Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T15:51:20.013Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Can We Read Cosmology in Ancient Maya City Plans? Comment on Ashmore and Sabloff

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Michael E. Smith
Michael E. Smith*
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, University at Albany, SUNY, Albany, NY 12222 ([email protected])
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Arguments for the cosmological significance of ancient Maya city layouts are plausible, but empirical applications are subjective and lack rigor. I illustrate this contention through brief comments on a recent article by Ashmore and Sabloff. I first discuss some of the complexities and pitfalls in studying cosmology from ancient city plans, and then focus on one component of the authors’ cosmological model—the hypothesized north-south axis at Classic Maya cities. My goal is not to down-play or rule out the role of cosmology in Maya city planning, but rather to encourage the use of explicit assumptions and rigorous methods that will provide the study of Maya city planning with a more secure empirical foundation.

Los argumentos para el significado cosmológico de las trazas de las ciudades antiguas mayas son plausibles, pero las aplicaciones empíricas son subjetivas y carecen de rigor. Ilustro este idea con unos comentarios sobre un artículo reciente de Ashmore y Sabloff. Primero discuto algunas de las complejidades y problemas en el estudio de la cosmología basado en los planos de las ciudades antiguas. Segundo, examino una parte del modelo cosmológico de los autores—el propuesto eje norte-sur en las ciudades mayas. Mi objetivo no es disminuir ni negar el papel de la cosmología en la planeación urbana Maya; más bien es fomentar el uso de asunciones explicitas y métodos rigurosos para dar al estudio de la planeación urbana una fundación empírica más segura.

Type
Comments
Information
Latin American Antiquity , Volume 14 , Issue 2 , June 2003 , pp. 221 - 228
Copyright
Copyright © 2003 by the Society for American Archaeology.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Allchin, F. Raymond (editor) 1995 The Archaeology of Early Historic South Asia: The Emergence of Cities and States. Cambridge University Press, New York.Google Scholar
Andrews, George F. 1975 Maya Cities: Placemaking and Urbanization. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1989 Construction and Cosmology: Politics and Ideology in Lowland May a Settlement Patterns. In Word and Image in Maya Culture: Explorations in Language, Writing, and Representation, edited by William F. Hanks and Don S. Rice, pp. 272–286. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1991 Site-Planning Principles and Concepts of Directionality Among the Ancient Maya. Latin American Antiquity 2:199–226.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1992 Deciphering Maya Architectural Plans. In New Theories on the Ancient Maya, edited by Elin C. Danien and Robert J. Sharer, pp. 173–184. University Museum Monograph, vol. 77. University Museum, University of Pennsylvania, Phildelphia.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy, and Sabloff, Jeremy A. 2000 El orden de espacio en los planes cívicos mayas. In Arquitectura e ideología de los aniguos mayas: memoria de la Segunda Mesa Redonda de Palenque, edited by Silvia Trejo, pp. 15–34. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy, and Sabloff, Jeremy A. 2002 Spatial Orders in Maya Civic Plans. Latin American Antiquity 13:201–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F. 1992 Moctezuma’s Sky: Aztec Astronomy and Ritual. In Moctezuma’s Mexico: Visions of the Aztec World, edited by David Carrasco and Eduardo Matos Moctezuma, pp. 149–158. University Press of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F. 2001 Skywatchers. 2nd ed. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F., Calnek, Edward E., and Hartung, Horst 1988 Myth, Environment and the Orientation of the Templo Mayor of Tenochtitlan. American Antiquity 53:287–309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Banning, E. B. 1996 Pattern or Chaos? New Ways of Looking at “Town Planning” in the Ancient Near East In Debating Complexity: Proceedings of the 26th Annual Chacmool Conference, edited by Daniel A. Meyer, Peter C. Dawson and Donald T. Hanna, pp. 510–518. Archaeological Association of the University of Calgary, Calgary.Google Scholar
Blanton, Richard E. 1989 Continuity and Change in Public Architecture: Periods I through V of the Valley of Oaxaca, Mexico. In Monte Alban’s Hinterland, Part II: Prehispanic Settlement Patterns in Tlacolula, Etla, and Ocotlan, the Valley of Oaxaca, Mexico, edited by Stephen A. Kowalewski, Gary M. Feinman, Laura Finsten, Richard E. Blanton and Linda M. Nicholas, pp. 409–447. Memoirs, vol. 23. Museum of Anthropology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Broda, Johanna, Carrasco, David, and Moctezuma, Eduardo Matos 1987 The Great Temple of Tenochtitlan: Center and Periphery in the Aztec World. University of California Press, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Calnek, Edward E. 1974 Conjunto urbana y modelo residencial en Tenochtitlan. In Ensayos sobre el desarollo urbano de México, edited by Woodrow Borah, pp. 11–65. Secretaría de Educacción Pública, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Calnek, Edward E. 1976 The Internal Structure of Tenochtitlan. In The Valley of Mexico: Studies of Pre-Hispanic Ecology and Society, edited by Eric R. Wolf, pp. 287–302. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Carrasco, Davíd 1991 To Change Place: Aztec Ceremonial Landscapes. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Carrasco, Davíd 1999 City of Sacrifice: The Aztec Empire and the Role of Violence in Civilization. Beacon Press, Boston.Google Scholar
Carrasco, Davíd, Jones, Lindsay, and Sessions, Scott (editors) 2000 Mesoamerica’s Classic Heritage: From Teotihuacan to the Aztecs. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Carter, Harold 1981 The Study of Urban Geography. 3rd ed. Edward Arnold, London.Google Scholar
Chang, Kwang-Chih 1976 Towns and Cities in Ancient China. In Ancient Chinese Civilization: Anthropological Perspectives, edited by Kwang-Chih Chang, pp. 61–71. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Coningham, Robin 2000 Contestatory Urban Texts or Were Cities in South Asia Built as Images? Cambridge Archaeological Journal 10:348–354.Google Scholar
D’Altroy, Terence N. 2002 The Incas. Blackwell, Oxford.Google Scholar
DeMarrais, Elizabeth 2001 The Architecture and Organization of Xauxa Settlements. In Empire and Domestic Economy, edited by Terence N. D’Altroy and Christine A. Hastorf, pp. 115–153. Plenum, New York.Google Scholar
Dumarçay, Jacques, and Royère, Pascal 2001 Cambodian Architecture, Eighth to Thirteenth Centuries. Handbook of Oriental Studies, Section Three, South-East Asia, vol. 12. Brill, Leiden.Google Scholar
Eliade, Mircea 1959 Cosmos and History: The Myth of the Eternal Return. Translated by Williard R. Trask. Harper and Row, New York.Google Scholar
Flannery, Kent V., and Marcus, Joyce 1993 Cognitive Archaeology. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 3:260–270.Google Scholar
Gasparini, Graziano, and Margolies, Luise 1980 Inca Architecture. Translated by Patricia J. Lyon. Indiana University Press, Bloomington.Google Scholar
Graulich, Michel 1997 Myths of Ancient Mexico. Translated by Bernard R. Ortiz de Montellano and Thelma Ortiz de Montellano. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.Google Scholar
Gutschow, Niels 1993 Bhaktapur: Sacred Patterns of a Living Urban Traditioa In Urban Form and Meaning in South Asia: The Shaping of Cities from Prehistoric to Precolonial Times, edited by Howard Spodek and Doris Meth Srinivasan, pp. 163–183. Studies in the History of Art, Center for Advanced Study in the Visual Arts, Symposium Papers XV, vol. 31. National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. Google Scholar
Higham, Charles 2000 The Symbolism of the Angkorian City. In: Viewpoint: Were Cities Built as Images? Cambridge Archaeological Journal 10:355–357.Google Scholar
Higham, Charles 2002 The Civilization of Angkor. University of California Press, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Hyslop, John 1990 Inka Settlement Planning. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
Kemp, Barry J. 2000 Bricks and Metaphor. In: Viewpoint: Were Cities Built as Images? Cambridge Archaeological Journal 10:335–346.Google Scholar
López Luján, Leonardo 1989 La recuperación mexica del pasado teotihuacano. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City.Google Scholar
López Luján, Leonardo 1998 Recreating the Cosmos: Seventeen Aztec Dedication Caches. In The Sowing and the Dawning: Termination, Dedication, and Transformation in the Archaeological and Ethnographic Record of Mesoamerica, edited by Shirley Boteler Mock, pp. 177–188. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Lynch, Kevin 1981 A Theory of Good City Form. MIT Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Mannikka, Eleanor 1996 Angkor Wat: Time, Space, and Kingship. University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu.Google Scholar
Matos Moctezuma, Eduardo 1995 Life and Death in the Templo Mayor. Translated by Bernard R. Ortiz de Montellano and Themla Ortiz de Montellano. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Maudslay, Alfred P. 1913 A Note on the Position and Extent of the Great Temple Enclosure of Tenochtitlan and the Position, Structure, and Orientation of the Teocalli of Huitzilopochtli (Abstract). In Proceedings, 18th International Congress of Americanists (London, 1912), vol. 1, pp. 173–175. Harrison and Sons, London.Google Scholar
Moseley, Michael E. 2001 The Incas and Their Ancestors: The Archaeology of Peru. Revised ed. Thames and Hudson, New York.Google Scholar
Motolinía, Fray Toribio de Benavente 1971 Memoríales, o libra de las cosas de la Nueva España y de los naturales de ella. Edited by Edmundo O’Gorman. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Prem, Hanns J. 2000 ¿Detrás de qué esquina se esconde la ideología? In Arquitectura e ideología de los aniguos mayas: memoria de la Segunda Mesa Redonda de Palenque, edited by Silvia Trejo, pp. 55–70. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City.Google Scholar
Rapoport, Amos 1993 On the Nature of Capitals and Their Physical Expression. In Capital Cities, Les Capitales: Perspectives Internationales, International Perspectives, edited by John Taylor, Jean G. Lengellé and Caroline Andrew, pp. 31–67. Carleton University Press, Ottawa.Google Scholar
Rowe, John H. 1967 What Kind of a Settlement was Inca Cuzco? Nawpa Pacha 5:59–77.Google Scholar
Rowe, John H. 1977 Archaeoastronomy in Mesoamerica and Peru. Latin American Research Review 14(2):227–233.Google Scholar
Smith, Michael E. 1997 City Planning: Aztec City Planning. In Encyclopaedia of the History of Non-Western Science, Technology, and Medicine, edited by Helaine Selin, pp. 200–202. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht.Google Scholar
Smith, Michael E. 2003 The Aztecs. 2nd ed. Blackwell, Oxford.Google Scholar
Smith, Michael E., and Montiel, Lisa 2001 The Archaeological Study of Empires and Imperialism in Prehispanic Central Mexico. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 20:245–284.Google Scholar
Spodek, Howard, and Srinivasan, Doris Meth (editors) 1993 Urban Form and Meaning in South Asia: The Shaping of Cities from Prehistoric to Precolonial Times. Studies in the History of Art, Center for Advanced Study in the Visual Arts, Symposium Papers XV, vol. 31. National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Stanislawski, Dan 1946 The Origin and Spread of the Grid Pattern Town. Geographical Review 36:105–120.Google Scholar
Steinhardt, Nancy S. 1990 Chinese Imperial City Planning. University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu.Google Scholar
Umberger, Emily 1987 Antiques, Revivals, and References to the Past in Aztec Art. RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics 13:62–105.Google Scholar
Umberger, Emily 1996 Art and Imperial Strategy in Tenochtitlan In Aztec Imperial Strategies, edited by Frances F. Berdan et al., pp. 85–106. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Wheatley, Paul 1971 The Pivot of the Four Quarters: A Preliminary Enquiry into the Origins and the Character of the Ancient Chinese City. Aldine, Chicago.Google Scholar
Zuidema, R. Tom 1990 Inca Civilization in Cuzco. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar