Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T08:55:47.605Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Toward Rational Criminal HIV Exposure Laws

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

Carol L. Galletly  and
Steven D. Pinkerton
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Criminal law and the proceedings surrounding it work, at least in theory, much like an author works when writing a play or a novel. Both the lawyer and the writer follow traditional formulae that allow them to create and express a vision of reality. When done well, the reality created is virtually seamless. This, however, is the point at which law and literary works diverge. Although we embrace creativity in literary endeavors, we would prefer that the foundation of our legal system be something more substantial. Unfortunately, where US. criminal HIV exposure statutes are concerned, there appears to be little if any concrete connection between proscribed behaviors and what we know about HIV transmission risk. Twenty-four states in the U.S. make it a criminal offense for a person who has HIV to expose another to the virus through consensual sexual activities. The relationship between the activities prohibited by these laws and actual risk of virus transmission is tenuous at best.

Type
Article
Information
Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics , Volume 32 , Issue 2 , Summer 2004 , pp. 327 - 337
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 2004

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 2903.11(B) (Anderson 2004).Google Scholar
Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 2929.13–14 (Anderson, 2004).Google Scholar
See supra note 1; Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 2907.01(A) (Anderson, 2004).Google Scholar
Lazzarini, Z. Bray, S.J. Burris, S., “Evaluating the Impact of Criminal Laws on HIV Risk Behavior,” Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics 30 (2002): 239–253, at 241–244.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id. at 244.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
DeGruttola, V. Seage, G.R. III Mayer, K.H. Horsburgh, C.R. Jr., “Infectiousness of HIV between Male Homosexual Partners,” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 42 (1989): 849–856.; Royce, R.A. Seña, A. Cates, W. Jr. Cohen, M.S., “Sexual Transmission of HIV,” N. Engl. J. Med. 336 (1997): 1072–1078.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Downs, A.M. De Vincenzi, I., “Probability of Heterosexual Transmission of HIV: Relationship to the Number of Unprotected Sexual Contacts,” Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes and Human Retrovirology 11 (1996): 388–395.; Mastro, T.D. Satten, G.A. Nopkesorn, T. Sangkharomya, S. Longini, I.M. Jr., “Probability of Female-to-Male Transmission of HIV-1 in Thailand,” Lancet 343 (1994): 204–207.; Padian, N.S., “Heterosexual Transmission: Infectivity and Risks,” in Alexander, N.J. Gabelnick, H. L. Spieler, J. M., eds., Heterosexual Transmission of AIDS (New York: Alan R. Liss, Inc., 1990): 25–34.Google Scholar
Hawkins, D.A., “Editorial,” Sexually Transmitted Infections 77 (2001):307–308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
del Romero, J. Marincovich, B. Castilla, J. Garcia, S. Campo, J. Hernando, V. Rodriguez, C., “Letter,” AIDS 16 (2002): 1296–1297; Page-Shafer, K. Shiboski, C.H. Osmond, D.H. Dilley, J. Mc Farland, W. Shiboski, S.C. Klausner, J.D. Balls, J. Greenspen, D. Greenspan, J.S., “Letter,” AIDS 16 (2002): 2350–2352.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dillon, B. Hecht, F.M. Swanson, M. Goupil-Sormany, I. Grant, R.M. Chesney, M.A. Kahn, J.O., “Primary HIV Infection Associated with Oral Transmission,” paper presented at 7th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections, January 30- February 2, 2000.Google Scholar
Vittinghoff, E. Douglas, J. Judson, F. McKirnan, D. MacQueen, K. Buchbinder, S.P., “Per-contact Risk of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Transmission between Male Sexual Partners”, American Journal of Epidemiology 150 (1999): 306–311.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pinkerton, S.D. Abramson, P.R., Condoms and the Prevention of AIDS, American Scientists 85 (1997): 364–373.Google Scholar
Pinkerton, S.D., (under review) “Sex Act Distributions and HIV Transmission Risk.”Google Scholar
Pinkerton, S.D. Abramson, P.R., “A Bernoulli Model of HIV Infection and Risk Reduction,” Evaluation Review 17 (1993): 504–528.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Royce, R.A. Seña, A. Cates, W. Jr. Cohen, M.S., Current Concepts, “Sexual Transmission of HIV,” N. Engl. J. Med. 336 (1997): 1072–1078.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ark. Code Ann. § 5-14-123 (Michie 2003).Google Scholar
Mich. Comp. Laws § 333.5210.1–2 (2004)Google Scholar
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Fact Sheet, HIV/AIDS & U.S. Women Who Have Sex With Women (WSW) at <http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/pubs/facts/wsw.htm> (last visited March 30, 2004).+(last+visited+March+30,+2004).>Google Scholar
San Francisco AIDS Foundation, AIDS 101, Reducing the Risk of Getting HIV from Sexual Activities, at <http://www.sfaf.org/aids101/sexual.html> (last visited March 30, 2004).+(last+visited+March+30,+2004).>Google Scholar
Ark. Code. Ann. § 5-4-401 (Michie 2004).Google Scholar
Mich. Comp. Laws § 750.503 (2004).Google Scholar
Idaho Code § 39–608.1–2 (2003).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Fact Sheet, HIV and Its Transmission at <http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/pubs/facts/transmission.htm> (last visited March 30, 2004).+(last+visited+March+30,+2004).>Google Scholar
See supra note 20.Google Scholar
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Transmission of HIV Possibly Associated with Exposure to Mucous Membrane Contaminated Blood,” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Reports 46 (1997): 620–622.Google Scholar
See supra note 23.Google Scholar
Nev. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 201.205 (Michie 2003).Google Scholar
Black, H.C., Black’s Law Dictionary, Abridged Sixth Edition, (New York: West Pub Co., 1990): at 638.Google Scholar
See supra note 16.Google Scholar
See supra note 28.Google Scholar
720 111. Comp. Stat. 5/12–16.2 (West 2003); Iowa Code § 709C.1 (2004).Google Scholar
Md. Code Ann., Health-General I § 18–601.1 (2003).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Closen, M.L. Deutschman, J. S., “A Proposal to Repeal the Illinois HIV Transmission Statute,” Illinois Bar Journal 78 (1990) 592.; Decker, A. M., Comment, “Criminalizing the Intentional or Reckless Exposure to HIV: A Wake-Up Call to Kansas,” University of Kansas Law Review 46 (1998): 333; Shriver, C.M., “State Approaches to Criminalizing the Exposure of HIV: Problems in Statutory Construction, Constitutionality and Implications,” North Illinois University Law Review 21 (2001): 319.Google Scholar
Bello, C., “Construction and Application of State Statute Governing Impossibility of Consummation as Defense to Prosecution for Attempt to Commit Crime,” American Law Reports 4th 588, 41 no. 588 (1985): 1–17 (updated January 2000).Google Scholar
Cal. Health & Safety Code § 120291 (West 2004).Google Scholar
21 Okla. Stat § 1192.1 (2003).Google Scholar
Kiefer, D., “HIV: When it’s OK to Tell a Lie,” The Examiner, May 15, 2002.Google Scholar
See supra note 4.Google Scholar
Model Penal Code § 2.02 (1990).Google Scholar
See supra note 28.Google Scholar
Colo. Rev. Stat. § 25-4-401 (2003).Google Scholar
Janssen, R.S. Holtgrave, D.R. Valdiserri, R.O. Shepherd, M. Gayle, H.D. De Cock, K.M., Commentary, “The Serostatus Approach to Fighting the HIV Epidemic: Prevention Strategies for Infected Individuals,” American Journal of Public Health 9 (2001): 1019–1024 at 1019.Google Scholar
See supra note 18.Google Scholar
See supra note 28.Google Scholar
See supra note 17.Google Scholar
See supra note 33.Google Scholar
See supra note 24Google Scholar
National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health Department of Health and Human Services, Workshop Summary, “Scientific Evidence on Condom Effectiveness for Sexually Transmitted Disease (STD) Prevention,” June 2001.Google Scholar
See supra note 24.Google Scholar
See supra note 36.Google Scholar
See supra note 17.Google Scholar
La. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 14:43.5 (West 2003)Google Scholar
Mo. Rev. Stat. § 191.677 (2004)Google Scholar
See supra note 32.Google Scholar
Iowa Code § 709C.1 (2004).Google Scholar
N.D. Cent. Code § 12.1-20-17 (2003).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See supra note 33.Google Scholar
See supra note 37.Google Scholar
Ga. Code Ann. § 16-5-60 (2003).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Model Penal Code § 6.06(2) (1990).Google Scholar
Model Penal Code § 6.06(3) (1990).Google Scholar
See supra note 36.Google Scholar
See supra note 54.Google Scholar
See supra note 23.Google Scholar
See supra note 18.Google Scholar
See supra note 28.Google Scholar
Sobo, E.J., “The Psychosocial Benefits of Unsafe Sex,” Choosing Unsafe Sex: AIDS-Risk Denial Among Disadvantaged Women (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2001) at 106–139.Google Scholar