Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-01T09:00:04.138Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A New Hope for an Old Britain? Nostalgia and the British Labour Party’s Alternative Economic Strategy, 1970–1983

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 August 2015

Abstract

Image of the first page of this content. For PDF version, please use the ‘Save PDF’ preceeding this image.'
Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Donald Critchlow and Cambridge University Press 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

NOTES

1. Cronin, James, New Labour’s Pasts: The Labour Party and Its Discontents (Harlow, 2004), 118.Google Scholar

2. Pugh, Martin, Speak for Britain: A New History of the Labour Party (London, 2010), 345.Google Scholar

3. See Panitch, Leo and Leys, Colin, The End of Parliamentary Socialism: From New Left to New Labour (London, 1997), 16.Google Scholar

4. See Bell, Patrick, The Labour Party in Opposition, 1970–1974 (London, 2004).Google Scholar

5. Cronin, New Labour’s Pasts, 136.

6. Holland, Stuart, Strategy for Socialism: The Challenge of Labour’s Programme (Nottingham, 1975), 27.Google Scholar

7. Holland, Stuart, The Socialist Challenge (London, 1975), 9.Google Scholar

8. See Shaw, Eric, The Labour Party since 1945: Old Labour–New Labour (Oxford, 1996), 113.Google Scholar

9. For example, see Holland, Stuart, “Inflation and Price Control: Note on the French Programme Contracts,”CrossRefGoogle Scholar February 1973, RD. 605, Labour History Archive, Manchester (LHA).

10. The Labour Party, Report of the Annual Conference and Special Conference of the Labour Party 1980 (London, 1980), 126Google Scholar.

11. Wickham-Jones, Mark, Economic Strategy and the Labour Party: Politics and Policy-Making, 1970–1983 (Basingstoke, 1996), 74.Google Scholar

12. Hatfield, Michael, The House the Left Built: Inside Labour Policy-Making, 1970–1975 (London, 1978), 28.Google Scholar

13. Wickham-Jones, , Economic Strategy and the Labour Party, 7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

14. Haseler, Stephen, The Tragedy of Labour (Oxford, 1980), 8.Google Scholar

15. In particular, see Seyd, Patrick, The Rise and Fall of the Labour Left (Basingstoke, 1987)Google Scholar; Wickham-Jones, , Economic Strategy and the Labour Party.Google Scholar

16. Santesso, Aaron, A Careful Longing: The Poetics and Problems of Nostalgia (Newark, 2006), 16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17. Hirsch, Marianne and Spitzer, Leo, “‘We Would Never Have Come Without You’: Generations of Nostalgia,” in Contested Pasts: The Politics of Memory, ed. Hodgkin, Katharine and Radstone, Susannah (London, 2003), 84Google Scholar.

18. See Bonnett, Alastair, Left in the Past: Radicalism and the Politics of Nostalgia (London, 2010).Google Scholar

19. Robinson, Emily, History, Heritage, and Tradition in Contemporary British Politics: Past Politics and Present Histories (Manchester, 2012), 181.Google Scholar

20. See Strangleman, Tim, “The Nostalgia of Organisations and the Organisation of Nostalgia: Past and Present in the Contemporary Railway Industry,” Sociology 33, no. 4 (November 1999): 743.Google Scholar

21. See Jobson, Richard and Wickham-Jones, Mark, “Gripped by the Past: Nostalgia and the 2010 Labour Party Leadership Contest,” British Politics 5, no. 4 (December 2010): 525–48.Google Scholar

22. Boym, Svetlana, The Future of Nostalgia (New York, 2001), xviii.Google Scholar

23. Samuel, Raphael, Theatres of Memory. Volume 1: Past and Present in Contemporary Culture (London, 1994), 150.Google Scholar

24. See Griffiths, Clare, “Remembering Tolpuddle: Rural History and Commemoration in the Inter-War Labour Movement,” History Workshop Journal, no. 44 (Autumn 1997): 144–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jobson, Richard, “‘Waving the Banners of a Bygone Age’: Nostalgia and Labour’s Clause IV Controversy, 1959–60,” Contemporary British History 27, no. 2 (2013): 123–44Google Scholar; Lawrence, Jon, “Labour–The Myths It Has Lived By,” in Labour’s First Century, ed. Tanner, D., Thane, P., and Tiratsoo, N. (Cambridge, 2000), 341–66.Google Scholar

25. Holland, Stuart, Capital Versus the Regions (London, 1976), 178.Google Scholar

26. Holland, , Socialist Challenge, 147.Google Scholar

27. Holland, Stuart, “The New Economic Imperatives: The State Holding Company, Planning and Policy Coordination, Planning Strategy, Tactics and Techniques: A Summary of RD. 271, RD. 315 and RD. 442,” November 1972, RD. 473, 2, LHAGoogle Scholar.

28. The Labour Party Industrial Policy Sub-Committee, “The Contribution to the Green Paper,” 19 April 1972, RD. 336, 1, LHAGoogle Scholar.

29. The Labour Party, Labour’s Programme 1973 (London, 1973), 30Google Scholar.

30. The Labour Party, Labour’s Programme: Campaign Document 1974 (London, 1974), 1Google Scholar.

31. Labour Party, Labour’s Programme 1973, 32, 35Google Scholar.

32. The Labour Party, Let Us Work Together: Labour’s Way Out of the Crisis (London, 1974). http://www.labour-party.org.uk/manifestos/1974/Feb/1974-feb-labour-manifesto.shtmlGoogle Scholar.

33. Benn, Tony, Morrell, Frances, and Cripps, Francis, “A Ten-Year Industrial Strategy for Britain,” April 1975, RE. 126, 1, LHAGoogle Scholar.

34. Benn, Tony, diary entry for 31 July 1972, in Tony Benn, Office Without Power: Diaries 1968–1972, ed. Winstone, Ruth (London, 1988), 442.Google Scholar

35. Benn, Tony, diary entry for 11 May 1970, in Benn, Office Without Power, 277Google Scholar.

36. Benn, Tony, diary entry for 18 January 1972, in Benn, Office Without Power, 397Google Scholar.

37. Windsor, John, “Drizzle Fails to Dampen Youth,” The Guardian, 8 November 1971, 20Google Scholar.

38. Benn, Tony, Arguments for Socialism, ed. Mullin, Chris (London, 1981), 23.Google Scholar

39. Ibid., 33.

40. Ibid., 44.

41. Ibid., 146.

42. Benn, Tony, Arguments for Democracy, ed. Mullin, Chris (London, 1981), 49.Google Scholar

43. Fenton, James, “Is This Mr Benn’s Party?” New Statesman, 1 October 1976, 434.Google Scholar

44. Gott, Richard, “By the Left,” The Guardian, 14 December 1981, 17.Google Scholar

45. For example, see Benn’s speech on Saturday 15 May 1976 at Burford Church, Oxford, commemorating the execution of three Levellers in 1649, recorded in Benn, Tony, “The Levellers,” Tribune, 14 May 1976, 5, 8–9.Google Scholar

46. Pierce, S. H., “‘Benn for Leader’ campaign,” letter to Tribune, 17 August 1979, 11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

47. Williams, A. H., “Gaitskell Never Won an Election,” letter to Tribune, 30 July/6 August 1982, 10.Google Scholar

48. Brown, Colin, “What Every Revolutionary Should Know Now,” The Guardian, 5 May 1981, 4.Google Scholar

49. Hart, Judith, “The Folk Memory of Early Struggles,” Tribune, 29 July 1977, 5.Google Scholar

50. Hart, Judith, “Democracy in Conflict with Capitalism,” Tribune, 12 August 1977, 4.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

51. Editorial, “The Significance of Leadership,” Socialist Commentary, January 1973, 1.

52. Hoggart, Simon, “Callaghan the Dauphin Holds Himself Aloof,” The Guardian, 25 March 1976, 13.Google Scholar

53. McKie, David, “Labour’s Scent of Victory,” The Guardian, 25 September 1973, 16.Google Scholar

54. Coane, Peter, “In Reply to Roy Jenkins,” letter to Tribune, 2 August 1974, 10.Google Scholar

55. Roberts, Robby, “Labour Turncoats,” letter to Tribune, 17 January 1975, 10.Google Scholar

56. See Cronin, , New Labour’s Pasts, 185.Google Scholar

57. Foot, Michael , quoted in Labour Party, LPACR 1980, 12, 13.Google Scholar

58. Johnson, Paul, “Shirty Welcome in the Stalls,” The Guardian, 18 May 1983, 2.Google Scholar

59. Pallister, David, “Labour Leader Beached by the Tide of History,” The Guardian, 9 June 1983, 2.Google Scholar

60. The Labour Party, The New Hope for Britain: Labour’s Manifesto 1983 (London, 1983), 4Google Scholar.

61. Ibid., 5.

62. The Labour Party, Labour’s Draft Manifesto: Issued on the authority of the National Executive Committee (London, 1980)Google Scholar; The Labour Party, Labour’s Programme 1982 (London, 1982).

63. The Labour Party Campaign’s Committee, “A Note on Campaign Strategy by the Research Secretary,” February 1981, RD. 723, 4, LHA.

64. Labour Party, Labour’s Programme 1982, 15.

65. Ibid., 55, 62.

66. Labour Party, Labour’s Programme 1982, 48.

67. Labour Party, New Hope for Britain, 14.

68. Ibid., 15.

69. The Labour Party National Executive Committee, “The General Election Campaign: A Note on Priorities from the Research Secretary,” October 1982, RD. 2522, 5, LHA.

70. The Labour Party Home Policy Committee, “Programme of Work, 1982–83: A Note from the Research Secretary,” November 1982: RD. 2539, 1, LHA.

71. Butler, David and Kavanagh, Dennis, The British General Election of 1983 (London, 1984), 289.Google Scholar

72. Chapple, Frank, quoted in The Trades Union Congress, Report of the 115th Annual Trades Union Congress held in the Opera House, Blackpool, September 5th to 9th 1983 (London, 1983), 360.Google Scholar

73. Mitchell, Austin, “Labour Must Choose between Ideological Purity and Impotence,” Tribune, 24 June 1983, 2.Google Scholar

74. Hatfield, Michael, “Labour Party Chiefs Plan to Challenge Benn for Making Divisive Speeches,” The Times, 25 September 1972, 2.Google Scholar

75. Tony Benn, “Exchange of Letters with Dr Mansholt (President of the European Commission),” 28 March 1972, in Tony Benn, Speeches (Nottingham, 1974), 117.

76. Holland, Stuart, The Regional Problem (London, 1976), 91.Google Scholar

77. Hughes, D., quoted in Labour Party, Report of the Seventieth Annual Conference of the Labour Party, Brighton, 1971, October 4th to 8th (London, 1971), 119Google Scholar.

78. Richard Briginshaw, quoted in Labour Party, LPACR 1971, 319.

79. Anthony Judge, quoted in Labour Party, LPACR 1971, 336.

80. Bottini, R., quoted in Trades Union Congress, TUC Report 1970: Report of the Proceedings of the 102nd Annual Trades Union Congress held in the Dome, Brighton, September 7th to 11th 1970 (London, 1970), 683Google Scholar.

81. Grantham, R. A., quoted in Trades Union Congress, TUC Report 1971: Report of the Proceedings of the 103rd Annual Trades Union Congress held in the Opera House, Blackpool, September 6th to 10th 1971 (London, 1971), 476Google Scholar.

82. The Young European Left, ‘The Left, the Referendum and the Future of Europe’, Socialist Commentary, May 1975, 4Google Scholar.

83. Flavius, Francis, “A Vote for European Socialism: Roy Jenkins,” Tribune, 29 October 1971, 3.Google Scholar

84. Marks, Harold, “Birmingham Faces a ‘Candy Floss’ Future,” Tribune, 10 November 1972, 8.Google Scholar

85. Walsh, Michael, “Steel Jobs: Market Rules Forbid Rescue,” Tribune, 9 May 1975, 1.Google Scholar

86. Hatfield, Michael, “Pressure for Control of Imports Is Growing,” The Times, 13 October, 1976, 2.Google Scholar

87. See Department of Applied Economics, Economic Policy Review: February 1975, No. 1 (Cambridge, 1975), 3; and Economic Policy Review: March 1976, No. 2 (Cambridge, 1976), 14.

88. Jenkins, Clive, quoted in The Labour Party, Report of the Seventy-fourth Annual Conference of the Labour Party, Blackpool, 1975, September 29th to October 3rd (London, 1975), 192Google Scholar.

89. Barbara Switzer, quoted in Labour Party, LPACR 1980, 28–29.

90. Goydor, Mark, Socialism Tomorrow: Fresh Thinking for the Labour Party, Young Fabian Pamphlet 49 (London, 1979), 10.Google Scholar

91. Day, Alan, “Don’t Try to Be Too Protectionist,” The Observer, 3 October 1976, 11.Google Scholar

92. Editorial, “The Case Against Import Controls,” New Statesman, 17 February 1978, 205.

93. For example, see Benn, Arguments for Socialism, 99.

94. Benn, , Arguments for Socialism, 102.Google Scholar

95. Labour Party, Labour’s Draft Manifesto 1980, 31; Labour Party, Labour’s Programme 1982, 235.

96. Alan Sapper, quoted in The Trades Union Congress, Report of the 114th Annual Trades Union Congress held in the Conference Centre, Brighton, September 6th to 10th, 1982 (London, 1982), 426.

97. Labour Party, Labour’s Programme 1982, 231.

98. Labour Party, New Hope for Britain, 205.

99. Bodington, Stephen, Eaton, John, Barratt-Brown, Michael, and Coates, Ken, An Alternative Strategy for the Labour Movement (Nottingham, 1975), 7.Google Scholar

100. Ibid., 9, 12.

101. Holland, , Socialist Challenge, 12.Google Scholar

102. Holland, , Strategy for Socialism, 72.Google Scholar

103. Ibid., 75.

104. Report of the 5th National Conference on Workers’ Control and Industrial Democracy held at Transport House, Coventry on June 10th and 11th, 1967, ed. Tony Topham (Hull, 1967), 79.

105. Ibid., 78.

106. Coates, Ken, “Labour and Industrial Democracy,” Tribune, 8 September 1972, 7.Google Scholar

107. Bodington, Stephen, “Democratising the Mining Industry: The Miners New ‘Next Step,’” Workers’ Control Bulletin, 4 May 1974, 2.Google Scholar

108. Coates, Ken, “How They Wanted to Democratise the Mines,” Workers’ Control Bulletin, 4 May 1974, 8.Google Scholar

109. Between 1901 and 1991, services increased from 34 percent of UK employment to 70 percent. Lindsay, Craig, “A Century of Market Change: An Overview of Labour Market Conditions in the Previous Century,” Labour Market Trends 111 (March 2003): 137Google Scholar. By 1981, women constituted 38.9 percent of the workforce. Gallie, Duncan, “The Labour Force,” in Twentieth-Century British Social Trends, ed. Halsey, A. H. and Webb, J. (Basingstoke, 2000), 292.Google Scholar

110. Workers’ Control Bulletin, 1 June 1974.

111. Ken Coates is quoted speaking at the IWC Miners’ Conference in Nottingham by The Miner in April 1974, “Miners Demand Workers’ Control,” Workers’ Control Bulletin, 1 June 1974, 8.

112. Malcolm Saunders, quoted in The Labour Party, Report of the Seventy-first Annual Conference of the Labour Party, Blackpool, 1972, October 2nd to 6th (London, 1972), 125.

113. The Labour Party Home Policy Committee, “Economic Strategy Growth and Unemployment: A Statement by the National Executive Committee of the Labour Party,” 25 January 1972, RD.165, 21, LHA.

114. Benn, Tony, “Mr Heath’s Confrontation: The Political Consequences,” Workers’ Control Bulletin, 2 February 1974, 7.Google Scholar

115. Townsend, Brian, “The New Workers’ Co-ops Show Us the Way Forward,” Labour Weekly, 13 February 1976, 10.Google Scholar

116. Tony Benn, “Industrial Democracy,” speech given at the Industrial Society lunch, 21 November 1968, in Benn, Speeches, 11,

117. Ibid., 14.

118. Tony Benn, “Thinking About Workers’ Control,” speech given at the Annual Delegate Meeting of the Amalgamated Union of Engineering Workers, Foundry Section at the Winter Gardens, Morecambe, 22 May 1971. in Benn, Speeches, 11.

119. Coates, Ken and Topham, Tony, The New Unionism: The Case for Workers’ Control (Harmondsworth, 1974), 43.Google Scholar

120. C. Jenkins, quoted in Trades Union Congress, TUCAR 1971, 393.

121. Jenkins, Clive, “White and Blue-collar Workers Have More in Common than the Enemies of Trade Unionism Think,” Tribune, 29 April 1977, 6.Google Scholar

122. Wise, Audrey, “Women Want a Different Economy,” Workers’ Control Bulletin, 16 February 1973, 3.Google Scholar

123. Hudson, David, “Unbalanced Women Voters?,” Tribune, 20 April 1979, 14.Google Scholar

124. Hewitt, Patricia and Harman, Harriet, “Women and the Alternative Economic Strategy,” Tribune, 26 June 1981, 2.Google Scholar

125. Gilhespy, Diana, “Women and the Alternative Strategy,” Tribune, 19 March 1982, 5.Google Scholar

126. Hobsbawm, Eric, “The Forward March of Labour Halted?,” Marxism Today 22, no. 9 (September 1978): 282.Google Scholar

127. See Wickham-Jones, , Economic Strategy and the Labour Party, 142–43.Google Scholar

128. See Coates, Ken and Topham, Tony, The Shop Steward’s Guide to the Bullock Report (Nottingham, 1977).Google Scholar

129. Kinnock, Neil, ‘Bullock and the Left’, New Statesman, 11 February 1977, 175.Google Scholar

130. Joe Gormley, quoted in The Labour Party, Report of the Seventy-sixth Annual Conference of the Labour Party, Brighton, 1977, October 3rd to October 7th (London, 1977), 195.

131. Jon Mordecai, “Fight for the Socialist Alternative: Minority LPYS 1977 Conference Document” (1977–78), in The Labour Party, The Archives of the British Labour Party, Pamphlets and Leaflets: Part 6: 1970–1979, ed. Stephen Bird (Reading, 1999), 10–11.

132. The TUC–Labour Party Liaison Committee Sub-Committee on Industrial Democracy and Planning, “Industrial Democracy: An Introductory Note by the Joint Secretaries,” March 1981, RD. 761, 2, LHA.

133. Bob Wylie, quoted in Labour Party, LPACR 1977, 170.

134. Benn, Arguments for Socialism, 42.

135. Ibid., 60.

136. Benn, Arguments for Democracy, 215.

137. The Labour Party, “Draft Synopsis of ‘Plan for Recovery,’” February 1983, RD. 2646, LHA.

138. Labour Party, New Hope for Britain, 6.