y modernización de la administración pública. April.Google Scholar
Organization of American States. 2008. Unpublished presentation on Dominican labor law reforms.Google Scholar
Oviedo, José, Brea, Ramonina, and Duarte, Isis. 2007. Indice de transparencia de las entidades públicas. Santo Domingo : Participación Ciudadana.Google Scholar
Palacio (Santo Domingo). 2008. Vicepresidente dictó conferencias en México y España. 4, 182: 6.Google Scholar
Panizza, Francisco. 2004. A Reform without Losers: the Symbolic Economy of Civil Service Reform in Uruguay, 1995–96. Latin American Politics and Society 46, 3 (Fall): 1–28.Google Scholar
Piore, Michael J. 1980. Economic Fluctuation, Job Security, and Labor-Market Duality in Italy, France, and the United States. Politics and Society 9 (January): 379–407.Google Scholar
Piore, Michael J. 2005. Rethinking International Labor Standards. In Labor and the Globalization of Production: Causes and Consequences, ed. Milberg, William. New York : Macmillan. 249–65.Google Scholar
Piore, Michael J., and Schrank, Andrew. 2006. Trading up: an Embryonic Model for Easing the Human Costs of Free Market. Boston Review 31, 5 (September–October): 11–14.Google Scholar
Piore, Michael J., and Schrank, Andrew. 2008. Toward Managed Flexibility: the Revival of Labour Inspection in the Latin World. International Labour Review 147, 1: 1–23.Google Scholar
Plasencia, Aleida. 2008. Los inspectores de trabajo no deben acceder a las nóminas. Periódico Hoy (Santo Domingo), July 3.Google Scholar
Rauch, James, and Evans, Peter. 2000. Bureaucratic Structure and Bureaucratic Performance in Less Developed Countries. Journal of Public Economics 75: 49–71.Google Scholar
Reid, Donald. 1986. Putting Social Reform into Practice: Labor Inspectors in France, 1892–1914. Journal of Social History 20, 1: 67–87.Google Scholar
Reid, Donald. 1994. “Les Jeunes Inspecteurs”: Ideology and Activism among Labour Inspectors in France after May 1968. French History 8, 3: 296–315.Google Scholar
Richthofen, Wolfgang von. 2002. Labour Inspection: A Guide to the Profession. Geneva : ILO.Google Scholar
Rinne, Jeffrey. 2003. The Politics of Administrative Reform in Menem's Argentina: The Illusion of Isolation. In Reinventing Leviathan: The Politics of Administrative Reform in Developing Countries, ed. Ross Schneider, Ben and Heredia, Blanca. Coral Gables : North-South Center Press. 33–58.Google Scholar
Rodríguez Sañudo, Fermín. 2003. El instituto de reformas sociales en el origen de la inspección de trabajo. Revista del Ministerio de Trabajo y Asuntos Sociales 1: 119–40.Google Scholar
Saint-Martin, Denis. 2001. How the Reinventing Government Movement in Public Administration was Exported from the U.S. to Other Countries. International Journal of Public Administration 24, 6: 573–604.Google Scholar
Schrank, Andrew. 2004. Ready to Wear Development? Foreign Investment, Technology Transfer, and Learning by Watching in the Apparel Trade. Social Forces 83, 1: 123–56.Google Scholar
Schrank, Andrew, and Piore, Michael. 2007. Norms, Regulations, and Labor Standards in Central America. Serie Estudios y Perspectivas 77. Mexico City : CEPAL.Google Scholar
Secretaría de Estado de Trabajo (SET). 2000a. Proceso de reforma y modernización de la administración del trabajo en República Dominicana: memoria de una gestión, 1991–2000. Santo Domingo : SET.Google Scholar
Secretaría de Estado de Trabajo (SET). 2000b. Boletín Estadístico No. 5. Santo Domingo : SET.Google Scholar
Secretaría de Estado de Trabajo (SET). 2007. Plan de implementación de las recomendaciones del libro blanco, 2007–2010. Santo Domingo : SET.Google Scholar
Seidman, Gay. 2007. Beyond the Boycott: Labor Rights, Human Rights, and Transnational Activism. New York : Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Shaheed, Zafar. 1994. Minimum Wages and Low Pay: an Ilo Perspective. International Journal of Manpower 15, 2–3: 49–61.Google Scholar
Shaiken, Harley. 2005. Statement of Harley Shaiken before the House Committee on Ways and Means on the Dominican Republic–Central America Free Trade Agreement. 109th Congress, 1st session. April 21.Google Scholar
Suleiman, Ezra. 2006. Is Weber Still Relevant? The Future of Bureaucracy. Paper presented at the Colloque International Penser Démocratie: Autour de l'oeuvre de Juan Linz. Université de Montpellier I, September 7.Google Scholar
Sullivan, John. 2006. Corruption, Economic Development, and Governance: Private Sector Perspectives from Developing Countries. Private Sector Opinion issue 2. Washington, DC : Global Corporate Governance Forum.Google Scholar
Symons, W. G. 1953. Some Problems of Labour Inspection in European Countries. International Labour Review 68: 47–64.Google Scholar
Tendler, Judith. 2002. The Fear of Education. Background paper for World Bank, Inequality and the State in Latin America and the Caribbean ( Washington, DC : World Bank, Fall 2003). Presented at the 50th Anniversary Meetings of the Banco do Nordeste, Fortaleza, Brazil, July 19. Available at <http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/43/40/2489865.pdf>.Google Scholar
Treichel, Bernd. 2005. The Ten Steps for Strengthening Labour Inspection. Labour Education 3–4, 140–41: 74–78.Google Scholar
Viceministerial Working Group (Working Group of the Vice Ministers Responsible for Trade and Labor in the Countries of Central America and the Dominican Republic). 2005. The Labor Dimension in Central America and the Dominican Republic: Building on Progress, Strengthening Compliance and Enhancing Capacity. Report. Washington, DC : IADB.Google Scholar
Weil, David. 2008. A Strategic Approach to Labor Inspection. International Labour Review 147, 4: 349–75.Google Scholar
Weyland, Kurt. 1997. “Growth with Equity” in Chile's New Democracy? Latin American Research Review 32, 1: 37–67.Google Scholar
Whiteside, Noel, and Salais, Robert. 1998. Comparing Welfare States: Social Protection and Industrial Politics in France and Britain, 1930–1960. Journal of European Social Policy 8, 2: 139–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wiarda, Howard. 1978. Corporative Origins of the Iberian and Latin American Labor Relations Systems. Studies in Comparative International Development 13 (Spring): 3–37.Google Scholar
World Bank. 2004. Doing Business in 2004: Understanding Regulation. Washington, DC : World Bank.Google Scholar
World Bank. 2006. Good Practices for Business Inspections: Guidelines for Reformers. Washington, DC : World Bank.Google Scholar
World Bank. 2008. World Development Indicators 2008. Washington, DC : World Bank.Google Scholar