Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T00:32:48.054Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Note on the Concept of Dementia Paralytica at the Time of Robert Schumann's Death in 1856

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 February 2018

A. Meyer
A. Meyer*
Affiliation:
University of London (From the Department of Neuropathology, Institute of Psychiatry, Maudsley Hospital)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In a recent paper Slater and Meyer (in press) have pointed out that the nature of Robert Schumann's final psychiatric illness has never been satisfactorily explained. Moebius (1906) diagnosed it as dementia praecox, while Gruhle (1906) favoured an organic disease of the brain, probably paretic dementia. Subsequent opinion has been evenly divided between these two diagnoses but recent writers have inclined more to a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Slater and Meyer, however, on critically re-examining the available evidence, have definitely come down on the side of Gruhle.

Type
Original Articles
Information
Journal of Mental Science , Volume 105 , Issue 438 , January 1959 , pp. 116 - 123
Copyright
Copyright © Royal College of Psychiatrists, 1959 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alzheimer, A., Histol. histopath. Arb., 1904, 1, 18.Google Scholar
Baillarger, J. G. F., Ann. méd,-psychol., 1847, 9, 331. Quoted from Zilboorg and Henry and von Krafft-Ebing.Google Scholar
Bayle, A. L. J., Recherches sur l'arachnitis chronique, 1822. Paris: Thesis. Quoted from Zilboorg and Henry.Google Scholar
Idem, Traité des maladies du cerveau et de ses membranes, 1826. Paris: Gabon.Google Scholar
Binswanger, O., Hirnsyphilis und Dementia, 1891. Hamburg. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Breuer, J., and Freud, S., Studien über Hysterie, 1895. Vienna: Deuticke.Google Scholar
Calmeil, L. F., De la paralysie chez les aliénés, 1826. Paris: Baillière.Google Scholar
Cox, J. M., Practical Observations on Insanity, 1804. London: Baldwin and Murray. Quoted from Zilboorg and Henry.Google Scholar
Delasiauve, –., Ann. méd.-psychol., 1851, 3, 611. Quoted from von Krafft-Ebing.Google Scholar
Delaye, J. B., Considérations sur une espèce de paralysie qui affecte particulièrement les aliénés, 1824. Paris: Thesis. Quoted from Zilboorg and Henry and Mönkemöller.Google Scholar
Duchek, –., Prager Vierteljahrsschrift, 1851, 29, 1. Quoted from Griesinger (1861), von Krafft-Ebing and Salomon.Google Scholar
Erlenmeyer, A. A., Die Gehirnatrophie der Erwachsenen. 3rd edition, 1857. Neuwied, Heuser. Quoted from Griesinger (1861) and Westphal.Google Scholar
Esmarch, F., and Jessen, W., Allg. Z. Psychiat., 1857, 14, 20.Google Scholar
Esquirol, J. E. D., Les passions considérées comme causes, symptomes et moyens curatifs de l'aliénation mentale, 1805. Paris. Quoted from Zilboorg and Henry.Google Scholar
Falret, J., Recherches sur la folie paralytique, 1853. Paris: Rignoux.Google Scholar
Fournier, A., Les affections parasyphilitiques, 1894. Paris: Rueff.Google Scholar
Foville, A., L'aliénation mentale (folie). In: Dictionnaire de médecine et chirurgie pratiques, 1829. Paris: Gabon.Google Scholar
Georget, E. J., Dictionnaire de médecine, 1823. Paris: Bechet, 8, 1.Google Scholar
Griesinger, W., Die Pathologie und Therapie der psychischen Krankheiten, 1845. Stuttgart: Krabbe.Google Scholar
Idem , ibid., 2nd edition, 1861.Google Scholar
Idem, Gesammelte Abhandlungen, 1872. Edited by Wunderlich, C. R. A., Berlin: Hirschwald, vol. 1, pp. 72–3,.Google Scholar
Gruhle, W., Zbl. Nervenheilk., 1906, 29, 805.Google Scholar
Haslam, J., Observations on Insanity, 1798. London: Rivington.Google Scholar
Hoffmann, L., Z. klin. Med., Breslau, 1850, 1, 35. Quoted from Griesinger (1861).Google Scholar
Hougberg, E., Allg. Z. Psychiat., 1894, 50, 546.Google Scholar
Jespersen, C., Skyldes den allmindelige fremskridende Parese Syfilis? 1874. Copenhagen, Thesis. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Joffe, J., Zeitschrift der k.k. Gesellschaft der Aerzte zu Wien, 1857, 13, 675. Quoted from Griesinger (1861).Google Scholar
Kjelberg, G., Upsala Univ. Årsskr., 1863. Quoted from Jber. Leist. ges. Med., 1868, ii, 16.Google Scholar
Kraepelin, E., Compendium der Psychiatrie, 1883. Leipzig: Abel.Google Scholar
Idem, Psychiatrie. 7th edition, 1904. Leipzig: Barth, vol. 2.Google Scholar
Idem, General Paresis. Tranlated by Moore, J. W., 1913. Nervous and Mental Disease Monograph Series, No. 14. New York: Nervous and Mental Disease Publishing Co.Google Scholar
Krafft-Ebing, R. von. Die progressive Paralyse. In: Spezielle Pathologie und Therapie, 1894. Edited by Nothnagel, H., Vienna: Hölder.Google Scholar
Mendel, E., Die progressive Paralyse der Irren, 1880. Berlin: Hirschwald. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Meyer, L., Annalen des Charité-Krankenhauses, 1858, 8(2), 44.Google Scholar
Idem. Allg. Z. Psychiat., 1861, 18. 327.Google Scholar
Mickle, J., General Paralysis of the Insane, 1880. London: Lewis.Google Scholar
Moebius, P. J., Über Robert Schumanns Krankheit, 1906. Halle: Marhold.Google Scholar
Mönkemöller, E. O., Z. ges. Neurol. Psychiat., 1911, 5, 500.Google Scholar
Nissl, F., Histol. histopath. Arb., 1904, 1, 315.Google Scholar
Nonne, K., Syphilis und Nervensystem. 2nd edition, 1909. Berlin: Karger.Google Scholar
Parchappe, M., Recherches sur l'encéphale, 1836. Paris: Rouvier.Google Scholar
Richarz, –., (1857). Quoted from Wasielewski, von, W. J., Robert Schumann. 4th edition, 1906. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel.Google Scholar
Idem. (1873). Quoted from Schumann, E., Robert Schumann, 1931. Leipzig: Köhler & Amelong.Google Scholar
Rieger, –., Jber. Fortschr. inn. Med., 1886, 210, 88. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Rohmell, –., Congrès périodique international des sciences medicales, 8ième session, Copenhagen, 1884. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Rokitansky, K., S.B. Akad. Wiss. Wien (math.-nat. Klasse), 1857, 24, 517.Google Scholar
Romberg, M. H., Lehrbuch der Nervenkrankheiten des Menschen (1851). 2nd edition, Berlin: Duncker.Google Scholar
Salomon, E., J. ment. Sci., 1863, 8, 365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schule, H., Handbuch der Geisteskrankheiten: Klinische Psychiatrie. 3rd edition, 1886. Leipzig: Vogel. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Slater, E., and Meyer, A., Confin. psychiat., in press.Google Scholar
Steenberg, V., Den syphilitiske Hjernelidelse, 1860. Copenhagen: Muhle. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Wedl, C., S.B. Akad. Wiss. Wien (math.-nat. Klasse), 1859. 27, 265. Quoted from Griesinger (1861), Salomon and Westphal.Google Scholar
Westphal, C., Allg. Z. Psychiat., 1863, 20, 481. Quoted from Hougberg.Google Scholar
Idem, J. ment. Sci., 1868, 14, 162, 506.Google Scholar
Willis, T., De anima brutorum, 1672. Oxford. Quoted from Zilboorg and Henry.Google Scholar
Zilboorg, G., and Henry, G. W., A History of Medical Psychology, 1941. New York: Norton.Google Scholar
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.