Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-l7hp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T05:23:40.990Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Health and Labour Force Participation: ‘Stress’, Selection and the Reproduction Costs of Labour Power*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2009

Mel Bartley
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper will discuss the applicability of concepts of ‘stress’ and ‘selection’ to which health researchers appealed in their attempts to explain the relationship between health and unemployment, and examine the implications of some of the major studies carried out in Europe and the USA for these competing approaches. The contradictions arising from this evidence will then be addressed with the aid of a technical advance in population statistics which allows us to test hypotheses about whether the associations between socio-demographic characteristics and mortality may be due to selective mobility of seriously ill persons into socially disadvantaged positions. It is concluded that a better understanding of the results of available studies may be reached if we avoid the dichotomy between ‘stress’ and ‘selection’, and explore whether concepts of labour market processes and the reproduction costs of labour power can throw new light on the relationship between health and patterns of labour force participation. The paper aims both to encourage health researchers to consider policy and market variables more closely, and to tempt researchers more specialised in these latter fields to apply recent advances in the understanding of the interaction between labour market and income maintenance policies to the question of how economic conditions and change may affect health.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of Social Policy , Volume 20 , Issue 3 , July 1991 , pp. 327 - 364
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1991

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Arber, S. (1987), ‘Social class, non-employment and chronic illness: continuing the inequalities in health debate’, British Medical Journal. 294, 1069–73.Google Scholar
Banks, M.H. and Jackson, P.R. (1982), ‘Unemployment and the risk of minor psychiatric disorder in young people’. Psychological Medicine. 12, 789–98.Google Scholar
Bartley, M. (1986), ‘Redundancy and health’, in Lee, R.M. (ed.), Redundancies, Layoffs and Plant Closures. Croom Helm. London.Google Scholar
Bartley, M. (1988), ‘Unemployment and health: selection or causation—a false antithesis?’, Sociology of Health and Illness. 10, 41–67.Google Scholar
Beale, N. and Nethercott, S. (1985), ‘Job-loss and family morbidity: a study of a factory closure’, Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners, 35, 510–4.Google Scholar
Beale, N. and Nethercott, S. (1987), ‘The health of industrial employees four years after compulsory redundancy’, Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners, 37, 390–4.Google Scholar
Blane, D. (1990), ‘Real wages, the economic cycle, and mortality in England and Wales. 1871–1914’, International Journal of Health Services, 21, 43–52.Google Scholar
Brannen, J. and Wilson, G. (eds) (1987), Give and Take in Families, Allen and Unwin, London.Google Scholar
Brenner, M.H. (1973), Mental Illness and the Economy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Brenner, M.H. (1977), ‘Health costs and benefits of economic policy’. International Journal of Health Policy, 7, 581–623.Google Scholar
Brenner, M.H. (1979), ‘Mortality and the national economy: a review and the experience of England and Wales’, Lancet, ii, 568–73.Google Scholar
Brenner, M.H. (1987), ‘Economic instability, unemployment rates, behavioural risks and mortality rates in Scotland, 1952–1983’. International Journal of Health Services, 17, 475–87.Google Scholar
Brenner, M.H. and Mooney, A. (1982), ‘Economic change and sex-specific cardiovascular mortality in Britain’. Social Science and Medicine, 16, 431–42.Google Scholar
Brown, G.W. and Harris, T.O. (1978), Social Origins of Depression, Tavistock, London.Google Scholar
Burchell, B. (1989), ‘Who is affected by unemployment ? Job insecurity and labour market influences on psychological health’, Department of Social and Political Sciences and Department of Applied Economics working paper, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Carpenter, L. (1987), ‘Some observations on the healthy worker effect’, British Journal of Industrial Medicine, 44, 287–91.Google Scholar
Charles, N. and Kerr, M. (1988), Women, Food and Families, Manchester University Press, Manchester.Google Scholar
Cobb, S. and Kasl, S.V. (1977), Termination: The Consequences of Job Loss, (DHEW-NIOSH Publication No. 77–224, Cincinatti, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health).Google Scholar
Cook, D.G. (1985), ‘A critical view of the unemployment and health debate’. The Statistician, 34, 73–82.Google Scholar
Cook, D.G., Cummins, R.O., Bartley, M.J. and Shaper, A.G. (1982), ‘The health of unemployed middle aged men in Britain’, Lancet, i, 1290–4.Google Scholar
Cooke, K. (1988), ‘The costs of unemployment’, in Walker, R. and Parker, G. (eds), Money Matters, Sage. London.Google Scholar
Costa, G., Crepet, P. and Florenzano, F. (1988), ‘Unemployment and mortality in Italy: the Turin Longitudinal Study’, in Kreitman, N. and Platt, S. (eds), Current Research on Suicide and Parasuicide, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Daniel, W.W. (1983), ‘How the unemployed fare after they find new jobs’, Policy Studies, 3, 246–260.Google Scholar
Daniel, W.W. and Stilgoe, E. (1978), Where Are They Now: A Follow-up Study of the Unemployed, Political and Economic Planning, London.Google Scholar
Smith, G. Davey. Bartley, M. and Blane, D. (1990), ‘Health inequalities ten years after the Black Report’, British Medical Journal, 301, 373–7.Google Scholar
Deacon, A. (1976), In Search of the Scrounger: Occasional Papers in Social Administration, Bell and Son, London.Google Scholar
Deacon, A. (1978), ‘The scrounging controversy: public attitudes towards the unemployed in contemporary Britain’, Social and Economic Administration, 12, 120–35.Google Scholar
Deakin, N. (1987), The Politics of Welfare, Methuen, London.Google Scholar
Fagin, L. (1981), Unemployment and Health in Families: case studies based on family interviews, DHSS, London.Google Scholar
Fagin, L. and Little, M. (1984), The Forsaken Families, Penguin, London.Google Scholar
Fevre, R. (1986a), ‘Contract work in the recession’, in Wood, S. et al. (eds), The Changing Experience of Work: Re-structuring and Recession, Macmillan. London.Google Scholar
Fevre, R. (1986b), ‘Redundancy and the labour market’, in Lee, R.M. (ed.), Redundancy, Layoffs and Plant Closures, Croom Helm, London.Google Scholar
Fevre, R. (1987), ‘Subcontracting in steel’, Work, Employment and Society, 1, 509–527.Google Scholar
Fox, A.J. (1989), Health inequalities in European Countries, Gower, Aldershot.Google Scholar
Fox, A.J. and Collier, P.F. (1976), ‘Low mortality rates in industrial cohort studies due to selection for work and survival in the industry’, British Journal of Preventative Social Medicine, 9, 180–5.Google Scholar
Fox, A.J., Goldblatt, P.O. and Adelstein, A.M. (1982), ‘Selection and mortality differentials’. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 36, 69–79.Google Scholar
Fox, A.J., Goldblatt, P.O. and Jones, D.R. (1985), ‘Social class mortality differentials: artefact, selection or life circumstances?’. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 39, 1–8.Google Scholar
Fox, A.J., Goldblatt, P.O. and Jones, D.R. (1990), ‘Social class mortality differentials: artefact, selection or life circumstances?’, in Goldblatt, P.O. (ed.). Longitudinal Study 1971–1981: Mortality and Social Organisation, OPCS Series LS No. 6, HMSO, London.Google Scholar
Fox, A.J. and Goldblatt, P. (1982), Longitudinal Study: Socio-Demographic Differentials in Mortality. HMSO, London.Google Scholar
Gallie, D. and Vogler, C. (1988), Labour Market Deprivation, Welfare and Collectivism, ESRC SCELI Working Paper 7.Google Scholar
Glendinning, C. and Millar, J. (eds) (1987), Women and Poverty in Britain, Wheatsheaf, Brighton.Google Scholar
Goldblatt, P.O. (1986), Social Class Mortality Differentials of Men aged 16–64 in 1981: a note on first results from the OPCS Longitudinal Study for the period 1981–83, Social Statistics Research Unit, LS Working Paper No. 42.Google Scholar
Goldblatt, P.O. (ed.) (1990), Longitudinal Study 1971–1981: Mortality and Social Organisation, OPCS Series LS No. 6, HMSO, London.Google Scholar
Golding, P. and Middleton, S. (1982), Images of Welfare: Press and Public Attitudes to Poverty, Martin Robertson, Oxford.Google Scholar
Gravelle, H.S.E., Hutchinson, J. and Stern, J. (1981), ‘Mortality and unemployment: a critique of Brenner's time-series analysis’, Lancet, ii, 675–9.Google Scholar
Gravelle, H.S.E. (1985), Does unemployment Kill?, Nuffield/York Portfolio No. 9, University of York.Google Scholar
Hakim, C. (1982), ‘The social consequences of unemployment’, Journal of Social'Policy, 4, 433–67.Google Scholar
Harris, C.C. (1987), ‘Redundancy and class analysis’, in Lee, R.M. (ed.), Redundancy, Layoffs and Plant Closures, Croom Helm, London.Google Scholar
Hennock, E.P. (1976), ‘Poverty and social theory in England: the experience of the 1880s’, Social History, 1, 67–91.Google Scholar
Illsley, R. (1986), ‘Occupational class, selection and the production of inequalities in health’, Quarterly Journal of Social Affairs, 2, 151–165.Google Scholar
Iversen, I., Andersen, O., Andersen, P.K., Christoffersen, K. and Keiding, N. (1987), ‘Unemployment and mortality in Denmark’, British Medical Journal, 295, 879–84.Google Scholar
Iversen, L., Sabroe, S. and Damsgaard, M.T. (1989), ‘Hospital admissions before and after shipyard closure’, British Medical Journal, 299, 1073–6.Google Scholar
Jahoda, M., Lazarsfeld, P.F. and Zeisl, H. (1933), Marienthal: the Sociography of an Unemployed Community, Tavistock Publications re-edition, 1972, London.Google Scholar
Jahoda, M. (1987), ‘Unemployed men at work’, in Fryer, D. and Ullah, P. (eds), Unemployed People, Open University Press, Milton Keynes.Google Scholar
Karasek, R. (1989), ‘The political implications of psychosocial work redesign: a model of the psychosocial class structure’, International Journal of Health Services, 19, 481–508.Google Scholar
Kasl, S.V. (1982), ‘Strategies of research on economic instability and health’, Psychological Medicine, 12, 637–49.Google Scholar
Kasl, S.V. and Cobb, S. (1982), ‘Variability of stress effects among men experiencing job loss’, in Goldberg, L. and Breznitz, S. (eds). Handbook of Stress, Free Press, New York.Google Scholar
Lee, R.M. (1985), ‘Redundancy, labour markets and informal relations’, Sociological Review, 33, 469–95.Google Scholar
Lee, R.M. and Harris, C.C. (1985), ‘Redundancy studies: Port Talbot and the future’, Quarterly Journal of Social Affairs, 1, 19–27.Google Scholar
Marmot, M.G. and McDowell, M.E. (1986), ‘Mortality and widening social inequalities’, Lancet, ii, 274–6.Google Scholar
Marx, K. (1965), Capital: A Critical Analysis of Capitalist Production, Progress Publishers, Moscow.Google Scholar
Micklewright, J. (1986), ‘Unemployment and incentives to work: policy and evidence in the 1980s’, in Hart, P.E. (ed.). Unemployment and Labour Market Policies, Gower, Aldershot.Google Scholar
Moser, K.A., Fox, A.J. and Jones, D.R. (1984), ‘Unemployment and mortality in the OPCS Longitudinal Study’, Lancet, ii, 1324–8.Google Scholar
Moser, K.A., Goldblatt, P.O., Fox, A.J. and Jones, D.R. (1986), ‘Unemployment and mortality 1981–83: follow-up of the 1981 Longitudinal Study Census sample’, LS Working Paper 43, Social Statistics Research Unit, City University, London.Google Scholar
Moser, K.A., Goldblatt, P.O., Fox, A.J. and Jones, D.R. (1987), ‘Unemployment and mortality: comparison of the 1971 and 1981 longitudinal study census samples’, British Medical Journal, i, 86–90.Google Scholar
Moser, K.A., Pugh, H. and Goldblatt, P.O. (1988), Inequalities in women's health in England and Wales: Mortality among married women according to social circumstances, employment characteristics and life cycle stage, Social Statistics Unit LS Working Paper No. 57.Google Scholar
Moylan, S. and Davies, R. (1980), ‘The disadvantages of the unemployed’. Employment Gazette, 88, 830–2.Google Scholar
Moylan, S.. Millar, J. and Davies, B. (1984), For Richer, For Poorer—DHSS Cohort Study of Unemployed Men. HMSO, London.Google Scholar
Murcott, A. (1983), ‘It's a pleasure to cook for him’, in Gamarnikov, E., Morgan, D., Purvis, J. and Taylorson, D. (eds), The Public and the Private, Gower, Aldershot.Google Scholar
Norris, G.M. (1978a), ‘Unemployment, subemployment and personal characteristics (i) The inadequacies of traditional approaches’. Sociological Review, 26, 89–108.Google Scholar
Norris, G.M. (1978b), ‘Unemployment, subemployment and personal characteristics (ii) Job separation and work histories: the alternative approach’, Sociological Review, 26, 327–47.Google Scholar
Offe, C. (1984), Contradictions of the Welfare State, edited by Keane, J., Hutchinson, London.Google Scholar
Offe, C. (1985), Disorganised Capitalism, Basil Blackwell, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Olsen, J. and Lajer, M. (1979), ‘Violent death in two trade unions in Denmark’, Social Psychiatry, 14, 139–45.Google Scholar
Pfautz, H. (1967), Charles Booth and the City: Physical Pattern and Social Structure, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
Platt, S. and Kreitman, N. (1984), ‘Trends in parasuicide and unemployment among men in Edinburgh 1968–82’, British Medical Journal, 289, 1029–32.Google Scholar
Platt, S. and Kreitman, N. (1985), ‘Parasuicide and unemployment among men in Edinburgh’, Psychological Medicine, 15, 113–23.Google Scholar
Platt, S. and Kreitman, N. (1990), ‘Long term trends in parasuicide and unemployment in Edinburgh, 1968–1987’, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 25, 56–61.Google Scholar
Robinson, J.C. (1986), ‘Job hazards and job security’, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 11, 1–17.Google Scholar
Sinfield, R.A. (1970), ‘Poor and out of work in Shields’, in Townsend, P. (ed.), The Concept of Poverty, Heinemann, London.Google Scholar
Sinfield, R.A. (1981), ‘Unemployment in an unequal society’, in Showier, B. and Sinfield, R.A. (eds), The Workless State, Martin Robertson, Oxford.Google Scholar
Sinfield, R.A. (1982), What Unemployment Means, Martin Robertson, Oxford.Google Scholar
Slote, A. (1969), Termination: The Closing at Baker, Bobbs-Merrill, Indianapolis.Google Scholar
Smee, C. and Stern, J. (1976), ‘The unemployed in a period of high unemployment—some notes on characteristics and benefit status’, DHSS discussion paper, DHSS, London.Google Scholar
Stefansson, C-G. (1989), Long-term Unemployment and Mortality in Sweden, 1980–1986, Paper to the Anglo Swedish Medical Sociology Workshop, Stockholm.Google Scholar
Sterling, P. and Eyer, J. (1987), ‘Biological basis of stress-related mortality’, Social Science and Medicine, 15E, 3–42.Google Scholar
Stern, J. (1979), ‘Who bears the burden of unemployment?’, in Beckerman, W. (ed.). Slow Growth in Britain, Clarendon, Oxford.Google Scholar
Stern, J. (1983a), ‘Social mobility and the interpretation of social class mortality differentials’, Journal of Social Policy, 12, 27–49.Google Scholar
Stern, J. (1983b), ‘The relationship between unemployment, morbidity and mortality in Britain’, Population Studies, 37, 61–74.Google Scholar
Townsend, P. (1979), Poverty in the United Kingdom Penguin, Harmondsworth.Google Scholar
Townsend, P. et al. (1991), The London Standard of Living Survey.Google Scholar
Ullah, P.. Banks, M.H. and Warr, P. (1985), ‘Social support, social pressures and psychological distress during unemployment’, Psychological Medicine, 15, 283–95.Google Scholar
Waldron, I., Herold, J., Dunn, J. and Staum, R. (1982), ‘Reciprocal effects of health and labour force participation: evidence from two longitudinal studies’. Journal of Occupational Medicine, 24, 126–132.Google Scholar
Walker, A., Noble, I. and Westergaard, J. (1985), ‘From secure employment to labour market insecurity’, in Roberts, B., Finnegan, R. and Gallic, D. (eds). New Approaches to Economic Life, Manchester University Press, Manchester.Google Scholar
Warr, P. (1985), ‘Twelve questions about unemployment and health’, in Roberts, B., Finnegan, R. and Gallie, D. (eds). New Approaches to Economic Life, Manchester University Press. Manchester.Google Scholar
Warr, P., Banks, M.H. and Jackson, P.R. (1982), ‘Duration of unemployment and psychological well-being in young men and women’. Current Psychological Research, 2, 207–214.Google Scholar
Warr, P., Banks, M.H. and Ullah, P. (1985), ‘The experience of unemployment among black and white urban teenagers’, British Journal of Psychology, 76, 75–87.Google Scholar
White, M. (1983), Long-term Unemployment and Labour Markets, PSI Report No. 622, PSI, London.Google Scholar
Whiteside, N. (1989), ‘Unemployment and health: an historical perspective’. Journal of Social Policy. 17, 177–94.Google Scholar
Wilkinson, R. (1989), ‘Class mortality differentials, income distribution and trends in poverty 1921–1981’, Journal of Social Policy. 18, 307–336.Google Scholar
Wilkinson, R. (1990), ‘Income distribution and mortality: a “natural” experiment’. Sociology of Health and Illness. 12, 391–412.Google Scholar
Wilson, G. (1987), ‘Money: patterns of responsibility and irresponsibility in marriage’, in Brannen, J. and Wilson, G. (eds). Give and Take in Families, Allen and Unwin, London.Google Scholar
Yelin, E., Nevitt, M. and Epstein, W. (1980), ‘Towards an epidemiology of work disability’, Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly, 58, 386–415.Google Scholar