Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T17:46:41.088Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

From Tula Chico to Chichén Itzá: Implications of the Epiclassic Sculpture of Tula for the Nature and Timing of Tula-Chichén Contact

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Keith Jordan
Keith Jordan*
Affiliation:
Department of Art and Design, California State University, Fresno, 5225 North Backer Avenue, M/S CA65, Fresno, California, 93740-8001 ([email protected])
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In the last four decades, a number of archaeologists and art historians have posited that “Toltec” Chichén Itzá (Yucatán, Mexico) flourished during the ninth and tenth centuries A.D. They argued that because the “Toltec” style in Yucatán predated the Tollan phase at Tula (Hidalgo, Mexico), most of the style features shared between the cities originated with the Maya. Here, I examine the relevance of the Epiclassic relief sculpture of Tula Chico for the timing and nature of contact between Tula and Chichén Itzá. The presence of reliefs of reclining figures in clear “Toltec” style at Tula Chico in contexts predating their occurrence at Chichén Itzá suggests that claims for a predominantly Maya origin for that style stand in need of revision. Such a rethinking is supported by other fragmentary images from Tula Chico (eagles and Venus symbols), as well as by new studies of ceramic materials and chronology at Chichén Itzá. It is clear that Tula was an active participant in whatever interactions led to similar visual arts at Chichén Itzá, and at least some of the shared iconography has temporal priority at Tula.

En las últimas cuatro décadas, un número de arqueólogos e historiadores del arte han propuesto que el estilo “Tolteca” de Chichén Itzá (Yucatán, México), floreció durante los siglos nueve y diez A.D. Estos investigadores argumentaron que, dado que el estilo “Tolteca” en Yucatán precedió a la fase Tollan en Tula (Hidalgo, México), la mayoría de los rasgos compartidos entre las ciudades se originaron de los Mayas. En este trabajo se examina la relevancia de la escultura relieve de Tula Chico para el tiempo y la naturaleza del contacto entre Tula y Chichén Itzá. La presencia de relieves de figuras reclinadas de estilo claramente “Tolteca” en Tula Chico, en contextos anteriores a su existencia en Chichén Itzá, sugiere que las afirmaciones acerca de que el origen del estilo fue predominantemente maya necesitan ser revisadas. Este replanteo es apoyado por otras imágenes fragmentarias de Tula Chico (águilas y símbolos de Venus), así como también por nuevos estudios de la cerámica y la cronología de Chichén Itzá. Es claro que Tula fue un participante activo en cualesquiera que hayan sido las interacciones que llevaron a las semejanzas del arte visual en Chichén Itzá. Además, al menos una parte de la iconografía compartida tiene prioridad temporal en Tula.

Type
Articles
Information
Latin American Antiquity , Volume 27 , Issue 4 , December 2016 , pp. 462 - 478
Copyright
Copyright © by the Society for American Archaeology 2016

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Baird, Ellen. T,. 1985 Naturalistic and Symbolic Color at Tula, Hidalgo. In Painted Architecture and Polychrome Monumental Sculpture in Mesoamerica, edited by Boone, Elizabeth Hill, pp. 115–144. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Bey, George J. III, and Ringle, William M. 2007 From the Bottom Up: The Timing and Nature of the Tula–Chichén-Itzá Exchange. In Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic and Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World, edited by Kowalski, Jeff Karl and Kristan-Graham, Cynthia, pp. 376–427. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Braswell, Geoffrey E., 2011 El estilo internacional de Chichen Itza: Innovación, adopción y adaptación. In XXIV Simposio de Investigaciones Arqueológicas en Guatemala, 2010, edited by Arroyo, B., Paiz, L., Linares, A. and Arroyave, A., pp. 1206–1216. de Arqueología, Museo Nacional y Etnología, , Guatemala, Guatemala City. Electronic document, http://www.academia.edu/5092135/_2011e_El_estilo_internacional_de_Chichen_Itza_Innovaci%C3%B3n_adopci%C3%B3n_y_adaptaci%C3%B3n, accessed June 2015.Google Scholar
Braswell, Geoffrey E., and May, Nancy Peniche 2012 In the Shadow of the Pyramid: Excavations of the Great Platform of Chichen Itza. In The Ancient Maya of Mexico: Reinterpreting the Past of the Northern Maya Lowlands, edited by Braswell, Geoffrey E., pp. 229–263. Routledge, Abingdon, UK.Google Scholar
Cobean, Robert H,. 1990 La cerámica de Tula, Hidalgo. Instituto Nacional de Antropología y Historia, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Cobean, Robert H., García, Elizabeth Jiménez, and Mastache, Alba Guadalupe 2012 Tula. Fondo de Cultura Económica, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Cobos, Rafael, 2004 Chichen Itza: Settlement and Hegemony during the Terminal Classic Period. In The Terminal Classic in the Maya Lowlands: Collapse, Transition, and Transformation, edited by Demarest, Arthur, Rice, Prudence, and Rice, Don, pp. 517–544. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Coggins, Clemency, 2002 Toltec. Res: Anthropology and Aesthetics 42:34–85.Google Scholar
Cohodas, Marvin, 1989 The Epiclassic Problem: A Review and Alternative Model. In Mesoamerica After the Decline of Teotihuacan A.D. 700–900, edited by Diehl, and Janet Catherine, Berlo, pp. 219–ó240. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
De la, Fuente, Beatriz, , Solana, Nelly Gutiérrez, and Trejo, Silvia 1988 Escultura en piedra de Tula. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Diehl, Richard, 1983 Tula: The Toltec Capital of Ancient Mexico. Thames and Hudson, New York.Google Scholar
García Moll, Roberto, and Cobos, Rafael 2009 Chichén Itzá. Conaculta, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Gillespie, Susan, 1989 The Aztec Kings: The Construction of Rulership in Mexica History. University of Arizona Press, Tucson.Google Scholar
Gillespie, Susan, 2007 Toltecs, Tula, and Chichén Itzá: The Development of an Archaeological Myth. In Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic to Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World, edited by Kowalski, Jeff Karl and Kristan-Graham, Cynthia, pp. 84–127. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Gómez Serafín, Susana, Sansores, Francisco Javier, and Dávila, Enrique Fernández 1994 Enterramientos humanos de la época prehispánica en Tula, Hidalgo. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Healan, Dan, 2012 The Archaeology of Tula, Hidalgo, Mexico. Journal of Archaeological Research 20:53–115.Google Scholar
Hers, Marie-Areti, 1989 Los Toltecas en tierras Chichimecas. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Jiménez García, Elizabeth, 1998 Iconografía de Tula: El caso de la escultura. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Jiménez García, Elizabeth, 2010 Sculptural-Iconographic Catalogue of Tula, Hidalgo: The Stone Figures. Foundation for the Advancement of Mesoamerican Studies, Incorporated Grant Report. Electronic document, www.famsi.org, accessed May 9, 2013.Google Scholar
Jones, Lindsay, 1995 Twin City Tales: A Hermeneutic Reassessment of Tula and Chichén Itzá. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Jordan, Keith, 2013 Serpents, Skeletons and Ancestors? The Tula Coatepantli Revisited. Ancient Mesoamerica 24(2):243– 274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jordan, Keith, 2014 Stone Trees Transplanted? Central Mexican Stelae of the Epiclassic and Early Postclassic and the Question of Maya “Influence.” Archaeopress, Oxford.Google Scholar
Kepecs, Susan, 2007 Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic-Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World System. In Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic to Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World, edited by Kowalski, Jeff Karl and Kristan-Graham, Cynthia, pp. 128–149. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Kowalski, Jeff Karl, 2007 What’s “Toltec” at Uxmal and Chichen Itza? Merging Maya and Mesoamerican World Views and World Systems in Terminal Classic to Early Postclassic Yucatan. In Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic to Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World, edited by Kowalski, Jeff Karl, and Kristan-Graham, Cynthia, pp. 248–313. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Jeff Karl, Kowalski, and Kristan-Graham, Cynthia 2007 Chichén Itzá, Tula, and Tollan: Changing Perspectives on a Recurring Problem in Mesoamerican Archaeology and Art History. In Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic to Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World, edited by Kowalski, Jeff Karl and Kristan-Graham, Cynthia, pp. 12–83. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Kremer, Jürgen, 1994 The Putun Hypothesis Reconsidered. In Hidden among the Hills: Maya Archaeology of the Northwest Yucatan Peninsula, edited by Prem, Hanns J., pp. 289–307. Verlag von Flemming, Mockmühl.Google Scholar
Kristan-Graham, Cynthia, 1989 Art, Architecture, and the Mesoamerican Body Politic at Tula and Chichen Itza. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Art History, University of California, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Kristan-Graham, Cynthia, 2007 Structuring Identity at Tula: The Design and Symbolism of Colonnaded Halls and Sunken Spaces. In Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic and Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World, edited by Kowalski, Jeff Karl and Kristan-Graham,, Cynthia pp. 530–577. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Kubler, George, 1961 Chichen Itza y Tula. Estudios de Cultura Maya 1:47–79.Google Scholar
Lincoln, Charles, 1990 Ethnicity and Social Structure at Chichen Itza, Yucatan. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts.Google Scholar
López Austin, Alfredo, and Luján, Leonardo López 2000 The Myth and Reality of Zuyua: The Feathered Serpent and Mesoamerican Transformation from the Classic to the Postclassic. In Mesoamerica’s Classic Heritage: From Teotihuacan to the Aztecs, edited by Carrasco, David, Jones, Lindsay, and Sessions, Scott, pp. 21–84. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Mastache, Alba Guadalupe, and Cobean, Robert H. 1989 The Coyotlatelco Culture and the Origins of the Toltec State. In Mesoamerica after the Decline of Teoti-huacan A.D. 700–900, edited by Diehl, Richard and Berlo, Janet Catherine, pp. 49–68. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Mastache, Alba Guadalupe, Cobean, Robert H., and Healan, Dan 2002 Ancient Tollan: Tula and the Toltec Heartland. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Mastache, Alba Guadalupe, Cobean, Robert H., and Healan, Dan 2009 Four Hundred Years of Settlement and Cultural Continuity in Epiclassic and Early Postclassic Tula. In The Art of Urbanism: How Mesoamerican Kingdoms Represented Themselves in Architecture and Imagery, edited by Fash, William L. and Luján, Leonardo López, pp. 290–328. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
McVicker, Donald, and Palka, Joel 2001 A Maya Carved Shell Plaque from Tula, Hidalgo, Mexico. Ancient Mesoamerica 12(2):175–197.Google Scholar
Miller, Arthur, 1973 The Mural Painting of Teotihuacan. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Miller, Virginia, 1989 Star Warriors at Chichen Itza. In Word and Image in Maya Culture, edited by Hanks, William and Rice, Don S., pp. 287–305. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City.Google Scholar
Pérez, Eduardo J., 2010 Ceramic Contexts and Chronology at Chichen Itza, Yucatan, Mexico. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Archaeology Program, La Trobe University, Victoria, Canada.Google Scholar
Ringle, William, and Bey, George III 2009 The Face of the Itzas. In The Art of Urbanism: How Mesoamerican Kingdoms Represented Themselves in Architecture and Imagery, edited by Fash, William L. and Luján, Leonardo López, pp. 329–383. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Ringle, William, Negrón, Tomás Gallareta, and Bey, George 1998 The Return of Quetzalcoatl: Evidence for the Spread of a World Religion in the Epiclassic. Ancient Mesoamerica 9(2):183–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schele, Linda, and Mathews, Peter 1998 The Code of Kings: The Language of Seven Sacred Maya Temples and Tombs. Scribners, New York.Google Scholar
Smith, Michael, 2007 Tula and Chichén Itzá: Are We Asking the Right Questions? In Twin Tollans: Chichén Itzá, Tula, and the Epiclassic to Early Postclassic Mesoamerican World, edited by Kowalski, Jeff Karl and Kristan-Graham,, Cynthia pp. 578–617. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Sterpone, Oswaldo José, 2006 Coyotlatelco y las orígenes de Tula Grande. In El fenómeno Coyotlatelco en el centro de México, edited by Valverde, Laura Solar, pp. 257–279. Instituto de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Sterpone, Oswaldo José, 2007 Tollan a 65 años de Jorge R. Acosta. Universidad Autónoma de Estado de Hidalgo/Instituto Nacional de Antropología y Historia, Pachuca.Google Scholar
Cortés, Suárez, Elena, María, Healan, Dan, and Cobean, Robert 2007 Los orígenes de la dinastia real de Tula: Excavaciónes recientes en Tula Chico. Arqueología Mexicana 15(85):48–50.Google Scholar
Taube, Karl, 1992 The Temple of Quetzalcoatl and the Cult of Sacred War at Teotihuacan. Res: Anthropology and Aesthetics 21:53–87 Google Scholar
Taube, Karl, 1994 The Iconography of Toltec Period Chichen Itza. In Hidden among the Hills: Maya Archaeology of the Northwest Yucatan Peninsula, edited by Prem, Hanns J., pp. 212–246. Verlag von Flemming, Mockmühl.Google Scholar
Taube, Karl, 2000 The Turquoise Hearth: Fire, Sacrifice, and the Mesoamerican Cult of War. In Mesoamerica’s Classic Heritage: From Teotihuacan to the Aztecs, edited by Carrasco, David, Jones, Lindsay, and Sessions, Scott, pp. 269–330. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Thompson, J. Eric, 1943 Representations of Tlachitonatiuh at Chichén Itzá and at Baul, Escuintla. Carnegie Institution Notes on Middle American Archaeology and Ethnology 1(19):117–121.Google Scholar
Thompson, J. Eric, 1970 Maya History and Religion. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.Google Scholar
Tozzer, Alfred M., 1957 Chichen Itza and Its Cenote of Sacrifice. Memoirs XI–XII. Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts.Google Scholar
Urcid, Javier, 2010 Los oraculos y la guerra: El papel de las narrativas pictóricas en el desarollo temprano de Monte Alban (500 a.C.–200 d.C.). In Monte Alban en la encrucijada regional y disciplinaría. Memoria de la Quinta Redonda de Monte Alban, edited by Robles, Nelly M. and Guzman, Angel Ivan Rivera, pp. 163–237. Instituto Nacional de Antropología, Oaxaca.Google Scholar
Volta, Beniamino, and Braswell, Geoffrey E. 2014 Alternative Narratives and Missing Data: Refining the Chronology of Chichen Itza. In The Maya and Their Central American Neighbors: Settlement Patterns, Architecture, Hieroglyphic Texts, and Ceramics, edited by Braswell, Geoffrey E., pp. 356–402. Routledge, London.Google Scholar