Introduction

The Ruwenzori are in reality a mountain range on the borders of Uganda and the Congo, and are thought to be the “Mountains of the Moon” referred to by the ancient Egyptians. Lying slightly north of the Equator in the western arm of the East African rift valley, the range is 95.5 km. long and has a maximum breadth of 48 km. The Ruwenzori can be subdivided into six ice-capped mountains and several lower peaks which are periodically snow-covered. Of the ten peaks which rise above 4,878 m. all but one are on Mount Stanley which claims the highest point, Margherita Peak (5,111 m.). The six largest mountains are separated by passes, the average elevation of which is 4,268 m., and by deeply incised valleys.

Unlike the other snow peaks of East Africa, the range is not of volcanic origin but is a gigantic uplifted horst, the origin of which is connected with the complex tectonics of the rift valley. Whereas the peripheral areas are composed of Archaean gneisses and mica-schists, the centre of the range consists of amphibolites, diorites, diabases and granites; this fact coupled with steep dips and vertical fractures is responsible for the existence and separation of the higher summits.

The permanent snow line stands at almost 4,573 m. on the Uganda slopes and 4,750 m. on the Congo slopes, although there is evidence of an earlier glaciation down to 2,134 m. on the eastern slopes.

Six expeditions have been organized by Makerere University College to study the glaciers of the Ruwenzori range. Five of these expeditions were planned as a direct contribution to the I.G.Y. programme and four of them were led by F. P. Henderson (Department of Geology, Makerere University College). The first expedition (December 1957—January 1958) conducted a general reconnaissance of the area to assess the possibilities of glaciological investigations and also established a second bivouac hut at 4,511 m. close to the Elena Glacier which was to serve as an advance base for later work. Four further expeditions followed (June 1958; December 1958—January 1959; June–July 1959; December 1959—January 1 960) at six-monthly intervals and the last, after a gap of 18 months, was in June–July 1961. These times were planned to take advantage of the less rainy season in the Ruwenzori. Each expedition was formed largely from staff members of Makerere University College and lasted two to three weeks. Each expedition followed approximately the same pattern, the parties generally dividing themselves between a base camp at Bujuku hut (3,963 m.) and an advance base at the Elena bivouac huts (4,511 m.). This enabled detailed observations over a considerable period to be made on the behaviour of the two major glaciers of the Uganda side, namely, the Speke Glacier and the, Elena Glacier. Reconnaissance work was also done on other parts of the range: on Mount Baker in June 1958 and June 1961, on Mounts Emin and Gessi in July 1959, on Mount Luigi di Savoia in January 1960 and on the Savoia Glacier of Mount Stanley in June 1961. Preliminary accounts of much of this work have already been published (Makerere College Ruwenzori Expedition, 1958 [a], [b], 1959). This paper summarizes the glaciological work of these expeditions but a considerable mass of detailed information on this and related topics still remains to be worked over.

Glaciological Investigations Prior to 1958

The earliest evidence of value in the glaciological field was provided by photographs of some of the glaciers on the western slopes of the Ruwenzori which were seen in 1891 by Reference StuhlmannStuhlmann (1894) but were not recognized by him as actual glaciers. It was not until the ascent by J. E. S. Moore in 1900 that the existence of genuine glaciers was confirmed. Reference MooreMoore (1901) made it quite clear in the account of his climb that the glacier he ascended from the upper Mobuku valley was the one now known as the Baker Glacier. For some reason, recent descriptions of Moore’s climb have linked his name with the glacier at the northernmost end of the upper Mobuku valley, and it is the latter glacier (originally termed the “Mobuku Glacier” by the Duke of the Abruzzi) which is now called the Moore Glacier. Between *****1900 and 1906 several parties (Reference JohnstonJohnston, 1902; Reference FisherFisher, 1905; Reference FreshfieldFreshfield, 1906) ascended the “Mobuku [Moore] Glacier”, including two members of the British Museum party, who also traversed the hanging glacier which separates Moore Peak from Wollaston Peak (Reference WollastonWollaston, 1908). So far as is known, apart from recording the position of the glaciers around the head of the Mobuku valley, nothing else of glaciological significance was recorded by any of these early explorers.

The first serious attempt to explore, identify and ascend the highest summits came in 1906, when a large-scale expedition, led by the Duke of the Abruzzi, provided a wealth of glaciological material (Reference FilippiFilippi, 1908). Although the highest summits had previously been described as snow-capped, earlier explorers had failed to realize the existence of six separate glacier complexes on the following mountains:

The Abruzzi expedition identified about 30 glaciers, 21 ofwhich were named. The majority of the unnamed glaciers were those situated on the Congo slopes of Mount Stanley. Photographs of many of the glaciers taken in 1906 have proved invaluable for purposes of comparison with more recent photographs.

In addition to mapping and describing the major glaciers, the 1906 expedition recorded numerous signs of an earlier glaciation extending down to the plain of Ibanda at about 1,373 m. This figure is of interest in that it represents the lowest altitude at which signs of glaciation have been reported in East Africa. It appears to be based on the presence of supposed erratics on the plain of Ibanda, although Roccati (the geologist of the expedition) admitted that they may not be the result of direct glacial transportation. More definite evidence of the presence of ice in the lower Mobuku valley was provided by the discovery in 1906 of the large Nyabitaba moraine, the base of which stands at 2,134 m. It was calculated that in 1906 the existing glaciers extended down to about 3,841 m., although no mention was made of any particular locality. Roccati briefly described the characteristics of the glaciers at the time and stated that the permanent snow line lay between 4,070 and 4,116 m. He was also of the opinion that the rate of movement of the glaciers was slight, and that all the Ruwenzori glaciers were in a state of rapid retreat.

No other work of glaciological significance was carried out on the Ruwenzori for more than 40 years, although the first flight over the mountains by Humphreys in 1931 proved conclusively that there were no ice peaks other than those already known. In July 1932, a Belgian expedition to study the natural history of the Congo slopes of the Ruwenzori took photographs of the glaciers which descend the western slopes of the Mount Stanley massif, and these allow a useful comparison to be made not only with recent photographs but also with those taken by Stuhlmann in 1891 and Chapin in 1927 (Reference ChapinChapin, 1927). This 1932 party, led by Reference GrunneGrunne (1937), estimated that the snow line stood at 4,451 m. on the Congo side of the Ruwenzori. Another minor but nevertheless valuable piece of glaciological evidence recorded about this time was when Reference SyngeSynge (1937) ascended the Nyamgasani valley in 1935 and noted lateral moraines extending down to about 2,743 m. His book also shows two interesting photographs of the rarely visited Thomson Glacier snout on the southern slopes of Mount Luigi di Savoia.

In 1937–38 a party of German mountaineers made a number of important climbs on the ice peaks of the Ruwenzori, and they produced the first contoured map of the central group (Mount Stanley, Mount Baker and Mount Speke) at a scale of 1 : 25,000 (Reference StumppStumpp, 1952). Although none of the Congo glaciers of Mount Stanley are included, all the Mount Baker glaciers are shown, in addition to the Speke and Johnston Glaciers of Mount Speke. This map, with its 25 m. contour interval and its clearly demarcated glaciers, is an invaluable aid to an understanding of the configuration of the major glaciers at a time almost midway between the Abruzzi expedition of 1906 and the more detailed glaciological studies of the 1950’s.

In December 1949, the first detailed survey of any of the individual Ruwenzori glaciers was carried out on the Speke Glacier and the glacier snout was calculated to stand at an elevation of 4,237 m. A brief description of the snout and ice conditions prevailing on the Speke and Elena Glaciers during this 1949 survey was given by Reference MenziesMenzies (1951 [a]) who recorded his observations “… in the hope that they may fill in some gaps and initiate a fuller enquiry”. His account of the Ruwenzori ice-crystal structure was the first recorded. A photograph of the Speke Glacier snout is contained in another article by Reference MenziesMenzies (1951 [b]). It is noteworthy that, when describing the Elena Glacier in 1949, Menzies wrote that the “… snout of the glacier terminates at 14,800 feet” (4,511 m.). Either the glacier advanced considerably between 1949 and 1952, or the earlier calculation was in error, since the British Ruwenzori Expedition of 1952 showed that the Elena Glacier snout stood at approximately 4,420 m.

Much valuable information concerning the western glaciers of Mount Stanley resulted from the visit of Reference HeinzelinHeinzelin (1955) to the Ruwenzori in July 1950. The Alexandra, West Stanley, Moebius and West Elena Glaciers were examined and evidence of recent retreat was found to be extensive. In addition to a detailed account of the recession of the West Stanley Glacier, Reference HeinzelinHeinzelin ([1952[a]]) noted the diverse periglacial phenomena of the western slopes.

The British Ruwenzori Expedition of July 1952, although largely concerned with a geological examination, provided the most valuable glaciological data so far collected (Reference BergströmBergström, 1955). The glaciologist of the expedition, Bergström, collaborated with Heinzelin and Menzies who were also in the Ruwenzori at that time, and a detailed examination on several of the Mount Stanley Glaciers was carried out.

Much of the time was devoted to a survey of the Elena Glacier and the budget of this glacier was also computed. A contour map of the glacier was made and the characteristics and stratification of the ice were noted in some detail. A series of markers was erected down the centre of the glacier, but unfortunately, so far as is known, they were not utilized in any subsequent resurvey. It will be noted elsewhere in this report that only one of the 1952 markers survived until January 1958, and even this was of no use for measurement purposes. A number of important weather observations were recorded over a period of three weeks on the Elena Glacier; these were the first significant meteorological readings from the high peaks of the Ruwenzori since the Abruzzi expedition of 1906. The West Stanley Glacier was also studied, and in this case a comparison was possible between recent photographs and those taken by earlier expeditions.

In addition to studying the ice, several moraines were mapped, particularly those below the snout of the Elena Glacier, and the rate of glacial recession was estimated. The front of the Elena Glacier was found to have retreated 100 m. between 1900 and 1920, and a similar distance between 1932 and 1952. It was believed that on the Congo slopes there were no moraines below 3,800 m., whereas on the Uganda side it was thought that there was evidence of a former glaciation down to about 2,000 m. Calculations showed that in 1952 glaciers on the Uganda slopes (Elena Glacier ?) descended to about 4,400 m., although it is probable that the Moore Glacier (which was not visited by the 1952 expedition) then descended to approximately 4,192 m. The stratigraphy in the mud at certain lake sites was also examined and an attempt was made to correlate the ancient shore-lines with oscillations of the glaciers.

Since the British Ruwenzori Expedition there has been very little glaciological investigation on the mountains, although H. A. Osmaston, of the Uganda Forestry Department, has visited the glaciers on several occasions; in August 1953 he reported that at one point the front of the Elena Glacier had advanced at least 2 m. in a year.

Certain discrepancies on the map in the area of the Savoia and Elena Glaciers were investigated in January 1953 by Reference BuskBusk (1954), and he proved conclusively that the Savoia Glacier did not have its origin on the Savoia Peak. He examined the higher reaches of the prominent hanging glacier west of the Elena Glacier, and named it the Coronation Glacier.

In December 1955, J. Smith and T. E. Fletcher, on a climbing expedition to the Ruwenzori, made a valuable contribution to the study of the Elena Glacier budget by obtaining a profile of the firn at 4,847 m. on the Stanley Plateau. In addition, photographs were taken of the Speke, Margherita and East Stanley Glaciers.

Heinzelin revisited the Congo slopes of Mount Stanley in January 1956 but on this occasion his research was primarily of a biological nature (Reference Heinzelin and MollaretHeinzelin and Mollaret, 1956). Nevertheless, the moraines and glacial lakes in the vicinity of the West Stanley and Moebius Glaciers were examined and mapped in great detail.

Thus, by 1958 all the Ruwenzori glaciers had been seen, although many of them had not been named or visited. In conclusion, it might be said that the exploration and description of the Ruwenzori glaciers can be grouped into three periods: 1891–1906, the earliest explorations, usually by large-scale expeditions (British Museum, Abruzzi); 1907–45, an interim period during which there was virtually no important glaciological work done, although Humphreys made useful explorations; 1946–58, which saw the well-equipped scientific expeditions on the Ruwenzori, and resulted in the work of Menzies, Bergström, Heinzelin, etc. In addition, the Uganda Surveys Department was able to make the first large-scale maps of the Ruwenzori (Margherita, sheet 65/11, 1 : 50,000, Directorate of Overseas Surveys, ist edition, 1957; Central Ruwenzori, sheet 326, 1 : 25,000, Directorate of Overseas Surveys, ist edition, 1960).

The Pattern of Ice Distribution

By comparison with glaciers of high latitudes, the 37 existing Ruwenzori glaciers are small in extent, the largest (the Vittorio Emanuele Glacier) being no more than 476,577 m² Footnote * in area. The total Ruwenzori ice coverage is slightly less than 5 km²,* of which the ice on Mounts Stanley and Speke accounts for over three-quarters. The general distribution of the ice is shown in Figure 1.

Fig. 1. Central Ruwenzori, Approximate ice distribution in 1960 with the routes followed by the Makerere College expeditions

Recent Surveys of the Speke Glacier (Mount Speke)

The Speke Glacier is probably the largest individual glacier of the Ruwenzori. Although the Duke of the Abruzzi was probably the first European to set eyes on it, and although it appears on his map, he did not traverse it and in Sella’s photographs the snout is obscured by clouds. This is unfortunate, since the character of the snout has changed radically over the past 54 years. The first-published photograph of the glacier appeared after the visit of Humphreys in 1926 (Reference HumphreysHumphreys, 1927, plate opposite p. 521).

It is probable that several photographs of the glacier were taken between 1926 and the visit of Menzies in 1949–50, but either they have remained unpublished or they are too small to be of great value for comparative purposes. Menzies’ visit was significant because the lower part of the glacier was photographed, surveyed and a map was produced at a scale of approximately 1 : 2,500. In 1952 and again in 1955 aerial photographs of the Ruwenzori were taken (by R.A.F. in April 1952; by Harward Maclachlan (Nairobi) in September 1952; by Hunting Aerosurveys in June and October 1955), and the Speke Glacier was recorded in its entirety at these dates. Between the latter date and the commencement of the Makererc College expeditions, several private parties visiting the Ruwenzori photographed the glacier, and through the kind co-operation of the individuals involved it has been possible to build up a fairly complete picture of the icc changes over the last ten years (Fig. 5).

Fig. 5. Snout of the Speke Glacier: recent changes

Members of the Makerere College I.G.Y. Ruwenzori team visited the glacier on every expedition, and the records of the changes are more complete than for any other glacier in this area.

The glacier collects its firn from the summit ridge of Mount Speke, and has a total surface area of about 375,000 m.². The accumulation zone extends from the summit ridge at 4,814 m. down to the fern line at about 4,573 m., and is roughly twice the size of the ablation zone (250,000 m.² to 125,000 m.²). The glacier descends almost due southwards, curving slightly to the west near its snout, and the present terminus is at about 4,344 m. Three melt streams emerge from the present glacier terminus to plunge over a steep rock wall before cascading over 300 m. down to the Bujuku hut on the valley floor (Fig. 9). The amount of debris and excavation at the foot of the main gully may indicate that at an earlier stage the avalanched ice coming down was sufficient to produce a small regenerated glacier at the foot of the rock wall. The photographs which the Duke of the Abruzzi and Humphreys took of this gully both show a prominent ice or snow cone at its foot, but this had disappeared by the time Menzies visited it in 1949.

During most of the visits of the Makerere College party, the surface of the glacier was almost bare of snow up to the firn line, and some prominent patches of medial moraine were revealed. The morainic material ranged in size from large blocks several metres in diameter to fine rock flour. Some of the larger blocks had formed glacier tables up to 1 m. in height, and digging showed that these moraines were ice-cored. The source of the moraine could not traced, but there seems little doubt that it is this surface moraine falling into the terminal crevasses which is responsible for the build-up of the small end moraine now forming at the western end of the snout. There is today little subglacial or englacial moraine, a fact noted by Menzies in 1950.

During the 18 months of study, one large crevasse at the western end of the snout opened out slowly until, by January 1960, it contained a considerable melt-water stream and, higher up, a hole which led through to an ice cave in the heart of the glacier. Small pieces of medial moraine were continually melting out and falling down the hole, presumably right to the bottom of the glacier. During sunny afternoons, which were very rare, the western part of the glacier in the ablation zone was covered with small trickles of melt water.

The glacier is quite heavily crevassed both at the snout and near the firn line, and the terminal crevasses often extend through the total thickness of the ice (18 m. at the snout). The pattern of the crevasses changes slowly with the passage of time, while at the snout where the crevasses intersect each other, seracs occasionally break off and fall to the valley floor 300 m. below. In three years at least three separate groups of seracs have broken off and have either fallen or melted in situ (Figs. 6, 7 and 8). Although their collapse appears to have been the result of slight forward movement of the eastern half of the glacier snout, they may also have been undermined by melt water. Reference SpinkSpink (1949) contends that the absence of seracs in the glaciers of Mount Kenya and Kilimanjaro results from the special nature of the ice, possibly caused by the extreme fluctuations of temperature in low latitudes. The presence of the Ruwenzori seracs may be indicative, therefore, of important contrasts in ice ductility, which in turn may reflect significant differences in the climatic environments of the Ruwenzori glaciers and those of the other East African ice masses. It has long been realized that, even though the Ruwenzori glaciers show many signs of recent recession, they are undoubtedly better nourished and better preserved than the glaciers of Mount Kenya and Kilimanjaro.

Fig. 6. The snout of the Speke Glacier (June 1958). Note the painted stones “C” and “D”

Fig. 7. The snout of the Speke Glacier (July 1959). Note the painted stones “B” and “C”

Fig. 8. The snout of the Speke Glacier (July 1961). Note the painted stones “B”, “C” and “D”

There is no doubt that, in common with all other East African glaciers, the Speke Glacier is in the midst of a recessional phase. The evidence for this is threefold: decrease in length, in width and in thickness. It has not yet been possible to decide the last date at which the Speke Glacier joined the glaciers which formerly descended eastwards from Mount Stanley before flowing together down the upper Bujuku valley, but a series of recessional moraines marking the retreat stages of this trunk glacier are found at intervals between the Nyamuleju hut (3,292 m.) and Lake Bujuku (3,963 m.). At a height of 4,143 m. and clearly visible from the Bujuku hut, the most recent recessional moraine lies at the foot of the final rock wall below the present glacier terminus. Although there is a considerable difference in elevation between this last moraine and the present position of the snout, the horizontal distance is only about 450 m.; this is comparable to the 550 m. between the snout of the Elena Glacier and its innermost recessional moraine. Since the formation of these moraines, both the Speke and Elena Glaciers have retreated a vertical distance of about 250 m. up steep rock walls. Therefore, there is some reason to suppose that they are now retreating at about the same rate. It has been suggested by Reference BergströmBergström (1955) that the ice stood at these inner moraines at a date a little later than the Swedish ice advances of 1740 and 1800.

Measurements taken approximately 150 m. above the snout suggest that the forward movement of the Speke Glacier is very slow and that in places it is almost stagnant. As can be seen from the map (Fig. 5), lines of painted stones and stakes were placed in the ice at various intervals, and these were measured by theodolite from fixed points at each visit. A maximum forward movement of just under 1 m. in 18 months was recorded for two stones at the western end of the line. It was unfortunate that on the last visit, in January 1960, the glacier was covered with fresh snow and the stones were obscured. The three stakes inserted in June 1959 showed negligible movement by January 1960; the westernmost seemed to have moved furthest. Evidence from the stones is a little questionable because, in the course of time, some have risen above the general level of the surface on small glacier tables and have then fallen off and slid forward. One stone had disappeared completely by June 1959. The fact that the westernmost stones have moved slightly more than the others in the line may not, indeed, be due to forward movement of the glacier as a whole but to localized slumping in its bed. The western half of the ablation zone may have already become completely stagnant, a stage that has already been reached by several of the smaller Ruwenzori glaciers, e.g. the Thomson Glacier and the Moore Glacier.

The eastern half of the ablation zone is still relatively active, and that part of the snout below it is the only section of the glacier edge which showed any advance during the 18 months’ observation. Between June 1958 and January 1959, the ice behind cairns 7, 8 and 9 advanced between 0.3 and 0.75 m., but it has since retreated. The crevasse field behind this part of the snout is less extensive than on the western side, and the individual crevasses are smaller in width and length. They do not seem to open out by melting as quickly as those on the western side. The eastern side of the glacier edge does not appear to be retreating from the rock wall as fast as the edge on the western side, and there is less morainic debris. Possible reasons for this are discussed below.

The rate of retreat of the snout itself can be traced from the 1926 photograph of Humphreys, the 1950 map of Menzies, and the six-monthly recordings of the Makerere College parties (Figs. 6, 7 and 8). The most spectacular change in the outline of the snout is the total disappearance of the ice tongue which formerly extended down from the eastern side of the glacier terminus. This is shown on Figure 5 as “Glacier edge in 1950 (Menzies)”, and photographs show that in 1926 it extended much lower down the rock face. By 1950 this tongue could not have been very thick, but nevertheless its disappearance between 1950 and 1958 does suggest an increasingly rapid rate of retreat over the past 30 years.

The cairns and painted stones marked by the Makerere College expedition in June 1958 were measured at six-monthly intervals until January 1960, and then again in July 1961. Some of these markers, especially those on the near-vertical rock walls fringing the ice were accessible only from the glacier itself. Thus, after the shrinkage of the glacier or the collapse of ice-cave roofs, certain of the markers became virtually inaccessible to the expedition members on later visits. This was particularly true of mark G and cairns 5 and 6, whilst stone A and cairn 7 were buried or swept away by falling seracs. Table II summarizes the retreat of the ice margins over the period of detailed measurements.

From Table II it can be concluded that the snout is generally retreating along its entire length, despite slight periodic advances at the eastern end. The highest recessional figures are due in part to collapse in addition to normal ablation.

The glacier is also decreasing in width (Figs. 10 and 11). Comparison between the 1950 and 1960 maps shows a reduction in width just above the snout from 292 m. to just under 237 m. This apparently rapid decrease in width in a decade is the continuation of a tendency which has been evident for at least 50 years. Observations by the Makerere College party show a decrease of up to 10.1 m. in width in 18 months.

Fig. 9. Mount Speke from the south-west showing the snout of the Speke Glacier and its melt stream, with the Bujuku hut (bottom left) in January 1958. Note the cirque-like basin, to the left of the glacier snout, which was full of ice in 1906

Fig. 10. Side recession of the Speke Glacier (position in January 1959). Note mark “G”, which was painted vertically below the we margin in June 1958

Fig. 11. Side recession of the Speke Glacier (position in July 1961). Note mark “G”

Other evidence of recent shrinkage is provided by the glacier thickness. A careful examination of photographs taken between 1906 and the present day shows that a considerable amount of rock which was submerged by ice some 30 to 50 years ago is now uncovered. This rock has a light grey appearance in photographs, indicating that there has not been sufficient time for colonization by lichens. In 1950 Menzies estimated the thickness of the ice front at 36.4 m. in places; today it is nowhere more than 18.2 m.

The main reason for the shrinkage of the Speke Glacier appears to be excessive surface ablation caused by direct insolation. There is also evidence of melting due to insolation being reflected and re-radiated from the rock walls near the edges of the snout. This is particularly true on the western side, where several spectacular ice caves are located in positions which make it difficult for melt streams to be entirely responsible for their formation. Temperature measurements near these caves showed that the heat radiated from the nearby rock wall is undoubtedly playing an important part in maintaining the present rate of ablation. The supply of fresh firn cannot possibly balance the present ablation rate.

Another factor which affects the degree and location of surface melting is the extent and duration of the shadow cast by Johnston Peak, and the rock wall beneath it, across the glacier surface. The eastern half of the Speke Glacier was seen to remain in shadow until midmorning, by which time clouds had usually obscured the sun. Early morning observations showed that this part of the glacier remained frozen and unchanneled by melt water, and the small marginal lake impounded on the eastern side of the glacier usually remained frozen throughout the day. On the other hand, the western side of the glacier surface received maximum solar radiation for a few hours on each morning when the sky was clear after sunrise. This part of the glacier rapidly developed numerous small surface runnels, some of which helped to enlarge the crevasses near the snout.

The only time of day when the whole ablation zone was likely to be exposed to direct sunlight was in the late afternoon. On several occasions members of the Makerere College party witnessed fitful clearance of the cloud and brief spells of intense insolation at this time of day (Table IV), but these periods were never sufficiently continuous to cause a significant rise in the volume of melt water coming from the eastern side of the glacier. The protection of this side of the glacier by shadow probably played an important part in the preservation for many years of the prominent ice tongue shown on Menzies’ map. The slight advance of the snout between June 1958 and January 1959, and again between June 1959 and January 1960, may also be connected with this factor.

In conclusion it might be said that, if the present ablation rate remains unchanged, the Speke Glacier can be expected virtually to disappear within the next 40 years. It has been calculated that in this time all the ice which occupies the present ablation zone would almost certainly disappear, leaving little but a reduced summit ice cap above 4,573 m.

Recent Surveys of the Elena Glacier (Mount Stanley)

Although the Elena Glacier is not one of the largest glaciers of the Ruwenzori, it possesses one of the longest ablation zones. It is one of six major glaciers which radiate from the central ice plateau on Mount Stanley (Fig. 1), and its accessibility has made it an obvious target for glaciological investigation.

The Duke of the Abruzzi was the first person to camp near the glacier. His “ridge camp”, however, was established on some relatively sheltered ledges about 90 m. below the site of the present Elena bivouac huts (Fig. 13), at a point which must then have been almost on a level with the snout of the glacier. Photographs of the glacier in 1906 show the snout hanging down a steep rock wall, up which the ice has since retreated, leaving at least three marked terminal moraines at the bottom. The glacier basin was then much fuller, there being a marked encroachment of the ice into the gullies on the west and north-west side of the glacier and the two prominent gullies (marked “A” and “B” on Figure 12) were ice-choked to an extent which rendered them unidentifiable individually. A photograph taken by A. H. Firmin in 1943 shows that the Coronation Glacier was confluent with the main Elena Glacier until the mid-1940’s (Reference FirminFirmin, 1945).

Fig. 12. The Elena Glacier: recent changes

Fig. 13. The Elena bivouac huts. The hut nearest to the camera was built by the Makerere College party in January 1958

The Elena Glacier was revisited briefly in 1926 and 1927 by Humphreys, whose photographs are of great interest as they show the intermediate state of the glacier between 1906 arid the present day. During his second expedition of July 1926 Humphreys camped for five days near the site of the Abruzzi “ridge camp” and observed that the Abruzzi cairns were already overgrown with lichens (Reference HumphreysHumphreys, 1927). It was after Humphreys’ expeditions that the general retreat of the Ruwenzori ice first became apparent, although no detailed work was undertaken at that time.

The first detailed commentary on the Elena Glacier was published by Reference MenziesMenzies (1951[a], Reference Menzies[b]) after a visit in December 1949. He calculated that the snout of the glacier stood at 4,511 m., a much higher figure than that for the present day, and much higher than the figure of 4,420 m. given by the British Ruwenzori Expedition of 1952. The present height of the snout is about 4,456 m. and the fire line is just below 4,573 m. Menzies calculated the glacier budget and observed that, in spite of snow falling nearly all the year round, the glacier seemed to have a definite “ablation season” between the middle of June and the end of July, with a less-pronounced one in late December, January and February. The accumulation months are therefore March to May and September to November. The definite ablation season in June and July was confirmed by the Makerere College parties. Menzies also gave the first recession figure for the glacier, based on the assumption that in two, the glacier stood at the last of the moraines at the foot of the rock wall. These moraines were plotted and appear on a small-scale map of the glacier in Menzies’ paper. The glacier was surveyed in detail by Menzies and Bergstrom in 1952 and a contoured map was drawn at a scale of 1 : 2,000, showing the ice limits (Reference BergströmBergström, 1955). These were revised in 1953 by Osmaston, who visited the glacier on several occasions (Reference BergströmBergström, 1955, p. 473). A good idea of the state of the glacier in 1955 is given by photographs of the Coronation Glacier which show four of the survey markers used by the 1952 British Ruwenzori Expedition still standing in the ice (Reference BuskBusk, 1957, plates 29 and 30).

When work was begun on the glacier by the Makerere College parties in January 1958, it was found that only one of the 1952 markers remained, and as a result a completely new survey had to be undertaken. Stakes were driven 30 to 50 cm. into the ice in an attempt to measure the rate of glacier flow, but due to either the very rapid surface ablation or the elasticity of the ice, these had mostly become dislodged a mere fortnight after the end of the initial survey. By January 1959, a year later, none of the previous year’s markers remained and new ones had to be put in, this time very much deeper. By July 1959 only one of the January markers remained in position. This remaining stake indicated a melt of 75 em. of ice and 18 cm. of snow in six months. The other stakes had originally been placed in the ice to depths of between 86 and 104 cm. below a variable thickness (50–70 cm.) of snow. This, therefore, gives some idea of the minimum amount of melting on the glacier surface during the six-month period, although it was not known how rapidly the stakes had become dislodged. It seemed probable that the survival of stakes in an upright position over a six-month period depended more on the depth of the snow cover than on the actual amount of insolation received, for the only surviving stake was standing in 18 cm. of snow in a slight hollow, while those which had been dislodged lay on bare ice on upstanding parts of the glacier surface. Lateral recession and the flow rate of the glacier were measured and the results of this work are summarized below. In addition, three pits were dug in the firn zone and profiles were obtained which have been described elsewhere (Reference WhittowWhittow, 1960). In January 1960 a deep and extensive cover of fresh snow obscured both the cairns and the ice edge, so that only one of the markers was of use. In July 1961 the lateral recession was measured and photographs were taken of the snout.

Summarizing as far as possible the recent changes in the ablation zone of the Elena Glacier, the following pattern emerges:

(a) Retreat of the Elena Glacier snout

• 1900 to 1920 (Menzies’ estimate): 100 m. or just under 5 m./yr.

• 1932 to 1952 (Menzies): 100 m. or just under 5 m./yr.

• (Osmaston reported an advance of part of the snout of up to 1.9 m. between August 1952 and August 1953, but the eastern side of the snout retreated 3.5 m. during the same period.)

• 1952 to 1960: maximum (eastern snout) 213 m.; minimum (centre of snout) 52 m.

A series of photographs illustrating the retreat of the snout between January 1959 and July 1961 is shown in Figures 14, 15, 16 and 17.

Fig. 14. The snout of the Elena Glacier (January 1959)

Fig. 15. The snout of the Elena Glacier (July 1959)

Fig. 16. The snout of the Elena Glacier (January 1960)

Fig. 17. The snout of the Elena Glacier (July 1961)

There seems little doubt that, as on the Speke Glacier, a long shallow tongue of ice at the eastern end of the snout has disappeared during the last eight years, and a vertical aerial photograph of 1956 shows the remains of this tongue. The outline of the glacier snout at that time was complex, with seracs and some isolated ice platforms decaying in situ. It must be remembered that the Elena Glacier is inclined at an angle and bearing which traps strong insolation from sunrise until late afternoon. This is particularly important in view of the limited hours during which strong insolation is usually experienced in the Ruwenzori. The glacier is also the focus for currents of slightly warmed air which reach over the Scott-Elliott Pass and travel upwards across the ablation zone.

(b) Lateral recession of the Elena Glacier

1952 to 1960: maximum 55 In.; minimum 8 m.

It must be noted that this six-month period did not include the whole of one of the annual periods of relatively dry weather, and therefore it is not quite indicative of a normal six-month recessional phase.

No measurements of side recession were made on the Pinnacle side of the glacier.

Since the time of the Abruzzi expedition, the width of the glacier just below the bivouac huts has shrunk from about 370 m. to 256 m.

The stakes in the side of the glacier showed melting and sinking of the order of 5.2 cm,/ week, with surface melt rates of between 2.6 and 10.4 cm./week. These rates for July 1959 probably represent conditions at the height of the ablation season and should therefore be regarded as maxima.

(c) Surface ablation of the Elena Glacier

Although it proved impossible in January 1960 to tell the exact amount by which the remaining stakes were still embedded in ice, they were showing between 0.94 and 1.10 m. above the snow. Assuming that the average snow depth on the ablation zone was between 18 and 31 cm. this would give a maximum ablation of 1.4 m. and a minimum of 1.1 m. for the period of July 1959—January 1960, which accords fairly well with the 1.0 to 0.9 m. for the previous six months. The present area of the ablation zone is about 101,500 m.², but the surface area of the accumulation zone is difficult to estimate, because of its imperceptible gradation into the Mount Stanley ice plateau; a rather arbitrary line appears on the Menzies map.

(d) Forward movement of the Elena Glacier

Attempts were made in both January and July 1959 to measure forward movements of the glacier at the ice—rock interface by inserting a stake and twice daily comparing the angles made by a fixed theodolite. An average movement of 13 cm./week (with a definite maximum during daylight hours) was indicated, or about 6.7 m./yr. The one stake in the centre of the ablation zone which proved fairly reliable gave the following figures:

The present state of the Elena Glacier is therefore one of fair supply and rapid retreat. This is an active glacier, apart from certain stagnant areas on its eastern fringe, but its relatively rapid rate of flow may be due more to its steep angle of slope rather than to its abundance of firn. While it is not possible to record exactly the configuration of the glacier bed, there may be a shallow part at the eastern side and a deep part at the Pinnacle side. Two experiments were made with electronic echo-sounders in an attempt to establish profiles of the glacier bed, but these were unsuccessful. Nevertheless, it seems that the glacier has been retreating from the eastern or shallow part of its bed mainly because this part is out of the direct Iine of nourishment from the Mount Stanley ice plateau. The snow-filled basin above the Elena huts, which formerly must have supplied some firn to the glacier, is now almost entirely below the firn line itself so that the ice within and immediately below this basin is virtually stagnant.

Despite the forward movement of the glacier, there are several signs of shrinking within the present bed. The lower part of the ablation zone lies across two broad gullies with a narrow separating ridge, and the glacier is gradually settling into the gullies. Ice caves along the eastern edge and snout of the glacier indicate that the sinking and retreat into these gullies is still continuing, though possibly at a slower rate than during the previous two decades. These caves show change and collapse within short periods of time (Figs. 14–17).

If the calculations of the rate of retreat are not too exaggerated, and if the present rate continues, then the whole of the present ablation zone of the glacier will have melted within the next 35 years.

Work carried out by the Makerere College teams on the Elena Glacier was of a more experimental nature than that carried out on the Speke Glacier. This fact, combined with the premature withdrawal of the second expedition owing to the death of one of its members, meant that the picture of activity of the Elena Glacier over the past three years is neither as complete nor as detailed as that obtained for the Speke Glacier.

The Savoia Glacier (Mount Stanley)

The Savoia Glacier is the most southerly of the glaciers on Mount Stanley. Its form is simple and the basin in which it lies is self-contained. The glacier is completely separated from Savoia Peak, from which it appears to originate when viewed from the south, by the upper basin of the Coronation Glacier. Its upper limit is, in fact, a smooth snow col east of Philip Peak at a height of a little under 4,878 m. (Reference BuskBusk, 1954). The only recorded observations on the form and regime of the glacier prior to 1961 are those of Reference OsmastonOsmaston (1961).

Unlike many of the other glaciers of Mount Stanley, the Savoia Glacier is not merely a tongue descending from the summit ice cap but is a separate entity. The rough dimensions of the ice (quoted by Osmaston) are a length of approximately 609 m. and a width of 152 m. As these are minimum values, this corresponds fairly well to the 1958 estimate of 100,000 m.² for the total surface area of the glacier. The rate of movement of the ice was measured by Osmaston some way up the glacier between August 1953 and February 1954, and during the six-month period it showed a forward movement of 10.7 m. in the centre of the ice and a forward movement of 4.5 m. at the eastern edge. These figures span a sufficiently long period to give a fair indication of the pattern of movement, particularly as they cover a period of heavy precipitation at the end of the year and a period of strong ablation in January. In June 1961, when the glacier was first visited by a Makerere College party, new snow covered the surface of the ice right down to the snout, but recent photographs of the glacier and observations by Osmaston suggest that the firn line lies between 4,664 and 4,756 m. This is much higher than the neighbouring Elena Glacier but may possibly be explained by periodic incursions of warm Congo air, leading to stronger ablation. Belgian observations suggest that the firn line on the western slopes of the Ruwenzori may be as high as 4,750 m. The glacier descends from its collecting grounds almost due south to a height of approximately 4,542 m. at its snout (Fig. 18). No detailed survey of the ice has yet been carried out, but a rough map was made of the lower part of the glacier in 1961 and a number of cairns were built round the ice to establish points for more detailed work in the future. Nevertheless, the recent history of the glacier can be pieced together using photographic, morphological and vegetational evidence.

Fig. 18. The Savoia Glacier: retreat stages (1906–58). The upper part of the Elena Glacier (E) can be seen on the right rising up to the Mount Stanley ice plateau (SP) beyond which is Margherita Peak (M)

The view of the southern peaks of Mount Stanley and the Savoia Glacier from the top of the Freshfield Pass, is a particularly fine one and, as a result, there is a good sequence of photographs of the glacier taken from almost identical positions. Comparison of these photographs is therefore relatively easy and changes in the ice margins can be clearly followed. A summary of the more important stages is shown in Figure 18. The Abruzzi photographs of 1906 are the earliest and they show the basin containing much more ice than at present. The névé field at the head of the glacier appeared to be much thicker and deep snow gullies extended towards the summit of Philip Peak. The glacier was also considerably longer, the snout being very regular in outline (except for a small avalanche cone almost detached from the main mass) and probably extended about 250 m. beyond its present edge. This is broadly comparable with the Elena Glacier measurements, if the steeper slopes below the snout of the latter are taken into account. Between 1906 and the present day, there has been a very considerable decrease both in width and thickness of the lower part of the glacier. Humphreys’ photographs enable the 1927 and 1931 positions to be established,Footnote * but the later aerial photographs show a considerable snow cover and are therefore less valuable. Photographs of the glacier in 1934 (Reference SyngeSynge, 1937, plates 37 and 38) indicate that only small changes had taken place since Reference HumphreysHumphreys’ 1927 visit, but a marked shrinkage of the glacier is evident from a photograph of Mount Stanley taken in January 1943 by Reference FirminFirmin (1945). A broad zone of light-coloured newly exposed rock encircles the snout and lower part of the glacier, this being particularly prominent on its eastern side where formerly the snout had extended farthest down the valley. Nevertheless, higher up the eastern side of the glacier, the ice, even in the Duke of the Abruzzi’s time, must have been relatively thin, judging by the prominent rocks which showed through it. This zone of thin ice must have melted away completely in the period 1934–43. In addition, the small ice patch lying to the north-east of the main tongue, so prominent in all earlier photographs, had by then been drastically reduced to something closely approximating to its present size. A considerable recession is therefore evident between 1934 and 1943, followed by a further considerable retreat at the centre of the snout between 1943 and 1948.Footnote * Photographs taken by a Makerere College party in 1958 show further shrinkage in length and width. Between 1958 and 1961 the changes were relatively slight but the outline of the ice tongue became more uniform through the melting away of two prominent lobes of ice which lay in shallow gullies on either side of the snout. The photographic evidence indicates, therefore, a general retreat since 1906 with an acceleration taking place during and after the middle 1950’s. This corresponds to evidence from the other Ruwenzori glaciers which have been studied in some detail.

Lying at a considerable distance below the present termination of the glacier is an extensive well-preserved and fresh moraine. This moraine marks a recessional phase of recent date for it has not yet lost its sharpness of outline nor has it been greatly colonized by vegetation. The Abruzzi photographs show the snout of the glacier just in contact with the fringe of this moraine in 1906, so that it is probably equivalent to the inner moraine of the Elena Glacier (dated as 1900 by Menzies but probably a little older) and the youngest moraine on the Congo slopes of the massif, described by Heinzelin. Below this innermost moraine of the Savoia Glacier, there is a much smaller morainic feature in a gully, but below this the valley slopes steepen and the preservation of a full morainic sequence, similar to that below the Elena Glacier, is missing. Any deposits from ice wastage lower down would not remain in situ but would avalanche to form the extensive screes which are a notable feature of the approach to the glacier from Kitandara.

Immediately below the snout an irregular semi-circular series of vegetation zones can be distinguished. For about 30 m. beyond the ice the ground is almost completely bare; farther from the ice there is a zone of mosses, lichens and scattered tufts of grass. About 90 m. from the snout the first Helichrysum appear together with very small Senecios no more than 15 cm. high. It is several hundred metres farther down-slope before larger Senecios (over 1.2 m. in height) appear together with a thick growth of Helichrysum. There would appear to be a distinct correlation between these vegetation zones and the recent recessional pattern of the Savoia Glacier.

The Moore Glacier (Mount Baker)

There seems little doubt that the Moore Glacier on Mount Baker descends to a lower elevation than any of the other Ruwenzori glaciers. This fact, coupled with its relative accessibility at the head of the Mobuku valley, was responsible for its having been the most frequently visited by the early explorers at the beginning of the present century. It is of interest, perhaps, to note that J. E. S. Moore, the first man to reach the snow line on the Ruwenzori, did not ascend the glacier which now bears his name, as is popularly supposed. It is quite clear from his description and photographs that the glacier he followed to the summit was the Baker Glacier; he mentions that the smaller glacier at the head of the Mobuku valley (now the Moore Glacier) appeared fearfully steep and inaccessible.

Among the early Ruwenzori explorers, Wollaston, the Duke of the Abruzzi, the two Fishers and Sir Harry Johnston, all took photographs of the Moore Glacier which are useful as a means of estimating its recession within the last 50 years. In 1906 Wollaston calculated the elevation of the glacier snout as 4,171 m., while the Duke of the Abruzzi (also in 1906) thought that it terminated at 4,174 m. The close agreement of these figures leads one to suppose that they are reasonably accurate, and it is therefore unfortunate that during the visit of the Makerere College I.G.Y. party in 1958 it was not possible to measure accurately the present elevation of the glacier snout. However, an estimate of 4,192 m. is probably not far from the true height of the existing glacier terminus. Although the vertical retreat does not appear to have been very great during the last 50 years, the Moore Glacier has retreated 90 m. since about 1906, judging from the photographs taken by Fisher and Wollaston, with an average recession rate of about 1.8 m./yr.

The gradual vegetational recolonization of the rocks below the glacier may enable one to give a more precise dating to the retreat rate of the ice front. For a distance of about 55 m. below the glacier snout the valley floor is free from vegetation of any kind, and the rocks are a characteristic light-grey colour. This zone is probably equivalent to the innermost un-colonized lichen zone noted by Bergström on Mount Stanley in 1952. He regarded the outer boundary of this zone as marking the position of the glacier fronts on the Ruwenzori in about 1930. If this correlation is accepted, then the Moore Glacier must have retreated approximately 55 m. in 28 years since 1930, as compared with a retreat of approximately 32 m. in the 24–year period between Abruzzi’s 1906 visit and 1930. The increased recession rate since 1930 adds further support to the evidence of an accelerated deglacierizatiort of the Ruwenzori within the last 50 years.

The recolonization of macroscopic lichens on the valley walls above the existing glacier also testifies to the considerable shrinkage in the ice thickness that has taken place since 1950. Measurements taken in 1958 slightly above the glacier snout show that Iichen growth commences at approximately 3 m. above the present ice surface. On the assumption that the glacier shrinkage has accelerated since 1950, then the glacier snout must have been at least 3–4 m. thicker than at present when visited by the earliest explorers. This fact is borne out by the Fisher photographs which show the snout at least 6 m. thick, whereas in 1958 it was nothing more than a thin wafer of ice, about 1 m. thick, onto which it was possible to walk (Fig. 19). The Wollaston and Johnston photographs depict numerous crevasses and towering seracs at the Moore Glacier terminus, and it was no doubt for this reason that Abruzzi and his guides chose to ascend the steep rock walls to overcome the “terminal fall of seracs”.

Fig. 19. The Moore Glacier: a dead glacier (June 1958). The rock (arrowed) was painted with a large numeral 1. Reproduced by courtesy of the Royal Geographical Society

An examination of the ice in 1958 left little doubt that the Moore Glacier is hardly more than a thin tongue of stagnant ice. There are no crevasses or surface moraines which might be indicative of movement and the glacier was seen to be melting at a great rate. The melt streams, which have cut through the ice to become completely subglacial, have carved out wide ice caves. During the 1958 visit a collapse of the existing ice tongue appeared to be quite imminent, so that a retreat of about 9 m. during the 1959 “dry” season would seem to be quite likely.

The location of the Moore Glacier, in a narrow chasm between precipitous rock walls, means that in addition to direct insolation on the ice surface there must be a certain amount of melting caused by the reflected and radiated heat from the rock walls themselves. Evidence of this can be seen at the edges of the ice, where wide gaps separate the glacier from the side walls. The ultimate cause of the rapid recession, however, is probably the gradually increasing elevation of the firn line in the Ruwenzori since the last ice advance, possibly in the mid nineteenth century. At present the firn line on the Uganda slopes of the Ruwenzori stands at an elevation of almost 4,573 m., which means that the upper basin of the Moore Glacier lies entirely below it. Since there is no longer a positive budget, and since the ice thickness has been so greatly diminished during the last 50 years, it would appear that if present trends continue the Moore Glacier will cease to exist within the next 20 to 30 years.

Further Scientific Observations

Numerous other observations of glaciological significance were made at different times during the course of the 1957–61 Ruwenzori expeditions. These included measurements of snow accumulation, firn profiles and air-mass movements, which have already been published by Reference WhittowWhittow (1960), and detailed meteorological statistics (Makerere College Ruwenzori Expedition, 1959) too lengthy to be included in the present paper. Nevertheless, it is pertinent to note that important relationships exist between these published observations and other glaciological meteorological measurements, the most significant of which are summarized below.

Conclusion

The obvious conclusion to be drawn from all the observations and measurements on the Ruwenzori glaciers is that there is an increasingly rapid deglacierization in progress. The causes of this ice recession on the East African snow peaks during the last century are not fully understood, but if as seems possible, the glacial recession is on a global scale, then its cause may be of extraterrestrial origin.

Local meteorological records are scanty in East Africa and they do not extend back much more than 50 years, so that it is not easy to distinguish a localized climatic change. A study of the available rainfall statistics has demonstrated that in the period 1920–49 there have been significant rainfall trends in East Africa (Reference SansomSansom, 1952). During the period in question rainfall decreased by as much as 150 mm. on Mount Kenya, but at the same time rainfall in the vicinity of Kilimanjaro and the Ruwenzori appears to have increased by approximately 75 mm. Thus, rainfall variations cannot be advanced as evidence for the general deglacierization of East Africa, although they may have had important local repercussions. Nor does a study of temperature trends provide a satisfactory answer to the problem, for the stations which have long-term records merely exhibit a series of wavelike oscillations since 1915, the amplitude being of the order 3° F. (2° C.). If anything, there appears to have been a slightly negative trend of East African mean temperatures since 1938 (private communication from the Meteorological Department, Entebbe, Uganda). It has been suggested that cloud cover on the Ruwenzori may have been greater during the nineteenth century, and this would certainly have an important effect on the ablation rates in low latitudes if it were true. Attempts have been made to study the effects of differing cloud amounts and their relationship to different air masses (Reference WhittowWhittow, 1960), but the results, though interesting, are inconclusive when related to the present question of long-term deglacierization. Before a definite conclusion can be reached, it will be necessary to collect far more meteorological statistics from the high mountain areas of East Africa and elsewhere in the Tropics.

Acknowledgements

The authors are indebted to the Royal Society, the Royal Geographical Society, the Mount Everest Foundation and Makerere University College, Uganda, for the necessary expedition funds and a contribution towards publication costs; to the many members of the expeditions, and in particular F. P. Henderson, C. J. Ball and L. E. Harrison, for their support in the field; to Professor G. Manley in Britain and Professors J. P. Andrews and S. J. K. Baker in East Africa for their help and encouragement.