Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T17:30:29.039Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The 1784 Handel Commemoration as Political Ritual

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2014

William Weber
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Between May 26 and June 5, 1784, five concerts were given in Westminster Abbey and a West End entertainment palace to mark the death of George Frideric Handel twenty-five years before. The event became a legend in its own time. The scale of the commemoration festival of 1784 was unparalleled among musical events: 4,500 people gathered in the abbey to hear 525 performers render Handel's Messiah, and, as European Magazine put it, “so extraordinary a spectacle, we believe, never before solicited the public notice.” This novel festival to a German-born composer captured public attention all around the Western world but in Britain made Handel's music into a national tradition. The commemoration was indeed a political event. It came on the heels of constitutional crisis—the dispute over the authority of crown and Parliament, the Fox-North ministry of 1783, and the turbulent election of 1784. Nobody planned the commemoration for political reasons, but that is what it became, willy-nilly, celebrating the end of the crisis and the hope for a harmonious new order.

The commemoration put in ritual form the culmination of the country's political development over the previous three decades. The new harmony seen in the grand event suggested the reunion of Tories with Whigs in government and the growth of a new political community—a kind of establishment—that, despite the conflict over the war and the constitution, was broad-bottomed in its inclusion of faction and opinion. Yet that does not mean that the commemoration was unanimously supported or was truly nonpartisan, any more than was this establishment itself.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 28 , Issue 1 , January 1989 , pp. 43 - 69
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1989

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 European Magazine, suppl. (June 1784), p. 1Google Scholar; see also Johnstone, H. Diack, “A Ringside Seat at the Handel Commemoration,” Musical Times 125 (1984): 632–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Smither, Howard, A History of the Oratorio, vol. 3, The Oratorio in the Classical Era (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1987), chap. 3Google Scholar.

3 On the constitutional crisis, see Cannon, John, The Fox-North Coalition (Cambridge, 1969)Google Scholar; Christie, Ian, The End of North's Ministry, 1780–1782 (London, 1958)Google Scholar; O'Gorman, Frank, The Rise of the English Two-Party System (London, 1983)Google Scholar. On the political aspects of Handel's career, see Lang, Paul Henry, George Frideric Handel (New York, 1966), pp. 218–25, 384, 464–65, 483, 540–41Google Scholar; and Burrows, Donald, “Handel and the English Chapel Royal during the Reigns of Queen Anne and King George I” (hereafter “Handel and the Chapel Royal”) (Ph.D. diss., Open University, 1981)Google Scholar. Since it was often thought that Handel was born in 1684 rather than 1685, the commemoration was to celebrate that centennial as well as his death; see Scots Magazine 46 (1784): 269Google Scholar.

4 Cannon, J. A., The Aristocratic Century: The Peerage in Eighteenth-Century England (New York, 1984)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Colley, Linda, “The Apotheosis of George III: Loyalty, Royalty and the British Nation, 1760–1820,” Past and Present, no. 102 (1984), pp. 94–129Google Scholar, “Whose Nation? Class and National Consciousness in Britain, 1750–1830,” ibid., no. 113 (1986), pp. 97–117.

6 Brewer, John, Party Ideology and Popular Politics at the Accession of George III (Cambridge, 1976)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, “English Radicalism in the Age of George III,” in Three British Revolutions: 1641, 1688, 1776, ed. Pocock, John (Princeton, N.J., 1980)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, “Commercialization and Politics,” in The Birth of a Consumer Society: The Commercialization of Eighteenth-Century England, by Brewer, John, McKendrick, Neil, and Plumb, J. H. (Bloomington, Ind., 1982)Google Scholar.

7 For the programs, see Burney, Charles, “Commemoration of Handel,” in An Account of the Musical Performances in Westminster Abbey (London, 1785)Google Scholar.

8 Myers, Robert Manson, Handel's Messiah, a Touchstone of Taste (New York, 1948)Google Scholar; Larsen, Jens Peter, Handel's Messiah: Origins, Composition, Sources (New York, 1957)Google Scholar; Smither; Pritchard, B. W., “The Musical Festival and the Choral Society in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries: A Social History” (hereafter “The Music Festival”), 2 vols. (Ph.D. diss., University of Birmingham, 1968)Google Scholar.

9 Scots Magazine 46 (1784): 271Google Scholar.

10 Pearce, Ernst Harold, Sons of the Clergy, 2d ed. (London, 1928)Google Scholar; Lysons, Daniel, History of the Origins and Progress of the Meeting of the Three Choirs of Gloucester, Worcester and Hereford (hereafter Three Choirs), 3d ed., ed. Amott, John (London, 1865)Google Scholar; Matthews, Betty, “Salisbury,” in The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, ed. Sadie, Stanley (London, 1980), 16:421–22Google Scholar; Husk, W. H., Account of the Musical Celebrations on St. Cecilia's Day in the Sixteenth, Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries (London, 1857)Google Scholar.

11 See Burrows, 2:152–55; Pritchard, , “The Music Festival,” vol. 1Google Scholar, and “Provincial Music Meetings of the Ashley Family,” Galpin Society Journal 22 (1969): 58–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and programs reprinted in the Research Chronicle of the Royal Musical Association 5 (1965): 51–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar; 6 (1966): 3–23; 7 (1967): 1–27; 8 (1968): 1–29. On the social process, see my article, “Mentalité, tradition et le ‘canon’ musical au 18e siècle,” Annales: Economies, sociétés. Civilisations (in press).

12 Pritchard, “The Music Festival.” See examples near Leicester in Anecdotes of the Five Music-Meetings: An Account of the Charitable Foundation at Church-Langston (Church-Langston, 1768)Google Scholar; and in Halifax in A Plain and True Narrative of the Differences between Messrs. B——s and the Members of the Musical Club (hereafter A Plain and True Narrative) (Halifax, 1767)Google Scholar.

13 Matthews, James E., “The Antient Concerts, 1776–1848,” Proceedings of the Royal Musical Association 33 (1906–1907): 55–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar; W. Weber, “Intellectual Origins of the Handelian Tradition, 1759–1800,” ibid. 108 (1981–82): 100–14. For the last decades of the series, see Weber, W., Music and the Middle Class (London, 1975), pp. 61–66, 74, 98, 123Google Scholar.

14 “A List of the Directors and Subscribers to the Antient Music, in Tottenham-Street, 1782,” attached to Concerts of Antient Music: The Performances for the Season 1782 (London, 1782)Google Scholar; likewise for 1786. The most complete collection of these programs in the United States is at the music library of Yale University.

15 The closest rival to the Ancient Concerts was the series put on by J. C. Bach and C. F. Abel from 1765 on; see newspaper reports naming the most prestigious members of the audience in the Public Advertiser (May 23, 1783), p. 3, and ibid. (May 7, 1784), p. 3.

16 Hiscock, W. G., Henry Aldrich of Christ Church (Oxford, 1960)Google Scholar; Bennett, G. V., The Tory Crisis in Church and State, 1688–1730: The Career of Francis Atterbury (Oxford, 1975)Google Scholar.

17 British Library (BL), Harleian MSS (Harl.), 7337–42; letters of Humphrey Wanley and Thomas Tudway, BL, Harl. 3778–82, and Portland Papers 29/249; Hogwood, Christopher, “Thomas Tudway's History of Music,” in Music in Eighteenth-Century England: Essays in Memory of Charles Cudworth, ed. Hogwood, Christopher and Luckett, Richard (Cambridge, 1983)Google Scholar.

18 BL, Minutes of the Academy of Ancient Music. The reputed Jacobite Other Windsor, earl of Plymouth, was a member as well; see Fritz, Paul S., The English Ministers and Jacobitism between the Rebellions of 1715 and 1745 (Toronto, 1975), p. 160Google Scholar.

19 See Pearce, appendices of officers, pp. 284–310.

20 Lysons, Three Choirs (n. 10 above), appendix, “List of Stewards, Preachers and Collections”; Sedgwick, Romney, History of Parliament, 1715–54, 2 vols. (London, 1970)Google Scholar; Namier, Lewis and Brooke, John, History of Parliament, 1754–90, 3 vols. (London, 1964)Google Scholar.

21 Subscription lists of this and succeeding festivals are found in the Norwich Public Library.

22 Langford, Paul, “Old Whigs, Old Tories and the American Revolution,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 8 (1980): 106–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gunn, J. A. W., Beyond Liberty and Property: The Process of Self-Recognition in Eighteenth-Century Political Thought (Kingston, 1983)Google Scholar; Clark, J. C. D., English Society, 1688–1832 (Cambridge, 1985)Google Scholar.

23 Langford, pp. 124–27.

24 Jones, William, Treatise on the Art of Music (Colchester, 1784), pp. iv, iiGoogle Scholar. His introduction is dated January 12, 1784. He was also on the subscription list of the Ancient Concerts in 1784 and subsequent seasons.

25 [Carter, Jane Francis Mary], Undercurrents of Church Life in the Eighteenth Century, ed. Rev. Carter, T. T. (London, 1899), pp. 193–94Google Scholar; Clark, pp. 242–43. See also Kassler, Jamie Croy, “William Jones,” in Sadie, , ed., 9:705Google Scholar, and “Systematic Writings of William Jones of Nayland,” Journal of the American Musicological Society 26 (1973): 92–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar. George Home, his colleague in discovering the nonjuring literature, wrote on ancient music in a similar vein in The Antiquity, Use and Excellence of Church Music: A Sermon preached at the Opening of a new Organ in the Cathedral Church of Christ Canterbury (London, 1784)Google Scholar.

26 Smith, Ruth, “Intellectual Contexts of Handel's English Oratorios,” in Hogwood, and Luckett, , eds., pp. 115–34Google Scholar; Brett, Philip and Haggerty, George, “Handel and the ‘Sentimental’: The Case of Athalia,” Music and Letters 69 (1988): 112–27Google Scholar. See as well Myers (n. 8 above), pp. 225–30.

27 Morning Herald (May 27, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar. The Morning Post likewise reported “the Rt. Rev. Bench of Bishops, who sat immediately under them [the royal house]” (May 31, 1784), p. 2. On the bishops, see the subscription list (n. 14 above); Powicke, F. M., Handbook of British Chronology, 2d ed. (London, 1961)Google Scholar. All but one of the seven bishops in 1782 were appointed under George III; there were nine in 1797.

28 Papers of the earl of Sandwich (hereafter SP), F 52/16–19, letters to and from the Bishop of Rochester, June 20–August 1, 1784. I am indebted to Victor Montagu for access to these papers in his private collection in Mapperton, Axminster, Dorset.

29 Though she did not go to the Ancient Concerts, Anna Larpent left behind a rich chronicle of the relations among several who did in her “Methodized Journal” (1774–82); Larpent Papers, Henry Huntington Library, San Marino, Calif.

30 Martelli, George, Jemmy Twitcher: A Life of the Fourth Earl of Sandwich (London, 1962)Google Scholar; Barnes, G. R. and Owen, J. H., eds., Private Papers of John Montagu, Earl of Sandwich, 1771–1782 (London, 1932)Google Scholar; Butler, Charles, Reminiscences, 2 vols., 4th ed. (London, 1824), 1:72, 289Google Scholar; Craddock, Joseph, Literary and Miscellaneous Memoirs, 4 vols. (London, 1828), 1:117–24Google Scholar; The Life, Adventures, Intrigues and Amours of the Celebrated Jemmy Twitcher (London, 1770)Google Scholar; Walpole, Horace, Memoirs of the Reign of George III, ed. Marchant, G., 4 vols. (London, 1845), 1:310–14Google Scholar; frequent mention in Crisis, 1775–76 (e.g., no. 32, August 26, 1775, p. 212); London Magazine 47 (July 1779): 291–92Google Scholar. For satirical drawings, see George, M. D., ed., A Catalogue of Political and Personal Satires Preserved in the Department of Prints and Drawings in the British Museum, 11 vols. (London, 1870–1954), 5:226, 324–26, 6:231–32Google Scholar; and his letters on musical topics, SP, F/52, 1–78. Montagu sometimes used his musical connections for political purposes: in 1783, for example, another director of the Ancient Concerts, Brownlow Cecil, the earl of Exeter, gave Montagu his proxy for the vote on the East India Bill, disclaiming any interest in the matter (Exeter to Sandwich, December 3 and 17, 1783, SP, F 43a/15, 26).

31 Dictionary of National Biography (DNB), 21:1174–75Google Scholar; Scots Magazine 46 (1784): 211–12Google Scholar; Walpole, Horace, Journal of the Reign of King George the Third, ed. Dr.Doran, , 2 vols. (London, 1859) 2:307–8Google Scholar, entry of December 1, 1778; Laprade, William, The Parliamentary Papers of John Robinson (London, 1922), p. 96Google Scholar; Mrs. Harris to her son, May 1, 1772, A Series of Letters of the First Earl of Malmesbury to his Family and Friends, 1745–80, ed. third earl of Malmesbury, 2 vols. (London, 1870), 1:256Google Scholar; SP, passim; see Langford.

32 Cudworth, Charles, “Fitzwilliam and Handel,” in Handel and the Fitzwilliam (Cambridge, 1974), pp. 8–9Google Scholar; Playfair, Lyon Baron, Playfair's British Antiquity, 9 vols. (London, 1809–1811), 2:31Google Scholar; SP F 52/87; two letters to his accountant in the library of the Fitzwilliam Museum; letters to Mme. Bernard, his mistress in Paris, in the Wilton Estate Office, Wilton, Wiltshire.

33 Morning Chronicle (May 25, 1784), p. 3Google Scholar; see also Westminster Magazine (March 1784), p. 165Google Scholar.

34 [Mann, A. H.], “Mr. and Mrs. Joah Bates: A Distinguished Amateur and a Notable Singer,” Musical Times 46 (1905): 13–20, 99–100Google Scholar; Venn, J. A., ed., Alumni Cantabrigiensis (1752–1900) (Cambridge, 1933), pt. 2, 1:184Google Scholar; Austen-Leigh, R. A., ed., Eton College Register, 1753–1790 (Eton, 1921), pp. 31–32Google Scholar; A Plain and True Narrative (n. 12 above); “Mr. Joah Bates and the First Performance of the ‘Messiah’ in Halifax,” Halifax Guardian (October 30, 1858); letters of Joah Bates and his family (1768–89), copies in the papers of A. H. Mann, King's College, Cambridge. Fortescue identifies as Joah a Mr. Bates who was loaned £3,250 by the royal house in the election of 1784; see Correspondence of King George the Third from 1760 to 1783, ed. John Fortescue, 6 vols. (London, 1927–28), 6:7. There is, however, no evidence that it was Joah; his letters do not concern politics much at all (see esp. Bates to Montagu, March 27, 1784, SP F 52/10). His older brother Henry may have originally broached the relationship with Montagu; see The Manuscripts of the Marquess of Abergavenny, Historical Manuscripts Commission Reports no. 15 (London, 1887), pp. 7, 11Google Scholar (the latter letter to Montagu, clearly by Henry, is misattributed to Joah).

35 Public Advertiser (May 27, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar; European Magazine, suppl. (May 1784), p. 2Google Scholar. The Prince of Wales became a director of the Ancient Concerts in 1792.

36 Morning Post (May 31, 1784), p. 3Google Scholar.

37 See ibid. (June 4, 1784), p. 3, for an interesting negative comment on Thurlow, suggesting the antagonism felt toward him among his own party.

38 Public Advertiser (May 31, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar.

39 Werkmeister, Lucylle, The London Daily Press, 1772–92 (Lincoln, Nebr., 1963), pp. 10, 42, 78, 97Google Scholar, on the political opinions of papers in general, see pp. 5–13, 68–83.

40 Morning Herald (May 31, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar.

41 Ibid. (May 27, 1784), p. 2.

42 Werkmeister, pp. 5, 8.

43 Morning Post (May 31, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar.

44 Ibid.

45 Public Advertiser (May 27, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar.

46 Morning Herald (May 31, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar.

47 Morning Post (June 4, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar.

48 Universal Magazine 74 (June 1784): 277–78Google Scholar.

49 Public Advertiser (May 27, 1784), p. 2Google Scholar; European Magazine, suppl. (May 1784), p. 1Google Scholar.

50 Morning Herald (May 27, 1784), p. 3 (emphasis in original)Google Scholar.

51 Cannon, Fox-North Coalition (n. 3 above), p. xii.

52 Roger North on Music, ed. Wilson, John (London, 1959), p. 222Google Scholar.

53 Burney, Charles, A General History of Music from the Earliest Times to the Present Period, 2 vols. (1935; reprint, New York, 1957), 1:706–7Google Scholar (emphasis added).

54 European Magazine, suppl. (June 1784) (n. 1 above), p. 1Google Scholar. Bates had solicited articles from it; see Bates to Montagu, April 3, 1784, SP F 52/10.

55 Burney, , An Account of the Musical Performances in Westminster Abbey (n. 7 above), pp. vi–viiGoogle Scholar.

56 Colley, “The Apotheosis of George III” (n. 5 above).

57 The London Stage, 1660–1800, ed. Van Lennep, William, 5 vols. (Carbondale, Ill., 1960–1968) 5, pt. 1:ccx–ccxiGoogle Scholar; Coxe, William, Anecdotes of George Frederick Handel and John Christopher Smith (London, 1799; reprint, New York, 1979), pp. 52–57Google Scholar. Stanley Ayling exaggerates the King's operagoing, based on one anecdote, in George the Third (New York, 1972), p. 201Google Scholar.

58 Brooke, John, King George III (New York, 1972), pp. 304–6Google Scholar; King, Alexander Hyatt, Some British Collectors of Music, 1600–1900 (London, 1963), pp. 107–17Google Scholar.

59 Register of Attendance and Repertory, V.B.4, Archive of Saint George's Chapel, Windsor. The performances of pieces by Handel were mostly at evensong, which the king rarely attended (Brooke, pp. 260–61). For a useful table of royal appearances at thanksgiving feasts, see Burrows (n. 3 above) 2:187–88.

60 Bates to Montagu, April 3, 1784, SP F 52/11.

61 The Historical and Posthumous Memoirs of Nathaniel Wraxall, ed. Wraxall, Henry Wheatley, 5 vols. (London, 1884), 3:340Google Scholar. See also Brooke's introduction, in Namier and Brooke (n. 20 above), 1:88–92; Speeches of the Right Honorable Charles Fox in the House of Commons, 6 vols. (London, 1815), 2:451–89Google Scholar; Parliamentary Register 15 (1784): 64Google Scholar. The discovery that the Civil List was in arrears may also have contributed to the king's concern to take a cultural high road; see Parliamentary History of England 24 (1783–1785): 1238, 1249Google Scholar.

62 Smith, Ruth, “Argument and Contexts of Dryden's Alexander's Feast,” Studies in English Literature 18 (1978): 465–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63 Cannon, Fox-North Coalition (n. 3 above), pp. 230–31.

64 On the fad in general, see Myers, Handel's Messiah (n. 8 above), and Handel, Dryden, and Milton (London, 1956)Google Scholar; and Smither (n. 2 above).

65 The London Stage, vol. 5, pt. 2, passim.

66 Petty, Frederick, Italian Opera in London, 1760–1800 (Ann Arbor, Mich., 1980), pp. 237, 241, 246, 328Google Scholar; Mount-Edgcumbe, Richard, Musical Reminiscences of an old Amateur Chiefly Respecting the Italian Opera in England (London, 1827), pp. 55–56Google Scholar.

67 Burney to Montagu, July 20, August 2 and 19, December 25, 1784, January 6, 1785, SP 52/15, 20, 32, 33, 39; Lonsdale, Roger, Charles Burney: A Literary Biography (Oxford, 1965), pp. 301–37Google Scholar; Grant, Kerry, Dr. Burney as Critic and Historian of Music (Ann Arbor, Mich., 1983), pp. 289–90Google Scholar.

68 Henry Bates to his sister (Grace Furey), July 18, 1784, Bates Letters, fol. 2.

69 Henry Bates to his sister, March 11, 1786, Bates Letters, fol. 24.

70 Doane, J., Musical Directory (London, 1794), p. 85Google Scholar.

71 London Chronicle (February 15, 1785), p. 2Google Scholar.

72 George, ed. (n. 30 above), vol. 5, 1771–1783, pp. 414–15.

73 See letters to Lord Sandwich by a variety of people, in 1784–86, in SP F 52/19–24, 32, 35–37; and also, Drummond, Pippa, “The Royal Society of Musicians in the Eighteenth Century,” Music and Letters 59 (1978): 280–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Claudie L. Johnson has suggested some interesting literary dimensions in the reverence for the large sonority in Handel's music; see her “‘Giant handel’ and the Musical Sublime,” 18th-century Studies 19 (1986): 515–33Google Scholar.

74 Ashley to Montagu, September 28 and December 10, 1789, SP F 52/76–77.

75 July 12, 1791, cited in Drummond, p. 282. See also The Diary, or Woodfall's Register, vol. 27 (May 31, 1790)Google Scholar; and Public Advertiser (June 4, 1791), p. 4Google Scholar. The arrival of the Prince of Wales as a director in 1792 is suggestive of a general political upheaval in these musical circles in 1791.

76 Wynn to Montagu, August 9, 1785, SP F 52/46. See also letters 47, 62, 74, and 87 in the same collection.

77 Cannadine, David, “The Context, Performance and Meaning of Ritual: The British Monarchy and the ‘Invention of Tradition,’ c. 1820–1977,” in The Invention of Tradition, ed. Hobsbawm, Eric and Ranger, Terence (Cambridge, 1983)Google Scholar.

78 Matthews, Betty, ed., The Royal Society of Musicians of Great Britain: A List of Members, 1738–1984 (London, 1985)Google Scholar.

79 British Mercury (June 23, 1787), pp. 112, 114Google Scholar. See as well ibid. (May 1787), pp. 48–51; and the New Plain Dealer, a Curry-Comb for Doubledealers (London, n.d.), pp. 330–31Google Scholar.

80 [Wolcot, John], “Instructions to a Celebrated Laureat,” in The Complete Works of Peter Pindar, 3 vols. (London, 1794), 2:35Google Scholar.

81 “Ode upon Ode; or, a Peep at St. James,” in The Complete Works of Peter Pindar, 1:407Google Scholar.

82 Tears of St. Margaret's (London, 1792), p. 10Google Scholar. On the role of Dissent in elections, see Phillips, John, Electoral Behavior in Unreformed England: Plumpers, Splitters and Straights (Princeton, N.J., 1982), pp. 17–18, 159–68, 286–305Google Scholar.

83 For a parallel example of interaction between music and politics, see my study, “La musique ancienne in the Waning of the Ancien Régime,” Journal of Modern History 56 (March 1984): 58–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and its critique by Milo, Daniel, “Le musical et le social: Variations sur quatre textes de William Weber,” Annales: Economies, sociétés, civilisations 42 (1987): 27–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

84 Brewer, John, “Theater and Counter-Theater in Georgian Politics: The Mock Elections at Garrat,” Radical History Review 22 (1979–1980): 7–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.