Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T12:14:13.900Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Ulster Awakened : The '59 Revival Reconsidered

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 April 2011

Myrtle Hill
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The 1859 revival has been granted a special place in Ulster's religious history. It is most often portrayed as a spontaneous and dramatic outpouring of the Holy Spirit, leading to the conversion of many thousands of men and women, and resulting in the moral and social reformation of a formerly sinful society. While this popular image requires a degree of modification in the interests of historical accuracy, the importance of the movement itself is not questioned. As Peter Gibbon ha pointed out, ‘the Ulster religious revival of 1859 involved larger numbers of people in sustained common activity than any movement in rura Ulster between 1798 and 1913’. Its value to the historian lies in its revelation of the attitudes of Ulster society — both religiouss and secular — to the popular, evangelical style of Protestantism which had been making steady progress in Ireland from the late eighteenth century. The dramatic visible and well-publicised nature of religious activity in 1859 serves to highlight the more controversial aspects of that faith, and indicates the degree of adjustment made by churchmen and laity to a movement wich largely ignored conventional ecclesiastical and social boundanes. It is the purpose of this paper to assess the impact of the events of 1859 on Ulster society and to consider its significance in the light of modern sociological approaches to the study of revivalism.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 41 , Issue 3 , July 1990 , pp. 443 - 462
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Gibbon, P., The Origins of Ulster Unionism: the formation of popular Protestant politics and ideology in nineteenth century Ireland, Manchester 1975 44.Google Scholar

2 Holmes, R. F. G., Our Irish Presbyterian Heritage, Belfast 1985, 121.Google Scholar

3 McLoughlin, W., Revivals, Awakenings and Reform : an essay on religion and sodai change in America, 1607–1977, Chicago 1978, p. xiii.Google Scholar

4 Paisley, I. R. K., The ‘Fifty Nine’ Revival, Belfast 1958, 11–12.Google Scholar

5 Scott, A. R., ‘The Ulster revival of 1859’, unpublished PhD diss., Trinity College, Dublin 1962Google Scholar; Hill, M., ‘The impact of evangelicalism on Ulster churches and society 1770–1850’, unpublished PhD diss., Queen's University, Belfast 1987.Google Scholar

6 Walsh, J., ‘The Great Awakening in the First Congregational Church of Woodbury, Connecticut’, William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd series xxviii (1971), 543–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

7 See the ‘Reports of the Committee on the State of Religion’, published in the Irish Presbyterian Missionary Herald (hereinafter cited as IPMH) from the 1840s.

8 Baxter, J., ‘The Great Yorkshire Revival 1792–6: a study of mass revival among the Methodists’, in A Sociological Yearbook of Religion in Britain vii, ed. Hill, M., 1974, 46–76Google Scholar; Hempton, D. N., ‘Methodism in Irish society, 1770–1830’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 5th series xxxvi (1986), 117–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Shaw, T., A History of Cornish Methodism, Truro 1967.Google Scholar

9 Miller, D., ‘Presbyterianism and “Modernization” in Ulster’, Past and Present lxxx (1980), 66–90.Google Scholar

10 Barkley, J. M., ‘The Arian schism in Ireland, 1830’, Studies in Church History, ix 323–40Google Scholar; Brooke, P., ‘Controversies in Ulster Presbyterianism: 1790–1836’ unpublished PhD dis., Cambridge 1981Google Scholar; Holmes, R. F. G.Henry Cooke, Belfast 1981Google Scholar; Thompson, J., ‘The inter-relationship of the Secession Synod and the Synod Ulster’, sunpublished PhD diss., Queen's University, Belfast 1980.Google Scholar

11 Minutes of the General Assembly, 1840–50, 139, 235, 322, 672, 690; Sibbett, R. M., For Christ and Crown: the story of a mission, Belfast 1926.Google Scholar For the temperance campaign see Winskill, P. T., The Temperance Movement and its Workers: a record of social, moral, religious and political progress, London 1892Google Scholar; Malcolm, E., Ireland Sober, Ireland Free, drink and temperance in nineteenth-century Ireland, Dublin 1986.Google Scholar

12 Minutes, 1840–50, 204; 8th Annual Report on Open-Air Preaching by Ministers of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland 1858, Belfast: 1859.

13 Barkley, J. M., ‘Tommy Toye — revivalist preacher’, Bulletin of the Presbyterian Historical Society of Ireland viii (Nov. 1978). 2–15Google Scholar; Boyd, A., Holy War in Belfast, 3rd edn, Belfast 1987, 10–44.Google Scholar

14 Minutes, 1840–50, 327–8, 484–5, 585, 672; Minutes of the General Assembly, 1851–60, 48–9, 185, 274, 364–7, 447.

15 Bailey, W. D., The Six Mile Water Revival of 1625, Newcastle 1976Google Scholar; Jennings, R. S., ‘The origins of Ulster Presbyterian revivalism, in the mid-nineteenth century’, partial fulfilment for M Theol., Queen's University, Belfast 1985Google Scholar; Westerkamp, M. J., Triumph of the Laity: Scots-Irish piety and the Great Awakening 1625–1760, Oxford 1988, 15–42.Google Scholar

16 Hanna, S. G., ‘The origin and nature of the Gracchill. Moravian settlement 1764–1855. With special reference to the work of John Cennick in Ireland 1746–1755’. unpublished MA diss., Queen's University, Belfast 1964.Google Scholar

17 Hempton, ‘Methodism in Irish society’; Hill, M., ‘Popular Protestanusm in Ulster in the post-Rebellion period c. 1790–1810’, Studies in Church History xxv (1988), 191–202.Google Scholar

18 G. Hamilton, The Great Necessity of Itinerant Preaching, Introductory Memorial to the Evangelical Society of Ulster, Armagh 1798; Wm. Gregory “Extracts of a Tour through the North of Ireland, engaged under the patronage of the Evangelia Society of Ulster, in the summer of the year 1800’, typescript in Linenhall Library Belfast.

19 Crockshank, C. H., History of Methodism in Ireland, 3 vols, London 1885-1888Google Scholar; Luker, D., ‘Revivalism in theory and practice’, this JOURNAL xxxvii (1986), 603–19.Google Scholar

20 O'Brien, S., ‘A transatlantic community of saints, the Great Awakening and the first evangelical network, 1735–1755’, The American Historical Review xci (1986), 811–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Edwin Orr, J., The Light of Kations: evangelical renewal and advance in the nineteenth century, Devon 1965.Google Scholar

21 Edwin Orr, J., The Second Evangelical Awakening in Britain, Edinburgh 1949, 17.Google Scholar

22 Minutes, 1840–50; Orr, op. cit. 39; Carwardine, R., Transatlantic Revivalism: popular evangelicalism in Britain and America, 1790–1865, Conneticut 1978, 170–4.Google Scholar

23 Minutes, 1840–50, 678; Thompson, J., ‘Irish Baptists and the 1859 revival’, Irish Baptist Historical Society Journal (hereinafter cited as IBHSJ) xvii (1984-1985), 4–10.Google Scholar

24 IPMH, Sept. 1858.

25 McLoughlin, , Revivals, 141.Google Scholar

26 Carwardine, , Transatlantic Revivalism, 172.Google Scholar

27 Jennings, ‘Origins of Ulster Presbyterian revivalism’.

28 The Revd Adams, D., The Revival at ahoghill, Its Narrative and Nature, Belfast 1859Google Scholar; Revd. Richey, W., Connor, and Coleraine: or scenes and sketches of the last Ulster awakening, Belfast 1870Google Scholar

29 Adams, op. ci., Orr, The Second Evangelical Awakening 40.

30 Orr, op. cit.; Gibson, W., The Year of Grace: a history of the Ulster revival of 1859, Belfast 1903Google Scholar; for details of the spread of the revival in counties Cavan and Monaghan see Brown, L. T., ‘The Presbyterians of Cavan and Monaghan: an immigrant community in South Ulster over three generations’, unpublished PhD diss., Queen's University, Belfast 1986, i. 326–69.Google Scholar

31 Carwardine, , Transatlantic Revivalism, 172–4Google Scholar; Kent, , Holding the Fort, 71–131Google Scholar; the Revd MacGill, H. M., The Present Revival of Religion in Scotland: A paper read at the Conference of the Evangelical Alliance, held at Nottingham, October 1860 (1860)Google Scholar; the Revd Venn, J., The Revival in Wales: A paper read at the Conference of the Evangelical alliance, held at Nottingham, October 1860Google Scholar, with subsequent additions (1860).

32 Crookshank, History of Methodism i; Lanktrce, Mathew, Biographical Narrative, Belfast 1836Google Scholar; Papers of Gideon Ouseley, Public Record Office of Northern Ireland (hereinafter cited as PRONI), CR6/3; Baxter, ‘Great Yorkshire revival’; Carwardine, , op. cit. 172–4.Google Scholar

33 Gibson, , Year of Grace, 82Google Scholar; Scott, , ‘Ulster revival’, 98, 209Google Scholar; Orr, Second Evangelical Awakening, 43; Carson, J. T., God's River in Spate, Belfast 1958, 63Google Scholar, 67, 124; Carwardine, , op. cit. 172.Google Scholar

34 Belfast Newsletter, Monday, 30 May 1859.

35 J. B. Armour to J. Megaw, Ballyboyland, 14 Sept. 1859, PRONI, Armour Papers, D1792.

36 Letters of the Revd E. Stopford on the Belfast Revival, 15, 18, 21 July 1859, Dublin, Representative Church Body Library, MS 77; the Revd Maguire, E., Fifty Eight Years of Clerical Life in the Church of Ireland, Dublin 1904, 22Google Scholar; Emerson, W. D., The Church of Ireland and the 1859 Revival, Belfast 1859, 6Google Scholar; Orr, op. cit. 184–5.

37 Repr. in Belfast Newsletter, 30 May 1859.

38 Gibson, , The Year of Grace, 100Google Scholar; Belfast Newsletter, 6 June 1859; the Revd Weir, J., The Ulster Awakening: its origin, progress and fruit with notes of a tour of personal observation and inquiry, London 1860, 93.Google Scholar

39 Adams, Revival at Ahoghill; the Revd Morgan, J., Thoughts on the Revival of 1859, Belfast 1859Google Scholar; McCann, A., The Sinkings Down and the Marks Vindicated, Belfast 1859.Google Scholar

40 The Revd E. Hicks, God's Works and Satan's Counter- Works, as now carried on in the North of Ireland: A Sermon preached in Killyleagh church on Sunday 31st July 1859, Belfast 1859; the Revd McIlwaine, W., Revivalism Renewed, Belfast 1859Google Scholar; the Revd Montgomery, J., The Holy Spirit: its nature and work: with a special reference to the movement now going on around us, called a Revival of Religion, Belfast 1859.Google Scholar

41 Armour to Megaw, 14 Sept. 1859.

42 Moore, F., The Truth abouth Ulster, London 1914, 188.Google Scholar

43 The Revd J. McCosh, The Ulster Revival and Its Physiological Accidents: A paper read before the Evangelical Alliance, September 22nd 1859, Belfast- 1860; the Revd Stopford, E., The Work and the Counter-Work, or the Religious Revival in Belfast, with an explanation of the Physical Phenomena, 4th edn, Dublin 1859Google Scholar; Weir, Ulster Awakening.

44 The Revd Nelson, I., The Year of Delusion: a review of The Year of Grace, 2nd edn, Belfast 1860, 25.Google Scholar

45 The Revd Hamilton, W., An Inquiry into The Scriptural Character of The Revival of 1859, Belfast 1866Google Scholar; MacNeece, T., Words of Caution and Counsel on the Present Religious Revival Addressed to his Parishioners, Belfast 1859.Google Scholar

46 The Revd Hamilton, T., History of the Irish Presbyterian Church, 43.Google Scholar

47 Baxter, , ‘Great Yorkshire revival’, 53–5.Google Scholar

48 Crookshanks, History of Methodism ii.

49 See letter from McIlvaine, bishop of Ohio, to the bishop of down and Connor, quoted in Gibson, , Year of Grace, 218.Google Scholar

50 The Missionary Herald of The Presbyterian Church in Ireland, 1 July 1859, 342.

51 Minutes of the General Assembly, 1815–60, 868.

52 See n. 36.

53 Emerson, Church of Ireland.

54 Gibson, , Year of Grace, 112Google Scholar; Orr, Secbd Evangelical Awakening, 184–207.

55 Currie, R., Gilbert, A. and Horsley, L., Churches and Churchgoers. Patterns of church growth in the British Isles since 1700, Oxford 1977, 38–45.Google Scholar

56 Minutes of the Presbyterian General Assembly.

57 Henry, J. M., ‘An assessment of the social, religious and political aspects of Congregationalism in Ireland in the nineteenth century’, unpublished PhD diss., Queen's University, Belfast 1965.Google Scholar

58 Thompson, ‘Irish Baptists’; Gribbon, H. D., ‘Irish Baptists in the 19th century: economic and social background’, IBHSJ xvi (1983-1984), 4–18Google Scholar; Coad, R., A History of the Brethren Movement, 2nd edn, Exeter 1976, 170–2.Google Scholar

59 Kingdon, D. P., ‘Irish Baptists and the revival of 1859 with special reference to Tobermore’, IBHSJ 1 (1968-1969), 19–30.Google Scholar

60 Belfast Newsletter, 1 June 1859; McMeekin, , Memories of '59, 43Google Scholar; Gibson, , Tear of Grace, 75.Google Scholar

61 McLcod, H., Religion and the People of Western Europe, 1789–1970, Oxford 1981, 39.Google Scholar

62 Kent, , Holding the Fort, 362–3.Google Scholar

63 Sibbet, , For Christ and Crown, 61.Google Scholar

64 Allen, W. E., The '59 Revival in Ireland, the United States of America, England, Scotland and Wales, Belfast 1955Google Scholar; Gibson, , op. cit. 75.Google Scholar

65 Belfast Newsletter, 30 May, 3, 8, 28 June 1859; McMeekin, , Memories of '59, 71.Google Scholar

66 Presbyterian Missionary Herald, 1 July 1859.

67 Carwardine, , Transatlantic Revivalism, 197.Google Scholar

68 For examples sec Belfast Newsletter, 13 June 1859; Orr, Second Evangelical Awakening, 49; Carson, , God's River in Spate, 120.Google Scholar

69 Gibbon, , Origins of Ulster Unionism, 45–65.Google Scholar

70 Turner, C. B., ‘Revivalism and Welsh society in the nineteenth century’, in Disciplines of Faith: studies in religion, politics and patriarchy, ed. Obelkivich, J., Roper, L., Samuel, R., London 1987, 311–23Google Scholar; Baxter, ‘Great Yorkshire Revival’; Hempton, ‘Methodism and Irish Society’.

71 Patterson, H., ‘Industrial labour and the labour movement, 1820–1914’, in An Economic History of Ulster 1820–1939, ed. Kennedy, L. and Ollerenshaw, P., Manchester 1985, 158–83.Google Scholar

72 McLcod, H., Religion and the Working-class in Nineteenth-century Britain, London 1984Google Scholar; Valenze, D., Prophetic Sons and Daughters, Princeton 1985Google Scholar; Prochaska, F., Women and Philanthropy in Nineteenth Century England, Oxford 1980.Google Scholar

73 Belfast Newsletter, 14 June 1859.

74 Orr, Second Evangelical Awakening, 205; Gibson, , Tear of Grace, 37Google Scholar, 196.

75 Kent, , Holding the Fort, 72.Google Scholar

76 Boyd, Holy War in Belfast.

77 Minutes, 1851–60, 364–7.

78 Letters and newscuttings dealing with riots in Belfast, 1857–8, Dublin, National Library of Ireland, Larcom Papers, MSS 7623, 7624; Haire, , The '59 Revival, 7Google Scholar; Orr, op. cit. 205.

79 Ford, A., ‘The Protestant Reformation in Ireland’, in Brady, G. and Gillespie, R. (eds), Natives and Newcomers: the making of Irish colonial society 1534–1641, Dublin 1986, 50–74.Google Scholar

80 Weir, , Ulster Awakening, 148–50Google Scholar; Buick's Ahoghill, Antrim 1987, 81; Reid, W., Authentic Records ofRevival, Belfast 1860, 161–73Google Scholar; Orr, Second Evangelical Awakening, 179; Gibson, Tear of Grace; Carson, , God's River in Spate, 96–9Google Scholar, 21; Scott, , ‘Ulster revival’, 402.Google Scholar

81 Kennedy, L., ‘The rural economy, 1820–1914’, in Kennedy and Ollerenshaw, Economic History, 1–61Google Scholar; Clarkson, L. A., ‘Population change and urbanisation, 1820–1911’,in Kennedy and Ollerenshaw, op. cit. 137–57.Google Scholar

82 Hempton, D. and Hill, M., ‘Godliness and good citizenship: evangelical Protestantism and social control in Ulster, 1790–1850’, Soathor xiii (1988), 68–80Google Scholar; Connolly, S.J., ‘Religion, work-discipline and economic attitudes: the case of Ireland’, in Devine, T. M. and Dickson, D. (eds), Ireland and Scotland 1600–1850, Glasgow 1983, 235–60Google Scholar; Kerrigan, C., ‘The social impact of the Irish Temperance Movement, 1839–1845’, Irish Economic and Social History xiv (1987), 20–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

83 Baxter, , ‘Great Yorkshire revival’, 59Google Scholar; McLoughlin, , Revivals, Awakenings and Reforms, 10.Google Scholar

84 Paisley, , The ‘Fifty-Nine’ Revival, 137.Google Scholar