Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T15:16:55.609Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Soviet Policy in Sub-Saharan Africa: the Final Phase

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 November 2008

Extract

The transformation of Soviet foreign policy during the Gorbachev era was truly seismic in nature. Re-evaluations were effected in all areas of policy, resulting, most visibly, in the fundamental reordering of relations with the United States and fellow N.A.T.O. countries, and the demise of the Warsaw Pact and communist régimes in Eastern Europe. Equally sweeping were alterations in approach to the Third World and, more specifically, sub-saharan Africa, where changes in policy Soviet retreat.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Albright, David E., ‘Moscow's African Policy of the 1970s’, in Albright, (ed.), Africa and International Communism (London, 1980);Google ScholarPorter, Bruce D., The USSR in Third World Conflict: Soviet arms and diplomacy in local wars, 1945–1980 (Cambridge, 1984),CrossRefGoogle Scholar ch. 3; and Breslauer, G. W., ‘Ideology and Learning in Soviet Third World Policy’, in World Politics (Princeton), 39, 3, 04 1987, pp. 435–8.Google Scholar

2 Halliday, Fred, The Making of the Second Cold War (London, 1983), ch. 4.Google Scholar

3 Martin, Ben L., ‘American Policy Towards Southern Africa in the 1980s’, in The Journal of Modern African Studies (Cambridge), 27, 1, 03 1989, pp. 2346 passim.Google Scholar

4 See Bender, Gerald J., ‘American Policy Toward Angola: a history of linkage’, in Bender, et al. (eds.), African Crisis Areas and U.S. Foreign Policy (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1985), for American-Angolan interactions.Google Scholar

5 Pravda (Moscow), 23 February and 20 July 1984Google Scholar; also Izvestiya (Moscow), 28 August 1984.Google Scholar

6 See statements of Soviet representatives to the Security Council, in Yearbook of the United Nations, 1981 (New York, 1984), pp. 1135–43, and to the United Nations Council for Namibia, in U.N. Document A/AC. 131/PV. 408, 14 February 1984, pp. 1214.Google Scholar See also, Urnov, A., ‘Al'yans Vashington-Pretoriya i Afrike’, in Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya (Moscow), 3, 1982.Google Scholar

7 Africa Contemporary Record, 1982–83, Vol. 15 (New York and London, 1983), pp. A26 and 28.Google Scholar

8 Campbell, Kurt M., ‘Soviet Policy in Southern Africa: Angola and Mozambique’, in Campbell, and MacFarlane, S. Neil (eds.), Gorbachev's Third World Dilemmas (London and New York, 1989), pp. 217–21.Google Scholar

9 U.S. Department of Defence, Soviet Military Power, 1988 (Washington, D.C., 1988), p. 138.Google Scholar

10 Valenta, Jiri, ‘Moscow's “New Thinking” and Third World Regional Conflicts: some conclusions’, in Valenta, and Cibulka, Frank (eds.), Gorbachev's New Thinking and Third World Conflicts (New Brunswick and London, 1990), pp. 291–3.Google Scholar

11 See McFaul, Michael, ‘The Demise of the World Revolutionary Process: Soviet-Angolan relations under Gorbachev’ in Journal of Southern African Studies (Oxford), 16, 1, 1990, pp. 166–9,Google Scholar and Kramer, Mark N., ‘The Role of the CPSU International Department in Soviet Foreign Relations and National Security Policy’ in Soviet Studies (Cambridge), 42, 3, 1990, passim.Google Scholar

12 For example, Anatoli Adamishin, appointed Deputy Foreign Minister with chief responsibility for Africa in May 1986, had been previously head of the Foreign Ministry's First European Department.Google Scholar

13 Soviet Television, 25 February 1986, in British Broadcasting Corporation, Summary of World Broadcasts: Soviet Union (London), 27 02 1986, hereafter BBC/SU.Google Scholar

14 Soviet News (London), 14 05 1986, p. 230.Google Scholar

15 Tass (Moscow), 10 June 1986, in BBC/SU, 11 June 1986, and Soviet News, 2 December 1987, p. 436.Google Scholar

16 Freeman, Chas W., ‘The Angola/Namibia Accords’, in Foreign Affairs (New York), 68, 3, 1989, p. 135.Google ScholarSee also, press reports in The Guardian (London), 30 April and 26 June 1988Google Scholar; Izvestiya, 3 August and 12 November 1988Google Scholar; The Economist (London), 2 July 1988, p. 61Google Scholar; and The Star (Johannesburg), 29 June 1988.Google Scholar

17 The Guardian, 10 December 1987Google Scholar; The Star, 22 December 1987Google Scholar; and Pravda, 2 June 1988.Google Scholar

18 These agreements are reprinted in Valenta and Cibulka (eds.), op. cit. pp. 336–42.

19 Lunn, Jon, ‘Angola and Namibia: the regional settlement in south-western Africa’, House of Commons Library Background Paper (London), 234, 1989, p. 27.Google Scholar

20 These two agreements were ‘The Mount Etjo Declaration’ of 9 April 1989 and ‘The Cahama Minute’ of 19 May 1988. See Ibid. pp. 28–9 and U.N. Chronicle (New York), 26, 3, 1989, pp. 9–10.

21 Resolution 640 was significant in that it contained provision for a possible increase in the size of the U.N. mission for monitoring the independence transition process in Namibia following the April 1989 debacle. This marked a reversal of the insistence by the permanent members of the Security Council (including the Soviet Union) that economies should be made in the cost of U.N. efforts in the territory–demands which had led the Security Council into disagreement with both Swapo and most of the non-aligned states at the United Nations, who had argued that inadequate funding would delay the positioning of monitors and limit the effectiveness of their mission in Namibia. See The Independent (London), 24 and 25 January 1989, and The Guardian, 18 January and 7 February 1989.

22 SAPA, 30 January 1990, in British Broadcasting Corporation, Summary of World Broadcasts: Middle East and Africa (London), 1 02 1990, hereafter BBC/MEA.Google Scholar

23 Aunapu, Igor, ‘Namibia: elections under international control’, in International Affairs (Moscow), 8, 1990, pp. 53 and 55;Google Scholar also Soviet Foreign Minister, Shevardnadze, Eduard, cited in Vestnik ministerstvo innostrannykh del SSSR (Moscow), 23, 57, 1989, p. 37, hereafter VMID.Google Scholar

24 Author's interview with Angolan diplomat, 15 November 1990.Google Scholar

25 Asoyan, Boris, Soviet Ambassador to Lesotho, cited in The Star, 13 April 1988, and Anatoly Adamishin, interviewed on Moscow Home Service, 20 August 1988, BBC/SU, 31 August 1988.Google Scholar

26 Adamishin, , cited in The Washington Post, 12 08 1988, and Vasev, , cited in Financial Times (London), 20 05 1988. The sensitivity of this issue was evidenced by the fact that Tass carried a ‘clarification’ of Adamishin's remarks the day after they were made, stating that Moscow did not have the right ‘to give advice to [Luanda] regarding what policy it should pursue inside the country’. Cited in The Los Angeles Times, 13 August 1988.Google Scholar

27 Gunn, Gillian, ‘A Guide to the Intricacies of the Angola-Namibia Negotiations’, in CSIS Africa Notes (Washington, D.C.), 90, 1988, pp. 10 and 13, and The Guardian, 30 May 1988.Google Scholar

28 Free Angola Information Service, The Gbadolite Declaration, Zaïre, June 22, 1989 (Washington, D.C., 1989), p. 5.Google Scholar

29 During 1989 and 1990, Soviet arms deliveries have been valued at $800 million and $500 million, respectively, compared with $1,200 million in 1988. See The Washington Post, 18 June and 8 October 1990.Google Scholar

30 VMID, 18, 52, 1989, pp. 31–2.Google Scholar

31 The U.S. involvement explains why Moscow was prepared at this point to defend an ally as distant as Angola, yet passively observe the downfall of communist régimes in Eastern Europe. In the latter case, American intervention was absent and incoming non-communist leaders were willing to negotitate arrangements with Moscow which took account of Soviet interests in the region. See Katz, Mark N., ‘Why Does the Cold War Continue in the Third World?’, in Journal of Peace Research (London), 27, 2, 1990, pp. 353–7.Google Scholar

32 Yukalov, Yuri, head of Second African Department, Soviet Ministry of Foreign Affairs, cited on Radiodi Fusao Portuguesa, 23 May 1990, in BBC/SU, 25 May 1990.Google Scholar

33 This corresponded to a similar strategy pursued during the quadripartite negotiations of 1988, when Moscow continued to arm the M.P.L.A. régime in order to bolster its negotiating position vis-à-vis Pretoria, and to guard against a resumption of hostilities by both South Africa and Unita.

34 ‘Angola: U.S. unsure about Soviet role in Angola’, in Inter Press Service (Washington, D.C.), 9 01 1990;Google ScholarYanelis, Vladislav, ‘Angol'skoi uzel sal'do Afrikanskoi stat'i nashego byudzheta’, in Lituraturnaya gazeta (Moscow), 23 06 1990, p. 15;Google ScholarIzvestiya, 19 07 1990Google Scholar; and The Washington Times, 3 08 1990.Google Scholar

35 Weitz, Richard, ‘Moscow and its African Allies’, in Radio Liberty Report on the USSR (Washington, D.C.), 3, 6, 1991, p. 9.Google Scholar

36 VMID, 4, 62, 1990, p. 7.Google Scholar

37 Ibid. 7, 65, 1990, p. 20, and Izvestiya, 27 03 1990.Google Scholar

38 The Guardian, 20 03 1990Google Scholar; The Washington Post, 16 April 1990Google Scholar; and The New York Times, 17 September 1990.Google Scholar

39 Southscan (London), 15 June 1990Google Scholar, and The New York Times, 17 September 1990.Google Scholar

40 ‘The Washington Principles’ are laid out in Luanda Domestic Service, 23 January 1991, in Foreign Broadcast Information Service: Africa, 24 January 1991, p. 17, hereafter FBIS/A.Google Scholar

41 Angop News Bulletin (London), 156, 30 January 1991, p. 3, and 158, 15 March 1991, pp. 1213.Google Scholar

42 Somerville, Keith, ‘Angola: a tough solution’, in New African (London), 285, 06 1991, p. 18.Google Scholar

43 Statement of U.S.S.R. Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Tass, 4 May 1991, BBC/SU, 8 May 1991, and Soviet Government Statement, Tass, 31 May 1991, ibid. 3 June 1991.

44 These bodies are known by their Portuguese acronyms-C.C.P.M. and C.M.V.F. For details of their work, see Angop News Bulletin, 162, 7 June 1991, pp. 1–3 and 9; 163, 25 June 1991, pp. 3 and 6–7; 164, 19 July 1991, pp. 3–5 and 7; and 165, 6 August 1991, pp. 46.Google Scholar

45 Radio Nacional de Angola, 5 May 1991, BBC/SU, 8 May 1991.

46 Facts and Reports (Amsterdam), 21 (L), 14 June 1991, p. 17Google Scholar, and Angop News Bulletin, 163, 25 June 1991, p. 4.Google Scholar

47 United States Arms Control and Disarmament Agency, World Military Expenditures and Arms Transfers, 1986 (Washington, D.C., 1987), p. 143Google Scholar, and ibid.1989 (Washington, D.C., 1990), p. 115.

48 Campbell, , loc. cit. pp. 222–6.Google Scholar

49 Soviet Foreign Minister, Bessmertnykh, Alexandr, cited in Novosti Press Photos Information (London), 4 06 1991, p. 19.Google Scholar

50 Radio Mozambique, 20 December 1990, in BBC/SU, 21 December 1990.

51 The Independent, 3 June 1989 and 16 March 1990Google Scholar, and ‘Western Arms for Mozambique’, in Information (Lisbon), 23, 1991, p. 12.Google Scholar

52 Weitz, , loc. cit. p. 11Google Scholar, and Africa Research Bulletin. Political Series (Oxford), 26, 8, 1989, p. 9385.Google Scholar

53 Keesing's Record of World Events (Cambridge), 36, 4, 1990, p. 37, 368Google Scholar; The Christian Science Monitor (Boston), 15 June 1990Google Scholar; and Weitz, loc. cit. p. 11.

54 Tass, , 7 March 1990, BBC/SU, 10 March 1990.Google Scholar

55 VMID, 15, 49, 1989, p. 45, and 20, 54, 1989, p. 60.Google Scholar

56 The Independent, 6 June 1990.

57 ‘USA/The Horn: all federalists now’, in Africa Confidential (London), 31, 25, 1990.Google Scholar

58 VMID, 1, 83, 1990.Google Scholar

59 Kapuscinski, Ryszard, ‘Africa's New Order’, in The Independent on Sunday Review (London), 1 09 1991, p. 4.Google Scholar

60 On the place of ideology in Soviet foreign policy, see Light, Margot, The Soviet Theory of International Relations (Brighton, 1988).Google Scholar

61 Izvestiya, 27 March 1990.Google Scholar

62 Pravda, 31 January 1991.Google Scholar

63 Gorbachev, Mikhail, Perestroika: new thinking for our country and the world (London, 1987), p. 143.Google Scholar See also, Meissner, Boris, ‘“New Thinking” and Soviet Foreign Policy’, in Aussenpolitik (Hamburg), 40, 2, 1989, pp. 104–6.Google Scholar

64 Kozyrev, Andrei and Shumikhin, Andrei, ‘East and West in the Third World’, in International Affairs, 3, 1989, pp. 64–5.Google Scholar

65 Grey, Robert D., ‘The Soviet Presence in Africa: an analysis of goals’, in The Journal of Modern African Studies, 22, 3, 09 1984, pp. 511–27 passim.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

66 Breslauer, , loc. cit. pp. 435–6.Google Scholar

67 Pravda, 7 March 1986.Google Scholar

68 Soviet Television, 25 February 1986, in BBC/SU, 27 February 1986.

69 19th All-Union Conference of the CPSU. Documents and Materials (Moscow, 1988), pp. 30–7,Google Scholar and Documents and Materials. 28th Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Moscow, 1990), pp. 33–6.Google Scholar

70 Kiva, Alexei, ‘Socialist Orientation: reality and illusions’, in International Affairs, 7, 1988, pp. 7985.Google Scholar

71 Ibid. p. 86, and Lev Entin, ‘African Countries: national statehood in the making’, in ibid. 1, 1988, p. 46.

72 According to Kiva, Alexei, ‘Sotsialisticheskaya orientatsiya: teoreticheskii potentsial kontseptsii i prakticheskie realii’, in Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 11, 1988, p. 68, the persistence of internal insurgencies in Angola and Mozambique owed much to the inability of ruling régimes to secure ‘ethno-national consolidation’.Google Scholar

73 G. Mirskii, ‘K voprosy o vubore puti orientatsii razvivayushchikhsiya stran’, in ibid. 5, 1987, p. 79; R. Avakov, ‘Novoe myshlenie i problema izucheniya razvivayushchikhsya stran’, in ibid. 11, 1987, p. 55; Vasil'ev, A., ‘Osvobodivshiesya strany: realii i pardoksy razvitiya’, in Kommunist (Moscow), 6, 1988, p. 120;Google Scholar and Chirkin, V., ‘Underdevelopment and Democracy’, in Front File Southern Africa Brief (London), 3, 17, 1989, pp. 89.Google Scholar

74 Olimov, M. A., ‘Etalon ekapitalisticheskovo razvitiya’, in Narody Azii i Afriki (Moscow), 4, 1989.Google Scholar

75 Belikov, Igor, ‘Perestroika, the Soviet Union and the Third World’, in Review of African Political Economy (Sheffield), 50, 1991, p. 34.Google Scholar

76 Pravda, 29 October 1988Google Scholar, and VMID, 16, 1988, pp. 34.Google Scholar

77 Clapham, Christopher, ‘The Socialist Experience in Ethiopia and its Demise’, pp. 67, paper delivered to a conference entitled ‘The Retreat from Moscow. African and East European Experiences of Disengagement from Moscow’, University of Birmingham, 23–24 September 1991.Google Scholar

78 For details of the tour, see VMID, 8, 66, 1990, pp. 821.Google Scholar

79 Novosti Press Photos Information, 9 April 1991, pp. 2930.Google Scholar

80 Larson, Lawrence P., ‘Antisubmarine Warfare’, in Watson, Bruce W. and Watson, Susan M. (eds.), The Soviet Navy: strengths and liabilities (Boulder, 1986), pp. 136–7 and 140Google Scholar, and Fukuyama, Francis, ‘The Military Dimension of Soviet Policy in the Third World’, The Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, February 1984, p. 4.Google Scholar

81 Remnek, Richard B., ‘Soviet Military Interests in Africa’, in Orbis (Philadelphia), 27, 1, 1984, p. 136.Google Scholar

82 McGwire, Michael, ‘Naval Power and Soviet Global Strategy’, in International Security (Cambridge, MA), 3, 4, 1979, p. 177,Google Scholar and Hosmer, Stephen T. and Wolfe, Thomas W., Soviet Policy and Practice Toward Third World Conflicts (Lexington, MA, 1983), pp. 34–5.Google Scholar

83 Rumer, Eugene B., ‘The Third World in Soviet Professional Military Thinking’, in Campbell, and MacFarlane, (eds.), op. cit. p. 118.Google Scholar

84 Fukuyama, , op. cit. p. 16Google Scholar; Hritsik, Michael, ‘The West Africa Naval Patrol’, in Watson, and Watson, (eds.), op. cit. pp. 203–7;Google Scholar and Kenneth Vernoski, ‘Soviet Naval Air Operations’, in ibid. pp. 247–53.

85 Porter, , op. cit. pp. 161 and 204Google Scholar, and Carolla, Mark A., ‘The Indian Ocean Squadron’, in Watson, and Watson, (eds.), op. cit. p. 242.Google Scholar

86 See The Sunday Telegraph (London), 27 September 1981Google Scholar, and Meason, James E., ‘Angolan Naval and Air Defences’, in U.S. Naval Institute. Proceedings (Annapolis, MD), 114/3/1021, 1988, p. 70.Google Scholar

87 Collins, John M., U.S.-Soviet Military Balance, 1980–1985 (Washington, D.C., 1985), pp. 145–51.Google Scholar

88 Fukuyama, op. cit. p. 5.

89 Hurrell, Andrew, ‘NATO and the South Atlantic: a case-study in the complexities of out-of-area operations’, in Coker, Christopher (ed.), The United States, Western Europe and Military Intervention Overseas (London and Basingstoke, 1987), p. 63.Google Scholar

90 The Somalian episode is well known, and was probably not unforeseen by Moscow when it switched allegiance to Ethiopia during the 1977–8 Ogaden war. On Guinea, see Remnek, loc. cit. p. 143; on Guinea-Bissau, see West Africa (London), 26 October 1981, p. 2542;Google Scholar on Cape Verde, see ibid. 17 October 1978, p. 1406; on Angola, see Marcum, John, ‘Angola: perilous transition to independence’, in Carter, Gwendolen M. and O'Meara, Patrick (eds.), Southern Africa: the continuing crisis (London, 1979), pp. 193–4.Google Scholar

91 Duncan, W. J. R., ‘Soviet Nuclear Deterrence – Is Minimalism Dead?’, in RUSI Journal (London), Autumn 1991, pp. 32–7.Google Scholar

92 United States Department of Defence, Soviet Military Power, 1990 (Washington, D.C., 1990), p. 85.Google Scholar

93 Ibid. p. 91, and Brooks, Thomas A., ‘The Soviet Navy in 1990. A U.S. View–Still Cautious’, in U.S. Naval Institute. Proceedings, 117/5/1059, 1991, pp. 183–9.Google Scholar

94 Thomas A. Brooks, ‘The Soviet Navy in 1989. A U.S. View’, in ibid. 116/5/1047, 1990s, p. 235.

95 The Guardian, 18 July 1991Google Scholar, and Izvestiya, 1 August 1991.Google Scholar

96 Vego, Milan, ‘East Europe’, in U.S. Naval Institute. Proceedings, 117/4/1058, 1991, p. 112.Google Scholar

97 Brooks, , 1990, op. cit. p. 237, and 1991, op. cit. p. 185;Google Scholar and Stockholm International Peace Research Institute Yearbook, 1990 (Oxford, 1990), pp. 33–5.Google Scholar

98 Izvestiya, 1 March 1990. Of the 7,515 million roubles owed by countries in sub-Saharan Africa, almost half was accounted for by the three socialist-oriented régimes of Angola, Ethiopia, and Mozambique.Google Scholar

99 ‘Neobkhodim uchet vzaimnykh vozmozhnostei i interesov’, in Vneshnyaya torgovlya (Moscow), 9, 1990, pp. 11–13.Google Scholar

100 Izvestiya, 20 July 1991.Google Scholar

101 Angop News Bulletin, 151, 5 November 1990, p. 9Google Scholar. Also, interview with Krainov, N., head of the Soviet delegation to the Joint Soviet-Angolan Inter-Governmental Commission on Economic Scientific Co-operation and Trade, on Radio Moscow to Africa, 19 January 1990, in Foreign Broadcast Information Service: Soviet Union, 23 January 1990, p. 24, hereafter FBIS/SU.Google Scholar

102 Izvestiya, 1 March 1990Google Scholar. According to a more recent Western estimate, Angola owes the Soviet Union $3,500 million. See Financial Times, 8 May 1991.

103 West Africa, 16–22 October 1989, p. 1735.Google Scholar

104 Izvestiya, 1 March 1990.Google Scholar

105 Interview with Belusov, I., chairman of the State Committee for Military-Industrial Affairs, Arms Exports in the Glasnost Era (Novosti, London, January 1991), p. 4Google Scholar. Also, West Africa, 23–9 April 1990, p. 677.Google Scholar

106 Izvestiya, 30 March 1990.Google Scholar

107 ‘The Foreign Policy and Diplomatic Activity of the USSR, 1989–1990’, in International Affairs, 4, 1991, p. 78.Google Scholar

108 Southscan, 5 July 1991Google Scholar, and Burmistrov, , cited in Yearbook of International Communist Affairs, 1990 (Stanford, 1990), p. 8.Google Scholar

109 Moscow, Radio, 25 June 1990, BBC/SU, 6 July 1990Google Scholar; Africa Research Bulletin. Economic Series, 27, 6, 1990, p. 10,005.Google Scholar

110 Ibid. 28, 6, 1991, p. 10,431.

111 C.I.A. Directorate of Information, Handbook of Economic Statistics, 1990 (Washington, D.C., 1990), p. 181, and Soviet Weekly (London), 17 January 1991, p. 1.Google Scholar

112 West Africa, 26 February–4 March 1990, and Facts and Reports 20 (P-Q), 17 August 1990, p. 24.Google Scholar

113 Angop News Bulletin, 151, 5 November 1990, p. 10.Google Scholar

114 Krainov, , op. cit., and Vneshnie ekonomicheskie svyazi i SSSR v 1989g. Statisticheskie sbornik (Moscow, 1990), p. 293.Google Scholar

115 Thus, Nigeria's delayed payment of debt has been due, in part, to the Soviet Union's inability to offer new credits. See Financial Times, 28 June 1990.

116 Popov, Yuri, ‘Africa and Soviet Perestroika’, in International Affairs, 3, 1991, pp. 4750,Google Scholar and Konstantin Ovchinnikov, ‘Third World Markets: mirages and prospects’, in ibid. 5, 1991, pp. 57–8.

117 Information on Soviet trade is derived from Vneshnie…Statisticheskie sbornik, various years.Google Scholar

118 For details, see Seltsovsky, V., Soviet Foreign Trade in 1990 (Novosti, London, 1991), pp. 6 and passim.Google Scholar

119 Ovchinnikov, , loc. cit. p. 55Google Scholar; Gromyko, Anatoly, ‘Africa: continent at the threshold’, in International Affairs, 9, 1989;Google Scholar and Grigori Polyakov, ‘What Shall We Buy in Africa?’, in ibid. 10, 1989, passim.

120 Mozambique, for example, has approached Indonesia as a possible source of cheap oil.

121 For American motives, see The Independent and The Times, 28 September 1991.Google Scholar

122 The Economist, 5 October 1991, p. 47.Google Scholar

123 Financial Times, 7 October 1991.

124 The Guardian, 12 September 1991.

125 In train with the demise of the U.S.S., a Commonwealth of Independent States was created in December 1991 comprising the former Republics of the Soviet Union apart from the Baltic states and Georgia. Following an agreement between its members in Minsk, a coordinated defence structure is, at the time of writing, in the process of being established.

126 The Guardian, 29 October 1991.