Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T18:55:01.979Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Dutch and the Second British Empire in the Early Nineteenth-Century Indian Ocean World

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 May 2019

James David Wilson
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

During the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars, the British Empire grew through its invasion of Dutch colonies around the Indian Ocean rim. The incursions entwined British and Dutch politics, cultures, and social networks. These developments were significant for the Dutch East Indies, but have received relatively little attention in histories of the Second British Empire. In light of recent interest in Anglo-Dutch interaction, connectivity across empires, and the uses of prosopography to question the boundaries of imperial history, this article uses Dutch biographies to interrogate the relationship between the politics of liberal reform and despotism in the Cape Colony and Java under the British. A dialectic between despotism and liberalism dominates the Second Empire's historiography. Conversely, tracing the biographies of two interstitial figures who passed between the Dutch Empire and that of Britain shows how despotism and reform were connected. The Dutch drew notions of reform from their social networks into the Cape and Java through their manipulation of loyalist rhetoric. Concurrently, the use of such rhetoric legitimized societies and controls linked to the entrenchment of autocracy. This article thus reveals links between connectivity and control in Britain's Indian Ocean empire.

Type
Original Manuscript
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 58 , Issue 2 , April 2019 , pp. 366 - 393
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

I am enormously grateful to Sujit Sivasundaram, Renaud Morieux, Peter Mandler, and the journal's peer reviewers and editors for their valuable advice on various drafts of this article. I also thank the Cambridge reading group and the panel organized by Elizabeth Elbourne and Durba Ghosh at the 2017 meeting of the North American Conference on British Studies for their interest and helpful feedback.

References

1 For the history of these colonies under the Dutch, see Ward, Kerry, Networks of Empire: Forced Migration in the Dutch East India Company (Cambridge, 2009)Google Scholar; for the Second Empire, see Bayly, C. A., Imperial Meridian: The British Empire and the World, 1780–1830 (London, 1989), 193–247Google Scholar, especially 162.

2 For information on the Literary Society, see Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1816 (Batavia, 1816), 163; for travel, see, for example, “Memorial from Mrs. Fichatt,” 5 July 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 90, British Library (hereafter BL); “Memorial of Jan de Bruyn Keizer,” 14 July 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 92, BL; for employment in government, see The National Archives, WO 1/324, Clark and Elphinstone to Dundas, 12 October 1795, 1–5.

3 van Goor, Jurrien, Prelude to Colonialism: The Dutch in Asia (Hilversum, 2004), 83–98Google Scholar; Carey, Peter, “Revolutionary Europe and the Destruction of Java's Old Order, 1808–1830,” in The Age of Revolutions in Global Context, c. 1760–1840, ed. Armitage, David and Subrahmanyam, Sanjay (Basingstoke, 2010), 167–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 There are some exceptions to this claim, notably Schrikker, Alicia, British and Dutch Colonial Intervention in Sri Lanka, 1780–1815: Expansion and Reform (Leiden, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Baptism of Dorothea Catharina Steyn, 13 February 1785, “South Africa, Dutch Reformed Church Registers (Cape Town Archives), 1660–1970,” FamilySearch, accessed 2 October 2017, https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VRLQ-6C7. See also Heese, J. A., Die Herkoms van die Afrikaner (Cape Town, 1971), 162Google Scholar.

6 “Reis na England,” 1813–14, A779, Western Cape Archives (hereafter WCA).

7 Stoler, Ann Laura, “Tense and Tender Ties: The Politics of Comparison in North American History and (Post) Colonial Studies,” Journal of American History 88, no. 3 (December 2001): 820–65CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed, at 852; Lambert, David and Lester, Alan, “Introduction: Imperial Spaces, Imperial Subjects,” in Colonial Lives across the British Empire: Imperial Careering in the Long Nineteenth Century, ed. Lambert, David and Lester, Alan (Cambridge, 2006), 1–31Google Scholar, at 2.

8 von Oppen, Achim and Strickrodt, Silke, “Introduction: Biographies between Spheres of Empire,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 44, no. 5 (2016): 717–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 718. This point also draws on Lambert and Lester, “Introduction: Imperial Spaces,” 2; Anderson, Clare, Subaltern Lives: Biographies of Colonialism in the Indian Ocean World, 1790–1920 (Cambridge, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 This point picks up on the uneven picture of connectivity explored in Ballantyne, Tony and Burton, Antoinette, “Introduction: The Politics of Intimacy in an Age of Empire,” in Moving Subjects: Gender, Mobility, and Intimacy in an Age of Global Empire, ed. Ballantyne, Tony and Burton, Antoinette (Urbana, 2009), 1–28Google Scholar.

10 As in Rothschild, Emma, The Inner Life of Empires: An Eighteenth-Century History (Princeton, 2011), 6–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 See Bayly, Imperial Meridian, 164–247; Laidlaw, Zoë, Colonial Connections, 1815–45: Patronage, the Information Revolution, and Colonial Government (Manchester, 2005), 13–168Google Scholar.

12 Bayly, Imperial Meridian, 235–47.

13 McKenzie, Kirsten, Imperial Underworld: An Escaped Convict and the Transformation of the British Colonial Order (Cambridge, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 11; Bayly, C. A., Recovering Liberties: Indian Thought in the Age of Liberalism and Empire (Cambridge, 2012)Google Scholar; Laidlaw, Colonial Connections, 40; Laidlaw, “Richard Bourke: Irish Liberalism Tempered by Empire,” in Lambert and Lester, Colonial Lives across the British Empire, 113–44.

14 McKenzie, Imperial Underworld, 103–58.

15 Class here is socially contingent, drawing on Anderson, Subaltern Lives, 7.

16 For an exploration of Anglo-Dutch aspiration, see Ross, Robert, Status and Respectability in the Cape Colony, 1750–1870: A Tragedy of Manners, 2nd ed. (Cambridge, 2009), 40–69Google Scholar.

17 Sannes, H., “De schoolmeesters van Franeker in de loop der tijden, I. De Latijnse school,” It Beaken: Meidielingen fen de Fryske Akademy, no. 11 (November 1949): 203–32Google Scholar, at 216; The National Archives, CO 48/16, Turr to Peel, 11 July 1812, 28.

18 Philip, Peter, British Residents at the Cape, 1795–1819: Biographical Records of 4,800 Pioneers (Cape Town, 1981), 358Google Scholar.

19 On trans-imperial history, see Jasanoff, Maya, Edge of Empire: Lives, Culture, and Conquest in the East, 1750–1850 (New York, 2005)Google Scholar; on Anglo-Dutch connections, see McKenzie, Imperial Underworld, 159–212. A panel at the November 2017 meeting of the North American Conference on British Studies (NACBS) explored the theme of “Anglo-Dutch Collaborations, Rivalries, and Exchanges in Europe and Beyond, 1585–1714.”

20 Drieënhuizen, Caroline, “Social Careers across Imperial Spaces: An Empire Family in the Dutch-British World, 1811–1933,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 44, no. 3 (2016): 397–422CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 398–99.

21 Drieënhuizen, “Social Careers across Imperial Spaces,” 399.

22 Buckner, Philip and Francis, R. Douglas, introduction to Rediscovering the British World, ed. Buckner, Philip and Francis, R. Douglas (Calgary, 2005), 9–20Google Scholar.

23 Dubow, Saul, “How British Was the British World? The Case of South Africa,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 37, no. 1 (March 2009): 1–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 17–18.

24 Dubow, “How British Was the British World?,” 10.

25 Dubow, 11, 15.

26 Pietsch, Tamson, “Rethinking the British World,” Journal of British Studies 52, no. 2 (April 2013): 441–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 415; Dubow, “How British?,” 19; Drieënhuizen, “Social Careers,” 399.

27 Schama, Simon, Patriots and Liberators: Revolution in the Netherlands, 1780–1813, 2nd ed. (London, 2005), 212Google Scholar.

28 The National Archives, WO 1/324, Clark and Elphinstone to Dundas, 12 October 1795, 1–5.

29 See Freund, William M., “The Cape under the Transitional Governments, 1795–1814,” in The Shaping of South African Society, 1652–1840, ed. Elphick, Richard and Giliomee, Hermann (Middletown, 1979), 324–51Google Scholar.

30 Freund, “The Cape under the Transitional Governments, 1795–1814.”

31 Carey, “Revolutionary Europe,” 167–88; van Goor, Prelude to Colonialism, 83–98; Jordaan, Roy, “Nicolaus Engelhard and Thomas Stamford Raffles: Brethren in Javanese Antiquities,” Indonesia, no. 101 (April 2016): 39–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 59.

32 John Bastin, Raffles’ Ideas on the Land Rent System in Java and the Mackenzie Land Tenure Commission, vol. 14, Verhandelingen van het Koniklijk Instituut voor Taal-, Land-, en Volkenkunde (Leiden, 1954), vii–193, at 154.

33 Ulrich, Nicole, “International Radicalism, Local Solidarities: The 1797 British Naval Mutinies in Southern African Waters,” International Review of Social History 58, no. 21 (December 2013): 61–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 68.

34 Goswami, Manu, Producing India: From Colonial Economy to National Space (Chicago, 2004), 280CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 Ward, Networks of Empire, 9.

36 Ward, 1–84, 239–82.

37 Schrikker, British and Dutch Colonial Intervention, 131–210; van Goor, Prelude to Colonialism, 84–85.

38 McKenzie, Imperial Underworld, 159–90.

39 Bayly, Recovering Liberties, 95.

40 Bayly, 95–96.

41 Schrikker, British and Dutch Colonial Intervention, 164–65; “Petition Addressed to Alexander Johnston by Over 40 Burghers,” 15 July 1815, 25.1/27, Sri Lanka National Archives; Eleventh Report of the Directors of the African Institution (London, 1817), 93–101.

42 For the chauvinistic interpretation, see Taylor, Jean Gelman, The Social World of Batavia: Europeans and Eurasians in Colonial Indonesia, 2nd ed. (Madison, 2009), 105Google Scholar; Janse, Maartje, “‘Holland as a Little England?’ British Anti-Slavery Missionaries and Continental Abolitionist Movements in the Mid Nineteenth Century,” Past and Present 229, no. 1 (November 2015): 123–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 125.

43 Sturgis, James, “Anglicization at the Cape of Good Hope in the Early Nineteenth Century,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 11, no. 1 (1982): 5–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 16–18.

44 Bosma, Ulbe and Raben, Remco, Being “Dutch” in the Indies: A History of Creolization and Empire, 1500–1920 (Singapore, 2008), 89–94Google Scholar; Tarling, Nicholas, Anglo-Dutch Rivalry in the Malay World, 1780–1824 (Cambridge, 1962)Google Scholar.

45 Marshall, P. J., “British Assessments of the Dutch in Asia in the Age of Raffles,” Itinerario 12, no. 1 (March 1988): 1–16CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 13.

46 Marshall, “British Assessments of the Dutch in Asia in the Age of Raffles,” 8.

47 Marshall, 3.

48 Marshall, 9; Taylor, Social World of Batavia, 78–113.

49 Ulrich, “International Radicalism,” 68.

50 Sujit Sivasundaram, “Towards a Critical History of Connection: The Port of Colombo, the Geographical ‘Circuit,’ and the Visual Politics of New Imperialism, ca. 1880–1914,” Comparative Studies in Society and History 59, no. 2 (April 2017): 346–84.

51 David Bell, “This Is What Happens When Historians Overuse the Idea of the Network,” New Republic, 25 October 2013; Heyman, Josiah and Campbell, Howard, “The Anthropology of Global Flows: A Critical Reading of Appadurai's ‘Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy,’” Anthropological Theory 9, no. 2 (June 2009): 131–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 134.

52 Bright, Rachel K. and Dilley, Andrew R., “After the British World,” Historical Journal 60, no. 2 (June 2017): 547–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53 Pietsch, “Rethinking the British World,” 441–63, at 463.

54 Ross, Status and Respectability, 40–69; Bickford-Smith, Vivian, “Revisiting Anglicization in the Nineteenth-Century Cape Colony,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 31, no. 2 (2003): 82–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

55 Bickford-Smith, “Revisiting Anglicization,” 91; Ross, Status and Respectability, 40–69, at 42, 69.

56 Anderson, Subaltern Lives, 7; Lambert and Lester, “Introduction: Imperial Spaces,” 2.

57 Ross, Status and Respectability, 69; Bayly, Recovering Liberties, 1, 147–48; Major, Andrea, Slavery, Abolitionism, and Empire in India, 1772–1843 (Liverpool, 2012), 321–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

58 Sannes, “De schoolmeesters van Franeker,” 216.

59 Sannes; “Het Gerechte der Stad Franeker,” Friesche Courant, 12 December 1797.

60 A. J. van der Aa, s.v. “Turr (Frederik Everard),” Biographisch Woordenboek der Nederlanden, 27 vols. (Haarlem, 1852–1878), 18:246.

61 F. E. Turr, Homerus (Amsterdam, 1810); Bouman, Hermannus, Geschiedenis van de voormalige Geldersche Hoogeschool en hare hoogleeraren, 2 vols. (Utrecht, 1844–1847), 2:572Google Scholar.

62 Turr, Homerus; Dongelmans, B. P. M., Johannes Immerzeel Junior (1776–1841) (Amstelveen, 1992), 188Google Scholar; Rosendaal, Joost, “Vrijmetselarij en Revolutie,” in “Een stille leerschool van deugd en goede zeden”: Vrijmetselarij in Nederland in de 18e en 19e eeuw (Hilversum, 1995), 63–83Google Scholar.

63 Turr, Homerus, xiii–xxxi.

64 Turr, 1–2.

65 See Young, Brian, “Pope and Ideology,” in The Cambridge Companion to Alexander Pope, ed. Rogers, Pat (Cambridge, 2008), 118–33Google Scholar.

66 Turr, Homerus, xxxiii.

67 Letter from “A Liberal Colonist,” Java Government Gazette, 13 January 1816.

68 Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 488.

69 Alan Amos Cooper, “The Origins and Growth of Freemasonry in South Africa, 1772–1876” (Master's thesis, University of Cape Town, 1980), 69–70.

70 F. E. Turr to Buyskes, Album Amicorum, 19 July 1814, A462, vol. 2, 44, WCA.

71 Message Book, July 1814, A462, vol. 2, 1–3, WCA.

72 A. H. van Bokkelen of New York to Buyskes, Album Amicorum, undated, A462, vol. 2, 25, WCA; Indo-Ceilonensis to Buyskes, Album Amicorum, undated, A462, vol. 2, 32, WCA; for van Bokkelen's career, see Spooner, Alden, Spooner's Brooklyn Directory, for the Year 1823 (Brooklyn, 1823), 32Google Scholar.

73 Maingard to Buyskes, Album Amicorum, 12 April 1812, A462, vol. 2, 30, WCA; G. H. Apthorp to Buyskes, Album Amicorum, 4 April 1815, A462, vol. 2, 45, WCA; Philip, British Residents, 9.

74 Taylor, Social World of Batavia, 52–113; Ross, Robert, “The Rise of the Cape Gentry,” Journal of Southern African Studies 9, no. 2 (April 1983): 193–217Google Scholar.

75 See Taylor, Social World of Batavia, 74–113; Kirsten McKenzie, “Social Mobilities at the Cape of Good Hope: Lady Anne Barnard, Samuel Hudson, and the Opportunities of Empire, c. 1797–1824,” in Ballantyne and Burton, Moving Subjects, 274–95, especially at 276 for middle-class experience of empire; McKenzie, Kirsten, The Making of an English Slave-Owner: Samuel Eusebius Hudson at the Cape of Good Hope, 1796–1807 (Rondebosch, 1993)Google Scholar.

76 McKenzie, “Social Mobilities,” 276.

77 McKenzie, 278–83.

78 For a discussion of elite sociability at this time, see Ross, Status and Respectability, 9–93.

79 Ross, 276.

80 “The Commercial and Navy Coffee House,” Cape Town Gazette and African Advertiser, 25 October 1800.

81 “Library,” Cape Town Gazette and African Advertiser, 22 March 1806. For more on Wehdemann, see Gunn, Mary and Codd, L. E., Botanical Exploration of Southern Africa (Cape Town, 1981), 372–73Google Scholar.

82 “Mantua Making and Millinery. A. Dick,” Cape Town Gazette and African Advertiser, 3 January 1801.

83 Baartman, Teun, “Protest and Dutch Burgher Identity,” in Cape Town between East and West: Social Identities in a Dutch Colonial Town, ed. Worden, Nigel (Auckland Park, 2012), 65–83Google Scholar; Worden, Nigel, van Heyningen, Elizabeth, and Bickford-Smith, Vivian, Cape Town: The Making of a City (Claremont, 1998), 58Google Scholar.

84 See “Request for Permission for Jacobus M. Wentzel and Alida Blankenberg to proceed to East Indies and Calcutta,” 15 March 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 35–36, BL.

85 P. C. Molhuysen and P. J. Blok, s.v. “Buyskes, Gerrit,” Nieuw Nederlands Biographisch Woordenboek, vol. 1 (Leiden, 1911), 529–30; “G. Buyskes Requesting for His Son to Proceed to Batavia,” 13 May 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 73–74, BL.

86 “Memorial from Mrs. Fichatt,” 5 July 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 90, BL; “Memorial of Jan de Bruyn Keizer,” 14 July 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 92, BL; for the ship's passenger list, see the Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1815 (Batavia, 1815), 148.

87 Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1815, 134, 197; Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1816, 176, 241.

88 Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1816, 175–76.

89 Heese, Die Herkoms, 29–31.

90 See Groenewald, Gerald, “Een Spoorloos Vrouwspersoon: Unmarried Mothers, Moral Regulation, and the Church at the Cape of Good Hope, circa 1652–1795,” Historia 53, no. 2 (November 2008): 5–32Google Scholar; Groenewald, , “‘A Mother Makes No Bastard’: Family Law, Sexual Relations, and Illegitimacy in Dutch Colonial Cape Town, c. 1652–1795,” African Historical Review 39, no. 2 (2007): 58–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

91 Onegt means “illegitimate”; see Groenewald, “Unmarried Mothers,” 13.

92 Philip, British Residents, 358.

93 Ross, Eddie, “George Ogilvie Ross in Four Continents,” North West Kent Family History 4, no. 8 (December 1987): 300–1Google Scholar; Philip, British Residents, 358.

94 Cooper, “Origins of Freemasonry,” 73.

95 “Reis na England,” 1813–14, A779, 7–8, WCA.

96 “Reis na England,” 35: “Wij de vriendelijkste onthalen heeft gehad.”

97 “Reis na England,” 19.

98 Molhuysen and Blok,“Buyskes, Gerrrit,” 529–30.

99 Hooft, H. G. A., Patriot and Patrician: To Holland and Ceylon in the Steps of Henrik Hooft and Pieter Ondaatje, Champions of Dutch Democracy (Canton, 1999), 54Google Scholar.

100 Cooper, “Origins of Freemasonry,” 55–56.

101 Cooper, 58.

102 Freund, “The Cape under the Transitional Governments,” 324–51.

103 Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 651.

104 Schama, 64, 212, 533–34.

105 Proclamations, Advertisements, and Other Official Notices Published by the Government of the Cape of Good Hope (Cape Town, 1827), 23; Report of a Commission Appointed to Inquire into and Report upon the Government Educational System of the Colony (Cape Town, 1863), xii.

106 “Reis na England,” 1813–14, A779, 25, WCA: “London is vol kerken daar men in gaan kom in welke kerk dat men wil … zo godsdienstig is de menschen in London, onder alle hunne lust voor ordikke eten en schouwburg spelen.”

107 Baartman, “Protest and Burgher Identity,” 65–83.

108 The Dutch wrote to the British governor and the East India Company for permission. See, for example, “Memorial of Jan de Bruyn Keizer,” 14 July 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 92, BL.

109 As in Drieënhuizen, “Social Careers,” 397–422; Taylor, Social World of Batavia, 74–113.

110 MacTaggart to Home, 30 April 1814, A578, vol. 1, 2–3, WCA.

111 Taylor, Social World of Batavia, 105; Jordaan, “Nicolaus Engelhard,” 39–66.

112 McKenzie, “Social Mobilities,” 278.

113 Original Familiar Correspondence between Residents in India, including Sketches of Java (Edinburgh, 1846), 373.

114 Letter from Weltevreden, 25 April 1812, 8–9, BL MSS Eur. D970.

115 Theal, George McCall, ed. Records of the Cape Colony, 36 vols. (London, 1897–1905)Google Scholar, 10:106, 103.

116 These figures are drawn from George Ross, The African Court Calendar for 1807 (Cape Town, 1807), 4–22, which lists 165 of 197 Capetonian posts as held by Dutchmen.

117 These figures are taken from the Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1815, 38–52.

118 “Mr. Cranssen's Party,” Java Government Gazette, 3 September 1814.

119 Jordaan, “Nicolaus Engelhard,” 59.

120 “Ode for His Majesty's Birth-Day,” Cape Town Gazette and African Advertiser, 4 June 1814.

121 “Reis na England,” 1813–14, A779, 2–3, WCA: “Eenige van die huisen, hier zijn zeer netjes gebouwd op den Engelse manier.”

122 “Reis na England,” 5: “Niets aanmerkelijk als een grote vlagge stok die voor omtrent zo jaar is door een Engelsche capiteyn op de hoogste berg daar geplant.”

123 “Reis na England,” 20–21: “Wij zijn naar Westminster gegaan, daar alle de Konings en groote lieden worden begraven, daar zijn de duizend beelden, onder welke is Lord Nelson en de Heer Pitt.”

124 “Reis na England,” 21–22: “Alle de kroonen die vol diamanten … zoveel gond en diamenten heb ik nooit gedacht om te zien.”

125 “Reis na England,” 32–33: “Dit stad van Madera is zeer aanzienlijk maar het is vol Roomsche priestes en bedelaars … daar fraaije dansen is te zien, maar zwelke onbeschaamde dansen zonder niet in Engeland gepermitteerd worden.”

126 “Reis na England,” 22–23: “Wij hebben ook alle de wilde dieren van alle landen gezien, onderwelke zijn veel van de Kaap.”

127 Theal, Records of the Cape Colony, 9:38–39, at 39.

128 Theal, 9:39.

129 “Advertisement,” Cape Town Gazette and African Advertiser, 19 December 1812.

130 “Advertisement.”

131 “Advertisement.”

132 Report of a Commission, xii.

133 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 29.

134 See Freund, “The Cape Under the Transitional Governments,” 324–51; Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 530.

135 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 27.

136 Report of a Commission, x.

137 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, pp. 27–28.

138 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, pp. 27–28.

139 Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 543–46.

140 Sigi Howes, “‘Tot Nut van het Algemeen’ School, Cape Town, 1804–1870: Case Study of a Cape School's Response to Political and Philosophical Changes in the 19th Century” (Master's thesis, University of Stellenbosch, 2004), 14; Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 534.

141 Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 534–35.

142 Schama, 537.

143 Schama, 536.

144 Howes, “Tot Nut van het Algemeen,” 24–26.

145 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 23.

146 Report of a Commission, xv.

147 Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1816, 164.

148 Van der Tuuk to Somerset, 27 June 1814, IOR/G/9/13, 86–87, BL.

149 “Reis na England,” 1813–14, A779, 26, WCA: “Deeze wonderlijk stad … . Publicke schoolen, weesen huisen en hospitalen voor den armen zijn hier in groote overvloed.”

150 “Reis na England,” 26.

151 “Reis na England,” 26–27: “Op een grooten dag is er meer als 1000 school kinderen na St Paules gegaan om een groote redevoering te hooren.”

152 Marsh, Herbert, “A Sermon Preached in the Cathedral Church of St. Paul's, London,” Pamphleteer, no. 1 (1813): 49–80Google Scholar.

153 Report of a Commission, xix.

154 Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 535.

155 Report of a Commission, xiv.

156 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, pp. 15–17.

157 “Advertisement,” Cape Town Gazette and African Advertiser, 19 December 1812.

158 Sturgis, “Anglicization at the Cape of Good Hope,” 8.

159 Sturgis, 8–9; Report of a Commission, xix.

160 Theal, Records of the Cape Colony, 9:38; Report of a Commission, appendix 3, p. 9.

161 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 25.

162 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, pp. 26–27.

163 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, pp. 24–26.

164 Report of a Commission, appendix 3, p. 9.

165 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 25.

166 Theal, Records of the Cape Colony, 9:37–38, at 38.

167 Theal, 9:195

168 Theal, 9:133–34.

169 Theal, 9:133.

170 Theal, 9:134, 163.

171 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, pp. 39–40.

172 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 40.

173 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 39.

174 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 39.

175 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 41.

176 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 42; for discussion of the debate about these systems in a global context, see Sivasundaram, Sujit, Nature and the Godly Empire: Science and Evangelical Mission in the Pacific, 1795–1850 (Cambridge, 2005), 66–77Google Scholar.

177 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, pp. 41–42.

178 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 42.

179 “Gelukwensching aan ‘t Volk van Nederland,” Cape Town Gazette and African Advertiser, 4 June 1814.

180 Report of a Commission, xxiv, appendix 3, p. 10, and appendix 5, p. 10.

181 See Sturgis, “Anglicization at the Cape of Good Hope,” 16–18.

182 Marsh, “A Sermon,” 61.

183 Report of a Commission, appendix 5, p. 41.

184 Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory for 1815, 148.

185 “A Large Portion,” Java Government Gazette, 21 January 1815.

186 Java Half-Yearly Almanac and Directory 1816, 241.

187 Jordaan, “Nicolaus Engelhard,” 39–66.

188 “Correspondence on State of Slavery in Territories under Rule of East India Company, and Slave Trade,” House of Commons Papers 125, vol. 24 (1828), 177Google Scholar.

189 Wright, H. R. C., “Raffles and the Slave Trade at Batavia in 1812,” Historical Journal 3, no. 2 (June 1960): 184–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

190 “Report from the Committee Appointed to Investigate the Case of Certain Chinese Whose Vessels Were Returned by HMS Cornelia,” Java Public Consultations, 5 January 1813, IOR/G/21/19, BL.

191 “Correspondence on State of Slavery,” 179.

192 “Correspondence on State of Slavery,” 179, 189.

193 Owen to Raffles, Java Public Consultations, 14 January 1813, IOR/G/21/19, BL.

194 “Correspondence on State of Slavery,” 177.

195 “Petition of Syed Alloo,” Java Public Consultations, 22 January 1813, IOR/G/21/19, BL.

196 Sayer to Gibbs, 23 March 1812, Java Public Consultations, 16 April 1812, IOR/G/21/16, BL; “Letter from the Civil Commissioner,” 31 March 1812, Java Public Consultations, 16 April 1812, IOR/G/21/16, BL.

197 Sayer to Gibbs, 23 March 1812, IOR/G/21/16, BL.

198 “Correspondence on State of Slavery,” 263.

199 Report of the Directors, 87. For the construction of idea of the “pirate,” see Layton, Simon, “Hydras and Leviathans in the Indian Ocean World,” International Journal of Maritime History 25, no. 2 (December 2013): 213–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

200 Report of the Directors, 87.

201 Report of the Directors, 87. See also Warren, James Francis, The Sulu Zone, 1768–1898: The Dynamics of External Trade, Slavery, and Ethnicity in the Transformation of a Southeast Asian Maritime State, 2nd ed. (Singapore, 2007)Google Scholar.

202 “Correspondence on State of Slavery,” 262–63.

203 “Correspondence on State of Slavery,” 265.

204 Report of the Directors, 77.

205 “Advertisement,” Java Government Gazette, 2 December 1815.

206 “Advertisement.”

207 “Letter from Anglicus,” Java Government Gazette, 30 December 1815.

208 “Letter from Anglicus.”

209 “Letter from Anglicus.”

210 “Letter from Anglicus.”

211 “A Meeting of Subscribers,” Java Government Gazette, 6 January 1816.

212 “Letter from a Colonist,” Java Government Gazette, 6 January 1816.

213 “A Meeting of Subscribers,” Java Government Gazette, 6 January 1816.

214 “A Meeting of Subscribers.”

215 Report of the Directors, 73

216 “Letter from a Liberal Colonist,” Java Government Gazette, 13 January 1816. The Dutch author is very probably Frederik Turr, as he references his experiences of travel and his chair on the institution's committee and even quotes a Latin phrase by Horace.

217 “Letter from a Liberal Colonist.”

218 “Letter from a Liberal Colonist.”

219 “Letter from a Liberal Colonist.”

220 “Letter from a Liberal Colonist.”

221 “Letter from a Liberal Colonist.”

222 Report of the Directors, 15.

223 Raffles, Thomas Stamford, History of Java, 2 vols. (London, 1817–1830)Google Scholar, 2:cxcvi.

224 Report of the Directors, 78.

225 Report of the Directors, 80.

226 Schama, Patriots and Liberators, 261.

227 Postma, Johannes, The Dutch in the Atlantic Slave Trade, 1600–1815 (Cambridge, 1990), 292CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

228 Saunderson, Barbara, “Frossard and the Abolition of Slavery: A Moral Dilemma,” Bulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester 72, no. 1 (1990): 155–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 156.

229 Theal, Records of the Cape Colony, 10:24–25.

230 Theal, 10:24–25.

231 “Letter from Philo Colonius,” Java Government Gazette, 20 April 1816.

232 “Letter from Philo Colonius.”

233 “Letter from Philo Colonius,”

234 Report of the Directors, 92.

235 Report of the Directors, 91–92.

236 Report of the Directors, 92.

237 Report of the Directors, 92.

238 Sturgis, “Anglicization at the Cape of Good Hope,” 11.

239 Sturgis, 10–11.

240 Sturgis, 16.

241 Sturgis, 17.

242 See Elbourne, Elizabeth, Blood Ground: Colonialism, Missions, and the Contest for Christianity in the Cape Colony and Britain, 1799–1853 (Montreal, 2002)Google Scholar.

243 Carey, “Revolutionary Europe,” 167–88.

244 Raffles, History of Java, 2:cxcvii.

245 Raffles, 2:cii.

246 Raffles, Sophia, Memoir of the Life and Public Services of Sir Thomas Stamford Raffles, 2 vols. (London, 1830–1835)Google Scholar, 2:52.

247 Van Goor, Prelude to Colonialism, 83–98.

248 Carey, “Revolutionary Europe,” 182–83.

249 Theal, Records of the Cape Colony, 35:365.

250 Report of a Commission, xxvii.

251 Theal, Records of the Cape Colony, 35:402–3.

252 “Java Benevolent Institution,” The Missionary Register for 1817 (London, 1817), 469Google Scholar; “Java Benevolent Institution,” Literary Panorama and National Register, no. 7 (1818): 652Google Scholar.

253 Report of the Directors, 69–92.

254 Cochin, Augustin, The Results of Slavery, trans. Booth, Mary L. (Boston, 1863), 205Google Scholar.

255 For the early modern period, see Israel, Jonathan I., ed., The Anglo-Dutch Moment: Essays on the Glorious Revolution and Its World Impact (Cambridge, 1991)Google Scholar; Oostindie, Gert and Roitman, Jessica V., eds., Dutch Atlantic Connections, 1680–1800: Linking Empires, Bridging Borders (Leiden, 2014)Google Scholar; Gaastra, Femme S., “War, Competition and Collaboration: Relations between the English and Dutch East India Company in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” in The Worlds of the East India Company, ed. Bowen, H. V., Lincoln, Margarette, and Rigby, Nigel (Suffolk, 2002), 49–68Google Scholar; for the later nineteenth century, see Ross, Status and Respectability, 40–69; McKenzie, Imperial Underworld, 159–90.

256 See McKenzie, Imperial Underworld, 103–58; Bayly, Imperial Meridian, 235–47; for a globally oriented history of nineteenth-century liberalism, see Bayly, Recovering Liberties, 104–245.

257 Ross, “George Ogilvie Ross in Four Continents,” 300–1.

258 Ross, 300.

259 “Advertentie, Mr. F. E. Turr heeft zijn kantoo als praktizijn in de Koe Straat,” Bataviasche Courant, 15 April 1820.

260 Jones, Edward J. Morse, Roll of the British Settlers in South Africa (Cape Town, 1971), 163Google Scholar.

261 Randall, Peter, Little England on the Veld: The English Private School System in South Africa (Johannesburg, 1982), 55Google Scholar.