Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T13:22:42.681Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Piety and Politics in Nineteenth Century Poitiers: The Cult of St Radegund

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 February 2009

Brian Brennan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

St Radegund, a sixth-century royal ascetic who relinquished her position as the wife of a Frankish king and established a convent in Poitiers, is today a rather obscure French local saint. Yet in the nineteenth century, as a result of the tireless promotion of her cult by Édouard Pie, bishop of Poitiers from 1849 to 1880, St Radegund was widely invoked in France as ‘la sainte reine de la France’ and ‘la mère de la patrie’. Her wonder-working tomb, a popular devotional site in the Middle Ages, offered cures and Pie saw to it that the pilgrim trains to Lourdes made an obligatory prayer-stop at Poitiers. This article analyses devotion to St Radegund during the Second Empire and the Third Republic and explores some of the religious and political connotations of the cult of this royal saint. The development of the cult is particularly significant for it allows us to see, reflected on the local level, something of the larger struggle for national self-definition that was taking place in nineteenth-century French society as royalists contended with Bonapartists and republicans, clericals waged war against secularists and the ultramontanes sought to rouse their fellow countrymen in support of Pius IX.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 47 , Issue 1 , January 1996 , pp. 65 - 81
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Brennan, B., ‘St Radegund and the early development of her cult at Poitiers’, Journal of Religious History xiii (1985), 340–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Aigrain, R., Sainte Radegonde, Paris 1918Google Scholar; Brittain, F., Saint Radegund, Cambridge 1925, 52Google Scholar; Filleau, J., La preuve historique des litanies de la grande reyne de France S. Radegonde, Poitiers 1643, 240–5Google Scholar, recording miracles from 1240 to 1562; Largeault, A. and Bodenstaff, H., Miracles de Sainte Radegonde (XIIIe et XIV siècle), Brussels 1904Google Scholar.

2 L'Abeille de la Vienne, 8 Dec. 1849, as quoted in Baunard, L., Histoire du Cardinal Pie, évêque de Poitiers, ii, Paris 1893, 240Google Scholar.

3 de Fleury, M. E., Histoire de Sainte Radegonde, Poitiers 1843, 322–3Google Scholar; Briand, E., Manuel de l'archiconfrérie de Sainte Radegonde, Poitiers 1883, 6Google Scholar.

4 Brittain, , Saint Radegund, 53Google Scholar. Briand, E., Histoire de Ste Radegonde, reine de France et patronne du Poitou, sanctuaires-pèlerinages en son honneur, Poitiers 1887, 256–7Google Scholar.

5 Tackett, T., Religion, revolution and regional culture in eighteenth-century France: the ecclesiastical oath of 1791, Princeton, NJ 1986, 368Google Scholar.

6 Labande, E.-R. and others, Histoire de l'abbaye Sainte-Croix de Poitiers, Poitiers 1986, 437–9, 453Google Scholar.

7 Kselman, T., Miracles and prophecies in nineteenth-century France, New Brunswick, NJ 1983, 76Google Scholar; Sevrin, E., Les missions religieuses en France sous la restauration (1814–30), ii, Paris 1959, 247–51Google Scholar.

8 Gough, A., ‘Bishop Pie's campaign against the nineteenth century: Catholic legitimism and liberal Bonapartism at Poitiers during the Second Empire’, in Zeldin, T. (ed.), Conflicts in French society: anti-clericalism, education and morals in the nineteenth century, London 1970, 96Google Scholar; Catta, E., La doctrine politique et sociale du Cardinal Pie, Paris 1959, 321–48Google Scholar; de Buzon, C., Henri V, comte de Chambord, Paris 1987, 120–36Google Scholar.

9 Gough, , ‘Bishop Pie's campaign,’ 105, 111–12, 147Google Scholar.

10 De Fleury, , Histoire, 377–82Google Scholar.

11 Baunard, , Histoire du Cardinal Pie, i. 272–3Google Scholar; Auber, Abbé, Inauguration de la chaisse de Ste Radegonde et de la crypte de l'église paroissale 13 August 1854, Poitiers 1854, 10Google Scholar.

12 Boulard, F. and others, Matériaux pour l'histoire religieuse du peuple français XlXe–XXe siècles, Paris 1982, i. 395–403Google Scholar, provides no figures for Poitiers before 1913.

13 Gough, , ‘Bishop Pie's campaign’, 111–12Google Scholar.

14 Quoted ibid. 163–5.

15 Eschoyez, C., Origines de l'abbaye royale de Sainte-Croix, Poitiers 1865, 28–9Google Scholar.

16 Joséphine de Marans, Superior of Sainte Croix to Oudin, M. Devouloir of L'Univers, 01 1854, AEP, 570 Ste RadegondeGoogle Scholar; Joséphine de Marans to Mgr Pie, 6 Aug. 1854, ibid.; Labande, and others, Histoire de l'abbaye, 450–61Google Scholar.

17 Demandes de reliques hors du diocèse de Poitiers, 1860s, 1870s, AEP, 570 Ste Radegonde.

18 Baunard, , Histoire du Cardinal Pie, i. 273Google Scholar.

19 Auber, , Inauguration, 15Google Scholar.

20 Boutry, P., ‘Les saints des Catacombes. Itinéraires français d'une piété ultramontaine (1800–1881)’, Mélanges de l'École française de Rome. Moyen âge-temps modernes xci (1979), 875–930CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cholvy, G. and Hilaire, Y.-M., Histoire religieuse de la France contemporaine, i. Toulouse 1985, 160Google Scholar.

21 Devlin, J., The superstitious mind: French peasants and the supernatural in the nineteenth century, New Haven, Conn. 1987, 6–18, 83–92Google Scholar; Kselman, , Miracles and prophecies, 25–36Google Scholar.

22 Devlin, , Superstitious mind, 7–8Google Scholar.

23 Ibid. 52–4. See also Cholvy, and Hilaire, , Histoire religieuse, i. 111–13Google Scholar.

24 Briand, E., Vie populaire de Ste Radegonde, reine de France et patronne du Poitiers, Poitiers 1891, 62Google Scholar; Brittain, , Saint Radegund, 54Google Scholar.

25 Ibid. On the practice elsewhere see Kselman, , Miracles and prophecies, 27Google Scholar.

26 Ibid. 26.

27 Briand, E., Vie populaire, 62Google Scholar; Brittain, , Saint Radegund 54Google Scholar.

28 Ibid.

29 Brittain, F., The lyfe of Saynt Radegunde, edited from the copy in Jesus College Library, Cambridge 1926, p. xviGoogle Scholar. On the practice of food offerings see Devlin, , Superstitious mind, 55Google Scholar.

30 Brittain, , Lyfe of Saynt Radegunde, p. xviGoogle Scholar.

31 Gallet, A., Pélerinages à Tours et à Poitiers: lettres à un vicaire Vendéen, Nantes 1865, 88Google Scholar. For the history of the shrine and this devotion see Briand, , Histoire, 213–19Google Scholar, and Ginot, E., Le manuscrit de Sainte Radegonde de Poitiers et ses peintures du Xle siècle, Paris 1920, 45Google Scholar.

32 Baudonivia, , Vita Radegundis 20. ed. Krusch, B., MGH SS rer. Mer. ii. 391Google Scholar.

33 Auber, , Inauguration, 20Google Scholar. See also du Boisrouvray, B., Monseigneur Gay, évêque d'Anthedon, auxiliaire de son eminence le Cardinal Pie, Tours 1921, i. 50–62Google Scholar.

34 Gallet, , Pèlerinages, 84Google Scholar.

35 For the debate about the feminisation of religion see Gibson, R., A social history of French Catholicism 1789–1914, London 1989, 152–3Google Scholar; Kselman, , Miracles and prophecies, 54–6Google Scholar.

36 Fortunatus, , Vita Radegundis 5, MGH SS rer. Mer. ii. 366–7Google Scholar; Pie, , ‘Sermon to the pilgrims from Paris’, 17 08 1874Google Scholar, in Oeuvres de monseigneur l'évêque de Poitiers, Cardinal Pie, 9 vols, Poitiers 1879, viii. 173Google Scholar: ‘Elle avait quitté son époux humain, le roi couronné d'un diadème terrestre; en épousant un autre roi, le roi couronné d'épines, elle avait épouse sa croix sans réserve.’

37 Langlois, C., Le Catholicisme au feminin: les congrégations françaises à supérieure générale au XIXe siècle, Paris 1984, 642–7Google Scholar.

38 Labande, and others, Histoire de l'abbaye, 457Google Scholar.

39 Pie, , ‘Sermon to the pilgrims from Paris’, 174Google Scholar.

40 Briand, , Vie populaire, 62Google Scholar; Brittain, , Saint Radegund, 54Google Scholar.

41 Briand, , Vie populaire, 25Google Scholar, and the painting ‘Miracle des avoines’; used as a frontispiece. On the possible origin of the story in folk tale see Brittain, , Lyfe of Saynt Radegunde, pp. xv–xvi, 18–9Google Scholar.

42 Fortunatus, , Vita Radegundis 24, MGH SS rer. Mer. ii., 372Google Scholar. Note the hymn in de Fleury, , Histoire, 336Google Scholar. This was also a theme in the sermon given by Mgr Freppel of Angers: Briand, E., Les fêtes du treizième centenaire et du couronnement de Ste Radegonde à Poitiers: documents relatifs à ces fêtes, Poitiers 1887, 42–4Google Scholar.

43 Baudonivia, , Vita Radegundis 10, MGH SS rer. Mer. ii. 384–5Google Scholar; Pie, , ‘Sermon on the role of the holy queen in time of war’, 14 08 1870, in Oeuvres, vi. 600Google Scholar.

44 Pie, , ‘Sermon to the pilgrims from Paris’, 175Google Scholar.

45 Devlin, , The superstitious mind, 7–8Google Scholar; Gibson, , Social history, 144Google Scholar.

46 Kselman, , Miracles and prophecies, 47–9Google Scholar.

47 See Briand, , Manuel, 108–28Google Scholar, for a description of the cure.

48 Guérisons obtenues par l'intercession de Ste Radegonde, dépositions, Mandement of 20 Jan. 1861, AEP, 570 Ste Radegonde.

49 Guérisons, printed account, dated 17 June 1867, of cure of Annette Gaudon of Le Blanc, 19 June 1866, ibid.

50 Anderson, R., ‘The conflict in education’, in Zeldin, , Conflicts in French society, 51–93Google Scholar; Cholvy, and Hilaire, , Histoire religieuse, i. 228–33Google Scholar.

51 Baunard, , Histoire, ii. 405Google Scholar.

52 Pie, , Oeuvres, vi. 598–602Google Scholar.

53 Appendix Fortunati carminum, I, De excidio Thoringiae, ed. Leo, F., MGH Auct. ant. iv. i. 271–5Google Scholar.

54 Baudonivia, , Vita Radegundis 10, MGH SS rer. Mer. ii. 384–5Google Scholar.

55 On the Frankish myth see James, E., The Franks, Oxford 1988, 235–43Google Scholar; Poliakov, L., The Aryan myth: a history of racist and nationalist ideas in Europe, New York 1971, 17–36Google Scholar.

56 Pie, , Oeuvres, vi. 601Google Scholar.

57 Baudonivia, , Vita S. Radegundis 10, MGH SS rer. Mer. ii. 384–5Google Scholar.

58 Briand, , Histoire, 217–18Google Scholar.

59 Brittain, , Saint Radegund, 52Google Scholar; Aigrain, , Sainte Radegonde, 176–7Google Scholar.

60 Kselman, , Miracles and prophecies, 33–34Google Scholar.

61 Osgood, S. M., French royalism since 1870, The Hague 1970, 1–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McManners, J., Church and State in France 1870–1914, London 1972, 34–44Google Scholar; Cholvy, and Hilaire, , Histoire religieuse, i. 233–4Google Scholar.

62 Gibson, , Social history, 148–9Google Scholar.

63 Mather, J., ‘The Assumptionist response to secularisation, 1870–1900’, in Besucha, R. J. (ed.), Modern European social history, Lexington 1972, 58–89Google Scholar.

64 See Bailly to Pie, 9 Aug. 1877, on the ease of modern train travel: AEP, 570 Ste Radegonde. On the pilgrimage phenomenon see Marrus, M. R., ‘Cultures on the move: pilgrims and pilgrimages in nineteenth-century France’, Stanford French Review i (1977), 205–20Google Scholar; Gibson, , Social history, 152–3Google Scholar; Turner, V. and Turner, E., Image and pilgrimage in Christian culture: anthropological perspectives, Oxford 1978, 1–39Google Scholar.

65 Bailly to Pie, 9 Aug. 1877, AEP 570 Ste Radegonde.

66 Bailly to Pie, 5 Sept. 1878, ibid.

67 Pie, , Oeuvres, viii. 166–78Google Scholar; ix. 668–77.

68 Boutry, P., ‘Marie, la grande consolatrice de la France’, L'Histoire 1 (1982), 38Google Scholar.

69 Pie, , Oeuvres, viii. 175–7Google Scholar.

70 AEP, 570 Ste Radegonde, contains the Cantique de Ste Radegonde, n.d., and Le Réveil de la France, n.d., in the one manuscript.

71 See Marie-Antoine, , Petit trésor du pélerin à Notre Dame de Lourdes, Toulouse 1873, 90Google Scholar; Le Réveil de la France, n.d., AEP, 570 Ste Radegonde.

72 Briand, , Manuel, 6–7Google Scholar.

73 Savart, C., ‘Pour une sociologie de la ferveur religieuse: l'archiconférie de Notre-Dame-des-Victoires’, Revue d'histoire ecclésiastique lix (1964) 823–44Google Scholar.

74 Briand, , Manuel, 139–58Google Scholar.

75 Idem, Histoire, 258.

76 Woodall, J. B., ‘Henri Bellot des Minières, republican bishop of Poitiers, 1881–1888’, Catholic Historical Review xxxviii (1952), 257–84Google Scholar; Favreau, R., Le diocèse de Poitiers, Paris 1988, 252–3Google Scholar; Gadille, J., La pensée et l'action politiques des évêques françaises au début de la IIIe république 1870/1883, Paris 1966, ii. 177–8Google Scholar.

77 See Woodall, , ‘Henri Bellot des Minières’, 268–71Google Scholar; du Boisrouvray, , Monseigneur Gay, ii. 558Google Scholar; Gadille, , La Pensée, ii. 178Google Scholar.

78 Kselman, , Miracles and prophecies, 33Google Scholar. See also Baunard, , Histoire, 215–16Google Scholar.

79 Briand, , Les fêtes, 9–12Google Scholar.

80 Osgood, , French royalism, 40–4Google Scholar.

81 Briand, , Les fêtes, 13–15Google Scholar, reproduces the letter. All press reports relating to the affair may be found on Mgr Bellot des Minières' file from the Administration des Cultes: AN, F. 19/2562.

82 Ibid. fo. 256, L'Avenir de la Vienne, 6 Aug. 1887; fo. 250, L'Observateur Français, 9 Aug. 1887; fo. 252, L'Avenir de la Vienne, 9 Aug. 1887; fo. 249, Dix-neuvième Siècle, 10 Aug. 1887; fo. 255, Le Courrier de la Vienne, 14 Aug. 1887.

83 Ibid. fo. 243, Le Courrier de la Vienne, 14 Aug. 1887.

84 Ibid. fo. 240, Le Courrier de la Vienne, 17 Aug. 1887.

85 Briand, , Les fêtes, 12Google Scholar.

86 Ibid.

87 Gallet, , Pélerinages, 84Google Scholar.

88 Briand, , Les fêtes, photograph at p. 2Google Scholar.

89 Osgood, , French royalism, 15–18Google Scholar.

90 Ibid. 36.

91 Briand, , Les fêtes, 31Google Scholar.

92 Ibid. 33–4.

93 Ibid. 49–50. For Freppel's literary reputation see Terrien, E., Monseigneur Freppel, sa vie, ses œuvres, Angers 1932, i. 172–5Google Scholar; ii. 571–2, 586–7.

94 AN, F. 19/2562, fo. 239, L'Avenir de la Vienne, 17 Aug. 1887; fo. 240, Le Courrier de la Vienne, 17 Aug. 1887.

95 Ibid. fo. 239, L'Avenir de la Vienne, 17 Aug. 1887.

96 Ibid. fo. 240, Le Courrier de la Vienne, 17 Aug. 1887.

97 Ibid. fo. 239, L'Avenir de la Vienne, 17 Aug. 1887.

98 Ibid. fo. 257, Le Voltaire, 17 Aug. 1887.

99 Ibid. fo. 240, Le Courrier de la Vienne, 17 Aug. 1887.

100 Ibid. fo. 391, L'Avenir de la Vienne, 19 Aug. 1887.

101 Aigrain, , Sainte Radegonde, 179Google Scholar.

102 Labande, and others, Historie de l'abbaye, 496Google Scholar. The historical display in St Radegund's church includes a photograph of Mgr Roncalli with the relic casket outside the cathedral.

103 Litanies de Sainte Radegonde, typescript leaflet (dated 1992) placed at the tomb for the use of pilgrims.