Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T17:16:03.926Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Value of Continuous Narcosis in the Treatment of Mental Disorder

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 February 2018

Harold A. Palmer
Harold A. Palmer*
Affiliation:
Woodside Hospital, London
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

There does not appear in the literature any method of treatment to which the term “prolonged narcosis” can be applied prior to the year 1897, when Macleod (47, 48) published his first article on the bromide sleep treatment. The Hippocratic “Aphorisms” (126) mention that immoderate sleep is bad for the patient, but Celsus (129) quotes Asclepiades as being in favour of procuring sleep, and remarks that some insane patients recover if sleep is obtained, and Paulus Aegineta (128) observes that sleep produces oblivion of mental suffering and rectifies the distracted powers of reason. Aretaeus (127) in discussing satyriasis mentions “very protracted sleep” as the proper cure for the condition”.

Type
Part I.—Original Articles
Information
Journal of Mental Science , Volume 83 , Issue 347 , November 1937 , pp. 636 - 678
Copyright
Copyright © Royal College of Psychiatrists, 1937 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Meerloo, A. M., “On the Action of Barbituric Acid Compounds”, Journ. Ment. Sci., 1933, 79, p. 336.Google Scholar
2 Müller, M., “Prolonged Xarcosis with Somnifaine in Psychiatry,” Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1925, 96, p. 653.Google Scholar
3 Ström-Olsen, R., “Prolonged Xarcosis in Mental Disorder”, Journ. Ment. Sci., 1934, 80, p. 658.Google Scholar
4 Idem , “Somnifaine Xarcosis: Toxic Symptoms and their Treatment with Insulin”, ibid., 1933, 79, p. 638.Google Scholar
5 Idem , Unpublished Thesis, University of Wales; communicated personally.Google Scholar
6 Furrer, J., “Observations on Prolonged Xarcosis with Somnifaine in Cases of Mental Disorder”, Schweiz. med. Wochenschr., 1924, 5, p. 275.Google Scholar
7 Kläsi, J., “Therapeutic Use of Continuous Narcosis for Schizophrenics by Somnifaine”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1922, 74, p. 557.Google Scholar
8 Segerath, F., “Modified Prolonged Sleep Treatment for States of Depression Deutsch. med. Wochenschr., 1931, Ivii, p. 1194.Google Scholar
9 Palmer, H. D., “Prolonged Narcosis as Therapy in the Psychoses Amer. Journ. Psych., 1932, 12, p. 143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
10 Oberholzer, H., “Prolonged Sleep Treatment with Somnifaine and Luminal at the Psychiatric Clinic, Burghölzli”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1927, 110, p. 81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
11 Idem , “Résurn of Thesis”, Zurich, 1927, L'Encéphale, 1929, 24, p. 680.Google Scholar
12 Barkas, M., and Dawson, W. S., “Somnifaine Treatment in the Psychoses”, Lancet, 1926, 2, p. 1155.Google Scholar
13 Bleuler, M., “Schizophrenia: A Review of the Work of Prof. E. Bleuler”, Arch. Neur. and Psychiat., 1931, 26, p. 6io.Google Scholar
14 Wyler, J., “Further Experiences with Somnifaine in Psychiatry”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1924, 94. p. 20.Google Scholar
15 Forel, O. L., “Toxic States”, Ann. Medico-psych., 1931, 89, 2, p. 362.Google Scholar
16 Berkeley-Hill, O. A. R., “Treatment by Prolonged Sleep in Psychiatry”, Ind. Med. Gazette, 1926, 61, p. 383.Google Scholar
17 Gundert, , “ Experiences with Somnifaine in Psychiatry Zeitschr. f. Psych., 1924, 81, p. 87.Google Scholar
18 Claude, H., “Clinical Xote on a Case Treated by Somnifaine”, L'Encéphale, 1928, 23, P-549 Google Scholar
19 Heuyer, G., “A Case of Somnifaine Addiction”, ibid., 1929, 24, p. 492.Google Scholar
20 Demole, V., “Sedative Treatment in Psychiatry Using Somnifaine”, Rev. Neurol., 1921, 28, p. 1222.Google Scholar
21 Kooy, F., “Somnifaine Treatment in Psychoses”, South African Med. Journ., 1934, 8, P. 567.Google Scholar
22 Parfitt, D. N., “Treatment of Psychoses by Prolonged Narcosis” Lancet, 1936, No. 5869, p. 424.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
23 Menzies, E. C., “A Non-Asylum Treatment for Acute Mania”, Canadian Med. Assoc. Journ., 1935, 32, p. 418.Google Scholar
24 Quastel, J., and Strom-Olsen, R., “Glucose-Insulin Administration in Prolonged Narcosis”, Lancet, 1933, 1, p. 464.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
25 Pochmann, E., “Somnifaine Psychoses”, Med. Klin., 1932, 27, p. 939.Google Scholar
26 Enke, W., “The Problem of Continuous Narcosis in Psychiatry”, Münch, med. Wochenschr., 1929, 47, p. 1961.Google Scholar
27 Hinsie, L., The Treatment of Schizophrenia, London, 1930.Google Scholar
28 Kiene, , “New-Experiences with Continuous Hypnotics”, Psych.-Neur. Wochenschr., 1931, 33, p. 21.Google Scholar
29 Grundler, W., “Experiences with Somnifaine in Institutional Practice”, ibid., 1930, 32, p. 29.Google Scholar
30 Kläsi, J., “Some Schizophrenic Treatments”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1922, 78, p. 606.Google Scholar
31 Schafgen, H., “The Use of Continuous Narcosis in Psychiatry”, Arch. f. Psych., 1927, 81, p. 333.Google Scholar
32 Moser, , “The Treatment of Schizophrenia with Prolonged Narcosis”, Deutsch. med. Wochenschr., 1923, 49, p. 884.Google Scholar
33 Horanszky, F., “Some New Methods of Treatment with Schizophrenia”, Arch. f. Psych., 1928, 84, p. 181.Google Scholar
34 Strauss, H., “Clinical Experiences with Somnifaine in Psychiatry”, Klin. Wochenschr., 1924, 4, p. 150.Google Scholar
35 Mollenhoff, F., “Dangers of Somnifaine in Psychiatry”, ibid., 1924, 3, p. 1171.Google Scholar
36 Malachowski, R., “Somnifaine in Psychiatry”, Med. Klin., 1924, 14, p. 454.Google Scholar
37 Sacristan, J., and Pinto, J., “Continuous Narcosis Treatment of Kläsi for Manic-Depressive Insanity”, Zeit. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1924, 91, p. 396.Google Scholar
38 Hoch, P., “New Methods of Treatment for Schizophrenia”, Zeit. f. Psych., 1930, 93, p. 305.Google Scholar
39 Malachowski, R., “Somnifaine Klin. Wochenschr., 1924, 3, p. 426.Google Scholar
40 Neuendorff, , “Experiences with Somnifaine”, Deutsch. med Wochenschr., 1924, 1, p. 83.Google Scholar
41 Werner, J., “Somnifaine in Psychiatry”, ibid., 1923, 49, p. 282.Google Scholar
42 Meerloo, A., “Pathology and Psychopathology of Continuous Narcosis”, Zeit. f. d. ges. Neur., 1930, 127, p. 168.Google Scholar
43 MacNiven, A., et al., Symposium on “Somnifaine Narcosis”, Royal Medico-Psychological Association, Glasgow, May 14, 1936, Journ. Ment. Sci., 1936, 82, p. 423.Google Scholar
44 Hennelly, T., “Prolonged Narcosis in Manic-Depressive Psychosis”, ibid., 1936, 82, p. 608.Google Scholar
45 Twenty-Second Annual Report of Board of Control, pp. 93, 123, 129, 147, 157, 162, 168, 173.Google Scholar
46 Lutz, J., “Prolonged Anæsthesia Treatment in Psychiatry”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1929, 123, p. 91.Google Scholar
47 Macleod, N., “The Bromide Sleep: A New Departure in the Treatment of Acute Mania”, Brit. Med. Journ., 1900, 1, p. 134.Google Scholar
48 Ragg, P. M., “ The Bromide Sleep in a Case of Acute Mania”, ibid., November 3, 1900, p. 1309.Google Scholar
49 Bleckwenn, W., “The Use of Sodium Amytal in Catatonia”. Schizophrenia, vol. x, Assoc. f. Res. in Neur. and Ment. Disease. Google Scholar
50 Muller, M., “Prolonged Anæsthesia with Liquid Dial with Psychotics, especially with Manic-Depressive Insanity”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1927, 107, p. 522.Google Scholar
51 Bleckwenn, W., “Narcosis as Therapy in Neuropsychiatrie Conditions”, Journ. Amer. Med. Assoc., 1930, 95, p. 1168.Google Scholar
52 Idem , “The Production of Sleep and Rest in Psychotic Cases”, Arch. Neur. and Psychiat., 1930, 24, p. 365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
53 Black, N. D., “Three Years' Observation of Intensive Sodium Bromide Therapy in Functional and Organic Psychoses”, Psych. Quart., 1932, 6, p. 691.Google Scholar
54 Idem , “Use of Sodium Amytal, Sodium Rhodanate and Sodium Barbital in the Treatment of Psychoses” ibid., 1932, 6, p. 657.Google Scholar
55 Murray, V. F., “Use of Sodium Amytal in Treatment of Psychoses ibid., 1932, 6, p. 273.Google Scholar
56 Lang, H. B., “A Note on the Use of Sodium Amytal and Sodium Rhodanate in the Psychoses”, ibid., 1932, 6, p. 380.Google Scholar
57 Bohn, R., “ Sodium Amytal Narcosis as a Therapeutic Aid in Psychiatry”, ibid., 1932, 6, p. 301.Google Scholar
58 Skoog, A. L., “A Treatment for Neuro-Psychiatric Syndromes Employing Twilight Narcosis”, Southern Med. Journ., 1935, 28, p. 468.Google Scholar
(58a) Palmer, H. D., “ Prolonged Narcosis as Therapy in the Psychoses”, Amer. Journ. Psychiat., 1932, 12, p. 143.Google Scholar
59 Witts, G. F., “Sodium Barbital—Sodium Phenobarbital Narcosis in the Treatment of the Acute Psychoses”, Texas State Journ. of Med., 1934, 30, p. 517.Google Scholar
60 and 61 Cloetta, M., and Maier, H., “An Improvement in the Prolonged Anæsthesia Treatment”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur., 1934, 150, p. 146; Synopsis of above article, Amer. Journ. Psychiat., 1935, xci, p. 1409.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
62 Hofmann, K., “Experiments with Wiethold's Prolonged Sleep Treatment and Prolonged Sleep—Protein Shock Therapy”, Psych. Neur. Wochenschr., 1933, 42, p. 507.Google Scholar
63 Bleckwenn, W., “Sodium Amytal in Certain Nervous and Mental Conditions”, Winconsin Med. Journ., 1930, 29, p. 693.Google Scholar
64 Hackfield, A. W., “Combination of Induced Narcosis and Fever: Its Effect on ‘Affective Syndrome’”, Arch. Neur. and Psychiat., 1932, 28, p. 1169.Google Scholar
65 Hoch, P., “Treatment of Schizophrenia with Prolonged Narcosis”, Psych. Quart., 1935, 9, p. 386.Google Scholar
66 Epstein, J., “The Use of Sodium Amytal in Various Mental Diseases”, U.S. Vet. Bur. M.B., 1931, 7, p. 393.Google Scholar
67 Christoffel, H., “Dial Ciba and Dialism”, Zeitschr. Neur., 1918, 43, p. 49.Google Scholar
68 Magnus, A., “Narco-sustained Therapy with Diallyl-barbituric Acid in Psychiatry”, Journ. of Nerv, and Ment. Dis., 1934, 79, p. 286.Google Scholar
69 Monnier, M., “Prolonged Sleep Treatment of Schizophrenics with the Anæsthetic Mixture of Cloetta at the Psychiatric Clinic, Burghölzli, Zurich”, Nervenarzt., 1936, 9, p. 14.Google Scholar
70 Friedemann, A., “Clinical Studies on Sleep and Sleep Remedies”, Deutsch. med. Wochenschr., 1929.Google Scholar
71 Blune, G., “The Problem of Avertin Narcosis in Psychiatry”, ibid., 1929.Google Scholar
72 Wiethold, F., “The Use of Prolonged Narcosis with Mental Patients”, Münch, med. Wochenschr., 1924, 42, p. 1466.Google Scholar
73 Idem , “Further Experiences with Prolonged Narcosis for Mental Patients”, ibid., 1925, 72, p. 1460.Google Scholar
74 Hinrichs, U., “The Prolonged Sleep Treatment with Scopolamine Paraldehyde”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1926, 105, p. 623.Google Scholar
75 Oppler, W., “Continuous Narcosis Using Trional”, Zeitschr. f. Psychiat., 1928, 88, p. 74.Google Scholar
76 Witt, G. F., “Prolonged Barbiturate Narcosis in the Treatment of Acute Psychoses”, Southern Med. Journ., 1936, 29, p. 574.Google Scholar
77 Broder, S. B., “Sleep Induced by Sodium Amytal: An Abridged Method for Use in Mental Illnesses”, Amer. Journ. Psychiat., 1936, 93, p. 57.Google Scholar
78 Bleckwenn, W. J., “Production of Sleep and Rest in Psychotic Cases”, Arch. Neur. and Psychiat., 1930, 24, p. 365.Google Scholar
79 Magnus, A., “Narco-sustained Therapy in Psychosis with Heart Lesions”, Illinois Med. Journ., 1936, 69, p. 237.Google Scholar
80 Kohra, T., Abstract on Sulphonal Technique, Zentralbl. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1929, 53, p. 638.Google Scholar
81 Serejsky, M., and Feldmanne, , “Progress of Continuous Narcosis in Psychiatry”, Zentralbl. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1937, 83, p. 630.Google Scholar
82 Horsley, J. S., “Therapeutic Narcosis with Soneryl”, Journ. Ment. Sci., 1937, 83, p. 25.Google Scholar
83 Brocker, J. W., “Treatment of Acute Narcotic Poisoning”, Zentralbl. f. Innere. Med., 1931, 12, p. 241.Google Scholar
84 Steinmeyer, T., “Luminal Poisoning”, Münch. med. Wochenschr., 1931, Xo. 423, p. 143.Google Scholar
85 Mosbacher, W., “Phanodorm Delirium”, Psych. Neur. Wochenschr., 1932, 34, p. 15.Google Scholar
86 Christoffel, H., “Dial Ciba and Dialism”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psychiat., 1918, 43, p. 39.Google Scholar
87 Maloney, A., “Picrotoxin as an Antidote in Acute Poisoning by the Longer-acting Barbiturates”, Journ. Pharm., 1932, 44, p. 337.Google Scholar
88 Fitch, R., “The Duration of Action of the Barbituric Acid Hypnotics as a Basis of Classifications”, ibid., 1932, 44, p. 325.Google Scholar
89 Gruber, C. M., “The Effect of Sodium Phenobarbital and Some Other Barbituric Acid Derivatives upon the Coronary Circulation”, Journ. Pharm. and Exper. Ther., 1926, 27, p. 319.Google Scholar
90 Idem , “The Effect of Sodium Phenobarbital and Some Other Barbituric Acid Derivatives upon the Cerebral Circulation”, ibid., 1926, 27, p. 349.Google Scholar
91 Schneider, K., “A Case of Veronal Poisoning”, Allg. z. f. Psychiatr., p. 72, 1916.Google Scholar
92 Anderson, H., “The Effect of Barbituric Acid Hypnotics on Basal Metabolism in Humans Journ. Pharm, and Exper. Ther., 1930, 40, p. 215.Google Scholar
93 Nielson, C., “A Comparative Study on Hypnotics of the Barbituric Acid Series”, ibid., 1925, 26, p. 371.Google Scholar
94 Olnsted, J., “The Effect of Amytal Anæsthesia on Glucose Tolerance”, Proc. Soc. Exper. Biol, and Med., 1929, 27, p. 103.Google Scholar
95 Hoff, H., “Concerning Chronic Medinal Intoxication”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psych., 1926, 103, p. 176.Google Scholar
96 Kaer, E., “Barbituric Acid Mixtures: Allonal”, Schmerz. Narkose. Anœsthesie, 1929, 2, p. 323.Google Scholar
97 Finesinger, , “The Action of the Narcotic Drugs on the Pial Vessels”, Journ. Pharm., 1935, 53, p. 1.Google Scholar
98 Carrière, G., “Eleven Cases of Coma by Barbiturate Poisoning”, Presse Méd., 1935, 93, p. 465.Google Scholar
99 Hoff, H., “Proposed Sleep Remedies for Xeuroses”, Wien. Med. Wochenschr., 1928, 78, p. 1187.Google Scholar
100 Quastel, J., “Xarcosis and Oxidation of Brain”, Proc. Roy. Soc., 1932, 112, p. 60.Google Scholar
101 Harris, N., “The Effect of the Administration of Sodium Amytal and Sod. Rhodanate on Mental Patients', Amer. Journ. Psychiat., 1932, 12, p. 1065.Google Scholar
102 Willcox, W. Sir, et al, “ Discussion on Barbiturates”, Proc. Roy. Soc. Med., 1927, 20, p. 1479.Google Scholar
103 Purves Stewart, J. Sir, “Poisoning by Barbitone and Allied Drugs”, Lancet, 1934, Xo. 226, p. 6.Google Scholar
104 Keller, A., “The Action of Anæsthetic Drugs on the Motor Cortex of Monkeys”, Amer. Journ. Phys., 1931, 97, p. 537.Google Scholar
105 Sollmann, T., A Manual of Pharmacology, 1936, p. 725.Google Scholar
106 Roper-Hall, H. T., “The Barbiturates”, Proc. Roy. Soc. Med., 1936, 29, p. 25.Google Scholar
107 Gros, O., “The Antagonism between Cardiazol and Coramine and Narcotics”, Arch. Exp. Path. Pharmakol., 1936, 93, p. 258.Google Scholar
(107a) Keeser, E., Arch. Exp. Path. u. Pharm., 1927, 25, p. 251.Google Scholar
108 Loevenhart, A. S., “Stimulation of the Respiration by Sodium Cyanide”, Arch. Int. Med., 1918, 21, p. 109.Google Scholar
109 Idem , “Cerebral Stimulation”, Journ. Amer. Med. Assoc., 1929, 92, p. 880.Google Scholar
110 Bancroft, W. D., “The Colloid Chemistry of Insanity, I”, Journ. Phys. Chem., 1931, 35, p. 1606.Google Scholar
111 Idem , “The Colloid Chemistry of Insanity, II”, ibid., 1931, 35, p. 3452.Google Scholar
112 Henderson, V., “Claude Bernard's Theory of Narcosis” Journ. Pharm., 1932, 44, p. 253 (résumé, Tohoku Journ. Exp. Med., 1934, xxiii, p. 279: Journ. Ment. Sci., April, 1935; résumé, Nederland Tijdschr. Geneeskunde, 1934, exxviii, p. 2319: ibid., April, 1935).Google Scholar
113 Begg, N. D., “Toxic Diphtheria: The Significance of Sugar-Tolerance Curves and the Value of Insulin”, Lancet, 1935, 1, p. 480.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
114 McCowan, P. K., and Quastel, J. H., “Blood-Sugar Studies in Abnormal Mental States”, Journ. Ment. Sci., 1931, 77, p. 525.Google Scholar
115 Benn, E. C., “Toxic Diphtheria: Combined Antitoxin and Dextrose Insulin Therapy”, Lancet, 1932, No. 222, p. 281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
116 Henderson, V., “The Present Status of the Theories of Narcosis”, Phys. Rev., 1930, 10, p. 171.Google Scholar
117 Pick, E. P., “Pharmacology of the Vegetative Nervous System: Report of 18th Neur. Congress German Neur. Soc.”, Arch. Neur., 1930, 23, p. 582.Google Scholar
118 Hepburn, J., “Effect of Insulin on the Sugar Consumption of the Isolated Surviving Rabbit Heart”, Amer. Journ. Phys., 1922, 62, p. 177.Google Scholar
119 Schwentker, F., “The Carbohydrate Metabolism in Diphtheria Intoxication”, Bull. Johns. Hopkins Hosp., 1930, 46, p. 259.Google Scholar
120 Pavlov, , Conditioned Reflexes, Oxford University Press, 1927.Google Scholar
121 Sehrijver, D., “The Biological Reactions in Continuous Narcosis”, Zeitschr. f. d. ges. Neur. u. Psych., 1931, 35, p. 528.Google Scholar
122 Hess, W. R., “The Correlation between Psyche and Vegetative Functions”, Schweiz. Arch. Neur., 15.Google Scholar
123 Boss, M., “The Psycho-dynamics of Continuous Narcosis in Schizophrenia”, Schweiz. Arch. f. Neur. u. Psych., 1935, 36, p. 209.Google Scholar
124 Gillespie, R. D., Sleep, London, 1929.Google Scholar
125 Hoch, A., and Kirby, G.—“A Clinical Study of Psychoses Characterized by Distressed Perplexity”, Arch. Neur. Psychiat., 1919, 1, p. 415.Google Scholar
126 The Genuine Works of Hippocrates, Sydenham Society, p. 705.Google Scholar
127 Extant Works of Aretaeus, ibid., p. 289.Google Scholar
128 Paulus Acquinata, ibid., p. 180.Google Scholar
129 Celsus, De Medicina, trans. Spencer, W. G. III, 18, pp. 3–6.Google Scholar
130 Boerhaave, , Aphorisms, No. 1097.Google Scholar
131 The Canon of Medicine of Avicenna, Gruner, O. G., No. 819.Google Scholar
132 Mental Pathology and Therapeutics, Griesinger, W., 1845, p. 476.Google Scholar
133 On Procuring Sleep in Insanity, Williams, J., 1845, p. 51.Google Scholar
134 Clinical Lectures on Mental Diseases, Clouston, T., 1883, p. 177.Google Scholar
135 Lange, J., Concise Textbook of Psychiatry, Leipzig, 1935, p. 241.Google Scholar
136 Strecker, and Ebaugh, , Practical Clinical Psychiatry, Philadelphia, 1935.Google Scholar
137 Noyes, , Modern Clinical Psychiatry, 1934.Google Scholar
138 Muller, M., Prognosis and Therapy of Mental Disorder, 1936.Google Scholar
139 Kretschmer, , Physique and Character, 1936.Google Scholar
140 Idem , Textbook of Medical Psychology, 1934.Google Scholar
141 Devine, H., Recent Advances in Psychiatry, second edition, 1933.Google Scholar
142 Henderson, and Gillespie, , Textbook of Psychiatry, fourth edition, 1936.Google Scholar
143 Bumke, O., Textbook of Psychiatry, pp. 176 and 460.Google Scholar
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.