Article contents
Financial Leadership and the Formation of Peruvian Elite Groups, 1884–1930*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 February 2009
Extract
Attempts to find social explanations for Peruvian economic backwardness have focused on the role of the elite's economic leadership between 1884 and 1930. Some of these studies consider the leading social class as an obstacle to economic growth. According to these interpretations the elite had, first of all, traditional ‘aristocratic’ or irrational economic behaviour.1 Secondly, the native elite's collaboration with international capital permitted foreign penetration adverse to national interests.2 Thirdly, in the 1884–1930 period, which was dominated by the export recovery after the War of the Pacific, an over-specialisation in export interests limited the elite's economic diversification, industrial capacity and financial decisions.3
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1988
References
1 Bourricaud, Francois, ‘Notas sobre la oligarquía peruana’, in Bourricaud, et al. , La oligarquía en el Perú (Lima, 1971), p. 30Google Scholar; Burga, Manuel and Galindo, Alberto Flores, Apogeo y crisis de la República Aristocrática (Lima, 1979), pp. 95–96Google Scholar; Amayo, Enrique, ‘Crisis y clase dominante: Perú 1876–1879’, in Reátegui, Wilson et al. , La Guerra del Pacífico (Lima, 1979), vol. 1, pp. 42–43.Google Scholar A similar approach for the Chilean case in Barros, Luis and Vergara, Ximena, El modo de ser aristocrático: el caso de la oligarquía chilena hacia 1900 (Santiago, 1978).Google Scholar
2 Yepes, Ernesto, Perú 1820–1920: un siglo de desarrollo capitalista (Lima, 1972), pp. 158–9Google Scholar; Bresani, Jorge Bravo, ‘Mito y realidad de la oligarquía peruana’, in Bourricaud, , La oligarquía, p. 86.Google ScholarCotler, Julio, Clases, Estado y Nación en el Perú (Lima, 1978), pp. 132, 146Google Scholar; Carbonetto, Daniel, ‘El modelo de acumulación descentrado y dependiente’, in Franco, Carlos et al. , El Perú de Velasco (Lima, 1983), vol. 1, p. 71.Google Scholar
3 Gilbert, Dennis, La oligarquía peruana: historia de tres familias (Lima, 1982), pp. 49–52.Google ScholarBertram, Geoffrey, ‘Development Problems in an Export Economy: A Study of Domestic Capitalists, Foreign Firms and Government in Peru, 1919–1930’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Oxford, 1974), pp. 258–9, 279Google Scholar; Thorp, Rosemary, ‘Endeudamiento o inversión directa: consideraciones a partir del caso peruano’, in Eduardo, Ferrero C. (ed.), El Perú frente al capital extranjero: deuda e inversión (Lima, 1985), p. 33.Google Scholar This third position, the best formulated and researched yet, has opened fundamental avenues of research: the present study owes much to its approach.
4 A 1925 article by J. M. Rodríguez in Economista Peruano; Capuñay, Manuel, Leguía: vida y obra del constructor del gran Perú (Lima, 1951), p. 92.Google Scholar
5 Ugarte, Cesar A., Bosquejo de la historia económica del Perú (Lima, 1926), p. 78.Google Scholar
6 Dunn, W. E., Peru: A Commercial and Industrial Handbook (Washington, D.C., 1925), pp. 21–2.Google Scholar
7 Bourricaud, François, Power and Society in Contemporary Peru (New York, 1970)Google Scholar; Bourricaud et al., La oligarquia; Malpica, Carlos, Los dueños del Perú, 11th ed. (Lima, 1980).Google Scholar For methodological criticisms of these interpretations see Valderrama, Mariano and Ludman, Patricia, La oligarquía terrateniente: ayer y hoy (Lima, 1979), pp. 3–14.Google Scholar
8 See the works of Maushammer, Miller, Albert, Gilbert, Thorp and Bertram cited below.
9 Leff, Nathaniel, Underdevelopment and Development in Brazil (London, 1982), vol. 2, chap. 3Google Scholar; Fritsh, Winston, ‘Aspects of Brazilian Economic Policy Under the First Republic’ (Ph.D. thesis: University of Cambridge, 1983), p. 253.Google Scholar
10 Dulanto, Abraham Rodríguez, ‘La agricultura nacional’, Revista Universitaria, vol. 2, no. 9 (1907), p. 5Google Scholar; Salomón, Alberto, ‘El desarrollo económico del Perú’, Revista Universitaria, vol. 13 (1918).Google Scholar Both were influential University of San Marcos professors in the faculty of Political and Economic Sciences and later finance ministers of different administrations.
11 Economista Peruano, vol. 2, no. 36 (1912).Google Scholar
12 Payán, José, ‘Les hypothèques au Pérou: leur développement’, typescript: Paris, 8 07 1911Google Scholar, Crédit Foncier Peruvien in Banco del Perú y Londres Papers, Superintendencia de Banca y Seguros, Sección Liquidaciones, Lima (hereafter BPLS).
13 Calderón, Francisco García, Le Pérou Contemporain (Paris, 1907), pp. 272–89, 324–9.Google Scholar
14 Villarán, Manuel Vicente, ‘Condición legal de las comunidades indígenas’, Revista Universitaria, vol. 2, no. 14 (1907), p. 3.Google Scholar
15 Lisson, Carlos, Breves apuntes sobre la sociología del Perú en 1886 (Lima, 1887)Google Scholar, a publication financed by Manuel Candamo and Ignacio de Osma.
16 Fuentes, Hildebrando, ‘Política financiera del Perú’, Anales Universitarios, vol. 26 (1899), p. 5.Google ScholarCapuñay, , Leguía, p. 71.Google Scholar
17 Economista Peruana, vol. 4, no. 35 (1912).Google Scholar
18 Cited in René, Hooper L., Leguía: ensayo biográfico (Lima, 1964), p. 54.Google Scholar
19 Garland, Alejandro, ‘La nueva política internacional sudamericana’ (1906?)Google Scholar, cited in Salomón, , ‘Desarrollo económico’, p. 350.Google Scholar
20 Villarán, Manuel Vicente, Las profesiones liberales en el Perú (Lima, 1900)Google Scholar, cited in Salomón, , ‘Desarrollo económico’, p. 356.Google Scholar On tasks for economic autonomy: Calderón, Francisco García, Latin America: its Rise and Progress (London, 1913), pp. 383–5.Google Scholar
21 Thorp, Rosemary and Bertram, Geoffrey, Peru 1890–1977: Growth and Policy in an Open Economy (New York, 1978), pp. 26–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bollinger, William, ‘The Rise of U.S. Influence in the Peruvian Economy, 1869–1921’ (M.A. thesis, UCLA. 1971), pp. 79–81.Google Scholar
22 Quiroz, Alfonso W., ‘Financial Institutions in Peruvian Export Economy and Society, 1884–1930’ (Ph.D. thesis, Columbia University, 1986), pp. 71, 361–3Google Scholar; Albert, Bill, ‘An Essay on the Peruvian Sugar Industry 1880–1920’ (Norwich, Norfolk, 1976), p. 140a.Google Scholar
23 Maushammer, , ‘Investor Groups, Informal Finance and the Economic Development of Peru’ (Ph.D. thesis, Wisconsin University, 1970), pp. 166, 199.Google Scholar
24 Balmori, Diana, Voss, Stuart and Wortman, Miles, Notable Family Networks in Latin America (Chicago, 1984).Google Scholar
25 Leff, Nathaniel, ‘Industrial Organization and Entrepreneurship in the Developing Countries: the Economic Groups’, Economic Development and Cultural Change 26 (1978), pp. 664–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Chapman, S. D., ‘British-Based Investment Groups Before 1914’, Economic History Review, vol. 38 (1985), pp. 230–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
26 Klein, Herbert, ‘The Creation of the Patiño Tin Empire’, Inter-American Economic Affairs, vol. 9 (1965), p. 22.Google Scholar
27 Galindo, Alberto Flores et al. , ‘Oligarquía y capital comercial en el sur peruano (1870–1930)’, Debates en sociología 3 (1978), p. 54Google Scholar; Miller, Rory, ‘The Coastal Elite and Peruvian Politics, 1895–1919’, Journal of Latin American Studies, vol. 8 (1976), p. 101.Google Scholar
28 Maushammer, , ‘Investor Groups’, p. 299.Google Scholar Family groups such as: Ayulo, Pardo, Nicolini, Gildemeister, Cillóniz, Aspíllaga, Beltrán and others.
29 Chavarría, Jesús, ‘La desaparición del Perú colonial (1870–1919)’, Aportes 23 (1972), pp. 120–53.Google Scholar On modern changes dating from the 1850s see works by Gootenberg and Quiroz cited below.
30 Gootenberg, Paul, ‘Merchants, Foreigners and the State: the Origins of Trade Policies in Post-Independence Peru’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Chicago, 1985), ch. 5.Google Scholar
31 Quiroz, Alfonso W., La deuda defraudada (Lima, 1987), chs. 6–7Google Scholar; Engelsen, Juan R., ‘Social Aspects of Agricultural Expansion in Coastal Peru, 1825–1878’ (Ph.D. diss., UCLA, 1977), pp. 24–6.Google Scholar
32 Gootenberg, Paul, ‘Artisans and Merchants: the Making of an Open Economy in Lima, Peru, 1830 to 1860’ (M.Phil, University of Oxford, 1981), ch. 5Google Scholar; Bonilla, Heraclio, Guano y burguesía en el Perú (Lima, 1974), pp. 48–50Google Scholar; Yepes, , Perú, pp. 87–91Google Scholar
33 Alcázar, Carlos Camprubí, Historia de los bancos en el Perú (1860–1879) (Lima, 1957), p. 252Google Scholar; Greenhill, Robert G. and Miller, Rory M., ‘The Peruvian Government and the Nitrate Trade, 1873–1879’, Journal of Latin American Studies, vol. 5 (1973), pp. 107–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
34 Quiroz, Alfonso W., ‘Las actividades comerciales y financieras de la Casa Grace y la Guerra del Pacífico, 1879–1890’ Histórica, vol. 7 (1983), pp. 214–54Google Scholar; Miller, Rory, ‘The Making of the Grace Contract: British Bondholders and the Peruvian Government, 1885–1890’, Journal of Latin American Studies, vol. 8 (1976), pp. 73–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
35 Alcázar, Carlos Camprubí, José Payány de Reina (1844–1919): su trayectoria peruana (Lima, 1967), pp. 62–4Google Scholar; Quiroz, , ‘Actividades comerciales’, pp. 241–9Google Scholar; Miller, Rory, ‘The Grace Contract, the Peruvian Corporation, and Peruvian History’, Ibero-Amerikanisches Archiv, vol. 9 (1983), pp. 319–348.Google Scholar
36 Quiroz, , ‘Financial Institutions’, pp. 66–74.Google Scholar
37 Chaplin, David, The Peruvian Industrial Labor Force (Princeton, 1967), pp. 99–100.Google Scholar
38 Gastón, Enrique Ramírez, Muelle y Dársena del Callao: refutación del contrato de privilegio por 50 años (Lima, 1886)Google Scholar; Mayer, Dora, La conducta de la compañía minera Cerro de Pasco (Callao, 1914)Google Scholar; Hobson, J. A., Imperialism: A Study (London, 1902).Google Scholar
39 Chandler, Alfred D., The Visible Hand: the Managerial Revolution in American Business (Cambridge, Mass., 1972).Google Scholar
40 Correspondence between directors of the Grace Co. and Peruvian businessmen (Payán, Prado, Falcón, Llaguno), W. R. Grace & Co. Papers, Columbia University, Manuscript Collections.
41 Peru, , de Senadores, Cámara, Diario de los debates del Congreso Ordinario de 1899 (Lima, 1897), 5 09 1889 session, pp. 237–8.Google Scholar
42 Londres, Perú y, Juntas de Accionistas, 1900–1914, BPLS.Google Scholar
43 Pardo, José, Perú: cuatro años de gobierno constitucional (New York, 1919)Google Scholar; Capuñay, Manuel, Leguía: Vida y obra del constructor del gran Perú (Lima, 1937) pp. 33–4Google Scholar; Cisneros, A. Ulloa, Leguía: apuntes de cartera (Lima, 1933).Google Scholar
44 ‘Solicitudes para guía de remisión de barras de plata al tesorero del gremio de mineros (12 mineros)’, Hacienda, year 1890, O.L. 591–607Google Scholar, Archivo General de la Nación, Lima (hereafter AGN); Moreno, Federico, El petróleo bajo el punto de vista industrial (Lima, 1891).Google Scholar
45 ‘Memoria del Presidente [Isaac Alzamora] de la Empresa Socavonera del Cerro de Pasco’ (including stockholders list of 71 members), La Gaceta Comercial, vol. 6 (1906), no. 127, p. 1213.Google Scholar
46 Kruijt, Dirk and Vellinga, Menno, Labor Relations and Multinational Corporations: the Cerro de Pasco Corporation in Peru (1902–1974) (Assen, 1979), pp. 44–5.Google Scholar
47 ‘Cuadro de las empresas organizadas dentro y fuera del Perú y establecidas en el país durante el decenio. 1886–1896’, El Economista, vol. 2–(1897), no. 69, pp. 263–4Google Scholar; Sayapullo, Campañía Minera, Memoria y balance anual, 1908–1911.Google Scholar
48 The following treatment of the Riva Agüero-Osma family is based on manuscript data from the uncatalogued section (Papeles Varios) of the Archivo Histórico Riva Agüero, Lima.
49 de Osma, Mariano, Causa de mi encarcelamiento: mis cuestiones ante los tribunales … (Lima, 1868?)Google Scholar; Cuestión célebre de la Hacienda Naranjal … (Lima, 1876?).Google Scholar
50 Londres, Perú y, Directorio, vol. 2, 17 07 1919Google Scholar, BPLS.
51 Gilbert, , Oligarquía peruana, p. 121.Google Scholar
52 Londres, Perú y, Directorio, vol. 1, 24 04 1899; vol. 2, 15 10 1900 and 4 03 1901; vol. 14, 14 02 1924Google Scholar, BPLS; on the background of the Carrillo de Albornoz family see Quiroz, Deuda defraudada, ch. 6.
53 A. B. Leguía to British minister, Lima 16 Jan. 1895, F.O. 61, no. 409, Public Record Office, London.
54 Hooper, , Leguía, pp. 24–5.Google Scholar
55 Hooper, , Leguía, p. 25.Google Scholar
56 Tribunal de Sanción Nacional, legs. 517, 519, AGN. On proven bribe taking by Juan Leguía, the president's son, from American representatives of the Seligman loans, according to U.S. congressional hearings see Basadre, Jorge, Historia de la República del Perú, 5th ed. (Lima, 1964), vol. 9, p. 4119.Google Scholar
57 Administrators Leguía, A. B., deceased, ‘Accounts of Receipts and Payments’, 28 02, 1955, Frederick Huth & Co. Papers, ms. 10.706/2, Guildhall Library, London.Google Scholar
58 Londres, Callao/Perú y, Directorio; Accionistas (1884–1930), BPLS.Google Scholar
59 Mallon, Florencia, The Defense of Community in Peru's Central Highlands (Princeton, 1983), pp. 174–5.Google Scholar
60 Quiroz, , ‘Financial Institutions’, p. 111.Google Scholar
61 Gilbert, Oligarquía peruana, ch. 4.
62 Mallon, , Defense of Community, p. 273.Google Scholar
63 Loan of £36,000 to the de Bellavista, Molineros: Callao, , Directorio, vol. 1, 10 01 1888Google Scholar, BPLS; Bardella, Gianfranco, Setenta y cinco años de vida económica del Perú, 1889–1964 (Milan, 1964), p. 90Google Scholar; Italiano, Banco, Memoria, years 1926–1931.Google Scholar
64 Pedro Larrañaga (urban investments and politics); Gio Batta Isola (trade and industry); Elías Mujica, Manuel Mujica y Carassa, Eulogio Fernandini, Alfredo Benavides (mining). Castillo, Rubén and Vásquez, Diógenes, Los banqueros y financistas peruanos vistos por dentro (Lima, 1937).Google Scholar
65 Gilbert, James, ‘Condiciones para ser banquero’ in La Gaceta Comercial, vol. 4 (1906), no. 127, p. 1189.Google Scholar
66 Montoya, Rodrigo, Capitalismo y no capitalismo en el Perú (Lima, 1980), pp. 95–7.Google Scholar
67 Bertram, Geoffrey, ‘Modernización y cambio en la industria lanera del Perú 1919/1930: un caso frustrado de desarrollo’ Apuntes, vol. 6 (1977), pp. 3–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar, which shows the tension between modernising landowners, the foreign railway firm, local merchants and traditional Indian alpaca herdsmen in Puno.
68 Londres, Perú y, Accionistas, 31 01 1929.Google Scholar
69 Beneficencia Italiana, Club Italiano, Circolo Sportivo Italiano.
70 Worral, Janet, ‘Italian Immigration to Peru: 1860–1914’ (Ph.D. thesis: Indiana University, 1972), p. 216Google Scholar; Segui, Emilio and Calcagnoli, Enrico, La vita italianna nella Repubblica del Peru (Lima, 1915?)Google Scholar; de Lima per la Esposizione de Milano, Comitato, L'Italia al Peru: ressegna della vita e dell'opera italianna nel Peru (Lima, 1905–1906)Google Scholar; Banco Italiano, Lima: 1889–1939 (Lima, 1939).Google Scholar
71 Herbold, Carl F., ‘Developments in the Peruvian Administrative System, 1919–1939’ (Ph.D. thesis, Yale University, 1973), pp. 81–2, 88Google Scholar; Carlos, Capuñay M., ‘El Perú financiero de 1919 a 1924’, La Nueva Economía, vol. 10, no. 109 (1944), p. 17.Google Scholar
72 Bertram, Geoffrey, ‘Development Problems’, pp. 6, 258–9, 279, 365.Google Scholar
73 U.S. Department of State 823.154/10, Microcopy 746, roll no. 10, US National Archives, Washington D.C. (hereafter USNA).
74 de Banca, Superintendencia, Banco del Perú y Londres en Liquidación: Memoria anual (Lima, 1931), p. 17.Google Scholar
75 Department of State 823.154/20, Microcopy 746, roll no. 10, USNA.
76 Department of State 823.5611, Microcopy 746, roll no. 27, USNA.
77 On charges of corruption of Leguía's administration, see Bertram, , ‘Development Problems’, pp. 51–2Google Scholar, and Thorp, Rosemary and Londoño, Carlos, ‘El efecto de la Gran Depresión de 1929 en las economías de Perú y Colombia’, HISLA, vol. 3 (1984), pp. 52–4.Google Scholar Also Basadre, Jorge, ‘Leguía y el leguiísmo’, in Primer panorama de ensayistas peruanos (Lima, 1978), p. 135.Google Scholar
78 Wils, Frits, Industrialization, Industrialists and the Nation-State in Peru (Berkeley, 1979), p. 24.Google Scholar
- 7
- Cited by