Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T21:43:57.907Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Touching the Holy: The Rise of Contact Relics in Medieval England

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 March 2017

REBECCA BROWETT
REBECCA BROWETT*
Affiliation:
Institute of Historical Research, University of London, Senate House, Malet Street, London WC1E 7HU; e-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores the use and promotion of contact relics in medieval England. It argues that by the late eleventh and early twelfth century, large English monastic houses were uncomfortable with unauthorised individuals touching high status corporeal relics and so re-introduced and promoted contact relics as alternative objects of veneration. It argues that contact relics were an important aspect of English saints' cults until the Reformation, in a similar manner to Celtic and Brittonic cults.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 68 , Issue 3 , July 2017 , pp. 493 - 509
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The Lives and miracles of Sts Oda, Dunstan and Oswald, ed. Muir, Bernard J. and Turner, Andrew J., Oxford 2006, 308–13Google Scholar.

2 Kerr, Julie, Monastic hospitality: the Benedictines in England, c. 1070–c. 1250, Woodbridge 2007, 55Google Scholar.

3 Tom Licence, ‘The cult of St Edmund', in Licence, Tom (ed.), Bury St Edmunds and the Norman Conquest, Woodbridge 2014, 104–10 at p. 107Google Scholar; Crook, John, English medieval shrines, Woodbridge 2011, 16–18 Google Scholar; Rollason, D., Saints and relics in Anglo-Saxon England, Oxford 1989, 26–8Google Scholar.

4 Licence, ‘Cult of St Edmund’, 110.

5 See Smith, J. M. H., ‘Oral and written: saints, miracles, and relics in Brittany, c. 850–1250’, Speculum lxv/2 (Apr. 1990), 309–43Google Scholar.

6 Blair, John, ‘A saint for every minster? Local cults in Anglo-Saxon England’, in Thacker, Alan and Sharpe, Richard, Local saints and local churches in the early medieval West, Oxford 2002, 455–94 at p. 486CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Ibid.

8 ‘Seruabatur in aecclesia ipsa scifus quo sacer antistes, gloriosus uidelicet pater et pastor Osuualdus, bibere usum habuerat’: Eadmer, Miracula s. Oswaldi, ed. Bernard J. Muir and Andrew J. Turner, in The Lives and miracles of Sts Oda, Dunstan and Oswald, 310.

9 ‘Hoc uase in festo nobilissimi patris post refectionem, praemissa prece, potum libabant omnes fratres, pia Deoque accepta simplicitate in fide tenentes hoc sibi ad obtinendam tanti pontificis benedictionem non nichil profuturum. Hac itaque die a fratribus eiusdem scifi a liquore pro more libato, ultimo illi qui ultimus sedebat, infirmo uidelicet fratri, scifus ipse cum potu defertur’: ibid. 308–13.

10 ‘morbi sanies atque putredo uasi adhesit ut, redintegrata a languore maxilla, nullum praeteriti mali indicium deprehendi posset in illa’: ibid. 312–13.

11 Ibid. 312 n. 16.

12 The two Lives of St Cuthbert, ed. Colgrave, Bertram, Cambridge 1940, 303Google Scholar.

13 Eadmer, The miracles of St Oswald, 308.

14 Ibid. 304–5.

15 Ibid. 306 –7.

16 ‘Refectorius portabit ciphum Sancti Æthelwoldi in Depositione ejusdem Sancti in Refectorio tempore prandii cum pichicherio vini, et osculate eo ibi a ceteris fratribus portabitur ad infirmariam, videlicet ad mensam munitorum et ad qui capellam potuit adire et divinorum servitum audire; muniti vero eodem modo omnes solebant interesse. Postea portabitur ad aulam Prioris, et, osculate eo ibi a Priore et a ceteris fratribus et ab honoratis viris, remeat ad Refectorium’: A consuetudinary of the fourteenth century for the refectory of the house of St Swithun in Winchester, ed. Kitchin, G. W., London 1886, 31, 20–1Google Scholar.

17 Obedientiary rolls of St Swithun's, Winchester, ed. Kitchin, G. W., London 1892, 64–5Google Scholar.

18 Tinti, F., Pastoral care in late Anglo-Saxon England, Woodbridge 2005, 10–11 Google Scholar; Doran, S. and Dusden, C., Princes, pastors and people: the Church and religion in England, 1500–1700, London 2002, 87Google Scholar.

19 Such a cup features in Wulfstan of Winchester's Vita s. Æthelwoldi. After expelling the canons from the Old Minster, the envious clerics put poison in the bishop's drink, and ‘he drank, quite unawares, all the poison brought to him in a goblet’: Wulfstan of Winchester: the life of St Æthelwold, ed. Lapidge, Michael and Winterbottom, Michael, Oxford 1991, 34–5Google Scholar.

20 For records of mass items, including cups and chasubles see Dodwell, C. R., Anglo-Saxon art: a new perspective, Manchester 1982, 23Google Scholar.

21 Crook, John, ‘St Swithun of Winchester’, in Crook, John (ed.), Winchester cathedral: nine hundred years, 1093–1993, Chichester 1993, 57–68 at pp. 60–2Google Scholar, and English medieval shrines, 127.

22 Licence, ‘Cult of St Edmund’, 105, and ‘History and hagiography in the late eleventh century: the life and work of Herman the archdeacon, monk of Bury St Edmunds’, EHR cxxiv (2009), 516–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar at p. 532; Herman the archdeacon and Goscelin of Saint-Bertin, Miracles of St Edmund, ed. Licence, Tom, Oxford 2014, pp. liv–lixGoogle Scholar.

23 Miracles of St Edmund, p. cxii.

24 Yarrow, Simon, Saints and their communities: miracle stories in twelfth-century England, Oxford 2006, 30, 55Google Scholar.

25 See Thomson, R. M., ‘Two versions of a saint's Life from St Edmund's abbey’, Revue benedictine lxxxiv (1974), 385–9Google Scholar.

26 Memorials of St Edmund's abbey, ed. Arnold, Thomas, London 1890, ii. 307Google Scholar.

27 Ibid. i. 187.

28 Ibid. i. 189–91.

29 Ibid. i. 202–4.

30 The Peterborough chronicle of Hugh Candidus, ed. Mellows, C. and Mellows, W. T., Peterborough 1941, 55–6Google Scholar.

31 ‘Quapropter uas unum in quo de ipsa aqua assidue seruatur in aecclesia Saluatoris Cantuariae habetur, uidelicet ne ii quid ea indigent aliqua mora uel incommodo ab adipiscenda sanitate praepediantur. Nam fere cotidie illuc pro ea pluribus curritur, et certa medicina egrotantibus inde defertur’: Eadmer, Miracles of St Dunstan, 210–11.

32 ‘quoniam res ita euidens est et usitata, ut plus nonnunquam mirabile uideatur, cum aliquis aqua in potum sumpta ab infirmitate non sanatur, quam cum sanatur’: ibid.

33 Bede, Historia ecclesiastica gentis anglorum, ed. Colgrave, B. and Mynors, R. A. B., Oxford 1969, iii. 9Google Scholar. For the diffusion of Oswald's early cult see Thacker, A., ‘Membra disjecta: the division of the body and the diffusion of the cult’, in Stancliffe, Clare and Cambridge, Eric (eds), Oswald: Northumbrian king to European saint, Stamford 1995, 97–127 Google Scholar.

34 Bede, Historia ecclesiastica iv. 19.

35 Alan Thacker, ‘The making of a local saint’, in Thacker and Sharpe, Local saints and local churches, 45–74.

36 Nancy Edwards, ‘Celtic saints and early medieval archaeology’, ibid. 225–65 at p. 226.

37 Gerald of Wales, Itinerarium Kambriae, ed. Dimock, J. S., London 1868, i. 2Google Scholar, trans. in Edwards, ‘Celtic saints and early medieval archaeology’, 252.

38 Edwards, ‘Celtic saints and early medieval archaeology’, 253, 261–2; Lucas, A. T., ‘The social role of relics and reliquaries in ancient Ireland’, Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland mcxvi (1986), 5–37 at pp. 29–31Google Scholar.

39 Edwards, ‘Celtic saints and early medieval archaeology’, 225–66; Davies, John Reuben, ‘Cathedrals and the cult of the saints in eleventh and twelfth-century Wales’, in Dalton, Paul, Insley, Charles and Wilkinson, Louise J., Cathedrals, communities and conflict in the Anglo-Norman world, Woodbridge 2011, 99–116 Google Scholar.

40 Edwards, ‘Celtic saints and early medieval archaeology’, 225; Davies, ‘Cathedrals and the cult of the saints’, 107.

41 Töpfer, Bernhard, ‘The cult of relics and pilgrimage’, in Head, Thomas and Landes, Richard (eds), The peace of God: social violence and religious response in France around the year 1000, New York 1992, 41–57 Google Scholar.

42 Liber Eliensis, ed. E. O. Blake (Camden 3rd ser. xcii,1962), 228–330. For discussion of translation trends after the Conquest see Sharpe, R., ‘The setting of St Augustine's translation, 1091’, in Eales, R. and Sharpe, R. (eds), Canterbury and the Norman Conquest: churches, saints and scholars, 1066–1109, London 1995, 1–13 at pp. 9, 12Google Scholar.

43 ‘Quod si conuenerint aliqui, uel clerici el laici, uolentes adorare crucem, portetur eius crux in alium locum ubi aptius adorent eam’: Monastic constitutions of Lanfranc, ed. Knowles, David, rev. Brooke, Christopher N. L., Oxford 2002, 62–3Google Scholar. See also Hicks, Leonie V., Religious life in Normandy, 1050–1300: space, gender and social pressure, Woodbridge 2007, 75Google Scholar.

44 Crook, John, The architectural setting of the cult of saints in the early Christian West, c. 300–c. 1200, Oxford 2000, 233Google Scholar.

45 Ibid.

46 Slocum, Kay Brainerd, Liturgies in honour of Thomas Becket, Toronto 2004, 84Google Scholar.

47 Tatton-Brown, Tim, ‘Canterbury and the architecture of pilgrimage shrines in England’, in Morris, Colin and Roberts, Peter (eds), Pilgrimage: the English experience from Becket to Bunyan, Cambridge 2002, 90–107 at p. 94Google Scholar, and ‘The burial places of St Osmund’, Spire (1999), 19–25.

48 Webb, Diana, Pilgrimage in medieval England, London 2000, 83 n. 77Google Scholar.

49 Goscelin of Saint-Bertin: the hagiography of the female saints of Ely, ed. Love, Rosalind C., Oxford 2004, 72CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

50 Wilmart, A., ‘De reliquiis Sancti Audeoni et quorundam aliorum sanctorum quae Cantuariae in aecclesia Domini Salvatoris habentur’, Revue des sciences religieuses xv (1935), 362–70 at pp. 367–9Google Scholar.

51 Eadmer, Miracles of St Oswald, 300–1.

52 ‘La Vie de S. Édouard le Confesseur par Osbert de Clare’, ed. M. Bloch, Analecta Bollandiana xli (1923), 5–131 at p. 121.

53 Goscelin of Saint-Bertin: the hagiography of the female saints of Ely, 76–7 n. 2.

54 ‘Habeant ex hoc quilibet sacrarum indigni attrectatores reliquarum quia nisi cum cordis munditia et humilitate id debent presumere’: ibid. 129.

55 Eadmer, The life of St Anselm archbishop of Canterbury, ed. Southern, R. W., Oxford 1962, 158Google Scholar.

56 ‘Solenne etenim jam hominibus quaquaversum egrotantibus extat, et maxime mulieribus in partu periclitantibus ipsum cingulum devote mentis intentione expetere’: ibid. 165.

57 Licence, ‘Cult of St Edmund’, 109–10.

58 ‘Exuitur itaque sanctus sancti martyrii uestibus, partim rubeis rubore sanguinis, partim perforates ictibus telorum crebis’: Herman, Miracles of St Edmund, 55

59 Ibid. 80–2. For a detailed distribution of Edmund's contact relics by Baldwin see Licence, ‘Cult of St Edmund’, 109–10.

60 Herman, Miracles of St Edmund, 84.

61 ‘Exuuie uero martyris in seruatorio reconduntur cum phylacteriis, unde de sacrario diuinitatis presto sunt beneficia multis, ad laudem eius, qui cum patre et spiritu sancto uiuit et regnat Deus’: ibid. 55.

62 ‘Cur sic irreuerenter reuerenda tractastis?… An obliuio iam sepeliuit, quod heri perpetratum est? Camisia sancti quam ob uulgi fauorem captandum publicis optutibus ingessistis – dum incaute minusue diligenter oppanditur, sacer sanguis quo infecta fuerat humi decidit et periit’: Goscelin, Miracles of St Edmund, 294–5.

63 Licence, ‘Cult of St Edmund’, 18.

64 ‘de peculiari fratrum familiaritate presumentes, uiciniora reuerende tumulationi loca petierunt’: Goscelin, Miracles of St Edmund, 227.

65 Licence, ‘Cult of St Edmund’, 18.

66 ‘Campana illius pulsetur de portando ad processionem et post missam deportetur ad cameram domine abbatisse replete uino ut omnes ex ea bibant. deinde ad cameras reliquas monialium modo predicto’: Ordinale and customary of the Benedictine nuns of Barking Abbey, ed. Tohurst, J. B. L., London 1927, ii. 222Google Scholar, trans. in Yardley, Anne Bagnall, ‘Liturgy as the site of creative engagement’, in Brown, Jennifer N. (ed.), Barking Abbey and medieval literary culture: authorship and authority in a female community, Woodbridge 2012, 267–82 at p. 272Google Scholar.

67 For Erkenwald's cult see Thacker, Alan, ‘The cult of the saints and the liturgy’, in Keene, Derek, Burns, Arthur and Saint, Andrew (eds), St Paul's: the cathedral church of London, 604–2004, New Haven 2008, 113–22Google Scholar.

68 Letters and papers, foreign and domestic, Henry VIII, ed. Gairdner, James, London 1892, xiii/2, 101Google Scholar.

69 These sources, which were written for political purposes, and probably included the subsection ‘superstitions’ to undermine and discredit the monasteries, must be viewed critically, but it is unlikely that the documentation of monasteries’ relics is falsified.

70 Letters and papers, Henry VIII, x. 137–44.

71 Ibid. x. 142.

72 Ibid. It is suggestive that in 1400–1 John Knowte, a goldsmith, was paid 4s. for making a cross for the banner of St Cuthbert, hooks for the shrine and for ‘repairing a cup belonging to the refectory’ associated with St Cuthbert: ‘Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries, Newcastle Upon-Tyne: the banner of Saint Cuthbert’, Gentleman's Magazine and Historical Review (Jan.–June 1857), 458–64 at p. 462.

73 See I. G. Thomas, ‘The cult of saints’ relics in medieval England', unpubl. PhD diss. York 1974, 73–87, 239–42, 280–4.

74 William of Malmesbury: Gesta pontificum anglorum, ed. Winterbottom, M., Oxford 2007, iGoogle Scholar, iii. 4, 419.

75 For the development of Æthelwold's cult in the High Middle Ages see Rebecca Browett, ‘The cult of St Æthelwold and its context’, unpubl. PhD diss. London 2017.