Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T07:02:35.812Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Cross-cultural Research in New Zealand Organisations: What We Know and What Needs to Be Addressed

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 September 2015

Lee Moya Ah Chong  and
David C. Thomas
Lee Moya Ah Chong
Affiliation:
Department of Management and Employment Relations, University of Auckland, Private Bag 92019, Auckland, New Zealand Phone 64-9-373-7599 (Ext 4813), E-mail: [email protected]
David C. Thomas
Affiliation:
Department of International Business, University of Auckland, Private Bag 92019, Auckland, New Zealand Phone 64-9-373-7599 (Ext 6636), E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Business in New Zealand is increasingly global in nature. Additionally, the domestic workforce reflects a unique blend of cultural groups. These factors highlight the need for managers to understand the cross-cultural nature of their task. In this article we review the research on cross-cultural management that has been conducted in New Zealand. Findings in seven topic areas of management (job satisfaction, motivation and performance, absenteeism and turnover, leadership, communication, group behaviour and employee adaptation) are discussed. We then identify areas that might benefit most from research attention.

This research was supported in part by the Carnegie Bosch Institute for Applied Studies in International Management. The authors gratefully acknowledge the helpful comments of Kerr Inkson and John Deeks on earlier versions of this manuscript

The increasingly multicultural nature of the business environment has become widely recognised as a management issue (Adler and Ghadar 1990). New Zealand is neither a large target market (population under 3.5 million) nor is it the headquarters of a large number of multinational corporations. However, because of its geography, it is dependent on international business for its quality of life. Additionally, its unique domestic cultural environment provides a dramatic back drop for cross-cultural management. These two dimensions make cross-cultural management a particularly salient issue in New Zealand.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Management & Organization , Volume 1 , Issue 2 , March 1995 , pp. 14 - 32
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press and Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adler, NJ (1992) International Dimensions of Organizational Behavior Boston: PWS-KentGoogle Scholar
Adler, NJ and Ghadar, F (1990) ‘International Strategy from the Perspective of People and Culture: The North American Context’ in Rugman, AM (ed) Research in Global Strategic Management: International Business Research for the Twenty-First Century Greenwich Connecticut: JAI PressGoogle Scholar
Anderson, LR (1980) Management of Multicultural Workgroups: Profile of the Effective Manager Unpublished Preliminary Report, Dept of Management Studies, University of Auckland, AucklandGoogle Scholar
Anderson, LR (1983) ‘Management of the Mixed-Cultural Work Group’ Organisational Behaviour and Human Performance Vol 31 pp 303–330CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Asch, SE (1946) ‘Forming Impressions of Personality’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 07 pp 258–290CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Barber, D (1993) ‘Maori: the Corporate Warrior’ Management 02 pp 37–41Google Scholar
Barnes, CC and Jamieson, BD (1977) ‘Reactions to Job Characteristics among Samoan, Maori and Pakeha Employees’ New Zealand Psychologist Vol 6 pp 14–24Google Scholar
Bass, BM and Stogdill, RM (1990) Bass and Stogdill's Handbook of Leadership: Theory, Research and Managerial Applications New York: Free PressGoogle Scholar
Bettenhausen, KL (1991) ‘Five Years of Group Research: What We Have Learned and What Needs to be Addressed’ Journal of Management Vol 17 pp 345–381CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Black, JS and Porter, LW (1991) ‘Managerial Behavior and Job Performance: A Successful Manager in Los Angeles May Not Succeed in Hong Kong’ Journal of International Business Studies Vol 22 pp 99–113CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brein, M and David, KH (1971) ‘Intercultural Communication and Adjustment of the Sojourner’ Psychological Bulletin Vol 76 pp 215–230CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bull, P, Flay, B and Tamahori, J (1983) ‘Labour Turnover in a Multi-Racial Car Assembly Plant’ in Marsh, NR and McDonald, WF (eds) The Multi-Cultural Workforce in New Zealand and Australia Auckland: Occasional Paper, Department of Management Studies, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Department of Labour (1979) The Work Experience of Pacific Island immigrants in the Greater Wellington Area Wellington: Research and Planning DivisionGoogle Scholar
Earley, PC (1993) ‘East Meet West Meets Mideast: Further Explorations of Collectivistic and Individualistic Work Groups’ Academy of Management Journal Vol 36(2) pp 319–348Google Scholar
Edgeley, LA and MacDonald, WF (1984) Working Together: A Handbook for Managers and Supervisors in a Multi-Cultural Workforce Wellington: HasselbergGoogle Scholar
Eldred-Grigg, S (1990) New Zealand Working People, 1890–1990 Palmerston North: Dunmore PressGoogle Scholar
Employment Task Force (1994) Employment: the Issues Wellington Prime Ministerial Task Force on EmploymentGoogle Scholar
Feldman, DC and Thomas, DC (1992) ‘Career Management Issues Facing Expatriates’ Journal of International Business Studies Vol 62 pp 271–293CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gist, ME, Locke, EA and Taylor, MS (1987) ‘Organizational Behaviour: Group Structure, Process, and Effectiveness’ Journal of Management Vol 13 pp 237–258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gold, H and Webster, A (1990) New Zealand Values Today: the Popular Report of the November 1989 New Zealand Study of Values Palmerston North: Alpha ProductionsGoogle Scholar
Goodman, PS, Ravlin, EC and Argote, L (1986) ‘Current Thinking about Groups: Setting the Stage for New Ideas’ in Goodman, PS (ed) Designing Effective Work Groups San Francisco: Jossey-BassGoogle Scholar
Graves, NB and Graves, TD (1977a) Understanding New Zealand's Multicultural Workforce Wellington: Vocational Training CouncilGoogle Scholar
Graves, NB and Graves, TD (1977b) ‘Preferred Adaptive Strategies: An Approach to Understanding New Zealand's Multicultural Workforce’ New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations Vol 2 pp 81–90Google Scholar
Graves, TD and Graves, NB (1978) Kinship Ties and the Preferred Adaptive Strategies of Urban Migrants Wellington: South Pacific Research Institute Research Report No 19Google Scholar
Haman, R (1977) Situational Factors in Intergroup Relations: Pacific Island Women in a New Zealand Factory Auckland: South Pacific Research Institute Research Report No 14Google Scholar
Haman, R (1978) Polynesian Women in Industry: Participation, Motivation and Orientations in a Multi-cultural Factory Auckland: Unpublished MA thesis, Department of Sociology, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Hawley, C (1983) ‘Industrial Language Training: The Potential for Development in the New Zealand Context’ in Marsh, NR and McDonald, WF (eds) The Multi-cultural Workforce in New Zealand and Australia Auckland: Occasional Paper, Department of Management Studies, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Henry, EY (1994) Rangatira Wahine: Maori Women Managers and Leadership Auckland: Unpublished MPhil thesis, Department of Management Studies and Labour Relations, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Hines, GH (1973) ‘Two-factor Motivation Theory in Cross-cultural Perspective’ Journal of Applied Psychology Vol 58 pp 375–377CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hines, GH (1974) Cultural Influences on Work Motivation Palmerston North: Department of Business Studies, Massey UniversityGoogle Scholar
Hines, GH and Hines, AB (1976) Cultural Differences in the Validity of Psychological Testing of Leadership in Fiji Palmerston North: Occasional Paper No 19, Department of Business Studies, Massey UniversityGoogle Scholar
Hoerr, J (1989) ‘The Payoff from Teamwork’ Business Week 07 pp 55–62Google Scholar
Hofstede, G (1983) ‘The Cultural Relativity of Organizational Practices and Theory’ Journal of International Business Studies Vol 14 pp 75–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hooper, AB (1961) ‘Cook Islanders in Auckland’ Journal of the Polynesian Society Vol 70(2) pp 147–193Google Scholar
Inkson, K (1987) ‘Organisational Behaviour: A Review of New Zealand Research’ New Zealand Journal of Psychology Vol 16 pp 9–27Google Scholar
Inkson, K and Paterson, J (1993) ‘Organisational Behaviour in New Zealand 1987–92: A Review’ New Zealand Journal of Psychology Vol 22 pp 54–66Google Scholar
Inter-Church Trade and Industry Mission (1973) Polynesians and Industry in New Zealand Auckland: Proceedings of Interchurch Trade Church and Industry Mission meetingsGoogle Scholar
Kanter, RM (1983) The Changemasters New York: Simon and SchusterGoogle Scholar
Lee, M (1974) Nga Kaimahi: Polynesians in Industry Wellington: Polynesian Advisory Committee, Vocational Training CouncilGoogle Scholar
Loomis, T (1990) Pacific Migrant Labour, Class and Racism in New Zealand Aldershot, UK: AveburyGoogle Scholar
Lord, RG (1985) ‘An Information Processing Approach to Social Perceptions, Leadership, and Behavioral Measurement’ in Cummings, LL and Staw, BM (eds) Research in Organizational Behavior Vol 7 Greenwich Connecticut: JAI Press pp 87–128Google Scholar
Lord, RG, Foti, RJ and DeVader, CL (1984) ‘A Test of Leadership Categorization Theory: Internal Structure, Information Processing, and Leadership Perceptions’ Organizational Behavior and Human Performance Vol 34 pp 343–378CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Love, M (1993) Maori Management: the Way of the Future? Paper given at ANZAME Conference 1993 Deakin University, MelbourneGoogle Scholar
McGrath, JE and Kravitz, DA (1982) ‘Group Research’ Annual Review of Psychology Vol 33 pp 195–230CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McLennan, R, Inkson, K, Dakin, S, Dewe, P and Elkin, G (1987) People and Enterprises: Human Behaviour in New Zealand Organisations Sydney: Holt, Reinhart and WinstonGoogle Scholar
Macpherson, C (1991) ‘The Changing Contours of Samoan Ethnicity’ in Spoonley, P, Pearson, D and Macpherson, C (eds) Nga Take: Ethnic Relations in Aotearoa/New Zealand Palmerston North: Dunmore Press pp 67–84Google Scholar
Macpherson, C (1983) ‘The Re-negotiation of Ethnic Identity: Impression Management in a Multi-cultural Workforce’ in Marsh, NR and McDonald, WF (eds) The Multi-cultural Workforce in New Zealand and Australia Auckland: Occasional Paper, Department of Management Studies, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Manatu Maori (Economic Development Unit) (1991) Maori and Work: the Position of Maori in the New Zealand Labour Market Wellington: Manatu MaoriGoogle Scholar
March, RM (1992) ‘Western Manager, Japanese Boss’ Intersect pp 11–16Google Scholar
Marsh, NR (1978) Constructs of Power and Authority and their Behavioural and Attitudinal Outcomes: a Comparative Study of European and Polynesian First-line Supervisors Bath, UK: PhD thesis, University of BathGoogle Scholar
Marsh, NR and McDonald, WF (1977, 12) ‘New Zealand's Multicultural Workforce’ Management pp 34–35Google Scholar
Mason, BL and Cole, BH (1977) ‘The Meremere Coal Gang: A Study of a Multicultural Workgroup’ New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations Vol 2(3) pp 90–97Google Scholar
Mendenhall, M and Oddou, G (1985) ‘The Dimensions of Expatriate Acculturation’ Academy of Management Review Vol 10 pp 39–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mintzberg, H and Quinn, JB (1991) The Strategy Process Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice HallGoogle Scholar
Misumi, J and Peterson, MF (1985) ‘The Performance-maintenance (PM) Theory of Leadership: Review of a Japanese Research Program’ Administrative Science Quarterly Vol 30 pp 198–223CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mobley, WW (1977) ‘Intermediate Linkages in the Relationship Between Job Satisfaction and Employee Turnover’ Journal of Applied Psychology Vol 62 pp 237–240CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morgan, LG and Herman, JB (1976) ‘Perceived Consequences of Absenteeism’ Journal of Applied Psychology Vol 61 pp 738–742CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nedd, ANB and Marsh, NR (1977) Attitudes and Behaviour of the Multicultural Industrial Workforce in New Zealand Auckland: Department of Management Studies, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Nedd, ANB and Marsh, NR (1983) ‘Social-traditionalism and Supervisory Style: An Empirical Investigation of the Relationships Between Social Values and the Compliance-gaining Strategies of Supervisors’ in Marsh, NR and McDonald, WF (eds) The Multicultural Workforce in New Zealand and Australia Auckland: Occasional Paper, Department of Management Studies, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Nedd, ANB, Marsh, NR and McDonald, WF (1978) A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Supervisors in New Zealand Wellington: Polynesian Advisory Committee, Vocational Training CouncilGoogle Scholar
O'Connell, MS, Lord, RG and O'Connell, MK (1990) An Empirical Comparison of Japanese and American Leadership Prototypes: Implications for Overseas Assignment of Managers Paper presented at the 1990 meeting of the Academy of Management, San Francisco, CaliforniaGoogle Scholar
Ongley, P (1991) ‘Pacific Islands' immigration and the New Zealand Labour Market’ in Spoonley, P, Pearson, D and Macpherson, C (eds) Nga Take: Ethnic Relations and Racism in Aotearoa Palmerston North: Dunmore Press pp 17–36Google Scholar
Pickering, T (1974) Analysis of Factors that may Cause Dissatisfaction Experienced by Tongan Employees at James Hardie and Co. Pty Ltd Auckland: Pilot Study, Centre for Continuing Education, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Pierce, BF (1967) ‘A Case Study of Maori Work Attendance’ Journal of the Polynesian Society Vol 76(4) pp 405–414Google Scholar
Pierce, BF (1969) Maoris and Industrial Technology: A Comparative Study of the Adaptation of a Pre-industrial People to an Industrial Milieu Auckland: Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Pitt, D and Macpherson, C (1974) Emerging Pluralism: The Samoan Community in New Zealand Auckland: Longman PaulGoogle Scholar
Polley, RB (1989) ‘Coalition, Mediation, and Scapegoating: General Principles and Cultural Variation’ International Journal of Intercultural Relations Vol 13 pp 165–181CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pringle, JK and Henry, EY (1993, 02) Diversity in Women's Organisations: Maori and Pakeha Paper presented at the Fifth International Interdisciplinary Congress on Women, University of Costa RicaGoogle Scholar
Reichers, A (1986) ‘Conflict and Organizational Commitments’ Journal of Applied Psychology Vol 71 pp 508–514CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rusbult, CE, Farrell, D, Rogers, G and Mainous, AG III (1988) ‘Impact of Exchange Variables on Exit, Voice, Loyalty and Neglect: An Integrative Model of Responses to Declining Job Satisfaction’ Academy of Management Journal Vol 31 pp 599–627Google Scholar
Sauers, DA (1993) ‘Managing Workforce Diversity: A challenge for New Zealand Business in the 1990s’ Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources Vol 31(3) pp 44–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schein, EH (1985) Organizational Culture and Leadership San Francisco: Jossey-BassGoogle Scholar
Scowcroft, JT (1993) ‘Managing Diversity’ in New Zealand Organisations: An Exploratory Study Auckland: MPhil Thesis, Department of Management Studies and Labour Relations, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar
Seidman, J (1975) Attitudes of New Zealand Workers Wellington: Industrial Relations Centre, Victoria UniversityGoogle Scholar
Smith, B and Wilson, P (1983) Labour Turnover in a Large Integrated Forest Complex Rotorua: Forest Research Institute Bulletin No 56Google Scholar
Smith, PB, Misumi, J, Tayeb, M, Peterson, M and Bond, M (1989) ‘On the Generality of Leadership Style Measures Across Cultures’ Journal of Occupational Psychology Vol 62 pp 97–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, PB, Peterson, M, Misumi, J and Bond, M (1992) ‘A Cross-Cultural Test of the Japanese PM Leadership Theory’ Applied Psychology: An International Review Vol 41(1) pp 5–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, PB, Peterson, M, Misumi, J and Sugiman, T (1990) ‘Cross-Cultural Tests of PM Leadership Theory: East meets West’ The Japanese Journal of Experimental Social Psychology Vol 29(3) pp 53–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spoonley, P (1975) Prospects for the Niuean Community in Auckland: the Role of Gatekeeper Groups in Migrant Adaptation Dunedin: MA Thesis, University of OtagoGoogle Scholar
Spoonley, P (1978) ‘The Role of Employers as Gatekeepers’ New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations Vol 3(2) pp 63–70Google Scholar
Statistics New Zealand (1994a) Labour Market 1993 Wellington: Statistics New ZealandGoogle Scholar
Statistics New Zealand (1994b) Demographic Trends 1993 Wellington: Statistics New ZealandGoogle Scholar
Statistics New Zealand (1993a) New Zealand's Multicultural Society Wellington: Statistics New ZealandGoogle Scholar
Statistics New Zealand (1993b) Overseas Trade Statistics Wellington: Statistics New ZealandGoogle Scholar
Staw, B (1984) ‘Organizational Behaviour: A Review and Reformulation of the Field's Outcome Variables’ Annual Review of Psychology Vol 35 pp 627–66CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Steers, RM and Rhodes, SR (1978) ‘Major Influences on Employee Attendance: A Process Model’ Journal of Applied Psychology Vol 63 pp 391–407CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, S (1981) ‘A Categorization Approach to Stereotyping’ in Hamilton, D (ed) Cognitive Processes in Stereotyping and Group Behavior Hillsdale, New Jersey: ErlbaumGoogle Scholar
Thomas, DC and Ravlin, EC (1994) Cultural Diversity in International Teams: Implications for Organisational Fit, Job Attitudes, and Performance Paper presented at the Carnegie Bosch Institute International Research Conference, Pittsburgh, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
Thomas, DC and Ravlin, EC (1995) ‘Responses of Workers to Cultural Adaptation by a Foreign Manager’ Journal of Applied Psychology Vol 80(1) pp 133–146CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thomas, DC and Toyne, B (1995) ‘Subordinates' Responses to Cultural Adaptation by Japanese Expatriate Managers’ The Journal of Business Research Vol 32(1) pp 1–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Weiss, J (1983) ‘The New Zealand Multi-Cultural Workforce’ in Marsh, NR and McDonald, WF (eds) The Multicultural Workforce in New Zealand and Australia Auckland: Occasional Paper, Department of Management Studies, University of AucklandGoogle Scholar