Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T02:42:26.404Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Multisectoral Movement Alliances and Media Access: Salvadoran Newspaper Coverage of the Health Care Struggle

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

Lisa Kowalchuk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Focusing on the social movement that resisted the privatization of health care in El Salvador in 2002–3, this article asks how the movement's multisectoral composition influenced news coverage of the health care policy debate. Specifically, it examines whether the diversity of perspectives in the alliance was reflected in the media's source selection and framing of the policy issues. A content analysis of Salvadoran newspapers' coverage shows that the media relied mainly on just two movement actors to represent the antiprivatization position: the striking doctors and the leftist opposition party. It also reveals that a period of elite dissensus on the policy issues opened a temporary opportunity to insert movement messages in the coverage. The study indicates that a multisectoral alliance does not enhance movement influence through the news media, though broad alliances confer strategic advantages for the movement's broader communication work.

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 52 , Issue 4 , Winter 2010 , pp. 107 - 135
Copyright
Copyright © University of Miami 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Almeida, Paul. 2006. Social Movement Unionism, Social Movement Partyism, and Policy Outcomes: Healthcare Privatization in El Salvador. In Latin American Social Movements: Globalization, Democratization, and Transnational Networks, ed. Johnston, Hank and Almeida, . Lanham : Rowman and Littlefield. 57–73.Google Scholar
Almeida, Paul. 2008a. The Sequencing of Success: Organizing Templates and Neoliberal Policy Outcomes. Mobilization: The International Quarterly 13: 165–87.Google Scholar
Almeida, Paul. 2008b. Waves of Protest: Popular Struggle in El Salvador, 1925–2005. Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Almeida, Paul, and Johnston, Hank. 2006. Neoliberal Globalization and Popular Movements in Latin America. In Latin American Social Movements: Globalization, Democratization, and Transnational Networks, ed. Johnston, and Almeida, . Lanham : Rowman and Littlefield. 3–18.Google Scholar
Altheide, David. 1996. Qualitative Media Analysis. Thousand Oaks : Sage.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Amaya, Ivette. 2002. Sindicato del Isss contra plan de salud. Diario de Hoy (San Salvador), October 15: 4.Google Scholar
Anderson, Alison. 1991. Source Strategies and the Communication of Environmental Affairs. Media, Culture, and Society 13: 459–76.Google Scholar
Bennett, W. Lance. 1990. Toward a Theory of Press-State Relations in the United States. Journal of Communication 40: 103–25.Google Scholar
Boyle, Michael P., McCluskey, Michael R., Devanathan, Narayan, Stein, Susan E., and McLeod, Douglas. 2004. The Influence of Level of Deviance and Protest Type on Coverage of Social Protest in Wisconsin from 1960 to 1999. Mass Communication and Society 7: 43–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, Jane Delano, and Bybee, Carl R.. 1987. Invisible Power: Newspaper News Sources and the Limits of Diversity. Journalism Quarterly 64: 45–54.Google Scholar
Carreiro, Joshua L. 2005. Newspaper Coverage of the U.S. Labor Movement: the Case of Anti-Union Firings. Labor Studies Journal 30: 1–20.Google Scholar
Collins, Patricia A., Abelson, Julia, Pyman, Heather, and Lavis, John L.. 2006. Are We Expecting Too Much from Print Media? an Analysis of Newspaper Coverage of the 2002 Canadian Healthcare Reform Debate. Social Science and Medicine 63: 89–102.Google Scholar
Comité de Incidencia para el Desarrollo Agrario y Rural (CIDAR). 2004. Situación de la salud en El Salvador y propuestas para un nuevo sistema de salud. Report. San Salvador.Google Scholar
Committee in Solidarity with the People of El Salvador (CISPES). 1998. El Salvador Update. March <http://www.hartford-hwp.com/archives/47/215.html> Accessed May 29, 2008.+Accessed+May+29,+2008.>Google Scholar
Oyague, Cruz-Saco, Amparo, María. 2000. Sistema de salud en El Salvador: diagnóstico y lineamientos de reforma. San Salvador : Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.Google Scholar
Davis, Aeron. 2000. Public Relations, News Production and Changing Patterns of Source Access in the British National Press. Media, Culture and Society 22: 39–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diario de Hoy (San Salvador). 2002. Fmln: “Es privatización disfrazada.” October 15: 4.Google Scholar
Dignas, Las. 2002. Porque la salud es un derecho, no una mercancía. Diario CoLatino (San Salvador), October 28, 8.Google Scholar
Entman, Robert M., and Rojecki, Andrew. 1993. Freezing out the Public: Elite and Media Framing of the U.S. Anti-Nuclear Movement. Political Communication 10: 155–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Entrevista al Dia. 2002a. Television program. Interview with Ricardo Alfaro, director, SIMETRISSS. Transcript. October 15.Google Scholar
Entrevista al Dia. 2002b. Television program. Interview with Isabel Nieto, Director of the Colegio Médico; and Luis Mario Rodríguez, Executive Director, Asociación Nacional de la Empresa Privada El Salvador (ANEP). Transcript. October 16.Google Scholar
Gamson, William A. 1990. The Strategy of Social Protest. Homewood , IL : Dorsey Press.Google Scholar
Gamson, William A., and Wolfsfeld, Gadi. 1993. Movements and Media as Interacting Systems. American Society of Political and Social Science Annals 528: 114–25.Google Scholar
Giralt, Ana. 2002. Otra mordaza a la información. Diario de Hoy, October 18: 2.Google Scholar
Gitlin, Todd. 1980. The Whole World Is Watching: Mass Media in the Making and Unmaking of the New Left. Berkeley : University of California Press.Google Scholar
Hallin, Daniel C. 1984. The Media, the War in Vietnam, and Political Support: a Critique of the Thesis of an Oppositional Media. Journal of Politics 46, 1: 2–24.Google Scholar
Hammond, John L. 2004. The Mst and the Media: Competing Images of the Brazilian Landless Farmworkers' Movement. Latin American Politics and Society 46, 4 (Winter): 61–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hirschsohn, Philip. 2007. Union Democracy and Shopfloor Mobilization: Social Movement Unionism in South African Auto and Clothing Plants. Economic and Industrial Democracy 28: 6–48.Google Scholar
Homedes, Nuria, Carolina Paz-Narváes, Ana, Selva-Sutter, Ernesto, Solas, Olga, and Ugalde, Antonio. 2000. Health Reform: Theory and Practice in El Salvador. In Healthcare Reform and Poverty in Latin America, ed. Lloyd-Sherlock, Peter. London : Institute of Latin American Studies, University of London. 57–77.Google Scholar
Huezo, Roxana. 2002. Oposición insiste en que Flores tiene que negociar. Diario de Hoy, October 13: 3.Google Scholar
Hughes, Sallie. 2006. Newsrooms in Conflict: Journalism and the Democratization of Mexico. Pittsburgh : University of Pittsburgh Press.Google Scholar
Klandermans, Bert. 1990. Linking the Old and the New: Movement Networks in the Netherlands. In Challenging the Political Order: New Social and Political Movements in Western Democracies, ed. Dalton, Russel J. and Kuechler, Manfred. New York : Oxford University Press. 122–36.Google Scholar
Klandermans, Bert, and Goslinga, Sjoerd. 1996. Media Discourse, Movement Publicity, and the Generation of Collective Action Frames: Theoretical and Empirical Exercises in Meaning Construction. In McAdam et al. 1996. 312–37.Google Scholar
Kumar, Deepa. 2001. Mass Media, Class, and Democracy: the Struggle over Newspaper Representation of the Ups Strike. Critical Studies in Media Communication 18: 285–302.Google Scholar
Ladutke, Lawrence Michael. 2004. Freedom of Expression in El Salvador: The Struggle for Human Rights and Democracy. Jefferson , NC : McFarland.Google Scholar
Laurell, Asa Cristina. 2000. Structural Adjustment and the Globalization of Social Policy in Latin America. International Sociology 15: 306–25.Google Scholar
Lombard, Matthew, Snyder-Duch, Jennifer, and Campanella Bracken, Cheryl. 2002. Content Analysis in Mass Communication: Assessment and Reporting of Inter-coder Reliability. Human Communication Research 28: 587–604.Google Scholar
McAdam, Douglas. 1996. Conceptual Origins, Problems, and Future Directions. In McAdam et al. 1996. 23–40.Google Scholar
McAdam, Douglas, McCarthy, John D., and Zald, Mayer N., eds. 1996. Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements: Political Opportunities, Mobilizing Structures and Cultural Framings. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McCammon, Holly J., and Campbell, Karen E.. 2002. Allies on the Road to Victory: Coalition Formation between the Suffragists and the Women's Christian Temperance Union. Mobilization 7: 231–51.Google Scholar
McCarthy, John D., Smith, Jackie, and Zald, Mayer N.. 1996. Accessing Public, Media, Electoral, and Governmental Agendas. In McAdam et al. 1996. 291–31.Google Scholar
McCombs, Maxwell E., and Shaw, Donald. 1972. The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media. Public Opinion Quarterly 36: 176–87.Google Scholar
McFarlane, Thomas, and Hay, Ian. 2003. The Battle for Seattle: Protest and Popular Geopolitics in the Australian Newspaper. Political Geography 22: 211–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Menjívar, Ana Concepción. 2004. Member of Movimiento de Mujeres “Mélida Anaya Montes” (“Las Melidas”). Author interview. San Salvador, March 23.Google Scholar
Meza, Patricia. 2002. Desechos hospitalarios pueden manejarse en el Isss. CoLatino, December 10: 1, 3.Google Scholar
Miller, David. 1993. Official Sources and “Primary Definition”: the Case of Northern Ireland. Media, Culture, and Society 15: 385–406.Google Scholar
Monge, Ricardo. 2004. Secretary-General, Stisss. Author interview. San Salvador, February 23.Google Scholar
Oshagan, Hayg, and Martin, Christopher. 1999. Coverage of Labor and Management in the Willow Run Assembly Plant Shutdown. Labor Studies Journal 23: 17–33.Google Scholar
Porto, Mauro. 2002. Framing the World of Politics: How Government Sources Shape the Production and Reception of Tv News in Brazil. Paper presented to the 23rd Annual Conference of the International Association for Media and Communication Research (IAMCR), Barcelona, July 21–26.Google Scholar
Porto, Mauro. 2007. Frame Diversity and Citizen Competence: towards a Critical Approach to News Competency. Critical Studies in Media Communication 24: 303–21.Google Scholar
Powers, Angela, and Fico, Frederick. 1994. Influences on Use of Sources at Large U.S. Newspapers. Newspaper Research Journal 15: 87–97.Google Scholar
Rivas, Ena, and Ramírez, Claudia. 2002. Peligran 48 contratos en el Isss. Prensa Gráfica (San Salvador), November 16: 2.Google Scholar
Robinson, Ian. 2000. Neoliberal Restructuring and U.S. Unions: toward Social Movement Unionism. Critical Sociology 26: 109–38.Google Scholar
Rockwell, Rick, and Janus, Noreene. 2002. The Politics of Coercion: Advertising, Media, and State Power in Central America. Journalism 3: 331–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rockwell, Rick, and Janus, Noreene. 2003. Media Power in Central America. Urbana : University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Ryan, Charlotte. 2004. It Takes a Movement to Raise an Issue: Media Lessons from the 1997 Ups Strike. Critical Sociology 30: 483–511.Google Scholar
Schiavone, Michael. 2007. Moody's Account of Social Movement Unionism: an Analysis. Critical Sociology 33: 279–309.Google Scholar
Schlesinger, Philip. 1990. Rethinking the Sociology of Journalism: Source Strategies and the Limits of Media-Centrism. In Public Communication: The New Imperatives: Future Directions for Media Research, ed. Ferguson, Margorie. Newbury Park : Sage. 61–83.Google Scholar
Schlesinger, Philip, and Tumber, Howard. 1994. Reporting Crime: The Media Politics of Criminal Justice. Oxford : Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Schmidt, Diane E. 1993. Public Opinion and Media Coverage of Labor Issues. Journal of Labor Research 14: 151–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sindicato de Médicos Trabajadores del ISSS (SIMETRISSS). 2002a. Que la opinión pública juzgue. CoLatino, July 17: 8.Google Scholar
Sindicato de Médicos Trabajadores del ISSS (SIMETRISSS). 2002b. Sobre la inconstitucionalidad del Dl 1024. CoLatino, December 10: 15.Google Scholar
Sindicato de Trabajadores del ISSS (STISSS). 2002. ¿Democratizar la salud o permitir el lucro con un bien público CoLatino, October 29: 14.Google Scholar
Smith, Conrad. 1993. News Sources and Power Elites in News Coverage of the Exxon Valdéz Oil Spill. Journalism Quarterly 70: 393–403.Google Scholar
Smith, Jackie, McCarthy, John D., McPhail, Clark, and Augustyn, Bousglaw. 2001. From Protest to Agenda Building: Description Bias in Media Coverage of Protest Events in Washington, D.C. Social Forces 79: 1397–1423.Google Scholar
Snow, David A., and Benford, Robert D.. 1988. Ideology, Frame Resonance, and Participant Mobilization. International Social Movement Research 1: 197–217.Google Scholar
Soriano, Antonio. 2002. Las cuotas: el Pcn teme alzas en nuevo sistema de salud. Diario de Hoy, October 17: 2.Google Scholar
Spronk, Susan. 2007. Roots of Resistance to Urban Water Privatization in Bolivia: the “New Working Class,” the Crisis of Neoliberalism, and Public Services. International Labor and Working-Class History 71: 8–28.Google Scholar
Stempel, Guido H. Iii, and Culbertson, Hugh M.. 1984. The Prominence and Dominance of News Sources in Newspaper Medical Coverage. Journalism Quarterly 62: 358–66.Google Scholar
Tenorio, Oscar. 2002. Ministro y empleados de maquila discuten reforma. Diario de Hoy, October 18: 12.Google Scholar
Tuchman, Gaye. 1978. Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality. New York : Free Press.Google Scholar
Umaña, Lorena, and Guzmán, Nataly. 2003. Tratamiento informativo de la prensa escrita de la campaña electoral 2003. Estudios Centroamericanos 653–54: 239–57.Google Scholar
Valiente, Bernardo. 2002. Fmln dice Isss deberá indemnizar. Prensa Gráfica, November 21: 10.Google Scholar
Vanden, Harry E. 2008. Social Movements, Hegemony, and New Forms of Resistance. In Latin American Social Movements in the Twenty-First Century: Resistance, Power, and Democracy, ed. Stahler-Sholk, Richard, David Kueker, Glen, and Vanden, . Lanham : Rowman and Littlefield. 39–55.Google Scholar
Van Dyke, Nella. 2003. Crossing Movement Boundaries: Factors that Facilitate Coalition Protest by American College Students, 1930–1990. Social Problems 50: 226–50.Google Scholar
Waisbord, Silvio, and Peruzzotti, Enrique. 2009. The Environmental Story that Wasn't: Advocacy, Journalism, and the Asembleísta Movement in Argentina. Media, Culture, and Society 31: 691–709.Google Scholar
Wolfsfeld, Gadi. 1997. Media and Politcal Conflict: News from the Middle East. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Yoon, Youngmin. 2005. Legitimacy, Public Relations, and Media Access: Proposing and Testing a Media Access Model. Communication Research 32: 762–93.Google Scholar
Zaller, J. 1994. Strategic Politicians, Public Opinion, and the Gulf Crisis. In Taken By Storm: The Media, Public Opinion, and U.S. Foreign Policy in the Gulf Crisis, ed. Lance Bennett, W. and Paletz, David L.. Chicago : University of Chicago Press. 250–74.Google Scholar