Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T15:16:46.380Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

From the Dance Floor to the Rifle Range: The Evolution of Manliness in the National Guards, 1870-19171

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 November 2010

Eleanor L. Hannah
Eleanor L. Hannah
Affiliation:
University of Minnesota, Duluth
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

From 1870 through 1900, the National Guard attracted tens of thousands of new members by offering men the opportunity to demonstrate that they were manly men who held dramatic civic roles that put them at the center of community social and patriotic life. Time, modernization, strike service, changes in technology, and warfare all worked to alter the environment in which Guardsmen made themselves men. Guardsmen of the early twentieth century no longer found their definition of manhood and citizenship in performances for the local community. By 1917, the elements of manhood National Guardsmen shared had evolved from the focus on style and sociability they celebrated the 1880s and 1890s into an individual focus on a concept of self-discipline, self-improvement, and national patriotism. The National Guard offers historians the opportunity to see how an organization that emphasized making men manly was able to shift what that meant as definitions of manhood evolved and as the Guard worked to keep its appeal current and fresh to each new batch of recruits.

Type
Essays
Information
The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era , Volume 6 , Issue 2 , April 2007 , pp. 149 - 177
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2 Turner, Henry L., Souvenir Album and Sketch Book, First Infantry I.N.G. of Chicago (Chicago, 1890), 5Google Scholar.

3 For evidence of the broad appeal of the late-nineteenth-century National Guards, see Cooper, Jerry, The Rise of the National Guard: The Evolution of the American Militia, 1865-1920 (Lincoln, NE, 1997), 30.Google Scholar See also Hannah, Eleanor, Manhood, Citizenship, and the National Guard: Illinois, 1870-1917 (Columbus, OH, 2007)Google Scholar; Johnson, Charles, African American Soldiers in the National Guard: Recruitment and Deployment during Peacetime and War (Westport, CT, 1992)Google Scholar; Schneirov, Richard, Labor and Urban Politics, Class Conflict and the Origins of Modern Uberalism in Chicago, 1864-97 (Urbana, IL, 1998), 59Google Scholar; Turnbaugh, Roy, “Ethnicity, Civic Pride, and Commitment: The Evolution of the Chicago Militia,” Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society 11 (1979): 111–27Google Scholar.

4 See Bederman, Gail, Manliness and Civilisation: A Cultural History of Gender and Race in the United States, 1880-1917 (Chicago, 1995)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Carnes, Mark C., Secret Ritual and Manhood in Victorian America (New Haven, CT, 1989)Google Scholar; Clawson, Mary Ann, Constructing Brotherhood: Class, Gender and Fraternalism (Princeton, NJ, 1989)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hoganson, Kristin L., Fighting for American Manhood: How Gender Politics Provoked the Spanish-American and Philippine-American Wars (New Haven, CT, 1998)Google Scholar; Kasson, John F., Houdini, Tartan, and the Perfect Man: The White Male Body and the Challenge of Modernity in America (New York, 2001)Google Scholar; Kimmell, Michael, Manhood in America, A Cultural History (New York, 1996)Google Scholar; Powers, Madelon, Faces Along the Bar: Lore and Order in the Workingman's Saloon, 1870-1920 (Chicago, 1998)Google Scholar; Rotundo, E. Anthony, American Manhood: Transformations in Masculinity from the Revolution to the Modern Era (New York, 1993)Google Scholar; and Winter, Thomas, Making Men, Making Class: The YMCA and Workingmen, 1877-1920 (Chicago, 2002)Google Scholar.

5 For general histories of the National Guards and militias, see Cooper, Rise of the National Guard; Cunliffe, Marcus, Soldiers and Civilians: The Martial Spirit in America, 1775-1865 (Boston, 1968)Google Scholar; Derthick, Martha, The National Guard in Politics (Cambridge, MA, 1965)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Doubler, Michael D., Civilian in Peace, Soldier in War (Lawrence, KS, 2003)Google Scholar; Mahon, John K., History of the Militia and the National Guard (New York, 1983)Google Scholar; Riker, William, Soldiers of the States: The Role of the National Guard in American Democracy (Washington, 1957).Google Scholar See also Davis, Susan G., Parades and Power: Street Theatre in Nineteenth-Century Philadelphia (Philadelphia, 1986)Google Scholar.

6 Illinois makes a good case study during the period between 1870 and 1917, as the Illinois National Guard ranked among the larger and busier state militias but was never as well funded as some of the eastern states. , Cooper, Rise of the National Guard, ch. 2.Google ScholarProceedings of the First Annual Convention, Interstate National Guard Association, held at Planter's Hotel, St. Louis, Missouri, December 7-8, 1897, bound, typewritten copy of the minutes, bound in Vol. II [sic], held in the NGAUS Library, Washington, DC, Appendix.

7 , Cooper, Rise of the National Guard, chs. 3, 4Google Scholar; , Doubler, Civilian in Peace, Soldier in War, ch. 3Google Scholar.

8 Biennial Report of the Adjutant General of Illinois, Transmitted to the Governor and Commander-in-Chief for 1873 and 1874 (Springfield, IL, 1874), 29–30.Google Scholar, Cooper, Rise of the National Guard, 25–43Google Scholar; , Doubler, Civilian in Peace, Soldier in War, ch. 3Google Scholar.

9 , Hannah, ManhoodGoogle Scholar; , Cooper, Rise of the National Guard, 75–76Google Scholar.

10 For work on public performance of citizenship, see Davis, Parades and Power, Ryan, Mary, “The American Parade: Representations of the Nineteenth-Century Social Order” in The New Cultural History, ed. Hunt, L. (Berkeley, 1989)Google Scholar; Ryan, Mary P., Women in Public: Between Banners and Ballots, 1825-1880 (Baltimore, 1990)Google Scholar; Schudson, Michael, The Good Citizen: A History of American Civic Life (Cambridge, MA, 1998)Google Scholar; and Snyder, R. Claire, Citizen-Soldiers and Manly Warriors: Military Service and Gender in the Civic Republican Tradition (New York, 1999)Google Scholar.

11 Chicago Tribune, July 5, 1880, p. 8Google Scholar.

12 Chicago Tribune, July 5, 1882, p. 1–2Google Scholar.

13 Chicago Tribune July 5, 1883, p. 2Google Scholar.

14 Bunzey, R.S., History of Companies I and E, Sixth Regt., Illinois Volunteer Infantry from Whiteside County (Morrison, IL, 1901), 42, 44Google Scholar.

15 For information on the rise of Memorial Day celebrations, see Dennis, Matthew, Red, White, and Blue Letter Days: An American Calendar (Ithaca, NY, 2002), ch. 5Google Scholar.

16 “Minute Book: Company ‘I’ 7th Inf., ING,” RG 301.106, Illinois State Archives, 57-58.

11 Chicago Tribune, May 31, 1883Google Scholar.

18 Headenburg, Chas. T., ed., Souvenir History. Governor's Guard. Company C, Fifth Infantry, Illinois National Guard, 1866-1902 (Springfield, IL, 1902), 31Google Scholar.

19 Daily State Journal, Oct. 16, 1874Google Scholar; Illinois State Register (Springfield), Oct. 15, 1874Google Scholar; Biennial Report for 1873 and 1874.

20 For more on manliness and the Civil War, see Linderman, Gerald F., The Mirror of War: American Society and the Spanish American War (Ann Arbor, MI, 1974)Google Scholar; and Mitchell, Reid, The Vacant Chair: The Northern Soldier leaves Home (New York, 1993)Google Scholar.

21 Rapids, GrandDaily Democrat, July 5, 1885Google Scholar, quoted in , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 27Google Scholar.

22 Daily State Journal, Oct. 16, 1874Google Scholar.

23 Daily State Journal, Oct. 16, 1874Google Scholar; Illinois State Register, Oct. 15, 1874Google Scholar.

24 Daily State Journal, Oct. 16, 1874Google Scholar.

25 Chicago Times, July 29, 1875, p. 5Google Scholar.

26 Biennial Report of the Adjutant General of Illinois, Transmitted to the Governor and Commanderin-Chieffor 1875 and 1876 (Springfield, IL, 1877), 33–34Google Scholar.

27 Theo. Schwan, “Report of Inspection of 2nd Brigade, Illinois National Guard, 1885,” RG 168.2, National Archives.

28 See the complete set of inspection reports in the Biennial Report…for 1875 and 1876 through Biennial Report of the Adjutant General of Illinois to the Governor and Commander-in-Chief 1899-1900.

29 Jonathon Guilfole, A.A.G., to Commanding General, Northern Division, June 2, 1904, RG 168.4, card 529914, National Archives.

30 , Kimmel, Manhood in America, ch. 4Google Scholar; , Rotundo, American Manhood, ch. 10Google Scholar; and Goldstein, Warren and Gorn, Elliot J., A Brief History of American Sports (New York, 1993).Google Scholar See also Hilkey, Judy, Character is Capital: Success Manuals and Manhood in Gilded Age America (Chapel Hill, 1997)Google Scholar.

31 The Citizens Association was specifically intended to oppose “the baser sort” and put “the best men” in power. See , Schneirov, Labor and Urban Politics, 58Google Scholar; and Smith, Carl, Urban Disorder and the Shape of Belief: The Great Chicago Fire, the FLaymarket Bomb, and the Model Town of Pullman (Chicago, 1995), 109Google Scholar.

32 “Report of the Committee of the Chicago Citizens Association” in Collins, Holdridge O., History of the Illinois National Guard, from the Organisation of the First Regiment in September, 1874, to the Enactment of the Military Code in May, 1879 (Chicago, 1884), 12Google Scholar.

33 Ibid.

34 State Register, March 13, 1875Google Scholar; Daily State Journal, March 13, 1875Google Scholar.

35 , Cunliffe, Soldiers and CiviliansGoogle Scholar; , Davis, Parades and PowerGoogle Scholar, and , Ryan, Women in PublicGoogle Scholar all discuss the role of women in public patriotic celebrations.

36 State Register, March 13, 1875Google Scholar; Daily State Journal, March 13, 1875Google Scholar.

31 State Register, March 13, 1875Google Scholar; Daily State Journal, March 13, 1875Google Scholar.

38 Chamberlin, Henry Barrett, “A Sketch of the Oakland Rifles” in Historical Sketch of the Oakland Rifles and Company “C,” 4th Infantry I.N.G (1889), 19, 23Google Scholar.

39 , Turner, Souvenir Album, 155Google Scholar.

40 Ford, Paul Leicester, The Honorable Peter Stirling and What People Thought of Him (1894, repr. New York, 1928), 179–80Google Scholar.

41 , Kimmel, Manhood in America, 131–41.Google Scholar See also Deloria, Philip J., Playing Indian (New Haven, CT, 1998)Google Scholar; Grant, Julia, “A ‘Real Boy’ and not a Sissy: Gender, Childhood and Masculinity, 1890-1940,” Journal of Social History 37 (Summer 2004): 829–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Griffith, R. Marie, “Apostles of Abstinence: Fasting and Masculinity during the Progressive Era,” American Quarterly 52 (Dec. 2000): 599–638CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; and Nelson, Robert K. and Price, Kenneth M., “Debating Manliness: Thomas Wentworth Higginson, William Sloane Kennedy, and the Question of Whitman,” American Uterature 73 (Sept. 2001): 497–524CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42 Minute Book: Company “I,” 39-48, April and May 1877 entries.

43 , Goldstein and , Gorn, American Sports, 140Google Scholar.

44 , Bunzey, Companies I and E, 22Google Scholar.

45 “Minute Book: Company I,” 39-48, April and May 1877 entries; Turner, Souvenir Album, individual company histories.

46 Chicago Tribune, May 14, 1875Google Scholar.

47 , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 27.Google Scholar, Bunzey, Companies I and E, 22Google Scholar.

48 Turner, Souvenir Album, individual company histories.

45 , Turner, Souvenir Album, 60Google Scholar.

50 , Bunzey, Companies I and E, 22.Google Scholar, Turner, Souvenir AlbumGoogle Scholar, individual company histories.

51 Chicago Inter Ocean, July 7, 1875Google Scholar.

52 “Minute Book: Company I,” 39–48, April and May 1877 entriesGoogle Scholar.

53 Chicago Inter Ocean, May 20, 1879Google Scholar.

54 Hannah, Eleanor L., “The Gilded Age of Camp Lincoln, 1886-1916,” Chicago History (Spring 2006): 20–41.Google Scholar Illinois' Project, Writers, “Camp Lincoln,” Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society 34 (Sept. 1941): 281–302Google Scholar.

55 State Register, March 9-13, 1875Google Scholar; Daily State Journal, March 10-13, 1875Google Scholar; , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 27Google Scholar; “Minute Book: Company ‘I’”; Turner, Souvenir Album, individual company histories.

56 , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 27Google Scholar.

57 “Minute Book, Co. ‘D’ 7th Infantry, ING (‘the Washington Guards’),” RG 301.105, Illinois State Archives; “Minute Book: Co. ‘I’”; , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 27Google Scholar; , TurnerSouvenir Album, 60, 73Google Scholar; Bolton, Horace W., History of the Second Regiment, Illinois Volunteer Infantry from Organisation to Muster Out, (Chicago, 1899), 22Google Scholar.

58 , Chamberlin, “Oakland Rifles,” 19.Google Scholar“Minute Book, Company D,” minutes of May 21, 1879Google Scholar.

59 , Chamberlin, “Oakland Rifles,” 19Google Scholar.

60 , Turner, Souvenir Album, 66Google Scholar.

61 , Chamberlin, “Oakland Rifles,” 23Google Scholar.

62 , Turner, Souvenir Album, 66.Google Scholar It turned out that the company took in $165 at the ball but spent $875.

63 Chicago Tribune, Oct. 21, 1892Google Scholar.

64 Illinois State journal, August 18, 1898Google Scholar.

65 , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 35Google Scholar.

66 For example, see , Chamberlin, “Oakland Rifles,” 29Google Scholar; , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 35Google Scholar.

67 , Headenburg, Governor's Guard, 35Google Scholar.

68 Chicago Defender, Oct. 17, 1914Google Scholar.

69 Chicago Defender, Dec. 26, 1914Google Scholar.

70 Skinner, John R., History of the Fourth Illinois Volunteers in Their Relation to the Spanish-American War for the Liberation of Cuba and other Island Possessions of Spain (Logansport, IN, 1899) 378–79Google Scholar.

71 , Skinner, Fourth Illinois Volunteers, 380–81Google Scholar.

72 , Skinner, Fourth Illinois Volunteers, 384Google Scholar.

73 , Ford, Peter Stirling, 350–87Google Scholar.

74 , Rotundo, American Manhood, 262–74Google Scholar; , Kimmell, Manhood in America, 148–55Google Scholar; See alsoSchudson, Michael, The Good CitizenGoogle Scholar.

75 Fourth Annual Report, 1872; Biennial Reports for 1873-1874 through 1899-1900Google Scholar.

76 Biennial Report for 1877 and 1878, 108–13Google Scholar.

77 “Report of Adjutant General Alfred Orendorff to Governor Altgeld, October 1,1894,” in Biennial Report 1893 and 1894, VII-VIII.

78 “C.C. Craig, Capt. Artillery Btty B, ING, to AG Reece, Galesburg, 9 November 1898,” in Biennial Report 1899-1900, 160; Biennial Report 1905-6.

79 Foner, Philip S., The Great Labor Uprising of 1877 (New York, 1977)Google Scholar; Birtle, Andrew, “Governor George Hoadly's Use of the Ohio National Guard in the Hocking Valley Coal Strike of 1884,” Ohio History 91 (1982): 37–57Google Scholar; and Linn, Brian M., “Pretty Scaly Times: The Ohio National Guard and the Railroad Strike of 1877,” Ohio History 94 (1984): 171–81Google Scholar; , Cooper, Rise of the National Guard, ch. 3Google Scholar; Arnesen, Eric, “Specter of the Black Strikebreaker: Race, Employment, and Labor Activism in the Industrial Era,” Labor History 44 (Aug. 2003): 319–35.CrossRefGoogle ScholarIllinois State Journal, Sept. 15, Oct., 2, 4, 10, 1898Google Scholar; Illinois State Journal, Nov. 24, 28, 30, Dec. 3, 21, 1904Google Scholar.

80 , Cooper, The Rise of the National Guard, 49.Google Scholar The ING intervened in fifteen strikes (nine in the coalfields) between 1878 and 1899, the Ohio National Guard in eight, New York National Guard in six, and Pennsylvania National Guard troops intervened in only four strikes after 1877.

81 “Report of Adjutant General J. N. Reece to the Governor, Oct. 1, 1900,” in Biennial Report 1899-1900, 7.

82 Biennial Report of the Adjutant General of Illinois to the Governor and Commander-in-Chief 1899-1900 (Springfield, 1900), 8–9Google Scholar.

83 “I st Illinois Volunteer Infantry, Morning Reports,” bound book, RG 94, National Archives; and Meldrum, Thomas Miller, The Cuban Campaign of the First Infantry Illinois Volunteers, April 25-September 9 1898 (Chicago, 1899)Google Scholar; John Kendrick Collection, Horace Mellum Collection, Nicholas Budinger Collection, and the Cary T. Ray Collection, Chicago Historical Society.

84 Biennial Report 1897-98, 39-40; McCard, Harry Stanton, History of the Eighth Illinois United States Volunteers (Chicago, 1899), 87Google Scholar.

85 “lst Illinois Volunteer Infantry, Morning Reports.”

86 Biennial Report, 1899-1900, 4; Bunzey, Companies I and E; Cosmas, Graham A., An Army for Empire: The United States Army in the Spanish-American War (Columbia, MO, 1971).Google Scholar The Second Illinois went to Cuba in December of 1898 after spending six months at camps in Jacksonville, Florida, and Savannah, Georgia, staying through April 3, 1899. The Third Illinois was in Puerto Rico from July 31 through November 9, 1898. The Fourth Illinois had the distinction of spending the longest amount of time in the federal service, almost a full year, from May 20, 1898, to May 2, 1899. The Fourth Illinois arrived in Cuba in January of 1899 for garrison duty and left on April 5. The Fifth and the Seventh Illinois, along with the First Cavalry, never left the United States despite being in federal service for several months each. Two companies of the Sixth Illinois, Companies “I” and “E,” USV, took part in the Puerto Rican campaign as part of the Fifth Army Corps. The rest of the Sixth also served briefly in Puerto Rico, July 25 through September 13, as did Battery A.

87 Meldrum, Cuban Campaign.

88 “Address of Lieut. J. H. Parker,” Souvenir of the banquet to the Interstate National Guard Association by the Illinois National Guard, Chicago, December 15, 1898, Great Northern Hotel (Chicago, 1899), 45Google Scholar.

89 , Bolton, Second Regiment, 433Google Scholar.

90 , Skinner, Fourth Illinois Volunteers, 386Google Scholar.

91 , Bunzey, Companies I and E, 37Google Scholar.

92 , Bunzey, Companies I and E, 352Google Scholar.

93 Goode, W. T., The Eighth Illinois (Chicago, 1899), 5Google Scholar; Hannah, Eleanor, “A Place in the Parade: Citizenship, Manhood, and African-American Men in the Illinois National Guard, 1870-1917,” Journal of Illinois History 5 (Summer 2002): 82–108Google Scholar; Gatewood, Willard Jr, “An Experiment in Color: The Eighth Illinois Volunteers, 1898-1899,” Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society 65 (1972): 293–312Google Scholar.

84 McCard, Harry Stanton, History of the Eighth Illinois United States Volunteers (Chicago, 1899), 82Google Scholar.

95 , McCard, History of the Eighth Illinois, 5Google Scholar.

96 Souvenir of the Banquet, 27.

97 Souvenir of the Banquet, preface, 5. The quotes are taken from Rudyard Kipling's poem, “The White Man's Burden,” 1899, written to Americans after the Spanish-American War.

98 “Address of Lieut. J. H. Parker,” Souvenir of the Banquet, 45.

99 In 1890 Senator W D. Washburn of Minnesota donated a trophy to be awarded to the winner of a marksmanship competition between teams representing Wisconsin, Michigan, Iowa, Minnesota, and Illinois. If one team won the trophy three times in a row, the trophy became its permanendy. Illinois won the competitions in 1891 and 1892. The third competition was not held until 1903. The Illinois State Rifle team won that meet, and the trophy went to the ING. See Biennial Report 1891 and 1892, 5; Biennial “Report 1903-1904, 7.

100 “President Wants Real, Not Parade Soldiers,” New York Times, Jan. 23, 1906, p. 4Google Scholar.

101 Bliss, Colonel E. R., “Address of Welcome,” in Turner, , Souvenir Album, 14Google Scholar.

102 Cbicago Tribune, July 3, 1880.

103 For turn-of-the-century newspaper coverage of rifle shooting, see: “6th Massachusetts Wins Rifle Trophy,” New York Times, Aug. 22, 1908, p. 8Google Scholar; New York Times, Dec. 26, 1907, p. 5Google Scholar.

104 See “Letter Book Company ‘G’ 4th Inf., ING,” RG 301.101, Illinois State Archives; “Letter Book Company ‘M’ 6th Inf., Illinois National Guard, “RG 301.102, Illinois State Archives.

105 Pratt, Walter Merriam, Tin Soldiers: The Organised Militia and What It Really Is (Boston, 1912), 165Google Scholar.

106 , Pratt, Tin Soldiers, 165–66Google Scholar.

107 A.L. Mills, Chief of the Division of Militia Affairs, to Adjutant General of Illinois, Feb. 2, 1914, Document 43398, Box 189, RG 168.7, National Archives.

108 Bush, Harold M., The Diary of an Enlisted Man (Columbus, OH, 1908), ForwardGoogle Scholar.

109 , Bush, Diary of an Enlisted Man, 7Google Scholar.

110 , Bush, Diary of an Enlisted Man, 206.Google Scholar

111 , Bush, Diary of an Enlisted Man, 208Google Scholar.

112 , Bush, Diary of an Enlisted Man, 5Google Scholar.

113 , Bush, Diary of an Enlisted Man, 122–32Google Scholar.

114 Major M.J Phillips, “In Our Country's Service,” serialized in the National Guard Magazine, beginning in Vol. II, No. 8, Aug. 1908, 355, and continuing through the April 1909 issue.

115 , Bliss, “Address of Welcome” in Turner, , Souvenir Album, 14Google Scholar.

116 , Phillips, “In Our Country's Service,” 358Google Scholar.

117 , Phillips, “In Our Country's Service,” 357–58Google Scholar.

118 , Phillips, “In Our Country's Service,” 358Google Scholar.

119 , Phillips, “In Our Country's Service,” 414Google Scholar.