Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-01T09:07:35.177Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Appointment and Removal Process for Judges in Argentina: The Role of Judicial Councils and Impeachment Juries in Promoting Judicial Independence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

Rebecca Bill Chávez
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores the conditions that allow judicial councils and impeachment juries to promote judicial autonomy. In theory, these bodies intervene in the appointment and removal of judges in order to reduce executive control over court composition, thereby promoting judicial independence. Using the case of Argentina at the federal and the subnational levels, this study demonstrates that competitive politics enhances the capacity of judicial councils and impeachment juries to bolster judicial autonomy. Interparty competition provides incentives for the executive to develop a meaningful system of checks and balances, which includes an independent judiciary that can check executive power. In contrast, monolithic party control—defined as a prolonged period of unified government under a highly disciplined party—permits the executive to maintain a monopoly on power and thereby control judicial appointments and removals.

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 49 , Issue 2 , Summer 2007 , pp. 33 - 58
Copyright
Copyright © University of Miami 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Agúndez, Miriam. 1999. Judicial Council Member (1991–93); President, San Luis Bar Association. Author interview. San Luis, May 24.Google Scholar
Ambito Financiero (Buenos Aires). 1989. La justicia en la Argentina. September 11.Google Scholar
Ambito Financiero (Buenos Aires). 1990. Quién es quién. April 11.Google Scholar
Ambito Financiero (Buenos Aires). 1994. Levene sin salida por el juicio. March 19.Google Scholar
Ambito Financiero (Buenos Aires). 1995a. Absolvieron a la corte. June 21.Google Scholar
Ambito Financiero (Buenos Aires). 1995b. Senado prepara calvarios. November 29.Google Scholar
Baglini, Raúl et al. 1993. Juicio a la corte. Buenos Aires: Mecanografix.Google Scholar
Barra, Rodolfo Carlos. 1998. Argentine Supreme Court Justice (1990–94). Author interview. Buenos Aires, November 13.Google Scholar
Bielsa, Rafael. 1998. Comments as member of panel Sres. Juristas Nacionales Invitados, Jornadas Internacionales sobre el Consejo de la Magistratura. Buenos Aires, October 28.Google Scholar
Bohm, Carlos. 1999. Mendoza Supreme Court Justice. Author interview. Mendoza, May 4.Google Scholar
Bordón, José Octavio. 2003. Former Mendoza Governor (1987–91). Author interview. Buenos Aires, March 12.Google Scholar
Bovino, Alberto. 1999. Attorney for Centro de Estudios Legales y Sociales (Cels). Author interview. Buenos Aires, June 23.Google Scholar
Bruni, Sergio. 1999. Member of Congress, Mendoza; member, Mendoza Judicial Council. Author interview. Mendoza, May 6.Google Scholar
Buenos Aires Herald. 1998. Frepaso presses for S. Court's impeachment. June 6.Google Scholar
Carrió, Alejandro. 1996. La Corte Suprema y su independencia. Buenos Aires: Abeledo-Perrot.Google Scholar
Casas, Daniel. 1998. Amo y señor de San Luis. Tres Puntos 2 (September 16): 46–50.Google Scholar
Cavagna, Martínez Mariano Augusto. 1998. Argentine Supreme Court Justice (1990–94). Author interview. Buenos Aires, November 27.Google Scholar
Caviglione, Fraga Bindo. 1998. Federal Judge. Author interview. Buenos Aires, October 22.Google Scholar
Chade, León Victor. 1999. Mendoza Minister of Government (1983–87). Author interview. Mendoza, May 7.Google Scholar
Clarín (Buenos Aires). 1990. Acuerdo para los nuevos integrantes. April 20.Google Scholar
Clarín (Buenos Aires). 1994a. Levene aún no se quiere ir. February 27.Google Scholar
Clarín (Buenos Aires). 1994b. La resistencia de Levene no afecta al pacto. March 2.Google Scholar
Clarín (Buenos Aires). 1995. Un operativo que aún no se aclara. November 30.Google Scholar
Colegio de Abogados de San Luis. 1998. Situación institucional en la provincia de San Luis. Photocopy of unpublished public statement.Google Scholar
Colegio de Abogados y Procuradores de la Ciudad de San Luis. Directorio. 1997. Declaración a la opinión pública. November 19. Photocopy of unpublished public statement.Google Scholar
Colegio de Abogados y Procuradores de Villa Mercedes. 1998. Comunicado. February 23. Photocopy of unpublished press release.Google Scholar
Consejo para la Consolidación de la Democracia. 1986. Reforma constitucional: dictamen preliminar del Consejo para la Consolidación de la Democracia. Buenos Aires: Editorial Universitaria de Buenos Aires.Google Scholar
Courtis, Christian. 1999. Attorney for Centro de Estudios Legales y Sociales (Cels). Author interview. Buenos Aires, June 28.Google Scholar
Crónica (Buenos Aires). 1993a. No hay seguridad. February 24.Google Scholar
Crónica (Buenos Aires). 1993b. “Jubilarán” a miembros de la corte. November 23.Google Scholar
Crónica (Buenos Aires). 1993c. Barra acató la orden. December 2.Google Scholar
Cronista (Buenos Aires). 1990a. Renunció Bacqué. April 18.Google Scholar
Cronista (Buenos Aires). 1990b. Jura hoy Moliné O'Connor. August 6.Google Scholar
Cruchaga, Melchor. 1996. Los riesgos en el proyecto del gobiemo. Agrupación para una Justicia Democrática 3: 15–17.Google Scholar
El Decamerón (San Luis). 1998. El juicio que viene. November 15.Google Scholar
Diario Popular (Buenos Aires). 1995. Vázquez. December 16.Google Scholar
Fayt, Carlos. Argentine Supreme Court Justice. Author interview. Buenos Aires, October 29.Google Scholar
Ferreira, Rubio Delia, and Goretti, Matteo 1996. Cuando el presidente gobierna solo: Menem y los decretos de necesidad y urgencia hasta la reforma constitucional, julio 1989-agosto 1994. Desarrollo Económico 36 (April-June): 443–74.Google Scholar
Financial Times. 1998. Scandals Hit Argentine Judiciary. May 13.Google Scholar
Finkel, Jodi Susan. 2004. Judicial Reform in Argentina: How Electoral Incentives Shape Institutional Change. Latin American Research Review 39, 3 (Fall): 87–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fiss, Owen. 1993. The Right Degree of Independence. In Transition to Democracy in Latin America: The Role of the Judiciary, ed. Stotzky, Irwin P. Boulder: Westview Press. 55–72.Google Scholar
Gallo, Adriana. 1998a. Declaration before the Impeachment Jury. San Luis, November 2.Google Scholar
Gallo, Adriana. 1998b. Former San Luis Judge. Author interview. San Luis, October 11.Google Scholar
Gambini, Hugo. 1999. Historia del peronismo: el poder total, 1943–1951. Buenos Aires: Planeta.Google Scholar
Garre, Nilda. 2003. Member, Argentine Congress. Author interview. Buenos Aires, March 12.Google Scholar
Garro, Alejandro M. 1983. The Role of the Argentine Judiciary in Controlling Governmental Action under a State of Siege. Human Rights Law Journal 4: 311–37.Google Scholar
Germano, Hugo. 2003. President, Buenos Aires Bar Association. Author interview. Buenos Aires, March 11.Google Scholar
Gil, Lavedra Ricardo. 2003. Former Justice Minister. Author interview. Buenos Aires, March 14.Google Scholar
Granillo, Ocampo Raúl. 1998. Argentine Justice Minister (1997–99). Author interview. Buenos Aires, November 18.Google Scholar
Guagnini, Lucas, O'Donnell, Santiago, and Semán, Ernesto 1997. El estado contra Vázquez. Tres Puntos 1 (September 25): 10–11.Google Scholar
Hamilton, Alexander. 1937 [1788]. Federalist No. 78. In The Federalist: A Commentary on the Constitution of the United States. From the original text of Hamilton, John Jay, and James Madison, Modern Library Edition. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
Hammergren, Linn. 2002. Do Judicial Councils Further Judicial Reforms? Lessons from Latin America. Working Papers, Rule of Law Series, No. 28. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.Google Scholar
Hilbink, Elisabeth. 1999. Legalism against Democracy: the Political Role of the Judiciary in Chile, 1964–1994. Ph.D. diss., University of California, San Diego.Google Scholar
Kemelmajer de Carlucci, Aída Rosa. 1999. Mendoza Supreme Court Justice. Author interview. Mendoza, May 4.Google Scholar
Llorente, Pedro. 1999. Mendoza Supreme Court Justice. Author interview. Mendoza, May 4.Google Scholar
Luna, Félix. 1984. La Argentina era una fiesta, 1946–49. Vol. 1 of Perón y su tiempo. Buenos Aires: Editorial Sudamericana.Google Scholar
Luna, Félix. 1998. Argentine historian. Author interview. Buenos Aires, November 3.Google Scholar
Mainwaring, Scott, and Shugart, Matthew Soberg 1997. Introduction. In Presidentialism and Democracy in Latin America, ed. Mainwaring, and Shugart, . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1–11.Google Scholar
Molinelli, Guillermo. 1996. Las relaciones presidente-congreso en Argentina 1983–1995. PostData 2 (November): 59–90.Google Scholar
Molinelli, Guillermo, Palanza, Valeria, and Sin, Gisela 1999. Congreso, presidencia y justicia en Argentina: materiales por su estudio. Buenos Aires: Temas Grupo.Google Scholar
Montbrun, Alberto. 1999. Mendoza Senator (1991–99). Author interview. Mendoza, May 6.Google Scholar
Moreno, Ocampo Luis. 1998a. Poder Ciudadano founder. Author interview. Buenos Aires, September 29.Google Scholar
Moreno, Ocampo Luis. 1998b. Statement before the Impeachment Jury. San Luis, November 2.Google Scholar
La Nación (Buenos Aires). 1990. Senado: radicales ausentes. April 20.Google Scholar
La Nación (Buenos Aires). 1993. Buen amigo de Eduardo Menem. December 22.Google Scholar
La Nación (Buenos Aires). 1994. Jurarán Bossert y López. March 29.Google Scholar
La Nación (Buenos Aires). 1998a. Destruyeron a la jueza enfrentada con Rodríguez Saá. December 18.Google Scholar
La Nación (Buenos Aires). 1998b. Careaga está dispuesta a dar batalla. December 19.Google Scholar
Nanclares, Jorge. 1999. Mendoza Supreme Court Justice. Author interview. Mendoza, May 4.Google Scholar
Nuevo Sur (Buenos Aires). 1990. Se completó la corte. April 21.Google Scholar
Pagano, Roberto Eduardo. 1999a. Member of Congress, San Luis (1993–97); former member, San Luis Impeachment Jury. Author interview. San Luis, May 19.Google Scholar
Pagano, Roberto Eduardo. 1999b. Jurado de enjuiciamiento de la provincia de San Luis, su brutal conquista, propuesta para su liberación. Paper presented at “Seminario sobre la independencia de los poderes judiciales provinciates,” San Luis, March.Google Scholar
Página 12. 1996. Un juez de la corte. July 2.Google Scholar
Parra, Mejías Gisela. 1999. President, Venezuelan Judicial Council. Author interview. Caracas, November 23.Google Scholar
Pérez, Hualde Alejandro. 1998. El Consejo de la Magistratura en la Constitución de Mendoza. Photocopy of unpublished manuscript.Google Scholar
Pesce, Félix. 1999. Member, Mendoza Judicial Council. Author interview. Mendoza, May 4.Google Scholar
Portabella, Oscar N. 1999. Member, Mendoza Judicial Council. Author interview. Mendoza, May 10.Google Scholar
La Prensa (Buenos Aires). 1993. La corte ya tiene tres nuevos miembros. December 11.Google Scholar
La Prensa (Buenos Aires). 1995. Vázquez admitió que fue nombrado en la corte por ser amigo de Menem. November 29.Google Scholar
Quiroga, Lavie Humberto. 2003. Member, Argentine Judicial Council. Author interview. Buenos Aires, March 10.Google Scholar
Río Negro (Río Negro and Neuquén). 1995. Vázquez a la corte. December 8.Google Scholar
Rosenn, Keith S. 1974. Judicial Review in Latin America. Ohio State Law Journal 35: 785–819.Google Scholar
Rosso, Graciela. 1999. Secretary, San Luis Bar Association; attorney for Judge Ana Maria Careaga before the Impeachment Jury. Author interview. San Luis, May 20.Google Scholar
Segal, Jeffrey A., and Spaeth, Harold J. 1993. The Supreme Court and the Attitudinal Model. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Staib, Alberto. 1999. Mendoza Judge; former president, Mendoza's Judges' Association. Author interview. Mendoza, May 11.Google Scholar
Supreme Court Justice. 2003. Author interview. Buenos Aires, March 13.Google Scholar
Szusterman, Celia. 1993. Frondizi and the Politics of Developmentalism in Argentina, 1955–1962. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Uno (Mendoza). 1998. Comienzan los exámenes para cargos judiciales. September 13.Google Scholar
Vacca, Domingo. 1998. Statement before the Impeachment Jury. San Luis, November 2.Google Scholar
Vanossi, Jorge Reinaldo. 1994. La constitución evanescente. La Ley 58 (December 2): 1–3.Google Scholar
Ventura, Adrián. 2003. La Nación journalist. Author interview. Buenos Aires, March 12.Google Scholar
Verbitsky, Horacio. 1993. Hacer la corte: la construcción de un poder absoluto sin justicia ni control. Buenos Aires: Planeta.Google Scholar
La Voz del Interior (Córdoba). 1996. Resignado a que lo llamen menemista. November 17.Google Scholar
Zaffaroni, Eugenio Raúl. 1994. Estructuras judiciales. Buenos Aires: Ediar Sociedad Anónima.Google Scholar
Zaffaroni, Eugenio Raúl. 1999. Argentine Supreme Court Justice. Author interview. Buenos Aires, July 1.Google Scholar
Zapata, Mercader Jorge. 1999. Mendoza Impeachment Jury member (1987–91). Author interview. Mendoza, April 27.Google Scholar