Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rcrh6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-20T09:36:20.108Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Costs and Benefits of Overlapping Regional Organizations in Latin America: The Case of the OAS and UNASUR

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 January 2018

Detlef Nolte
Detlef Nolte*
Affiliation:
Director of the GIGA Institute of Latin American Studies
*
[email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article investigates whether the overlapping of intergovernmental regional organizations in Latin America with regard to membership and mandate is harmful or beneficial to regional cooperation (with a special focus on mediation in domestic and international conflicts). The article begins by systematizing the discussion about the possible risks and potential benefits of overlapping regional organizations, and then outlines hypotheses that can be tested in concrete episodes of overlap of action. The article then analyzes nine episodes in which an overlap of action has occurred between two Latin American organizations, the Organization of American States (OAS) and the Union of South American Nations (UNASUR). The results of the study are mixed. However, the effects of overlapping seem to be much less problematic than a large body of literature generally assumes.

Keywords

regionalismregional integrationLatin AmericaOASUNASURdemocracy protectionBoliviaColombiaEcuadorVenezuela
Type
Research
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 60 , Issue 1 , February 2018 , pp. 128 - 153
Copyright
Copyright © 2018 University of Miami 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Acharya, Amitav. 2011. Norm Subsidiarity and Regional Orders: Sovereignty, Regionalism, and Rule-Making in the Third World. International Studies Quarterly 55, 1: 95–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Agencia EFE. 2016. Gobierno venezolano dice que no quiere “nada” con la OEA. El Nuevo Herald (Miami), May 5. http://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/mundo/america-latina/venezuela-es/article75994767.html Google Scholar
Alter, Karen, and Meunier, Sophie. 2009. The Politics of International Regime Complexity. Perspectives on Politics 7, 1: 13–24.Google Scholar
Arugay, Aries A., and Bonifaz Moreno, Gustavo Xavier. 2014. Competing Regionalisms? The Role of the OAS and UNASUR in Bolivia’s Constitution-Drafting Process. Stockholm: IDEA. http://www.idea.int/sites/default/files/publications/competing-regionalisms.pdf Google Scholar
Becker, Marc. 2016. The Correa Coup. Latin American Perspectives 43, 1: 71–92.Google Scholar
Bianculli, Andrea. 2016. Regionalism in Latin America: Old, New, Post or Overlapping? In The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Regionalism, ed. Tanja A. Börzel and Thomas Risses. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 154–177.Google Scholar
Biermann, Rafael. 2008. Towards a Theory of Inter-Organizational Networking: The Euro-Atlantic Security Institutions Interacting. Review of International Organizations 3, 2: 151–177.Google Scholar
Bonifaz, Gustavo. 2011. Causas y consecuencias geopolíticas de la brecha entre legalidad en Bolivia. El caso de la violencia en Pando en septiembre de 2008. Policy Paper 33. Bogotá: FES-Colombia, Programa de Cooperación en Seguridad Regional.Google Scholar
Briceño-Ruiz, José. 2010. From the South America Free Trade Area to the Union of South American Nations. Latin America Policy 1, 2: 208–229.Google Scholar
Briceño-Ruiz, José, and Hoffmann, Andrea Ribeiro. 2015. Post-hegemonic Regionalism, UNASUR, and the Reconfiguration of Regional Cooperation in South America. Canadian Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Studies 40, 1: 48–62.Google Scholar
Briceño-Ruiz, José, and Morales, Isidro. 2017. Post-Hegemonic Regionalism in the Americas: Toward a Pacific-Atlantic Divide? London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Brosig, Malte. 2010. Governance Between International Institutions: Analysing Interaction Modes Between the EU, Council of Europe and OSCE. In Cooperation or Conflict? Problematizing Organizational Overlap in Europe, ed. David J. Galbreath and Carmen Gebhard. Farnham: Ashgate. 29–58.Google Scholar
Brosig, Malte. 2011. Overlap and Interplay Between International Organisations: Theories and Approaches. South African Journal of International Affairs 18, 2: 147–167.Google Scholar
Busch, Marc L. 2007. Overlapping Institutions, Forum Shopping, and Dispute Settlement in International Trade. International Organization 61, 4: 735–761.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Closa, Carlos, and Palestini, Stefano. 2015. Between Democratic Protection and Self-Defense: The Case of UNASUR and Venezuela. EUI Working Paper RSCAS 2015/93. Florence: European University Institute.Google Scholar
Closa Montero, Carlos, Palestini, Stefano, Céspedes, Stefano, and Ortiz, Pablo Castillo. 2016. Regional Organisations and Mechanisms for Democracy Protection in Latin America, the Caribbean, and the European Union. Hamburg: EU-LAC Foundation.Google Scholar
Dabène, Olivier. 2009. The Politics of Regional Integration in Latin America. Basingstoke: Palgrave.Google Scholar
Dabène, Olivier. 2014. La cuarta ola de regionalismo. In Los desafíos del desarrollo en América Latina, ed. Institut des Amériques. Paris: Agence Française de Développement. 64–95.Google Scholar
Délano, Manuel. 2008. Lula toma las riendas de la crisis boliviana. El País (Madrid), September 15. http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2008/09/15/actualidad/1221429 616_850215.html Google Scholar
Foro Permanente de las Naciones Unidas para Cuestiones Indígenas. 2009. Misión a Bolivia. Informe y recomendaciones. August 31. http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/—ed_norm/—declaration/documents/publication/wcms_151540.pdf Google Scholar
Gehring, Thomas, and Faude, Benjamin. 2013. The Dynamics of Regime Complexes: Micro-foundations and Systemic Effects. Global Governance 19, 1: 119–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gómez-Mera, Laura. 2015. International Regime Complexity and Regional Governance: Evidence from the Americas. Global Governance 21, 1: 19–42.Google Scholar
Gutner, Tama, and Thompson, Alexander, 2010. The Politics of IO Performance: A Framework. Review of International Organizations 5, 3: 227–248.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halvorssen, Thor, and El-Hage, Javier. 2013. Ante el silencio de la OEA, UNASUR avalará las elecciones en Venezuela. El País, April 5. http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2013/04/05/actualidad/1365171251_395385.html Google Scholar
Heine, Jorge, and Weiffen, Brigitte. 2015. 21st Century Democracy Promotion in the Americas. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Herz, Mónica. 2011. The Organization of American States (OAS). New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hoffay, Mercedes, and Mustiga, Karen. 2017. OAS and Venezuela: Another Contested Vote but with Recommendations. Global Americans, March 29. http://theglobalamericans.org/2017/03/oas-venezuela-another-contested-vote-recommendations Google Scholar
Hofmann, Stephanie, and Mérand, Frédéric. 2012. Regional Organizations À La Carte: The Effects of Institutional Elasticity. In International Relations Theory and Regional Transformation, ed. T.V. Paul. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 133–157.Google Scholar
Horwitz, Betty. 2010. The Transformation of the Organization of American States: A Multilateral Framework for Regional Governance. London: Anthem Press.Google Scholar
Hurrell, Andrew. 1992. Latin America in the New World Order: A Regional Bloc of the Americas? International Affairs 68, 1: 121–139.Google Scholar
Hurrell, Andrew. 1998. Security in Latin America. International Affairs 74, 3: 529–546.Google Scholar
Iglesias-Cavicchioli, Manuel. 2010. U.S. Foreign Policy, the South American Integration, and the Case of the Military Bases in Colombia. Revista Electrónica de Relaciones Internacionales (REEI) 19, 1–10. http://eprints.ucm.es/30884/1/1294844328-Nota_IGLE-SIAS_CAVICCHIOLI_Manuel.pdf Google Scholar
International Crisis Group. 2016. Venezuela: Tough Talking. Latin America Report 59, December 16. Brussels: International Crisis Group.Google Scholar
Jupille, Joseph, Mattli, Walter, and Snidal, Duncan, eds. 2013. Institutional Choice and Global Commerce. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Kacowicz, Arie M. 2005. The Impact of Norms in International Society: The Latin American Experience, 1881–2001. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Kellow, Aynsley. 2012. Multi-level and Multi-arena Governance: The Limits of Integration and the Possibilities of Forum Shopping. International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics 12, 4: 327–342.Google Scholar
Lambert, Peter, 2012. The Lightning Impeachment of Paraguay’s President Lugo. E-International Relations. August 9. http://www.e-ir.info/2012/08/09/the-lightning- Google Scholar
Latin American Regional Report. Andean Group. 2008–15. Various issues. London: Latin American Newsletters. www.latinnews.com.Google Scholar
Latin American Regional Report. Brazil and Southern Cone. 2012. RBS-12–07.Google Scholar
Latin American Security and Strategic Review. 2008–2015. Various issues.Google Scholar
Latin American Weekly Report. 2008–17. Various issues.Google Scholar
Malamud, Andrés. 2013. Overlapping Regionalism, No Integration: Conceptual Issues and the Latin American Experiences. EUI Working Paper RSCAS 2013/20. Florence: EUI.Google Scholar
Malamud, Andrés, and Gardini, Gian Luca. 2012. Has Regionalism Peaked? The Latin American Quagmire and Its Lessons. International Spectator: Italian Journal of International Affairs 47, 1: 116–133.Google Scholar
Malamud, Carlos. 2008. La cumbre de Unasur en Santiago de Chile y el conflicto en Bolivia. Análisis del Real Instituto Elcano series. ARI 121. Madrid: Real Instituto Elcano.Google Scholar
Márquez Restrepo, Martha Lucía. 2012. Dilemas y perspectivas de la relación de Colombia con Venezuela durante la era Santos. In Colombia: ¿una potencia en desarrollo? Escenarios y desafíos para su política exterior, ed. Stefan Jost. Bogotá: Fundación Konrad Adenauer-Colombia. 577–598.Google Scholar
Marsteintredet, Leiv, Llanos, Mariana, and Nolte, Detlef. 2013. Paraguay and the Politics of Impeachment. Journal of Democracy 24. 4: 110–123.Google Scholar
Mena, Paúl. 2009. Suramérica se pone en estado de alerta. El País, August 10. http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2009/08/10/actualidad/1249855202_850215.html Google Scholar
Mills, Frederick B., and Camacaro, William. 2015. Venezuela Takes Control of Its Border as Bogotá and Caracas Bring Their Cases to UNASUR. Council on Hemispheric Affairs, August 31. http://www.coha.org/category/regions/south-america-region/colombia http://www.coha.org/?s=Venezuela+Takes+Control+of+Its+Border+ Google Scholar
Morse, Julia C., and Keohane, Robert O., 2014. Contested Multilateralism. Review of International Organizations 9, 4: 385–412.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murphy-Gregory, Hannah, and Kellow, Aynsley. 2016. Forum Shopping and Global Governance. In Rethinking International Institutions: Diplomacy and Impact on Emerging World Order, ed. Wilhelm Hofmeister and Jan Melissen. Singapore/The Hague: Konrad Adenauer Stiftung / Clingendael. 39–50.Google Scholar
Nolte, Detlef. 2014. Latin America’s New Regional Architecture: A Cooperative or Segmented Regional Governance Complex? EUI Working Paper RSCAS 2014/89. Florence: EUI.Google Scholar
Nolte, Detlef, and Wehner, Leslie. 2014. UNASUR and Security in South America. In Regional Organisations and Security: Conceptions and Practices, ed. Stephen Aris and Andreas Wenger. London: Routledge. 183–202.Google Scholar
Nolte, Detlef, and Wehner, Leslie. 2016. Geopolitics in Latin America, Old and New. In Routledge Handbook of Latin American Security, ed. David R. Mares and Arie M. Kacowicz. London: Routledge. 33–43.Google Scholar
Organization of American States (OAS). 2015a. Carta a la presidenta del Consejo Nacional Electoral (CNE), Tibisay Lucena. Washington, DC, November 10. http://www.oas.org/documents/spa/press/Carta-a-Sra.-Tibisay-Lucena.pdf Google Scholar
Organization of American States (OAS). 2015b. IACHR Concludes Visit to Colombia’s Border with Venezuela. Press release. September 28. http://www.oas.org/en/iachr/media_center/PReleases/2015/109.asp Google Scholar
Organization of American States (OAS). 2015c. Note from the Permanent Mission of Colombia requesting a date for the convocation of a meeting of consultation of Ministers of Foreign Affairs. CP/INF. 7204/15, August 30. http://www.oas.org/en/council/CP/documentation/var_docu ments/cpinf/ Google Scholar
Organization of American States (OAS). 2016. Report on Venezuela of Secretary General to the Permanent Council Invoking the Democratic Charter. Washington, DC, May 30. http://www.oas.org/documents/eng/press/OSG-243.en.pdf Google Scholar
Organization of American States (OAS). 2017. Updated Report on Venezuela of the Secretary General to the Permanent Council. Washington, DC, March 14. http://www.oas.org/documents/eng/press/Informe-VZ-II-English-Final-Signed.pdf Google Scholar
Orsini, Amandine, Morin, Jean-Frédéric, and Young, Oran. 2013. Regime Complexes: A Buzz, a Boom, or a Boost for Global Governance? Global Governance 19, 1: 27–39.Google Scholar
Ospina Peralta, Pablo. 2011. Ecuador: ¿intento de golpe o motín policial? Nueva Sociedad 231, 14–27.Google Scholar
Perina, Rubén M.. 2015a. The Organization of American States as the Advocate and Guardian of Democracy. Lanham: University Press of America.Google Scholar
Perina, Rubén M.. 2015b. ¿OEA marginada? El País, September 15. http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2015/09/15/actualidad/1442342603_269196.html Google Scholar
Prost, Mario, and Clark, Paul Kingsley. 2006. Unity, Diversity and the Fragmentation of International Law: How Much Does the Multiplication of International Organizations Really Matter? Chinese Journal of International Law 5, 2: 341–370.Google Scholar
Raustiala, Kal, and Victor, David. 2004. The Regime Complex for Plant Genetic Resources. International Organization 58, 2: 277–309.Google Scholar
Riggirozzi, Pia, and Tussie, Diana. 2012. The Rise of Post-hegemonic Regionalism in Latin America. In The Rise of Post-hegemonic Regionalism: The Case of Latin America, ed. Riggirozzi and Tussie. Dordrecht: Springer. 1–16.Google Scholar
Riggirozzi, Pia, and Grugel, Jean. 2015. Regional Governance and Legitimacy in South America: The Meaning of UNASUR. International Affairs 91, 4: 781–797.Google Scholar
Saiz, Eva. 2014. La OEA cede ante Venezuela con una resolución benevolente sobre la crisis. El País, March 8. http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2014/03/08/actualidad/1394248962_313854.html?rel=mas Google Scholar
Salazar, Hernando. 2010. Acuerdo de bases entre Colombia y Estados Unidos queda sin efecto. BBC Mundo, August 18. http://www.bbc.com/mundo/america_latina/2010/08/100817_0027_colombia_estados_unidos_acuerdo_militar_corte_rb.shtml Google Scholar
Sanahuja, José Antonio. 2010. La construcción de una región: Suramérica y el regionalismo posliberal. In Una región en construcción: UNASUR y la integración en América del Sur, ed. Manuel Cienfuegos and Sanahuja. Barcelona: Barcelona Center for International Affairs. 87–136.Google Scholar
Scharfenberg, Ewald. 2017. La oposición venezolana da por roto el actual diálogo con Maduro. El País, January 26. http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2017/01/26/actualidad/1485435698_041820.html Google Scholar
Sullivan, Mark P. 2017. Venezuela: Issues for Congress, 2013–2016. Congressional Research Service R43239. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.Google Scholar
Tokatlian, Juan Gabriel, 2009. Suramérica y las bases en Colombia. El País, August 21. http://elpais.com/diario/2009/08/21/opinion/1250805604_850215.html Google Scholar
Tulchin, Joseph S. 2016. Latin America in International Politics: Challenging US Hegemony. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.Google Scholar
Tussie, Diana. 2016. Presidential Diplomacy in UNASUR: Coming Together for Crisis Management or Marking Turfs? In Summits and Regional Governance: The Americas in Comparative Perspective, ed. Gordon Mace, Jean-Philippe Thérien, Tussie, and Olivier Dabène. London: Routledge. 71–87.Google Scholar
Union of South American Nations (UNASUR). 2009. Acta de la Reunión Extraordinaria del Consejo de Jefas y Jefes de Estado y de Gobierno de la UNASUR. August 28. https://repo.unasursg.org/alfresco/service/unasursg/documents/content/ACTA_DE_LA_REU NION_EXTRAORDINARIA_DEL_CONSEJO_DE_JEFAS_Y_JEFES_DE_ESTA DO_Y_DE_GOBIERNO_DE_LA_UNASUR.pdf?noderef=2eabe385-cdb0-4121-c90-4189d3f1ba95 Google Scholar
U.S. Department of State. Bureau of Western Hemisphere Affairs. 2017. Declaration on Venezuela by Member States of the OAS. March 23. https://www.state.gov/p/wha/rls/prsrl/2017/269071.htm Google Scholar
Weiffen, Brigitte, Wehner, Leslie, and Nolte, Detlef. 2013. Overlapping Regional Security Institutions in South America: The Case of OAS and UNASUR. International Area Studies Review 16, 4: 370–389.CrossRefGoogle Scholar