Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T17:45:13.077Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Little Manx Nation: Antiquarianism, Ethnic Identity, and Home Rule Politics in the Isle of Man, 1880–1918

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2014

John Belchem
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

As imperial pride flourished in the racial discourse of late Victorian British politics, ethnic revival and Celtic nationalism also gained purchase and resonance. These complex and seemingly competing issues of identity extended beyond the “four nations” of the United Kingdom to the Isle of Man, a crown dependency constitutionally outside the United Kingdom but at the very center of the British Isles. In this “land of home rule,” adrift in the Irish Sea, the juxtaposition of Britishness and Celticism was particularly acute, compounded by the proud persistence of Norse traditions. Manx independence within the Atlantic archipelago was symbolized by the annual Tynwald Day ceremony, a Viking “Thing” or general meeting, at which the year's new legislation was promulgated in both English and Manx Gaelic. In the late Victorian period, as Anglo-Manx business syndicates invested heavily in the “visiting industry,” transforming the island into “one large playground for the operatives of Lancashire and Yorkshire,” gentlemanly antiquarians constructed (and/or invented) the necessary traditions to safeguard Manx cultural distinctiveness and its devolved political status. Through the assertion of Celticism, a project that tended to downgrade Norse contributions to the island's past, the little Manx nation girded itself against cultural anglicization, yet remained unquestionably loyal to the British empire.

Slightly other than English, the Manx have displayed what Sir Frank Kermode has described as “mild alienation” and “qualified foreignness,” characteristics that need to be considered in the wider debate about British identity.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 39 , Issue 2 , April 2000 , pp. 217 - 240
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For detailed analysis of the constitutional relationship between the Isle of Man and the United Kingdom, see Kermode, David, Devolution at Work: A Case Study of the Isle of Man (Farnborough, 1979)Google Scholar. Historians have yet to locate the Isle of Man within the pluralist framework sketched by Pocock, J. G. A., “British History: A Plea for a New Subject,” Journal of Modern History 47 (1975): 601–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Quayle, Robert, “The Isle of Man Constitution,” in The Isle of Man: Celebrating a Sense of Place, ed. Robinson, Vaughan and McCarroll, Danny (Liverpool, 1990), pp. 123–24Google Scholar.

3 Belchem, John, “‘The Playground of Northern England’: The Isle of Man, Manxness and the Northern Working Class,” in Northern Identities, ed. Kirk, Neville (Aldershot, 2000)Google Scholar, in press. Passenger arrivals reached a peak of 634,512 in 1913.

4 Kermode, Frank, Not Entitled (London, 1996), p. 19Google Scholar. For the best introduction to the debate on Britishness, see Samuel, Raphael, “British Dimensions: ‘Four Nations History,’” History Workshop Journal 40 (1995): iii–xxiiCrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 For useful introductions to the revival in Ireland, see Lyons, F. S. L., Culture and Anarchy in Ireland, 1890–1939 (Oxford, 1982)Google Scholar, chs. 2 and 3; and Foster, R. F., Modern Ireland, 1600–1972 (London, 1989)Google Scholar, ch. 18.

6 Mona's Herald (17 April 1844).

7 The analysis applied here relies heavily on Hobsbawm, Eric and Ranger, Terence, eds., The Invention of Tradition (Cambridge, 1983)Google Scholar; Anderson, Benedict, Imagined Communities (London, 1991)Google Scholar; and Smith, A. D., The Ethnic Origins of Nations (Oxford, 1986)Google Scholar.

8 See the “Prospectus,” inserted in the Manx Museum Library (MML), Douglas, , copy of Publications of the Manx Society (Douglas, 1859), p. iGoogle Scholar.

9 See the chapter on “Cultural History” coordinated by Bazin, Fenella and Faragher, Martin in Belchem, John, ed., New History of the Isle of Man, 1830–Present (Liverpool, in press)Google Scholar.

10 Levine, Philippa, The Amateur and the Professional: Antiquarians, Historians and Archaeologists in Victorian England, 1838–1886 (Cambridge, 1986), pp. 70–100Google Scholar.

11 “The Origin of the Manx Language Society,” in the annual report of YCG, 1913–14, appendix to Mannin, no. 2 (May 1914): 20.

12 Celtia 1, no. 9 (September 1901): 142–43Google Scholar.

13 Brown, T. E., “Dedication: Fo'c'sle Yarns: Second Series,” in Poems of T. E. Brown, 2 vols. (Liverpool, 1952), 1:iiGoogle Scholar.

14 Although the nation remains the “major narrative principle” of this article, it is to be hoped it will find favor with postmodernist historians for whom “writing from the periphery is coming to be much more interesting than writing from the center.” See Joyce, Patrick, “The Return of History: Postmodernism and the Politics of Academic History in Britain,” Past and Present, no. 158 (1998): 225–27Google Scholar.

15 See the biographical sketch of Moore, , the “Manninee Dooie of Modern Times,” in Cubbon, William, Island Heritage (Manchester, 1952), pp. 321–23Google Scholar; and the obituary in Celtic Review 6 (1909–1910): 283–86Google Scholar.

16 Moore, A. W., Manx Note Book: A Quarterly Journal of Matters Past and Present Connected with the Isle of Man 1, no. 1 (1885): 1–3Google Scholar.

17 “Artistic merit cannot compensate for a defective balance sheet,” Walpole, Spencer, “Epilogue,” Manx Note Book 3, no. 12 (1887): 193–94Google Scholar. On occasion, the lieutenant governor's wife assisted with the illustrations.

18 “Memorandum on the Antiquities of the Isle of Man,” Manx Note Book 2, no. 5 (1886): 38–40Google Scholar. When the British Association for the Advancement of Science met in Manchester in 1887, Boyd-Dawkins led a delegation to visit the island; see The British Association Visit to the Isle of Man (Douglas, 1887)Google Scholar.

19 Moore, A. W., “The Connection of the Isle of Man with Ireland,” Celtic Review 6 (1909–1910): 110–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

20 Shimmin, Christopher, Outlines from Manx History (Peel, 1916), p. 15Google Scholar.

21 On the “poor history” of the Manx, see Brown, T. E., “Preface,” in Manx Ballads and Music, ed. Moore, A. W. (Douglas, 1896), p. xGoogle Scholar; on the lack of disasters, see Brown, T. E. to Roeder, C., 4 November 1895, Mannin, no. 9 (May 1917): 520–23Google Scholar.

22 Brown, T. E. to Brown, H. F., 25 August 1895, in Letters of Thomas Edward Brown, ed. Irwin, S. T., 4th ed. (Liverpool, 1952), p. 216Google Scholar.

23 SirCaine, Thomas Henry Hall, The Little Manx Nation (London, 1891), pp. 46–49Google Scholar.

24 Shimmin, , Outlines, p. 10Google Scholar.

25 Moore, A. W., The Folk-Lore of the Isle of Man (Douglas and London, 1891), pp. 1 and 33Google Scholar.

26 Killip, Margaret, The Folklore of the Isle of Man (London, 1975), p. 43Google Scholar. The multi-million pound “House of Manannan” opened in Peel in 1997, the latest “heritage” attraction of the award-winning “Story of Mann.”

27 “Manx Names,” Celtia 4, no. 2 (1904): 20–25Google Scholar.

28 Moore, A. W. (with an introduction by Rhys, ), The Surnames and Place-Names of the Isle of Man (London, 1890), pp. 1–21Google Scholar.

29 Manx Note Book 2, nos. 7 and 8 (1886): 97–113 and 164–66Google Scholar, and 3, nos. 9, 10, and 11 (1887): 5–22, 78–90, and 120–24. See also the review of Roger, J. C., “Celticism, A Myth,” in Proceedings of the Isle of Man Natural History and Antiquarian Society 1 (1889): 297–99Google Scholar.

30 Kermode, P. M. C., Manx Crosses (1907; reprint, with an introduction by Wilson, David, Balgavies, 1994)Google Scholar.

31 For thirty years and five months, Moore took daily weather readings at Cronkbourne; he even kept a record of his bicycle mileage—some twenty-one hundred miles between 1 April 1902 and 1 January 1903; see A. W. Moore, personal diary, 1892–1909, MML, A. W. Moore Papers, 168A.

32 Beddoe, John, “The Physical Anthropology of the Isle of Man,” Manx Note Book 3, no. 9 (1887): 22–33Google Scholar. For a discussion of Beddoe's impressive ethnological credentials and innovative methods, see Curtis, L. Perry Jr., Apes and Angels, rev. ed. (Washington, D.C., 1997), pp. 19–20Google Scholar.

33 Moore, A. W. and Beddoe, J., “Physical Anthropology of the Isle of Man,” Journal of the Anthropological Institute (August 1897), pp. 104–30Google Scholar.

34 Report of the Visit of the Celtic Congress to the Isle of Man, 1938 (Douglas, 1938), p. 9Google Scholar.

35 Brown, T. E. to Roeder, C., 11 September 1895, Mannin, no. 9 (May 1917): 519–20Google Scholar.

36 “Manxland People,” newspaper cutting dated 1884 in A. W. Moore, scrapbook, MML, A. W. Moore Papers, F64/65.

37 Caine, Hall, Little Manx Nation, pp. 147–48Google Scholar.

38 Gill, W. H., “National Traits,” in The Manx National Song Book: From the Manuscript Collection of the Deemster Gill, Dr J. Clague and W. H. Gill (1896; reprint, Douglas, 1979), p. ixGoogle Scholar.

39 Moore, , Manx Ballads and Music, p. xxxvGoogle Scholar.

40 Gill, , Manx National Song Book, p. xiGoogle Scholar.

41 Bazin, Fenella, “Music in the Isle of Man Up to 1896” (Ph.D. thesis, University of Liverpool, 1995), pp. 403–4Google Scholar.

42 Fenella Bazin, “‘Mylecharaine’: A Forgotten Call to Nationhood” (paper presented at the Folksong Tradition and Revival Conference, Sheffield, 10–12 July 1998).

43 Norris, Samuel, Two Men of Manxland (Douglas, 1947), p. 165Google Scholar.

44 Brown, T. E., “Preface,” in Moore, , Manx Ballads and Music, pp. x–xiGoogle Scholar.

45 Brown, T. E. to Irwin, S. T., 28 January 1894, in Irwin, , ed., Letters, pp. 156–57Google Scholar.

46 “Seventeenth Annual Report of the Manx Society, 1916,” Mannin, no. 8 (November 1916): 498Google Scholar.

47 Feltham, J., A Tour through the Isle of Mann in 1797 and 1798 (1798; reprint, Manx Society, 1861), p. 53Google Scholar.

48 Shirley to his parents, 18 February 1847, and to R. H. Cheney, 23 February 1847, in Letters and Memoir of the Late Walter Augustus Shirley, ed. Hill, T. (London, 1849), pp. 474–76 and 480–81Google Scholar.

49 W. Gill's introduction to Rev.Kelly, John, A Practical Grammar of the Antient Gaelic, or Language of the Isle of Man, Usually Called Manks (Manx Society, 1859), p. ixGoogle Scholar.

50 Ibid., pp. viii–ix.

51 Moore, A. W., “An Historical Sketch of the Manx Language, with an Account of the Sources from Which a Knowledge of It Can Be Acquired,” in Proceedings of the Isle of Man Natural History and Antiquarian Society 1 (1889): 129–34Google Scholar.

52 Quoted in Broderick, George, “Language Death in the Isle of Man” (Habilitationsschrift, University of Mannheim, 1997), pp. 202–3Google Scholar.

53 Killip, , Folklore, p. 58Google Scholar.

54 A. W. Moore to Edmund Goodwin, 8 September 1909, quoted in Moore, A. W. (with the cooperation of Morrison, S. and Goodwin, E.), Vocabulary of the Anglo-Manx Dialect (Oxford, 1924), p. viGoogle Scholar.

55 See the advertisement for the dictionary at the end of Mannin, no. 2 (November 1913).

56 Kewley-Draskau, Jennifer, “Englishes in the Isle of Man,” in Belchem, , ed., New HistoryGoogle Scholar.

57 T. E. Brown to A. M. Worthington, 18 October 1886, and to Mrs. Williamson, 16 April 1890 (?), both in Irwin, , ed., Letters, pp. 77–78 and 88–90Google Scholar.

58 T. E. Brown to J. C. Tarver, 18 February 1894, in Irwin, , ed., Letters, pp. 163–65Google Scholar.

59 Sutton, Max Keith, The Drama of Storytelling in T. E. Brown's Manx Yarns (Newark, 1991), p. 34Google Scholar.

60 T. E. Brown to J. R. Mozley, 4 November 1882, in Irwin, , ed., Letters, pp. 64–65Google Scholar.

61 T. E. Brown to H. G. Dakyns, 20 October 1895, in Irwin, , ed., Letters, p. 227Google Scholar.

62 T. E. Brown to E. Rydings, 19 January 1895, in Irwin, , ed., Letters, p. 197Google Scholar.

63 T. E. Brown to H. G. Dakyns, 20 October 1895, in Irwin, , ed., Letters, p. 227Google Scholar.

64 Thomas Edward Brown: A Memorial Volume, 1830–1930 (Cambridge, 1930)Google Scholar.

65 Moore, A. W., Manx Worthies (Douglas, 1901), p. 79Google Scholar.

66 See Dr.Newton's, articles on armorial bearings in Manx Note Book 2, nos. 5 and 7 (1886): 1–16, 125–27Google Scholar.

67 Report of the Manx Language Society, Celtia 2, no. 3 (March 1902): 44–45Google Scholar; Gill's, W. H. “Arranger's Preface,” Manx National Song Book, p. xiiGoogle Scholar. “Our only instrument was the fiddle, and this we had in common with every country in Europe, but we had no instrument of a distinctively national kind,” Quayle, J. E., “Characteristics of Manx Folk-Song,” in Transactions of the Celtic Congress 1921 (Swansea, 1923), pp. 111–24Google Scholar.

68 Moore, , Folk-Lore, p. 179Google Scholar. However, the Irish delegation to the Celtic Congress in 1938 included two teams of girls who “played a demonstration Camoge match … Camoge is the organised and developed modern form of the only known Manx traditional game of Cammag” (Report of Visit of the Celtic Congress to the Isle of Man 1938 [Douglas, 1938], p. 18Google Scholar).

69 On the formation of the Manx Folk Dance Society, see Joe Woods to Oscar MacUilis, 22 September 1951, National Library of Wales (NLW), Aberystwyth, Celtic Congress Papers, A1983/151.

70 This report is based on the journals produced by the Association, Celtia (1901–5) and Celtic Review (1904–14). For a brief secondary study of the Congress, see Ellis, Peter B., The Celtic Revolution (Talybont, 1985), pp. 192–93Google Scholar.

71 Celtia 1, no. 9 (September 1901): 144Google Scholar.

72 Celtia 1, no. 3 (March 1901): 33–34Google Scholar.

73 Breesha Maddrell, “Locating Sophia” (paper presented at the Center for Manx Studies seminar, Douglas, 6 November 1997).

74 Brown, T. E. to Roeder, C., 11 September 1895, quoted in Mannin, no. 9 (May 1917): 520Google Scholar.

75 T. E. Brown to S. T. Irwin, 18 September 1892, in Irwin, , ed., Letters, p. 98Google Scholar.

76 Caine, Hall, Little Manx Nation, p. 126Google Scholar.

77 Review of Goodwin, E., First Lessons in Manx (Celtic Association, Dublin)Google Scholar, in Celtia 2, no. 1 (January 1902): 15–16Google Scholar; annual report of YCG, Celtic Review 1 (1911): 188–89Google Scholar.

78 Yearly report of YCG, 1913, appendix to Mannin, no. 1 (May 1913): 6Google Scholar.

79 For required changes in names and spelling, see Celtia 1, no. 4 (April 1901): 59Google Scholar; see Celtia 2, no. 8 (August 1902): 115Google Scholar regarding language.

80 Celtia 3, no. 6 (July-August 1903): 89–92Google Scholar.

81 YCG annual report, 1913–14, appendix to Mannin, no. 3 (May 1914): 2–3Google Scholar.

82 Finn, Iolar, “Language and Nationality in the Isle of Man,” in Irish Freedom (January 1914)Google Scholar; reprinted in Celtic History Review 2 (1996): 10–11Google Scholar.

83 Joe Woods to Oscar MacUilis, 27 May 1951, NLW, Celtic Congress Papers.

84 Ibid.

85 For Tynwald as Celtic, see Joe Woods, “Lecture on National Life in the Isle of Man” (delivered to Brest Congress, 1955), NLW, Celtic Congress Papers. Moore's account stressed how the Tynwald Court coincided with traditional Celtic midsummer festivities; see Moore, A. W., “The Tinwald,” Transactions of the International Folk-Lore Congress, 1891 (London, 1892), pp. 379–84Google Scholar.

86 Lord Castletown's presidential address, Celtia 1, no. 9 (September 1901): 142–43Google Scholar. See also E. T. John's presidential address in 1921 when the Congress first met on the island, in praise of “the unique achievement of the little Manx nation … its organised separate national existence as embodied in its legislature … You enjoy a vantage ground—a privileged position—in this respect, which is more or less the envy of all the sister Celtic nations,” in Transactions of the Celtic Congress, 1921, p. 32.

87 Celtia 4, no. 6 (Congress Number, 1904): 101Google Scholar.

88 See the review of Walpole, Spencer, Land of Home Rule (London, 1893)Google Scholar, in Edinburgh Review 178 (1893): 32–55Google Scholar.

89 Vaukins, J., “The Manx Struggle for Reform” (M.Ph. thesis, University of Lancaster, 1984)Google Scholar; Norris, Samuel, Manx Memories and Movements, 3d ed. (1941; reprint, Douglas, 1994)Google Scholar, “Book Two: The Reform Movement.”

90 A. W. Moore, personal diary, 1892–1909, MML, A. W. Moore Papers, 168A, and personal scrapbook (which also includes material on his contribution to Masonic activity on the island), 9432/1.

91 A. W. Moore, personal diary, 15 August and 8 September 1902, and 19 June 1905, MML, A. W. Moore Papers.

92 (Deemster) Cain, T. W., “Constitutional Reform in the Twentieth Century,” in Proceedings of the Isle of Man Natural History and Antiquarian Society 10 (1993–1995): 201–24Google Scholar.

93 Annual report of YCG, appendix to Mannin 2, no. 3 (May 1914)Google Scholar. After Shimmin, the most successful writer of Anglo-Manx plays was “Cushag,” Josephine Kermode, sister of P. M. C. Kermode.

94 Mannin, no. 6 (November 1915): 371Google Scholar. Each issue printed a “Roll of Honour” of Manxmen killed or missing in action.

95 Mannin 3, no. 5 (May 1918): 306–8Google Scholar.

96 Clucas, G. Fred, “Should Our National Legislature Be Abolished?” Mannin, no. 8 (November 1916): 475–80Google Scholar.

97 Transactions of the Celtic Congress, 1921, p. 14.

98 Simpson, H. Derwent, “A Protest,” Mannin 8 (November 1916): 481–85Google Scholar; “Notes,” Mannin, no. 9 (May 1917): 564–65Google Scholar.

99 Sargeaunt, B. E., The Isle of Man and the Great War (Douglas, n.d.)Google Scholar.

100 Shimmin, , Outlines, p. 26Google Scholar.

101 Ellis, John, “Reconciling the Celt: British National Identity, Empire, and the 1911 Investiture of the Prince of Wales,” Journal of British Studies 37 (1998): 391–418CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

102 For the flavor of Manx ethnic essentialism, the lifelong passion of Mona Douglas for race, blood, and tradition, see her novel Rallying Song (Douglas, 1981)Google Scholar.

103 Prentice, Richard, “The ‘Manxness of Mann’: Renewed Immigration to the Isle of Man and the Nationalist Response,” Scottish Geographical Magazine 106 (1990): 75–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Miller, Stephen, “Mending Up the Rags: The Return of Manx Gaelic,” Planet: The Welsh Internationalist 101 (1993): 83–87Google Scholar.