Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-31T19:05:46.907Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘This democracy is killing us’: perceptions of rights and democracy in the South African Police Service

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 August 2020

Heidi Brooks
Heidi Brooks*
Affiliation:
University of Johannesburg, P.O. Box 542, Auckland Park 2006, Johannesburg, South Africa; Mapungubwe Institute for Strategic Reflection (MISTRA)
*
Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Police reform in South Africa has been a crucial component of democratic consolidation. Yet recent research presents a contrasting set of opinions, indicating low levels of public trust in the South African Police Service (SAPS), but continued belief in their right to enforce the law, and a strong sense of isolation amongst officers themselves. As police are constitutive of the officers who populate their ranks, attention should be given to how ‘democracy’ is perceived by those charged with its protection. Through a series of interviews, this article examines how SAPS officers understand and experience ‘democracy’. Situating officers in the broader society and communities in which they work, it shows that officers conceive of democracy predominantly through the lens of ‘rights’ and that their role in protecting rights is complicated by the transitional nature of South Africa's democracy. It also provides insight into a sense of disempowerment amongst officers, suggesting negative conceptions of the quality of democracy and of the balance of liberal constitutionalism with the democratic impetus of building safer communities.

Keywords

Democratic policingrightsdemocracypolicejustice
Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Modern African Studies , Volume 58 , Issue 2 , June 2020 , pp. 165 - 187
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2020

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

My thanks go to the South African Police Service and SAPS Division for Research for their support of the data gathering, and to the individual police officers who gave their time to be interviewed. I am grateful to the Centre for Social Change at the University of Johannesburg for ongoing support during the conduct and writing up of this research and to IIE MSA where some writing was undertaken. I also thank the two anonymous reviewers who provided valuable feedback on the article.

References

REFERENCES

Afrobarometer. 2015. ‘Summary of results: Afrobarometer round 6, survey in South Africa’, Plus 94 Research, <www.afrobarometer.org>, accessed 7.2.2018.,+accessed+7.2.2018.>Google Scholar
Afrobarometer. 2016. ‘In South Africa, citizens’ trust in president, political institutions drops sharply’, AD90: Dispatches, <www.afrobarometer.org>, accessed 7.2.2018.,+accessed+7.2.2018.>Google Scholar
Altbeker, A. 2005. The Dirty Work of Democracy: a year on the streets with the SAPS. Johannesburg: Jonathan Ball.Google Scholar
Bayley, D. 2001. Democratising the Police Abroad: what to do and how to do it. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice, US Department of Justice.Google Scholar
Bobbio, N. 1990. Liberalism and democracy. London and New York: Verso.Google Scholar
Bradford, B., Huq, A., Jackson, J. & Roberts, B.. 2014. ‘What price fairness when security is at stake? Police legitimacy in South Africa’, Regulation and Governance 8, 2: 246–68.Google Scholar
Brewer, J. 1994. Black and Blue: policing in South Africa. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Brooks, H., Ngwane, T. & Runciman, C.. 2020. ‘Decolonising and re-theorising the meaning of democracy: a South African perspective’, Sociological Review 68, 1: 17–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bruce, D. 2013. ‘New blood: Implications of en masse recruitment for the South African Police Service’, South African Crime Quarterly, 43: 17–28.Google Scholar
Bruce, D. & Neild, R.. 2005. ‘The police we want: a handbook for oversight of police in South Africa’, Johannesburg: CSVR and New York: Open Society Justice Initiative.Google Scholar
Bruce, D., Newham, G. & Masuku, T.. 2007. ‘In the service of the people's democracy: an assessment of the South African Police Service’. Johannesburg: CSVR.Google Scholar
Buur, L. 2008. ‘Democracy and its discontents: vigilantism, sovereignty and human rights in South Africa', Review of African Political Economy 35, 118: 571–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Comaroff, J. & Comaroff, J.L.. 2006. Law and Disorder in the Postcolony. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Comaroff, J. & Comaroff, J.L.. 2016. The Truth about Crime: sovereignty, knowledge, social order. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Corruption Watch. 2012. ‘SA sees SAPS as most corrupt within the state – survey’, 27.6.2012, <http://www.corruptionwatch.org.za>, accessed 7.2.2018.,+accessed+7.2.2018.>Google Scholar
Dubber, M.D. 2005. The Police Power: patriarchy and the foundations of American government. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Faull, A. 2013. ‘Fighting for respect: violence, masculinity and legitimacy in the SAPS’, South African Crime Quarterly, 44: 5–14.Google Scholar
Faull, A. 2016. ‘Measured governance? Police and performance management in South Africa’, Public Administration and Development, 36: 157–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Faull, A. 2017 a. Police Work and Identity: a South African ethnography. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Faull, A. 2017 b. ‘Police culture and personal identity in South Africa’, Policing 11, 3: 332–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gordon, D. 2006. Transformation and Trouble: crime, justice and participation in democratic South Africa. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hornberger, J. 2007. ‘Don't push this constitution down my throat: human rights in everyday practice. An ethnography of police transformation in Johannesburg, South Africa’, PhD Thesis, 2007.Google Scholar
Hornberger, J. 2010. ‘Human rights and policing: exigency or incongruence?’, Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 6: 259–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jensen, S. 2009. ‘The vision of the state: audiences, enhancements and policing in South Africa’, in Jefferson, A.M. & Jensen, S., eds. State Violence and Human Rights: state officials in the south. Abingdon: Routledge-Cavendish, 61–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kutnjak Ivkovic, S. & Sauerman, A.. 2015. ‘Treading the thin blue line: transition towards democratic policing and the integrity of the South African Police Service’, Policing and Society 25, 1: 25–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Loader, I. 2006. Policing, recognition and belonging’, ANNALS, American Association of Political Science 605: 202–21.Google Scholar
Manning, P.K. 2010. Democratic Policing in a Changing World. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Marenin, O. 2000. ‘Democracy, democratization, democratic policing’, in Das, D.K. & Marenin, O., eds. Challenges of Policing Democracies: a world perspective. Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach.Google Scholar
Marks, M. 2005. Transforming the Robocops: changing the police in South Africa. Scottsville: UKZN Press.Google Scholar
Mattes, R., Davids, Y.D. & Africa, C.. 2000. ‘Views of democracy in South Africa and the region: trends and comparisons’, Afrobarometer Paper No. 8, <www.afrobarometer.org>, accessed 8.7.2018.,+accessed+8.7.2018.>Google Scholar
Reiner, R. 2013. ‘Who governs? Democracy, plutocracy, science and prophecy in policing’, Criminology and Criminal Justice 13, 2: 161–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
SAPS. 2017. ‘Annual Report 2016/17, Vote no. 23’, 31.8.2017.Google Scholar
Shearing, C. & Marks, M.. 2011. ‘Criminology's Disney World: the ethnographer's ride of South African criminal justice', in Bosworth, M. & Hoyle, C., eds. What is Criminology? Oxford: Oxford University Press, 125–42.Google Scholar
Sklansky, D.A. 2005. ‘Police and democracy’, Michigan Law Review 103, 7: 1699–830.Google Scholar
Smith, N.R. 2015. ‘Rejecting rights: vigilantism and violence in post-apartheid South Africa’, African Affairs 114, 456: 341–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, N.R. 2019. Contradictions of Democracy: vigilantism and rights in post-apartheid South Africa. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stats SA. 2017. ‘Victims of crime survey 2016/17’, Statistics South Africa, <www.statssa.gov.za>, accessed 7.2.2018.,+accessed+7.2.2018.>Google Scholar
Steinberg, J. 2008. Thin Blue: the unwritten rules of South African policing. Johannesburg: Jonathan Ball.Google Scholar
Steinberg, J. 2012 a. ‘Establishing police authority and civilian compliance in post-apartheid Johannesburg: an argument from the work of Egon Bittner’, Policing and Society 22, 4: 481–95.Google Scholar
Steinberg, J. 2012 b. ‘Security and disappointment: policing, freedom and xenophobia in South Africa’, British Journal of Criminology 52: 345–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steyn, J. & Mkhize, S.. 2016. ‘Darker shades of blue: a comparison of three decades of South African Police Service culture’, South African Crime Quarterly 57: 15–26.Google Scholar
Super, G. 2014. ‘Twenty years of punishment (and democracy) in South Africa: the pitfalls of governing crime through the community’, South African Crime Quarterly 48: 7–15.Google Scholar
Super, G. 2016. ‘Volatile sovereignty: governing crime through the community in Khayelitsha’, Law and Society Review 50, 2: 450–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wood, D. 2016. ‘The importance of liberal values within policing: police and crime commissioners, police independence and the spectre of illiberal democracy’, Policing and Society 26, 2: 148–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zakaria, F. 1997. ‘The rise of illiberal democracy’, Foreign Affairs 76, 6: 22–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Newspapers and media

Business Day. 11.9.2018. ‘Bheki Cele: We are close to war zone’, <https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2018-09-11-dire-crime-statistics-are-nothing-to-write-home-about-bheki-cele-says/>, accessed: 27.9.2018.,+accessed:+27.9.2018.>Google Scholar
Business Tech. 3.9.2019. ‘South Africans are calling for the death penalty to be reinstated – here's what government says’, <https://businesstech.co.za/news/government/338473/south-africans-are-calling-for-the-death-penalty-to-be-reinstated-heres-what-government-says/>, accessed 11.12.2019., accessed 11.12.2019.' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Business+Tech.+3.9.2019.+‘South+Africans+are+calling+for+the+death+penalty+to+be+reinstated+–+here's+what+government+says’,+,+accessed+11.12.2019.>Google Scholar
Eye Witness News (EWN). 14.7.2017. ‘Deputy police minister questions why Hillbrow is 80% occupied by foreign nationals’, <www.youtube.com/watch?v=4k8JVTtohmI&feature=youtu.be>, accessed 27.9.2018.,+accessed+27.9.2018.>Google Scholar
South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC). 1.8.2018. ‘President Ramaphosa meets #TotalShutdown marchers at Union Buildings’, <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JoF3AhmNH50>, accessed 1.8.2018.,+accessed+1.8.2018.>Google Scholar
South Africa Press Association (SAPA). ‘Bring back death penalty – survey’, 22.2.2013, <www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2013-02-22-bring-back-death-penalty-survey>, accessed 9.10.2018.,+accessed+9.10.2018.>Google Scholar

Interviews

C4, Constable (black female), station two, 6.7.2018.Google Scholar
C8, Constable (black female), station three, 14.8.2018.Google Scholar
C13, Constable (black female), station four, 23.10.2018.Google Scholar
C14, Constable (black female), station four, 23.10.2018.Google Scholar
CAP1, Captain (black male), station two, 9.7.2018.Google Scholar
CAP5, Captain (white male), station four, 23.10.2018.Google Scholar
LC1, Lieutenant Colonel (black male), station one, 2.7.2018.Google Scholar
LC2, Lieutenant Colonel (Indian male), station two, 6.7.2018.Google Scholar
PO1, Visible Policing Officer (black male), station two, 6.7.2018.Google Scholar
S1, Sergeant (coloured male), station one, 3.7.2018.Google Scholar
S4, Sergeant (black female), station two, 27.8.2018.Google Scholar
S5, Sergeant (black female), station two, 27.8.2018.Google Scholar
S6, Sergeant (black female), station three, 17.8.2018.Google Scholar
WO2, Warrant Officer (white male), station two, 6.7.2018.Google Scholar
WO3, Warrant Officer (black male), station two, 26.7.2018.Google Scholar
WO4, Warrant Officer (black male), station three, 14.8.2018.Google Scholar
WO5, Warrant Officer (black male), station three, 14.8.2018.Google Scholar
WO14, Warrant Officer (black male), station four, 16.10.2018.Google Scholar
WO15, Warrant Officer (black male), station four, 23.10.2018.Google Scholar