We study the viscous fingering or Saffman–Taylor instability in two different dilute or semi-dilute polymer solutions. The different solutions exhibit only one non-Newtonian property, in the sense that other non-Newtonian effects can be neglected. The viscosity of solutions of stiff polymers has a strong shear rate dependence. Relative to Newtonian fluids, narrower fingers are found for rigid polymers. For solutions of flexible polymers, elastic effects such as normal stresses are dominant, whereas the shear viscosity is almost constant. Wider fingers are found in this case. We characterize the non-Newtonian flow properties of these polymer solutions completely, allowing for separate and quantitative investigation of the influence of the two most common non-Newtonian properties on the Saffman–Taylor instability. The effects of the non-Newtonian flow properties on the instability can in all cases be understood quantitatively by redefining the control parameter of the instability.