Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T02:06:04.228Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Exploring the Past of the ‘Other’: the Practice of U.S. History in Mexico

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 November 2010

Georg Leidenberger
Georg Leidenberger
Affiliation:
Urban Studies Research Group Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana-AzcapotzalcoMexico City
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the courses on U.S. history I teach in Mexico, this speech by Maine congressman Severance serves well to illustrate arguments of the opposition movement to the U.S.-Mexican War. Severance offers a variety of reasons for his anti-war stand, but to my students I like to emphasize this particular one, for it follows a logic contrary to their nationally-framed perceptions. What Severance suggests here, is that these two countries share a common identity, namely that of being “the two largest republics of the world” based on “the principles of civil liberty and elective government,” and that therefore they ought not to be at war. My insistence on a perspective that views the commonalities of the two countries' historic experiences has been futile, however, when teaching about a war that resulted in the “transfer” - to put it in neutral terms - of over half of Mexico's national territory to the U.S. Students are little impressed by this congressman's (and my own) argumentation and stress instead what divides Mexico and the U.S., not only with regard to this historical event, but also with regard to the countries' pasts as a whole. For instance, in a conference at a university in Toluca, my efforts to make my audience understand the internal dynamics of U.S. foreign policy during the 19th century not only appeared to fall on deaf ears but also provoked nearly hostile reactions.

Type
Essays
Information
The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era , Volume 1 , Special Issue 4: Teaching the GAPE Internationally , October 2002 , pp. 308 - 329
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 2002

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Selected Bibliography

Anglia: Anuario Estudios Angloamericanos (Anglia: Annual Journal of Anglo-American Studies), vols. 1–6 (1968–1973).Google Scholar
Weiss, Amaga, Adolfo, Víctor & Arguello, Ana Rosa Suárez, eds. Estados Unidos desde América Latina: sociedad, política y cultura (The United States as Seen from Latin America: Society, Politics and Culture). Proceedings of the Second Meeting of Latin Americanists Dedicated to the Study of the United States, Mexico, 1992. Mexico City, Instituto de Investigaciones Dr. José Luis Mora, Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económicas & El Colegio de México, 1995.Google Scholar
Boorstin, Daniel, ed. Compendio histórico de los Estados Unidos (Historie Outline of the United States). Mexico City, Fondo de Cultura Económica, 1997, 1966.Google Scholar
Bosch García, Carlos. La base de la política exterior estadounidense (The Basis of U.S. Foreign Policy). Mexico City, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, 1969.Google Scholar
Brinkley, Alan. Historia de Estados Unidos (History of the United States). Mexico City, McGraw Hill, 1996.Google Scholar
Bruce-Novoa, . “Escritores del otro lado. Literatura de la frontera” (Writers On the Other Side: The Literature of the Frontier). Los universitarios (Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Coordinación de Difusión Cultural) No. 17 (February 2002): 52–57.Google Scholar
Daniel, Cosío Villegas. “De la necesidad de estudiar la historia de Estados Unidos” (Of the Necessity to Study U.S. History), Anglia 1 (1968): 9–17.Google Scholar
Fritsche Aceves, Ernesto & Muñoz, Maria Elena García. “Los niños héroes, de la realidad al mito” (The Niños Héroes: From Reality to Myth), UNAM, Thesis Licenciatura, Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 1989.Google Scholar
Granstein Dickter, Arturo. “Estado y ferrocarriles en México y EU, 1890–1911” (State and Railroads in Mexico and the United States, 1890–1911), Secuencia 20 (1991): 79–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lerner, Victoria. La imagen de los Estados Unidos en los viajeros mexicanos (The Image of the United States among Mexican Travellers). Mexico City, El Colegio de México, 1971.Google Scholar
Rojo, Levin, Alexandra, Danna. “Traducción y estudio historiográfico de Charles Mclean Andrews” (Translation and Historiographie Study of Andrews, Charles Mclean), Los antecedentes coloniales de la revolución de independencia en los Estados Unidos (The Colonial Origins of the U.S. Revolution of Independence), UNAM, Thesis Licenciatura, Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 1993.Google Scholar
Morris, Richard, ed. Las revoluciones de independencia de México y Estados Unidos (The Revolutions of Independence in Mexico and the United States). Mexico City, Colegio de México, American Historical Association, 1976.Google Scholar
Moyano Pahissa, Angela & Estela Báez-Villaseñor, Moreno. EU A: una nación de naciones (USA: A Nation of Nations). Series: “¿Cómo son los norteamericanos?” (What are North Americans Like?). Mexico City, Instituto de Investigaciones Dr. José Luis Mora, 1993.Google Scholar
Orozco, José Luis. Sobre la filosofía norteamericana del poder (A North American Philosophy of Power). Ciudad Juárez, Universidad Autónoma de Ciudad Juárez, 1995.Google Scholar
Orozco, José Luis. El estado pragmático (The Pragmatic State). Mexico City, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Facultad de Ciencias Políticas y Sociales, 1997.Google Scholar
Ortega, y Medina, Juan Antonio. La evangelización puritana en Norteamérica: Delundi sunt Indi (The Puritan Evangelization of North America. Delundi sunt Indi). Mexico City, Fondo de Cultura Económica, 1976.Google Scholar
Ortega, y Medina, Juan Antonio. Destino manifiesto. Sus razones históricas y su raíz teológica (Manifest Destiny: Its Historical Reasons and Theological Roots). Mexico City, Secretaría de Educación Pública, 1972.Google Scholar
Rama, Carlos M.La imagen de Estados Unidos en los viajeros mexicanos (The Image of the United States Among Mexican Travellers). Mexico City, Secretaría de Educación Pública, 1975.Google Scholar
Said, Edward W.Orientalism. New York, 1978.Google Scholar
Said, Edward W.Culture and Imperialism. New York, 1993.Google Scholar
Secuencia 20 (1991), Instituto de Investigaciones DrMora, José Luis.Google Scholar
Soto Estrada, Miguel. “La disputa entre Mondova y Saltillo y la independencia de Texas” (The Dispute between Mondova and Saltillo and Texan Independence), Tempus 1 (otoño 1993): 150–74. Mexico City, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 1993.Google Scholar
Argüello, Suárez, Rosa, Ana. Peso de intereses privados en las relaciones EU A-México, 1848–1854 (The Importance of Private Interests for U.S.-Mexican Relations). Mexico City, Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, forthcoming.Google Scholar
Argüello, Suárez, Rosa, Ana, Basante, Marcela Terrazas, Soto, Miguel, eds. Política y negocios, ensayos sobre la relación entre México y los Estados Unidos en el siglo XIX (Politics and Business: Essays on Mexican-U.S. Relations During the 19th Century). Mexico City, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México & Instituto de Investigaciones José Luis Mora, 1997.Google Scholar
Thelen, David. “Rethinking History and the Nation-State: Mexico and the United States,” Journal of American History 86 (September 1999): 439–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tindall, George B. & E., David Shi. Historia de los Estados Unidos (History of the United States). Bogota, Tercer Mundo Editores, 1995.Google Scholar
Tyler, Daniel. De Truman a Nixon: uso y abuso del poder presidencial (From Traman to Nixon: Uses and Abuses of Presidential Power). Mexico City, Universidad Iberoamericana & El Colegio de México, 1981.Google Scholar
Tyler, Daniel. et. al. El destino manifiesto en la historia de la nación norteamericana (Manifest Destiny in the History of the North American Nation). Mexico City, Universidad Iberoamericana, 1977.Google Scholar
Vann Woodward, C. ed. Historia comparativa de los Estados Unidos (A Comparative History of the United States). Mexico City, Ed. Letras, 1971, 1967.Google Scholar
Vázquez, Josefina Z. “La enseñanza e investigación de la historia de Estados Unidos en México” (The Teaching and Researching of the History of the United States in Mexico), Secuencia (Instituto de Investigaciones DrMora, José Luis) 20 (1991): 148–52.Google Scholar
Vázquez, Josefina Z.La intervención norteamericana, 1846–1848 (North American Intervention, 1846–1848). Mexico City, Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, 1997.Google Scholar
Vázquez, Josefina Z. “La mujer en la historia norteamericana” (Women in North American History), Anglia 4 (1971).Google Scholar
Vázquez, Josefina Z. & Meyer, Lorenzo. México frente a los Estados Unidos (Mexico Facing the United States). Mexico City, El Colegio de México, 1982.Google Scholar
Vázquez, Josefina Z. & Morris, Richard, eds. Las revoluciones de independencia de México y Estados Unidos (The Revolutions of Independence in Mexico and the United States). Mexico City, Colegio de México, American Historical Association, 1976.Google Scholar
Velasco Márquez, Jesús. “Calhoun y el expansionismo norteamericano” (Calhoun and North American Expansionism), Anuario de Historia 9 (1979): 53–80.Google Scholar
Velasco Márquez, Jesús, Pahissa, Angela Moyano, Dickter, Arturo Grunstein, Argüello, Ana Rosa Suárez et. al. EUA (USA) 10 vols. Mexico City, Instituto de Investigaciones Dr. José Luis Mora, 1988.Google Scholar
Velasco Márquez, Jesús et. al. ¿Qué son los Estados Unidos? (What are the United States Like?) Mexico City, McGraw-Hill, 1996.Google Scholar
Zavála, Silvio. El mundo americano en la época colonial (The American World in the Colonial Period). Mexico City, Editorial Porrúa, 1967.Google Scholar