On 2 October 1394, Richard II (d.1400), king of England, landed at the port town of Waterford on the southeast coast of Ireland, commanding an army estimated at eight thousand in strength. It was the largest English military intervention in Ireland since the English conquest of the late twelfth century. Richard II's Irish expedition of 1394–95 has attracted a considerable amount of scholarly attention, yet much of the scholarship has focused on Richard's relations with the beleaguered colonial administration in Ireland. Historians have pointed almost solely to the Dublin government's pleas for greater royal investment in the Anglo-Irish colony, politically, financially, and militarily, as the main reason for Richard's decision to intervene in Ireland.Footnote 1 However, securing the colony, particularly the southern marches, against the encroaching MacMurrough-Kavanaghs formed but one, albeit significant, aspect of Richard's Irish venture.Footnote 2
The other main area of historical research relating to Richard II and Ireland has centered on the issue of the Gaelic submissions. It has generally been accepted that the submission of so many Irish lords (over eighty nobles submitted to Richard between January and April 1395) represented a growing willingness among the fractious Gaelic chieftains and wayward Anglo-Irish nobility to acknowledge the authority of the English crown.Footnote 3 This interpretation nevertheless, represents an oversimplification of the submissions, the political realities pertaining to late fourteenth-century Ireland, and the extent of English power there. Rather than receiving the submissions of a host of petty, fractious chieftains, Richard was in fact negotiating with an established aristocratic alliance network that had come to dominate much of the Irish political landscape. The four most powerful of these lords—O'Neill of Tyrone, O'Brien of Thomond, Burke of Clanrickard, and O'Connor Donn of Roscommon—between them controlled over a third of Ireland (see figure 1). Furthermore, it was largely through these “Big Four” (under the guidance of James Butler (d.1405), earl of Ormond) that Richard secured most of the other submissions.
Figure 1 “Lordships in Ireland, c.1390.” Note: This map is based on an earlier version compiled by Kenneth Nicholls; see Patrick J. Duffy, David Edwards, and Elizabeth FitzPatrick, “Introduction: Recovering Gaelic Ireland, c.1250–c.1650,” in Gaelic Ireland, c.1250–c.1650: Land, Lordship and Settlement, ed. Patrick J. Duffy, David Edwards, and Elizabeth FitzPatrick (Dublin, 2001), 21–73, at 24–25.
Though historians have outlined various reasons for Richard's Irish expedition of 1394–95, such as the Irish council's plea of 1385 and the growing threat posed by the MacMurrough-Kavanaghs in southern Leinster, the preoccupation with Anglo-centric source material has detracted from explorations of Richard's relations with the Gaelic nobility.Footnote 4 Attempts at salvaging the Irish archival catastrophe of 1922 have yielded some promising results; the mainstay of recovered material nonetheless, deals with the Anglo-Irish colony.Footnote 5 The notarial instruments used to record the submissions reveal little about the aims and ambitions of the foremost Irish dynasts. Contemporary chroniclers including Henry Knighton and Adam of Usk, though rich in detail on English domestic affairs, gloss over the king's Irish expedition and divulge nothing about his relations with the most powerful Irish lords.Footnote 6 Much of John Froissart's material on the 1394–95 expedition remains apocryphal regarding Richard's dealings with the main Irish chieftains.Footnote 7 The limitations of the English material are nonetheless offset by an abundance of Gaelic sources. These records, the corpus of annals in particular, reveal not only a great deal about the aims and ambitions of the Irish lords who submitted to Richard but are essential for exploring and contextualizing Richard's relations with elements of the wider Gaelic world.Footnote 8
The submissions formed part of a much larger strategy of negotiation that extended beyond Ireland to Scotland. Richard's government had by 1390 established strong relations with the MacDonald lordship of the Isles that at the close of the fourteenth century had come to dominate much of the northern Irish Sea world and threatened to overrun large areas of the western Scottish Highlands. By negotiating with these Irish lords, as well as the highly militarized MacDonald lordship, Richard was in effect attempting to rebuild English power within the wider British Isles, albeit through non-English mediums. The only notable absentee from the submission lists, as many have remarked, was O'Donnell of Tyrconnell.Footnote 9 The fact remains that O'Donnell did not submit in 1395, nor did his allies Burke of Mayo and O'Connor Ruadh of Roscommon (see figure 1). These three lords represented an alternative aristocratic network that rivaled the “Big Four” for control of much of Ireland's western seaboard. There is, moreover, considerable evidence that O'Donnell and his allies were aligned with the Stewart monarchy and the Avignon papacy.
Richard's negotiations with the Irish lords and the MacDonald lordship of the Isles thus need to be viewed within the broader context of developments within the wider Gaelic world, the course of Anglo-Scottish relations, and the Hundred Years’ War. The king's relationship with the lords of the wider Gaelic world remains a fundamentally unexplored facet of his kingship. This issue is symptomatic of both the aforementioned reliance on English source material and current historiographical and methodological trends. The work of Rees Davies and Robin Frame has been instrumental in decoding the political development of late medieval Britain and Ireland,Footnote 10 but their work, however pioneering, remains highly Anglo-centric in outlook; both scholars focus on the expansion of Anglo-French aristocratic culture, transnational landholding, and power in Ireland and the wider British Isles c.1100–c.1340. For the period c.1340–c.1460, the decline of pan-insular Anglo-French culture and power, coupled with the deterioration of Anglo-Scottish relations, has led historians to move away from the “British Isles” model espoused by Davies and Frame toward the “Plantagenet” model of interpretation, locating the development of English power in Ireland, for example, within the context of the wider Plantagenet empire.Footnote 11 Though offering useful insights into the inner workings of the Anglo-Irish colony, this approach has drawn attention further away from the Gaelic west. Historians of late medieval Scotland in comparison have, understandably, adopted a more national-centered approach when examining the consolidation of Bruce and early Stewart Scotland, albeit with limited consideration for Scotland's relations with Ireland.Footnote 12
This present article argues for the continued worth of using the archipelagic model in exploring the political development of Britain and Ireland in the later fourteenth century—particularly when considering the role of the wider Gaelic world in influencing the course of “British” politics. Brendan Smith and Michael Brown have both outlined the value of utilizing such an approach when exploring inter-insular relationships between c.1300 and c.1460, though admittedly from respective Anglo- and Scottish-centric perspectives.Footnote 13 Steven Ellis has drawn attention to the Gaelic world (or “Celtic fringe”) as a force within late medieval “British” politics, yet his approach is likewise highly Anglo-centric in outlook.Footnote 14 Believing the Gaelic resurgence of the fourteenth century to have been built upon “flimsy military foundations,” Ellis has focused on the expansion of English power within the wider British Isles rather than assessing how developments within the wider Gaelic world could act as check on English expansion.Footnote 15 Ellis's views on Gaelic identity have in turn drawn criticism from scholars such as Wilson McLeod and Martin MacGregor, who have both offered more nuanced readings on Gaelic cultural and political identity during the late medieval period.Footnote 16 Yet McLeod's and MacGregor's models, though offering useful insights into concepts of Gaelic identity, ultimately lack a forensic examination of the hard political and dynastic structures underpinning Gaelic Irish and Gaelic Scottish interaction during the later medieval period.
By using Richard II's relations with the wider Gaelic world as a dedicated case study and by drawing upon a broad meld of material from within the Gaelic world, English and Scottish governmental records, and material from the Avignon papacy, this essay challenges the notion that events in the Gaelic west were peripheral to the political development of late medieval Ireland and Britain. The first section explores Richard's relationship with the MacDonald lordship of the Isles and its significance for Irish affairs. The next section examines the context surrounding the emergence of the “Big Four” and their enemies in Ireland during the later fourteenth century and the way that this, in tandem with events in Gaelic Scotland, laid the foundation for Richard's expedition in 1394–95. The third and final section focuses on Richard's Irish venture of 1394–95, reassessing the submissions and his difficulties in achieving a permanent settlement in Ireland. The complexity of lineage-based societies and the fragmentary nature of surviving source material can make sifting through the dynastic world of Gaeldom appear to be an arduous task. The associated maps and tables, however, provide guides essential for locating each lordship geographically, tracing the development of each, and navigating the complex, dynastic milieu of the late fourteenth-century Gaelic world.
Gaelic Scotland in the Late Fourteenth Century
It is rarely acknowledged that over the course of the later Middle Ages, nearly half the landmass of Britain and Ireland fell under autonomous Gaelic control. In Ireland, a combination of factors including the Bruce invasions (1315–18), the Black Death, a cooling of the climate, and the migration of Scottish mercenary galloglass to Ireland saw English power across the northwestern section of the island retreat significantly. Though Robin Frame has amply demonstrated that English power in Leinster and much of Munster was exercised effectively by the colonial earls, a good deal of the northern and western seaboard, including most of the de Burgh earldom of Ulster and lordship of Connacht, was lost to resurgent Irish dynasties or to the increasingly independent and acculturated Anglo-Irish Burkes of Clanrickard and Mayo.Footnote 17
A similar process occurred in fourteenth-century Scotland, providing context crucial for exploring Richard II's later Irish venture. Robert Bruce's wars for control of Scotland in the early part of the century, coupled with the extinction of certain noble lines, brought about the disintegration of royal power in northern Scotland.Footnote 18 As in Ireland, the political vacuum was filled by resurgent Gaelic clans such as the MacRuairís of Garmoran, the Clan Donnchaidh of Atholl, and the Clan Chattan of Lochaber and Badenoch, many of them migrating eastwards from the western highlandsFootnote 19 The most powerful Gaelic faction to emerge during the first half of the fourteenth century was the MacDonald lordship of the Isles.Footnote 20 The lordship was comprised of numerous Hebridean and west highland kindreds, each subject to the nominal authority of the lord of the Isles, a direct descendant of Somerled (d.1164), king of the Hebrides (see figure 2). Over the course of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, the lordship of the Isles became a major political force within the Gaelic world and also on the wider “British” stage. This powerful position rested chiefly on the lords of Isles’ ability to raise considerable military and maritime resources from the various sub-kindreds.Footnote 21 Though the lordship crumbled apart in the late fifteenth century, largely due to internecine struggles and growing royal Scottish encroachment, successive lords of the Isles were able to maintain the relative cohesion of the wider lordship until the mid-fifteenth century.
Figure 2 “The Northern Irish Sea World and the Kingdom of Scotland during the Late Fourteenth Century.” Note: This map is based on an earlier version compiled by Michael Brown; see The Wars of Scotland, 1214–1371 (Edinburgh, 2004), 317.
It was under the leadership of John MacDonald of Islay (d.1387), the first lord of the Isles, that the lordship emerged as a potent force within the Irish Sea world. The lordship's strategic position made it an ideal ally of the English crown, and from the late 1330s to the late 1360s John was courted by Edward III of England and by Edward Baliol, the pro-English claimant to Scotland.Footnote 22 These accords proved mutually beneficial. On one level, they helped safeguard England's northern frontiers with Scotland during the early decades of the Hundred Years’ War.Footnote 23 They also served to protect the east coast of Ulster from Scottish intervention. For John, the accords gave him a freer hand to continue expanding across large areas of northern Scotland, as well as the opportunity to meddle in affairs in Ireland, where he had considerable interests.
Sometime during the early 1330s, John allegedly exiled his cousins, the Clan Alexander, to Ireland.Footnote 24 There they were subsequently forced to become mercenary galloglass, serving the expansionist O'Neills of Tyrone, then led by Aodh Reamhar O'Neill (d.1364). Though the record is fragmentary, it appears that John became concerned that the Clan Alexander, with O'Neill support, would attempt to retake Islay—John's seat of power.Footnote 25 He quickly set about shoring up alliances in both Scotland and Ireland. In 1337 he married Amy MacRuairí, sister of Ruairí MacRuairí of Garmoran, the most powerful lord in the northern Hebrides—a match that secured him possession of the northern Hebrides following Ruairí’s assassination in 1346 (see figure 2).Footnote 26 In Ireland John moved to cultivate links with the O'Neills’ Irish enemies and the English administration. In 1335 he had traveled to Drogheda to assist in preparations for an attack on Scotland. Three years later he successfully petitioned Edward III (d.1377) to allow his cousins, Hugh and John Bisset, to acquire possession of the Antrim-based barony of Larne and Isle of Rathlin respectively (see figure 2).Footnote 27 John also secured from Edward III a number of safe passes to allow himself and his mother, Áine, the daughter of O'Cahan, to travel between Scotland and Ireland in 1337 and 1338.Footnote 28
Áine was a member of the O'Cahan kindred whose lordship was located on the northern coast of Ulster, bordering the O'Neill lordship of Tyrone (see figure 2). She had married, c.1300, John's father, Angus Óg—a previous lord of Islay who fell at the Battle of Faughart during the Bruce Invasions of Ireland in 1318.Footnote 29 Soon after the granting of the 1338 pass, Áine married Murtagh Ceannfhada O'Neill (d.1395), the brother of the lord of the Clandeboy O'Neills, Brian (d.1369). The Clandeboy O'Neills were regional rivals of the Tyrone branch and contested the Tyrone's branch's claim to the chieftaincy of the wider O'Neill kindred (see figure 2).Footnote 30 As allies of the colonial government, Brian and his brother Murtagh Ceannfhada acted as a check on the territorial ambitions of Aodh Reamhar O'Neill, lord of Tyrone and patron of the Clan Alexander. By drawing the O'Neills of Clandeboy and O'Cahans closer to one another, John created a buffer between himself and the Clan Alexander, while at the same time helping to protect the earldom of Ulster, now confined to an increasingly narrow strip of land hugging the southeast coast of Ulster. Moreover, John is recorded as leading two expeditions to Ireland (probably in the mid-1340s) in an attempt to secure the O'Neill chieftaincy for his cousin, Brian; both ventures failed.Footnote 31
Despite the highly fragmentary nature of surviving source material, it appears that relations between the lordship of the Isles and the O'Neills improved during the last two decades of the fourteenth century. The reconciliation of the O'Neills of Tyrone and Clandeboy during the late 1360s undoubtedly contributed to this process.Footnote 32 Developments in the western section of Ireland—namely, the rise of the O'Donnells—played an equal if not more important role in strengthening ties between the O'Neills of Tyrone and the Islesmen (and are discussed in greater detail below). It is also worth noting here that by the late 1370s the Clan Alexander had fragmented into a series of sub-kindreds. Though the main sept remained in the employ of the O'Neills of Tyrone, the smaller family branches migrated westward into Connacht. Here they sought and eventually found employment with kindreds allied to the O'Donnells.Footnote 33 There is evidence (outlined below) to suggest that the O'Donnells had by the early 1380s drifted into the orbit of the Scottish crown. John of Islay thus may have feared becoming stretched on two fronts, with the O'Donnells and the Clan Alexander in the west, and the Scottish monarchy in the east. Relations between the O'Neills of Tyrone and the lordship of the Isles gradually improved as both faced a common enemy in Ireland. Against the backdrop of the Hundred Years’ War, the government of Richard II sought to exploit this shift in Gaelic realpolitik through negotiation with the O'Neills and their allies (a topic discussed below, in the final section) and by allowing a more permanent MacDonald presence in Ulster.
The death of David II in 1371 and the accession of Robert Stewart (d.1390) as Robert II led to a brief period of rapprochement between the lord of the Isles and the Scottish crown. Unlike David, Robert enjoyed more cordial relations with his Gaelic-speaking subjects. Originally hailing from western Scotland, he was acculturated to Gaelic Scotland and able to move easily between the Gaelic and Scots-English-speaking worlds.Footnote 34 In fact, much of his support base within the kingdom derived from Gaelic kindreds, such as the Campbells of Loch Awe, the Clan Donnchaidh of Atholl, and the lordship of the Isles.Footnote 35 Married to Robert's daughter Margaret in 1350, John had aligned himself with the Stewarts during David II's protracted captivity (1346–57) before drifting back into English allegiance upon David's return to Scotland in 1357.Footnote 36 As a son-in-law of the new king in 1371, John perhaps hoped to secure legitimization for his “acquisitions” in northern Scotland.Footnote 37 A combination of factors, however, placed great pressure on his relationship with the new regime. As suggested by Alexander Grant, John may have expected to have been awarded a grant of royal lieutenancy over much of western Scotland; instead the lieutenancy was awarded to Gillespic Campbell of Loch Awe, one of John's main regional rivals.Footnote 38 The far more damaging rift, however, occurred in northern Scotland, where Robert II failed to curtail the activities of his son, Alexander Stewart, the infamous “Wolf of Badenoch,” whose forces continually raided John's holdings in Lochaber (see figure 2).Footnote 39
Within a few years, tensions between John and the crown had risen once again. With little recourse, John had by the late 1370s revived his alliance with the English government.Footnote 40 Once more this arrangement proved mutually beneficial. The renewal of the Hundred Years’ War in 1371, the advent of Franco-Castilian naval supremacy, and Robert II's commitment to the French meant that English holdings within the Irish Sea world were vulnerable to French and Scottish attack.Footnote 41 For example, during the 1370s, the English government feared that Owain Lawgoch (d.1378), a Welshman in French military service and the self-proclaimed Prince of Wales, would return to Wales and launch a major revolt with French support.Footnote 42 Despite Lawgoch's assassination at Mortagne in 1378, Richard II's government remained concerned about French intervention along the southern coasts of England and Wales well into the 1380s.Footnote 43 English possessions in Ireland were also subject to French and Scottish attack. In 1381 the port town of Kinsale on the southwest coast of Ireland was raided by a large Franco-Castilian force commanded by Jean de Vienne (d.1396), the admiral of France and architect of French naval supremacy.Footnote 44 Richard subsequently approved funds for the walling of Kinsale to protect the inhabitants from further attack.Footnote 45 The port of Waterford was likewise raided by Castilian forces in 1377, while the city of Cork and its hinterland in 1388 are recorded as suffering numerous burnings at the hands of Irish rebels and the king's enemies.Footnote 46 More striking still is that in 1388 (a year after John's death) a large Scottish force commanded by Sir William Douglas of Nithsdale (d.1391) ravaged colonial settlements at Carlingford Lough before raiding the Isle of Man as part of the broader Otterburn campaign.Footnote 47
These attacks capitalized upon the English entanglement on the European continent, particularly during the mid-1380s, when English forces had become increasingly ensnared in the Iberian Peninsula.Footnote 48 Though the earldom of Ulster had by this time shrunk to a thin strip of coastline, it appears to have remained economically viable due to a lucrative fishing trade operating from Strangford Lough, Carlingford, and the Abbey of Inch (see figure 2).Footnote 49 Moreover, the defense of Carrickfergus Castle remained of paramount importance both to the Crown and Irish Council; in 1392 it was feared that Carrickfergus would fall to the Gaelic Irish, and the justicar, Sir John Stanley (d.1414), received orders to reinforce the castle's defenses.Footnote 50
John's considerable military and maritime resources offered a greater degree of protection to English holdings north of Wales, especially the castles and fisheries of eastern Ulster. Prior to his removal from governance in 1387, Richard II took steps to secure a greater MacDonald presence in Ulster. On 16 February 1387 a license was granted by the Irish Council for the marriage of Robert Savage to Christina, a daughter of John, lord of the Isles. The marriage was subsequently ratified by the English Council on 4 May 1388.Footnote 51 The identity of Robert Savage is uncertain, but, as Katharine Simms has suggested, he was most likely the son of the previous crown seneschal of Ulster, Robert (d.1360) and brother of the current seneschal, Edmund (fl.1385).Footnote 52 Based in the Ards Peninsula and originally of Anglo-Norman extraction, the Savages had defended the declining earldom of Ulster from O'Neill expansion for much of the earlier fourteenth century. Despite a brief spell of disfavor in the 1370s, the Savages had reestablished themselves during the early 1380s as key agents of both the English crown and the Mortimer earls of March.Footnote 53 There is evidence to suggest that the Savages were highly acculturated to the sociocultural world of Gaelic Ireland, and by association, of Gaelic Scotland. For example, a Jenkin Savage, possibly a brother of Robert (d.1360), was a noted patron of Gaelic bards—this would help explain and contextualize their cordial relations with the lord of the Isles.Footnote 54 The Savage match of 1387 formed the basis for further MacDonald expansion in Ireland, which again served the purposes of the both MacDonalds and the English crown. By 1387, John of Islay was an old man; he was probably in his late eighties and had ruled the Isles successfully for more than fifty years. He may, however, have been concerned regarding the succession of the lordship.Footnote 55 It has been suggested that following his death later that year, there may have been a very brief period of interregnum in the lordship of the Isles, and that there was some opposition among the island kindreds to the succession of his heir designate, Donald (d.1423), the grandson of Robert II.Footnote 56
The council of the Isles (comprising the chiefs of the main island kindreds) soon agreed to support the decision of Ranald—John's eldest son by his first marriage to Amy MacRuairí—who had been acting as the caretaker lord of the Isles until Donald was ready to take power.Footnote 57 In any case, there was a brief period during which the lordship of the Isles may have been vulnerable to a dynastic challenge from the Scottish monarchy or their recent Irish allies, the O'Donnells.Footnote 58 The marriage of Christina (Donald's sister) and Robert Savage gave the new lord of the Isles a greater foothold in Ireland and formed the basis for the subsequent MacDonald acquisition of the Seven Glynns of Antrim. The precise dating of the MacDonald acquisition of the Glynns– brought about by the marriage of Donald's brother, John Mór (d.1427) (son of John of Islay and Margaret Stewart) to Marjory Bisset, the heiress to the Glynns—remains uncertain. John had certainly secured possession of the Glynns in 1400, owing to the fact that he is styled as lord thereof in correspondence with the English crown.Footnote 59 Though historians have gravitated toward this later date, by broadening the scope of investigation it becomes possible to posit an earlier date for the acquisition.
Allowing for a greater degree of MacDonald influence in Ulster was part of a broader “British”-oriented defensive system orchestrated by Richard II, though a rarely acknowledged aspect of his kingship.Footnote 60 Through the promotion of loyalist servitors and by forming alliances with non-English mediums, such as the lordship of the Isles, Richard hoped both to secure his own personal rule and rebuild English power within the wider British Isles. For example, as Prince of Wales, he enjoyed a strong support base among the native Welsh and colonial communities. He also promoted strong relations with the port town of Chester and in 1392 granted possession of the strategic Isle of Man to the loyalist William Scrope (d.1399).Footnote 61 Ireland, nonetheless, continued to pose a significant challenge due to the lack of effective English royal power beyond the colony and the increasing level of aristocratic factionalism among the Anglo-Irish community.Footnote 62 Negotiating with the wider Gaelic nobility, the MacDonalds in this instance, and their capacity to raise considerable military resources in regions beyond effective English influence, offered Richard a solution.
In October 1389, a year after Richard reassumed power, Edmund Savage was granted the wardship of the heiress Marjory Bisset and her sister Elizabeth—both daughters of the recently deceased “Hugh Byset”—with permission to marry them to any of the king's loyal lieges.Footnote 63 While no record provides a date for the union of John Mór and Marjory, it is possible that the match may have occurred as early as 1390. Surviving proclamations of Anglo-French treaties between August 1389 and March 1396 name John Mór (“Jehan de Ysles” or “Johan des Isles”) as an ally of the English crown.Footnote 64 The fact that the actual lord of the Isles, Donald, is not included suggests that John Mór had become the main intermediary between the crown and his brother and may have been engaged in negotiations with the crown and Savages as early as 1389, settling soon after as the de facto lord of the Glynns.Footnote 65
The marriage not only secured a lasting MacDonald presence in Ulster but may also have helped to mend relations with the O'Neills of Tyrone. Numerous Irish annals indicate that the head of the Bisset affinity—MacEoin Bisset—was married to Sadhb (d.1387), daughter Aodh O'Neill—quite probably Aodh Reamhar O'Neill, which would make her a sister of the O'Neill chieftain Niall Mór (d.1397).Footnote 66 Owing to a mistake in the English translation of the Annals of the Four Masters, there is no record of MacEoin Bisset's first name.Footnote 67 It is therefore very possible that “MacEoin Bisset” and the aforementioned “Hugh Byset,” father of Marjory and Elizabeth, were one and the same. This would in turn mean that Marjory was the niece of Niall Mór O'Neill and would suggest a familial link between all three dynasties.
The territorial aggrandizement of the MacDonalds in Antrim would form a central aspect of Richard II's Irish strategy. Though nominally at peace with Scotland and France since 1389, the lordship of the Isles’ ability to check Scottish expansion in the northern Irish Sea world allowed Richard to direct his full attention to Ireland. Here he could pursue the recovery of the Mortimer inheritance and the reduction of forces hostile to English interests therein—particularly in the west of Ireland. The idea that the O'Neills of Tyrone had a vested interest in the MacDonald acquisition of Antrim is also reinforced by developments in Ireland west of the River Shannon. Therefore, in order to understand the broader context behind both the cooling of O'Neill-MacDonald tensions and the background to Richard's Irish expeditions, it is necessary to first trace the political development of Gaelic Ireland's western seaboard at the close of the fourteenth century.
Gaelic Ireland in the Late Fourteenth Century
The Annals of Connacht record that on 25 November 1384, Ruairí O'Connor, king of Connacht, died from plague.Footnote 68 The earlier fourteenth century had witnessed growing tensions and divisions within the O'Connor lordship of Roscommon. Contemporary annalists, however, credited Ruairí’s sixteen-year reign as allowing for a greater degree of stability and political cohesion within the wider O'Connor lordship.Footnote 69 Indeed, his death has been described by Kenneth Nicholls as causing “the fatal division” of the O'Connor’ lordship into the two dominant, competing lines of O'Connor Ruadh and O'Connor Donn.Footnote 70 Following Ruairí’s death, two rival claimants to the vacant kingship were proclaimed almost immediately. Turlough Óg O'Connor Donn (d.1406) (a nephew of Ruairí and son of Ruairí’s predecessor, Aodh d.1356, son of Turlough d.1343/5) was elected king of Connacht by the O'Connor Donn kindred, their kinsmen the O'Connors of Sligo, the O'Rourkes of Breifne, the O'Kellys of Hymany, the MacDermots of Airteach and the Burkes of Clanrickard.Footnote 71 Conversely, Turlough O'Connor Ruadh (d.1425/6)—a second cousin of Turlough Óg O'Connor Donn and son of Aodh (d.1368), son of Felim (d.1316) —was supported by the MacDermots of Moylurg, the O'Malleys of the Owles and the Burkes of Mayo. O'Connor Donn and O'Connor Ruadh's alliance networks (including lesser kindreds) are depicted on the table and map below (see table 1 and figure 1). For the purpose of this essay, these alliance networks are referred to as the Donn and Ruadh factions, terms originally coined by Kenneth Nicholls and later adopted by Art Cosgrove.Footnote 72 Both scholars have alluded to the existence of these networks in Connacht. However, the fact that these Connacht-based alliances developed into larger, competing aristocratic networks that eventually came to dominate nearly two-thirds of Ireland during the later fourteenth and early fifteenth centuries, remains hitherto unacknowledged in the historiography.
Table 1 Donn/Ruadh allegiance within Connacht
It is important to bear in mind that while this conflict stemmed from a civil war in Roscommon, hegemonic control of Connacht was, in reality, contested by the more powerful patrons of O'Connor Donn and O'Connor Ruadh, namely the competing Burke of Clanrickard and Mayo families (and eventually by the O'Briens, O'Donnells, and O'Neills). Initially this conflict had been confined west of the River Shannon, primarily to the province of Connacht. In the space of a few short years, however, it had spread to neighboring provinces of Ulster, Leinster, and Munster (see table 2 and figure 1). The reasons behind the expansion of this conflict lie in the geopolitical situation pertaining both to Connacht and the other provinces and to the political and territorial ambitions of the main magnates therein. The lords of western Leinster became drawn into the conflict in eastern Connacht partly due to power struggles in northern Leinster but also to maintain control of the Shannon. For example, the competing branches of the O'Ferralls of Annaly (the Clan Sean and Clan Aedh) sought support from O'Connor Donn/Burke of Clanrickard and O'Connor Ruadh respectively in an attempt to control this vital waterway. Further south, the O'Connors of Offaly, kinsmen of the O'Connor Ruadh kindred through marriage, acted as a check on O'Connor Donn and Burke of Clanrickard expansion in Leinster. For example, not only did the O'Connors of Offaly provide military support to O'Connor Ruadh when required but the O'Connors of Offaly were later joined in marriage to the O'Donnells of Tyrconnell (see below).Footnote 73 Another comparable situation existed in northern Munster. The O'Briens of Thomond, with the support of the Burkes of Clanrickard (both members of the Donn faction), emerged as the dominant regional powers and posed an ever greater threat to the towns of Limerick and Cork, as well as the authority of the earl of Desmond.Footnote 74 Likewise the MacCarthys of Desmond, due to necessity, became increasingly drawn into the Donn/Ruadh struggle (see section 3).
Table 2 Donn/Ruadh allegiance beyond Connacht
The Ulster dimension to this conflict was perhaps the most significant and is essential in exploring why the O'Neills later wished to cooperate with Richard. As noted, the earlier fourteenth century witnessed a sustained period of O'Neill expansion in central and eastern Ulster. Following Aodh Reamhar's death in 1364, his son and successor, Niall Mór (d.1397) continued this process.Footnote 75 By the early 1380s most of central and eastern Ulster had fallen under the control of the O'Neills, with Gaelic factions such as the Maguires, Clandeboy O'Neills, MacMahons, Magennises, and O'Hanlons, as well as kindreds of Anglo-Norman extraction, such as the Bissets of the Glynns, owing their loyalty to the O'Neills of Tyrone (though the Clandeboy O'Neills and the Magennises appear to have later joined with O'Donnell—see below). This powerful position rested both on the compliance of these lesser kindreds and on the relative cohesion of the wider Tyrone lordship. As with the Donn and Ruadh factions in Connacht, the allegiance of the smaller lordships, Maguires and MacMahons, was maintained through ties of dynastic politics including marriage alliances and fosterage but also enforced through military intimidation. Niall Mór and his heir designate, Niall Óg (d.1403), maintained their court in southeastern Tyrone or northern Armagh, either at Dungannon or Eamhain Macha (Navan Fort).Footnote 76 From here they continued to expand O'Neill power in eastern Ulster and posed an ever greater menace to the northern borders of the Pale. The fulcrum of O'Neill power in this period, however, derived from the activities of another of Niall Mór's sons, Éinrí Aimhreidh (d.1392), and his ability to protect Tyrone from Turlough an Fhíona O'Donnell (d.1422), the lord of Tyrconnell.
Éinrí Aimhreidh's duty in defending the western approaches to Tyrone rested on the maintenance of large military forces—drawn from Tyrone and the Maguire lordship of Fermanagh—and the fomenting of dynastic unrest within Tyrconnell. The O'Neills’ ability to play rival branches of the O'Donnells against one another in Tyrconnell formed the basis for O'Neill expansion in eastern Ulster during the 1360s and 1370s.Footnote 77 For example, two of Niall Mór's daughters were married to rival claimants to the O'Donnell lordship; Gormlaith (d.1416) was married to Sean O'Donnell (d.1380) while her sister Gráinne was married to Turlough an Fhíona O'Donnell.Footnote 78 Turlough an Fhíona seized power within Tyrconnell in 1380 and quickly came to pose a serious threat to O'Neill dominance in Ulster.Footnote 79 Over the course of the early 1380s, the O'Donnells gradually began to reassert themselves; the conflict in Connacht came to play an increasingly important role in the O'Neill-O'Donnell struggle. In an attempt to flank the O'Donnells, Éinrí Aimhreidh sought assistance from the Donn faction in Connacht, allying himself with the O'Connors of Sligo and O'Rourkes of West Breifne—both of whose lordships bordered with southern Tyrconnell.Footnote 80 These lordships held great strategic value: whoever controlled them could, in theory, control the passageways between Ulster and Connacht (see figure 1). Conversely, in order to ease pressure on his southern flank, O'Donnell reached out to the Ruadh faction in Connacht who could attack Sligo and West Breifne and draw Donn faction forces away from Tyrconnell.
It therefore comes as no surprise that Sligo and West Breifne became hotly contested combat zones over the next number of years as the O'Donnells, O'Neills and their respective Ruadh and Donn faction allies each jostled for control of these lordships. Indeed, the scenario in northern Connacht forced the Burkes of Clanrickard and the O'Briens of Thomond to participate more actively in central Connacht in order to draw the Ruadh faction away from northern Connacht. This strategy of tying the Ruadh faction down on a series of fronts initially proved successful. During the late 1380s and early 1390s, Éinrí Aimhreidh, in cooperation with his allies in Connacht, succeeded in containing the O'Donnell threat. This, in turn, enabled Niall Mór and Niall Óg to continue solidifying their hold upon eastern Ulster—a prime example being the O'Neill assault upon the town of Dundalk on the north coast of Leinster in 1392 (see figure 2).Footnote 81
The O'Donnells, however, had one major advantage in this broadening geopolitical conflict. Unlike Tyrone, Tyrconnell was a maritime lordship, and there is evidence to suggest that the O'Donnells were able to draw upon sizeable maritime resources, giving them a tactical advantage over their opponents. The importance of galleys and other seafaring craft in Gaelic Scottish warfare has been amply demonstrated. Galleys or smaller craft like birlinn enabled west Highland factions such as the MacDonald lordship of the Isles and Campbells of Loch Awe to dominate much of the western Scottish seaboard, patrolling strategic lochs and safeguarding trade routes and maritime passageways.Footnote 82 Yet historians of Gaelic Ireland have tended to overlook the importance of the maritime landscape in late medieval Irish politics, a topic that to date has largely been the pursuit of marine archaeologists.Footnote 83
The O'Donnells were noted for their ability to raise from among their sub-kindreds large military forces, including cavalry drawn from the O'Dohertys of Inishowen and light infantry or “kern” from the O'Gallaghers and O'Boyles of Boylagh.Footnote 84 The three MacSweeny galloglass septs of Fanad, Banagh and na Doe, however, formed the backbone of O'Donnell armies. Originally hailing from Knapdale in western Scotland, the MacSweenys were displaced during the Scottish-Norse wars of the late thirteenth century and the Anglo-Scottish wars of the early fourteenth century.Footnote 85 A maritime kindred, they quickly found shelter in Ireland and secured permanent employment as hereditary galloglass for successive O'Donnell chieftains; the Fanad branch emerged as the dominant MacSweeny grouping. From their coastal lordship in western Tyrconnell, the MacSweenys of Fanad not only provided their O'Donnell masters with heavy infantry but also maintained a small fleet of galley-style craft.Footnote 86 The tactical and logistical advantages of the MacSweeny fleet allowed the O'Donnells to intervene directly in Connacht, side-stepping any obstacles posed by the O'Connors of Sligo or the O'Rourkes of West Breifne.
As demonstrated elsewhere, the ability to intervene in far-flung regions of Gaelic Ireland would later prove essential to establishing the O'Donnell hegemony over much of northwestern Ireland in the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries.Footnote 87 During the late fourteenth and early fifteenth centuries, maritime connections enabled the O'Donnells and MacSweenys to develop and strengthen the alliance with the Ruadh faction in Connacht. Though composed in the early sixteenth century, the genealogical history of the MacSweeny dynasty, the Leabhar Chlainne Suibhne, recounts that by the early fifteenth century the MacSweenys had married into the O'Malleys of the Owles—another prominent seafaring kindred (see table 1 and figure 1).Footnote 88 At the turn of the century, a large force of MacSweeny galloglass were serving alongside the O'Malleys in Connacht, with the O'Malleys also providing military support to the O'Donnells and MacSweenys in Tyrconnell when required.Footnote 89 This arrangement effectively allowed the O'Donnells to resist encroachment from both the O'Neills of Tyrone to the east and the O'Connors of Sligo in the south. Maritime connections also enabled the O'Donnells to open a second front against the O'Neills in eastern Ulster; during the early fifteenth century, O'Neill of Clandeboy, O'Hanlon, and Magennis were each co-opted into an alliance with O'Donnell (see figure 2).Footnote 90
The sea was important to the O'Donnells and their allies for two further reasons. The cooling of the climate in the fourteenth century resulted in the migration of vast herring stocks to the coasts of Ireland and Scotland.Footnote 91 The influx of English, French, Spanish, and Dutch fishermen generated considerable prosperity for the Gaelic nobility. Using fleets, Gaelic kindreds such as the O'Donnells, (or the O'Malleys, the O'Driscolls, and the O'Sullivan Beare dynasties of south Munster), and the Campbells of Argyll imposed levies on visiting fishermen for fishing within their respective spheres of influence or for seeking shelter along the coast.Footnote 92 The wealth generated by the fisheries enabled the Gaelic nobility to develop trading links with the rest of the British Isles and continental Europe. Over time the lords of the western Ireland built strong trading connections with insular ports such as Bristol and Glasgow as well as continental trading hubs including La Rochelle and Bordeaux (O'Donnell's soubriquet “an Fhíona”—“of the wine”—suggests he may have been personally involved in the trade).Footnote 93 The O'Donnells also maintained a network of agents in many of these ports to safeguard their mercantile interests and also to carry and receive news,Footnote 94 ensuring that the Gaelic “periphery” remained attuned to developments within the wider Atlantic world.Footnote 95
The Irish intrigues of the later Stewart kings, James IV (d.1513) and James V (d.1542), particularly their relationship with the O'Donnells, has been the subject of recent scholarship.Footnote 96 The O'Donnell-Stewart alliance of the late fifteenth and early sixteenth century was nonetheless, built upon much earlier foundations that can be tentatively traced to the early 1380s. Indeed, though it has received little scholarly attention, the O'Donnell's alliance with the Stewart monarchy runs like a leitmotiv through the history of late medieval Ireland. Evidence for the origins of this relationship is contained in the registers of the Avignon papacy. Recent years have witnessed a growing interest in the development of the church in late medieval Gaelic Scotland, including the impact of the Avignon papacy.Footnote 97 Aside from a number of short studies, little research has been conducted on the Papal Schism's impact upon Gaelic Ireland.Footnote 98 Though Edouard Perroy originally framed Richard's Irish expeditions as a crusade against the Clementist Irish, it has generally been assumed that the Avignon papacy had little impact upon Gaelic Irish politics. A reexamination of surviving sources suggests otherwise.Footnote 99
The papal schism of the later fourteenth century further entrenched preexisting alliance blocs that had developed across Europe during the Hundred Years’ War. Among those adhering to the Roman papacy of Urban VI (d.1389) were the English, the Flemish, the Danes, the Swedes, the northern Italian city states, the Poles, and the Hungarians. Conversely, Clement VII of Avignon (d.1394) was supported by the French, Castilians, and Aragonese, the kingdoms of Naples and Cyprus, and Scotland. In Ireland, there appears to have been a large support base for Clement VII in the dioceses of Raphoe, Killala, Clonfert, Clogher, and Annaghdown, with a lesser following in the dioceses of Tuam and Elphin.Footnote 100 Raphoe, Killala, Clonfert, Annaghdown, and western Clogher were each controlled by lords of the Ruadh faction. Tuam and Elphin, on the other hand, were divided between the Donn and Ruadh factions, which may explain the resistance to Avignon influence there.Footnote 101
A full reconsideration of the Avignon papacy's impact upon the wider Hiberno-Scottish world remains a desideratum. Such an enterprise is made extremely difficult due to the limitations of surviving source material. While this article is not the forum for such an undertaking, there are nonetheless, a number of brief points to make in relations to the Scottish-Avignon interest in late fourteenth-century Ireland and how this ultimately shaped Richard II's security concerns regarding the island. The possible adherence of the aforementioned dioceses and lordships to the Avignon papacy opened up a further international dimension to Irish politics. Material contained within the calendar of Avignon papal registers indicates that members of the Ruadh faction were in contact with the Scottish king through clerical intermediaries loyal to the Avignon papacy from 1379 onwards. While the greater number of petitions were sent directly to Avignon, it appears that some were forwarded to the Scottish court and were included in Robert II's correspondence with Clement VII in 1381.Footnote 102 These petitions originally came from the O'Muldoons of Lurg and the O'Lennons of Lisgool, both located in the diocese of Clogher.Footnote 103 While the political allegiance of the O'Lennons is more difficult to trace due to the fragmentary nature of source material, it is worth noting that the bishop of Clogher, John O'Corcrain, wrote to Richard II c.1380 informing the king that he had been driven from his bishopric; whether or not this was linked with Scottish/Avignon involvement in Clogher remains uncertain.Footnote 104 The O'Muldoons, on the other hand, appear to have been allies of the O'Donnells and controlled a territory coexistent with the modern-day barony of Lurg. Their lands were, moreover, located north of the passes from Connacht into Ulster and were subjected to raids by members of the Donn faction (see figure 1).Footnote 105
A pattern of communication between the O'Donnells and their allies and the Scottish monarchy appears to have developed over the next number of years. This is evident both from further material contained in Avignon registers and the broader context of Scottish activity in the wider Irish Sea world. In February 1383, the bishop of Glasgow, Walter Wardlaw (d.1387), was ordered by Clement VII to assist in removing the bishop of Killala, Robert Eliot, to put in place the Clementine favored candidate, Cornelius O'Connor.Footnote 106 The following year Wardlaw was appointed Avignon papal legate for Ireland and Scotland with the intention of further undermining English and Roman papal influence in the northern Irish Sea world.Footnote 107 Though Wardlaw died in 1387, there is evidence that his successor as bishop of Glasgow, Matthew Glendinning, maintained the connection with Ireland and in 1394 he secured a benefice in the diocese of Sodor for one “Maurice Nemie” of Raphoe diocese in Tyrconnell.Footnote 108 The movement of Avignon clerics across the North Channel provided the Stewart monarchy with a direct line of contact to the O'Donnells of Tyrconnell.Footnote 109 As noted, the early Stewart kings Robert II and Robert III (d.1406), in the mold of their ancestor Robert Bruce, were acculturated to the Gaelic world and enjoyed strong relations with many Gaelic Scottish factions such as the Campbells of Loch Awe and Clan Donnchaidh of Atholl. Cultivating cordial relations with these lords was essential to the security of the Scottish kingdom, particularly from the 1380s onwards once the MacDonalds switched their allegiance to Richard II. These cultural and political ties to Gaelic Scotland acted as a bridge into Gaelic Ireland and allowed the Stewarts to develop an alliance with the O'Donnells. Indeed, though it is beyond the scope of this present article, there is evidence to suggest that the Campbells of Loch Awe may have developed links with the O'Donnells during this time.Footnote 110
From the Scottish perspective, the alliance with the O'Donnells opened another front against the English in the western section of Ireland. This new theatre of military operations, in addition to aforementioned Scottish forays on eastern coast of Ulster and the Franco-Castilian raids on the south coast of Ireland, placed greater pressure on English military and financial resources. The O'Donnells could also contribute to the defense of Scotland, largely by tying English forces down in Ireland and, perhaps more importantly, by acting as a check on the MacDonalds. As noted earlier, it appears that by the early 1380s the Clan Alexander—the dynastic rivals of the lords of the Isles—had fragmented into smaller family branches. One of these branches migrated westwards, and by the early 1390s had found employment as galloglass under the MacDermots of Moylurg, who were members of the Ruadh faction and allies of Turlough an Fhíona O'Donnell.Footnote 111 This branch also appears to have had links with the O'Donnells; in 1397 O'Donnell personally attempted to secure a permanent lordship for the Clan Alexander by displacing the O'Connors of Sligo (see below). Though this venture ultimately ended in failure, the prospect of the Clan Alexander possessing a permanent base of operations in Ireland can hardly have been welcomed by the lord of the Isles.
At the close of the fourteenth century, much of the northern two-thirds of Ireland had become divided into the two opposing camps. The death of Éinrí Aimhreidh in May 1392 placed greater pressure on Tyrone's western defenses.Footnote 112 The same year, O'Donnell captured Éinrí’s son and successor, Domhnall Bog (d.1432), and only a combined attack led by Niall Óg O'Neill and O'Connor of Sligo contained the O'Donnell threat, albeit briefly, and secured Domhnall Bog's release.Footnote 113 By 1395 O'Donnell and his Ruadh faction allies had made significant gains both in Ulster and Connacht. It is from within this context that the MacDonalds sought to strengthen their ties with the English monarchy against the O'Donnells and their growing attachment to the Stewarts. Likewise, the O'Neills of Tyrone and their Donn faction allies, faced with a powerful network of enemies within Ireland, sought greater recognition and protection under English law. For Richard, the willingness of these Gaelic factions to negotiate provided him with the opportunity not only to strengthen English power in Ireland but to reestablish across much of the wider British Isles a degree of influence that had not been seen since the military hegemony of Edward I (d.1307).
Richard II in Ireland
Dorothy Johnston has noted that Richard II may have considered leading an expedition to Ireland as early as 1389. The limitations of surviving English and Anglo-Irish governmental sources make the reasons behind this intent extremely difficult to discern.Footnote 114 Having recovered his position from the Lords Appellant in late 1388, Richard was still focused on regaining his domestic standing, mainly by building ties with Wales, Chester, and other “peripheral” areas of his dominions. What is certain is that he regarded developments in Ireland as of great importance.Footnote 115 This poses the question as to what extent he was aware of developments in Ireland, particularly in the Gaelic west.
Taken at face value, surviving Anglo-Irish and English sources suggest that the colonial nobility's knowledge of developments in the western section of Ireland was limited. Developments in western Ireland were, however, unlikely to appear in English patent or close rolls unless of direct concern to the colonial government.Footnote 116 Yet Richard's actions in Ireland point to his having, at the very least, some understanding of the significant geopolitical shift then occurring in the western section of Ireland and the growing level of Avignon and Scottish influence there. Indeed, much of Richard's intelligence on affairs in western Ireland may have derived from the colonial earls who, as Robin Frame has outlined, had successfully adapted to frontier life in fourteenth-century Ireland.Footnote 117 James Butler, third earl of Ormond, for example, not only acted as interpreter for Richard during the submission of numerous chieftains but, according to Froissart, played an important role in persuading the most powerful chieftains to submit.Footnote 118 An investigation of the Richard's initial military campaign, coupled with an analysis of the submissions themselves, and the context of specific grants made to individual Gaelic lords, in turn, suggest that Richard was more informed on Gaelic affairs than is evident in surviving chronicle sources.
As noted in the introduction, the threat posed to colony's southern defenses by Art MacMurough-Kavanagh (d.1416/17) has attracted considerable scholarly attention. The course of Richard's successful campaign, culminating in Art's submission on 7 January, has been dealt with elsewhere.Footnote 119 Richard's success against the MacMurrough-Kavanaghs coupled with the sheer military might of his forces has long been regarded as one of the chief reasons why the other Gaelic lords felt compelled to submit (see table 3).Footnote 120 If this threat of force was indeed a factor, then it pertained mainly to the submissions of the Gaelic and rebel Anglo-Irish lords in Leinster, where the proximity of the royal army was more visible. For example, Murchadh O'Connor of Offaly (d.1421)—a member of the Ruadh faction—is recorded as being on the receiving end of sustained English assault; hence his submission to Richard (see table 3).Footnote 122 In comparison, the terrain of the Gaelic heartlands stretching from Thomond on the Atlantic seaboard to the northern coasts of Ulster presented a foreboding obstacle to Richard's army. The king would have been faced with a powerful coalition of Irish chieftains in the Donn faction had he decided to march north in an attempt to force their submission. That scenario was unlikely, considering that Richard's army was needed to secure Leinster and prevent Art MacMurrough-Kavanagh from breaking his peace. The activities of Richard and the lords of the Donn faction suggest instead that both parties hoped to achieve a mutually beneficial arrangement.
Table 3 Chief nobles who submitted to Richard IIFootnote 121
*Submitted to Roger Mortimer at Trim in late 1394
**Submitted both to Mortimer in late 1394 and Richard in spring 1395
Accompanying Richard on this expedition were a number of prominent English noblemen, chief among them Roger Mortimer (d.1398), fourth earl of March and the greatest absentee landlord in Ireland. In addition to his expansive estates in England and southeast Wales, Roger had inherited the earldom of Ulster and lordships of Connacht, Trim, and Meath from his father, Edmund, third earl of March (d.1381).Footnote 123 The recovery of these estates was of paramount importance to Richard and fitted into the aforementioned strategy of strengthening English power in the “peripheral” areas of the British Isles.Footnote 124 Richard had already developed a link between the MacDonalds and Mortimer through the earl's tenants, the Savages, and their marriage into the Bisset affinity. The remainder of Mortimer's Irish lands were largely controlled by members of the Donn faction (although Burke of Mayo, O'Donnell, and O'Connor Ruadh each held segments of the Mortimer lands). The O'Neills of Tyrone controlled most of Mortimer's lands in Ulster, though other segments were held by the O'Cahans, MacMahons, O'Neills of Clandeboy, O'Hanlons, and Magennises. The O'Reillys of Breifne, O'Ferralls, MacGeoghegans, and O'Kearneys each bounded parts of Mortimer's patrimony in southern Ulster and northern Leinster, while Mortimer's lands in Connacht were controlled primarily by the Burkes of Clanrickard and the O'Connor Donn dynasty (see table 3).Footnote 125
Roger Mortimer's father, Edmund, had previously tried to recover these lands during his tenure as lord deputy of Ireland (1379–81). Though Edmund had some initial success in acquiring the submissions of Niall Mór O'Neill, O'Ferrall, MacGeoghegan, O'Kearney, O'Hanlon, Magennis, and O'Reilly, his heavy-handed tactics (such as the burning of large areas of eastern and southern Ulster) pushed many Gaelic lords into rebellion.Footnote 126 Following Edmund's death in 1381, the Dublin government was unable contain O'Neill incursions into eastern Ulster and northern Leinster. Carrickfergus was burned in 1384, while Dundalk was suffered two major O'Neill raids in 1387 and 1392 (see figure 1).Footnote 127 For Richard, it was clear that military action against the lords of the Donn faction would yield minimal results. By negotiating with these lords, he stood a better chance of recovering of recovering the Mortimer inheritance; moreover, the establishment of strong, cordial relations with these lords would greatly bolster English influence across the northwestern section of the island and limit the potential for Scottish intervention in Ireland.
Richard thus strove to build stronger links between the lords of the Donn factions, the colonial administration, and the crown. He secured a greater degree of legal protection for the submitted lords by defining their legal status before the Irish Council, issuing pardons for past offences, and knighting the more powerful lords—Niall Óg, Brian O'Brien (d.1400), Turlough Óg O'Connor Donn, and William Burke of Clanrickard (d.1423) (as well as Burke's regional ally, Walter Bermingham).Footnote 128 The knighthoods bound these lords closer to the king; the case of O'Connor Donn is particularly important. In addition to being admitted to English law (placing him, in the words of one scholar, within Richard's “charmed circle”), O'Connor Donn was also granted the constabulary of Roscommon Castle.Footnote 129 Once a bastion of English power west of the Shannon, Roscommon Castle had been lost to the O'Connors since the 1350s; Richard's grant, however, went beyond simply acknowledging the castle's current occupant.Footnote 130 Within the broader context of the submissions, the grant served to bolster O'Connor Donn's position against his main rival, Turlough O'Connor Ruadh, the main ally of O'Donnell and a supporter of the Avignon papacy in Connacht. Furthermore, when taking the submission of the Donn faction, Richard used clerics loyal to Rome as intermediaries and messengers (such as the bishops of Kilfenora and Kilmacduagh). Further, to prevent these lords’ breaking the king's peace, he bound most of them to various sums of money before the representative of the Roman papal camera, Francis de Capanago.Footnote 131 The promotion of the Roman Church, in turn, served to limit the influence of Avignon and therefore the Scottish crown in Gaelic Ireland.
Ultimately, it was the fear of a Scottish attack on northern England that convinced Richard to return home, leaving Waterford on 15 May 1395.Footnote 132 Traditionally, his expedition of 1394–95 has been regarded as a failure, owing to the necessity of a second expedition in 1399, one that effectively ended his reign. Richard's Irish settlement was nonetheless made unworkable for two main reasons: the territorial ambitions of the earl of March and his ally Ormond, and the activities of O'Donnells. Surviving letters indicate that sometime in late 1394, Niall Óg O'Neill, O'Brien, O'Connor Donn, and Tadhg MacCarthy (d.1428) of Desmond discussed the prospect of submitting.Footnote 133 O'Brien and O'Connor Donn were reluctant to submit to Richard and attempted to convince O'Neill of the same.Footnote 134 The reasons for their hesitancy are uncertain. It is likely that both lords were anxious at the possibility of a renewed English presence in the west – a region where English influence had been defunct for nearly fifty years. O'Brien and O'Connor Donn also appear to have been faced with significant opposition from their regional allies, the most notable of them being Domhnall O'Connor (d.1395), lord of Sligo—a supporter of O'Connor Donn (see figure 1).Footnote 135 Unlike most other colonial towns lost to the Gaelic Irish, Sligo remained a functioning borough with a lucrative maritime trade. Domhnall may have feared that a renewed English presence in the west would have undermined his control of the port town.Footnote 136 By late January 1395, Niall Óg O'Neill was engaged with highly sensitive talks with Richard. Unwilling to tolerate any opposition, Niall Óg threatened to attack Domhnall O'Connor unless he acquiesced and submitted to Richard.Footnote 137 While Niall Óg's threat of military intervention in Sligo ultimately secured Domhnall's compliance, the O'Neill aggression demonstrates how lesser families (such as the O'Connors of Sligo) were often expendable in the hands of more powerful lords.
Tadhg MacCarthy's concerns regarding his submission related to developments in the southern half of Ireland, particularly Munster (see figure 1).Footnote 138 James Butler, earl of Ormond, and Gerald FitzGerald (d.1398), third earl of Desmond had been feuding since the early 1380s.Footnote 139 The Mortimers had been allies of the Butlers since the late 1370s, and Roger Mortimer naturally aligned himself with Ormond to gain leverage within Irish politics.Footnote 140 As Peter Crooks has suggested, Ormond used his influence with Roger and Richard to have the king's cousin – Edward Albemarle (d.1415), earl of Rutland—created earl of Cork.Footnote 141 Ormond's ploy effectively drove a wedge into Desmond's power base, forcing MacCarthy to acknowledge the authority of Rutland rather than Desmond as his immediate overlord.Footnote 142 Though MacCarthy eventually agreed to this arrangement and received a knighthood from Richard, he first met with the lords of the Donn faction to discuss the prospect of submission.Footnote 143 Melaghlin O'Kelly (d.1402), lord of Hymany and a member of the Donn faction, presented a similar case. Writing to Richard II in March 1395, he expressed his fears that Ormond, under the guise of Richard's authority, was about to seize lands held by O'Kelly's kindred since the early fourteenth century.Footnote 144 O'Kelly also informed Richard that as a security measure to counter Ormond, he had enlisted the support of the earl of Desmond's son, John (d.1399).Footnote 145
Brendan Smith has suggested that Mortimer was more adept at negotiating frontier life in Ireland than perhaps has been acknowledged.Footnote 146 A great lord of the Anglo-Welsh marches, Mortimer enjoyed strong relations with both his English and Welsh tenants—not unlike his ally Ormond and his ability to uphold English power in Ireland while at the same time engaging with Irish culture.Footnote 147 Mortimer was also a patron of the Welsh poet Iolo Goch (d.1397). In a famous poem addressed the earl in early 1394, Iolo Goch extolled Mortimer's martial prowess and encouraged him to subdue the “Ulster dog”—Niall Óg O'Neill.Footnote 148 Mortimer's desire to “get his rents” from the Irish of Ulster, however energetic, placed great strain upon Richard II's Irish settlement.Footnote 149 In January 1395, Niall Óg wrote to Richard beseeching him to be his “shield” against the ambitions of the young earl.Footnote 150 The O'Neills were willing to reach a settlement with Mortimer and agreed to surrender the buannacht (the billeting of soldiers on local populations) of Ulster to him.Footnote 151 Relations between the O'Neills and Mortimer, however, soured the following year. Having been appointed lord deputy of Ireland by Richard (though his jurisdiction was limited to Ulster, Connacht and Meath; Sir William Scrope had had powers over Munster, Leinster, and Louth), Mortimer, with the support of Ormond and the earl of Kildare, attacked the O'Neills, O'Reillys, and O'Ferralls, burning Armagh and its cathedral in the process before raiding the Magennis territory of Iveagh and killing the heir to the lordship, Cú-Uladh.Footnote 152 These attacks, though aimed at cowing the O'Neills and the Irish of eastern Ulster, achieved relatively little. Mortimer's actions instead had a ripple effect upon the western section of Ireland, one that was ruthlessly exploited by O'Donnell and his allies.
Niall Mór and Niall Óg's fixation with Richard in the east left western Tyrone vulnerable. An O'Donnell-fomented civil war in the Maguire lordship of Fermanagh in early 1395 created a distraction that Turlough an Fhíona used to raid western Tyrone, capturing Brian (d.1402), brother of Domhnall Bog (see figure 1).Footnote 153 A second attack orchestrated by O'Donnell's ally Burke of Mayo on the Donn faction in western Connacht drew the O'Connors of Sligo westwards, enabling O'Donnell to launch a devastating raid upon the Sligo lordship (see figure 1).Footnote 154 With Brian held captive, there was little Domhnall Bog could to do to withstand O'Donnell. The lack of assistance from his cousin, Niall Óg, appears to have pushed Domhnall Bog into rebellion. By late 1395, he is recorded as leading an attack on Niall Óg's caput (possibly either Dungannon or Navan Fort), taking both his son and heir designate, Brian Óg, and wife, Úna, captive, before handing Úna over to the English.Footnote 155 While the annals do not identify Úna's new captors, it is possible that they were handed over to Mortimer as a stark warning to Niall Óg to devote greater resources to war against O'Donnell.
Niall Óg was spurred into action. In early 1396, he ransomed Brian from O'Donnell, subsequently handing him over to Domhnall Bog in exchange for his own son, Brian Óg (d.1403).Footnote 156 By this time, Niall Óg was under assault from Mortimer in the west and unable to take further action against O'Donnell. Over the course of 1396, O'Donnell launched a number of assaults upon Sligo, eventually driving Murtagh Bacach O'Connor (d.1403)—brother and successor of Domnall O'Connor—from his lordship in early 1397.Footnote 157 The Donn faction were now stretched on a series of fronts: O'Donnell in the north and Mortimer pressing on Tyrone and Annaly, while O'Connor Ruadh defeated an army led by O'Connor Donn in central Connacht (see figure 1).Footnote 158 O'Donnell now sought to establish full control of Sligo, installing his grandson Tadhg O'Connor (d.1403) as lord of Sligo and granting a segment of the lordship to the Clan Alexander (see figure 1).Footnote 159 It was only bickering among Tadhg O'Connor's men and the Clan Alexander over the division of lands, and a surprise counterattack by Murtagh Bacach that saw O'Donnell's forces driven from the region, enabling Murtagh Bacach to regain control of Sligo by early1398.Footnote 160 Despite this victory, a considerable amount of damage had been done. Domnall Bog had briefly refused to support Niall Óg against O'Donnell in 1397, effectively giving O'Donnell a free reign in the west. Though Domnall reconciled with Niall Óg in 1398, divisions had been sown between the two dominant O'Neill kindreds in Tyrone. This growing rift would eventually lead to the outbreak of both civil war and a succession crisis in Tyrone during the early fifteenth century (see below).
From the perspective of the crown, the situation in Leinster was little better. Mortimer's attacks on the Gaelic Irish of Ulster and Ormond's activities in Munster made it very difficult for the recently submitted chieftains to remain within the king's peace. Though Dorothy Johnston has argued that Leinster was at peace during 1395–98, evidence contained in the Irish annals suggests a very different state of affairs.Footnote 161 Tensions between the Gaelic Irish of Leinster and northeastern Munster increased following a botched attempt at capturing Art MacMurrough-Kavanagh in late 1395.Footnote 162 Art's allies, the O'Tooles, are recorded as inflicting a heavy defeat upon English forces in 1396.Footnote 163 Though colonial troops, perhaps in retaliation, burned the monastic site of Glendalough in the Wicklow Mountains during the summer of 1398, the O'Connors of Offaly succeeded in capturing Gerald FitzGerald (d.1432), earl of Kildare, the same year.Footnote 164 The English position in Leinster was to suffer a further blow later in the year. Despite a brief spell of royal disfavor, owing largely to the activities of his uncle, the Appellant Sir Thomas Mortimer (d.1397), Roger Mortimer was reconciled with Richard and reappointed to his Irish lieutenancy in April 1398—only to perish two months later while campaigning against the O'Byrnes in Carlow.Footnote 165
Prior to Mortimer's death Richard had become increasingly concerned about the situation in Ireland and announced his intention to lead a second expedition there in the autumn of 1397.Footnote 166 Whether or not the king was genuinely interested in securing a suitable compromise between the crown and the main Irish lords—the O'Neills and Donn faction in particular—remains a matter of debate.Footnote 167 Mortimer's death and Kildare's capture in 1398 nonetheless forced Richard's hand regarding Ireland, and the following year, on 1 June 1399, Richard landed at Waterford.Footnote 168 Unlike his venture of 1394–95, this expedition proved a military disaster. Richard was soundly beaten by Art MacMurrough-Kavanagh at every turn. The subsequent outbreak of Henry Bolingbroke's rebellion forced Richard to return to England, only to be deposed by the new king in October 1399.Footnote 169 The vacuum created by Mortimer's death and Richard's sudden departure allowed Art MacMurrough-Kavanagh to reassert his position in southern Leinster. Mercenaries raised from Munster enabled him to push northwards through Wicklow, while an alliance with Maurice, de facto fifth earl of Desmond, opened a second front against Art's main regional ally, James, earl of Ormond.Footnote 170
The situation in Leinster was but one in a series of problems faced by the new Lancastrian administration in Ireland and the wider Irish Sea world. Mortimer's earlier raids on Ulster, followed by the outbreak of civil war in Tyrone, seriously damaged the O'Neills’ relationship with the colonial government in Dublin. It would take years and the strong leadership of Niall Óg's son, Eoghan (d.1456), to rebuild this relationship. Internecine feuding in Tyrone would facilitate the rise of Turlough an Fhíona's son, Niall Garbh (d.1439), who would come to dominate northern Irish affairs until the early 1430s. The consolidation of O'Donnell power in this period, coupled with the outbreak of Owain Glyn Dŵr's rebellion in Wales, in turn exposed large areas of the Irish and Welsh coastlines to French and Scottish intervention. While Glyn Dŵr's son, Maredudd ab Owain, finally surrendered to Henry V (d.1422) and accepted a pardon from the king in April 1421, the situation in Ireland played out somewhat differently.Footnote 171 It was largely thanks to the intervention of Alexander, lord of the Isles (d.1449), that Niall Garbh was defeated and the earlier O'Neill hegemony restored.Footnote 172
Conclusion
Richard II was the last English head of state to lead military operations in Ireland until Oliver Cromwell in 1649. In an age when the “first English Empire” of the thirteenth and earlier fourteenth centuries was entering a period of protracted decline, Richard's Irish expeditions represented a concerted and pragmatic attempt to reverse the “ebb tide” of English power and build stronger links with the more “peripheral” areas of the British Isles. The decline of English power within the wider British Isles during this period, coupled with England's increasing entanglement in France during the Hundred Years’ War, has seen an increasing number of scholars gravitate toward the “Plantagenet” model when exploring the development of English royal power in the later Middle Ages. Nonetheless, it is important to locate Richard's Irish ventures within the broader archipelagic context and to utilize a regional approach when considering both the English crown's relations with the archipelago's constituent regions and the political development of late medieval Britain and Ireland as whole—the dynamic relationship between elements of Gaelic Ireland and Gaelic Scotland in particular. As a case study, this article has, on one level, offered new insights into Richard's relationship with lords of the wider Gaelic world. On another level, it has demonstrated the necessity of paying closer attention to the Gaelic west as a force within “British” politics. Although the so-called Celtic fringe remains a geographically peripheral region of late medieval Ireland and Britain, developments there could impact and impinge upon the English and Scottish world during both the later Middle Ages and well into early modern periods. The Gaelic world's ability to influence the course of “British” politics and its capacity to destabilize the kingdoms of England and Scotland in these eras however, have yet to be fully appreciated.
