Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-4rdpn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T01:32:02.121Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Environmental Justice, Political Agenda Setting, and the Myths of History

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 October 2011

Martin V. Melosi
Affiliation:
University of Houston

Extract

The emergence of the environmental justice movement in the 1980s has stimulated much debate on the extent to which race and class have been or should become central concerns of modern environmentalism. Leaders in the environmental justice movement have charged that mainstream environmental organizations and, in turn, environmental policy have demonstrated a greater concern for preserving wilderness and animal habitats than addressing health hazards of humans, especially those living in cities; have embraced a “Save the Earth” perspective at the expense of saving people's lives and protecting their homes and backyards. Some advocates of environmental justice have gone so far as to dissociate their movement from American environmentalism altogether, rather identifying with a broader social justice heritage as imbedded in civil rights activities of the 1950s and 1960s.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA. 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. The Internet lists a wide array of environmental justice groups. See the Ecojustice Network on EcoNet, www.igc.apc.org/envjustice. See also the Center for Health, Environment and Justice, www.essential.org/cchw/cchwinf.html; Environmental Justice Resource Center, www.ejrc.cau.edu; and Environmental Justice Links, www-personal.umich.edu/~jrajzer/nre/links.html.

2. “Environmental racism” is an extension of traditional racism, can be intentional or unintentional, and suggests discrimination in environmental policymaking, enforcement of laws, and in targeting certain communities for toxic-waste disposal sites and polluting indus-tries.

3. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) defines environmental justice as the “fair treatment for people of all races, cultures, and incomes, regarding the development of environmental laws, regulations, and policies.” See “About Environmental Justice” on the Internet at www.epa.gov/swerosps/ej/aboutej.htm. See also definitions discussed in a course offered at the School of Natural Resources, University of Michigan on the Internet, www.personal.umich.edu/~jtaj2er/nre/defintions.html; Bryant, Bunyan, ed., Environmental Justice: Issues, Policies, and Solutions (Washington, D.C., 1995), 56.Google Scholar

4. Foreman, Christopher H. Jr, The Promise and Peril of Environmental Justice (Washington, D.C., 1998), 11.Google Scholar

5. This section draws heavily on Melosi, Martin V., “Equity, Eco-racism, and the Environ-mental Justice Movement” (paper delivered at the World History Association Meeting, Aspen, Colorado, 1994)Google Scholar, and idem, “Equity, Ecoracism, and Environmental History,” in Char Miller and Hal Rothman, eds., Out of the Woods: Essays in Environmental History (Pittsburgh, 1997), 194-211.

6. See Dobson, Andrew, Justice and the Environment: Conceptions of Environmental Sustainabiliry and Theories of Distributive Justice (New York, 1998), 18CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; Bullard, Robert D., “Race and Environmental Justice in the United States,” Yale Journal of International Law 18 (1993): 325Google Scholar ; , Bullard, ed., Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the Grassroots (Boston, 1993), 9Google Scholar.

7. DiChiro, Giovanna, “Nature as Community: The Convergence of Environmental and Social Justice,” in Cronon, William, ed., Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature (New York, 1996), 303.Google Scholar

8. The CRJ was founded in 1963 after the assassination of black activist Medgar Evers, church bombings in Birmingham, Alabama, and other anti-civil rights activities.

9. See Grossman, Karl, “Environmental Racism,” Crisis 98 (April 1991): 17.Google Scholar

10. McGurty, Eileen Maura, “From Nimby to Civil Rights: The Origins of the Environmental Justice Movement,” Environmental History 2 (July 1997): 318. See also 301-2, 305-7, 309-14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

11. Quoted in Grossman, Karl, “The People of Color Environmental Summit,” in Bullard, Robert D., ed., Unequal Protection: Environmental Justice and Communities of Color (San Francisco, 1994), 272.Google Scholar

12. A variety of goals were set forth at the meeting, including the less radical call for sustainable development as it pertained to the disadvantaged presented by architect and urban planner Carl Anthony. Anthony is president of the Earth Island Institute and director of its Urban Habitat Program, founded in 1989. While committed to the notion that socio-economic and environmental problems are interconnected, he has taken a particularly pragmatic stand on implementing environmental justice programs through the development of ecologically sustainable communities in the San Francisco Bay Area. He also has argued that African Americans could benefit from a greater environmental awareness and has urged them not to become isolated from the stewardship of the environment. See “Speak Out,” Internet, www.vida.com/speakout/People/Carl Anthony.html; “Urban Habitat Program,” Internet, www.igc.apc.org/uhp; Anthony, Carl, “Why African-Americans Should Be Environmentalists,” Earth Island Journal (Winter 1990): 4344Google Scholar.

13. Mowrey, Marc and Redmond, Tim, Not in Our Backyard: The People and Events That Shaped America's Modem Environment Movement (New York, 1993), 435–36.Google Scholar

14. Szasz, Andrew, Ecopopulism: Toxic Waste and the Movement for Environmental Justice (Minneapolis, 1994), 5.Google Scholar

15. Later renamed the Center for Health, Environment and Justice and based in Falls Church, Virginia.

16. Gibbs, Lois Marie, “Celebrating Ten Years of Triumph,” Everyone's Backyard 11 (February 1993): 2.Google Scholar

17. , Szasr, Ecopopulism, 6, 6972.Google Scholar See also The Grassroots Movement for Environmental Justice,” Everyone's Backyard 11 (February 1993): 3Google Scholar.

18. Mazmanian, Daniel and Morell, David, Beyond Superfailure: America's Toxics Policy for the 1990s (Boulder, Colo., 1992), 181.Google Scholar See also Rabe, Barry G., Beyond NIMBY: Hazardous Waste Siting in Canada and the United States (Washington, D.C., 1994), 23Google Scholar ; Arrandale, Tom, “When the Poor Cry NIMBY,” Governing 6 (September 1993): 3641Google Scholar.

19. Gottlieb, Robert, “Beyond NEPA and Earth Day. Reconstructing the Past and Envisioning a Future for Environmentalism,” Environmental History Review 19 (Winter 1995): 10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

20. Hamilton, Cynthia, “Coping with Industrial Exploitation,” , Bullard, ed., Conjronting Environmental Racism, 63.Google Scholar

21. Bullard, Robert D., Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality, 2d ed. (Boulder, Colo., 1994; ), xiii.Google Scholar

22. Capek, Stella M., “The ‘Environmental Justice’ Frame: A Conceptual Discussion and an Application,” Social Problems 40 (February 1993): 8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

23. Bryant, Bunyan and Mohai, Paul, eds., Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse (Boulder, Colo., 1992), 12.Google Scholar

24. For example, civil rights law was used in 1993 as a basis for filing the first environ-mental justice complaints with EPA. It also was used in other litigation on the state level as early as 1979 in Houston, Texas. Courts have hesitated to overturn locally undesirable land uses on the basis of environmental justice concepts, however. See Kevin, Daniel, “‘Environmental Racism’ and Locally Undesirable Land Uses: A Critique of Environmental Justice Theories and Remedies,” Villanova Environmental Law Journal 8 (1997): 145Google Scholar ; Gay, Kathlyn, Pollution and the Potverless: The Environmental Justice Movement (New York, 1994), 106Google Scholar.

25. , Foreman, The Promise and Peril of Environmental Justice, 2.Google Scholar

26. The Sierra Club, National Wildlife Federation, Audubon Society, Environmental Defense Fund, Environmental Policy Institute/Friends of the Earth, Greenpeace, and so forth.

27. See Alston, Dana A., ed., we Speak for Ourselves: Social Justice, Race, and Environment (Washington, D.C., 1990), 3Google Scholar ; From the Front Lines of the Movement for Environmental Justice,” Social Policy 22 (Spring 1992): 12Google Scholar ; Bullard, Robert D., “Anatomy of Environmental Racism and the Environmental Justice Movement,” in , Bullard, ed., Confronting Environmental Racism, 2223Google Scholar ; Bryant, Pat, “Toxics and Racial Justice,” Social Policy 20 (Summer 1989): 51Google Scholar ; , Bryant and , Mohai, eds., Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards, 6Google Scholar.

28. Kreger, Janet, “Ecology and Black Student Opinion,” Journal of Environmental Education 4 (Spring 1973): 3034CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; , Anthony, “Why African Americans Should Be Environmentalists,” 4344Google Scholar ; Mohai, Paul, “Black Environmentalism,” Social Science Quarterly 71 (December 1990): 744.Google Scholar See also Buttel, Frederick H. and Flinn, William L., “Social Class and Mass Environmental Beliefs: A Reconsideration,” Environment and Behavior 10 (September 1978): 433–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; , Alston, ed., We Speak for Ourselves, 3Google Scholar ; Taylor, Dorceta, “Can the Environmental Movement Attract and Maintain the Support of Minorities?” in , Bryant and , Mohai, eds., Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards, 38Google Scholar ; idem, Blacks and the Environment: Toward an Explanation of the Concern and Action Gap Between Blacks and Whites,” Environment and Behavior 21 (March 1989): 175–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

29. Davis, Henry Vance, “The Environmental Voting Record of the Congressional Black Caucus,” in , Bryant and , Mohai, eds., Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards, 5563Google Scholar ; “Beyond White Environmentalism,” Environmental Action (January-February 1990): 19, 27Google Scholar.

30. See “Do Environmentalists Care About Poor People?U.S. News and World Report 96 (2 April 1984): 52Google Scholar ; “1997 National Environmental Scorecard,” Internet, http://scorecard.lcv.org/introduction.htm; “The Unofficial 106th Congress U.S. Congressional Black Caucus Member Directory,” Internet, www.famu.edu/cbc/cbcdir.html; “The 105th Congress, U.S. Congressional Black Caucus Member Directory,” Internet, www.freenet.tlh.fl.us/tacotlbm/cbcdir.html.

31. National Conference of Black Mayors-Environmental Justice, www.rtk.net/mayors/enviro.html, p. 2.

32. Mohai, Paul and Bryant, Bunyan, “Is There a ‘Race’ Effect on Concern for Environ-mental Quality?Public Opinion Quarterly 62 (Winter 1998): 475, 500-502.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

33. On the latter point, see Gelobter, Michel, “The Meaning of Urban Environmental Justice,” Fordham Urban Law Journal 21 (1994): 841Google Scholar ; Tarlock, A. Dan, “City Versus Country-side: Environmental Equity in Context,” Fordham Urban Law Journal 21 (1994): 467–68Google Scholar.

34. See Lee, Charles, “Toxic Waste and Race in the United States,” in , Bryant and , Mohai, eds., Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards, 10-16, 2227Google Scholar ; Mealy, Rosemari, “Charles Lee on Environmental Racism,” We Speak for Ourselves, 8Google Scholar ; Paul Mohai and Bunyan Bryant, “Environmental Racism: Reviewing the Evidence,” in ibid., 163-69; , Grossman, “Environmental Racism,” 1617Google Scholar ; , Grossman, “From Toxic Racism to Environmental Justice,” E: The Environmental Magazine 3 (May-June 1992): 3032Google Scholar ; Russell, Dick, “Environmental Racism,” Amicus Journal 11 (Spring 1989): 2225Google Scholar ; , Bryant, “Toxics and Racial Justice,” 4950Google Scholar.

35. According to Daniel Kevin, an environmental analyst at the Ernest Orlando Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, environmental justice advocates have “dominated that portion of law review literature addressing environmental justice issues.” See , Kevin, “‘Environmental Racism’ and Locally Undesirable Land Uses,” 122Google Scholar.

36. For arguments making race the core issue in siting toxic facilities, see Godsil, Rachel D., “Remedying Environmental Racism,” Michigan Law Review 90 (November 1991): 397–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; , Bullard, Confronting Environmental Racism, 1013, 18, 21.Google Scholar For a listing of empirical studies of environmental disparities by income and race in the United States, see Goldman, Benjamin A., Not Just Prosperity: Achieving Sustainabiliry with Environmental Justice (Washington, D.C., 1993), 56Google Scholar.

37. See Been, Vicki, “Market Forces, Not Racist Practices, May Affect the Siting of Locally Undesirable Land Uses,” in Petrikin, Jonathan S., ed., Environmental Justice (San Diego, 1995), 38.Google Scholar See also What's Fairness Got to Do with It?” Environmental Justice and the Siting of Locally Undesirable Land Uses,” Cornell Law Review 78 (September 1993): 1014–15, 1018-24Google Scholar ; , Been, “Locally Undesirable Land Uses in Minority Neighborhoods: Disproportionate Siting or Marketing Dynamics?Yale Law Journal (April 1994): 1386, 1406.Google Scholar See also Lazarus, Richard J., “Pursuing ‘Environmental Justice’: The Distributional Effects of Environmental Protection,” Northuestern University Law Review 87 (1993): 796Google Scholar ; Anderton, Douglas L. et al., “Environmental Equiry: The Demographics of Dumping,” Demography 31 (May 1994): 229CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; , Kevin, “‘Environmental Racism’ and Locally Undesirable Land Uses,” 133-38, 145–50Google Scholar.

38. Hurley, Andrew, “Fiasco at Wagner Electric: Environmental Justice and Urban Geography in St. Louis,” Environmental History 2 (October 1997): 474.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

39. Bullard, Robert D., “Environmental Racism and ‘Invisible’ Communities,” West Virginia Law Review 96 (1994): 1037.Google Scholar

40. , Bullard, Unequal Protection, xvi.Google Scholar

41. See Warner, David and Worsham, James, “The EPA's New Reach,” Nation's Business (October 1998): 1319.Google Scholar

42. , Bullard, “Conclusion: Environmentalism with Justice,” in , Bullard, ed., Confronting Environmental Racism, 195.Google Scholar

43. The executive order also intended “to promote nondiscrimination in Federal pro-grams substantially affecting human health and the environment, and to provide minority communities and low-income communities access to public information on, and an opportunity for public participation in, matters relating to human health or the environment” and created an Interagency Working Group on Environmental Justice. See Clinton, William, “Executive Order on Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations” (Washington, D.C., 11 February 1994)Google Scholar ; Not in My Backyard,” Human Rights 20 (Fall 1993): 2728Google Scholar ; , Bryant and , Mohai, eds., Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards, 5Google Scholar ; , Grossman “The People of Color Environmental Summit,” 287Google Scholar.

44. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Environmental Justice Initiatives, 1993 (Washington, D.C., February 1994).Google Scholar See also A Skeptic Scrutinizes Environmental Justice,” Brookings 8 (Winter 1998): 5Google Scholar.

45. See EPA's website on the Internet—www.epa.gov—for an extensive listing of federal environmental justice programs and initiatives.

46. , Kevin, “‘Environmental Racism’ and Locally Undesirable Land Uses,” 129.Google Scholar

47. Texas Environmental Almanac, Internet, www.tec.org/almanac/enjustice.html, p. 1.

48. According to Samuel P. Hays, conservation did not arise from a broad popular movement or focused narrowly on private corporations, but from a scientific movement centered in the federal government. See Conservation and the Gospel of Efficiency (New York, 1972; orig. pub. 1959)Google Scholar.

49. Ekirch, Arthur A. JrMan and Nature in America (New York, 1963), 81, 88Google Scholar ; McCarthy, G. Michael, Hour of Trial: The Conservation Conflict in Colorado and the West, 1891-1907 (Norman, Okla., 1977), 15Google Scholar ; Petulla, Joseph M., American Environmental History: The Exploitation and Conservation of Natural Resources (San Francisco, 1977), 217–18Google Scholar.

50. , Nash, ed., American Environmentalism, 36, 45Google Scholar ; , Petulla, American Environmental History, 228–30Google Scholar ; , Ekirch, Man and Nature in America, 83Google Scholar ; , Allin, The Politics of Wilderness Preservation, 2436.Google Scholar See also Nash, Roderick, Wilderness and the American Mind (New Haven, 1967)Google Scholar.

51. , Petulla, American Environmental History, 221–25Google Scholar ; , Ekirch, Man and Nature in America, 87Google Scholar ; , Nash, ed., American Environmentalism, 59Google Scholar ; , Allin, The Politics of Wilderness Preservation, 1923Google Scholar ; , McCarthy, Hour of Trial, 15Google Scholar.

52. See , Merchant, ed., Major Problems in American Environmental History, 338Google Scholar ; Gottlieb, Robert, Forcing the Spring: The Transformation of the American Environmental Movement (Washington, D.C., 1993), 1921Google Scholar ; , Petulla, American Environmental History, 217Google Scholar ; , Nash, ed., American Environmentalism, 1011Google Scholar ; , McCarthy, Hour of Trial, 34, 12Google Scholar.

53. Melosi, Martin V., “Battling Pollution in the Progressive Era,” Landscape 26 (1982): 35.Google ScholarPubMed See also , Melosi, ed, Pollution and Reform in American Cities, 1870-1930 (Austin, 1980)Google Scholar.

54. , Melosi, “Battling Pollution in the Progressive Era,” 3637Google Scholar ; idem, “Environmental Crisis in the City: The Relationship Between Industrialization and Urban Pollution,” in , Melosi, ed., Pollution and Reform in American Cities, 1822.Google Scholar See also , Gottlieb, Forcing the Spring, 4780Google Scholar ; Melosi, Martin V., “The Place of the City in Environmental History,” Environmental History Review 17 (Spring 1993): 123CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

55. In “Efficiency, Equity, Esthetics: Shifting Themes in American Conservation,” in Worster, Donald, ed., The Ends of the Earth: Perspectives on Modem Environmental History (New York, 1988), 233–34Google Scholar , Clayton Koppes argues persuasively that three ideas dominated the rising conservation movement: efficiency (management of natural resources); equity (distribution of the development of resources rather than control by the few); and esthetics (the preservation of nature free from development). Of the three, efficiency held the greatest sway in the Progressive Era. However, Koppes makes little provision for an urban equivalent of the conservation movement in his argument, and equity is defined in substantially different terms than in the more recent environmental justice context.

56. See Melosi, Martin V., Coping with Abundance: Energy and Environment in Industrial America (New York, 1985), 296–97.Google Scholar See also Caulfield, Henry P., “The Conservation and Environmental Movements: A Historical Analysis,” in Lester, James P., ed., Environmental Politics and Policy: Theories and Evidence (Durham, N.C., 1990), 14, 19, 25, 3940Google Scholar.

57. , Gottlieb, Forcing the Spring, 6.Google Scholar See also , Gottlieb, “Beyond NEPA and Earth Day: Reconstructing the Past and Envisioning a Future for Environmentalism,” Environmental History Review 19 (Winter 1995): 1011Google Scholar ; Dowie, Mark, Losing Ground: American Environmentalism at the Close of the Twentieth Century (Cambridge, Mass., 1997), 126Google Scholar.

58. Paehlke, Robert C., Environmentalism and the Future of Progressive Politics (New Haven, 1989), 21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

59. Melosi, Martin V., “Lyndon Johnson and Environmental Policy,” in Divine, Robert A., ed., The Johnson Years, Volume Two: Vietnam, the Environment, and Science (Lawrence, Kan., 1987), 113, 117.Google Scholar

60. Memo, Stewart L. Udall to the President, 17 October 1968, White House Central File, Ex NR, box 6, Lyndon B. Johnson Presidential Library.

61. , Melosi, “Lyndon Johnson and Environmental Policy,” 134, 137340.Google Scholar See also , Melosi, Coping with Abundance, 212, 272-73, 300-304Google Scholar.

62. , Melosi, “Lyndon Johnson and Environmental Policy,” 140.Google Scholar

63. For useful discussions of environmental equity and environmental justice from a philosophical perspective, see Wenz, Peter S., Environmental Justice (Albany, 1988)Google Scholar ; Singer, Brent A., “‘An Extension of Rawls’ Theory of Justice to Environmental Ethics,” Environmental Ethics 10 (Fall 1988): 217–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; Shrader-Frechette, K. S., Risk and Rationality: Philosophical Foundations for Populist Reforms (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1991)Google Scholar ; Margolis, Howard, Dealing with Risk: Why the Public and the Experts Disagree on Environmental Issues (Chicago, 1996), 116Google Scholar ; Hartley, Troy W., “Environmental Justice: An Environmental Civil Rights Value Acceptable to All World Views,” Environmental Ethics 17 (Fall 1995): 277CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

64. Schnaiberg, Allan, “Redistributive Goals versus Distributive Politics: Social Equity Limits in Environmental and Appropriate Technology Movements,” Sociological Inquiry 53 (Spring 1983): 214.CrossRefGoogle Scholar See also Hird, John A., “Environmental Policy and Equity: The Case of Superfund,” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 12 (1993): 323–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; Nijkamp, Peter, “Equity and Efficiency in Environmental Policy Analysis: Separability Versus Inseparability,” Schnaiberg, Allan et al., Distributional Conflicts in Environmental-Resource Policy (New York, 1986), 6173Google Scholar.

65. See Lineberry, Robert L., Equality and Urban Policy: The Distribution of Municipal Public Services (Beverly Hills, Calif., 1977).Google Scholar

66. Ircha, M. C., “Municipal Service Distribution: Equity Concerns,” in Cheremisinoff, Paul N. et al., eds., Civil Engineering Practice (Lancaster, 1988), 590–93.Google Scholar

67. Freeman, A. Myrick III “Distribution of Environmental Quality,” in Kneese, Allen V. and Bower, Blair T., eds., Environmental Quality Analysis: Theory and Method in the Social Sciences (Baltimore, 1972), 264.Google Scholar

68. Gianessi, Leonard P., Peskin, Henry M., and Wolff, Edward, “The Distributional Effects of Uniform Air Pollution Policy in the United States,” Quarterly Journal of Economics 93 (May 1979): 281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

69. Ibid., 281-96.

70. Gelobter, Michel, “Toward a Model of ‘Environmental Discrimination,’” in , Bryant and , Mohai, eds., Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards, 6473.Google Scholar For a contrary view, see , Mohai and , Bryant, “Environmental Racism: Reviewing the Evidence,” 164Google Scholar.

71. Nijkamp, Peter, “Equity and Efficiency in Environmental Policy Analysis: Separability Versus Inseparability,” in Schnaiberg, Allan, Watts, Nicholas, and Zimmerman, Klaus, eds., Distributional Conflicts in Environmental-Resource Policy (New York, 1986), 61.Google Scholar See also Merkhofer, Miley W., Decision Science and Social Risk Management (Boston, 1987), 181–82Google Scholar.

72. , Freeman, “Distribution of Environmental Quality,” 274.Google Scholar

73. See Hays, Samuel P., Beauty, Health, and Permanence: Environmental Politics in the United States, 1955-1985 (New York, 1987), 62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

74. , Rabe, Beyond NIMBY, 2.Google Scholar

75. Ibid., 2-3.

76. Price, Jerome, The Antinuclear Movement (Boston, 1990), 7-9, 1112, 15, 17, 19, 24, 37-38.Google Scholar See also , Hays, Beauty, Health, and Permanence, 174, 182Google Scholar ; , Gottlieb, Forcing the Spring, 177–84Google Scholar.

77. Like several of the grassroots organizations of the past, women have played a major role in the toxics campaigns-possibly a greater role than in any previous environmental pro-test activity. See Newton, David E., Environmental Justice: A Reference Handbook (Santa Barbara, Calif., 1996), 25Google Scholar ; Krauss, Celene, “Blue-Collar Women and Toxic-Waste Protests: The Process of Politicization,” in Hofrichter, Richard, ed., Toxic Struggles: The Theory and Practice of Environ-mental Justice (Philadelphia, 1993), 110–12Google Scholar ; Epstein, Barbara, “Ecofeminism and Grass-roots Environmentalism in the United States,” in , Hofrichter, ed. Toxic Struggles, 144–52Google Scholar ; Merchant, Carolyn, Radical Ecology: The Search for a Livable World (New York, 1992), 181ff.Google Scholar ; , DiChiro, “Nature as Community: The Convergence of Environmental and Social Justice,” 299301Google Scholar.

78. , Szasz, EcoPofrulism, 5-6, 1314, 69-72.Google Scholar

79. Ibid., 72.

80. See , Dowie, Losing Ground, 131–35.Google Scholar See also Pulido, Laura, Envimnmentalism and Economic Justice: Two Chicano Struggles in the Southuiest (Tucson, 1996), 39Google Scholar , on “subaltern environmental struggles.”

81. For classification of social and environmental justice protest groups, see Beyond the Green: Redefining and Diversifying the Environmental Movement (1992), 8, 13, 14Google Scholar.

82. , DiChiro, “Nature as Community: The Convergence of Environmental and Social Justice,” 303.Google Scholar

83. See Vig, Norman J. and Kraft, Michael E., eds., Environmental Policy in the 1990s: Reform or Reaction? (Washington, D.C., 1997), 67.Google Scholar

84. Foreman, Christopher, “Environmentalism or Ideology? Inner City Activists Talk Pollution, Push Social Agenda,” SE Journal 7 (Fall 1997): 15.Google Scholar See also Austin, Regina and Schill, Michael, “Black, Brown, Poor & Poisoned: Minority Grassroots Environmentalism and the Quest for Eco-Justice,” Journal of Law and Public Policy 1 (Summer 1991): 71Google Scholar.

85. On the issue of class and the environment, see Jacoby, Karl, “Class and Environmental History: Lessons From The War in the Adirondacks,’Environmental History 2 (July 1997): 324–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.