Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T11:45:13.387Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Medical Practice Guidelines as Malpractice Safe Harbors: Illusion or Deceit?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

Maxwell J. Mehlman
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The idea that physicians should accept recommendations from learned colleagues on how to practice medicine is probably as old as medicine itself, but beginning around 1990, it took on new urgency in the face of rising health care costs, widespread, unjustifiable variation in practice patterns, concerns about medical errors and quality of care, and what some perceived to be perverse effects of the malpractice system. One solution put forward was practice guidelines, which the Institute of Medicine (IOM) defined as systematically developed statements to assist practitioner and patient decisions about appropriate health care for specific clinical circumstances.

Type
Independent
Information
Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics , Volume 40 , Issue 2 , Summer 2012 , pp. 286 - 300
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Institute of Medicine, National Academies of Science, Clinical Practice Guidelines: Directions for a New Program, Field, M. J. Lohr, K. N., eds. (Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press, 1990): At 38 (hereinafter cited as 1990 IOM Report).Google Scholar
Havighurst, C. C., “Practice Guidelines for Medical Care: Policy Rationale,” St. Louis University Law Journal 34 (Summer 1990): 777–819, at 783; Hall, M. A., “The Defensive Effect of Medical Practice Policies in Malpractice Litigation,” Law and Contemporary Problems 54, nos. 1–2 (1991): 119–145, at 130.Google Scholar
Id. (Hall), at 131.Google Scholar
Id., at 135.Google Scholar
Id., at 131.Google Scholar
Begel, J., “Maine Physician Practice Guidelines: Implications for Medical Malpractice Litigation,” Maine Law Review 47, Winter (1995): 69–103, at 86.Google Scholar
Id., at 342.Google Scholar
Trail, W. R. Allen, B. A., “Government Created Medical Practice Guidelines: The Opening of Pandora's Box,” Journal of Law & Health 10, no. 2 (1995/1996): 231–258, at 245.Google Scholar
Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 24, 2975(1) (West Supp. 1993–1994).Google Scholar
Rosoff, A. J., “Evidence-Based Medicine and the Law: The Courts Confront Clinical Practice Guidelines,” Journal of Health Politics, Policy, and Law 26, no. 2 (2001): 327–368, at 343.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id., at 340.Google Scholar
See Trail, Allen, , supra note 8, at 244; Hyams, A. L. Shapiro, D. W. Brennan, T. A., “Medical Practice Guidelines in Malpractice Litigation: An Early Retrospective,” Journal of Health Politics, Policy, and Law 21, no. 2 (1996): 289–313, at 307–308.Google Scholar
See Trail, Allen, , supra note 8, at 247.Google Scholar
See Hyams, Shapiro, Brennan, , supra note 12, at 308.Google Scholar
Office of Technology Assessment, Impact of Legal Reforms on Medical Malpractice Costs, 1993, available at <http://www.fas.org/ota/reports/9329.pdf> (last visited April 4, 2012).+(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
See Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 335; Trail, Allen, , supra note 8, at 248.Google Scholar
See Hall, , supra note 2, at 137–138.Google Scholar
Id.; Hyams, Shapiro, Brennan, , supra note 12, at 308–310; Ayres, J. D., “The Use and Abuse of Medical Practice Guidelines,” Journal of Legal Medicine 15, no. 3 (1994): 421–443, at 422.Google Scholar
See Hyams, Shapiro, Brennan, , supra note 12, at 308–310; Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 340.Google Scholar
Todd, J. S., “Only Parameters Will Give MDs Needed Flexibility,” American Medical News, January 6, 1989, at 15.Google Scholar
See Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 343.Google Scholar
See Begel, , supra note 6, at 342.Google Scholar
Id., at 86; see Hyams, Shapiro, Brennan, , supra note 12, at 306–307; Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 343.Google Scholar
See Hall, , supra note 2, at 135.Google Scholar
Kuc, G. W., “Comment: Practice Parameters as a Shield Against Physician Liability,” Journal of Contemporary Health Law & Policy 10, Spring (1994): 439–468, at 441.Google Scholar
See Trail, Allen, , supra note 8, at 245.Google Scholar
See Office of Technology Assessment, supra note 15, at 33.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
See Ayres, , supra note 18, at 429.Google Scholar
See Hall, , supra note 2, at 143.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Id., at 436.Google Scholar
Shaneyfelt, T. M. Mayo-Smith, M. F. Rothwang, J., “Are Guidelines Following Guidelines? The Methodological Quality of Clinical Practice Guidelines in the Peer-Reviewed Medical Literature,” JAMA 281, no. 20 (1999): 1900–1905, at 1904.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id., at 1903–1904.Google Scholar
Shekelle, P. G. Ortiz, E. Rhodes, S. Morton, S. C. Eccles, M. P. Grimshaw, J. M. Woolf, S. H., “Validity of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Clinical Practice Guidelines: How Quickly Do Guidelines Become Outdated?” JAMA 286, no. 12 (2001): 1461–1467, at 1466.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See 1990 IOM Report, supra note 1, at 6.Google Scholar
Id., at 15.Google Scholar
See Hyams, Shapiro, Brennan, , supra note 12, at 309.Google Scholar
Obama's Health Care Speech to Congress, September 9, 2009, available at <http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/10/us/politics/10obama.text.html?pagewanted=1&%2360;!–Undefined%20dynamic%20function%20data_sanitationlib::sanitize_string:1%20called–&%2362;> (last visited April 4, 2012). (last visited April 4, 2012).' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=39+Obama's+Health+Care+Speech+to+Congress,+September+9,+2009,+available+at++(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
Agency for Healthcare Quality and Research, HHS Announces Patient Safety and Medical Liability Demonstration Projects, Press Release, June 11, 2010.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Oregon Masters of Public Health, Field Experience and Internships Opportunities, available at <http://www.oregonmph.org/content/field-experience-internship-opportunities> (last visited April 4, 2012).+(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Weinstein, M. C. Skinner, J. A., “Comparative Effectiveness and Health Care Spending: Implications for Reform,” New England Journal of Medicine 362, no. 5 (2010): 460–465.Google Scholar
H. R. 3590. Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, 111th Cong., 2nd sess. (2010).Google Scholar
Sawka, A. M. Magalhães, L. Gafni, A. Lewis, G. F., “Competing Interests in Development of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Diabetes Management: Report from a Multidisciplinary Workshop,” Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare 2008, no. 1 (2008): 29–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Hall, R. F., “Right Question, Wrong Answer: A Response to Professor Epstein and the ‘Permititis’ Challenge,” Minnesota Law Review Headnotes 94 (Spring 2010): 50–84, at 75.Google Scholar
Keyhani, S. Kim, A. Mann, M. Korenstein, D., “A New Independent Authority Is Needed to Issue National Health Care Guidelines,” Health Affairs 30, no. 2 (2011): 256–265, at 259–260; Sniderman, A. D. Furberg, C. D., “Why Guideline-Making Requires Reform,” JAMA 301, no. 4 (2009): 429–431.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Sniderman, Furberg, , supra note 49, at 430.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id. (emphasis added).Google Scholar
Mendelson, T. B. Meltzer, M. Campbell, E. G. Caplan, A. L. Kirkpatrick, J. N., “Conflicts of Interest in Cardiovascular Clinical Practice Guidelines,” Archives of Internal Medicine 171, no. 6 (2011): 577–584; see Keyhani, et al. , supra note 48; Sniderman, Furberg, , supra note 49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Mendelson, et al. , supra note 52, at 577.Google Scholar
See Sniderman, Furberg, , supra note 49, at 429.Google Scholar
Stolzfus Jost, T., “Oversight of Marketing Relationships between Physicians and the Drug and Device Industry: A Comparative Study,” American Journal of Law & Medicine 36, nos. 2–3 (2010): 326–342, at 327.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Sniderman, Furberg, , supra note 49, at 430.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Mendelson, et al. , supra note 52, at 578.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Id., at 579.Google Scholar
See Sawka, et al. , supra note 46, at 33.Google Scholar
See Jost, , supra note 55, at 332–333.Google Scholar
See Mendelson, et al. , supra note 52, at 578–579.Google Scholar
Ronn, S., “In the Lymelight: Law and Clinical Practice Guidelines,” Southern Medical Journal 102, no. 6 (2009): 626–630, at 627.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id., at 627.Google Scholar
Id., at 628. See also Blumenthal, R., “Conn. Att'y Gen'l: Conflicts of Interest in Treatment Guidelines,” The Day, July 19, 2009, available at <http://www.theday.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090719/OP05/307199960&template> (last visited April 4, 2012). (last visited April 4, 2012).' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=65+Id.,+at+628.+See+also+Blumenthal,+R.,+“Conn.+Att'y+Gen'l:+Conflicts+of+Interest+in+Treatment+Guidelines,”+The+Day,+July+19,+2009,+available+at++(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
See Mendelson, et al. , supra note 52, at 580.Google Scholar
Council of Medical Specialty Societies, Code for Interactions with Companies, available at <http://www.cmss.org/uploadedFiles/Site/CMSS_Policies/CMSS%20Code%20for%20Interactions%20with%20Companies%204-19-10.pdf> (last visited April 4, 2012); Avraham, R., “Clinical Practice Guidelines: The Warped Incentives in the U.S. Healthcare System,” American Journal of Law & Medicine 37, no. 1 (2011): 7–40, at 29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Avraham, , supra note 67, at 29.Google Scholar
See Mendelson, et al. , supra note 52, citing Van Wyck, D. Eckardt, K. U. Uhlig, K. Rocco, M. Levin, A., “Response to 'Influence of Industry on Renal Guideline Development,” Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology 2, no. 1 (2007): 13–14.Google Scholar
Id., at 581.Google Scholar
See Sniderman, Furberg, , supra note 49, at 429.Google Scholar
Id., at 430–431.Google Scholar
Id., at 430.Google Scholar
Tricoci, P. Allen, J. M. Kramer, J. M. Califf, R. M. Smith, S. C. Jr., “Scientific Evidence Underlying the ACC/AHA Clinical Practice Guidelines,” JAMA 301, no. 8 (2009): 831–841, at 832.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id., at 832.Google Scholar
Id., at 831.Google Scholar
Id., at 835.Google Scholar
McAlister, F. A. van Diepen, S. Padwal, R. S. Johnson, J. A. Majumdar, S. R., “How Evidence-Based Are the Recommendations in Evidence-Based Guidelines?” PLoS Medicine 4, no. 8 (2007): E250 at e250.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
IOM, Initial National Priorities for Comparative Effectiveness Research (Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press, 2009): At 30.Google Scholar
See Sawka, et al. , supra note 46, at 33.Google Scholar
See McAlister, et al. , supra note 78, at e250.Google Scholar
Mathews, S. C. Provonost, P. J., “Physician Autonomy and Informed Decision Making: Finding the Right Balance for Patient Safety and Quality,” JAMA 300, no. 24 (2008): 2913–2915, at 2915.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
See McAlister, et al. , supra note 78, at e250.Google Scholar
Chung, K. C. Shauver, M. J., “Crafting Practice Guidelines in the World of Evidence-Based Medicine,” Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 124, no. 4 (2009): 1349–1354, at 1350.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Shaneyfelt, et al. , supra note 33, at 1904. See also Harpole, L. H. Kelley, M. J. Schreiber, G. Toloza, E. M. Kolimaga, J. McCrory, D. C., “Assessment of the Scope and Quality of Clinical Practice Guidelines in Lung Cancer,” Chest 123, Supp. (2003): 7S–20S, at 17S and Hinds, P. S. Gattuso, J. S. Barnwell, E. Cofer, M. Kellum, L. Mattox, S. Norman, G. Powell, B. Randall, E. Sanders, C., “Translating Psychosocial Research Findings into Practice Guidelines,” JONA 33, nos. 7–8 (2003): 397–403 at 397–398.Google Scholar
See Avraham, , supra note 67, at 29.Google Scholar
Lin, G. A. Redberg, R. F. Anderson, H. V. Shaw, R. E. Milford-Beland, S. Peterson, E. D. Rao, S. V. Werner, R. M. Dudley, R. A., “Impact of Changes in Clinical Practice Guidelines on Assessment of Quality of Care,” Medical Care 48, no. 8 (2010): 733–738.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id., at 734.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Harris, J., “Development, Use, and Evaluation of Clinical Practice Guidelines,” Journal Occupational & Environmental Medicine 39, no. 1 (1997): 23–34 (emphasis added); see also Chung, Shauver, , supra note 86; Murphy, R. N., “Legal and Practical Impact of Clinical Practice Guidelines on Nursing and Medical Practice,” Nurse Practitioner 22, no. 3 (1997): 138–148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Howard, P. K., Making Civil Justice Sane, City Journal, April 17, 2006, available at <http://www.city-journal.org/html/16_2_civil_justice.html> (last visited November 12, 2006).+(last+visited+November+12,+2006).>Google Scholar
See Hyams, et al. , supra note 12, at 295.Google Scholar
Id., at 292.Google Scholar
Orient, J. M., “What Healthcare Reform ‘Comparative Effectiveness Research’ Means to You,” Association of American Physicians and Surgeons, December 13, 2010, available at <http://www.aapsonline.org/index.php/article/what_health-care_reform_comparative_effectiveness_research_means_to_you/> (last visited April 4, 2012).+(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
Association of American Physicians and Surgeons, “The Standard of Care,” AAPS Newsletter 62, no. 1 (January 2006), available at <http://www.aapsonline.org/newsletters/jan06.php> (last visited April 4, 2012).+(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
Tzeel, A., “Clinical Practice Guidelines and Medical Malpractice,” Physician Executive 36 (March-April 2002): 36–39 at 38.Google Scholar
See Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 357.Google Scholar
See Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 327.Google Scholar
Id.; Avraham, , supra note 67.Google Scholar
See Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 328.Google Scholar
See Keyhani, et al. , supra note 49, at 262.Google Scholar
See Hall, , supra note 2, at 140.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Keyhani, et al. , supra note 49, at 257.Google Scholar
See Avraham, , supra note 67, at 31.Google Scholar
See Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 328.Google Scholar
See Hall, , supra note 2, at 131.Google Scholar
See Havighurst, , supra note 2, at 789.Google Scholar
Institute of Medicine, “About the IOM,” available at <http://www.iom.edu/About-IOM.aspx> (last visited April 4, 2012).+(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
See Rosoff, , supra note 10, at 344; Begel, , supra note 6, at 93–97. But see Mello, M. M. Chandra, A. Gawande, A. A. Studdert, D. M., “National Costs of the Medical Liability System,” Health Affairs 29, no. 9 (2010): 1569–1577.Google Scholar
Mehlman, M. J. Nance, D. A., Medical Injustice: The Case Against Health Courts (Washington, D.C.: American Association for Justice, 2007): At 7.Google Scholar
See Lin, et al. , supra note 89, at 735–736.Google Scholar
See Mello, , supra note 111, at 660–661, 695, 701.Google Scholar
ABA Model Code of Professional Responsibility, Preliminary Statement, 1983, available at <http://www.law.cornell.edu/ethics/aba/mcpr/MCPR.HTM> (last visited April 4, 2012); ABA Model Rules for Professional Conduct, Preamble and Scope, at [14], available at <http://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/model_rules_of_professional_conduct_preamble_scope.html> (last visited April 4, 2012).+(last+visited+April+4,+2012);+ABA+Model+Rules+for+Professional+Conduct,+Preamble+and+Scope,+at+[14],+available+at++(last+visited+April+4,+2012).>Google Scholar
See Mello, , supra note 111, at 695.Google Scholar