Published online by Cambridge University Press: 18 February 2013
This study focuses on disputes among Dutch Calvinists (Reformed Protestants) in Asia and in Europe over how to administer the sacraments of baptism and communion to people with little or no exposure to Protestant Christianity. Historians have tended to view these conflicts as evidence of Calvinist rigidity and the incompatibility between Protestantism and non-European societies. When examined within global patterns of Christianization, however, it becomes clear that Calvinists had much in common with Roman Catholic missionaries in trying to convert people across cultural borders. All missionaries had to negotiate the inherent tensions between accommodation and orthodoxy in early modern missionary programmes. Many Calvinists on the missionary frontier, like their Catholic counterparts, opted for syncretistic strategies over objections from authorities in their religious heartland.
The author would like to thank Gerrit Schutte, James Tracy, and the editors of this journal for their helpful comments and suggestions.
1 Boxer, C. R., The Dutch seaborne empire, London: Penguin, 1965, pp. 149–150Google Scholar
2 Furber, Holden, Rival empires of trade in the orient, 1600–1800, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1976, pp. 325–327Google Scholar
Taylor, Jean Gelman, The social world of Batavia: European and Eurasian in Dutch Asia, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 1983, pp. 21–23Google Scholar
Ricklefs, M. C., War, culture, and economy in Java, 1677–1726: Asian and European imperialism in the early Kartasura period, Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1993, pp. 3–15Google Scholar
Joosse, L. J., ‘Scoone dingen sijn swaere dingen’: een onderzoek naar de motieven en activiteiten in de Nederlanden tot verbreiding van de Gereformeerde religie gedurende de eerste helft van de zeventiende eeuw (‘Beautiful things are difficult things’: an inquiry into the motives and activities in the Netherlands for the propagation of the Reformed religion in the first half of the seventeenth century), Leiden: Groen en Zoon heerenveen, 1992, pp. 58–59Google Scholar
Bertrand, Romain, L'histoire à parts égales: récits d’une rencontre orient–occident (XVIe–XVIIe siècle), Paris: Éditions du Seuil, 2011, pp. 232–233Google Scholar
3 Taylor, Jean Gelman, The social world of Batavia: Europeans and Eurasians in colonial Indonesia, 2nd edn, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 2009, p. 22Google Scholar
4 Axtell, James, The invasion within: the contest of cultures in colonial north America, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985, pp. 131–178Google Scholar
5 Salisbury, Neal, ‘Red Puritans: the “praying Indians” of Massachusetts Bay and John Eliot’, in Roger L. Nichols, ed., The American Indian: past and present, New York: Knopf, 1986, pp. 73–88Google Scholar
Strong, Rowan, Anglicanism and the British empire, c.1700–1850, New York: Oxford University Press, 2007, pp. 4–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nelson, E. Clifford, Lutherans in North America, Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1980, pp. 72Google Scholar
Mason, J. C. S., The Moravian Church and the missionary awakening in England, 1760–1800, Woodbridge: Boydell & Brewer Ltd, 2001, pp. 5–27Google Scholar
6 Niemejer, H. E., Calvinisme en koloniale stadscultuur: Batavia 1619–1725 (Calvinism and colonial urban culture: Batavia 1619–1725), Amsterdam: Academisch Proefschrift, 1996, p. 213Google Scholar
Niemeijer, H. E., Batavia: een koloniale samenleving in de zeventiende eeuw (Batavia: a colonial society in the seventeenth century), Amsterdam: Balans, 2005Google Scholar
7 Schutte, G. J., ‘De kerk onder de compagnie (The church under the company)’, in G. J. Schutte, ed., Het Indisch Sion: de Gereformeerde kerk onder de Verenigde Oost-Indische Compagnie (The Indies Zion: the Reformed Church under the Dutch East India Company), Hilversum: Verloren, 2002, pp. 48–54Google Scholar
8 Burke, Peter, Cultural hybridity, Cambridge: Polity Press, 2009, pp. 9–11Google Scholar
Ditchfield, Simon, ‘Decentering the Catholic reformation: papacy and peoples in the early modern world’, Archiv für Reformationsgeschichte (Archive for Reformation History), 101, 2010, pp. 186–208Google Scholar
9 Zürcher, Erik, ‘Jesuit accommodation and the Chinese cultural imperative’, in D. E. Mungello, ed., The Chinese rites controversy: its history and meaning, Sankt Augustin: Institut Monumenta Serica and The Ricci Institute for Chinese Western Cultural History, 1994, pp. 31–64Google Scholar
Hsia, R. Po-chia, The world of Catholic renewal, 1540–1770, New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998, pp. 166–167Google Scholar
Thornton, John, ‘The development of an African Catholic Church in the kingdom of Kongo, 1491–1750’, Journal of African History, 25, 1984, pp. 151–160CrossRefGoogle Scholar
10 Leavelle, Tracy Neal, The Catholic calumet: colonial conversions in French and Indian North America, Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2012, p. 8Google Scholar
11 Bosma, Ulbe and Raben, Remco, Being ‘Dutch’ in the Indies: a history of creolisation and empire, 1500–1920, trans. Wendie Shaffer, Athens, OH: Ohio University Press, 2008, pp. 26–50Google Scholar
Hsin-hui, Chiu, The colonial ‘civilizing process’ in Dutch Formosa, 1624–1668, Leiden: E. J. Brill, 2008, pp. 197–198Google Scholar
Shepherd, John R., Statecraft and political economy on the Taiwan frontier 1600–1800, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1993, p. 66Google Scholar
Meuwese, Mark, ‘Dutch Calvinism and Native Americans: a comparative study of the motivations for Protestant conversion among the Tupís in northeastern Brazil (1630–1654) and the Mohawks in central New York (1690–1710)’, in James Muldoon, ed., The spiritual conversion of the Americas, Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida, 2004, p. 119Google Scholar
12 Nagtegall, L. W., Riding the Dutch tiger: the Dutch East Indies Company and the northeast coast of Java, 1680–1743, trans. Beverley Jackson, Leiden: KITLV Press, 1996, pp. 142–170Google Scholar
Blussé, Leonard, Rivalry and conflict: European traders and Asian trading networks in the 16th and 17th centuries, Leiden: CNWS Publications, 2005, pp. 78–82Google Scholar
13 Hsin-hui, Dutch Formosa, p. 198Google Scholar
C. W. T. Baron van Boetzelaer van Asperen en Dubbledam, ‘Correspondentie van Ds. Adriaan Jacobszoon Hulsebos (Correspondence of Adriaan Jacobszoon Hulsebos)’, Nederlandsch archief voor kerkgeschiedenis (Dutch Archive for Church History), 33, 1943, pp. 1–11Google Scholar
14 Dubbledam, ‘Hulsebos’, p. 21Google Scholar
15 Dubbeldam, ‘Hulsebos’, p. 22Google Scholar
16 Arasaratnam, S., Ceylon and the Dutch, 1600–1800: external influences and internal change in early modern Sri Lanka, Aldershot: Variorum, 1996, p. 32Google Scholar
Hsin-hui, Dutch Formosa, p. 198Google Scholar
Niemejer, Calvinisme, p. 187Google Scholar
17 Niemeijer, Calvinisme en koloniale stadscultuur, pp. 184–187Google Scholar
18 Niemeijer, H. E., ‘Orang Nasrani: protestants Ambon in de zeventiende eeuw (Followers of the Nazarene: protestant Ambon in the seventeenth century)’, in Schutte, Indisch Sion, pp. 129–135Google Scholar
Niemeijer, H. E., ‘Agama kumpeni? Ternate en de protestantisering van de noord-Molukken en noord-Sulawesi 1627–1795 (The religion of the company? Ternate and the protestantization of the north Moluccas and north Sulawesi 1627–1795)’, in ibid., pp. 147–176Google Scholar
19 Kuepers, J. J. A. M., The Dutch Reformed Church in Formosa 1627–1662: mission in a colonial context, Immensee: Neue Zeitschrift für Missionswissenschaft, 1978, p. 21Google Scholar
20 SA 379, no. 184, Oost-Indien, 17 March 1622.
21 Dubbeldam, ‘Hulsebos’, p. 16Google Scholar
22 Ibid., p. 40 (undated, after 19 December 1618 and before 1 July 1619).
23 SA 379, no. 184, Oost-Indien, 23 and 24 January 1625.
24 J. N. Bakhuizen van den Brink ed., De Nederlandse belijdenisgeschriften (The Dutch confessions), Amsterdam: Ton Bolland, 1976, p. 132Google Scholar
25 Berkhof, Louis, Systematic theology, Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 1996, pp. 641–642Google Scholar
26 Van den Brink, Nederlandse belijdenisgeschriften, p. 134Google Scholar
Parker, Charles H., ‘The moral agency and moral autonomy of church folk in post-reformation Delft, 1520–1620’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 48, 1997, p. 44CrossRefGoogle Scholar
27 SA 379, no. 184, Oost-Indien, 20 August 1624.
28 Hsia, World of Catholic renewal, pp. 165–177Google Scholar
29 SA 379, no. 184, Oost-Indien, 24 April 1622.
30 Ibid., 9 August 1622.
31 Ibid., 20 August 1624.
32 Ibid., 10 April 1624.
33 Schutte, Gerrit J., ‘Between Amsterdam and Batavia: Cape society and the Calvinist Church under the Dutch East India Company’, Kronos: Journal of Cape Society, 25, 1998/99, p. 35Google Scholar
34 SA 379, no. 185, Oost-Indien, 22 August 1645.
35 J. N. Bakhuizen van den Brink ed., De Nederlandsche belijdenisgeschriften: vergelijkende teksten (The Dutch confessions: comparative texts), Amsterdam: Uitgeversmaatschappij Holland, 1940, p. 252Google Scholar
36 Dubbeldam, ‘Hulsebos’, p. 79Google Scholar
Haafner, Jacob, Onderzoek naar het nut der zendelingn en zendeling-genootschappen (Inquiry into the profit of missionaries and missionary societies), Haarlem: Joh. Enschede en Zoonen en J. van Walré, 1807, p. 199Google Scholar
37 SA 379, no. 184, Oost-Indien, 5 February 1624.
38 SA 379, no. 163, Amsterdam classis, 8 June 1636 and 14 December 1643.
39 SA 379, no. 165, Amsterdam classis, 30 May 1661.
40 SA, 379, no. 201 Ceylon, 29 December 1684 and 19 January 1689.
41 SA 379, no. 185, Oost-Indien, 9 June 1651; no. 164, Amsterdam classis, 7 August 1651. See also SA 379, no. 185, Oost-Indien, 7 October 1650; no. 165, Amsterdam classis, 30 May 1661.
42 NA, VOC, no. 11160, 16 November 1722 and 6 November 1726.
43 SA 379, no. 186, Oost-Indien, 26 August 1667 and 31 January 1670.
44 SA 379, no. 165, Amsterdam classis, 4 September 1679.
45 Niemejer, Calvinisme, p. 173Google Scholar
46 See NA, VOC, no. 11162, passim.
47 Ibid., ‘Extract uijt de notulen van't gebesoigneerde en geresolveerde in Rade van India (Excerpt from the minutes of the acts and resolutions in the Council of India)’, 1 July 1730.
48 Enklaar, I. H., Pembaptisan massal & pemisahan sakramen: de scheiding der sacramenten op het zendingsveld (Mass baptism & separation of the sacraments: division of the sacraments in the mission field), Jakarta: Gunung Mulia, 2003, p. 48Google Scholar
Joosse, L. J., ‘Kerk en zendingsbevel (The church and the Great Commission)’, in Schutte, Indisch Sion, pp. 39–40Google Scholar
Schutte, ‘Between Amsterdam and Batavia’, pp. 33–39Google Scholar
49 Chijs, Plakaatboek, vol. 4, pp. 374–377Google Scholar
50 NA, VOC, no. 11160, 27 November 1697 and 15 October 1698; no. 11162, 15 December 1724.
51 Mooij, J., Bouwstoffen voor de geschiedenis der protestantsche kerk in Nederlandsche Indië (Sources for the history of the Protestant church in the Dutch Indies), 3 vols., Batavia: Weltevreden, 1927, vol. 3, pp. 281–282Google Scholar
52 Blussé, Leonard, Strange company: Chinese settlers, mestizo women and the Dutch in VOC Batavia, Leiden: KITLV Press, 1986, pp. 166–167Google Scholar
53 SA 379, no. 185, Oost-Indien, 4 January 1653.
54 NA, VOC, no. 11160, 18 August 1730; SA 379, no. 201, Ceylon, 29 December 1684.
55 Mooij, Bouwstoffen, vol. 2, p. 86Google Scholar
56 Bosma and Raben, Being ‘Dutch’, pp. 34–35Google Scholar
Blussé, Strange company, pp. 159–162Google Scholar
57 Dumonceaux, Pierre, ‘Conversion, convertir: étude comparative d'après les lexographies du XVIIe siècle’, in Roger Duchêne, ed., Conversion au XVIIe siècle: actes du XIIe colloque de Marseille, Marseilles: Centre méridionale de rencontres du XVIIe siècle, 1983, pp. 7–17Google Scholar
Luria, Keith P., ‘Rituals of conversion: Catholics and Protestants in seventeenth-century Poitou’, in Barbara Diefendorf and Carla Hesse, eds., Culture and identity in early modern Europe (1500–1800): essays in honor of Natalie Zemon Davis, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 1993, p. 73Google Scholar
Morrison, Karl F., Understanding conversion, Charlottesville, VA: University Press of Virginia, 1992, pp. 185–186Google Scholar
58 Greer, Allan, ‘Conversion and identity: Iroquois Christianity in seventeenth-century New France’, in Kenneth Mills and Anthony Grafton, eds., Conversion: old worlds and new, Rochester, NY: University of Rochester Press, 2003, p. 177Google Scholar
59 Hsia, R. Po-Chia, ‘Translating Christianity: Counter-Reformation Europe and the Catholic mission in China, 1580–1780’, in Mills and Grafton, Conversion, p. 88Google Scholar
Županov, Ines, ‘Twisting a pagan tongue: Portuguese and Tamil in sixteenth-century Jesuit translations’, in ibid., p. 110Google Scholar
Gose, Peter, ‘Converting the ancestors: indirect rule, colonial settlement consolidation, and the struggle over burial in colonial Peru’, in ibid., pp. 140–143Google Scholar
60 NA, VOC, no. 11160, 18 November 1706, 1 December 1708, and 9 December 1711; SA 379, no. 201, Ceylon, 29 December 1684.
61 NA, VOC, no. 11162, 1 July 1730.
62 SA 379, no. 201, Ceylon, 11 September 1690.
63 Arasaratnam, S., Ceylon and the Dutch, 1600–1800: external influences and internal change in early modern Sri Lanka, Aldershot: Variorum, 1996, p. 32Google Scholar
64 Mooij, Bouwstoffen, vol. 2, p. 86Google Scholar
65 F. A. van Lieburg, ‘Het personeel van de Indische kerk: een quantitative benadering (The personnel of the Indies Church: a quantitative approximation)’, in Schutte, Indisch Sion, p. 73Google Scholar
Meuwese, ‘Dutch Calvinism and Native Americans’, in Muldoon, Spiritual conversion, p. 123Google Scholar
66 Hsia, World of Catholic renewal, pp. 167–168Google Scholar
67 Ricklefs, M. C., Mystic synthesis in Java: a history of Islamization from the fourteenth to the early nineteenth centuries, Norwalk, CT: Eastbridge, 2006, pp. 11–22Google Scholar
68 Royal Netherlands Institute of Southeast Asian and Caribbean Studies (KITLV), H216, 20 November 1719.
69 Hoornbeek, Johannis, De conversione indorum et gentilium libri duo (On the conversion of the Indians and gentiles in two books), Amsterdam: Johannem Janssonium, 1669, pp. 11–15Google Scholar
70 Baldaeus, Philippus, Nauwkeurige en waarachtige ontdekking en wederlegginge van de afgoderye der Oost-Indische heydenen (Accurate and true discovery and refutation of the idolatry of the East Indies heathens), Amsterdam: Janssonius van Waasberge en Johannes van Someren, 1672, pp. 55Google Scholar
71 Spierling, Karen E., Infant baptism in reformation Geneva: the shaping of a community, 1536–1564, Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 2009, pp. 31–59Google Scholar
Eire, Carlos M. N., War against the idols: the reformation of worship from Erasmus to Calvin, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986, pp. 1–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davis, Natalie Zemon, ‘The rites of violence’, in Society and culture in early modern France, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1975, p. 174Google Scholar
72 Burkhart, Louise M., The slippery earth: Nahua–Christian moral dialogue in sixteenth-century Mexico, Tuscon, AZ: University of Arizona Press, 1989, pp. 20Google Scholar
73 Hsia, Catholic renewal, p. 173Google Scholar
Poole, Stafford, ‘Some observations on mission methods and native reactions in sixteenth-century New Spain’, in Tanya Storch, ed., Religions and missionaries around the Pacific, 1500–1900, vol. 17, The Pacific world: lands, peoples, and history of the Pacific, 1500–1900, Aldershot: Variorum, 2006, pp. 94–100Google Scholar
74 Caraman, Philip, The lost paradise: an account of the Jesuits in Paraguay 1607–1768, London: Sidgwick and Jackson, 1975, pp. 212–234Google Scholar
75 Thornton, ‘African Catholic Church’, pp. 151–160Google Scholar
76 Phelan, John L., ‘Pre-baptismal instruction and the administration of baptism in the Philippines during the sixteenth century’, in Gerald H. Anderson, ed., Studies in Philippine church history, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1969, pp. 35Google Scholar
77 Phelan, John Leddy, The hispanization of the Philippines: Spanish aims and Filipino responses 1565–1700, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 1959, pp. 55Google Scholar
Rafael, Vicente L., Contracting colonialism: translation and Christian conversion in Tagalog society under early Spanish rule, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1988, pp. 185–209Google Scholar
78 Spence, Jonathan D., ‘Claims and counter-claims: the Kangxi emperor and the Europeans (1661–1722)’ in Mungello, Chinese rites controversy, p. 17Google Scholar
79 Clercq, Chrestien Le, Premier établissement de la foy dans la nouvelle France, 2 vols., Paris: Amarle Auroy, 1691, vol. 1, pp. 547–548Google Scholar
80 Axtell, Invasion within, pp. 50–53Google Scholar
George Minamiki, SJ, The Chinese rites controversy from its beginnings to modern times, Chicago, IL: Loyola University Press, 1985, pp. 23–24Google Scholar
81 Nicolo Longobardi, SJ, Traité sur quelques points de la religion des Chinois, Paris: Jacques Josse, 1701, p. 84Google Scholar
82 Mooij, Bouwstuffen, vol. 2, p. 86Google Scholar
83 Mills, Kenneth, Idolatry and its enemies: colonial Andean religion and extirpation 1640–1750, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1997, pp. 3–15Google Scholar
Gose, ‘Converting the ancestors’, pp. 144–147Google Scholar
84 Knight, Alan, Mexico: the colonial era, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002, pp. 33–34Google Scholar
85 Clendinnen, Inga, Ambivalent conquests: Maya and Spaniard in Yucatan, 1517–1570, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987, pp. 72–76Google Scholar
Liss, Peggy, Mexico under Spain, 1521–1556: society and origins of nationality, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1975, pp. 80–82Google Scholar
Lockhart, James, The Nahuas after the conquest: a social and cultural history of the Indians of central Mexico, sixteenth through eighteenth centuries, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1992, pp. 235–260Google Scholar
86 Knight, Mexico, p. 51Google Scholar
87 Hsia, Catholic renewal, p. 169Google Scholar
88 Phelan, Hispanization, pp. 56Google Scholar
Rafael, Contracting colonialism, pp. 79–80Google Scholar
89 Anthoine de Saint Marie, OFM, Traité sur quelques points importans de la mission de la Chine, Paris: Jacques Josse, 1701, pp. 8–11Google Scholar
90 Minamiki, Chinese rites controversy, p. 37Google Scholar
Claudia von Collani, ‘Charles Maigrot's role in the Chinese rites controversy’, in Mungello, Chinese rites controversy, pp. 149–156Google Scholar
Jr, John E. Wills, ‘From Manila to Fuan: Asian contexts of Dominican mission policy’, in ibid., pp. 123–124Google Scholar
91 Mungello, D. E., ‘An introduction to the Chinese rites controversy’, in Mungello, Chinese rites controversy, pp. 3–4Google Scholar
Mungello, D. E., The great encounter of China and the West, 1500–1800, Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, 2005, p. 52Google Scholar
92 Treadgold, Donald W., The West in Russia and China: religious and secular thought in modern times, 2 vols., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973, vol. 2, pp. 14Google Scholar