Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-4rdpn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-04T21:20:43.882Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Financial health and the valuation of corporate pension plans

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 November 2019

Jun Cai ,
Miao Luo  and
Alan J. Marcus
Jun Cai
Affiliation:
Department of Economics and Finance, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong, P. R. China
Miao Luo
Affiliation:
Department of Finance and Investment, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou, P. R. China
Alan J. Marcus*
Affiliation:
Department of Finance, Carroll School of Management, Boston College, Chestnut Hill, MA02467, USA
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We return to the long-standing question ‘Who owns the assets in a defined benefit pension plan?’ Unlike earlier studies, we condition the market's assessment of implicit property rights on the sponsoring firm's financial health. Valuations of financially strong firms, and those that are strengthening, are more responsive to pension plan funding. For these firms, each extra dollar of net plan assets is valued at between $0.50 and $1.00. In contrast, for weak and weakening firms, valuation effects are statistically indistinguishable from zero. This result is consistent with the higher likelihood that they will renege on their pension obligations.

Keywords

Bankruptcy scoresdefined benefit pension plansfinancial distressproperty rightsstock market valuation effectsG23G32
Type
Article
Information
Journal of Pension Economics & Finance , Volume 19 , Issue 4 , October 2020 , pp. 459 - 490
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Addoum, J, van Binsbergen, J and Brandt, M (2010) Asset allocation and managerial assumptions in corporate pension plans. Working Paper, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ali, A and Zarowin, P (1992) The role of earnings levels in annual earnings-returns studies. Journal of Accounting Research 30, 286–296.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Altman, E (1968) Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy. Journal of Finance 23, 589–609.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Amir, E and Benartzi, S (1998) The expected rate of return on pension funds and asset allocation as predictors of portfolio performance. Accounting Review 73, 335–352.Google Scholar
Amir, E and Gordon, E (1996) Firms’ choice of estimation parameters: empirical evidence from SFAS 106. Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance 11, 427–448.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Amir, E, Guan, Y and Oswald, D (2010) The effect of pension accounting on corporate pension asset allocation. Review of Accounting Studies 15, 345–366.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Asthana, S (1999) Determinants of funding strategies and actuarial choices for defined-benefit pension plans. Contemporary Accounting Research 16, 39–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barnow, B and Ehrenberg, R (1979) The costs of defined benefit pension plans and firm adjustments. Quarterly Journal of Economics 93, 523–540.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barth, M (1991) Relative measurement errors among alternative pension asset and liability measures. Accounting Review 66, 433–463.Google Scholar
Barth, M, Beaver, W and Landsman, W (1992) The market valuation implications of net periodic pension cost components. Journal of Accounting and Economics 15, 27–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Begley, J, Ming, J and Watts, S (1996) Bankruptcy classification errors in the 1980's: an empirical analysis of Altman's and Ohlson's models. Review of Accounting Studies 1, 267–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bergstresser, D, Desai, M and Rauh, J (2006) Earnings manipulation, pension assumptions, and managerial investment decisions. Quarterly Journal of Economics 121, 157–195.Google Scholar
Blankley, A and Swanson, E (1995) A longitudinal study of SFAS No. 87 pension rate assumptions. Accounting Horizons 9, 1–21.Google Scholar
Bodie, Z, Light, J, Morck, R and Taggart, R (1987) Funding and asset allocation in corporate pension plans: An empirical investigation. In Bodie, Z, Shoven, J and Wise, D (eds), Issues in Pension Economics, National Bureau of Economic Research Project Report Series. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press, pp. 15–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bulow, J (1982) What are corporate pension liabilities? Quarterly Journal of Economics 97, 435–422.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bulow, J and Scholes, M (1983) Who owns the assets in a defined benefit pension plan? In Bodie, Z and Shoven, J (eds), Financial Aspects of the United States Pension System, National Bureau of Economic Research Project Report Series. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press, pp. 17–36.Google Scholar
Bulow, J, Scholes, M and Menell, P (1983) Economic implications of ERISA. In Bodie, Z and Shoven, J (eds), Financial Aspects of the United States Pension System, National Bureau of Economic Research Project Report Series. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press, pp. 37–56.Google Scholar
Bulow, J, Morck, R and Summers, L (1987) How does the market value unfunded pension liabilities? In Bodie, Z, Shoven, J and Wise, D (eds), Issues in Pension Economics, National Bureau of Economic Research Project Report Series. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press, pp. 81–104.Google Scholar
Campbell, J, Hilscher, J and Szilagyi, J (2008) In search of distress. Journal of Finance 63, 899–2,939.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Campbell, J, Dhaliwal, D and Schwartz, W Jr (2012) Financing constraints and the cost of capital: evidence from the funding of corporate pension plans, Review of Financial Studies 25, 868–912.10.1093/rfs/hhr119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chava, S and Jarrow, R (2004) Bankruptcy prediction with industry effects. Review of Finance 8, 537–569.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chuk, E (2013) Economic consequences of mandated accounting disclosures: evidence from pension accounting standards. Accounting Review 88, 395–427.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coronado, J and Sharpe, S (2003) Did pension plan accounting contribute to a stock market bubble? Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1, 323–371.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coronado, J, Mitchell, O, Sharpe, S and Nesbitt, S (2008) Footnotes aren't enough: the impact of pension accounting on stock values. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance 7, 257–276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Daley, L (1984) The valuation of reported pension measures for firms sponsoring defined benefit plans. The Accounting Review 59, 177–198.Google Scholar
Dambolena, I and Khoury, S (1980) Ratio stability and corporate failure. Journal of Finance 35, 1017–1026.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davis-Friday, P, Folami, L, Liu, C and Mittelstaedt, H (1999) The value relevance of financial statement recognition vs. Disclosure: evidence from SFAS No. 106. Accounting Review 74, 403–423.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dhaliwal, D (1986) Measurement of financial leverage in the presence of unfunded pension obligations. Accounting Review 61, 651–661.Google Scholar
Fama, E and French, K (1992) The cross section of expected stock returns. Journal of Finance 47, 427–465.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fama, E and French, K (1993) Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds. Journal of Financial Economics 33, 3–56.10.1016/0304-405X(93)90023-5CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fama, E and MacBeth, J (1973) Risk, return, and equilibrium: empirical tests. Journal of Political Economy 81, 607–636.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Faulkender, M and Wang, R (2006) Corporate financial policy and the value of cash. Journal of Finance 61, 1957–1990.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Financial Accounting Standard Board (FASB) (1985) Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 87, Employers’ Accounting for Pensions, Norwalk, Connecticut.Google Scholar
Financial Accounting Standard Board (FASB) (1998) Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 132, Employers’ Disclosures about Pensions and Other Postretirement Benefits, An Amendment of FASB Statements No. 87, 88, and 106, Norwalk, Connecticut.Google Scholar
Financial Accounting Standard Board (FASB) (2006) Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 158, Employers’ Accounting for Defined Benefit Pension and Other Postretirement Plans, An Amendment of FASB Statements No. 87,88, 106 and 132I, Norwalk, Connecticut.Google Scholar
Feldstein, M and Morck, R (1983) Pension funding decisions, interest rate assumptions, and share prices. In Bodie, Z and Shoven, J (eds), Financial Aspects of the United States Pension System, National Bureau of Economic Research Project Report Series. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press, pp. 177–210.Google Scholar
Feldstein, M and Seligman, S (1981) Pension funding, share prices, and national savings. Journal of Finance 36, 801–824.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Francis, J and Reiter, S (1987) Determinants of corporate pension funding strategy. Journal of Accounting and Economics 9, 35–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Franzoni, F (2009) Underinvestment vs. overinvestment: evidence from price reactions to pension contributions. Journal of Financial Economics 92, 491–518.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Franzoni, F and Marín, J (2006) Pension plan funding and stock market efficiency. Journal of Finance 61, 921–952.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ghicas, D (1990) Determinants of actuarial cost method changes for pension accounting and funding. Accounting Review 65, 384–405.Google Scholar
Glaum, M (2009) Pension accounting and research: a review. Accounting and Business Research 39, 273–311.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Godwin, J, Goldberg, S and Duchac, J (1996) An empirical analysis of factors associated with changes in pension plan interest rate assumptions. Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance 11, 305–322.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gopalakrishnan, V and Sugrue, T (1995) The determinants of actuarial assumptions under pension accounting disclosures. Journal of Financial and Strategic Decisions 8, 35–41.Google Scholar
Griffin, J and Lemmon, M (2002) Book-to-market equity, distress risk, and stock returns. Journal of Finance 57, 2317–2336.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grinblatt, M and Moskowitz, T (2004) Predicting stock price movements from past returns: the role of consistency and tax-loss selling. Journal of Financial Economics 71, 541–579.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hann, R, Heflin, F and Subramanyam, K (2007) Fair-value pension accounting. Journal of Accounting and Economics 44, 328–358.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harris, M and Raviv, A (1992) The theory of capital structure. Journal of Finance 46, 297–354.10.1111/j.1540-6261.1991.tb03753.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hillegeist, S, Keating, E, Cram, D and Lundstedt, K (2004) Assessing the probability of bankruptcy. Review of Accounting Studies 9, 5–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ippolito, R (2001) Reversion taxes, contingent benefits, and the decline in pension funding. Journal of Law and Economics 44, 199–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jin, L, Merton, R and Bodie, Z (2006) Do a firm's equity returns reflect the risk of its pension plan? Journal of Financial Economics 81, 1–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Landsman, W (1986) An empirical investigation of pension fund property rights. Accounting Review 61, 662–691.Google Scholar
Liébana, P and Vincent, L (2004) Financial reporting for defined benefit pension plans. Working Paper, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, 60208.Google Scholar
Liew, J and Vassalou, M (2000) Can book-to-market, size, and momentum be risk factors that predict economic growth. Journal of Financial Economics 57, 221–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (2006) Pension Reform will Increase Funding Requirements for Under-funded U.S. Pension Plans, Global Credit Research, Moody, New York. NY.Google Scholar
Morris, M, Nichols, W and Niehaus, G (1983) Considerations driving interest rate assumption changes. Financial Analysts Journal 39, November, 13–15.Google Scholar
Nance, D, Smith, C and Smithson, C (1993) On the determinants of corporate hedging. Journal of Finance 48, 267–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ofek, E (1993) Capital structure and firm response to poor performance: an empirical analysis. Journal of Financial Economics 34, 3–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ohlson, J (1980) Financial ratios and the probabilistic prediction of bankruptcy. Journal of Accounting Research 18, 109–131.10.2307/2490395CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ohlson, J (1995) Earnings, book values, and dividends in equity valuation. Contemporary Accounting Research 11, 661–687.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oldfield, G (1977) Financial aspects of the private pension system. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 9, 48–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Petersen, M (1992) Pension reversions and work-stockholder wealth transfers. Quarterly Journal of Economics 107, 1033–1056.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Petersen, M (1996) Allocating assets and discounting cash flows: Pension plan finance. In Fernandez, P, Turner, J and Hinz, R (eds), Pensions, Savings, and Capital Markets. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor, 1–26.Google Scholar
Petersen, M (2009) Estimating standard errors in finance panel data sets: comparing approaches. Review of Financial Studies 22, 435–480.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Picconi, M (2006) The perils of pensions: does pension accounting lead investors and analysts astray? Accounting Review 81, 925–955.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pontiff, J, Shleifer, A and Weisbach, M (1990) Reversions of excess assets after takeover. Rand Journal of Economics 21, 600–613.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rauh, J (2006) Investment and financing constraints: evidence from the funding of corporate pension plans. Journal of Finance 61, 33–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rauh, J (2009) Risk shifting versus risk management: investment policy in corporate pension plans. Review of Financial Studies 22, 2687–2734.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scholes, M and Wolfson, M (1992) Pension and retirement program planning. In Scholes, M and Wolfson, M (eds), Taxes and Business Strategy: A Planning Approach. Englewood Cliff, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, pp. 197–219.Google Scholar
Sharpe, W (1976) Corporate pension funding policy. Journal of Financial Economics 3, 183–193.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shivdasani, A and Stefanescu, I (2010) How do pensions affect corporate capital structure decisions? Review of Financial Studies 23, 1287–1323.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shumway, T (2001) Forecasting bankruptcy more accurately: a simple hazard model. Journal of Business 74, 101–124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tepper, I (1981) Taxation and corporate pension funding policy. Journal of Financial Economics 6, 3–51.Google Scholar
Thomas, J (1988) Corporate taxes and defined benefit pension plans. Journal of Accounting and Economics 10, 199–237.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thomas, J and Tung, S (1992) Cost manipulation incentives under cost reimbursement: pension costs for defense contracts. Accounting Review 67, 691–711.Google Scholar
Thompson, S (2011) Simple formulas for standard errors that cluster by both firm and time. Journal of Financial Economics 99, 1–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Treynor, J (1977) The principles of corporate pension finance. Journal of Finance 32, 627–638.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilcoxon, F (1945) Individual comparisons by ranking methods. Biometrics Bulletin 1, 80–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yu, K (2013) Does recognition versus disclosure affect value relevance? Evidence from pension accounting. Accounting Review 88, 1095–1127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar