Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-02T20:26:18.240Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Between Reform and Reformation: The English Church in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 April 2011

Peter Heath
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Forty years ago the story of the Church in late medieval England was a simple one and not very different from the version which had prevailed half a century before that. The interpretation presented by W. Capes in 1900 had been slightly modified but largely underlined by 1950, and the Church and its development which was commonly depicted in that year would not have been strikingly unfamiliar to him. The current version was that, after the reforming efforts of the thirteenth century, which failed to achieve their end, and the advent of the friars, who even by the middle of that century were departing from their earlier zeal and purity, the Church in the following hundred years was exploited by the pope when it was not saved or oppressed by the Crown. The resulting corruption of the clergy contributed to its negligence and provoked an eruption of heresy which in due course was savagely suppressed and virtually expunged; rid of this threat, the fifteenth-century clergy were so notorious for their laxity, greed and mediocrity that a few devout members of the laity, perhaps inspired by the mystical writings, took refuge in private devotions which anticipated the individualism of the Protestant. The Reformation was viewed as the inescapable result of these circumstances.

Type
Bibliographical Surveys IV
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 41 , Issue 4 , October 1990 , pp. 647 - 678
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The English Church in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries, London 1900, repr. 1909.

2 See Vickers, K. H., England in the Later Middle Ages, London 1913, 6th edn 1937Google Scholar; Cam, Helen, England before Elizabeth, London 1950Google Scholar; and, for the fullest and most balanced account then available, Myers, A. R., England in the Late Middle Ages (1347–1536), London 1952Google Scholar, rev. edn 1956. For the background to the Church in this period, see Moorman, J. R. H., Church Life in England in the Thirteenth Century, Cambridge 1945.Google Scholar

3 Oxford 1947.

4 Cambridge 1955.

5 Manchester 1943, 2nd edn enlarged, 1953. One of the reprinted papers (‘English conciliar activity, 1395–1418’) had originally been published in 1931.

6 In 4 vols, CYS 1943–7.

7 London 1952.

8 Posthumously, in Lancastrian Kings and Lollard Knights, Oxford 1972.Google Scholar

9 Oxford 1926.

10 Scottish Historical Review xi (1914), 55–92.

11 2 vols, Oxford 1964.

12 Respectively at Oxford 1957–9 and Cambridge 1963.

13 12 vols, one of which concerns the monastic cathedrals, one the Welsh; London 1962–7.

14 London 1981.

15 Oxford 1952.

16 Cambridge 1980.

17 Toronto 1980.

18 Toronto 1986.

19 Respectively, BIHR xliv (1971), 153–61, and ibid, xlviii (1975), 149–61.

20 Ecclesia Militons: Studien zur Konzilien- und Reformationsgeschichte i, ed. Brandmüller, W., Immenköter, H. and Iserloh, E., Paderborn 1988, 129–55.Google Scholar

21 This JOURNAL x (1959), 139–52.

22 Annuarium Historiae Pontificiae xix (1981), 97–146.

23 London 1966.

24 Oxford 1967.

25 PhD diss., Cornell University 1970, Ann Arbor 1986.

26 In Church, Politics and Patronage in the Fifteenth Century, ed. Dobson, R. B., Gloucester 1984, 82–98.Google Scholar

27 London 1967.

28 London 1947.

29 TRHS, 5th ser. xii (1952), 1–23; repr. in Essays in Late Medieval History, Manchester 1968.

30 Respectively the Register of John Morton, Archbishop of Canterbury 1486–1500 i (CYS 1987); this JOURNAL xxix (1978), 1–21; and Journal of Religious History x (1979), 236–52.

31 EHR cii (1987), 2–30.

32 The Register of William Melton, Archbishop of York 1317–1340 i, ed. Hill, R. M. T. (CYS, 1977)Google Scholar; ii, ed. D. Robinson (CYS, 1978). For Butler's article see this JOURNAL ii (1951), 54–68.

33 BJRL liv (1971–2), 173–213.

34 Ibid, lix (1976–7), 40–74.

35 See Borthwick Texts and Calendars. Records of the northern province viii, xi, York 1981, 1985; and, for Hughes, n. 166 below.

36 PhD diss., Emory University, 1973, Ann Arbor 1979.

37 Cambridge 1983.

38 Cambridge 1978.

39 London 1961.

40 Respectively in this JOURNAL xix (1968), 11–40, and xxv (1974), 225–47; Medieval Studies xxxiv (1972), 435–61.

41 Oxford 1988.

42 Oxford 1975.

43 TRHS, 5th ser. vi (1956), 115–38.

44 See his articles, some of which are itemised below, in JMH i (1975), 329–62; Speculum li (1976), 659–93; BJRL lix (1976–7), 40–74; EHR xcii (1977). 309–44; and n. 22 above.

45 In Profession, Vocation and Culture in Late Medieval England, ed. Clough, C. H., Liverpool 1982, 51–89.Google Scholar

46 Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society cxxix (1985), 30–81.

47 In The Church in Reformation Society, ed. Barron, C. M. and Harper-Bill, C., Woodbridge 1985. 199–211.Google Scholar

48 In Church, Politics and Patronage, 146–67.

49 EHR xcii (1977), 309–44.

50 For the first of these articles see n. 29 above; for the other two see, respectively, Proceedings of the British Academy xxxvii (1951), 121–53 (repr. in Essays in Late Medieval History); and Essays in History Presented to Sir Keith Feiling, ed. Trevor-Roper, H. R., London 1965, 61–83.Google Scholar

51 PhD diss., Columbia University 1976, Ann Arbor 1979.

52 London 1983.

53 University of Birmingham Historical Journal vi (1958), 108–31.

54 American Philosophical Society, 1970.

55 See Heath, P., English Parish Clergy on the Eve of the Reformation, London 1969.Google Scholar

56 Borthwick Papers xxxvii, 1969.

57 See n. 157 below.

58 London Record Society Publications xiii, 1977.

59 Speculum xlv (1970), 197–215.

60 Respectively, VCH Staffordshire iii (1970), 140–99Google Scholar; A History of St Paul's Cathedral, ed. Matthews, W. R. and Atkins, V. V. M., London 1957, 38–100Google Scholar; A History of York Minster, ed. Aylmer, G. E. and Cant, R., Oxford 1977, 44–109Google Scholar; VCH Wiltshire in (1957), 156–210.Google Scholar

61 This JOURNAL xxx (1979), 145–74.

62 Ibid, xxxii (1981), 265–83.

63 In The Church in Pre-Reformation Society, 158–69.

64 Northern History xix (1983), 15–44.

65 Manchester 1970.

66 Cambridge 1965.

67 Cambridge 1982.

68 Cambridge, Mass. 1979.

69 See n, 149 below.

70 Annuarium Historiae Conciliorum vii (1975), 290–313.

71 Princeton 1985.

72 Canadian Historical Journal iv (1969), 1–22.

73 Medieval Studies xxiv (1962), 263–302.

74 Speculum lv (1980), 696–714.

75 In The University in Society i, ed. Stone, L., Princeton 1974, 111–49.Google Scholar

76 Past and Present cvi (1985), 28–61.

77 Northern History v (1970), 12–33.

78 In Patronage, the Crown and the Provinces in Later Medieval England, ed. Griffiths, R. A., Gloucester 1981, 167–80.Google Scholar

79 Cambridge 1983.

80 In People, Politics and Community in the Later Middle Ages, ed. Rosenthal, J. and Richmond, C., Gloucester 1987, 19–39.Google Scholar

81 3 vols, Cambridge 1948, 1955, 1959.

82 Leicester 1970.

83 Oxford 1977.

84 Cambridge 1973.

85 Hampshire Record Series, 1978.

86 History xxvi (1941), 204–12.

87 Oxford 1962.

88 SCH xii (1975), 133–41.

89 Cambridge 1987.

90 In Church, Politics and Patronage, 45–81.

91 Speculum xli (1966), 209–45.

92 Studies in Medieval and Renaissance History vii (1970), 79–210.

93 Journal of Church and Stale xi (1969), 111–31.

94 Toronto 1968.

95 Traditio xix (1963), 295–349.

96 London 1962.

97 DPhil diss., Oxford University 1978.

98 Cambridge 1974.

99 Minnesota Law Review lx (1976), 1,011–33, repr. in Helmholz, R. H., Canon Law and the Law of England, London 1988.Google Scholar

100 Medieval Studies xliii (1981), 297–314; also in Canon Law and the Law of England.

101 Medieval Legal Records, ed. Hunnisett, R. F. and Post, J. B., London 1978, 342–408.Google Scholar

102 Borthwick Papers xvi, 2nd edn, 1972.

103 Oxford 1952.

104 Cambridge, Mass. 1981.

105 For Denton and McHardy see nn. 16 and 58 above; for Rogers see BIHR xliv (1973), 123–44. A general discussion and survey are to be found in Heath, P., Church and Realm 1222–1461, London 1988.Google Scholar

106 In Church, Politics and Patronage, 168–92.

107 London 1961.

108 BIHR li (1978), 72–8.

109 In Church and Government in the Middle Ages, ed. Brooke, C. N. L., Luscombe, D. E., Martin, G. H. and Owen, D. M., Cambridge 1976, 247–74.Google Scholar

110 Cambridge, Mass. 1962.

111 American Philosophical Society, 1968.

112 Journal of Medieval History ii (1976), 339–64.

113 In War, Literature and Politics in the Late Middle Ages, ed. Allmand, C. T., Liverpool 1976, 169–89.Google Scholar

114 London 1972.

115 See n. 22 above.

116 See n. 42 above.

117 EHR lxxxiii (1968), 516–22.

118 In Medieval Studies Presented to Aubrey Gwynn, ed. Watt, J. A., Morrall, J. B. and Martin, F. X., Dublin 1961, 349–58.Google Scholar

119 Kirchengeschichtliche Quellen und Studien xii (1983).

120 Cambridge 1979. Swanson, though, was not one of Jacob's students.

121 Historical Studies. Fifth conference of Irish historians iv (1963), 93–110.

122 SCH xii (1971), 219–27. The other articles are: ‘The first English delegation to the Council of Basel’, this JOURNAL xii (1961), 167–96; ‘The second English delegation to the Council of Basel’, ibid xvii (1966), 29–64; and ‘England, the pope, and the Council of Basel, 1435–1449’, Church History xxxiii (1964), 248–78.

123 See n. 44 above.

124 Archivum Historiae Pontificiae xxiv (1986), 49–70.

125 SCH xxiv (1987), 161–73.

126 Archivum Historiae Pontificiae viii (1970), 139–78.

127 London 1965.

128 Oxford 1988.

129 Respectively SCH ii (1965), 220–36; in The Church and Changing Society. Proceedings of the CIHEC Conference in Uppsala 1977, Uppsala 1978; and SCH ix (1972), 109–30.

130 SCH, Subsidia v (1987).

131 Leiden 1974.

132 2 vols, Manchester 1967.

133 New York 1968.

134 PhD diss., York University 1975.

135 Oxford 1965.

136 Originally Past and Present xvii (1960), 1–44; repr. in idem, Lollards and Reformers: images and literacy in late medieval religion, London 1984.

137 History lxii (1977), 347–71, and in Lollards and Reformers.

138 See n. 90 above.

139 ‘William White's Lollard followers’, Catholic Historical Review lxviii (1982), 469–97, and in Lollards and Reformers.

140 Camden Society, 4th ser. xx, 1977.

141 Cambridge 1978.

142 Vol. i, Oxford 1983; vol. ii, ed. P. Gradon, Oxford 1988.

143 Both are to be found in Wyclif and His Times, ed. Kenny, A., Oxford 1986Google Scholar; for other relevant studies, see Hudson, A., Lollards and their Books, London 1985.Google Scholar

144 Toussaert, J., Le Sentiment religieux en Flandre à la fin du Moyen Age, Paris 1960.Google Scholar

145 Delaruelle, E., ‘La vie religieuse du peuple chrétien’, in L'Église au temps du Grande Schisme et de la crise conciliaire, Paris 1964Google Scholar, vol. xiv of Histoire de l'Église originally edited by A. Fliehe and V. Martin.

146 In History and Imagination. Essays in honour of H. R. Trevor-Roper, ed. Lloyd Jones, H., Pearl, V. and Worden, B., London 1981, 43–55.Google Scholar

147 Oxford 1988. For an almost identical account, see idem, ‘The household as a religious community’, in People, Politics and Community, 123–39.

148 London 1972.

149 In The Church in Pre-Reformation Society, 123–42.

150 Transactions of the Bristol and Gloucestershire Archaeological Society xcviii (1982), 99–112.

151 In England in the Fifteenth Century, ed. Williams, Daniel, Woodbridge 1987, 53–74.Google Scholar

152 In Property and Politics: essays in late medieval English history, ed. Pollard, T., Gloucester 1984, 36–58.Google Scholar

153 Borthwick Papers 1, 1976.

154 In Church, Politics and Patronage, 193–208.

155 This JOURNAL xxxvi (1985), 46–65.

156 In Church, Politics and Patronage, 209–34.

157 Toronto 1984.

158 In The Church in Pre-Reformation Society, 13–37.

159 SCH, xxiii (1986), 97–109.

160 In Parish, Church and People, ed. Wright, S. J., Leicester 1988, 29–55.Google Scholar

161 In People, Politics and the Community, 108–22.

162 Past and Present xcviii (1983), 3–29.

163 In Church, Politics and Patronage, 99–114.

164 Oxford 1970. For a brief discussion of the musical innovations, and for further references, see pp. 55–9 of the article by Burgess listed in n. 155 above.

165 TRHS, 5th ser. xviii (1968), 97–121.

166 Woodbridge 1988.

167 Journal of Religious History xiv (1987), 361–81.

168 Speculum xlii (1966), 53–67.

169 Respectively Oxford 1924 and 1939.

170 Princeton 1977.

171 In Parish, Church and People, 56–85.

172 ‘The Cordyal’ by Anthony Woodville, Earl Rivers, ed. Mulders, J. A., Nijmegen 1962.Google Scholar

173 See n. 156 above and the appendixes in Pape, T., Medieval Newcastle-under-Lyme, Manchester 1928Google Scholar, and idem, Newcastle-under-Lynxe in Tudor and Stuart Times, Manchester 1938.

174 ‘Popular religion and the Pilgrimage of Grace’, in Order and Disorder in Early Modern England, ed. Fletcher, A. and Stevenson, J., Cambridge 1985, 79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

175 ‘The shape of anti-clericalism and the English Reformation’, in Politics and Society in Reformation Europe: essays for Sir Geoffrey Elton, ed. Kouri, E. I. and Scott, T., London 1987, 379–410.CrossRefGoogle Scholar