Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T12:20:34.909Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Great Whigs and Parliamentary Reform, 1809–1830

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2014

Extract

The genesis of the Reform Act of 1832 is still not fully understood. It has become fashionable for historians to direct their attention toward two groups of Whigs who are seen as the ultimate arbiters of policy. The first, men of high visibility such as Lords Grey and Holland, was certainly of importance. The Reform Bill prime minister was the most brilliant political tactician the Whigs had produced since Walpole. But the senior leaders of the 1830s were already becoming rather antiquated in their ideas, and men of their type and generation were generally very moderate reformers. The other group to whom historians attribute the progressive elements of Whiggism, the Edinburgh Reviewers and especially Henry Brougham, are seen as the “new men,” the radicalizers and educators of Whiggery. Yet Brougham, for example, frequently worked against the efforts of advanced Whigs to unify and strengthen the party. Indeed, he actually regretted the liberal nature of the Reform Bill. The “new men” who might have played such a role in the House of Commons, Romilly, Horner, and Whitbread, were dead by 1818, the victims of disease and madness. Mackintosh and Macaulay contributed to the party's articulation of principles but did not shape them in the 1810s and 1820s.

No peaceful steps could have been taken toward actual constitutional change without the acquiescence, indeed the active cooperation, of the great Whig magnates. No Whig government could hope to survive for long or call itself Whig without support from the great families, most of them cousins by blood or marriage, whose surnames and titles were inextricably bound up with mythology anchored in the events of 1688–89.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1985

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Clive, John, Scotch Reviewers (London, 1957), pp. 123, 147, 184CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Thomas, William, “Whigs and Radicals in the Westminster Election of 1819,” Guildhall Miscellany 3 (1970): 181Google Scholar. Roberts, Michael, “The Leadership of the Whig Party in the House of Commons from 1807 to 1815,” English Historical Review 1 (1935): 636Google Scholar. Trevelyan, G. M., Lord Grey of the Reform Bill (London, 1920), p. 187Google Scholar.

2 J. C. Hobhouse, diary, British Library (BL), Additional (Add.) MS 56555, fol. 89. Brougham, Henry, Life and Times (Edinburgh, 1871), 2:341Google Scholar. Wasson, E. A., “The Coalitions of 1827 and the Crisis of Whig Leadership,” Historical Journal 20 (1977): 102CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Viscount Milton, diary, May 9, 13, 1820, Milton Park, Milton MSS (used by kind permission of the late Earl Fitzwilliam). Viscount Althorp to Earl Spencer, July 5, 7, 1830, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS (used by kind permission of the Earl Spencer).

3 Mitchell, Austin, “The Whigs and Parliamentary Reform,” Historical Studies: Australia and New Zealand 12 (1965): 25, 3536Google Scholar. Wasson, E. A., “The Spirit of Reform, 1832 and 1867,” Albion 12 (1980): 164 ffCrossRefGoogle Scholar. An alternative view of Whiggery can be found in Mandler, Peter, “Liberalism and Paternalism: The Whig Aristocracy and the Condition of England, 1830–1852” (Ph.D. diss., Harvard University, 1984)Google Scholar. Mandler offers, however, insufficient contemporary evidence to substantiate his categories of Whigs and fails to demonstrate that Tavistock, Althorp, and Milton were more “rustic” than their peers. For the Holland House set, see Mitchell, Leslie, Holland House (London, 1980)Google Scholar.

4 O'Gorman, Frank, “Electoral Deference in ‘Unreformed’ England: 1760–1832,” Journal of Modern History 56 (1984): 391429CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Davis, R. W., “The Whigs and the Idea of Electoral Deference,” Durham University Journal, n.s., 36 (1974): 7991Google Scholar, and Deference and Aristocracy in the Time of the Great Reform Act,” American Historical Review 81 (1976): 532–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Stone, Lawrence and Stone, Jeanne C. Fawtier, An Open Elite? England, 1540–1880 (Oxford, 1984), pp. 412–19Google Scholar. Milton-Smith, J., “Earl Grey's Cabinet and the Objects of Parliamentary Reform,” Historical Journal 15 (1972): 5574CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Duke of Devonshire to Henry Brougham, November 1830, University College, London, Brougham MS 18663.

6 Northampton Mercury (December 15, 1830) (Sir Charles Knightley). Greville, Charles, Memoirs, 1814–1860 (London, 1938), 2:207, October 12, 1831Google Scholar. Williams, Orlo, ed., Life and Letters of John Rickman (London, 1912), p. 284Google Scholar.

7 Bagot, Josceline, ed., George Canning and His Friends (London, 1909), 2:398Google Scholar. Whishaw, John, The “Pope” of Holland House (London, 1906), p. 183Google Scholar. For the Fitzwilliams, see Smith, E. A., Whig Principles and Party Politics: Earl Fitzwilliam and the Whig Party, 1748–1833 (Manchester, 1975)Google Scholar; Mee, Graham, Aristocratic Enterprise: The Fitzwilliam Industrial Undertakings, 1795–1857 (Glasgow, 1975)Google Scholar.

8 Spring, David, “Earl Fitzwilliam and the Corn Laws,” American Historical Review 59 (1954): 304CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Austin Mitchell, p. 30. Smith, p. xii. William Elliot to Fitzwilliam, January 20, 1817, Northamptonshire Record Office (RO), Fitzwilliam MSS.

10 Viscount Milton, notes for a speech, 1807, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MS X1605.

11 Collini, Stefan, Winch, Donald, and Burrow, John, That Noble Science of Politics: A Study in Nineteenth-Century Intellectual History (Cambridge, 1983), p. 56CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Parliamentary Debates (PD), 17:137–39, May 21, 1810Google Scholar. Milton, diary, June 15, 1818, and April 17, 1821, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

13 PD, 22:148–50, May 8, 1812, and 35:384–90, May 17, 1817. Milton, diary, May 7, 1819, Milton Park, Milton MSS. Leeds Mercury (October 17, 1812).

14 PD, 14:501, May 11, 1809. Viscount Milton to Viscount Folkestone, April 1, 1809, Berkshire RO, Pleydell-Bouverie MS D/EPb 025/64. Thomas Creevey to Samuel Whitbread, April 4, 1809, Bedfordshire RO, Whitbread MS W1/373/13.

15 PD, 14:776–77, May 26, 1809, and 1015, June 12, 1809; 17:137–39, May 21, 1810; 27:889, May 16, 1814; and 34:369, May 8, 1816.

16 Willis, Richard, “Fox, Grenville, and the Recovery of Opposition, 1801–1804,” Journal of British Studies 11, no. 2 (1972): 25CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Hill, B. W., “Fox and Burke: The Whig Party and the Question of Principles, 1784–1789,” English Historical Review 89 (1974): 3Google Scholar.

17 PD, 8:972, February 23, 1807.

18 PD, 20:510, June 7, 1809.

19 Earl Fitzwilliam to Milton, [March 1809], Fitzwilliam MS X1611.

20 PD, 13:540–45, March 15, 1809.

21 Grey, C., ed., Some Account of the Life and Opinions of Charles Second Earl Grey (London, 1861), pp. 223–24Google Scholar. Earl Grey to Lady Grey, May 10, 1809, University of Durham, Grey MSS. Earl of Dudley, Letters to “Ivy” (London, 1905), p. 134Google Scholar.

22 Grey to Lady Grey, May 13, 1809, George Ponsonby to Grey, December 16, 1809, and George Tierney to Grey, July 17 and August 30, 1809, University of Durham, Grey MSS.

23 SirJackson, George, Diaries and Letters (London, 1872), 2:420–21Google Scholar.

24 Milton to Viscount Duncannon, November 18, 1834, West Sussex RO, Bessborough MSS (used by kind permission of the earl of Bessborough).

25 Milton, diary, December 22, 1828, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

26 PD, 24:261–69, December 10, 1812.

27 Northampton Mercury (March 13, 1813).

28 PD, 33:930–34, April 4; 32:965–71, February 28, and 1075, March 4; and 34:493–95, 504, May 13, 1816.

29 PD, 32:1075, March 4, and 33:95–99, March 8, 1816.

30 Northampton Mercury (February 24, 1816, and February 11, 1815). PD, 32:1047, March 1, 1816 (Thomas William Coke).

31 PD, 34:628, May 20, and 903–6, May 28, 1816. SirRomilly, Samuel, Memoirs (London, 1840), 3:249Google Scholar.

32 Milton to Lady Fitzwilliam, November 21, 1802, and March 15, 1803, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

33 PD, 11:578, May 25, 1808, and 22:848, April 23, 1812.

34 Lady Spencer to Spencer, January 28, 1817, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS.

35 C. Pelham to Lord Yarborough, February 20, 1817, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

36 Lady Spencer to Spencer, April 17, 1817, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS. PD, 35:730–33, February 26, 1817.

37 PD, 35:789–99, February 28, 1817.

38 PD, 40:471, May 17, 1819.

39 PD, 40:1211, June 18, and 1083, June 10, 1819(Milton). The Times (June 19, 1819).

40 PD, 36:1082–85, June 20, and 35:731, February 26, 1817.

41 PD, 36:1129–31, June 23, 1817. The Times (June 24, 1817).

42 Halévy, Elie, The Liberal Awakening, 1815–1830 (London, 1961), p. 34Google Scholar.

43 Charles Williams Wynn to Mary Williams Wynn, February 27, 1817, University of Wales, Aberystwyth, Wynn MSS (transcript, History of Parliament Trust).

44 Lady Spencer to Milton, July 6, 1817, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

45 The Times (June 28, 1977), quoting a letter from David Ricardo to a friend, April 27, 1819.

46 Lord Grenville to Fitzwilliam, March 23, 1817, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS. Grey to Grenville, [February 22, 1817], BL, Add. MS 58949, fol. 191.

47 PD, 35:384–90, February 17, and 36:811, May 20, 1817.

48 Althorp to Milton, January 20, 1830, and January 21 and May 17, 1818, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

49 Robert Price to Milton, April 22, 1819, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS. Milton, diary, May 7, 1819, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

50 PD, 22:149–50, May 8, 1812, and 40:279–81, May 10, 1819. Milton, diary, May 10, 1819, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

51 Milton to Fitzwilliam, August 23, 25, and Fitzwilliam to Milton, August 22, 24, 1819, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

52 Ziegler, Philip, Addington (London, 1965), pp. 374–75Google Scholar. Twiss, Horace, Life of Lord Chancellor Eldon (London, 1844), 2:339Google Scholar. Brock, W. R., Lord Liverpool and Liberal Toryism, 1820–1827 (Cambridge, 1941), pp. 78, 109, 117–18Google Scholar. White, R. J., Waterloo to Peterloo (London, 1968), pp. 8796Google Scholar. Bentley, Michael, Politics without Democracy, 1815–1914 (London, 1984), pp. 29, 4143Google Scholar.

53 Grey to Lady Grey, December 1, 1819, University of Durham, Grey MSS. Yonge, Charles, Life and Administration of Robert Banks, Second Earl of Liverpool (London, 1868), 2:419Google Scholar.

54 Lord Holland to Viscount Ebrington, September 20, 1819, Devon RO, Fortescue MS/FC77. Marquess of Tavistock to J. C. Hobhouse, September 14, 1819, BL, Add. MS 47223.

55 Leeds Mercury (October 9, 16, 1819). Lord Lascelles to Viscount Sidmouth, October 15, 1819, Devon RO, Sidmouth MS 152M/c1819/OZ 20.

56 Pellew, George, Life and Correspondence of Henry Addington (London, 1847), 3:88Google Scholar.

57 Fitzwilliam to Grey, October 10, [1819], University of Durham, Grey MSS. SirHeron, Robert, Notes (Grantham, 1852), p. 104Google Scholar.

58 Grey to Devonshire, Chatsworth, Derbyshire, September 23, 1819, Chatsworth MSS (used by kind permission of his grace the duke of Devonshire). Grey to Brougham, August 25, 1819, Brougham (n. 2 above), 2:342.

59 PD, 41:1414, December 21, 1819.

60 Milton, diary, November 30 and December 13, 1819, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

61 Leeds Mercury (October 16, 1819).

62 Milton, diary, December 9, 1819, Milton Park, Milton MSS. Northampton Mercury (December 11, 1819).

63 Milton, diary, December 14, 1819, Milton Park, Milton MSS. Northampton Mercury (March 18, 1820).

64 Broughton, Lord, Recollections of a Long Life (London, 1909), 2:140, January 23, 1821Google Scholar.

65 Fitzwilliam to Milton, October 31, 1820, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS. PD, 4:362, February 5, 1821 (marquess of Tavistock).

66 Milton, diary, 1820, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

67 Althorp to Milton, September 2, 1821, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MS X1608.

68 Milton, memorandum, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MS X1608. Fitzwilliam to Grey, March 24, 1822, University of Durham, Grey MSS.

69 PD, 14:1089, March 3, 1826.

70 Althorp to Spencer, October 24, 1819, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS. Brougham (n. 2 above), 2:349. Milton to James Scarlett, July 28, 1830, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS. Milton to Brougham, August 1, 1830, University College, London, Brougham MS 9483.

71 Northampton Mercury (February 2, 1822).

72 New, Chester, Lord Durham (London, 1968), p. 54Google Scholar. Grey to Lady Grey, December 2, 1819, University of Durham, Grey MSS.

73 Fitzwilliam to Grey, April 17, 1827, University of Durham, Grey MSS.

74 Wasson, E. A., “The Young Whigs: Lords Althorp, Milton, and Tavistock and the Whig Party, 1809–1830” (Ph.D. thesis, Cambridge University, 1975), pp. 134–35Google Scholar. PD, 41:643–45, 667, December 2, 1819. Althorp to Spencer, October 24, 1819, and January 17 and April 17, 1820, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS.

75 William Lyttelton to Tierney, February 9, 1820, Hampshire RO, Tierney MS 48. Althorp to Spencer, February 13, 1820, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS.

76 Plumb, J. H., The Growth of Political Stability in England, 1675–1725 (Baltimore, 1969), pp. 6971Google Scholar.

77 Lord John Russell to Holland, February 23, 1818, BL, Add. MS 51677, fol. 34. Northampton Mercury (March 21, 1818). Grantham did not inherit a Bedfordshire estate until 1833.

78 Sir B. Bloomfield to Sidmouth, October 19, 1819, Devon RO, Sidmouth MS OH 16. The prince regent to Sidmouth, October 24, 1819, Devon RO, Sidmouth MS OH 17. Althorp to Milton, October 24, 1819, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MS X1607.

79 Twiss (n. 52 above), 2:347. Sidmouth to Viscount Castlereagh, October 16, 1819, Devon RO, Sidmouth MS 152M/c1819/OH 17 (copy).

80 Ironically, Fitzwilliam himself had replaced the duke of Norfolk in 1798 after the latter's removal on account of his famous toast, “The People, our Sovereign.” The earl accepted in order to gratify an old resentment against Norfolk. (LordHolland, , Memoirs of the Whig Party During My Time [London, 18521854], 1:131Google Scholar.) For a defense of the government's decision, see Gash, Norman, Lord Liverpool (London, 1984), p. 145Google Scholar.

81 Brougham (n. 2 above), 2:349.

82 Althorp to Milton, October 24, 1819, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MS X1607. Althorp to Spencer, October 24, 1819, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS.

83 Lady Spencer to Sarah Lyttelton, November 15, 1819, Lyttelton, Lady, Correspondence (London, 1912), p. 217Google Scholar.

84 Duke of Buckingham, Memoirs of the Court of George IV, 1820–1830 (London, 1859), 2:364, October 30, 1819Google Scholar.

85 James MacDonald to Holland, October 31, [1819], BL, Add. MS 51542, fol. 154.

86 Northampton Mercury (December 11, 1819).

87 Milton, diary, November 22, 1819, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

88 PD, 41:1415, December 21, 1819.

89 Smith (n. 7 above), p. 231.

90 PD, 11:958, May 31, 1824.

91 Milton, diary, April 18, 1826, Milton Park, Milton MSS. Spring (n. 8 above). PD, 15:353, April 18, 1826.

92 Tavistock to W. Russell, December 22, 1830, LordRussell, William, Letters from Various Writers, 1817–1845 (privately printed, London, 19151917), 2:300Google Scholar. Tavistock to Hobhouse, March 31, 1830, BL, Add. MS 36466.

93 Moore, Thomas, Memoirs, Journal, and Correspondence (London, 1853), 3:252, July 8, 1821Google Scholar.

94 PD, 15:351–54, April 18, 1826.

95 Fitzwilliam, Earl, First, Second, and Third Addresses to the Landowners of England on the Corn Laws (London, 1839), p. 44Google Scholar.

96 Grey to Brougham, August 25, and Brougham to Grey, September 19, 1819, Brougham (n. 2 above), 2:342–43, 346–47. Holland to Ebrington, postmarked September 20, 1819, Devon RO, Fortescue MS FC 77. Sir James Mackintosh to Lord John Russell, January 12, 1820, Russell, R., ed., Early Correspondence of Lord John Russell, 1805–40 (London, 1913), 1:210Google Scholar. Leeds Mercury (November 20, 1819) (Althorp). Milton, diary December 13, November 30, and December 8, 1819; and May 15, 1821, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

97 Milton, diary, February 13, 1821, Milton Park, Milton MSS. Milton to Sir George Cayley, March 11, 1821, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

98 PD, 5:437–38, April 17, 1821. Morning Chronicle (April 3, 1821).

99 PD, 5:437–38, April 17, 1821. Morning Chronicle (April 3, 1821). Milton, diary, April 17, 1821, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

100 Leeds Mercury (January 25, 1823). Althorp to J. C. Gotch, February 12, 1821, Northamptonshire RO, Gotch MS GK 1206.

101 Moore, 3:201, February 22, 1821.

102 Ibid., p. 172, November 24, 1820.

103 Milton, diary, June 6, 1821, Milton Park, Milton MSS.

104 Milton to Grey, October 22, 1822, University of Durham, Grey MSS. Milton to Walter Fawkes, August 10, 1822, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS. Leeds Mercury (November 9, 1822, and January 25 and April 17, 1823). The Times (January 25, 1823), quoted in Austin Mitchell (n. 3 above), p. 37.

105 Lady Spencer to Spencer, October 2, 1812, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS.

106 Francis Jeffrey to Francis Horner, December 21, 1809, Horner, Francis, Memoirs and Correspondence (London, 1843), 2:12Google Scholar. Jeffrey to John Allen, December 22, 1809, Cockburn, Lord, Life of Lord Jeffrey (Edinburgh, 1852), 2:126Google Scholar.

107 Leeds Mercury (June 13, 1807). PD, 5:997, May 24, 1821, and 32:964–65, February 28, 1816.

108 Thompson, F. M. L., “Whigs and Liberals in the West Riding, 1830–1860,” English Historical Review 74 (1959): 217–18Google Scholar. Smith, E. A., “The Yorkshire Elections of 1806 and 1807,” Northern History 2 (1967): 83CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

109 Lady Spencer to Milton, Friday, [May?] 22, [1818], Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

110 Fitzwilliam (n. 95 above), pp. 34–35.

111 Horner to Jeffrey, September 15, 1806, Horner, 1:374.

112 PD, 17:139, May 21, 1810.

113 Collini et al. (n. 11 above), pp. 84, 122.

114 Leeds Mercury (June 21, 1826, and April 28, 1821). Baines, Edward Jr., The Life of Edward Baines (London, 1859), p. 96Google Scholar.

115 Pellew (n. 56 above), p. 88.

116 Watson, George, The English Ideology (London, 1973), p. 16Google Scholar.

117 Grey to Lady Grey, December 4, 1819, University of Durham, Grey MSS.

118 PD, 22:848, April 23, 1812.

119 Jennings, Louis, ed., The Croker Papers (London, 1884), 1:170Google Scholar. Ward, Robert Plumer, Memoirs (London, 1850), 2:25Google Scholar.

120 Grey to Fitzwilliam, April 9, 1820, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS. James Abercromby to Tierney, [1818], Hampshire RO, Tierney MS la. Cockburn (n. 106 above), 2:189. Althorp to Spencer, December 21, 1819, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS.

121 Milton, diary, May 9, 1825, Milton Park, Milton MSS. PD, 13:238, April 26, 1825.

122 PD, 7:85, April 25, 1822.

123 Fitzwilliam to Grey, March 24, 1822, University of Durham, Grey MSS. Milton to Fawkes, August 10, 1822, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS. Heron (n. 57 above), pp. 107–8.

124 For the latest discussion of the coalitions and Catholic emancipation, see Davis, R. W., “The Tories, the Whigs, and Catholic Emancipation, 1827–1829,” English Historical Review 87 (1982): 8998CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Machin, G. I. T., “Canning, Wellington, and the Catholic Question, 1827–1829,” English Historical Review 89 (1984): 94100CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

125 Wasson, “The Coalitions of 1827 and the Crisis of Whig Leadership” (n. 2 above), passim. LordCampbell, , Life (London, 1881), 1:453Google Scholar.

126 Milton to Hobhouse, Wednesday, 1827, BL, Add. MS 36464, fol. 133.

127 Colonel L. G. Jones to Milton, December 8, 1829, Northamptonshire RO, Fitzwilliam MSS.

128 Milton to Ebrington, October 6, 1831, Devon RO, Fortescue MS 1262M/FC 87.

129 Praed, W. M., quoted in Gibbs, Vicary and Doubleday, H. A., eds., The Complete Peerage (London, 1926), 5:524Google Scholar.

130 Milton to Ebrington, October 6, 7, 1831, Devon RO, Fortescue MS 1262M/FC 87.

131 Duke of Wellington, Wellington and His Friends (London, 1965), p. 94Google Scholar.

132 PD, 13:299, June 1, 1832, and 15:910, May 14, 1832.

133 PD, 13:431, June 5, 1832.

134 See PD, 5:1099, August 9, and 6:344–46, August 20, 1831. Althorp to Grey, November 1831, Althorp Park, Althorp MSS. Edward Littleton, diary, February 29, 1832, Staffordshire RO, Hatherton MS 26/7/364. PD, 6:346, August 20, and 200, August 17; and 5:777, August 4, 1831. Aspinall, Arthur, ed., Three Early Nineteenth Century Diaries (London, 1952), p. 121Google Scholar. For a contrasting view, see Moore, D. C., The Politics of Deference (New York, 1976), pp. 137 ff.Google Scholar; but also Cannon, John, Parliamentary Reform, 1640–1832 (Cambridge, 1973), pp. 246 ff.Google Scholar; Brock, Michael, The Great Reform Act (London, 1973), pp. 223 ff.Google Scholar; Wasson, , “The Young Whigs” (n. 74 above), p. 164Google Scholar; PD, 9:1117, February 1, 1832, and 6:274, August 18, 1831.

135 Northampton Mercury (June 4, 1831), Milton, letter, May 25, 1831.