‘The Earth is an ellipsoid’, says the Admiralty Navigation Manual firmly, although in a later volume the expression is softened to ‘approximately ellipsoidal’, For in fact, as was implied by Captain Topley, the exact shape of the Earth is not yet known. Nevertheless, for nautical purposes it appears sound teaching practice to consider it a perfect sphere and then explain the departures of the nautical mile or minute of arc from its mean value. Nor need one quarrel with the Manual's statement that ‘to regard certain small triangles as plane is not to disregard the initial decision to regard the Earth as a sphere’. But the writer next indulges in an historical aside which cannot be allowed to pass. ‘This assumption (he says) gives rise to the expression plane sailing, which is popularly referred to as if plane were spelt plain and the sailing were free from difficulty’. But this is to put the cart before the horse. ‘Plain sailing’ was the original term, and it was only sophisticated into ‘plane sailing’ during the eighteenth century by teachers of navigation among whom John Robertson was the chief. Robertson was master at the Mathematical School of Christ's Hospital towards the middle of the century, and afterwards taught at the Portsmouth Naval College, finally becoming Librarian to the Royal Society. His Elements of Navigation was considered authoritative and ran into many editions, a later master at the Hospital, James Wilson, prefixing to it a Dissertation on the history of navigation which was also accepted as definitive. It is in this volume that we read: ‘Plane sailing is the art of navigating a ship upon principles deduced from the notion of the Earth's being an extended Plane. On this supposition the meridians are esteemed as parallel right lines…’, and the author goes on to what he terms the Plane Chart, with its equally-spaced meridians. There is little doubt that his passage is the source of the theory taught to modern sailors that ‘Plain Chart’ is a corruption of ‘Plane Chart’, while the latter was drawn by people who believed the Earth was flat. Actually we have only to go back a generation from Robertson to find an almost identical description of the chart—actually an equal-spaced conventional cylindrical projection of the sphere—but with the addition of the words ‘The rectangle formed by these meridians and parallels they (i.e. mariners) call the Plain Chart’. This was said in 1714 by John Wilson, a teacher in Edinburgh.