Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T10:43:41.997Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The New Philanthropy: The Emergence of the Bradford City Guild of Help

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2009

Michael Cahill  and
Tony Jowitt
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The early twentieth century has been seen as a crucial period in the development of British social policy. However, attention has been concentrated almost entirely on the increased role of the state, and in particular on the Liberal ‘welfare reforms’ after 1906. These developments have tended to mask the significant changes that were taking place in the field of voluntary charitable effort. One organization which emerged out of the ferment surrounding social policy in late Victorian and Edwardian England was the Guild of Help movement.

The first guild was formed in Bradford in 1904 and embodied a new approach to the organization of charity. It rapidly expanded from Bradford throughout England and Wales and was in 1919 the leading organization which took part in the merger which created the National Council for Social Service. In this article the creation of the guild will be examined within the context of the changing economic situation, the growth of the labour movement and the nature of existing charitable provision in an attempt to give a critical assessment of the nature and role of this new body.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of Social Policy , Volume 9 , Issue 3 , July 1980 , pp. 359 - 382
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1980

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See in particular Yeo, Stephen, Religion and Voluntary Organizations in Crisis, Croom Helm, London, 1976Google Scholar; and Moore, M. J., ‘Social Work and Social Welfare: The Organisation of Philanthropic Resources in Britain, 1900–1914’, Journal of British Studies, XVI:2 (1977), 85–104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 Details of the first year's work of the Bradford City Guild of Help are given in its monthly magazine, Help, 1:2 (1905).

3 See Snowden, G. R., Report to the President of the Local Government Board on Guilds of Help in England, Cd 5664, HMSO, London, 1911Google Scholar, Parliamentary Papers (PP) XXXII.

4 Brasnett, M., Voluntary Social Action: A History of the National Council of Social Service 1919–69, National Council of Social Service, London, 1969, pp. 5–6.Google Scholar

5 Moore, op. cit. p. 86.

6 The concept of the ‘voluntary local welfare state’ has been developed in Yeo, op. cit. p. 219.

7 See Census of Great Britain 1851, Population Tables 1801–51; and Weber, A. F., The Growth of Cities in the Nineteenth Century, Macmillan, New York, 1899Google Scholar, reprinted by Cornell University Press, New York, 1963, p. 55.

8 See Census of England and Wales 1901, County of York area, Houses and Population, p. 38.Google Scholar

9 For an analysis of the depression in the Bradford worsted trade in the third quarter of the nineteenth century see Sigsworth, E. M., Black Dyke Mills, Liverpool University Press, Liverpool, 1958, pp. 72–134.Google Scholar For a detailed examination of the composition of the textile labour force in the late nineteenth century and the changes it was experiencing see Ross, W. D., ‘Bradford Politics, 1880–1906: A Detailed Study of the Fortunes of the Political Parties in Bradford as shown in Parliamentary Elections and by the Movement of Public Opinion’, doctoral thesis, University of Bradford, 1977, pp. 16–22.Google Scholar

10 The experiment at Saltaire, which was an attempt to ‘try and marry the technology and economic structure of the nineteenth century to the ordered authority and intimate relationship of the pre-industrial rural society’, is looked at in Reynolds, J., Saltaire: An Introduction to the Village of Sir Titus Salt, City of Bradford Metropolitan Council Art Galleries and Museums, Bradford, 1976.Google Scholar The general model village building movement in the mid-nineteenth century West Riding is examined in Creese, W. L., The Search for Environment: The Garden City Before and After, Yale University Press, New Haven, 1976.Google Scholar

11 See Ross, op. cit. p. 24.

12 The Manningham Mills strike and the subsequent formation of the ILP are looked at in Laybourn, K., ‘The Manningham Mills Strike: Its Importance in Bradford History’, Bradford Antiquary, 1976, pp. 7–35Google Scholar; Reynolds, J. and Laybourn, K., ‘The Emergence of the ILP in Bradford’, International Review of Social History, XX (1975), 313–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Pearce, C., The Manningham Mills Strike, Bradford December 1890–April 1891, Occasional Papers in Economic and Social History, University of Hull, 1975Google Scholar; and Thompson, E. P., ‘Homage to Tom Maguire’, in Briggs, A. and Saville, J. (eds), Essays in Labour History, Macmillan, London, 1960.Google Scholar

13 The minute books of the Samaritan Society are lodged in the Library of the Bradford Royal Infirmary.

14 The Bradford Observer, 8 10 1890.Google Scholar

15 For biographical information see Priestman, Alice, Recollections of Henry Brady Priestman, Field Sons, Bradford, 1918Google Scholar; and, for Godwin, J. A., The Bradford Daily Telegraph, 7 10 1910.Google Scholar

16 See The Bradford Observer, 21 04 1891Google Scholar; 13 June 1891; and 30 June 1891.

17 The Bradford Observer, 12 11 1890.Google Scholar

18 See The Bradford Observer, 27 02 1891Google Scholar, in which a correspondent says ‘It must be a very modest and retiring body as its existence seems to be unknown to the majority of the people of Bradford.’ See also The Bradford Observer, 13 03 1891.Google Scholar

19 See Pelling, H., The Origins of the Labour Party, second edition, Oxford University Press, London, 1965, pp. 134–5.Google Scholar

20 See The Bradford Observer, 12 10 1892.Google Scholar

21 See The Bradford Observer, 17 03 1893.Google Scholar

22 See The Bradford Observer, 30 11 1895.Google Scholar

23 See the obituary of Moser, Jacob in The Yorkshire Doily Observer, 19 07 1922Google Scholar; and that of Moser, Florence in The Bradford Daily Argus, 14 02 1921.Google Scholar

24 The Priestmans were prodigious charity workers: in 1895, in the COS alone, Frederick Priestman was Vice-President and John Priestman Chairman, and Edgar and George Edward Priestman sat on the committee.

25 See The Yorkshire Daily Observer, 25 01 1924.Google Scholar

26 Masterman, N., ‘The Guild of Help Movement’, Charity Organisation Review, XX (1906) 145.Google Scholar

27 See Wakefield, E. W., ‘The Growth of Charity Organisation in the North of England’, Charity Organisation Review, XXIV (1908).Google Scholar

28 Report of the Bradford Delegates to the COS Conference at Oxford, Bradford, 1890.Google Scholar

29 In 1900 Noel Masterman published an edition of Chalmers's writings – Masterman, N. (ed.), Chalmers on Charity: A Selection of Passages and Scenes to Illustrate the Social Teaching and Practical Work of Thomas Chalmers, Constable, London, 1900.Google Scholar

30 See Report on the Elberfeld Poor Law System and German Workmen's Colonies, Cd 5341, HMSO, London, 1888, PP LXXXGoogle Scholar; and Simey, M. B., Charitable Effort in Liverpool, Liverpool University Press, Liverpool, 1951.Google Scholar

31 See ‘The Associated Charities of Boston’, Help, 1:1 (1905)Google Scholar; and Bremner, Robert H., American Philanthropy, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1960.Google Scholar

32 Sutter, Julie, Britain's Next Campaign, R. Brimley Johnson, London, 1903.Google Scholar

33 Ibid. p. 58.

34 Ibid. pp. 83–4.

35 See Sigsworth, op. cit. pp. 100–1.

36 See The Bradford Observer, 27 03 1901.Google Scholar

37 For details on Bentham, F. H. see The Bradford Weekly Telegraph, 30 12 1910.Google Scholar

38 The Yorkshire Daily Observer, 19 01 1903.Google Scholar

39 Priestman, Alice B., ‘The City Guild of Help’, Friends Quarterly Examiner, XXXIX (1905), 220.Google Scholar

40 In 1887 the Neighbourhood Guild – a form of settlement – had been started in New York. The Mansion House Settlement formed the Friendly Workers Guild in 1894, and there was the Neighbourhood Guilds Association in Sheffield, which was involved in settlement work from its inception in 1897. See Henderson, C. R., Social Settlements, Lentilhon, New York, 1899, pp. 46–7Google Scholar; and Reason, W. (ed.), University and Social Settlements, Methuen, London, 1895Google Scholar; and The Yorkshire Daily Observer, 27 09 1904.Google Scholar

41 Guild of Help Executive Committee Minute Book, 13 11 1903.Google Scholar

42 Bradford City Guild of Help, Instructions for District Heads, No. 9.

43 See The Yorkshire Daily Observer, 27 02 1904.Google Scholar

44 See The Yorkshire Doily Observer, 2 03 1904Google Scholar; and Cinderella, Club, Fifteenth Annual Report, 1903–1904.Google Scholar

45 See The Yorkshire Daily Observer, 21 09 1904.Google Scholar

46 The authors are currently engaged on writing an analysis of the day-to-day work of the Bradford City Guild of Help. The case books of the guild, some 5,682 books covering the period from April 1905 to January 1921, are lodged in the Archives at Bradford Central Library.

47 Guild of Help Executive Committee Minute Book, 13 November 1903.

48 Ibid. 12 December 1904.

49 See Hartley, E. R., ‘Gilded Help, Forward, 10 03 1906.Google Scholar

50 See Brasnett, , op. cit. pp. 5–6.Google Scholar

51 Milledge, Walter, ‘Guilds of Help’, Charity Organisation Review, XX (1906), 46.Google Scholar

52 See The Yorkshire Daily Observer, 27 09 1904.Google Scholar

53 See The Yorkshire Daily Observer, 21 01 1907.Google Scholar

54 Rowntree, B. Seebohm, ‘Social Symposium 1: The Social Worker’, Friends Quarterly Examiner, XXXVIII (1904), 73.Google Scholar

55 For further details see Moore, , op. cit. pp. 99–100.Google Scholar This article gives an excellent analysis of the various strands in Edwardian philanthropy.

56 See Brasnett, , op. cit. p. 14.Google Scholar

57 Ibid. p. 25.